What this covers

Karen Lloyd, a geobiologist at the University of Southern California, discusses life thriving kilometers beneath Earth's surface in environments so extreme they challenge conventional assumptions about what living things need. The episode covers her research into subsurface microorganisms that survive without sunlight, oxygen, or rapid growth, deriving energy instead from chemical reactions, radioactive decay, and direct electron transfer through protein structures. Lloyd draws on field work and laboratory studies to explain how these organisms function at metabolic rates thousands of times slower than familiar microbes, operating in conditions stable for thousands of years where a single energy source must sustain life across geological timescales.

The conversation ranges across several distinct territories. Lloyd explains how subsurface life maintains itself through chirality—the handedness of amino acids—a molecular signature that proves active self-repair even without cell division, and how these organisms shape planetary geochemistry by controlling the redox state of Earth's crust. She describes the discovery of entirely new organisms through DNA sequencing, including archaea so small they confounded early imaging, and microbes that transport electrons like living wires. The discussion ventures into thermodynamic philosophy, presenting life as fundamentally parasitic upon [entropy](jargon:entropy) increase rather than working against it—a reframing that challenges how we define living systems. Lloyd also addresses practical applications: how subsurface microbes colonize carbon-capture wells and could undermine storage efforts, and speculates on habitability elsewhere—the liquid oceans of Europa and the methane traces on Mars both align with conditions that support subsurface life on Earth. The subsurface harbors an estimated 10^29 microbial cells, a vast ecosystem largely unmapped despite centuries of drilling technology.

Sharpest takeaway

Lloyd argues that life deep in Earth's crust survives on chemical and even radioactive energy gradients at incredibly slow metabolic rates, demonstrating that oxygen, light, and fast growth are not requirements for life, and that the defining feature of life is its ability to create extra opportunities for entropy production.

  • Subsurface microbes live off chemical reactions, radioactive decay of water, and even direct electron transfer rather than sunlight
  • These organisms grow thousands of times slower than lab cultures and may be the longest-lived organisms on Earth
  • Life is parasitic upon entropy increase rather than working against it, stretching out free energy release to produce more entropy than abiotic processes

The argument · threads10 threads · 39 claims
0.85

Subsurface life requires only chemical energy gradients and water, not oxygen, light, fast growth, or other conditions typically considered necessary.

7 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Many specifics commonly attributed as necessary for life—oxygen, light, space to move, fast growth, dying after a century or millennium—are not actually necessary; what is necessary is gradients of free energy that can be exploited, and these are found all over the place (though water still seems important, in surprisingly small amounts).

    “a lot of the specifics that we attribute to being necessary for life. Oxygen, light, space to move around, fast growth, dying after 100 years or 1000 years. None of that is necessary for life. What's necessary for life is what you just said. You got to have gradients, of free energy that you can exploit.”

  • Because there is no sunlight or photosynthesis in the subsurface, all biological activity must be fueled by chemical reactions, and the subsurface offers a gigantic variety of them because it is rich in minerals and metals with redox power that can be oxidized and reduced.

    “in the subsurface, there's no photosynthesis, there's no sunlight. And so, all of that activity has to be fueled by chemical reactions. But the nice thing about the chemical reactions is that, there's a just a gigantic variety of them... because if there's one thing they're rich in, it's minerals and metals and things that have a lot of redox power”

  • The deep subsurface may be a favorable place for life to originate because surface energy gradients are harsh and damaging (requiring protective adaptations like sunscreen or oxygen-detoxifying enzymes), whereas the subsurface offers slower, more varied, overlapping energy gradients where primitive metabolic networks could form without being energetically or physically blasted apart—functioning like a protective nursery.

    “the deep subsurface is a great place to form life. If you think about energy gradients at the surface, they're really harsh, they're really extreme... in the subsurface, things are slower, the gradients are more varied... you get all of these overlapping energy gradients, and so you can imagine these networks sort of forming in a way that they would just get blasted out energetically and possibly physically by impacts”

  • There are an estimated 10^29 living microbial cells in the subsurface—roughly 10,000 times more than the estimated number of stars in the universe—making it a gigantic, largely undescribed ecosystem despite the small biomass of individual cells.

