318 | Edward Miguel on the Developing Practice of Development Economics
What this covers
Ted Miguel sits down with Sean Carroll to discuss how development economics has matured from abstract theorizing into a field grounded in empirical observation and randomized controlled trials. Miguel, who helped pioneer this methodological shift, traces how borrowing RCT designs from medicine has allowed economists to isolate the causal effects of poverty-reduction interventions in low- and middle-income countries. The conversation centers on what the evidence now shows: that cheap, precisely targeted programs—childhood deworming at 30 cents per child per year, direct cash transfers, mass treatment to break disease transmission cycles—reliably improve health, earnings, and survival. The discussion moves through decades of follow-up data, including a 27-year study of Kenyan schoolchildren showing that deworming in childhood raised adult earnings by roughly 10 percent, alongside evidence that a $1,000 cash transfer cut infant mortality by 40 percent in recipient areas.
Beyond the headline results, Miguel and Carroll explore the methodological tensions and unexpected findings that have emerged. Spillover effects from deworming campaigns required new econometric methods to measure; careful follow-up revealed that poor recipients spend less than 1 percent of cash transfers on alcohol and drugs, undercutting familiar caricatures. The conversation addresses why climate shocks destabilize poor agricultural societies—and how meta-analysis suggests warming could raise armed conflict risk by 40 percent—while also acknowledging the gap between short-term shocks that are statistically measurable and long-term climate change that cannot yet be studied with precision. Miguel reflects on the changing prestige of applied development work within economics, the replicability standards that now distinguish the field, and the policy question of why foreign aid, amounting to only 0.2–0.3 percent of the US budget, faces cuts just as the evidence for its effectiveness has solidified.
Miguel argues that development economics has been transformed by randomized controlled trials and long-term follow-up, producing a robust evidence base showing that cheap, well-targeted interventions like deworming and direct cash transfers reliably improve health, incomes, and even save lives in poor countries.
- Randomized controlled trials borrowed from medicine let economists estimate unbiased causal effects of interventions in poor countries
- Long-run tracking shows childhood deworming raises adult earnings ~10% and cash transfers cut infant mortality 40%
- Foreign aid is a tiny share of budgets yet highly cost-effective, so current cuts come just as the field knows what works
Cash transfers break poverty cycles by relieving psychological stress and enabling life-improving investments, with local multiplier effects and immediate health gains.
- Poverty carries hidden costs—buying goods in small quantities raises per-unit prices, and psychological stress about money systematically degrades decision-making and productivity—so poverty breeds more poverty, while a large one-time cash transfer or basic income can temporarily lift people out of that state long enough to make life-improving investments.
“people who are just super stressed out about money systematically make certain types of errors. They're less productive. So poverty breeds more poverty”
- A large one-time $1,000 cash transfer to poor rural Kenyan households—about 75% of average annual household income—produced large local economic multipliers, much bigger than seen in the US, because the marginal propensity to consume is very high (recipients spent ~90% in the first year), boosting local business revenue, hiring, and generating more than a dollar of local GDP per dollar transferred.
“The marginal propensity to consume in rural Kenya is really high. If you target poor households, we find that in the first year after they get the cash, they spend like 90% of it”
- In the year that a large $1,000 cash transfer was received by households in a 300,000-person area of Kenya, infant mortality in recipient areas fell by 40%, demonstrating that cash transfers don't just benefit the local economy but literally save children's lives.
“in the year the cash transfer, this big $1,000 cash transfer, was received by households, in that year, infant mortality in recipient areas fell by 40%”
- Cheap, visible proxies like the building materials of a home are highly correlated with poverty, so using such rough targeting criteria for cash transfers is preferable to expensive precise measurement (e.g., two-hour surveys), because it cuts overhead and means more of every dollar reaches recipients while yielding nearly the same accuracy.
“they can use something that's really cheap and very visible, very easy to observe for targeting. And that cuts out a lot of overhead costs”
Mass deworming interventions are highly cost-effective with documented spillover effects and extraordinary long-term labor market returns from school-age treatment.
- Mass deworming of schools produced spillover effects: even untreated people living within a few miles of treated schools showed big reductions in worm infections because mass treatment broke the cycle of transmission, requiring new econometric methods beyond simple treatment-versus-control comparisons.
“even people that hadn't gotten the drugs who lived within a few miles of these schools showed big reductions in worm infections because we had broken the cycle of transmission”
- Tracking the original Kenyan deworming cohort for 27 years shows children who received extra years of deworming treatment around age 10 earn about 10% more in the labor market as adults in their 30s, are more likely to migrate to cities, and move into better-paid non-agricultural occupations—an extraordinarily high rate of return on a 30-cent-per-year intervention.
