What this covers

Sean Carroll talks with historian Lindsey Fitzharris about two of her books: Sleuth-Hound, on the Edinburgh surgeon Joseph Bell, and The Facemaker, on Harold Gillies. They begin with the pre-anesthesia operating theatre, where patients came to surgeons only in desperation and amputation was common because compound fractures nearly always became infected. Ether anesthesia made surgeons willing to cut deeper, but with no grasp of germs, postoperative infection rose until Joseph Lister's antisepsis explained what was killing patients. Without welfare, losing a limb could also mean losing a livelihood.

The Bell portion covers his habit of reading scuffed shoes, posture, and the way a jacket was worn to build a diagnostic narrative, and his insistence on avoiding leading questions. Arthur Conan Doyle learned this as a student and handed it to Sherlock Holmes. Fitzharris stresses Bell's wider work: bringing forensic medicine into the courtroom, reforming Edinburgh nursing, and supporting women in medicine. She also describes Henry Duncan Littlejohn's fingerprinting and postmortem photography, and the Victorian baby-farming trade.

The Gillies portion begins with the First World War, whose weapons produced roughly 280,000 men needing facial reconstruction. It follows his tubed skin flaps, his team of dentists and artists, and his conviction that a typical-looking face also works better. The conversation then turns to the social damage: veterans isolated on blue benches, a broken engagement, and the relief of Queen's Hospital, where everyone was disfigured. It ends with Gillies's work for the trans man Michael Dillon.

Sharpest takeaway

Fitzharris argues that the history of surgery and forensic medicine is best understood through individual practitioners whose diagnostic habits and humane priorities drove change, using Joseph Bell and Harold Gillies to show how medicine's biggest advances came from attention to detail, identity, and patients' lives beyond survival.

  • Joseph Bell's method of reading small physical clues was the real template for Sherlock Holmes, and Bell applied it to forensic work with Henry Duncan Littlejohn.
  • Harold Gillies pioneered reconstructive surgery by pairing aesthetics with function and by treating psychological recovery as part of medicine.
  • Surgical progress was limited as much by surgeons' ego and habits as by the lack of technology, as the Lister and antisepsis story shows.

The argument · threads16 threads · 98 claims
0.71

Bell was Holmes's real inspiration, but public caricature and attention obscured his credit.

7 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Bell did not invent a single tool or discipline, but changed the way people think about crime scenes and forensic reasoning, a shift that passed through Conan Doyle and Holmes to the wider world.

    “Bell didn't create a single tool or he didn't create a discipline... But he does do something. He changes the way we think.”

  • In a 1892 interview, Conan Doyle named Bell as the inspiration for Holmes, and in his letter to Bell he wrote, 'Yes, it's to you I owe Sherlock Holmes,' before dedicating the Holmes stories to Bell and printing Bell's address in the book.

    “And Conan Doyle writes him this extraordinary letter which I've seen with my own eyes. And it says, 'Yes, it's to you I owe Sherlock Holmes.'”

  • After Conan Doyle dedicated the Holmes stories to Bell and printed his address, journalists showed up at Bell's house, and his initial flattery turned to irritation as the public wanted him to be Sherlock Holmes.

    “He dedicates the Holmes stories to Bell and he puts his address right in the front of the book. So now everybody knows”

  • Holmes is sociopathic in comparison with Joseph Bell, who was an empathetic family man, meaning the public's Holmes caricature obscured the real Bell.

    “Bell wasn't that. He was a very empathetic man. He was a family man.”

  • The 1888 Ripper murders, which police could not solve, eroded public confidence in police, and rising literacy and cheap printing made the case a mass-media obsession, showing that true-crime appetite was as strong in the 19th century as today.

    “in 1888, you have rising literacy rates and you have all of this cheap printing.”

  • The executioner later claimed Bury had confessed to being Jack the Ripper, a story Fitzharris treats as a pub tale of unknown truth rather than evidence.

    “the executioner claimed later that Bury had confessed to being Ripper.”

  • Bell found the sociopathic Holmes caricature irritating, writing that his old student must not have thought highly of him, because Bell was an empathetic family man, and the public wanted him to be Holmes despite the differences.

