What this covers

Sean Carroll talks with Jared Diamond about Profits, Prophets, Coaches, and Kings, which carries the geographic reasoning of Guns, Germs, and Steel into a question about individuals: what leaders add to politics, business, religion, and sport. Since leaders can't be randomly assigned, much of the conversation is about method. Diamond favors a natural experiment approach, comparing countries where leaders died in office or were assassinated (about 85 natural deaths and 57 assassinations since World War II) with matched cases where they weren't. Sports is the testing ground because results arrive weekly. Firing a coach after a losing season looks effective partly through regression to the mean. A variance decomposition of CEO effects puts the leader's share near 30 percent, falling to roughly 15 percent when non-switching CEOs are included. A Danish registry study of family deaths among CEOs is also discussed.

The range is wide. Diamond defends geography against scholars who put institutions first, citing sea versus land transport costs, tropical disease, and the north-south "sandwich" pattern of African incomes. He traces early advantage to the Fertile Crescent and its domesticable species, and he contrasts a fragmented Europe with a China whose emperor scrapped its fleets in 1432. Tree-ring evidence links Genghis Khan's rise to a wet period. Religion is treated as needing charisma, organization, and sometimes an army, usually supplied by different people. The most contested case is Adolf Hitler. Gustav Stresemann's alternative and A. J. P. Taylor's view of Hitler as a normal German politician are weighed against Hitler's distinctive deceit and evil.

Sharpest takeaway

Diamond argues leaders matter only under specific conditions (discretion, unique qualification, public resistance, and no ready replacement), so neither pure great-man history nor pure structural determinism explains outcomes.

  • Leaders have outsized effects only when they hold real decision discretion, as with CEOs of trend-driven firms versus regulated utilities.
  • Leaders matter when they are uniquely qualified or when no colleague could replicate their action, as with Seretse Khama versus Clement Attlee.
  • Natural experiments and variance decomposition, tested first on sports coaches, are the methods that can measure leader effects.

The argument · threads10 threads · 59 claims
0.78

Environment and geography, not human capacity or institutions, explain historical development gaps.

10 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Diamond concluded after one day in New Guinea that New Guineans are as smart as Europeans, so the gap in writing, metal tools, and state government must come from environmental differences in domesticable plants and animals rather than from human brains.

    “it took me about one day to realize that, literally one day, New Guineans are every bit as smart, if anything smarter and more curious than Europeans”

  • Transporting goods by sea costs about seven times less per mile per kilogram than over land, so landlocked African countries face a structural cost penalty that helps explain their lower incomes.

    “transportation by sea is seven times cheaper per mile per kilogram than transportation over land”

  • Plotting per capita income across Africa's 48 countries shows a sandwich pattern: the north and south coasts are richer than the tropical interior, and inland countries are poorer than coastal ones, because tropical diseases, low-productivity soils, and expensive land transport all disadvantage them.

    “Africa is a sandwich. The north coast, the five countries of the north coast, and the three countries of the south coast, almost all of them are richer”

  • Diamond argues that politics and culture are universal, citing New Guineans as more skilled at politics than Europeans, so Europe's distinctive advantage lay in its geography and early agriculture rather than any special political culture.

    “So there's nothing unique about European politics and culture”

  • The Fertile Crescent gained its early lead because its wild ancestors of cow, sheep, goat, pig, and horse, plus wheat, peas, beans, and lentils, were domesticable, producing food surpluses that fed full-time leaders and inventors, and those advantages then spread to Europe.

    “the reason that you and I are speaking English, not Nahuatl, has everything to do with the wild plants and animals of the Fertile Crescent”

  • Once the Fertile Crescent's domesticable plants and animals spread quickly across Europe, Asia, and China, the region lost its unique advantage, and its dry, salinization-prone land left it behind even though it had led earlier.

