326 | Natalie Batalha on What We Know and Will Learn About Exoplanets
What this covers
Natalie Batalha, an astrophysicist at UC Santa Cruz and former mission scientist for NASA's Kepler observatory, discusses the transformation of exoplanet science from discovery-driven curiosity to systematic demographic study. She speaks with host Sean Carroll about what Kepler revealed—that planets orbit nearly every star and that the most common type has no parallel in our solar system—and how synergistic telescopes now map planetary properties at scale. The conversation traces the field's evolution from the 1995 detection of the first exoplanet through present efforts to catalog sizes, orbits, atmospheric compositions, and habitability markers.
Batalha covers the technical foundations: how transit photometry yields radius, how the Doppler method measures mass, and how transmission spectroscopy reveals atmospheric chemistry. She examines obstacles Kepler overcame—stellar variability, astrophysical false positives, and instrumental failure—and explains how population synthesis techniques disambiguated signal from noise. The discussion moves to what future missions will achieve: JWST's emerging atmospheric detections (including photochemical markers like sulfur dioxide on WASP-39b), the Habitable Worlds Observatory's potential to detect biosignatures, and the unresolved question of whether M dwarf planets retain atmospheres after their young, violent phase. She argues that the search for life requires first understanding disequilibrium chemistry and the physical limits of habitability—building a baseline of what life is not before claiming to have found it.
Batalha argues that exoplanet science has matured from cataloging individual discoveries to systematic demographic and atmospheric study, revealing that planets are ubiquitous and diverse beyond our solar system, and that finding life requires first understanding the physical processes and limits of habitability rather than rushing to claim biosignatures.
- Kepler showed nearly every star has at least one planet and that the most common planet type (super-Earth/mini-Neptune) has no solar system analog
- Synergistic missions (Kepler, TESS, JWST, Roman, HWO) build a complete census and characterize atmospheres
- Detecting life requires understanding what life is not, including abiogenic sources and habitability limits like M-dwarf atmosphere stripping
Kepler discovered that essentially every star hosts at least one planet, transforming our understanding of planetary prevalence.
- A key result from Kepler is that on average every star has at least one planet, and Batalha suspects there are essentially no stars without planets, though the true average will rise as future missions probe outer orbits and smaller planet sizes.
“That is another result from Kepler, is that on average, every star has at least one planet. So could there be stars without planets? My guess is no.”
- From the Kepler prime field at Cygnus, about 5,000 planet candidates were found of which about 2,800 are confirmed, and combined with K2 discoveries, Kepler accounts for roughly half of all confirmed planets in public exoplanet catalogs even years later.
“we ended up with about 5,000 planet candidates, of which I think about 2,800 have been confirmed”
- Kepler taught us that the nearest potentially habitable planet is probably about 10 light years away—extremely close—illustrated by the analogy that if the Milky Way were shrunk to the continental US, the nearest such planet would be just down at the campus library.
“the nearest potentially habitable planet is probably 10 light years away, very close”
- Kepler taught us that the diversity of planets in the galaxy far exceeds the diversity of planets in our solar system, with the most common type of planet orbiting within one astronomical unit being a 'super Earth' or 'mini Neptune' that has no analog in our solar system.
“It taught us that, you know, the diversity of planets in the galaxy far exceeds the diversity of planets in our solar system”
Planets show unexpected diversity and structure, including a bimodal radius distribution with a valley shaped by atmospheric escape.
- Complex planet formation models generate synthetic populations that qualitatively match Kepler data when plotted over orbital period and planet radius, but they fail badly when planet masses are plotted against radius, indicating significant unresolved gaps in our understanding of how planets form and evolve.
“when you look at the distribution of the properties over orbital period and planet radius, it kind of looks okay. You can tune it to look reasonable, but then you take the synthetic population, which also has planet masses, and you plot the masses versus radius, and it kind of all goes to hell.”