    “My old student must not have thought very highly of me to put this heap of rubbish on my head.”

0.64

Bell and Littlejohn pioneered forensic methods, and Bell's observational method helped bring medicine into investigation.

10 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Joe Bell claimed in a later interview that he and Littlejohn separately investigated the Ripper and wrote the same suspect's name in envelopes they exchanged, though the name was never disclosed.

    “they exchanged envelopes, and in the envelopes, they had written down the same name.”

  • Eugène Chantrelle was drinking companions with Robert Louis Stevenson and may have inspired aspects of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, though no direct evidence has been established.

    “he was drinking buddies with Robert Louis Stevenson, and he became one of the inspirations for Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.”

  • Henry Duncan Littlejohn was a pioneer of fingerprinting and courtroom photography, and he began photographing postmortems so that jurors could understand forensic evidence.

    “a police surgeon named Henry Duncan Littlejohn, who's a fascinating pioneer of fingerprinting and courtroom photography”

  • Littlejohn first handled the baby farming case alone with his son, but after finding a second child at Jessie King's flat, he brought in Bell, and they jointly performed the second postmortem and testified together.

    “So Bell performs the second postmortem with Littlejohn and they testify in the case as well.”

  • Eugène Chantrelle, executed for murdering his wife, reportedly told the police surgeon on the scaffold to give his regards to Joe Bell, implying Bell helped secure the noose, but Fitzharris has no evidence Bell worked on the case.

    “Give my regards to Joe Bell. He did a good job putting the noose around my neck.”

  • Carroll questioned whether the Holmes method is repeatable, since most people do not carry obvious clues; Fitzharris agreed that the skill is rare and extraordinary, but argued that Bell actually possessed it, so the fictional method was grounded in real perceptual training.

    “I don't know anybody today who has that Sherlockian skill, completely has that skill.”

  • The Bell and Littlejohn partnership represents the first time medicine systematically entered the courtroom, with forensic science becoming a formal part of criminal investigation in the 19th century.

    “It is the first time that medicine enters the courtroom, and Bell is very much a part of that.”

  • Police surgeon Henry Duncan Littlejohn, who had taught Bell, began calling on him as a second set of eyes on cases; they sometimes investigated separately and then compared notes, often reaching the same conclusions.

    “he starts calling on Bell to be sort of second eyes on a lot of his cases.”

  • Joseph Bell was an early advocate of both antisepsis and vaccination, placing him at the forefront of medical progress in his era alongside his advocacy for women in medicine.

    “he was an early advocate of antisepsis. Like I said, he advocated for women in medicine. So he was always sort of at the forefront of progress there.”

  • Bell's method was not just observation but turning observations into a narrative, as illustrated by his advice that doctors should not assume a sleeping-pill patient is sleeping well, but first ask whether they took the medication.

    “You also, it wasn't just about observation. You had to take that information in and then you create a narrative, right?”

0.57

Surgery was a deadly last resort before anesthesia, and anesthesia's deadliness ended only with Lister's antisepsis.

13 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Surgeons did not wash hands between patients before germ theory because, without understanding invisible germs, washing seemed pointless since hands would get dirty again with the next patient.

    “Until you understand germs exist, it doesn't actually make sense.”

  • The most dangerous thing in medicine is not ignorance but ego, and Lister had to persuade surgeons to change habits that were killing patients, which proved harder than the discovery itself.

    “the most dangerous thing in medicine isn't necessarily ignorance, it is ego.”

  • Joseph Lister saved more lives than almost anyone by applying Louis Pasteur's germ theory to surgical practice, explaining postoperative infections and making surgery far safer.

    “Lister, I always say, saved more lives than any other person who lived because he applies Louis Pasteur's germ theory to surgical practice”

  • Surgery became more dangerous right after anesthesia arrived, because surgeons became willing to cut deeper into patients who no longer fought back, but they still did not understand germs, so postoperative infection rose.

    “surgery becomes a lot more dangerous immediately following this because the surgeon is more willing to pick up the knife.”

  • After ether arrived, operations became slow-moving executions because postoperative infection rose, and Lister's work solved the medical mystery of what was killing patients.

    “operations became nothing more than slow-moving executions after that because postoperative infection rose.”