    “are about 10^29 living microbial cells in the subsurface... I usually say it's 10,000 times more than the estimated number of stars in the universe.”

  • The subsurface is defined not by absolute depth but by being in a stable environment sufficiently remote from steady inputs of oxygen and light; it can start just centimeters or even millimeters down in places like mud flats, and extends kilometers deep.

    “the question is, are you in a stable enough environment that's sufficiently remote from steady inputs of oxygen and light? And if you are, then you're in the subsurface. So I think it starts a couple centimeters down or even millimeters in some places.”

  • Temperature ultimately limits life as we know it because all known life is carbon-based, and at sufficiently high temperatures carbon molecules cannot hold together in the configurations needed for life to function; much of the Earth's deep lithosphere is probably simply too hot for life.

    “temperature is something that ultimately will limit life as we know it. Because it's some, everything we know about so far is carbon-based life. And at some high temperature, you're not gonna get carbon molecules holding together in the way that we know that they need to, to have life function.”

  • Some subsurface organisms cut out the diffusion of chemicals entirely and literally move electrons through appendages that act as tiny conductive wires made of proteins with conjugated structures, allowing electrons to flow through biological material the way they flow through metal.

    “there are organisms that just cut to the chase and don't deal with the diffusion of chemicals. They just literally move electrons through appendages that are basically tiny little wires... biological material can also be put together in such a way that electrons can flow through it as well. And so these cells do it.”

0.76

The subsurface contains enormous microbial diversity including wholly new phyla and branches on the tree of life not found elsewhere.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The deep underground biosphere contains not just a few species but billions of species, including deep branches on the tree of life—whole phyla—that are not found anywhere else on Earth, with tens of newly discovered phyla.

    “It's a lot of species, billions of species. And furthermore, it's not just a couple of extra types of things that are related to E. Coli. It's deep branches on the tree of life, whole phyla that are not found elsewhere.”

  • The Asgardarchaeota are archaea that carry the DNA for cytoskeletal elements previously thought unique to eukaryotes; they appear to be direct descendants of the ancestor that, before engulfing an Alpha Proteobacterium that became the mitochondria, gave rise to eukaryotes—making them a kind of stepping stone between archaea and eukaryotes that upends our understanding of life's divisions.

    “they have the DNA for the cytoskeletal elements that we use as eukaryotes to make all these organelles... So the question is, who ate the Alpha Proteobacteria and became a eukaryote? And to all appearances, these are the direct descendants of that ancestor, before it picked up the Alpha Proteobacteria, it turned into mitochondria and became a eukaryote.”

  • The ability to use DNA from the environment to infer what is living somewhere only came into popular usage in the early 2000s; before that, the first subsurface DNA sequences looked like nothing known at the surface, which initially seemed like scientist error but was actually the collective discovery of entirely new organisms.

    “the ability to use DNA from the environment to infer what's living there, is something that only came into popular usage in the early 2000s... I looked at the DNA sequences that I had, and they didn't look like anything at the surface... it wasn't my problem at all... we were all collectively discovering new stuff and nobody had ever seen it before.”

  • All the newly discovered branches on the tree of life still use DNA, so for life as we know it DNA appears to be primordial, tracing back to the last universal common ancestor; the new branches reveal how life differentiated (e.g., the emergence of the eukaryotic branch) rather than the chemical origin of life itself.

    “We're finding all these extra branches on the tree of life, but they're still using DNA. At least for life as we know it, DNA seems to be primordial, the last universal common ancestor.”

  • A shadow biosphere—living organisms unrelated to all other life and not using DNA—is absolutely possible and remains on the table; Lloyd has not seen one, but acknowledges her DNA-based detection methods would miss it entirely, whereas amino-acid chirality methods could in principle detect non-standard life.

    “I haven't seen any, but the methods that I use to look for life would miss them... I use DNA. So if you have a shadowed biosphere that doesn't use DNA, I would miss it, with my methods.”

0.68

Life is fundamentally a thermodynamic phenomenon that creates and exploits entropy gradients far more efficiently than abiotic processes.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Life acts like a catalyst that speeds up kinetically blocked reactions (those with high activation energy, such as methane plus oxygen that normally need a match) but makes them react much more slowly and with more entropy production than overcoming the activation energy abiotically with a flame.

