What this covers

Andy Strominger joins Sean Carroll to discuss how string theory has shifted from candidate "theory of everything" to a source of conceptual tools for understanding quantum gravity and black holes. Strominger argues that while string theory will almost certainly not be the literal final answer, it has already produced reusable insights—chiefly the holographic principle and emergent symmetry—that are now guiding real investigations of black hole physics. The conversation moves from the historical impasse between quantum mechanics and general relativity through concrete advances like the Strominger-Vafa calculation of black hole entropy, which provided the first existence proof that a region of spacetime could be encoded on a holographic surface. Strominger walks through how this stringy construction revealed something deeper: an infinite family of emergent conformal symmetries near the black hole horizon that do the real work of explaining information storage.

The discussion then reaches toward observation. Strominger describes how rapidly spinning real astrophysical black holes—including Cygnus X-1 and GRS 1915, many spinning near the speed limit—exhibit the same conformal symmetry that emerged in the string-theory analysis, a correspondence that now enables quantitative predictions about the photon ring observed by the Event Horizon Telescope. He explains the photon ring as a cascade of images produced when light orbits a black hole multiple times before escaping, offering a window into the spacetime geometry itself rather than just the hot swirling matter. Strominger advances the hypothesis—still lacking mathematical proof—that the photon ring may be the actual holographic surface of a real black hole. He also contextualizes string theory within physics more broadly, estimating its odds at one extreme or the other as vanishingly small, while stressing the need for multiple approaches—top-down and bottom-up alike—to make progress on fundamental questions.

Sharpest takeaway

Strominger argues that although string theory will almost certainly not be the literal final 'theory of everything,' it has already delivered profound, reusable insights—especially the holographic principle and emergent conformal symmetry—that are now guiding both quantum gravity theory and real-world observations of black holes like the photon ring.

  • String theory provided the first concrete existence proof of holography by reproducing black hole entropy via stringy microstates (Strominger-Vafa).
  • Emergent conformal symmetry near extremal black holes is the key mechanism, and it reappears in real astrophysical (rapidly spinning) black holes and the photon ring.
  • Connecting quantum gravity to observation via the Event Horizon Telescope's photon ring is now a live, near-term research program.

The argument · threads7 threads · 29 claims
0.68

Quantum gravity remained unsolved for decades because gravity's infinity problem makes standard quantization impossible, unlike other interactions.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • In the era when Strominger began, quantum mechanics and general relativity—two of the greatest 20th-century achievements—were completely incompatible: there was no self-consistent way to write both on the same piece of paper, and only dozens of people worldwide were working on the problem.

    “these two pillars of physics were at that time completely incompatible... No self-consistent way of having them both on the same piece of paper existed and the number of people interested in that problem was in the dozens.”

  • Wolfgang Pauli first noticed in the 1950s the 'infinity problem': you cannot simply apply the standard quantization recipe to gravity the way it succeeded for the electroweak and strong interactions—gravity does not play by those rules.

    “Which is the one that Wolfgang Pauli first noticed in the 1950s, that you can't just take out your cookbook and dress up gravity with quantum mechanics in the way that we did so incredibly successfully for the electroweak and the strong interactions”

  • The basic scale where quantum mechanics and gravity both become important is 10 to the minus 33 centimeters, which is unimaginably small, making direct experimental contact extraordinarily difficult.

    “the basic scale and size of the phenomena that we're looking at, where quantum mechanics and gravity are both important, is 10 to the minus 33 centimeters, which is unimaginably small.”

  • Strominger forecasts that, although it is not logically impossible and people should keep trying, nobody will succeed in directly measuring quantum gravitational effects or deviations from classical GR due to string theory within the next 20-30 years—after which all bets are off because we cannot predict what science will look like.

    “I don't think anybody will succeed in the next 20, 30 years. After that all bets are off.”

0.68

Strominger and Vafa used string theory to construct black holes whose entropy exactly matched Bekenstein-Hawking predictions, proving holography exists.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Strominger and Vafa used a very complicated string-theory construction to build special stringy black holes with event horizons subject to Bekenstein-Hawking analysis, and explicitly constructed the hologram in complete detail, hitting the entropy answer exactly on the nose—an existence proof of the holographic principle showing how a region of spacetime can be realized by a holographic plate.

