356 | Andrea Wulf on Enlightenment, Nature, Romanticism, and Modernity
What this covers
Andrea Wulf talks with Sean Carroll about three interconnected books that trace how modern ideas took shape through the lives of late-18th-century thinkers. She examines George Forster, a naturalist and early champion of universal human equality; the Jena circle of Romantics, including Goethe and Fichte, who rewrote philosophy and aesthetics; and Alexander von Humboldt, who synthesized empirical observation with subjective experience to invent modern environmentalism. The conversation argues that these figures did not simply inherit their era's views but actively chose stances—against racism, for interconnected nature, for individual freedom—in ways that reshaped what modernity became.
The substance moves across several distinct intellectual territories. Fichte placed the self at the center of reality, arguing that consciousness creates the world we perceive and thereby grants us free will, a move that would echo through modern thought about autonomy and self-determination. The Jena group, gathered in a town of 4,000 people, redefined Romanticism not as sentiment but as a project to reunite arts and sciences, arts and nature, humanity and the cosmos. Humboldt bridged Enlightenment and Romanticism by insisting that nature must be both precisely measured and felt, creating the vision of nature as an interconnected web where deforestation, monoculture, and industrial emissions posed genuine threats—making him an early voice on climate harm around 1800. Forster, by contrast, inferred Polynesian migration routes through linguistic and botanical patterns centuries before DNA would confirm them, yet his chief legacy was the reverse of racism: having witnessed colonial violence in the South Pacific, he returned to Europe arguing for the equality of all humans across gender and race at a moment when even philosophers like Kant defended racial hierarchy. The episode examines whether such progressive stances emerged from these figures' status as perpetual outsiders and travelers in the mind, willing to be intellectually displaced.
Wulf argues that the foundational modern ideas of interconnected nature, the autonomous self, and universal human equality were not inevitable but were invented by specific individuals in the late 18th century, and that examining their lives reveals these stances (including anti-racism and environmentalism) were active choices, not products of their era.
- Forster's anti-racist, egalitarian worldview shows racism was a choice even in an overwhelmingly racist 18th-century society
- The Jena Romantics and Fichte placed the self at the center of reality, giving rise to modern conceptions of free will and self-determination
- Humboldt synthesized Enlightenment empiricism with Romantic subjectivity to invent the idea of nature as an interconnected web, founding environmentalism
Nature is a living interconnected web where everything hangs together, not a mechanical system.
- Alexander von Humboldt gave us the concept of nature as a living, interconnected organism in which everything hangs together from the smallest insect to the tallest tree, rather than as a mechanical system or machine, which fundamentally shaped our modern understanding of nature.
“he said that everything in nature is connected, that nature is this kind of living organism where everything hangs together from the smallest insect to the tallest tree”
- Because Humboldt understood nature as a web of life where pulling one thread can unravel the whole, he was the first to talk about and warn against harmful human-induced climate change, identifying deforestation, monoculture, and irrigation as threats and even the gases emitted by industrial centers as harmful to the environment around 1800-1832.
“he's the first to really talk about and warn about harmful human-induced climate change, which of course, we are living with the consequences of ignoring him”
- Humboldt never saw nature and humans as separate; he described how one breath of life is poured over plants, animals, rocks, humans, and mountains, treating the whole planet as one interconnected breath of life of which humanity is an inseparable part.
“Humboldt talks about how one breath of life is poured over plants, animals, rocks, humans, mountains. The whole planet is one breath of life, he calls it, because we are all part of this one beautiful planet that is ours.”
- Humboldt is the bridge between Enlightenment and Romanticism because Goethe and the Jena set gave him a stronger emphasis on subjectivity—'new organs to see the world'—so that, unlike Newton who explained rainbows mechanically or Keats who accused Newton of destroying the rainbow's poetry, Humboldt insisted both that nature must be measured precisely and that it must be felt, bonding the objective with the subjective.
“Humboldt himself says that Goethe has given me new organs to see the world... he sees this new world through these new eyes that Goethe has given him, through a greater emphasis on subjectivity”
- The modern division between arts and sciences—seen in how six-year-olds get sorted into being either mathematical/logical or artistic/creative—is a failed experiment, because curiosity and imagination are essential to both, and most scientists became scientists out of a sense of wonder at nature that the profession nonetheless 'peer-reviews out of you.'
“when I look at education, like six-year-olds get put into these kind of boxes. "Oh, you are so mathematical and logical and you are so artistic or creative," and that's it... So I think that experiment kind of pretty much failed.”
