288 | Max Richter on the Meaning of Classical Music Today
What this covers
Sean Carroll sits down with composer and pianist Max Richter to explore what classical music means now—not as a historical museum piece, but as a living, evolving practice. Richter, trained under Luciano Berio and shaped by decades of solo work, film scoring, and collaborations across genres, discusses how the tools, technologies, and social contexts of music-making have shifted since the tuxedo-and-gown concert hall era. The conversation centers on a paradox: composing music demands intense architectural conceptual work, yet the listener's experience is entirely visceral and emotional, innocent of technical analysis. [Listener's Biography as Prism](concept:Listener's Biography as Prism) becomes Richter's governing principle—each person hears through the lens of every piece they have previously encountered, making the listener's own story half the work's meaning.
The discussion ranges across several contentious territories. Richter argues that genre boundaries have dissolved through streaming and shared digital tools, so 'classical music' should simply be called music; that total serialism, the post-Boulez orthodoxy in which he trained, chased abstraction into divorce from sensation; and that electronics and ambient materials are simply the orchestra's natural palette expanding, as it has for centuries. He describes his compositional method as Maximum From Minimum—every note earned, language direct and plain—and his use of repetition and redundancy as a technique of Novelty Within a Known Space, where small shifts land powerfully once the listener knows the territory. Two specific works surface: Sleep, an eight-hour piece built partly from neuroscience findings about low-frequency tones and rest, conceived as protest against always-on productivity culture; and 24 Postcards, tiny ringtone fragments that treat the smartphone not as an enemy but as legitimate creative space.
Richter argues that classical music today is not a museum artifact but a living, borderless practice, and that the most powerful music achieves maximum expression through minimal, direct means while treating the listener's biography and the surrounding world as the other half of the conversation.
- Streaming and shared digital tools have dissolved genre boundaries, so 'classical' should just be called music
- Repetition and redundancy create a known territory in which small changes become powerfully affecting
- Music is half the work; the listener's biography and context complete its meaning
Tonal language offers directness and emotional authenticity, escaping the systematic abstraction and intellectual orthodoxy of total serialism.
- During Richter's academic composition training, there was an enforced orthodoxy of complexity—post-Boulez total serialism—under which being interested in tonal music was taken to mean you were literally stupid, even if technically capable.
“there was an orthodoxy, about the kind of music you should write. And this was kind of complexity, basically, It was sort of post boles, total serialism plus, plus plus. And if you were interested in tonal music, it just meant you were stupid. Literally, that was the attitude.”
- Serialism, devised by Schoenberg around 1908-1915, organized music in the absence of a tonal center by placing tones in predetermined orders and building geometric structures from them; it progressively systematized pitch, duration, rhythm, and dynamics into an 'arms race of abstraction' that is essentially divorced from the sensation and feeling of music.
“one of the ways of organizing it was a thing called serialism, which Schoenberg comes up with around 1908... this is to do with like putting tones in a predetermined order and building sort of geometrical structures out of tones... It's actually nothing to do with like the sensation and feeling of music... it becomes this really weird sort of arms race of abstraction.”
- When Richter showed Berio a deliberately impossible-to-play student piano piece, Berio asked whether this was really what he wanted to do with his time and what music is for, and these fundamental questions unsettled Richter and helped redirect him toward a more direct tonal language.
“he looked at it, and he was just like, is this actually what you wanna be doing, really, with your time? What is music for? Why are you doing this? Asking sort of really profound questions, really, basic fundamental questions about what music was. And so, that kind of, in a way, unsettled me.”
- Richter's aesthetic is to do the maximum with the minimum—every note exists for a reason and he aims for lean, direct, low-information expression—rather than pattern-based minimalism in the style of early Glass and Reich, which he uses but not as an end in itself.
“I'm certainly trying to do the maximum with the minimum. Every note is there for a reason... I'm trying to sort of achieve a kind of a very lean, direct expression... I work a lot with patterns because there's something very fundamental in music to do with patterns... But that isn't my sort of main thing or rather it's not a thing in itself.”
- The tonal system—a structure of triads codified by Bach—is essentially a cultural elaboration of the harmonic series, which itself comes from physics and concerns numerical, physical relationships; tonal music is an expression of that physical phenomenon.