  • Lister was unusually honest in publishing his surgical results and admitting failures, which was rare because many doctors did not admit failure, and hospital statistics only came later in the nineteenth century.

    “Lister starts publishing his results. He's very honest, which is kind of unusual as well. A lot of doctors didn't admit when they had failure.”

  • Pre-antisepsis surgical survival depended on the patient's place in the day's schedule, because surgeons did not wash instruments or tables, so later patients faced steadily worse odds.

    “If you were the first patient, great. If you were the last patient, remember, the surgeon's not washing his hands or his instruments.”

  • Medical history is underrated because everyone has experienced being a patient, so it lets people see how much medical experience has changed over the last 100 to 200 years.

    “Because everybody knows what it's like to be sick, to be a patient. And I tell you how that experience was like 100, 150, 200 years ago.”

  • In the pre-anesthesia era, people went to surgeons only when desperate, and amputation was often chosen because compound fractures almost always became infected, while lacking welfare meant losing a limb could be a death sentence.

    “And so there was no net to catch you. So if you suddenly lost your legs and you couldn't work, that could be a death sentence too.”

  • Surgeons were historically lowly in the medical hierarchy, descended from barber-surgeons, and they separated from barbers in 1745 while physicians dealt with internal disease, which is the origin of internal medicine.

    “they split with the barber-surgeons in 1745 and they tried to really distance themselves from barbering, but they were men who made money with their hands.”

  • Doctors in the 19th century often caught smallpox and tuberculosis and died, even Henry Gray of Gray's Anatomy, who died prematurely from smallpox despite vaccination, because there were no antibiotics and limited vaccines.

    “Even Henry Gray of Gray's Anatomy dies prematurely by catching smallpox.”

  • Operating theaters in the 19th century were true theaters where people bought tickets to watch surgery, and Fitzharris argues this morbid curiosity persists today through shows like The Pitt.

    “The operating theaters were theaters in the truest sense. I mean, people bought tickets to witness this.”

  • Early 19th-century medical training was disturbing, and some would-be doctors quit after witnessing surgery or dissections, including Hector Berlioz, who jumped out a window, and James Simpson, who left surgery after watching a mastectomy performed with a fork-like instrument.

    “he's so horrified by the cadavers and the anatomy lessons that he jumps out the window”

0.53

Gillies transformed care for disfigured soldiers and founded modern plastic surgery, whose legacy continues.

11 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Early facial reconstruction in the American Civil War looked poor because surgeons did not yet accept Lister's antisepsis, so they focused on function rather than appearance, increasing infection risk.

    “Civil War surgeons don't believe Joseph Lister yet. So infection rates could be really high”

  • Gillies rebuilt faces by rolling skin flaps from the chest or thigh into tubes that kept their own blood supply, attaching one end to the face and then moving the other end up in stages, because microsurgical transfer was not yet available.

    “he would roll it in a tube, if you can imagine, almost like an elephant trunk. And then he would attach one end to the face.”

  • Gillies assembled an interdisciplinary team including dentists, who handled bone architecture, and artists, while he handled soft tissue, a cross-specialty approach unusual because dentists were seen as lower than surgeons.

    “So when Gillies opens his own hospital, he brings dentists on board. At the time, dentists were seen to be much lower than the surgeon”

  • Battlefield doctors often hastily stitched facial wounds to stop bleeding without addressing lost tissue, and sometimes sealed bacteria into the wound, so faces caved in and Gillies later had to unpick the work.

    “they were sometimes inadvertently sewing up the bacteria from the battlefield into the face, so they were literally sealing these men's fate.”

  • About 280,000 men in World War I needed some form of facial reconstruction, creating an unprecedented opportunity for experimentation that helped establish plastic surgery as a discipline.

    “280,000 men during the First World War needed some form of facial reconstruction. So it was this incredible opportunity to experiment.”

  • Harold Gillies effectively founded modern plastic surgery, and most plastic surgeons know his work, with training lineages tracing back to him in few degrees of separation.

    “Gillies basically births all of plastic surgery. I go around talking to plastic surgeons at conferences and they all know of Gillies.”

  • Plastic surgery is not only cosmetic; reconstructive surgery for cancer, accidents, and war injuries remains a central part of the field, and many plastic surgeons only do reconstruction.