Forster's egalitarianism and anti-racism were choices enabled by outsider status and openness to challenge.
- Forster began the voyage as an Enlightenment thinker who believed Europeans were superior and brought improvement to 'savages,' but within six weeks reversed his view, and by the end concluded Europeans brought only death and disease and that it would have been better for South Sea inhabitants never to have encountered the English.
“within six weeks, he starts criticizing the European influence. And he says, by the end of the voyage, he says Europeans just bring death and disease. It would have been much better for the inhabitants of the South Seas if they had never encountered the English”
- Forster was one of the very first to use the term 'human rights,' and unlike the American and French revolutionaries who excluded women, slaves, and non-Europeans, he applied the general rights of mankind to all people of every part of the world and every gender, making him far ahead of his contemporaries.
“he's one of the very first to use the term human rights, for example. And unlike the American and the French revolutionaries, who very firmly excluded women, slaves, and non-Europeans, he includes them. He talks about the general rights of mankind”
- Georg Forster's life proves that being racist in the 18th century was a choice rather than an unavoidable product of the era, since he returned from Cook's voyage believing in the equality of races despite being raised in a deeply racist society where even philosophers like Kant and Hume openly described Black people as inferior.
“we tend to say that in the 18th century, it was kind of inevitable to be racist. That's just the way people were. And I think his life really proves that it was a choice even back then. It is not an unavoidable way to see the world.”
- Forster's open-mindedness toward other peoples stemmed in part from being a perpetual traveler and outsider who did not belong to any single nation, because if you are an outsider yourself you tend to be kinder to other outsiders—a contrast Wulf draws with today's retreat behind national boundaries.
“If you are an outsider yourself, you tend to be nicer to other people who are outsiders. And he does not feel, he doesn't even know which country he belongs to”
- What enabled figures like Forster and Humboldt to resist racism and conformity was a combination of being perpetual outsiders and travelers with no fixed national belonging plus a willingness to step out of their comfort zone intellectually and physically—'traveling in the mind' to other concepts and ideas and allowing oneself to be challenged, rather than the curated travel of the Instagram generation.
“I like to believe it has a lot to do with being willing to step out of your comfort zone intellectually, but also physically.”
The Jena Romantics united arts and science through collaborative intellectual community creating unfinished dynamic philosophy.
- The Jena circle of the mid-1790s were the very first to use the word Romanticism in its new literary meaning, defining it not as moonlit forests or candlelit love but as a project to unite humankind with nature and to unite arts and science, holding that everything from a piece of music to a scientific experiment could be Romantic poetry.
“they are the very first to use the word Romanticism in its kind of new meaning, in its kind of literary meaning”
- The kind of intense in-person intellectual community seen in the Jena salons is somewhat less common today but still happens in places like writers' clubs or the Santa Fe Institute, though contemporary figures might dissipate that energy into podcasts rather than gathering to eat, drink, and recite together as the Jena set did.
“Being together, I mean, the Jena set in particular, for them being together, drinking together, eating together, reciting poems together, that was very much part of it.”
- Part of the Jena set's appeal was that their ideas were ephemeral and unfinished rather than completed theories; Fichte, for instance, developed much of his philosophy of the self live in front of his students, who were thrilled to watch a new and dynamic philosophy being created before their eyes rather than studying finished systems like Aristotle's.
“Fichte, for example, with his philosophy of the self, he would develop quite a lot of that in front of his students... they actually saw how in front of their eyes their professors were developing something very new and dynamic.”
- In the tiny German town of Jena of around 4,000 people in the mid-1790s, one could in a single day have seen more famous thinkers than in a whole century in another town, because the Romantics believed working together as a group rather than each in isolation would create a greater philosophy.
“in one day, with some luck in Jena, you would have seen more famous people than in a whole century in another town... they believe that working together, not everybody in their kind of little study, but working together will create a kind of greater philosophy.”
Enlightenment and Romanticism negotiate between individual selfhood and social duty, requiring freedom balanced with moral constraint.
- The French Revolution demonstrated that a revolution is fundamentally a revolution of ideas, showing that ideas, words, and philosophy are more powerful than weapons, swords, kings, and queens—an empowering moment that, combined with Fichte's philosophy of the self, transformed how people understood themselves.
“the French Revolution really also proves that a revolution is a revolution of ideas. So ideas, words, philosophy is more powerful than weapons and swords and kings and queens”
- Fichte never intended the centrality of the self to mean narcissistic self-celebration; he held that freedom always comes with moral duty and extends only so far as it does not impinge on others, so the modern selfish, narcissistic interpretation of the self is a distortion of his original idea.