    “Life is better at slowing down the... I'm sorry, speeding up the reactions that are blocked for some, kinetically blocked... it's a catalyst, that will make those two things react, but they react much more slowly with more entropy production, than it would if you got over that activation energy with just a flame.”

  • Life does not work against the second law of thermodynamics; rather it is parasitic upon entropy increase. Life is extremely good at producing entropy: feeding methane and oxygen to a methanotroph yields far more total entropy than burning them in a flash of heat, because the organism builds structures and supports a whole community. The defining feature of life is its ability to create extra opportunities for entropy production far beyond what existed without it.

    “life it seems, is super, super good at making entropy... if you take that same squirt of methane and same amount of oxygen, and you feed it to a growing culture of a methanotroph... The total amount of entropy that gets produced by these organisms, is gonna be so much more, than you get from just that flash of heat when you light a match.”

  • A whirlpool/eddy formed by a rock in a moving river is a bounded structure created purely by obeying the second law of thermodynamics, with no living or communicating water molecules; life does the same thing but additionally creates much larger downstream opportunities for entropy production (e.g., spawning a whitewater rafting company), which marks the cutoff between life and non-life.

    “Look at a whirlpool as a river moves down... it's a structure... But none of those water molecules are alive... They are just increasing entropy in a way that they have to. And so, life is kind of doing that too. It's just we are... making eddies in the stream, except we realize that we can make a whitewater rafting company”

0.67

Subsurface microbes persist for millennia with minimal energy, rarely dividing, maintaining cellular integrity through active repair without reproduction.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Maintaining chirality, membrane integrity, and intact DNA—keeping the cell whole over thousands of years—does not necessarily require cell division; growth-rate estimates for these organisms reflect the time to recreate one's body intact rather than the time to make new cells.

    “to maintain chirality, to maintain membrane integrity, to keep your DNA intact, to do all these maintenance things to make your body whole, you don't necessarily need to actually undergo cell division. So when we make estimates of growth rate, it's not necessarily making new cells, it's the amount of time we estimate it takes to make, to recreate your body so that you are intact.”

  • Living organisms maintain a single chirality (handedness) in their amino acids; after death, with no maintenance, amino acids slowly revert to a random racemic mixture of both handednesses, so the ratio of the two handednesses serves as a clock for how long something has been dead—useful over millennia. In subsurface sediments this ratio shows organisms are actively maintaining their chirality, proving they are alive and repairing themselves even without dividing.

    “if you take a living organism... and you kill it... it will naturally revert to a random mixture of the two types of chirality of it's amino acids... It's a great little time recorder of how long it's been since something has died... We can see, they're keeping them alive. They are not letting everything go to this random mixture of the two hands. So it means that they are maintaining themselves.”

  • By measuring chemicals in layered sediments (which act like a recorder tape of time) and using differential equations to calculate energy use, researchers find subsurface communities have 1,000 to 10,000 times less energy available than anything grown in the lab can survive on, implying these organisms are essentially not growing at all.

    “when we run those numbers and calculate exactly how much energy everyone has... it is 1,000 to 10,000 times less than anything that's grown in lab would be able to survive on... So basically what all this means, is that they're not growing. They're not growing at all.”

  • Because subsurface microbes can persist and self-maintain for millennia without dividing, there is a good chance they are the longest-lived organisms on Earth.

    “I would say there's a good chance they are the longest lived organisms on Earth.”

  • Subsurface microbes in deeply buried marine sediments live in environments where nothing changes for thousands of years, surviving on diffusion alone and eating the organic matter buried with them extremely slowly—analogous to being given a single pizza to make last for the rest of one's life.

    “the organic matter, the dead plants and dead phytoplankton that got buried with them, they just basically eat it super, super slowly. So it's like if you got given a pizza and then said, 'This is all you're getting for the rest of your life, make it last.'”

  • Some deep aquifers capped by the Canadian Shield have been isolated so long that the liquid water itself is billions of years old—it never became rain, ice, snow, or cloud—a striking demonstration that liquid water can remain liquid and untouched for geological eras.