“tonality itself, the tonal system is really like a cultural elaboration of the Harmonic series. The Harmonic series is something from physics and it's to do with numerical physical relationships. And the tonal system is like an expression of that.”
Music's fundamental paradox: composition demands intense structural and conceptual work while listening is visceral, emotional, and unreflective.
- Music is paradoxical: composing it involves intense conceptual work—architectural schemes, structure, pacing, energy—yet the listener's experience is entirely visceral and emotional; they don't analyze bar counts and dominant preparations, they simply nod, tap their feet, or walk out.
“it is very conceptual. There's a lot of thinking going on... But ultimately, it's totally a feeling thing. A listener doesn't go, 'Oh, that was a 13-bar thing. And then there was a dominant preparation'... They go, they either nod their head and go, hmmm or they walk out of the room... it goes directly to our emotions. So, it's paradoxical in that sense.”
- Much music relies on artifice, misdirection, and sleight of hand; Richter instead aims for a language where the material speaks directly and plainly, so the listener does not need to analyze it but can simply listen.
“within music, there's a lot of artifice, there's almost like misdirection or sleight of hand... So, I'm sort of, I've been trying to get towards a situation where the material speaks very directly and plainly. So, in other words, it's not necessary to think of it in a kind of analytical way, but you can just listen to it.”
- When you connect with a piece of music, even purely instrumental music, you feel you are being spoken to about something and sharing the consciousness of the person who made it—a profound effect given that physically it is just air bouncing around, which Richter regards as one of music's great puzzles.
“when you hear a piece of music, if you sort of connect with it in any way, you do feel like you're being spoken to about something. And you're sharing something of the consciousness of the person who made that piece or who played it... We feel it look, this is just air bouncing around, right? And yet there is something very profound going on.”
- Music is simultaneously very simple and very mysterious, deeply involving and connected to the experience of being a person and how we relate to one another, and is endlessly elusive in a way Richter genuinely enjoys.
“It's a very simultaneously very simple and very mysterious thing. And I really enjoy that about it actually. The fact that it's kind of endlessly elusive in a way.”
Audiences cocreate meaning through their own biography and context; live performance is the most direct occasion for this conversational unfolding.
- Richter distinguishes ambient background listening, which he enjoys for surprise while cooking, from focused listening: when he deliberately puts a record on he gives it full concentration because that is what the artist intended, treating attentive listening as a kind of contract.
“if I listen to music, then I'll... If I put a record on, then I will sit and listen to that music with full concentration. Because that is what the artist will have intended. So, I guess that's a sort of, it's like a contract.”
- Playing music live is the most authentic, direct musical experience because it is a one-time, unrepeatable occasion in which the conversational aspect of music unfolds in real time between performers and audience.
“playing music live is really, in a way, the most authentic, the realist, most direct musical experience we have. It's a setting where you really get to experience the conversational aspect of music in real time”
- Putting newly written music in front of a live audience is like testing a theory: the composer has ideas on paper, learns more through recording, but only discovers what the music truly is by observing how real human beings in a room respond to it, and audiences differ in energy and enthusiasm around the world.
“I love, putting the music out into the real world and seeing what happens, because I think it's a little bit like testing a theory. I write a bunch of stuff on a piece of paper, and I have ideas about what that might be... But really, part two, and maybe the most important part, is finding out what happens when you put it in a room with human beings.”
- Every listener hears a piece of music through the prism of their own biography: every piece of music they have previously heard informs how they hear what they are hearing in the present moment.
“every listener is bringing, well, put it this way, they're listening through the prism of their biography... Every piece of music they've heard informs the way they hear what they're hearing in that moment. And there's something really beautiful about that.”
- When performing Sleep live to 500 people in beds, Richter learned that the musicians were not giving a concert by projecting the piece into the space, but rather accompanying something happening in the room—a community of strangers who have trusted one another to enter a vulnerable state and travel through the night together.
“What we were doing is we were accompanying something that is happening in the room, which is a community of strangers, hundreds of people who don't know one another, who've come together and basically trusted one another to be sort of in this very vulnerable state and go on this journey through the night together. And really, we were just accompanying this thing that's happening.”
