70 | Katie Mack on How the Universe Will End
What this covers
Katie Mack and Sean Carroll explore four physically plausible scenarios for the universe's end: heat death, big crunch, big rip, and vacuum decay. Mack, a cosmologist working on a book about cosmic endings, anchors the discussion in observable physics—the cosmological constant driving accelerating expansion, measurements of the dark energy equation of state, and precision values of the Higgs boson and top quark masses. Each end-state scenario maps to measurable parameters, making the study of far-future cosmology a tool for sharpening present-day models rather than pure speculation. The conversation spans the observational grounding for cosmic expansion (the Hot Big Bang as incontrovertible fact, distinct from popular "explosion" language), the peculiar physics of a cosmological constant that maintains uniform density even as space expands, and why Freeman Dyson's proposal for indefinite intelligent survival no longer works under current cosmology.
The scenarios diverge sharply in outcome. Heat death—the most data-consistent future—brings a slow fade over 10^100 years as galaxies separate, stars die, and the universe reaches maximum entropy and absolute cold. A big crunch requires dark energy to reverse and contract, concentrating not only matter but all radiation ever emitted, cooking everything before gravitational collapse. Phantom dark energy, if it exists, would progressively tear apart galaxies, then stars, then atoms in a "big rip." Most speculatively, the Higgs field could quantum-tunnel to a true vacuum state, triggering an expanding bubble of "quantum death" that annihilates matter—though estimates place this 10^100 to 10^500 years ahead. Mack emphasizes that studying these extremes reveals hidden assumptions in physics; the real payoff is not prediction but the discovery that our best models (the standard model, general relativity, concordance cosmology) are mutually incompatible at fundamental scales, with no observational anomalies yet pointing toward the deeper theory needed to reconcile them.
Mack argues that physics has progressed enough to sketch several plausible, mostly bleak endings for the universe—heat death, big crunch, big rip, and vacuum decay—and that studying these extrapolations is valuable both for constraining present-day physics and for confronting questions of meaning given the universe's finite future.
- The 'Hot Big Bang' (universe was hotter and denser in the past) is incontrovertible and observable, distinct from the popular 'explosion' picture
- The accelerating expansion driven by dark energy points toward heat death as the most data-consistent future
- Each end-of-universe scenario maps onto a measurable parameter (deceleration, equation-of-state W, Higgs/top-quark masses), so studying endings sharpens our physical models
Dark energy's nature and behavior determine which end-of-universe scenario will occur.
- Unlike phantom dark energy, a true cosmological constant only expands empty space and never rips apart gravitationally bound systems like galaxies, because the amount of dark energy in a bound region does not increase over time while the matter remains bound.
“the cosmological constant only expands really empty space, wherever those gravitationally bound things, cosmological constant is not gonna mess with those... 'cause the energy density doesn't increase over time.”
- The real mystery of the cosmological constant is not that it exists but that it is so small without being zero: quantum field theory first-principles calculations of vacuum energy yield a number vastly larger than the measured cosmological constant, a massive disagreement that is genuinely strange and signals we either misunderstand the calculation or are missing theory.
“when we calculate vacuum energy from quantum field theory first principles and compare that number to the cosmological constant, there's a massive disagreement”
- The cosmological constant / vacuum energy has the strange property that it maintains the same energy density in every cubic centimeter even as the universe expands—doubling the size of the box doubles the total dark energy—unlike normal matter whose density dilutes as space grows; this is exactly what the theory predicts but unlike anything in earthly experience.
“normally the density of something will change as the size of the box its in gets bigger... And dark energy isn't like that. You make the box twice as big, now you have twice as much dark energy.”
- Distinguishing among the end-of-universe scenarios relies mainly on measuring dark energy, which is only accessible through the expansion history and the growth rate of large-scale structure—because gravitational collapse forming galaxies and clusters always fights the expansion, the shapes and statistics of the cosmic web encode how dark energy has influenced structure over time.
“gravitational collapse is how galaxies and clusters of galaxies grow, but they're always fighting against the expansion of the universe and as the expansion is getting faster, it's preventing more collapse of structure. And so the shapes and sort of statistics of large scale structure can tell us a lot about what's in the universe”
- If dark energy is 'phantom' dark energy whose density increases over time (equation-of-state parameter W slightly less than -1), it would progressively rip apart larger and then smaller bound structures—clusters, galaxies, stars and planets, finally atoms—in a big rip; the current best-fit W is just below -1 but error bars include -1, and the data guarantee at least 120 billion years before any such rip.
“if you have something called phantom dark energy, the density of the dark energy is increasing over time... you get to a point where it rips the entire universe apart. So first, it gets the clusters of galaxies, then the galaxies, then the planets and then atoms... that's called the big rip.”
