Podcast

What this covers

Marq de Villiers, a writer and journalist who has worked across continents and published widely on history and science, joins Sean Carroll to trace the history of hell as a human concept rather than a revealed doctrine. De Villiers argues that the idea emerged from three practical needs: explaining misfortune in a world ruled by a single, all-powerful God; delivering justice that earthly life fails to provide; and—critically—controlling religious adherents through fear. The conversation unfolds as a genealogy, tracking how earlier, non-punitive afterlife concepts gradually transformed into systems of eternal torment, with the details elaborated and sharpened across centuries of competitive embellishment among monks and clergy rather than handed down in any canonical form.

The episode ranges widely across religious traditions and historical periods. Ancient Egypt, Mesopotamia, and early Judaism conceived of the afterlife without punishment—souls simply ended or were forgotten. The Greeks, by contrast, developed Tartarus as a place of torture, though without the Christian notion of eternity. Zoroastrianism contributed dualism, the idea of cosmic forces in conflict. Christianity synthesized these sources, borrowed the structure of rebellion and imprisonment wholesale from Greek myth (the Cronus-Zeus narrative mapped onto Satan and God), and later elaborated Satan's identity in contradictory ways—as both God's agent of punishment and as a willful rebel. Jesus himself said remarkably little about hell; the vivid imagery came later, from apocryphal gospels, Gnostic Gospels, and monastic writers like Adamnan who outdid one another in grotesquerie. The discussion also covers Islamic, Hindu, and Buddhist hells—each with distinct logics and punishments—and notes a peculiar modern paradox: belief in hell persists among secular and non-Christian Americans, even as the traditional theology that supports it weakens.

Sharpest takeaway

De Villiers argues that hell is a human invention that emerged from three converging needs—explaining misfortune, achieving justice that life fails to deliver, and controlling religious adherents—and that its specifics, including Satan, were elaborated competitively over centuries rather than revealed, revealing more about human psychology than about any actual afterlife.

  • Hell as punishment was a later addition to an earlier, non-punitive idea of the afterlife
  • The severity of hell's punishments grew as religious hierarchies felt threatened by dissenters
  • Belief that hell is necessary for moral behavior is a condescending and logically weak view of human nature

The argument · threads8 threads · 37 claims
0.71

Fear of eternal punishment is a logically weak foundation for morality and reflects condescending assumptions about human nature; modern credulous beliefs mirror historical ones despite scientific advancement.

11 pointscentrality 4/5
  • In 'polite company,' it remains more socially acceptable to be slightly religious than slightly unreligious—fundamentalism is rejected as impolite, but so is overt atheism, and the media-approved standard mocks those who believe too literally in Satan and demonic possession even though most people do believe—though this norm appears to be changing rapidly as newer generations retreat from organized religion.

    “I still think it's more acceptable to be slightly religious than it is to be slightly unreligious... Although, I think that's changing pretty quickly... The newer generations seem to be retreating fairly rapidly from the... At least from the organized church”

  • Even articulate, sensible, eminent scientists like Galileo and Newton were able to hold bizarre and contradictory beliefs simultaneously—Galileo calculated hell's dome to be 650 kilometers beneath Earth's surface based on Dante's geometry and Satan's presumed size, while Newton held lunatic ideas—showing that intellectual capacity does not prevent credulous beliefs.

    “he spent quite a long while calculating how far beneath the surface hell would be, based on the notion of Dante's, that at Satan's naval is the actual center of the earth, and the presumed size of Satan. And he calculated that hell is therefore, the dome of hell is therefore 650 kilometers beneath the surface of the earth.”

  • Pope Francis reportedly said hell is simply a radical separation from God—a more intellectual, non-physical version of the catechism—and although the Vatican rapidly backpedaled, the Catholic hierarchy is now skeptical of literal interpretations of the gospel, favoring metaphorical readings of hell rather than the literal burning of the past.

    “Francis, for example, said that hell is simply a radical separation from God, which is a much more intellectual and not physical version of catechism.”

  • Polytheism easily explained misfortune through quarrelsome warring gods (one god prevailing over another), but when the Hebrews invented monotheism, an infinitely able and everlasting God could not be wrong—so blame shifted to humans: misfortune meant we had failed to worship or obey properly, making punishment our fault rather than God's.

    “When the ancient Hebrews invented monotheism, it no longer made sense that because God was infinitely able and infinitely everlasting... it was therefore impossible for him to be wrong and therefore, what happened, what had to happen is that we were wrong.”

  • Satan in Hebrew simply means 'adversary' and was originally one of the servants/children of God in the Royal Court, who goaded God into testing Job's faith with boils—the two cooked up the scheme together; the Christians later transformed this figure into the evil Satan and conflated him with Lucifer, though a minority view (held by figures like Origen) that Lucifer could be redeemed was punished as heresy.