    “Cosmetic surgery is one part of plastic surgery. There is still reconstructive surgery.”

  • Surgeons such as Steve Orton in Texas are treating face injuries from trench warfare in Ukraine using methods descended from Gillies's work, but faster and with later knowledge.

    “there's this surgeon in Texas named Steve Orton, and he is doing this amazing work in Ukraine.”

  • Ivan Magill, Gillies's anesthesiologist, developed intratracheal anesthesia, which allowed anesthesia for facial surgery despite missing noses and mouths and kept ether from reaching Gillies's face.

    “it's really his anesthesiologist, a man named Ivan Magill, who comes up with the idea of intratracheal anesthesia.”

  • Harold Gillies died after a stroke that occurred while he was operating, and in later life he continued both congenital and accident reconstruction and cosmetic work he saw as helping people make peace with their appearance.

    “He has a stroke... that is the thing that ultimately kills him off.”

  • Gillies died after suffering a stroke, which was the eventual cause of death although he did not die immediately.

    “He has a stroke. ... He doesn't die immediately, but that is the thing that ultimately kills him off.”

0.50

Medical progress brought real benefits but also serious costs, risks, and failures.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • World War I produced major medical advances such as blood transfusions and blood banks near the front, but repaired soldiers were sent back to fight, so medical progress was partly feeding the war machine.

    “as these doctors got better at mending these men, they of course were being sent back to the front, and it was feeding the war machine.”

  • Women using X-rays for facial hair removal developed cancers, and Gillies had to remove large portions of one patient's face, showing how cosmetic experimentation carried serious risks.

    “Women also removed hair using X-rays. Again, terrible to think that they were X-raying their face to remove the hair.”

  • Amputation was a death sentence in the pre-welfare era because losing a limb ended the ability to work and there was no social safety net, so Lister's antisepsis saved people from lifelong disability as well as death.

    “if you suddenly lost your legs and you couldn't work, that could be a death sentence too. There's no welfare.”

  • Gillies's surgical failures were frequent, and failure was his constant companion, as it is for any doctor attempting something revolutionary, with some patients dying in his care and others living as recluses.

    “failure was his constant companion, as it is with every doctor who's trying to do something revolutionary.”

0.50

Joseph Bell's diagnostic reading of bodies trained Conan Doyle's fiction.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Arthur Conan Doyle practiced medicine for several years but gave it up after a severe bout of flu, which followed the death of his sister from flu, and turned to writing because it generated more income.

    “He ends up catching a very severe case of the flu. His sister had died of the flu... he's going to just give up doctoring and he's gonna throw his lot in as a writer.”

  • Joseph Bell diagnosed patients by reading small physical and behavioral details, such as an army deserter's chest tattoo and a female patient's smoking habit inferred from a burn and a lip sore.

    “there is a D tattooed on his chest for a deserter.”

  • Joseph Bell was a Scottish surgeon teaching medical students in Edinburgh, and Arthur Conan Doyle became his medical student in 1878, learning to read patients' bodies and lives like crime scenes.

    “a Scottish surgeon named Joe Bell was teaching medical students how to read a human body like a crime scene. And in 1878, Arthur Conan Doyle becomes his medical student.”

  • Conan Doyle's medical training never left him, and its fingerprints appear throughout his fiction beyond Sherlock Holmes.

    “that medical training never left him, and you can see the fingerprints of that medical training in not just Sherlock Holmes, but in other things that he writes.”

0.46

Disfigurement brings lasting stigma, and its damage is largely social rather than physical.

8 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Although Gillies's plastic surgery aimed to restore identity to disfigured soldiers, the field has made many people more aware of and anxious about their appearance, creating a paradoxical backlash.

    “plastic surgery has now sort of made us all ultra-aware of how we look.”

  • Hollywood still uses disfigurement as a lazy trope for evil, with villains like Darth Vader, Voldemort, Bond villains, and the Joker, which perpetuates stigma against disfigured people.

    “Think about how many villains are disfigured. You have Darth Vader, Voldemort, the Bond villains, Joker. I mean, it's this very lazy trope for evil.”

