What this covers

This is a roughly half-hour solo walkthrough by Jeff Snider of Eurodollar University, built around New York Fed data on repo fails and a Bloomberg piece in which Mizuho describes buying safe assets in case a US soft landing fails. Snider reads the fails data alongside swap spreads, Treasury bill yields and dealer holdings, and then ties them to Japanese firms unwinding positions. He also says he is moving to a live-stream format because new collateral information is arriving quickly.

The data section is specific. Fails rose from August 5th and reached about $400 billion in the week before the end of September, ending an 18-month downward trend. Dealer coupon holdings hit a record on August 5th. The four-week bill yield dropped below one-month term SOFR, which Snider says goes beyond what an expected rate cut explains. He argues that collateral scarcity persists despite heavy bill issuance, so the problem looks like dealer reluctance to circulate collateral rather than a shortage of supply. He gives three drivers of swap spreads: hedging demand, dealer balance sheet limits, and collateral concerns. He treats the alignment of these signals across June through October as stronger evidence than any single one. Historical reference points include the Treasury's bill restriction during the early-2023 banking crisis and the Swiss National Bank dollar auctions in October 2022.

The contested part is his account of the yen carry trade. He says it is not hedge funds borrowing yen. It is large Japanese financial firms swapping yen deposits into dollars. He argues those firms had moved into riskier CLO) tranches on Powell's message of economic strength, then reversed after the July CPI release and weak labor data. On his reading the yen kept strengthening into September, so the unwind was not finished. He also argues the record stock market and the September payroll report hid this, and that the real story is institutional risk management.

Sharpest takeaway

Financial markets are signaling persistent US recession risk and collateral fragility through rising repo fails, widening swap spreads, and ongoing yen carry trade unwinding, despite official optimism about economic strength and stock market record highs.

  • Repo fails have broken a 18-month downward trend since early August and remain elevated through end of Q3, indicating collateral scarcity
  • Japanese financial firms are proactively unwinding carry trades and shifting from risky CLOs to US Treasuries due to recession risk perception
  • Multiple collateral indicators (swap spreads, bill yields, dealer coupon holdings) show coordinated stress despite Treasury supply and strong payroll data

The claims · ranked22 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.75

Collateral scarcity is persisting despite the US Treasury's continued issuance of large quantities of Treasury bills, suggesting the scarcity is not a supply problem but a distribution or demand problem—possibly dealers' unwillingness to circulate collateral due to risk aversion

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“there's a story as I said going on in repo fails and collateral overall so we take a step back and look at the last couple years what you see is that repo fails absolutely surged during that that uh volatile year of 2022 we had repo fails that continued to climb until we got to September and October of 2022 when things really started to break down remember we had those Swiss national bank auctions in uh dollar auctions in early October 2022 these things are all related to that and then on the other side of that as it looked like Europe was going to survive and um maybe the some of the worst case scenarios with some of the bond yields and bond spreads whether it be Italian or some of the European spreads they got better and repo fails have been basically on a downward trajectory over the last year and a half”

0.74

US dollar and US Treasury collateral markets are the central hub through which the entire global financial system—derivatives, currencies, cash flows, collateral flows—circulates and is redistributed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“US money dealers are in the center of everything and I mean everything whether it be derivatives currencies collateral the entire system”

0.72

The real yen carry trade is not hedge funds borrowing in yen, but major Japanese financial firms with access to large yen deposits and interbank yen who swap yen into US dollars to acquire higher-yielding US dollar assets or to further swap into other currencies, because they do not want to invest in Japan given poor domestic returns.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“there's this very wide and Broad idea that the Yen carry trade is a bunch of hedge funds who borrow in yen to reinvest someplace else and that's not the real carry trade the real carry trade trade is Japanese firms who have access to tons of Yen either through deposits or other interbank means and nothing to do with that Yen they don't want to invest in Japan because why would you want to invest in Japan that seems pretty obvious and so what they do instead is use the Yen that they have or the access to Yen that they have as collateral to swap into US dollars”