    “Once those advantages of the Fertile Crescent had spread out, the Fertile Crescent was left with no unique advantages”

  • Aboriginal Australia had no agriculture in modern times because no Australian animal or plant was domesticable; European attempts to domesticate kangaroos failed because of the kangaroo social system, so the absence reflects the environment rather than the people.

    “to this day, there is no Australian animal or plant that has been domesticated”

  • Diamond argues that social scientists who claim institutions now outweigh geography are mistaken, because tropical disease burdens, poor tropical soils, and landlocked transport costs still explain much of Africa's poverty.

    “There are social scientists, including good, admired friends of mine, who would say no, what counts today is institutions”

  • Some social scientists, including admired friends of Diamond, argue that institutions rather than geography and environment determine current development outcomes, a view Diamond rejects.

    “There are social scientists, including good, admired friends of mine, who would say no, what counts today is institutions.”

  • Europe overtook India despite both receiving Fertile Crescent crops because Europe fronts the Atlantic and has the Mediterranean as a shipbuilding training ground, while India does not front the Atlantic.

    “Europe fronts on the Atlantic Ocean. India does not front on the Atlantic Ocean. Europe has this huge inlet, the world's biggest inland sea, the Mediterranean, which was a practice ground for shipbuilding and sailing.”

0.71

Leader effects can be measured through natural experiments and shared comparative methods.

13 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Diamond's New Guinea bird research compares mountains with and without the Lowland Mouse-babbler to measure its effect on the Mountain Mouse-babbler, which is the same logic used to study leaders through natural experiments.

    “I can compare mountains in New Guinea that happen to have the Lowland Mouse-babbler with mountains that happen to not have the Lowland Mouse-babbler”

  • Whether Hitler made a difference is an open question: Hitler was distinctively evil and deceptive, but Germany's post-World War I conditions and Stresemann's peaceful alternative mean any German leader would have sought to undo Versailles, and A. J. P. Taylor argued Hitler was a normal German politician.

    “Hitler was a distinctive person. One can argue, therefore, that Hitler made a difference. But the other side of it is that Germany lost World War I”

  • Because political leaders cannot be experimentally manipulated, historians can use natural experiments, comparing countries where leaders died in office or were assassinated with countries where they did not, with about 85 natural deaths and 57 assassinations of leaders since World War II as the data.

    “you can use those as natural experiments. You can compare what happened in countries where the leader died of a heart attack or got assassinated”

  • The 1930 car accident in which a truck stopped just short of Hitler's car shows that a single chance event could have removed Hitler before he took power in 1933, which Diamond uses to frame whether the Holocaust and World War II depended on one man.

    “if the truck had been going a bit faster, it would have run over Hitler and Hitler would have died”

  • Diamond's book Collapse focuses on whole-society collapse, such as the Classic Maya around AD 900 where drought and limited water access were probably a main factor, whereas his new book focuses on how individual leaders affect outcomes.

    “The Classic Maya... collapsed around AD 900. There's still some argument about the contributions of causes, but probably a main factor was a drought”

  • Diamond restricts his political analysis to leaders from 1940 to 2000 because only then is documentation rich enough from photographs and television to judge leader impact, and he avoids judging Merkel or Trump because their stories are unfinished.

    “I discuss only politicians from 1940 onwards because we have rich documentation from photographs and then from television”

  • Physicists and physiologists can run manipulative experiments, but in politics such experiments are impossible and unethical, so causal analysis depends on natural experiments and biographical evidence.

    “But in politics, it's not possible. And if it were possible, it wouldn't be legal or nice to do manipulative experiments”

  • Because leaders cannot be randomly assigned or removed experimentally, social scientists must use natural experiments, comparing outcomes where leaders died naturally, were assassinated, or were absent with matched cases where they were not, which Diamond argues offers the most insight into leaders across politics, business, sports, and religion.

    “But in politics, it's not possible. And if it were possible, it wouldn't be legal or nice to do manipulative experiments.”