- Kepler revealed a bimodal radius distribution among close-in planets with a dearth of planets centered around 1.8 Earth radii (the 'radius valley'); models attribute this to stellar ultraviolet and extreme-ultraviolet radiation breaking apart molecules and driving them off planet surfaces, sculpting the outer envelopes and modifying radii in a timescale-dependent way that produces pile-ups at certain sizes.
“you have a lot of planets that are smaller than about one and a half times the radius of Earth, and you have a lot of planets that are larger... And there's a dearth of planets in between, kind of centered on about 1.8.”
- The most common planets—'between worlds' larger than Earth but smaller than Neptune, peaking around 2.5 Earth radii—remain compositionally unidentified because many theoretical models (gas dwarf, mini-Neptune, water world, Hycean planet, steam world) yield the same mass and radius, a degeneracy that JWST transmission spectroscopy of objects like K2-18b aims to break.
“there are many theoretical models that could explain their composition, and they all yield the same mass and radius. So there's what we call a degeneracy.”
- Kepler discovered an Earth-sized rocky planet around Kepler-444, a star essentially as old as the galaxy itself, which was surprising given expectations that older metal-poor stars would be less likely to host planets, but is explained by the Milky Way already being enriched by supernovae when it formed.
“the discovery of an Earth-sized planet orbiting the star. I think its phone number was Kepler-444. Because this star was literally the age of the galaxy itself. And here it had a rocky planet.”
The future Habitable Worlds Observatory with coronagraphic technology will detect biosignatures in planetary atmospheres, enabling life's discovery.
- The future Habitable Worlds Observatory, a large space telescope with star suppression technology launching after Roman (possibly within 20 years), would be capable of detecting biosignatures in atmospheres of planets where life has had a global impact, representing a very promising pathway to the first evidence of life beyond Earth.
“the Habitable Worlds Observatory, which is a large space telescope with star suppression technology that will be capable of detecting biosignatures in the atmospheres of planets where life has taken a global toehold”
- Despite high public interest in observing rocky planets, the James Webb Space Telescope is not going to deliver biosignatures or evidence of life; detecting life will require the future Habitable Worlds Observatory with star suppression technology.
“Sorry to disappoint, but we are not going to get biosignatures or evidence of life with the James Webb Space Telescope.”
- The Roman Space Telescope will conduct a microlensing survey—using the general relativistic bending of light around foreground masses—that is sensitive to planets at longer orbital periods than transit surveys, allowing it to be linked with the Kepler demographic survey to produce a complete census of exoplanets in the galaxy beyond one astronomical unit.
“one of the things it's going to do is a microlensing survey. This is another planet detection technique, which makes use of the general relativistic effect of light bending around masses”
Transit and Doppler methods combined measure planet radius, mass, and bulk density, constraining composition and habitability.
- The transit method gives a planet's radius (from light blocked) while the Doppler method gives its mass (from the star's velocity wobble), and combining mass over volume yields bulk density, which constrains composition—Jupiter is ~1 g/cm³, Saturn less than 1 (it would float), and Earth ~5.5 g/cm³.
“if you have mass and radius, then you can calculate mass divided by volume, which is density”
- When a planet transits its star, some starlight filters through the atmosphere hugging the planet's surface, carrying the chemical fingerprints of that atmosphere; by disentangling photons from the star versus those trickling through the atmosphere, astronomers can detect atmospheric composition—a technique called transmission spectroscopy that JWST uses on the nearest, brightest transiting systems TESS identified.
“when a planet is right in front of its star, some of that starlight is going to filter through the atmosphere of the planet that is hugging the surface. And in doing so, it will bring to us the chemical fingerprints of that atmosphere. We call that transmission spectroscopy.”
- Because a planet and star orbit their common center of mass, the star wobbles, shifting its spectral absorption lines back and forth in color space via the Doppler effect; precisely measuring this velocity maps to the gravitational force and thus the planet's mass.