- In classical concerts, audience coughing between movements may function as a socially permitted substitute for applause, since clapping between movements is not allowed but coughing releases the same impulse and spreads contagiously once one person starts.
“I wonder whether coughing isn't, sometimes like you'll get loads of coughing between numbers. And it's almost like a substitute for applause... people are like no, we're not allowed to clap, 'cause it's like not finished between movements, but we will cough.”
Classical music is a living practice of human storytelling through sound, not a museum artifact from dead composers of the past.
- Although the public consciousness treats classical music like a museum—instrumental music played by an orchestra and written by a dead composer of the past—it is in fact a living thing: human beings telling stories with sound, responding to the world around them through music.
“it's a bit like a museum. It's this thing that comes from history. But really, it's a living thing. It's a thing, human beings, telling stories with sound, writing things they're passionate about, trying to communicate those things”
- Contemporary classical music has escaped the project of merely adding to an inherited canon (Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, Brahms) and has become borderless, marked by a wide-open multiplicity of influences, such that ideally we would stop talking about 'classical music' and simply talk about music.
“classical music now is something which is really borderless, we've got to a position now where it isn't really just about, adding to the canon... there's this kind wonderful multiplicity, this sort of wide openness of influence going on in music culture right now. So, that ideally, we would kind of stop talking about classical music, and we'd just be talking about music.”
- Adding electronic instruments and ambient sounds to composition is simply a continuation of the orchestra's centuries-long growth in size and color through the 18th and 19th centuries; composers have always pushed against the possible into new colors, and electronics are just the palette getting bigger.
“I see it really as simply a continuation of a process that's happened to the orchestra from the beginning... The orchestra grows both in size and in terms of available colors, different instruments get added... we're always looking for new things, new colors, new possibilities, and for me, the electronics, are really just the palette getting bigger.”
Digital tools and streaming have democratized musical discovery and enabled interpenetration of compositional methods across all genres.
- Musicians of all kinds now work with the same computer-based tools—notation programs, samplers, Max MSP—whether trained in a conservatoire or coming from dance/EDM, and this interpenetration of tools has produced a broad openness to materials and methods across genres.
“musicians of all kinds are now working with the computer. So, we've all got the same tools... if you're coming from what, like a dance music perspective, or an EDM perspective... there's a kind of interpenetration of like tools. So, everyone's using the same things. And that, I think, has led to a kind of an openness to materials and methods.”
- Streaming has eliminated the cost and commitment that once gated musical discovery—where hearing a new sound required saving pocket money, traveling to a record store, and risking money on a purchase—so listeners can now follow their enthusiasms freely through the entire musical universe, which has made people listen much more widely.
“if I heard something that I loved and wanted to know more about, I had to like, open up my piggy bank, get the pocket money out, take the risk, go to the record store... Whereas now, you literally just click your mouse and there it is, all the music in the world. So, that's meant that people... Have no risk in terms of just following their enthusiasms through the musical universe. And that's meant that people are listening much more widely.”
- Rather than resenting the smartphone era, Richter treated the millions of small loudspeakers in people's pockets as a legitimate creative space, writing 24 Postcards—little musical fragments designed as ringtones—prompted by the ubiquitous, traumatic Crazy Frog ringtone.
“there's all these millions of little loudspeakers going around the world. We could actually... This is a space for music. It could be a creative space. So I wrote, yeah, all these little fragments. And just almost like treated them like Polaroids, just little snapshots of a moment for people to use as ringtones.”
Repetition and material variation allow small changes to land powerfully within known sonic territory, creating novelty through reimagining.
- Working with redundant, repeated material keeps the listener in the same place re-experiencing the same moment, so that small shifts and changes produce the experience of novelty within a known space; once the listener has learned the territory of a piece, a small change—like introducing a melody—lands powerfully, like a character walking into a familiar room.
“if you work, say with repeated material, in a sense, you are sort of always in the same place. You are re-experiencing the same moment. And so, if you make small shifts and changes, you get the experience of novelty, but within a known space... when I make very small changes by introducing a, for example, a melody line, it's like a character walking into a room that we know very well.”
- A finished composition is like a negative map of all the things you didn't do with it—the territory implies the million other unrealized versions—and variation forms in music, like Bach's Goldberg Variations offering thirty-one ways to make a journey, partly fill the space of paths not taken.