0.69

CLOs (collateralized loan obligations) are structured products made up of leverage loans and other lower-quality debt, and CLO performance in past crises (2008 financial crisis, 2015-16 leverage loan debacle) was poor, giving Japanese firms institutional reason to believe that US recession risk translates directly into CLO liquidity and value risk.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“these clo are made up of Leverage loans and other lower quality uh uh debt uh pieces of debt”

0.68

Central banks and the Federal Reserve are focused on debt and Fed policy reactions, while the real financial story playing out in markets is about perceived risk and proactive risk management by institutional participants.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“everybody is taking a step back off the recession Cliff especially after the September payroll report and even to to an extent today's CPI focused on entirely mostly the Federal Reserve and their reaction to the debt and everything else in the system itself in the financial markets it's a very different story it's not about payroll reports it's about perceived risk and taking proactive steps to manage them”

0.68

The Yen continued to appreciate against the US dollar through mid-August and into September 2024 despite mainstream dismissal of ongoing carry trade unwind, indicating Japanese firms continued to liquidate positions and repatriate proceeds beyond the visible August crisis

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“it seems like at least from the mainstream perspective that the Yen carry trade kind of just it it it hit another equilibrium and then just everything was fine thereafter I mean stocks are back high again the US economy seems fine so there is no more Yen carry trade to worry about um in fact you see mainstream media reports about how their version of the end carry trade has been put back on by hedge funds but as you can see here just from the Yen's uh exchange value to the US dollar it continued to go higher the Yen did against the US Dollars suggesting more carry trade unwinding not just early August but also the the middle of August and into September”

0.66

The stock market's recovery to record highs and the mainstream focus on the September payroll report have obscured ongoing financial fragility in collateral markets, causing most observers to dismiss the August volatility as a resolved event rather than an incomplete unwind of carry trades and repricing of risk.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“everybody is taking a step back off the recession Cliff especially after the September payroll report and even to to an extent today's CPI focused on entirely mostly the Federal Reserve and their reaction to the debt and everything else in the system itself in the financial markets it's a very different story it's not about payroll reports it's about perceived risk and taking proactive steps to manage them”

0.63

Repo fails have been rising since August 5th and surged to around 400 billion in the week before the end of September, the most in fails since the end of last year, representing a break in an 18-month downward trend that had been consistent since late 2022.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“repo fails have been rising since August 5th and I'll come back to that in just a minute that's that's really important because we all know what happened in early August and so they kept on going through the middle middle part of September and then we got the last week's data which showed a 400 billion Surge and repo fails”

0.61

The timing of collateral stress (repo fails, swap spreads, dealer coupon hoarding) is 'even more compelling' than the individual signals because the consistent alignment across multiple independent indicators at multiple time points (June, July, August, September, October) suggests a coordinated underlying cause rather than random noise.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“and the timing the timing is even more compelling than everything else so there's collateral scarcity that's Brewing despite the fact that the treasury is still offering a ridiculous amount of treasury bills every week the Yen carry trade is a big part of all of this”

0.52

Recent versions of CLOs have never actually been tested in a US recession scenario, giving Japanese firms additional reason to exit positions proactively rather than wait for performance data.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“and in reality these latest versions of Clos have never actually been tested so even more reason for Japanese firms when confronted the confronting the idea of a potential us recession to say screw it the recession risk appears to be real I'm I'm just ex I'm going to get out of these positions because I don't want to find out I don't want to be the guinea pig in this test case”

0.52

The four-week Treasury bill yield fell faster and further than other Treasury maturities and even dipped below one-month term SOFR in late August and early September, and approached three-month term SOFR levels, indicating collateral scarcity demand beyond what the anticipated Federal Reserve rate cut alone would explain.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“you can see especially the four-week bill that kind of moved down a lot faster than all of the other ones much farther than you would expect given its relationship to other interest rates especially at the front end”

0.47

Falling swap spreads in mid-June signaled shifting market sentiment to Japanese carry traders, and on July 11th CPI release, Japanese firms became increasingly nervous about recession risk and began to reverse the carry trade, a process that accelerated into early August when labor market data (JOLTS, jobless claims, August 2nd unemployment report) confirmed recession risk was real.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“as they began to see more and more signs around June and July remember swap spreads falling low lower in June that signaled that the that the tide was shifting and the Japanese in particular especially on July 11th”