  • Assessing whether ancient leaders such as Augustus or Julius Caesar made a difference is hard because the historical record lacks the richness of modern photographic and television documentation, and biographies can be biased.

    “it's difficult to make a strong argument in the past because we just don't have the richness of information we have at present.”

  • The new book examines whether leaders make a difference across four spheres (politics, business, sports coaching, and religion) and uses shared methods across them, with an epilogue suggesting extension to art, music, science, and military history.

    “So those are the four areas that I look at.”

  • Business school and public policy researchers developed statistical methods for measuring coach effects in sports and then applied them to CEOs and politicians, finding that governors hold more power than city mayors, with Los Angeles mayoral turnout only about 20 percent.

    “within the United States, governors of states have more power, make more of a difference than do mayors of cities”

  • US governors have more power and make more of a difference than big-city mayors, and low mayoral turnout (about 20 percent in Los Angeles) reflects the view that mayors have little power.

    “within the United States, governors of states have more power, make more of a difference than do mayors of cities.”

  • Industry choice has large effects on profitability: perfume manufacturing and teen T-shirts are profitable industries, while tightly regulated public utilities are not, and the average year effect on profits is only about 3 percent.

    “public utilities, it's so tightly regulated, it's not a terribly profitable industry.”

0.57

Leaders matter only under conditions of discretion, uniqueness, and irreplaceability.

7 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Diamond's general answer to whether leaders matter is that they do so only under specific conditions: when they have discretion, when they are uniquely qualified, when they do things in a distinctive way, or when no capable colleagues could replace them.

    “So in short, answer to your question is leaders can make a difference, one, if they have discretion, and sometimes they do and sometimes they don't.”

  • Diamond's answer that leaders sometimes matter and sometimes do not is an intentionally complex answer, and he treats the complexity as the correct lesson rather than a failure to answer.

    “sometimes it makes a difference, sometimes it doesn't make a difference.”

  • Leaders matter most when they are uniquely qualified for a task, as Seretse Khama was in Botswana, where only 21 university graduates existed at independence and he straddled European and African worlds, chiefly controlled the diamond-bearing land, and could abolish chiefly power.

    “Botswana at independence had only 21 university graduates. If you're founding president, you'd better be a university graduate”

  • A leader's impact is contingent on whether capable colleagues stand ready to continue the same work: Clement Attlee's death would have been replaced by a colleague, whereas Rachel Carson's or Seretse Khama's would not have been.

    “if Clement Attlee had died in bed the next morning, one of his colleagues would have done the same thing.”

  • Many leaders make a difference not by uniquely doing something no one else could do but by doing it in a distinctive way, as Bezos, Zuckerberg, and Jobs did in e-commerce and social media, where eBay, Walmart, and others offered alternative approaches.

    “some leaders make a difference not because they did what nobody else could have done, but that they did it in a distinctive way”

  • Leaders can make a difference when they pursue something the public does not want but can persuade the public to accept it, as Franklin Roosevelt did in preparing the United States for World War II and Charles de Gaulle did in leaving Algeria.

    “They may make a difference if they want to do something that the public does not want to do, but they're sufficiently persuasive”

  • Diamond's experiences of World War II and family losses in the Holocaust and Siberian camps shaped his lifelong sense that his life had been influenced by leaders, motivating his shift to a book on leaders after Upheaval in 2019.

    “So my life has been spent in the shadow of leaders, but also my life has been spent with advantages gained from leaders.”

0.41

Business leaders measurably affect firm performance, but discretion and company factors limit their impact.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • A Danish registry study of 78,000 companies found that when a CEO's only child or spouse dies, profits drop for a year or two, with sibling deaths having a smaller effect and parent deaths smaller still, showing that CEO distraction measurably affects firm performance.

    “when a close relative of a CEO dies, the company's profits take a hit for a year or two because the CEO is distracted, and CEOs do make a difference”

  • Sports is a better setting than business for studying leaders because results appear every week, whereas in business results are either invisible or arrive only every five years, making sports a testing ground for methods later applied to CEOs.