  • After WWI, losing a limb made a man a hero, while losing a face made him a monster, and facially disfigured veterans were isolated, as shown by blue benches set aside so people would not look at them.

    “I say that it was a time when losing a limb made you a hero, but losing a face made you a monster.”

  • Gillies believed cosmetic surgery was important because it helped people make peace with their appearance, and he believed people should control aspects of their identity such as their noses.

    “he very much believed that people should have control over the aspects of their identity.”

  • Fitzharris chose the term disfigured rather than facial difference for The Facemaker because the men were disfigured in the eyes of observers and softer language would lessen their isolation.

    “these men were disfigured to the people who looked on their faces. They were isolated, they were on the fringes, and I didn't wanna lessen that experience”

  • Society treats caring about one's looks as unserious even though appearance matters to most people, and women face a higher threshold for appearing on video because of pretty privilege and appearance judgments.

    “the threshold for women going on video is a little bit higher than men. And that is a reality and it's not just vanity.”

  • Many disfigured veterans suffered psychologically, including isolation and rejection, such as Walter Ashworth, whose fiancée broke their engagement and whose employer hid him at the back of a shop, reflecting how much of the damage was social rather than physical.

    “a lot of the wounds were psychological at that time.”

  • Society honored soldiers who lost limbs as heroes but treated soldiers who lost faces as monsters, a double standard Fitzharris argues persists today in Hollywood's use of disfigurement as shorthand for villainy.

    “Think about how many villains are disfigured. You have Darth Vader, Voldemort, the Bond villains, Joker. I mean, it's this very lazy trope for evil.”

0.44

Good diagnosis means detecting what patients conceal, as Bell's practical questioning showed.

7 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Patients often fail to disclose all vitamins they take, even though some vitamins can cause overdose, so doctors do not get a full medical story even when patients have good intentions.

    “a lot of patients don't even realize that, for instance, maybe you should disclose how many vitamins you're taking because sometimes you can actually overdose on vitamins”

  • Bell diagnosed a patient who claimed sudden blindness as not truly blind by making her react to a gesture, and this kind of cutting through petty deceit shows his practical diagnostic skill.

    “he puts his thumb on his nose and wiggles his fingers, and she says, 'How dare you.'”

  • Bell trained students to avoid leading questions, for example not telling a patient they look well when asking about sleep medication, so that patients reveal whether they actually take the medication.

    “Let them first say whether they're taking the medication at all, right?”

  • Bell's students suspected he had seen the notes before patients arrived, but last-minute patients proved his observational skill was real.

    “they would say, 'Well, he must have gotten sight of the notes before the patients came in.' But then ultimately there would be a last-minute patient”

  • Bell taught students to recognize a disease the way one recognizes a best friend in a crowd of men, by seeing the unique traits that distinguish it, and Fitzharris compares this to caricature, which captures what makes a face unique rather than mocking it.

    “You need to be able to recognize specific diseases as you would recognize your best friend in a group of men.”

  • Doctors remain detectives in practice, and the original Sherlock Holmes being a doctor reflects that medicine requires investigating patients' concealed information.

    “Because doctors are still detectives. And it's an important part of doctoring.”

  • Bell's approach of linking how someone smokes, walks, or dresses to their ailments anticipated a holistic view of patients that modern medicine still struggles to accept, because patients often withhold information from doctors.

    “we lie to our doctors still today, don't we? Or we don't tell them everything we should.”

0.39

Medicine is about what comes after survival, restoring identity and self-worth to disfigured patients.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Walter Ashworth, after multiple surgeries and a fiancée's breakoff, found a new life, yet later declined further surgery because he had made peace with the face that brought him happiness, illustrating that the book's theme is identity rather than perfect appearance.

    “He had made peace with the face he had been given, a face that had brought him happiness.”

  • Fitzharris was persuaded to seek a second opinion from a surgeon influenced by The Facemaker, because he offered reconstruction planning, showing that cancer care should consider the body patients must live in after treatment.

    “it's nice to have a surgeon who's also thinking about the body that you need to occupy after the cancer is gone.”

  • Medicine is not just about survival but about what comes after survival, and Gillies's work focused on giving disfigured men back a sense of self.

    “I always say that medicine isn't just about survival. It's about what comes after surviving.”

