What this covers

Raychelle Burks, an analytical chemist at St. Edward's University who previously worked in crime labs, sits down with Sean Carroll to examine how forensic chemistry actually works—and how it differs from television portrayals. The conversation centers on analytical chemistry as a discipline of pattern recognition: finding and interpreting a specific compound amid a sea of similar ones. Burks traces how this work connects to crime investigation, discussing the real tools—presumptive tests, fingerprint visualization, metabolite detection—that help law enforcement solve cases. The backbone of the episode is the idea that modern murder is harder to commit undetected not because criminals are clumsy but because of relentless technological advance and the inescapable digital traces people leave behind.

The episode moves across several distinct territories. Burks explains Detection Lag—how each new poison once required chemists to develop an entirely new test, meaning today's perfect murder became tomorrow's solved crime once methods caught up. She explores poisons in history, from arsenic in ornamental gardens to scopolamine in drug-facilitated crimes, and discusses how alkaloids and other compounds behave in the body and in disguise. On the mechanics of crime, Burks points to Planning Trail as Evidence—that the searches and purchases needed to execute a murder create evidence of intent—and to the vulnerability of body transport, where ubiquitous CCTV and routine traffic stops often catch perpetrators before forensic science enters the picture. She also examines how cases go unsolved not because evidence is absent but because of practical failures: staff shortages and backlogged labs mean warehouses of samples never get analyzed. Throughout, she grounds her claims in Applied Science Rests on Basic Research, showing how field-ready tools always depend on understanding the underlying chemistry, and notes that Provisional Scientific Knowledge—even trusted techniques like superglue fuming—rests on incomplete understanding and can be revised as better instruments emerge.

Sharpest takeaway

Burks argues that real forensic chemistry is an analytical, pattern-recognition discipline whose power lies in detecting and explaining substances rather than 'solving' crimes, and that committing an undetectable murder is harder than ever—not because of clever planning but because of relentless technological advance and the digital trail people leave.

  • Analytical chemistry is detective work: finding a specific 'needle in a stack of needles' and interpreting patterns in data.
  • Forensic detection is a perpetual race—each new poison requires a new test, so today's perfect murder is tomorrow's solved crime.
  • Modern digital records (CCTV, search history, bank/card activity) make body disposal and 'no body, no crime' nearly impossible, while real escapes come from systemic failures like backlogged labs.

The argument · threads7 threads · 27 claims
0.85

Forensic detection methods emerge from basic chemical research and are refined as instruments improve, revealing accepted explanations were provisional.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Scientific understanding is provisional: even when the best available evidence makes researchers confident about a mechanism (as with slime cross-polymerization or superglue fuming), better techniques can later reveal the accepted explanation was wrong, and in forensics improved instruments that detect smaller amounts can revolutionize an entire thought process.

    “We have really good mechanisms worked out or we think we've got very strong evidence that this, is this the action? ... Until we don't.”

  • The seemingly simple field tests everyone takes for granted are only possible because applied forensic scientists first understand the basic research—the clinical metabolism, mechanisms, and the 'why'—so good applied tools always come back to fundamental science.

    “the reason I can build better tests is I have to understand the basic research in the clinical applications and the roots in order to get to the point where the little test that everyone takes for granted, that it's so simple.”

  • Forensic detection is a perpetual race against time: every new drug or poison requires a new test to be developed, so a substance that enables today's perfect murder becomes tomorrow's easily solved crime once a method is created—as happened historically with arsenic ('inheritance powder').

    “every new drug or new poison requires another set of people like myself, who develop a method like it's a race, it's a race against time”

  • Ninhydrin interacts with amino acids to turn a purplish-pink color, allowing latent fingerprints to be visualized on materials like paper, and this forensic use emerged from researchers doing amino-acid and protein staining and chromatography who realized it could be repurposed.

    “you can use Ninhydrin which interacts with amino acids, turns purplish pink color.”

  • Cyanoacrylate (superglue) fuming, a widely used fingerprint visualization technique discovered accidentally, still has an incompletely understood mechanism that chemists continue to debate in the literature, illustrating that even reliable forensic methods rest on provisional scientific understanding.

    “Even CA Cyanoacrylate or superglue fuming that you see a lot on TV. That was a total, oops!”

