What this covers
Sean Carroll interviews Natalya Bailey, the founder of Accion Systems, about the near-term transformation of orbital infrastructure and humanity's long-term prospects beyond Earth. The conversation pivots on a central technical problem: the rapid proliferation of small satellites creates both economic opportunity and collision risk, yet conventional ion engines cannot be miniaturized using existing methods. Bailey explains how Accion's ionic-liquid thrusters solve this by embracing rather than fighting nanoscale physics—using an electric field to extract ions directly from a liquid, a mechanism that naturally occurs at roughly 20 nanometers and becomes more efficient when parallelized rather than shrunk. The interview moves from this engineering foundation into questions of orbital sustainability, commercial space economics, and the philosophical shape of human expansion beyond Earth.
Bailey traces the practical constraints that will reshape space infrastructure. The satellite boom—roughly one thousand launches yearly, climbing toward three to five thousand—depends on standardization through CubeSats and faces a chicken-and-egg problem between launch costs and satellite demand. The risk of Kessler syndrome—cascading debris from collisions—is real enough that space agencies now mandate either sub-500-kilometer low Earth orbit deployment or de-orbit capability to keep satellite lifespans under 25 years. On longer timescales, Bailey argues that terraforming Mars is unrealistic and that humanity's sustainable future lies instead in curated orbiting habitats or sending biological material and recorded memory rather than frail human bodies on interstellar journeys. She touches on Oumuamua, asteroid mining economics, and the Great Filter problem—why intelligent civilizations seem rare despite abundant Earth-like planets—offering a space-centered answer to why exploration matters.
Bailey argues that the future of space is being reshaped by an explosion of small, cheap satellites that require a new class of miniaturized ion propulsion, and that humanity's long-term off-world future likely lies in curated orbiting habitats and post-biological exploration rather than terraforming hostile planets.
- Small satellite launches are growing rapidly, creating both opportunity and the Kessler-syndrome debris risk that demands in-space maneuvering
- Conventional ion engines cannot scale down, so Accion's ionic-liquid thrusters fill the gap by scaling up an inherently nanoscale ion-emission mechanism
- Because biological humans are frail and faster-than-light travel is implausible, the realistic path forward favors orbiting stations and sending stem cells/memories rather than whole humans
Ion propulsion scaled down requires fundamentally new approaches because shrinking traditional chambers fails thermally.
- Traditional ion engines work by injecting neutral gas (Xenon/Argon) and high-energy electrons into an ionization chamber, but shrinking the chamber reduces the residence time for ion-forming collisions; compensating by injecting more electrons drives so many into the chamber walls that they melt most known materials, so the technology fundamentally fails to close at small satellite scales.
“as you tried to scale this technology down, the first thing you do is you make that ionization chamber smaller... you've reduced the likelihood that they'll collide with one another. And so you basically don't form any ions”
- Accion's approach uses an ionic liquid—positive and negative ions liquid over a wide temperature range with no solvent—and applies an electric field to extract and accelerate ions of one polarity directly, eliminating the ionization chamber; because this ion emission inherently occurs over a region of about 20 nanometers, the design works by parallelizing a naturally small-scale mechanism rather than shrinking a large one.
“we don't need to ionize anything on orbit, we already have positive and negative ions, so we don't need this large chamber for these collisions to occur in”
- Electric propulsion is more mass-efficient than chemical propulsion because it converts electrical rather than chemical energy into kinetic energy, but it requires carrying a separate power source and is slower—expelling fewer massive particles per unit time—so it needs more on-orbit time to accumulate the desired velocity change, a trade-off most operators accept for the fuel savings.
“it's actually more efficient to do electrical into kinetic in terms of the unit mass, however you need your own power source when you're doing the electrical conversion, chemical carries the power required within the reaction”
- Each thruster chip produces only about 12.5 to 50 micro-newtons—comparable to a mosquito landing on your hand—but because there is no gravity well or atmospheric drag to fight in space, this tiny force accumulated over hundreds or thousands of hours is enough to complete most commercial satellite missions.