    “Satan is, as you probably know already, in Hebrew simply means adversary. It's the word for adversary. And he was a... He was originally, one of the servants of God and he was the one who goaded God into, for example, testing Lot with the boils”

  • In a recent Gallup poll, US religious belief rose from around 45% to approaching 60% over a decade, and more Americans believe in hell than in heaven; in Canada belief in hell is lower (30-35%) while almost everyone believes in heaven, and in Europe too more people believe in hell than heaven.

    “More people curiously believed in hell than actually believe in heaven, which is seemed to me an indication of the peculiar nature of American politics.”

  • In the modern era people are just as credulous and conflicted as they were in Galileo's time, as shown by conspiracy theories such as the claim that Joe Biden was a 'sacred jihadist' plotting to take over the US government.

    “people are just as credulous and just as conflicted as they were then. I mean, I read this morning that Joe Biden was now sacred jihadist who's plotting to take over the government of the US.”

  • Exorcisms have returned to popular culture and you can now book a freelance exorcist online, with their business flourishing—reflecting persistent belief in demonic possession (which is not necessarily belief in Satan) even in the modern era.

    “I was fascinated to learn that you could actually now book an exorcist online. There are a number of them available for freelance exorcisms, and their business seems to be flourishing.”

  • The gates of hell (Egyptians had seven, Zoroastrians eight, Ishtar passed through eight losing clothing at each) were always designed to keep people out until their time came rather than to keep souls in, since nobody ever tried to escape—escape was simply not part of the plan.

    “Always keeping people out, because when your time has come, you couldn't go... You couldn't enter hell until your time was ready... But nobody ever tried to escape, because you couldn't get out. That wasn't part of the plan.”

  • Hell arose from three converging threads: first, animist need to explain why things went wrong (demons explained misfortune); second, the urban-era perception that life was unfair as wrongdoers prospered, requiring post-death punishment since nobody punished them in life; and third, 'soul control'—imposing religious discipline by threatening punishment for disobeying the hierarchy.

    “I think the third thread of why people invented hell was as what former Episcopal Bishop Simone called a Soul control, which is basically a way of imposing discipline on the adherence to a religion, and threatening them with punishment when they didn't follow the injunctions of the hierarchy.”

  • The argument (made by Ross Douthat) that without hell there is no reason to be a good person is a condescending and logically weak view of humanity—it assumes people will automatically be evil unless a controlling force forces them to be good, when the reverse could equally be argued (why not assume people are good unless forced to be evil); most people simply do not want to murder others, and basing morality on fear of eternal punishment says little for one's spiritual development.

    “if you're automatically going to be evil, unless there's a controlling force that forces you to be good, it doesn't say much for your spiritual development... Why couldn't you be good unless you're being forced to be evil? But they don't seem to confront that.”

0.66

Hell contains unresolved internal contradictions: Satan portrayed both as God's punishing agent and as rebellious victim, while eternal punishment is disproportionate to finite human life.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Both the ancient Greek and the Christian hell began with a revolt and an underground prison for the defeated—the Greek Titans (led by Cronus who swallowed his children) were banished by Zeus into a pit, and the Christian Lucifer's rebellion led God to send Gabriel to prepare a pit, a story borrowed 'holus bolus' from the Greeks with new names; about half the heavenly host revolted, reflecting poorly on God's management skills.

    “God, in a fit of anger, again, sent the Angel Gabriel to prepare a pit for Lucifer, which was basically borrowed holus bolus from the Greeks. There was the same story, just updated with new names.”

  • Eternal punishment for finite human life is disproportionate and lacks any concept of parole—your life is only 80 years but your punishment is eternal—and the same problem applies to heaven: because we are finite beings whose imaginations cannot truly embrace eternity, it is hard to understand how one could be happy and content in heaven for infinity years.

    “why is there no concept of parole? Why is it... Your life is only 80 years, but your punishment is eternal? That just seem disproportionate.”

  • Modern hell contains an internal contradiction: Satan is portrayed both as an agent of justice working for God (punishing evildoers on God's behalf) and as the willful rebellious angel Lucifer who was a victim of his own hubris and banished into the pit—and the monotheisms have never reconciled these contradictory roles.

    “you have this contradictory things where Satan is either a victim of his own hubris, as I put it in the book, and he seemed to be an ambitious lad, trying to take over the family business from dad who was the God, Or he was either that or he was an agent holding the evil doers to account. And the monotheisms have not really got this sorted out, the internal contradictions.”

  • In the Christian telling, hell predates humankind—it was originally created as a primitive prison (a pit with sharp rocks heaped on heads) for the rebellious Lucifer and his fallen angels, and was only later 'repurposed' as a prison for sinful humans when the church needed a way to control people's actions and prevent heresy.

    “it became, in your word, re-purposed into a prison for malefactors and not just a prison for the chief, the devil in chief.”