0.85

Understanding poison metabolism and detection requires knowing why compounds are poisoned, how they break down, and what traces remain.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Scopolamine is doubly difficult to detect in drug-facilitated crimes because it is rapidly metabolized and because one of its own effects is memory loss—so victims may not realize they need medical attention until days later, meaning the drug's action itself limits its detectability.

    “one of its effects is memory loss... So by the time you might even realize... the drug's action itself limits its ability to be found”

  • Even when a poison's parent compound can no longer be found, detecting its metabolites in characteristic ratios provides strong indirect evidence of poisoning, which is why understanding metabolism mechanisms is essential to building better detection tests.

    “you can find all of it's little metabolites in certain ratios, and then it's like, it's indirect, but it's very good evidence.”

  • Poisons that are rapidly metabolized or that were rarely used, such as succinylcholine, historically evaded detection because investigators were not looking for them and had no developed test—succinylcholine paralyzes the breathing muscles and went 'under the radar' as a murder weapon for a long time.

    “it literally wasn't found, now it's been the jig is up because it just was not commonly used.”

  • Certain poisons such as arsenic persist in bone and remains for centuries, allowing historical forensic investigators to compare measured levels against an environmental baseline (arsenic being a naturally occurring element present in water and artifacts) and conclude—as with the suspected Medici-court poisoning—that levels far exceeding baseline demand explanation.

    “there are certain poisons that just, they stay with you. They stay, they're literally in the bone, or in certain amounts, they get preserved.”

  • In past eras the same substances that were lethal poisons were, in smaller quantities, used as cosmetics, medicines, and pest control, so affluent households commonly kept buckets of dangerous substances—the equivalent of a modern medicine cabinet—making poison both accessible and unremarkable.

    “at the same time that these things are lethal and poisonous a lot of the same things were in cosmetics. In smaller quantities they were considered medicinal.”

0.71

Crime solving depends on digital records, body transport vulnerability, and processing backlogs rather than criminal planning or investigator glamour.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Real forensic work differs from CSI portrayals chiefly in mundane ways—investigators lack the glamorous looks and wardrobes, do not run the crime scene, and spend at least half their time documenting and writing reports rather than the dramatic activity shown on television.

    “they never show them doing paperwork, and I know I spent at least half my time documenting and writing reports.”

  • Elaborate planning of a crime is self-defeating because the plan itself creates evidence of intent—Google searches, location specifics, purchase records—so 'the more you plan, the plan reveals your maleficence,' and getting away with crimes is usually a perfect storm of incompetence, slow response, or mishandled evidence rather than clever design.

    “the more you plan, the plan reveals your maleficence.”

  • The old maxim 'no body, no crime' has weakened because pervasive digital records mean a dead person's sudden inactivity—no bank or card use, no withdrawals, an abandoned car—lets investigators reasonably conclude something happened, since going completely off-grid is extremely hard, making murder far harder to get away with than decades ago.

    “almost with the advent of as much data and how everything is kind of logged... unless this person has totally ghosted everyone, and then gone completely off the grid, which is really, really hard to do. They're dead.”

  • Transporting a body is the key point of vulnerability in disposal: it exposes the perpetrator to chance traffic stops (a broken taillight, speeding) and ubiquitous CCTV in garages and streets, multiplying the number of witnesses and records, so movement rather than the killing is often where people get caught.

    “Body transport can be where you get caught. There's key cases where moving people and or bodies is when you got pulled over for that broken taillight.”

  • People escape justice not because they left no evidence but because of practical limitations—staff shortages, instrument and budget constraints—producing warehouses of unanalyzed evidence; when Michigan funded processing of backlogged sexual assault kits, the analysis identified numerous serial predators who had effectively been protected by administrative backlog.

    “you get away with it not, because you didn't leave evidence behind, but because of limitations in staff, instruments, budgets”

0.52

Forensic science uses absence of expected items and multiple data visualization approaches to interpret evidence and direct investigation.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Interpreting scientific data is a creative act analogous to viewing art: the same dataset can be visualized in different ways (bar chart, line graph) to reveal different patterns, and just as one must step back from a large painting to see the whole, scientists must step back from complex data to perceive how variables relate.