  • Gillies's Queen's Hospital, the first dedicated plastic surgery hospital, was psychologically freeing because everyone there was disfigured, reducing self-consciousness and building community among patients.

    “if you were disfigured and you were sent to a general hospital... But at Gillies' hospital, everybody was disfigured.”

  • Harold Gillies performed one of the first phalloplasties on a trans man, Michael Dillon, in the 1940s, and the technique he developed is still used today, while Gillies defended Dillon's right to control his identity.

    “he performs the first phalloplasty on a trans man in the 1940s, a man named Michael Dillon.”

0.37

Bell's legacy extended beyond Holmes into real forensic and reform work.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Conan Doyle's public credit for Bell was widely known, but the real Bell was largely lost behind the Sherlock Holmes persona, and Sherlockians who know Holmes can know Bell too.

    “And I think he was generally lost in it. And another thing I like to tell people is if you're a Sherlockian... you will know about Joe Bell because this wasn't a secret.”

  • Joseph Bell's legacy extends beyond inspiring Sherlock Holmes: he advanced forensic medicine entering the courtroom, reformed Edinburgh nursing, was friends with Florence Nightingale, and supported women in medicine.

    “He also reforms nursing in Edinburgh. He's good friends with Florence Nightingale. He's a proponent of women in medicine.”

  • Bell's diary, donated to the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh after being held privately by the Bell family, revealed he worked unofficially with police surgeon Henry Duncan Littlejohn on high-profile 19th-century crimes, doing what Holmes did in reality.

    “his diary was donated to the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh... I suddenly had access to sort of the inner world of Joe Bell.”

  • Joseph Bell's main legacy was his students, and Conan Doyle happened to be the one who made his diagnostic style famous, though Bell also made independent contributions.

    “I think his legacy was his students, and Conan Doyle happened to be one of them.”

0.28

Conan Doyle resented Holmes, yet the character's popularity grew through continual reinvention.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The name Watson may have come from a real Edinburgh figure, Patrick Heron Watson, a ballistics expert in Sleuth-Hound, though Conan Doyle also worked with another Watson, so the origin remains debated.

    “Patrick Heron Watson, who's the ballistics expert who appears in 'Sleuth-Hound', he could potentially have been... That's where Conan Doyle maybe had gotten the name”

  • Conan Doyle hated the Holmes character almost from the start, felt imprisoned by him, and wanted to be seen as a more serious writer, as shown by a 19th-century caricature of him with a tiny Holmes shackled to his ankle.

    “Conan Doyle, he hated the character. He wanted to be seen as a more serious writer.”

  • Conan Doyle tried to kill off Holmes, but public anger, including obituaries, mourning bands, and a reported handbag attack, pressured him to bring the character back.

    “People were really angry with him when he killed off Holmes... people wore mourning bands, some lady allegedly tried to beat him up on the street with her handbag.”

  • Holmes became the first viral character, and his popularity has been sustained through continual reinvention across adaptations, which Fitzharris says makes him the most adapted character in TV and film.

    “he was like the first viral character. And also he's the most adapted character in TV and films.”

  • Holmes's addiction may come from Conan Doyle's father, an alcoholic who created a broken home, showing how the author's personal experience shaped the fictional detective.

    “the addiction probably comes from his father. His father was an alcoholic, and he comes really from this broken home”

  • Conan Doyle transformed detective fiction into a genre and changed magazine serialization so each Holmes story stood alone, unlike Dickens's continuing installments, which left late readers lost.

    “each serialization is a story in and of itself. The repeat is the characters.”

0.21

Ether spread unregulated and invited early profiteering over medical innovation.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • After ether was discovered in 1846 and published in a journal, it spread around the world within days, before any clinical trials or formal safety rules existed.

    “So when ether is discovered, it's written up in a journal and literally within days, it just kind of spreads like wildfire around the world. And remember, this is a time before you had to go through clinical trials”

  • The discovery of ether anesthesia was followed by the dentist who discovered it trying to patent it, and by other men claiming ownership, making it an early case of medical capitalism and a template for asking who benefits from powerful medical innovations.

    “ether is discovered by a dentist in Boston, and then he immediately tries to patent it and make money off of it. So, it's the American way. So it's the first attempt at medical capitalism.”