    “in sports you see the results every week. In business, you either never see the results or you see them every five years”

  • Diamond argues that a competent corporate structure selecting a good CEO is a minor consideration because almost no major company has had an unblemished or consistently productive record in choosing leaders.

    “I'm hard-pressed to think of a major company that has had an unblemished or even a productive”

  • Procter and Gamble has been well-run for 150 years and remains relatively profitable even within its soap and personal-products industry, illustrating that company-level factors can persist across leadership changes.

    “Procter & Gamble has been a well-run company for 150 years”

  • Allison Mackie's study of CEOs who switched companies attributed about 30 percent of profit variation to the leader, about 20 percent each to the industry and the company, and about 3 percent to the year, and when non-switching CEOs were included the CEO share fell to roughly 15 percent.

    “Her conclusion was that CEOs account for about 30% of the variation in profits”

  • Leaders make a difference when they have discretion to make decisions, as CEOs of trend-driven firms like teen T-shirt or perfume companies do, but not when they run railroads locked in for decades or heavily regulated utilities, where their choices are constrained.

    “the magic word is discretion. Discretion not in the sense of being discreet and polite, but discretion in the sense of having the power to make decisions”

0.39

A leader's impact depends heavily on being in the right time and place.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Mark Zuckerberg's Facebook succeeded partly because he happened to launch at the point when technology had advanced enough to support social media, after earlier social media had failed for lack of adequate technology, and he did not recognize the timing as perfect.

    “Mark Zuckerberg happened to be born at the time of the right technological advances. He didn't know it”

  • Leaders relate to right time and place in three ways: some select the moment, as Charles de Gaulle and Bill Gates did; some are offered the moment, as Winston Churchill was; and some happen to be in the right place without knowing it, as Genghis Khan and Mark Zuckerberg were.

    “there are leaders who were aware of the importance of time and place and looked for the right time and place”

  • Winston Churchill could not engineer his own rise, but when he was offered the prime ministership after Chamberlain faced resignation pressure, he recognized the moment as the culmination of his life's preparation, an example of a leader whose time is offered rather than selected.

    “I knew that this was the moment for which my entire life was a preparation”

  • Dendrochronology of Central Asian pine trees shows the wettest period in 2,000 years coincided with Genghis Khan's birth, and abundant grass for sheep, goats, and horses, which Mongol warriors needed in large numbers, meant the conqueror was lucky without knowing it.

    “the wettest time in Central Asia in the last 2,000 years was around the time of Genghis's birth”

  • Bill Gates initially told Paul Allen the time was not right for microcomputers, then after the 1975 Popular Electronics cover on an Intel microchip he decided to act immediately because others would otherwise move first, illustrating leaders who select the moment.

    “Now is the time. We gotta act now 'cause other people will do it”

0.37

Hitler's personal impact is contested, and structural pressures constrained German leaders.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Hitler's effectiveness came from being a mesmerizing speaker and brilliant deceiver who believed he would die early and so took risks, some of which paid off, such as the Rhineland and war, while others, like Stalingrad and the Battle of the Bulge, failed.

    “He was convinced that he was gonna die early, and so he wanted to do things quickly. And so he took risks”

  • A. J. P. Taylor argued, without new evidence, that Hitler was a normal German politician with normal goals of reversing World War I's effects, and that his firing of generals over alleged homosexuality reflected genuine moral outrage, a reading that Diamond presents as an open question.

    “he retold the story of Hitler's life. And he said Hitler was a normal German politician with normal goals”

  • Any German leader after World War I would have prioritized undoing Versailles' effects, because the treaty's conditions and the 1923 hyperinflation caused by the occupation of the Ruhr destroyed the middle class, so the pressure on German leadership was structural as well as personal.

    “So one can say that any leader of Germany after World War I, a prime objective would have been to undo the effects of World War I.”