“these kids that got additional years of health treatments when they were like 10 years old, if you look at them in their 30s, they're earning more in the labor market... On average, they're earning like 10% more”
- Intestinal worm infections affected over 90% of Kenyan schoolchildren but could be treated for under a dollar (about 30 cents) per child per year, making mass deworming a highly cost-effective intervention that increased school attendance by breaking the cycle of disease transmission.
“in our data, 90 something percent of kids had these infections, but they were super cheap to treat... for less than a dollar a year, you can really clear these worm infections out of kids”
Development economics has achieved methodological rigor through randomized trials and field experiments, establishing an evidence base for effective interventions.
- After 20-30 years of randomized controlled trials, development economics now has a solid scientific evidence base for interventions proven to improve living standards and health, so the simultaneous slashing of foreign aid by the US, UK, France, and China is especially discouraging because it withdraws funding precisely at the moment when researchers finally know what works.
“finally after the last 20 or 30 years, we have a scientific evidence base in development economics. We really know certain things... Now is not the time to be cutting funding. Now is the time where we know what to do.”
- Because standard economic assumptions about how well markets work and how good information is don't hold in developing countries, a theory-agnostic empirical approach—running experiments to establish empirical facts that drive the next generation of theory—is more appropriate than testing tightly theory-motivated predictions.
“in development economics, a lot of the assumptions of those theories about how markets work and how well markets work and how good information is in the world about how markets work, all those things just don't hold as well”
- When resources are scarce and not everyone can be treated, randomizing the order of a program's rollout is both methodologically sound—creating statistically equivalent treatment and control groups—and arguably a fairer way to allocate resources than favoring politically connected areas.
“you could make the case that randomizing was a pretty fair way to do it rather than just going to politically connected areas or something first”
- Economics has a less severe replicability crisis than psychology and is actually ahead of medical research on data sharing, because economics journals aggressively force authors to post replication data publicly, whereas health fields have been slower—sometimes using personally identifiable information concerns as a pretext to avoid sharing.
“econ journals have been much more aggressive in forcing authors to post their data to make replication data public. And I'm really proud of that in our field, because I think we were ahead of the curve on that”
- Researchers whose findings drive policy must keep the scientific ethos front and center rather than becoming policy advocates—standing by whatever the data show, including publishing results that would undercut their own prior conclusions, even if that changes the policy calculation.
“If I do new research and the new research shows deworming has harms or deworming doesn't do anything good, I'm going to try to put it out there just as strongly as my first results”
- While AI can usefully accelerate parts of research like extracting estimates from existing studies for meta-analysis, it cannot automate the original field data generation central to development economics, which requires actually talking to people and using specialized methods to measure hard-to-observe things like living standards.
“there's just going to be a lot of machinery and data generation in our field that will not be automated that AI can't do. We have to actually talk to people”
Environmental shocks and climate change interact with social vulnerability to trigger conflict, requiring adaptation strategies as warming raises armed conflict risk globally.
- In poor agricultural African societies, anomalously warm or dry years cause income shocks that destabilize society—because poor people have less to lose and become more willing to join insurgencies—and meta-analysis suggests expected warming over the next 30-40 years could raise the risk of armed conflict worldwide by roughly 40% absent effective adaptation.
“those climate shocks turn into economic shocks that are destabilizing. Because when people are poor, they have much less to lose. They may be more willing to fight the government, join an insurgency”
- Although researchers care about long-run climate change, statistical analysis of climate impacts has largely relied on short-term shocks (an anomalously hot year or month) rather than multi-decadal variation because the long-run data don't exist, creating a gap between short-term estimates and the possibility that societies can adapt to gradual long-term change.
“a lot of the statistical analysis among social scientists trying to understand the effect of climate has focused on shorter term climatic shocks... rather than like a multi-decadal scale analysis, because we just haven't had the data”
- In a randomized lab experiment manipulating room temperature, Berkeley participants' decisions barely changed between hot and cool rooms, but in Nairobi the rate of destroying others' payoffs in the 'Joy of Destruction' game was about 50% higher in the hot room, suggesting uncomfortable heat triggers antisocial behavior, helping pinpoint the mechanism behind observed links between high temperatures and social breakdown.
“in the hot room, it was like another 50% higher on top of that. So there was something about being in this uncomfortable environment where people were kind of agitated... That made them kind of antisocial”
- The heat-induced rise in destroying others' payoffs in Nairobi was concentrated among participants from ethnic groups aligned with the political opposition during a contested election season, suggesting that latent feelings of marginalization combine with environmental stressors like heat to trigger antisocial behavior.