    “some of these aquifers, like for the ones that are capped by the Canadian shield have been isolated. That water is billions of years old. The water itself, which is crazy to think that liquid water has just hung out liquid for that long.”

0.63

Asgard archaea possess eukaryote-like structural elements and appear to be evolutionary stepping stones between archaea and eukaryotes.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Cultured Asgard archaea are extremely tiny—on the scale of the wavelength/amplitude of visible light—and the first images show they have structure and 'arms,' confirming they actively use their eukaryote-like elements.

    “now the first images are coming out from these cultures and they are using them. They have structure, they're tiny. They're the width of visible light. They're the amplitude of visible light. That's the size of their cell... And they've got arms.”

  • In culture, Asgard archaea divide only every couple of weeks—insanely slow compared to normal microbiology where E. coli divides every half hour—making physiology experiments of the usual kind a non-starter for these organisms.

    “in the cultures, they will divide, every cell will divide every couple of weeks... it divides every half hour like E. Coli... These guys, they're never gonna get to that big turbid culture, and they're only gonna divide once every couple weeks. So the idea of performing experiments on their physiology in the way that we would for something that we can grow quickly in lab, is a non-starter.”

  • The entire domain of archaea has no known pathogens—one of the greatest mysteries of archaea—despite living commensally in our guts and being with us all the time; they have never evolved to take advantage of us, unlike viruses and bacteria.

    “that entire domain of life has no pathogens... It's one of the greatest mysteries of archaea. They commensal. They live in our guts. They're with us all the time, and for whatever reason, they've never decided to take advantage of us.”

  • Eukaryotes have a well-defined nucleus and complex organelles like mitochondria and tend to have larger cells, and almost all depend on oxygen, while bacteria and archaea lack such structures and are characterized as simpler 'bags of goo' with their genome in a region but no membrane-bound house around it.

    “eukaryotes have a well defined nucleus. So they have all their DNA that sits inside an organelle... then you compare it to the bacteria in the archaea, and they don't have the structures. They are sort of like little bags of goo.”

  • Both bacteria and archaea are found in the human and animal gut microbiome, and all the methane that comes out of cows is produced by archaea.

    “All the methane that comes out of cows, that's all produced by archaea.”

0.50

New molecular technologies enable direct inference of subsurface organism lifestyles from recovered genomes, RNA, and proteins without cultivation.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Technology now allows researchers to recover whole genomes from subsurface microbes without growing them, and to pull out their messenger RNA and actual proteins from deep-sea muck, enabling inference of these organisms' lifestyles directly from biomolecules.

    “We can now pull out whole genomes from these little critters, without having to grow them. So we can look not just at their entire genome, we can also pull out all of their messenger RNA molecules... We can pull out their actual proteins and see what they're doing. So we can infer their lifestyles from all of these biomolecules”

  • A deeply buried aquifer microbe called Desulforudis audaxviator ('bold traveler') appears to have an essentially unchanged genome found all around the world, an unsettling phenomenon researchers cannot yet explain.

    “there are some deeply buried aquifer microbes that seem to have an unchanged genome all around the world. Is called Desulforudis audaxviator. And I don't know why... We find it very unsettling.”

0.50

Subsurface life can be fueled by abiotic chemical reactions including hydrogen from serpentinization, radioactive decay, and redox-active minerals.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • At subduction zones, the process of serpentinization—just rocks reacting with water—can produce hydrogen that supplies everything needed to run life, depending on what type of rocks are being subducted.

    “There can be a lot of hydrogen produced through a process called serpentinization, depending on what type of rocks are being subducted. And that's a great reaction because just rocks and water and it makes everything you need to run life”

  • Radioactive decay occurs everywhere in Earth's crust for free; alpha, beta, or gamma radiation interacting with pure water splits it into hydrogen and oxygen, and although this is a slow background process, an already-slow subsurface microbe can live off the hydrogen produced by the radioactive decay of water.

    “when that interacts with pure water, some of it, will split apart the water into hydrogen and oxygen... if you're already a slow microbe, you can actually live off of the radioactive decay of water, which is kind of cool.”