    “there is a creative aspect in how you visualize it... I'm gonna make it a bar chart versus a line graph first. And then, what does that visualization reveal about the underlying process?”

  • Presumptive tests are quick visual screening tests that change color rapidly—for example breaking ampoules in a baggie with a sample to produce purple for scheduled drugs—and require substantial development work to make them simple enough for non-chemists like roadside officers to use for command decisions.

    “by presumptive test I mean that it's just a quick screening test, usually they change color really visual, really fast to do”

  • At a crime scene, the absence of expected items (a missing EpiPen for a known allergy sufferer, a missing weapon for a stabbing, dog blood with no dog) can be as informative as what is present, and the same principle applies to interpreting analytical data across sciences.

    “what's missing is just as important as what maybe should be there”

  • Whether a bloodstain is human or animal can be determined with an immunoassay—a dipstick test resembling a pregnancy test—that detects species-specific antibodies, which can in turn raise new investigative questions like why dog blood is present.

    “you might do an immunoassay... Certain antibodies for different types of animals would be present, or not present, and you can do kind of like the same type of technology as a pregnancy test.”

0.32

Historical chemical knowledge for pest control, medicine, and cosmetics made poisons accessible in affluent households as ordinary household items.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Many historically planted 'ornamental' plants were deliberately placed to release volatile organic chemicals that controlled pests or attracted desired organisms, and medicinal gardens were sited near homes for easy access when ill—so elaborate gardens reflected functional chemical knowledge, not just aesthetics.

    “it's not an accident that these very elaborate gardens that were planned out, plants were where they were, and it wasn't just because they looked cool”

  • Effective concealment of poison follows a 'like dissolves like' principle: sweet poisons like ethylene glycol or lead acetate should be hidden in already-sweet beverages (e.g., Gatorade, Cherry Lambrini) rather than in bitter drinks, because adding a bitter alkaloid to a familiar Negroni would be immediately noticeable and rejected.

    “such a sweet beverage that adding a little bit... Is gonna disguise it. You wouldn't wanna add something like strychnine”

  • Some mummification protocols applied a thin layer of honey, which served a functional antibacterial role keeping bacterial growth under control rather than being merely symbolic or due to stickiness, because honey is chemically complex containing thousands of compounds.

    “some protocols actually a thin layer of honey, and it did, it did help keep down some of the little bacteria friends from getting a bit out of control.”

0.32

Analytical chemistry emerged from verifying trust in currency and determining causes of death, protecting confidence that holds society together.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Analytical chemistry is the 'detective' branch of chemistry: practitioners typically do not synthesize chemicals but instead find a specific target chemical amid a sea of similar ones, then interpret the resulting data statistically or through modeling to determine its meaning.

    “I like to call analytical chemists the detectives of chemistry. So we tend not to make chemicals, we find them. And we tend to find them in a sea of other ones.”

  • Unlike fields such as theoretical physics, chemistry careers split roughly into thirds across academia, government labs, and industry, so for most chemistry PhD students becoming a professor is not the default expectation.

    “the common thing is that a third are in academia, a third are kind of in government labs, a third 's in industry”

  • The earliest analytical chemistry was driven by the need to verify trust and security—testing whether currency was actually the gold or silver it claimed to be, since a fraudulent foundation could collapse an economy, and determining why people kept dying—so foundational chemical tests were rooted in protecting the tenuous confidence that holds society together.

    “in specific analytical chemistry was to test currency... Is it gold? Is it silver?”

0.26

Forensic science's everyday value lies in keeping people safe through food, water, and environmental testing rather than catching criminals.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The use of science in both criminal and civil matters has dramatically increased over the last 200 years and especially the last 30, with the pre-DNA to post-DNA transition (visible even in long-running shows like Murder, She Wrote) marking a major revolution in forensic capability.

    “the use of science in both criminal and civil matters has really dramatically increased in the last, I would definitely say, in the last 200 years, and definitely in the last 30”

  • The everyday value of forensic and analytical chemistry lies less in catching criminals than in keeping people safe—ensuring food, drink, water, and air are uncontaminated (as with a boil-water notice after a storm)—and empowering people to trust the things they take for granted, reflecting a broader scientific motive simply to help people.

    “it's in the business of keeping us safe and being able to have confidence in the things that we take for granted, our food, and our drink, and our air.”