239 | Brian Lowery on the Social Self
What this covers
Brian Lowery, a psychologist at Stanford, and Sean Carroll explore whether the self is a fundamental feature of human existence or a construct built entirely through social interaction. Lowery argues for a strong version of social constructionism: the self does not emanate from an inner essence or soul, but rather emerges only within relationships and communities. To be a self at all requires both how you conceive of yourself and how your community recognizes you. The conversation draws on perceptual illusions, historical shifts in how people have understood consciousness, philosophical arguments about identity persistence, and the real-world stakes of identity claims in a society that insists both that you must be free to choose who you are and that your choices must fit what others recognize as coherent.
The discussion moves across several domains. Lowery uses experimental evidence—the rubber hand illusion, out-of-body effects, and the enfacement effect—to show that our sense of bodily boundary and selfhood is learned rather than given. He argues that identity categories like gender and race function as social facts, not biological essences: Money as a Social Construction serves as an analogue—real and consequential but grounded in collective agreement. He traces the modern ideal of the rugged individual to recent history, noting that classical thinkers did not frame experience as arising from an inner self. Central to his argument is that authenticity as traditionally understood—peeling away social masks to find a true self—is incoherent: there is no substrate beneath the masks. The conversation also engages Terror Management Theory, which explains how mortality awareness drives people toward enduring groups and identities, and addresses the ethical tangles that arise when someone's self-conception meets community recognition and finds it wanting or contested.
Lowery argues for a strong social-constructionist view that the self is not an essential inner core or soul but is created through and only exists within social relationships and communities, so identity requires both self-conception and community recognition to be real.
- Perceptual illusions (rubber hand, out-of-body, enfacement) show the self/body boundary is learned and constructed, not given
- Identity categories like gender and race require community acceptance, not just individual declaration
- Concepts like authenticity and a singular 'true self' dissolve under scrutiny, leaving 'masks all the way down'
Emergent concepts earn legitimacy through usefulness rather than fundamental physical status.
- Concepts like 'table' or 'self' are not part of fundamental physics but are emergent concepts that earn their place by being useful—conveying information, enabling predictions, and bearing causal relationships to other things—rather than being arbitrarily made up.
“A table is an emergent concept. It's not anywhere in the standard model of particle physics... but by saying there's a table here, that conveys a lot of information.”
Personal identity is not an essentialist fact but a constructed notion requiring update.
- In the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics, a measurement splits into literally separate worlds with a version of you in each; the objection 'but which one is me?' rests on a flawed essentialist notion of personal identity, since neither copy is uniquely you and our notions of personal identity must be updated.
“People who wanna say, the many world's point of view doesn't comport with my notion of personal identity, I wanna say your notion of personal identity was never that good.”
Psychological measures of stable traits predict life outcomes reliably.
- Philip Zimbardo claimed that people have stable orientations toward time—past, present, or future—that can be easily measured psychologically and that correlate with life outcomes such as career choices more strongly than other psychological test results.
“his claim was that you could easily test this psychologically to figure out which one you were and it correlated much more strongly than other psychology test results with outcomes in life, careers you choose”