“when Fichte put the self in the center of his philosophy, he never wanted this kind of narcissistic celebration of the self. Because he always said that freedom comes always with our moral duty. Our freedom is only as far as we are not impinging on someone else's duty.”
- Fichte argued that the self (the Ich) determines how we see the world and is the source of all reality, positing its own being and thereby creating the non-self (Nicht-Ich)—the external world—in our minds, so that everything we understand of the external world is shaped by our self, which grants us free will.
“he basically says that the self determines how we see the world. The self is the source of all reality. And he says there's the self, the Ich, and then there's the Nicht-Ich, the non-self”
- The central legacy of the Enlightenment and Romanticism is an ongoing negotiation between two questions—who am I as an individual and who am I as a member of society—requiring us to reconcile personal liberties and self-fulfillment with moral goodness and the constraints of society on a daily basis.
“underpinning this are two crucial questions. One is: who am I as an individual and who am I as a member of a society?”
Understanding ideas requires understanding the people, communities, and connections that shaped them.
- We tend to treat a person's work or idea as a standalone thing, but ideas are deeply influenced by the life the person lived and the community, family, and nation they belonged to, so understanding ideas requires understanding the people and their connections.
“we sometimes tend to think about the work of someone or the idea of someone as a kind of standalone thing, and we forget that it was very much influenced also by the life they lived”
- Forster's later political radicalism in Europe—co-founding the Mainz Republic, Germany's first republic—stemmed not from reading French philosophers but from what he had seen in the South Pacific, where he observed more egalitarian societies with fluid class boundaries that shaped his political thinking.
“it shaped his political thinking, which then later made him a revolutionary in Europe, not by reading French philosophers, but by what he had seen in the South Pacific”
- Forster became the family breadwinner by age twelve, translating popular best-selling travel accounts into English—not his mother tongue—having picked up English on the ship journey from Russia, alongside Russian, German, and French.
“his father took young George to London, where the young boy became the family's breadwinner by translating popular and best-selling travel accounts. He was a bit of a wunderkind”
Scientific voyages were imperial projects where colonial ambitions were framed as scientific discovery.
- The public fight between Forster and Kant over human races ultimately became a battle over methodology at the nexus of the Enlightenment: Forster argued you cannot make claims about peoples you have never seen and that nature is connected by nuances not sharp categories, while Kant argued you cannot interpret observations without first traveling with a theory in mind—raising the core question of whether knowledge starts with theory or with observation.
“it ends up being really a fight about methodology. How do we gain knowledge?”
- Even ostensibly scientific voyages like Cook's were fundamentally imperial endeavors financed by the British Admiralty; Cook carried precise instructions to report on soils, plants, and the temperament of indigenous peoples to assess whether they could be exploited or enslaved, and the scientific framing (such as finding the southern continent) served colonial ambitions.
“even with a scientific purpose like finding the southern continent, it is an imperial endeavor. So it is not like, "Oh well, we just want to find out a few things."”
Forster's narrative storytelling and Polynesian migration research exemplified empirical observation grounded in lived experience.
- By comparing languages across the South Pacific (such as va'a, vaka, waka for canoe) and the distribution of seedless breadfruit trees that could only be spread by human cultivation, Forster worked out roughly the route of Polynesian migration about 200 years before DNA analysis and archaeological studies confirmed it.
“by comparing the different languages across the South Pacific and the distribution of breadfruit trees, he works out roughly the route of Polynesian migration 200 years before DNA analysis and archaeological studies prove it”
- Forster wrote a new kind of travel account in which even icy Antarctica became shades of purple, green, and blue and distant worlds and peoples were brought into European parlors—a born-storyteller, intuitive-ethnographer style that contrasts with Columbus merely calling South America 'green,' making this narrative his chief contribution rather than the expedition's botanical collections.
“Forster even turns the icy world of Antarctica into shades of kind of purple, green, and blue. So he writes this book which makes him famous because he brings these different worlds, but also these different people, into the parlors of European houses.”
- Cook never took scientists on his voyages again after the second voyage, in part because Georg's father Reinhold Forster was so difficult—fighting with everyone aboard the Resolution, even challenging the famously unflappable Cook to a duel and being thrown out of the great cabin.
“it did not help that Georg Forster's father, Reinhold, was a really quite a terrible person... He managed to have fights with everybody on the Resolution, even with the quite unflappable Cook... Like, once he asked him for a duel.”