“This response to the high temperature was concentrated among people who belong to ethnic groups aligned with the opposition... if I have some like underlying latent anger or feeling of marginalization, then I get triggered by the environmental stressor”
Large-scale political and social reforms can transform persistent norms like corruption and ethnic division, though the US risks decline by slashing scientific and social investment.
- The traditional prestige hierarchy in economics, which placed abstract general-equilibrium theorists at the top and applied development economists lower, has flattened over recent decades, as reflected in several Nobel Prizes awarded to applied researchers combining new methods, new data, and new problems.
“over the last decade now, several groups of applied researchers have gotten the Nobel Prize for contributions that really are a combination of some new methods... uses of new types of data, tackling new problems”
- The 'Worm Wars' debate centered on a coding error Miguel made in estimating spillover effects between three and six kilometers, which when corrected produced very imprecise estimates at that distance; however, the direct effects and effects within three kilometers remained precisely estimated and meaningful, and statistical reviewers largely sided with the original direct-effect conclusions.
“I basically capped the number of schools I would consider just in the code. And so actually when you go out to six kilometers, the kind of corrected code has standard errors on the estimate... that gets really large”
- Studying UN diplomats in New York, who shared the same environment but enjoyed diplomatic immunity, showed that home-country corruption strongly predicted unpaid parking ticket accumulation—diplomats from high-corruption countries like Nigeria racked up many tickets while those from low-corruption countries like Norway almost none—demonstrating that corruption is a persistent, self-reinforcing cultural norm that people carry with them across contexts.
“the home country corruption very strongly predicts which diplomats abuse their position in New York City by racking up unpaid parking tickets”
- Large-scale political and social reforms can transform social identities and norms in African settings, as in Tanzania where post-independence emphasis on the Swahili language, a nationalistic pan-African school curriculum, and abolishing traditional chiefs built a strong shared national identity that diminished ethnic divisions, and in Botswana where visionary leadership built a coherent identity alongside durable democracy and strong economic performance.
“all the kind of historical evidence and survey evidence since then points to the fact that it was pretty successful. Like Tanzanians feel very proud of being Tanzanian. Ethnic identities have kind of fallen in importance relative to this national identity”
- Americans wildly overestimate foreign aid spending—guessing 15-20% of the government budget—when in reality it was only about 0.2-0.3% of the budget, yet that minuscule amount produced large impacts saving lives through HIV and malaria treatments and cash transfers before being slashed.
“people say, oh, I think it's 20 %. I think it's 15 %. Of course, in truth... it was like 0.3 of 1 %, I think. 0.2 of 1 % of the budget was going to foreign aid”
- The US, historically the richest society and the focal point of global science since World War II, risks becoming poorer and less healthy because the social investments, scientific research funding (NIH, NSF), and public health programs that powered its prosperity are being politically threatened and slashed.
“it feels like we're kind of unlearning some of our own lessons. There's a lot of things that have powered our prosperity. Big social investments in old folks are being threatened politically”
- Relatives at family gatherings ask economists for stock tips because they know they are economists.
“at family gatherings, relatives always want stock tips, right? Because they know I'm an economist”
Low-income regions have experienced substantial documented economic growth and health improvements despite persistent negative stereotypes about poor recipient behavior.
- Despite negative popular perceptions, systematic data over the last 30-40 years show low-income regions including China, South Asia, and sub-Saharan Africa have experienced substantial economic growth, improved living standards, big reductions in infant mortality, and reductions in malnutrition.
“if we look at data systematically over the last 30 years, 35 years, 40 years, and look at low-income regions of the world, they've really been transformed”
- Across dozens of cash transfer studies, careful follow-up surveys show that very small shares of transferred money—less than 1% in Miguel's data—are spent on 'sin' or 'temptation' goods like alcohol and cigarettes, contradicting the caricature that poor recipients waste windfalls on booze and drugs.
“across these studies, very small shares are being spent on those things. A little bit, like people do buy some alcohol with the money, but in our data, it's less than 1%”
Aging populations in developing countries create an opportunity to design pension and healthcare systems informed by global evidence rather than inherit flawed institutions.
- Low- and middle-income countries from Latin America to China, India, and increasingly sub-Saharan Africa are seeing growing shares of older people, yet their institutions—pensions covering only a few percent of workers, healthcare systems, and long-term care—are not set up for aging populations, creating an opportunity to design systems from scratch informed by the best global evidence.
“in a lot of poor societies, the institutions and policies really aren't set up to deal with aging populations. They don't have, in most countries, pensions for old people”