- Under concordance cosmology with a cosmological constant, the standard future is a slow fade to black: accelerating expansion eventually separates galaxies so far that in ~100 billion years extragalactic astronomy ends, star formation ceases as fuel runs out, stars die, matter collapses into black holes that then evaporate via Hawking radiation, and the universe reaches a maximum-entropy heat death of cold waste heat at ~10^-40 kelvin.
“in something like 100 billion years, we won't be able to see other galaxies anymore because they'll be so far away and their light will be so stretched out that we won't be able to pick up any information from them. So extra-galactic astronomy will be over.”
Current particle physics and cosmology are mutually incompatible despite passing all local tests.
- We are in an unusual scientific moment where particle physics is fully consistent with the standard model, cosmology fully consistent with concordance cosmology, and general relativity passes every test, yet these pictures are known to be mutually incompatible at a fundamental level—and there are no clear observational anomalies pointing the way to the deeper theory that must reconcile them.
“all of our particle physics experiments are fully consistent with the standard model... all of our measurements of the cosmic evolution are fully consistent with the concordance cosmology... General relativity is passing every test with flying colors. But we know that those things don't all fit together in a fully consistent fundamental theory... And we don't know what it is, and we don't have any clues”
- The entire prospect of vacuum decay depends on assuming the standard model of particle physics is the complete picture, which we know it cannot be (it doesn't accommodate dark matter, dark energy, or general relativity), so it is very plausible that new physics replacing or modifying the standard model would change our understanding of vacuum decay in a way that removes the worry entirely.
“the whole idea of vacuum decay depends on the assumption that the standard model of particle physics is the whole picture. And we know it can't be... it's very plausible that something will come up that'll change our understanding of vacuum decay in a way that will mean that it was never a worry to begin with”
- General relativity is the most bulletproof theory in physics—it passes every test thrown at it with no anomaly, including gravitational wave signals from black hole collisions that exactly match the predictions of equations Einstein wrote in 1915 without any modification—yet it must break down somewhere because it doesn't mesh with quantum mechanics.
“general relativity is the most bulletproof theory out there. We throw everything we can at this thing and we haven't found a single... Anomaly, everything looks exactly as it should”
The Hot Big Bang and its early-universe physics are observationally confirmed and well-tested.
- The physicist's 'Hot Big Bang'—simply that the universe was hotter, denser, and smaller in the past, derived from running the observed expansion backward—is completely incontrovertible because we can actually see it: looking far enough in any direction shows light from when the universe was on fire, distinct from the popular notion of an explosion from a single point.
“what we're talking about is just simply the fact that the universe was hotter and denser and smaller in the past... And that is completely incontrovertible”
- In the late 1990s, measurements of the deceleration parameter (q0) intended to determine whether expansion would reverse found it was negative—the universe is accelerating. Expansion was very rapid at the start, slowed for billions of years, then about 5 billion years ago began speeding up, which is as physically strange as throwing a ball up and having it shoot off into space.
“they found out that the deceleration parameter was a negative number... the universe is not decelerating at all, it's accelerating. The expansion is going faster and faster”
- The observable universe is about 46 billion light years in radius even though the universe is only 13.8 billion years old, because the expansion of space has pushed the point from which 13.8-billion-year-old light originated much farther away than the naive 13.8 billion light years.
“That's about 46 billion light years in radius, something like that and that comes from just the fact that as the universe has been expanding all this time”
- We can confirm physics from a second after the Big Bang because we can extrapolate to hot dense conditions reproducible in colliders (creating quark-gluon plasma) and because Big Bang nucleosynthesis—element fusion when the whole universe was as hot as a star's center—predicts helium and lithium abundances that match observations very well.
“It's called Big Bang nucleosynthesis, so in this early hot stage there was a time when the whole universe was as hot as the center of a star... we can figure out what the abundance of those elements should be in the universe if that were taking place and it matches really well.”
Vacuum decay via Higgs field tunneling is theoretically possible but faces fundamental uncertainties.
- The Large Hadron Collider cannot trigger vacuum decay because cosmic ray collisions in space occur constantly at energies far higher than the LHC can reach, and those have not destroyed the universe; therefore human particle smashing poses no danger and there is no prospect of a deliberate vacuum-decay doomsday device.
“what we can do with smashing particles together at the Large Hadron Collider is way less powerful than what cosmic rays do in space all the time... just the fact that those collisions are happening all the time in space and have not destroyed us, suggest that there's really no possible way that we... can do anything even slightly dangerous.”
- Calculations show a very small evaporating black hole can dramatically raise the probability of vacuum decay in its vicinity and seed a true-vacuum bubble; accounting for the known ~5-solar-mass black holes in our galaxy evaporating in the far future shortens the expected lifetime of our observable universe to roughly 10^69 years, and the absence of small primordial black holes (which would have triggered decay) can be used to constrain extra dimensions of space.