“The finished piece is a sort of a, it's like a negative map of the things you didn't do with it... there's a million other universes out there with the, all the different versions”
- Research available around 2012-2013 demonstrated that repetitive low-frequency tones can elongate slow-wave sleep, improving information processing and memory, which Richter used compositionally in Sleep by drawing on his longstanding love of subsonic low-end sound around 25-40 Hz that one half-hears and half-feels.
“some people have demonstrated that using like repetitive low frequency tones can elongate slow wave sleep so you get better information processing and memory, that kind of stuff. So, that for me was great 'cause I love, I love the sort of low end and sub-sonics.”
Composers should develop their unique biographical voice through rigorous learning, trusting their own story rather than pursuing greatness or grandiosity.
- Richter seeks to escape the Romantic and modernist hierarchy of 'greatness'—the great composer writing the great piece while everyone listens and behaves—drawing a distinction between genuine greatness and grandiosity, exemplified by valuing small ubiquitous bits of art (like the Lincoln penny) and making them good.
“I guess, question the sort of hierarchical aspect of music as this, again, going back to the Romantics or the modernists, this idea of greatness. You have the sort of the great composer, who writes the great piece, and then we all have to listen and sort of shut up and behave... I wanted to try and get away from that idea.”
- Richter's advice to aspiring composers and musicians is to learn relentlessly—technical and historical—then identify the unique part of your biography and story that no one else has, because that origin point is what you write from and is probably the best thing you've got, even though being yourself can feel anxiety-inducing and requires trust.
“you have to just learn, learn, learn... And then I think try to figure out what it is that you've got, which is the thing that really makes you, you. That bit of your biography, that bit of your story, which is really, which no one else has got... Because that's what you write from, and that's where you, that's your sort of origin point.”
- In Richter's composing process, the most exciting and beloved moment—shared by most creative people—is when the material begins to feel like it has its own intentionality, so that composing becomes a matter of following the material where it wants to go, sometimes leading outside the current project into an entirely different piece.
“the big thing that I really, and I think probably most creative people have this that I really love is when the material starts to feel like it has a kind of intentionality. Things start to sort of happen in the material... it's about like following that material kind of where it wants to go.”
Specific works address contemporary conditions: Sleep responds to digital overload while In a Landscape pleads for coexistence in polarized moments.
- The album In a Landscape is built around polarities and their reconciliation—acoustic versus electronic instruments, composed music versus found-object interludes, natural world versus human world—and uses the title's ambiguity (external landscape versus inner landscape) to make a small plea for coexistence and listening in a polarized historical moment.
“the record is about kind of polarities and reconciling polarities. So, I'm working with disparate means. So, acoustic instruments, electronic instruments, looking at themes from the natural world, the human world.”
- Bruce Springsteen's 'Born in the USA' is a dark song about loss and everything falling to pieces, written with the blackest irony, yet its anthemic music led many—including political campaigns—to adopt it as a patriotic anthem without listening to the words.
“It's a very dark song. It's a song about loss and everything falling to pieces... it's actually the blackest irony, right? That song.”
- Sleep was conceived around 2013-2014 as 4G internet put 24/7 social media in our pockets with significant psychological load; modeled on how large-scale artworks can blanket out reality, Richter built an eight-hour piece to act as a 'big pause button'—simultaneously a lullaby and a protest song against neoliberalism's demand for constant productivity.
“Sleep comes from, I guess, about 2013, 2014, when 4G internet moved into our pockets. So, that meant we then had social media 24/7 in our pockets... I'm gonna make a piece which can be like a big pause button. You'll put it on and you can just like zone out for eight hours... It's at one level a kind of a lullaby, at one level a kind of a protest song.”
- Scoring film or TV is fundamentally collaborative and different from writing a symphony, because the music must serve a world that already contains actors and story; the goal is to find the music that feels innate or inevitable within that story, arrived at through experiment, conversation, and luck.
“It's a fundamentally a collaborative thing... what's the best way for the music to be part of the thing? That's what we're trying to figure out. Trying to figure out, what is the music that feels innate or inevitable within the world of that story. And that's something which you arrive at by experiment and conversation and luck sometimes.”