“we can see those absorption lines wiggle back and forth in color space due to the motion of the star. So that's the Doppler effect... that gives us the velocity that the star is moving towards us and away from us... that maps to the gravitational force that maps to the mass of the planet”
- Interpreting transmission spectra requires knowing the planet's mass because surface gravity and mean molecular weight both affect atmospheric thickness and thus absorption-line depth—high gravity or heavy molecules (CO2) compress the atmosphere making it thin, while low gravity or light molecules (hydrogen) loft it—creating a degeneracy that mass measurements help disambiguate.
“If the surface gravity is really high, the atmosphere becomes very compact and it's thin. It scrunches down. If the surface gravity is low, the atmosphere lofts and it's very thick.”
Planetary habitability depends on precise conditions including radiogenic heating, stellar youth effects, and planetary mass and composition.
- M dwarf stars comprise about 70% of galactic stars and are very luminous when young, raising a major open question of whether rocky planets around them have their atmospheres stripped before the star settles onto the main sequence; observed M-dwarf rocky planets so far appear to be bare rocks, though many were expected to be bare and current precision may be insufficient to detect low-level atmospheres.
“The M dwarf stars are about 10 times smaller mass, one-tenth of the mass of the sun. And they comprise about 70% of the stars in our galaxy.”
- About 50% of Earth's internal heat comes from radioactive decay of heavy elements like thorium that are largely produced in extreme events like neutron star mergers, and planet interior models are extremely sensitive to the abundance of these radiogenic species—too much shuts off magnetism by altering core convection while too little fails to drive plate tectonics—with Earth residing at a habitability sweet spot.
“50% of that internal heat is due to radioactivity that's going on in the center. And the radioactivity comes from elements like thorium or these really heavy elements. And it turns out that those heavy elements are largely produced in these extremely violent events like neutron star mergers.”
- Despite similar sizes, Earth, Venus and Mars have radically different surface conditions: Mars is geologically dead because its smaller size and greater solar distance cause faster heat loss, while Venus's closer orbit can trigger an early runaway greenhouse that desiccates the planet, though much about Venus remains unknown pending missions like DaVinci.
“Mars is, you know, two times smaller, about half the radius of Earth, and its smaller size will influence the rate of heat loss. It's also further from the Sun... So it's no surprise that Mars is geologically dead today.”
- The history of life on Earth includes radical, still-unexplained transitions such as endosymbiosis (an archaea and bacteria combining to form a eukaryote with nucleus and mitochondria, enabling oxygen-based energy) and the move from single-celled to multicellular life, and because the fossil record only covers the ~500 million years since exoskeletons appeared, studying the prior soft-bodied billions of years requires creative methods like isotope analysis.
“like endosymbiosis, where you produce a eukaryote, where an archaea and a bacteria hooked up and created a eukaryote that had a nucleus and a mitochondria”
- After Kepler lost a second reaction wheel in 2013, engineers recovered the mission (K2) by pointing the telescope's axis of symmetry toward the sun so that solar radiation pressure pushed symmetrically, stabilizing the third uncontrolled axis—analogous to pointing a symmetric boat straight upstream so the current cannot make it sway.
“the engineers came up with this very clever way of controlling that third axis of rotation by pointing the telescope towards the sun and making use of its architectural axis of symmetry”
- Michel Mayor announced the very first exoplanet orbiting a normal sun-like star in 1995, an event Batalha witnessed firsthand as a third-year graduate student, marking the beginning of exoplanet discovery.
“on the last day of that conference, Michel Mayor announced the very first exoplanet orbiting a normal sun-like star”
- Studying the evolution of complexity from the Big Bang to intelligence leads Batalha to believe life is creative, prolific and robust, that the laws of physics give rise to complexity locally, and that interesting things will happen wherever there is opportunity.