0.45

Life could exist on Mars and other bodies with liquid water and chemical energy gradients despite lacking plate tectonics or sunlight.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Subsurface life does not necessarily require plate tectonics; even though Mars lacks plate tectonics (which is why it has the solar system's biggest volcano, Olympus Mons), the abiotic reactions that occur without sunlight produce hydrogen, carbon dioxide, and formate—exactly the chemicals methanogens need—plus the metals, nitrogen, and oxygen for their bodies are present on Mars.

    “You don't necessarily need plate tectonics I think, to support subsurface life... so many of the reactions that we know about, that happen on their own, without sunlight on Earth, create hydrogen and carbon dioxide and formate. And these are the chemicals that are pretty much all these methanogens need to make energy.”

  • Life could have started on either Mars or Earth and transferred between the two planets, since rocks regularly travel from Mars to Earth and could carry life that seeded one planet from the other.

    “it could have started in one of our two planets between Mars and Earth and transferred. We get rocks from Mars all the time, and they could have life on them that seeded Earth. So that's definitely a possibility.”

  • Europa is very well established to have liquid oceans underneath its ice cap, and since liquid oceans imply exploitable energy gradients, Lloyd would be shocked if life were not found there; Mars similarly shows real, now well-monitored methane whiffs that are exactly what subsurface life would produce, though they do not prove life.

    “Europa has liquid oceans underneath the ice cap... when I hear liquid ocean, I just think there's got to be energy gradients that are exploitable by something. So I would be shocked if we didn't find life on Europa. And Mars too... there are methane whiffs that appear every now and then... if there was life underground, that is absolutely what I would expect to see in their atmosphere.”

  • It is always hard to conclude there is nothing living in a place, including Mars; we have neither found definitive proof of life on Mars nor definitive proof that there is no life there, so the jury is still out.

    “it's always hard to conclude there's nothing living in a place. Including Mars... I don't think that we have not, we have found definitive proof there's not life on Mars.”

0.40

Advancing subsurface research requires expensive drilling infrastructure; US drilling capability has been discontinued while China has expanded its capacity.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Advancing the study of subsurface life primarily requires attaching to or directing more drilling, but boreholes cost one to ten million dollars each and require serious, often international investment; getting drilling proposals funded is highly competitive, and the US program enabling scientists to direct such drilling is now over.

    “Drilling a borehole costs a million to $10 million. And so, that's something that needs an actual investment. It's often an international investment... now that program is over in the United States, we don't do that anymore.”

  • The JOIDES Resolution, the US-supported drilling ship used for deep-sea subsurface sampling, has been retired with no plans to replace it, ending a capability in which the United States had always been a leader; China has built its own such ship.

    “the JOIDES Resolution is the name of the ship that we use to do this drilling in the ocean and it has sunset... the United States does not have plans to replace it. So China has built one, but we don't have one in the states anymore.”

  • Humans have never drilled below roughly 10 kilometers into the Earth for any reason, so all knowledge of the mantle and core is indirect (via seismology); no one has ever directly sampled those regions.

    “we've never actually drilled, humans have never drilled below maybe 10 kilometers. Never. For any reason, not just for biology.”

0.36

Subsurface organisms control Earth's crustal redox state, shape mineral deposits, and have fundamentally altered atmospheric and planetary chemistry over time.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Subsurface organisms determine the redox state of Earth's crust, which in turn governs mineral deposits and how much oxygen is available in the atmosphere; over the course of Earth's history these organisms have effectively made the world that humans now use.

    “They're basically determining what's happening with our redox state of our crust. And the redox state of our crust determines our mineral deposits, it determines how much oxygen is available in the atmosphere... Over the course of Earth's history, they have made the world that we now use.”

  • Underground carbon sequestration is not like storing CO2 in an empty container—living subsurface organisms inhabit those wells, and some, as seen in a Louisiana test well, convert the injected CO2 into methane, which fails to sequester the carbon; therefore any carbon-drawdown technology that injects CO2 underground should consult a microbiologist to ensure the carbon will actually stay there.

    “There's things living down there... some of the ones, in some of these wells are producing methane out of it, which is not what we want. Because that's not actually gonna sequester the carbon... call up a microbiologist before you do that, and make sure that it's actually gonna stay there.”