“Each chip produces about 12 and a half to 50 micro-newtons... That's about as much as a mosquito landing on your hand.”
Thousands of satellites will launch annually, driven by private funding and shrinking electronics, requiring innovation in launch and spacecraft cost.
- The number of active space companies grew roughly from 80 in 2008 to around 800 in 2018, though many of the newer ones are not launching things themselves but occupy other parts of the value chain.
“in something like 2008 I believe there were around 80 active space companies, and then 2018 there were something like 800”
- Roughly a thousand spacecraft are launched each year, a number that has increased every year for the past decade and will likely climb to 3,000-5,000 annually, driven by private money, Moore's law shrinking electronics, and rising internet demand.
“every year there are around a thousand spacecraft launched, that number has increased from the previous kind of space industry... I think we'll probably start to see numbers more like 3,000, 5,000 spacecrafts launched annually”
- Innovation in launch and satellite design is stuck in a chicken-and-egg problem: guaranteed demand of 5,000 launches per year would unlock launch-side innovation, and a guaranteed $500-per-kilogram-to-orbit price would unlock satellite-side innovation, but neither can be guaranteed without the other already existing.
“It's a bit of a chicken and egg problem. If they could be guaranteed 5,000 launches per year, we could start seeing a lot of innovation on the launch side, if we could be guaranteed $500 a kilogram to orbit, we could see more innovation on the satellite side.”
- Standardizing the satellite form factor through the CubeSat reduces costs and thereby enables more users worldwide—including countries, organizations, high schools, and garage hobbyists—to leverage spacecraft.
“a standardized anything basically can lead to reduced costs, and therefore more users around the world being able to leverage spacecraft”
Orbital debris and collision cascades threaten low Earth orbit unless satellites are placed high or built to deorbit within 20–25 years.
- Orbital lifetime increases exponentially with altitude: a satellite at ~300 km decays in about a year, at 500 km it can last ~20 years, and above 500 km objects become effectively permanent fixtures, which is why agencies prefer either sub-500 km orbits or built-in de-orbit capability to keep lifetimes under 20-25 years.
“a satellite launched to about, I think it's 300 or so kilometers, will stay there for about a year. A satellite launched to 500 kilometers, could stay there for about 20 years, and it's actually an exponential relationship with altitude”
- Space agencies including the UN and NASA actively prefer satellites be placed in low orbits (500 km and below) or carry de-orbit capability so they last only 20-25 years, making impermanence a deliberate part of the solution to orbital clutter.
“a satellite launched to about, I think it's 300 or so kilometers, will stay there for about a year. A satellite launched to 500 kilometers, could stay there for about 20 years, and it's actually an exponential relationship with altitude”
- When satellites collide they can shatter into thousands of new debris pieces, which can trigger a runaway cascade called the Kessler syndrome, potentially generating so much debris that low Earth orbit becomes unusable for Earth-facing applications.
“sometimes satellites collide with one another or hit another object in space, and they themselves turn into 10,000 new pieces of debris, and that can actually have a kind of water fall sort of effect called The Kessler syndrome”
- The risk of a person being hit by spacecraft debris is negligible—comparable to being attacked by a shark and struck by lightning on the same day—and apparently no one has ever actually been hit.
“you're more likely to be attacked by a shark and struck by lightning in the same day than you are to be hit by a piece of debris from a spacecraft”
Space infrastructure is better built as permanent orbiting stations than through terraforming or fleeing to harsher planets.
- Once humanity escapes one gravity well, it is risky to plant ourselves in another; rather than terraforming a harsh planet like Mars, it would be more feasible to build an orbiting station around Earth or at a Lagrange point where we can design and curate our own environment, especially given how frail humans are.
“it's a bit risky to plant yourself in another gravity well once you make it off of one... it's probably worthwhile considering building an orbiting station maybe at around the Earth, or something at a Lagrange point”
- Terraforming Mars seems unrealistic given that humanity cannot even control the climate of its own planet; if humans survive 300-400 years it will likely be because we learned to live sustainably on this one planet and diversify life-support locally rather than fleeing to a harsher world.