  • Robert Liston, known as the fastest knife in the West End and 6'2' tall, performed the first British ether operation in December 1846, calling it the Yankee Dodge, and the operation succeeded despite his doubts.

    “He calls it the Yankee Dodge. And it does work, and it's a miracle.”

0.21

Victorian policing, Ripper speculation, and forensic evidence shaped Holmes's analytical image.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The rise of the Holmes character coincided with public distrust of London's bumbling bobbies after Jack the Ripper in 1888, and Holmes's logical image pressured police to adopt more analytical methods.

    “in a way, the rise of Sherlock Holmes puts pressure on the police to change their ways.”

  • William Henry Bury had opportunity and violent tendencies, was in Whitechapel at the time of the murders, and was later hanged for murdering his wife, but Fitzharris considers him a weaker Ripper candidate than others, and the Ripper link rests on uncertain evidence.

    “I don't think a lot of Ripperologists take him seriously... I think there's probably stronger candidates, and we're never gonna ultimately know.”

  • In 19th-century trials, forensic science was new and jurors lacked background knowledge, so experts had to convey technical medical evidence clearly, and Littlejohn used photographs to do so, as the O.J. Simpson DNA trial showed how technical evidence can backfire.

    “they had to be incredibly good at conveying sort of technical information to them.”

0.21

Jenner's cowpox vaccine was safer than inoculation but provoked fear and resistance.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Before Jenner, inoculation used live smallpox virus and could cause death or outbreaks, while Edward Jenner noticed dairymaids with cowpox were protected and developed a safer vaccine from cowpox, the first vaccine.

    “Inoculation uses the live smallpox virus, which was dangerous... Now, what Jenner does is he notices that dairy maids are not catching smallpox because they get something called cowpox.”

  • Smallpox is the only human disease ever fully eradicated, so younger people generally are not vaccinated against it because the disease no longer circulates, though some military personnel were vaccinated after 9/11 due to bioweapon fears.

    “It is the only human disease that we've ever fully eradicated. So if you're a younger listener, you will not have been vaccinated for smallpox”

  • Jenner's cowpox vaccine provoked fear, satirical drawings of people turning into cows, and burnings of effigies of Jenner, but it was somewhat effective against smallpox despite not being foolproof, as Henry Gray's case shows.

    “they would burn effigies of Jenner”

0.18

Surgeons' psychological suffering from patient deaths deserves consideration in medical history.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Pre-anesthesia surgeons faced psychological burden from repeated patient deaths and having to amputate limbs, so surgeons' suffering should be considered alongside patients' suffering in medical history.

    “even with going back to the pre-anesthetic era, we tend to think about the patients, but also spare a thought for the surgeon”

  • The TV show The Knick depicts a surgeon who cannot cope with repeated patient deaths and takes his own life, illustrating the psychological burden surgeons faced in the past.

    “he can't handle the fact that his patient died, because they just keep dying, and he ends up taking his own life.”

0.09

Separate historical cases in medicine, law, and war illustrate related practical concerns.

4 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Baby farming existed because 19th-century women had no birth control and no legal route for adoption, so poor families paid baby farmers to place children with families who could care for them, creating a system that some baby farmers exploited through murder.

    “in the 19th century, there was no birth control and there was no legal route for adoption. So women were having babies, tons of babies.”

  • Gillies's key insight was that a face that looks typical also tends to function better, so a nose in the correct position works better than one shifted aside, which led him to marry aesthetics with functionality.

    “It's really under Gillies where this idea that something that looks good or looks typical also tends to function better.”

  • Scotland's third verdict of not proven, which carries an acquittal, is preferable to not guilty because it places more onus on the prosecution's performance, and Fitzharris regrets Scotland abolished it in recent years.

    “I feel like not proven would have landed better than not guilty, perhaps.”

  • Weapons in World War I had advanced so much that a company of 300 men in 1914 could deploy firepower equivalent to a 60,000-strong army in the Napoleonic Wars, producing huge numbers of disfiguring but nonfatal facial wounds.

    “a company of just 300 men in 1914 could deploy equivalent firepower as a 60,000 strong army during the Napoleonic Wars.”