“the more I think that life is creative and prolific and robust and is going to find its niches, that the laws of physics are going to give rise to complexity on a local scale, and interesting things are going to happen wherever there's an opportunity”
JWST enables transmission spectroscopy of exoplanet atmospheres, revealing composition and photochemical processes like those on WASP-39b.
- On WASP-39b, JWST detected sulfur dioxide, which is significant because sulfur dioxide cannot exist without photochemistry—it requires a star irradiating the planet and breaking apart water molecules to start a cascade of reactions—marking the first opportunity to study a photochemical pathway in an exoplanet atmosphere.
“we detected sulfur dioxide. That was interesting because sulfur dioxide cannot exist without photochemistry. That is, you have to have a star that's irradiating the surface and breaking apart water molecules in order to start a cascade of chemical reactions that leads to sulfur dioxide.”
- The James Webb Space Telescope's design began before exoplanet detections with extragalactic astronomy as the main science driver; the 1995 discovery changed priorities, and because Webb is unserviceable unlike Hubble, a time-series spectroscopy mode had to be built into every instrument during development to enable transmission spectroscopy.
“Webb, the design of Webb started before there were exoplanet detections and the big science drivers were mostly extragalactic astronomy.”
- By observing a planet just before and after it ducks behind its star (secondary eclipse) and subtracting, astronomers isolate the planet's thermal radiation, and by watching this in real time they obtain longitudinal information across the surface—a raster scan that maps surface temperature and reveals how atmospheric climate redistributes heat.
“if you subtract those two things, you can get the light that's actually being emitted by the planetary surface, what we call the thermal radiation of the planet”
Stellar variability and astrophysical false positives posed measurement challenges that Kepler overcame through filtering and statistical validation.
- Star spots posed a fundamental obstacle to transit photometry because their projected area can exceed a planet's shadow and they rotate in and out of view, modulating stellar brightness; this was solved partly by digital signal filtering (since transits occur on 4-12 hour timescales while most solar variability is slower) and partly by population synthesis showing only ~30% of target stars are young rapid rotators whose variability impinges on transit timescales.
“star spot areas could be larger than the shadow of a planet or a projected area of the planet on the disk of the star. And I knew that they rotate in and out of view with the rotation of the star”
- Kepler was intentionally designed as a simple, relatively low-cost discovery-class mission (hundreds of millions, not billions) measuring only brightness without color filters, deliberately trading the false-positive discrimination that multiple colors offer in order to minimize failure modes and noise sources.
“We opted not to do that, to keep it as simple as possible so that there were fewer failure modes and so, and fewer noise sources. And I think that that was a really good strategy at the time.”
- Beyond stellar variability, astrophysical false positives such as background eclipsing binary stars can dilute the signal of a foreground star and mimic a planetary transit, a confounder that the ground-based Vulcan survey at Lick Observatory helped catalog before Kepler launched.
“there are eclipsing binary stars in the galaxy, and they can actually dilute the signal of a foreground star and make it look like there's a transit”
Carbon-based life using water is a reasonable first target for biosignature searches given elemental abundances and chemical bonding properties.
- It is probably not a coincidence that life on Earth uses carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen—the most abundant heavy elements the universe produces—and that carbon's four valence electrons enable complex polymers; silicon's analogous valence electrons sit in more distant orbital shells producing weaker bonds, making carbon-based life and water as a solvent a reasonable first target in the search for life even though life may find other pathways.
“life on Earth is made of carbon, and carbon is also one of the most abundant heavy elements that the universe creates, carbon and oxygen, and nitrogen... That's probably not a coincidence.”
- Rather than looking only for chemicals presumed unique to Earth life, astronomers increasingly favor 'agnostic biosignatures'—looking for disequilibrium chemistry that wouldn't persist abiotically, patterns that life sculpts in its environment, anomalous isotope ratios (life prefers carbon-12 over carbon-13), and ultimately elevated information content—as indicators of life as a rise of complexity.
“there's a trend to think about what we call agnostic biosignatures, agnostic because it doesn't assume Earth life”