“if humans are around in 300, 400 years, it's probably because we found a way to live off of just this one planet and to diversify a little bit in terms of where we're able to support life”
Space shifted from rare strategic asset to critical dependency accessible to many, elevating its geopolitical and military importance.
- Space went from being a rare strategic asset for a few space-faring countries in the 1960s-90s to a dependency and liability today, because so many critical systems now rely on it while access is no longer rare, prompting the Pentagon to consider a separate military branch for space.
“space in the '60s to '90s was a big asset for space-faring countries. Now it's kind of flipped into a liability and we're so dependent on it, but now it's not a rare place that only a few people can access”
- Ion propulsion cannot be used for launch from a planet not because of fundamental physics but because available power sources have too low a specific power (power per kilogram) to be safely launched from inhabited countries; nuclear or antimatter sources could in principle enable it, making the barrier political and engineering rather than physical.
“for launch the current limitation is in the power supply system, so the specific power, power per kilogram. Most power sources that people feel comfortable launching from a country with people living in it are too... that number is too low”
Interstellar exploration via probes, memory transfer, or solar sails offers more promise than sending biological humans across vast distances.
- Because frail biological humans are the main obstacle to interstellar travel, a more feasible approach than sending whole people is to send stem cells with a robot, or—if we learn to read and write human memory—to package memories into a spacecraft, since memories are arguably the only things that make us unique and the biological form becomes unnecessary.
“humans in our frail biological forms are the main problem there. And so instead, maybe we send some stem cells and a robot or something”
- The interstellar object Oumuamua was shaped suspiciously like a solar sail and showed an anomalous trajectory with an apparent thruster-like burst; while the leading explanation is outgassing from solar heating, its unprecedented interstellar origin and peculiar form made it worth far more study than it received.
“our best guess as humans is that it passed by something that heated it up and caused gases to expand and give it a push”
- Breakthrough Starshot aims to use a gigawatt-scale laser to accelerate tiny solar-sail chip spacecraft to a respectable fraction of light speed to reach Alpha Centauri in about 20 years; every part of it is impossible today—the laser doesn't exist and receiving the return signal would require a detector the size of the Earth-Sun distance—yet it is exciting because the world's smartest people are working on it.
“the goal is to use, I don't know, gagillion watt laser to accelerate tiny spacecraft with little solar sails, to speed such that they could reach Alpha Centauri in I think it was 20 years”
Asteroid mining and extraterrestrial life are constrained by economic or existential realities different from popular assumptions.
- Accion's thrusters have progressed from operating for 10-20 hours when they spun out of the lab to recently breaking 1,000 hours of operation, the key metric that has made the technology ready to go to market.
“when we spun out of our lab, we were operating for 10 hours, 20 hours, recently we just broke a 1,000 hours and that's actually what we're... Now we're ready to go to market”
- Pulsars may be something we do not yet understand and warrant continued suspicion.
“I will forever remain really suspicious of pulsars too. Like what are those? Those have gotta be something that we don't understand yet.”
- Self-replicating molecules and bacterial-type life are probably very common given the number of Earth-like planets, but the probability of life reaching an intelligent, knowledge-generating stage is roughly matched by the probability of that planet being wiped out by a self-made or external catastrophe, so the tragedy is that accumulated knowledge is repeatedly lost and each civilization starts over.
“the main problem I see is that to make it to that point, that probability is probably about the same probability as that whole planet getting wiped out by some sort of catastrophe”
- Mining asteroids for a commodity like platinum is economically self-defeating because bringing back large quantities and inserting them into the market collapses the price, undermining the justification for the cost; the equation only works when the goal is harvesting resources (like water) more cheaply than returning to Earth for them.
“as soon as you start bringing back that amount of platinum to the earth and inserting it into the market, all of a sudden the value of platinum has completely diminished. And so, how do you justify the cost of doing that?”