0.60

Jesus said very little about hell in the Gospels; aggressive punishments and detailed torment narratives were invented later as the institutional church grew and faced competition.

2 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Hell's punishments became more grotesque and Satan turned from God's agent into a malevolent evil being as the church faced growing competition from free thinkers and later Protestant reformers like Calvin and Luther—the same syndrome as the European witch trials becoming more aggressive when the church felt under attack, which explains why Germany (where many early dissenters arose) burned more witches than anywhere else.

    “It's the same syndrome as the witch trials of Europe in the 17th and 18th century became more and more aggressive, the more that the church felt itself under attack from dissenters. And so it's no wonder, for example, that Germany where many of the early dissenters began, there were more witches that burned and hanged in Germany than in any other place.”

  • Jesus in the Gospels had very little to say about hell—only a few references quoted by Matthew about people consigned to eternal flames and 'wailing and gnashing of teeth'—and never specified where it was or who went there; the aggressive punishments were invented later as the church grew in stature and got further from the gospel writers.

    “Jesus, in the Gospel, had very little to say about hell... But he never said where it was, and he never said much about who went there, and who didn't.”

0.55

Christian hell doctrine borrowed and synthesized concepts from Zoroastrianism, Greek mythology, and other earlier religious traditions, then standardized these accretions over centuries.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The Greeks developed the afterlife into a systematic place where torture was central (with Tartarus as the innermost pit of hellfire), going beyond the Egyptian goal of merely killing failed souls; however, even the Greeks did not have eternity—the notion that hell was endless and that eternity was part of the formula was introduced later by the Christians and monotheisms.

    “The Greeks developed this into a much more systematic thing... But even the Greeks didn't have eternity... That was after the Christians and the monotheisms, too, introduced the notion that hell was an ending, that eternity was part of the formula.”

  • Christianity adopted its concept of hell from multiple earlier sources—Zoroastrianism (the first multinational monotheistic religion, with a dualistic universe in contention between forces of virtue and evil), Greek mythologies of Hades, and stories like Prometheus having his liver pecked out for eternity—and these accreted and were embellished until by the time of Charlemagne (7th-8th century) the vision of hell had become reasonably standardized.

    “Christianity picked up a lot of its thoughts about hell from Zoroastrianism, from the Greek mythologies of Hades, from their stories of the torches of Prometheus, and having his liver pecked out for eternity by a vulture.”

  • The detailed stories of Jesus's 'harrowing of hell'—descending to rescue Adam and pre-Christian people—came mostly from apocryphal and Gnostic gospels (the Gospel of Nicodemus, Gospel of Bartholomew) that were rejected from the canon, and one Gnostic text, the Testimony of Truth, inverted the Adam and Eve story by portraying God as a malicious grudger and the serpent (Satan) as the sensible worldly figure.

    “Most of the real stories about the harrowing of hell were from the apocryphal gospels, or some of the Gnostic Gospels... For example, The Gospel of Nicodemus, The Gospel of Bartholomew, which were rejected by the early church fathers, and not incorporated into the canon.”

  • Hell as punishment was a later addition; early afterlife conceptions were non-punitive—ancient Egyptians (from at least 3000 BC, via the cult of Osiris) had a 'devourer of souls' who simply annihilated those who failed the moral virtue test rather than torturing them, and Mesopotamian, Canaanite, and old African cultures similarly had places of the dead without punishment, where failing souls were simply forgotten or ended.

    “there was a being called the devourer of souls, who were standing by to grab hold of those people who failed to prove their virtuousness. But he just devour the soul, so if you failed that test, if you weren't able to pass the gates, you simply disappear, there was no punishment, you were just dead, you were ended.”

  • In the ancient Egyptian afterlife judgment, priests and the royal family were exempt from the moral virtue test and automatically assumed to be virtuous—a self-serving 'hedge' built into the system by those who controlled it.

    “there were people who were exempt from this tests, and those were the, no surprise here, the priests, and the Royal Family. They didn't have to, they we automatically assumed to be virtuous.”

0.49

Vivid hellish details were invented through competitive embellishment among monks and clergy, not derived from official doctrine or canonical sources.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The specific details of hell were invented and embellished through competition—one monastery competed with another, one monk told more lurid, up-to-date, modern tales than the previous monk, in a dynamic comparable to modern 'fake news'—and nobody knows who actually invented them.

    “Stories started and then, they became embellished and one monastery was competing with another, and one monk was telling tales that were more up-to-date and more modern and more lurid than the previous monk. And I think there was a competitiveness in what we would now call fake news, that they out did each other”

  • The vivid specifics of hell are not in the catechism or official doctrines—the Catholic catechism states only that hell is an actual place where actual sinners are actually tortured without specifics; the embellishments (cauldrons, demons, hierarchies of imps) came from outside the canon, in the writings of Jesuits and bishops like Adamnan, who adapted and embellished each other's work.