0.47

Japanese carry traders justified increasing allocations to riskier CLO tranches (double-A, single-A, and lower) by reasoning that the US economy was strong and resilient (per Fed Chair Powell's messaging) and therefore there was no risk in these investments, irrationally downplaying recession risk despite bank of Japan warnings and their own internal risk committees likely flagging the danger.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“justifying it in a couple different ways but one of the ways in which they Justified it was that the US economy was strong and resilient J Powell said so so there's no risk in in buying say a double a rated clo or part of a clo or a single a rated”

0.47

Dealer holdings of US Treasury coupons spiked to a record high on August 5th and remained elevated through mid-September, declining somewhat in late September but anticipated to rise again in early October, as dealers accumulate Treasuries defensively in anticipation of collateral scarcity or proactively to profit from collateral-desperate buyers.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“huge Spike which was up to a record high on August 5th again consistent with everything that was going on at that time including a collateral shortage”

0.44

Swap spreads are driven by three primary factors: hedging demand (portfolio protection), dealer balance sheet constraints (risk capacity), and collateral concerns (scarcity risk)

definitionestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“big drop and leading up to August little bit of a sideways in the middle part of August and then another another another leg lower in swap spreads indicating more hedging demand more dealer balance sheet constraints more concerns about collateral those are basically the three big big factors and properties that drive swap spreads in what either direction”

0.34

The US dollar functions as a reserve currency and vehicle currency because foreigners, including Japanese banks, use it as a medium of exchange and store of value to invest in non-US assets and manage international liabilities.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Jeff Snider

“use those US dollars that they swap into to then swap into another currency by assets over there which is what a reserve currency is supposed to be it's a vehicle currency”

0.25

There are multiple ways in which carry trade unwinding connects to dealer risk aversion and collateral stress, with the informational channel (dealers learning from sophisticated client liquidation) being one important mechanism.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Jeff Snider

“there's other ways in which this happens but that's just wanted to throw that out there”

0.12

The story of collateral and repo fails requires close monitoring because the implications of continued fragility are substantial and its persistence suggests risk management by financial institutions rather than resolution of the underlying stress.

normative· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“so like I said there's a story Brewing here in collateral and it was just confirmed a little bit earlier today with what we saw at the quarter end and this is definitely something we need to keep an eye on because it is corroborated and consistent across monetary indications as well as the other financial markets”

0.12

A live stream format for discussing financial market data is being adopted by the speaker because the pace of new information and developments in collateral and financial conditions suggests frequent updates will be necessary going forward.

forecast· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“I think we're going to do some of these more frequently because got a hunch we're going to need to”

0.12

Swiss National Bank dollar auctions in early October 2022 were connected to broader repo fails surge and European financial stress during the volatile 2022 period when repo fails peaked.

factual· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“we had those Swiss national bank auctions in uh dollar auctions in early October 2022 these things are all related to that”

0.12

Term SOFR (Secured Overnight Financing Rate) is a rate that is supposed to tell us what short-term money markets are like at various terms (one-month, three-month) on a given day, and is derived from term SOFR Futures, which themselves try to price out what term SOFR will be in the future.

definition· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“this is this is we're talking about term suur not term suur Futures which are derived to try to to price out what term suur will be down the road and to make it even more confusing term suur itself is derived from term suur Futures but essentially term Sofer supposed to tell us what short-term money markets are like at various terms today or whatever day we're actually analyzing”

0.12

The Treasury Department restricted Treasury bill supply during the early 2023 banking crisis, causing bill yields to plummet and prices to skyrocket, as Treasury management prioritized debt ceiling concerns over normal market supply patterns.

factual· Unidentified Speaker — BREAKING: Repo Data Exposes Major Trouble in the Banking Sy… [n-RiPgF0s98]

“treasury was restricting treasury bill Supply during the banking crisis itself which is why Bill yields went plummeting and prices skyrocketed”