  • Diamond notes that historians largely doubt that Hitler's personal idiosyncrasies explain the war, and that Hitler's 1937 firing of two generals reflects contested personality-based interpretations.

    “Even historians disagree. Probably most historians view Hitler as uniquely evil”

0.34

Political fragmentation or unity shaped innovation, with unity sometimes becoming a long-run disadvantage.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • China was unified around 500 BC and mostly stayed unified, and although unity sometimes helped under good emperors, it was a long-run disadvantage because policy quality depended on whoever held power.

    “Paradoxically, though, unity has been a disadvantage, and disunity in Europe by stimulating competition has been an advantage”

  • China had large fleets between 1400 and 1432 and even bigger ships than Europe, but in 1432 its single emperor abolished the fleets, and no rival polity existed to exploit the decision, unlike in fragmented Europe where rival princes would have seized the opportunity.

    “In 1432, China abolished its big fleets. Europe never did that. Why? Because China had one emperor”

  • Europe's peninsulas, islands, and radially flowing rivers fragmented it into competing polities, and when one prince abandoned a technology such as guns, a neighboring prince would exploit the gap, so fragmentation forced innovation and competition.

    “fragmentation means that there are different polities that are competing with each other”

0.23

Coaches' effects are smaller than naive comparisons suggest, concentrated in avoiding penalties and errors.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The largest effect a football coach has on outcomes is training players to avoid penalties, fumbles, and yellow cards rather than tactical choices like forward passes, and Argentina's yellow-card and red-card record cost it the 2022 World Cup final against Spain.

    “The biggest effect is of teaching your players not to incur penalties”

  • Coaches are often fired after a losing season, but much of that losing reflects random factors, so by regression to the mean the next season tends to improve regardless; the right test compares next-year performance with and without firing, which shows the coach's real effect is smaller than naive comparisons suggest.

    “simply because of regression to the mean, just for random reasons, the coach gets fired for reasons that don't have much to do with the coach”

  • Coaches have a larger effect on outcomes in college sports than in professional sports, because professional rosters turn over less predictably and star players, such as Tom Brady, dominate results across coaching changes.

    “they make more of a difference in college sports than in professional”

  • Carroll and Diamond agree the claim is not that penalties decide the game but that coaches have the most leverage in training teams to commit fewer penalties, since an 85-yard forward pass is more exciting yet less consequential than avoiding fumbles and penalties.

    “what a coach does that has a bigger effect on the outcome of a game is by getting his players not to fumble and not to incur penalties”

0.18

Required leadership traits differ by domain, such as charisma in religion versus politics.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Religious leadership requires charisma, organizational capacity, and often military capacity, usually embodied in different people: Jesus supplied charisma, Paul organized early Christianity, later Christian armies spread it, and Joseph Smith's charisma depended on Brigham Young's organization and a Mormon army.

    “religion requires two separate sets of talent, charisma and organization. And often it requires a third set, namely military organization”

  • Charisma is necessary for religious leaders but only sometimes useful for political leaders, who can also succeed by terrifying people or guiding group discussion, as Pinochet, who was not charismatic, illustrates.

    “But in the world of religion, you have to be charismatic.”

0.05

Scholars who leave their specialty face penalties, as Diamond's own career shows.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Academia penalizes scholars who step outside their specialty, with the assumption that they are no longer productive in their core field, and Diamond was denied a UCLA promotion after Guns, Germs, and Steel because colleagues judged his history book by his lower-citation bird papers.

    “There was only one time when I was denied a promotion at UCLA, and that was immediately after 'Guns, Germs, and Steel' was published and won the Pulitzer Prize”

  • After his twin sons were born near his fiftieth birthday, Diamond judged that their future would depend on history and geography rather than gallbladder physiology, and a MacArthur Fellowship reinforced his move to the broader field.

    “I realized the future of my boys is not going to depend upon gallbladders. It's going to depend upon the state of history and geography”