    “The catechism of the Catholic Church itself does say that hell is an actual place, where actual sinners are going to be actually tortured. But they don't get into the specifics on that, that's left for the commentary, the commentariat.”

  • Medieval visions of hell shared a peculiar 'physics of the netherworld': hellfire gave off no light and burned but did not destroy, because destroying people would defeat the purpose by being over too soon, and bodily harm such as entrails dragged out were 'endlessly self-renewing.'

    “Hellfire couldn't destroy people, because it would be beside the point. It would be over too soon... So it had to burn you, but you couldn't die of it.”

0.38

Most world religions developed elaborate hells with distinctive torments, while some like Judaism and Hindu-Buddhist traditions conceived afterlife punishment as purgative and cyclical rather than eternal.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Islam developed hell with inventive embellishments, especially around diet—sinners are forced to drink the sap of a root so poisonous a single drop would kill all life on earth—and around torture without death, such as pouring boiling liquid on heads to pool out at the feet, with the body then resurrected to repeat the process; Islamic hell emphasized fire to burn off skin and flaying rather than the mincing favored by Buddhists or boiling in oil favored by Christians.

    “Muhammad himself was very good on the ways that you could, in fact, torture people without them dying, pouring incredibly hot boiling liquid on top of their heads and then it would run through the body and pool out at their feet.”

  • Almost all religions have a hell or many hells; Burmese Buddhism has 40,040 hells, one for each sin, including hells for trivial offenses like failing to return borrowed books, lying about one's age at marriage, throwing broken pottery on fences, and even having irregular teeth.

    “there are 40,040 hells in Burmese Buddhism, one for each sin”

  • Judaism is 'not very good at hell'—Jewish hell (Sheol) is boring, with everyone good or bad going to the same place, because there is no belief in the eternality of the soul, so the faith concentrates on the here-and-now rather than the afterworld.

    “Everybody goes to Sheol, and everybody... Good or bad, evil or virtuous, they all go to the same place. And the Jewish faith is more interested in the here-and-now than in the after world”

  • In Hindu and Buddhist traditions hell is not open-ended but purgative—you are sent there to work through your sins via torture (for 400,000 to several million years in Hindu tradition), then released on parole to begin life again; once your sins are purged and you are bathed in the River of Forgetfulness, the cycle restarts.

    “the reason you were sent there was to work through the sins that you committed in life and once you had purged those from your system and the best way of purging them was to be tortured for a millennia... You were let out to start your life again”

0.33

Hell originated as believed physical locations on Earth before becoming abstract, with specific entrances identified across cultures from Mount Etna to Fengdu China.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Hell was historically believed to have concrete physical entrances on Earth rather than being purely conceptual—the early Romans located it near Mount Etna (a grotto emitting poisonous gases that killed birds and cows), with other entrances in Vernon, Greece, Turkmenistan, Lough Derg in Ireland, the Gulf of Mexico, and especially Fengdu, China, a city known as a repository of hellish law for 1500 years whose artisans prospered by manufacturing instruments of torture.

    “the early Romans knew exactly where it was, it was just off Mount Etna. And there's a grotto there which gives off what are called befitted gases, which are poisonous gases. And people had noticed that birds that flew past it, or that cows that wandered into it keeled over dead.”

  • The belief that one survives death is nearly as old as the human search for causality—just as people sought reasons for thunder (gods stumbling across clouds), they reasoned that supernatural beings existed and that under the right circumstances humans could join them; this belief dates to at least 3000 BC and possibly to Stone Age hunter-gatherer cultures.

    “the notion that there was a... That you didn't die went back almost as early as the search for causality in the universe, as a search for the reason why things happened. It must have been a reason for something.”

0.33

Hell served dual functions simultaneously as entertaining narrative and as disciplinary threat, though believers understood consequences as serious but escapable rather than inevitable.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Hell stories served two simultaneous functions: they were thrilling tales people enjoyed, and they were tools for inculcating discipline by threatening children and families with punishment if they did not behave—though almost certainly nobody literally believed they would spend two trillion years in torment, only that 'it's gonna be bad' but escapable.

    “I think it was a story that they could be thrilled with. And also it was a way of inculcating in people who succeeded them, their children and their families, a way of threatening them with punishment if they didn't shape up.”

  • The historical writings on hell are far more interesting and comprehensive than the few, banal writings on heaven (which depict it as angels singing 'Holy, holy, holy' day and night forever)—as the saying goes, the Devil has the best music and a much better story to tell; everyone agrees Dante's Inferno is more compelling to read than the Paradiso.

    “the writings... The historical writings on hell are much more interesting and comprehensive than the writings on heaven, which have a few and banal... They used to say The Devil has the best music but he also has a much better story to tell than that.”