“if you have a very small black hole, as it's evaporating, it can trigger vacuum decay... a little black hole as it's evaporating can make the probability of tunneling in its vicinity much higher.”
- If the Higgs field quantum tunnels to the true vacuum at any point in space, it triggers an expanding bubble of true vacuum whose high-energy wall incinerates everything it touches and inside which matter cannot hold together; the bubble expands at nearly the speed of light, so it cannot be seen coming, would not be felt, and could in principle begin at any moment—though parameter estimates put it at 10^100 to 10^500 years away.
“there'll be this expanding bubble of true vacuum... this bubble then expands at likely about the speed of light... you absolutely cannot see it coming... it would destroy absolutely everything, and it could happen at any moment technically.”
- Based on the measured masses of the Higgs boson and top quark, our universe appears to be metastable rather than stable: particle physics works fine now, but the Higgs field sits in a 'false vacuum' that could quantum tunnel to a lower-energy 'true vacuum,' and the data point to the existence of such a true vacuum.
“you can chart out based on the masses of the Higgs Boson, the top quark, where we lie in this landscape of stable universes or non stable universes... you can have what's called a metastable universe where particle physics is fine for now, but eventually, it's all gonna fall apart”
Studying extreme cosmological futures reveals hidden assumptions and tests alternative universe models.
- Although the cosmic microwave background images the very early universe, careful examination of it could reveal signals about the future or origin of our universe—Roger Penrose's controversial search for circular features from a previous cycle, or signatures of bubble universe collisions arising in inflation—thereby testing whether a cyclic or multiverse model is compatible with observation.
“there's also this model by Roger Penrose... where he's looking for these signals in the cosmic microwave background that would come from a previous cycle, and whether or not there's been anything seen there is very controversial.”
- Some cyclic cosmological models—including the Ekpyrotic model from Steinhardt and Turok, originally involving colliding parallel universes—feature a collapse-and-bounce that does not reach infinite density, so faint traces such as matter-density fluctuations could survive through the bounce, though no usable information or 'time capsule' from intelligent life could be passed forward.
“There's an idea that was first described by my PhD advisors Paul Steinhard and Neil Turo... you can have a sort of slower bounce, and maybe something interesting could go through there.”
- The main intellectual payoff of studying the end of the universe is that extrapolating known physics all the way to the edge of our knowledge reveals the assumptions embedded in our physical models, so these wild extrapolations—vacuum decay, evaporating black holes, cosmic rays—are really tools for better understanding present-day physics.
“it tells you something about the assumptions of your physical model... if you extrapolate, let's take what we know and extrapolate it all the way to the edge of our knowledge, what does that tell us? That can either tell us something about the far future or can just tell us something about what kind of assumptions we're making about our model”
Even if the universe ends, meaning can be found in how we live and what we discover now.
- Physicists don't talk enough about the future of the universe even though people really want to know where it's all going.
“people just really wanna know about the future, where it's all going and stuff like that and we just don't talk about that enough as physicists.”
- Once the universe reaches maximum entropy, time stops mattering: because we define the direction of time by where entropy is increasing, if entropy can no longer increase there is no arrow of time and no meaningful difference between one moment and another—the universe just sits in an eternal, unchanging cold state.
“we define time by the direction where entropy is increasing. If entropy can't increase anymore, what even is time?”
- Even though the universe's end means we ultimately have no lasting legacy, Mack argues meaning can still be found by making the most of the time we have—just as spending quality time with a dying grandmother is meaningful even after she is gone, the fact that the universe and thinking beings existed and figured things out remains meaningful even when it all disappears.
“The important thing is that we make the most of the time we have... we can spend quality time with our universe now, and eventually it'll go away. And that doesn't mean it's meaningless... even if it's gone, there's still some meaning that it was here, that we were here, that we as thinking beings figured some stuff out.”
- If dark energy changes and reverses expansion, the universe ends in a big crunch—but this is worse than the Big Bang run backward: compression concentrates not just matter but all radiation, including starlight accumulated since the Big Bang, cooking everything; eventually the surfaces of stars ignite in thermonuclear explosions, leaving nothing survivable.
“in a big crunch universe, the space is compressing, not just the matter, but also, all of the radiation... we'll be cooked by this radiation background from all the starlight, from all the stars that have ever shone.”
- Freeman Dyson's proposal that intelligent life could survive forever by progressively slowing its processing and hibernating only works in a linearly expanding universe; it does not work in an accelerating universe driven by a cosmological constant, so the idea no longer holds given current cosmology.
“that only works for a universe that's linearly expanding, it doesn't work for an accelerating universe... his idea was that if you are in a universe that's expanding forever and you keep slowing down your processing and hibernating and stuff, you can technically live forever.”