    “Vafa and I actually constructed the hologram in complete detail... it was completely correct and we hit the answer on the nose... it was an existence proof of the holographic principle.”

  • Bekenstein and Hawking showed via a stunningly simple argument that the information capacity (number of gigabytes) a black hole can store is proportional to its surface area, not its volume—deeply strange because ordinary storage scales with volume—which is the first version of the holographic principle, suggesting information can be stored on the horizon surface like a hologram.

    “Bekenstein and Hawking showed using a stunningly simple and elegant argument that the number of gigabytes... that a black hole can store is proportional to its area... it's very, very strange that the number of gigabytes should go like the area.”

  • Green and Schwarz's achievement was an existence proof: they demonstrated a mathematically consistent theory that solved the infinity problem and could reduce to Einstein's general relativity in one limit and to Heisenberg-Schrödinger quantum mechanics in another—though they were clear it could not be the real world because it lacked quarks, leptons, and parity violation.

    “Green and Schwarz were claiming to have solved the first problem in just an existence proof of a theory which could reduce to Einstein's theory of general relativity in one limit and Heisenberg Schrodinger quantum mechanics in another.”

  • Stripping the Strominger-Vafa calculation down over time revealed that only one thing mattered—an emergent conformal (scaling) symmetry that appears near a black hole's horizon, not just a few but an infinite number of emergent conformal symmetries—and such infinite conformal symmetry gives enough control to derive universal formulas for information capacity, which is exactly what was needed to explain the Bekenstein-Hawking area law.

    “there was only one thing that mattered, and the thing that mattered was what we call an emergent symmetry... very near the horizon of a black hole, you got an emergent symmetry, and not just a few of them but an infinite number of them, emergent conformal symmetries.”

0.57

Physics advances by balancing interesting problems against doable ones; diverse approaches including top-down and bottom-up thinking are all necessary.

9 pointscentrality 3/5
  • At the liquid-to-gas critical point of carbon, at just the right pressure and temperature, the substance suddenly becomes opaque (critical opalescence) because it acquires extra conformal symmetries that produce excitations capable of absorbing light—an example of emergent symmetry being the organizing principle across modern physics from condensed matter to particle physics.

    “if we take carbon at just the right pressure and temperature, it goes from being a liquid to being a gas, all of a sudden it becomes opaque right at that moment... that's because at that point, it suddenly gets extra symmetries, so-called conformal symmetries”

  • Strominger initially resisted string theory because he believed quantum gravity was a deep problem that had resisted solution for decades and therefore needed fundamentally new conceptual input—like the equivalence principle or uncertainty principle—whereas the hypothesis that particles are little strings seemed comparatively trivial and merely mathematical.

    “it's a very deep problem and it had resisted solution for decades and we really needed some new conceptual input like the equivalence principle or the uncertainty principle”

  • Physicists tend to be too arrogant about how complete current knowledge is; there will be fundamental new ideas and ways of looking at things, and string theory today is already a very different theory than the one Green and Schwarz presented in the '80s, and it will continue to grow and accrete other ideas before finding its home in physical reality.

    “we tend to be too arrogant about how complete our current knowledge is. I think there are going to be fundamental new ideas and ways of looking at things, and we've already seen that happen within string theory many times”

  • The art of being a good physicist is staying on the knife edge between problems that are doable but uninteresting and problems that are interesting but undoable; the most important questions are precisely those that are both interesting and doable, and most physicists most of the time fall off one side of that edge.

    “there's things that are, you can do, but they're not interesting and then there's things that are interesting but you can't do. And things which you can do and are interesting, that's a knife edge. And the art of being a good physicist is not falling off the knife edge”

  • By putting geometry back into string theory—examining how the 10 dimensions consistently curl up to four using the Calabi conjecture and algebraic geometry—Strominger and collaborators found that the simplest construction naturally produced a parity-violating structure with room for all the leptons and quarks and nearly unique unified gauge groups, connecting string theory to real-world particle physics.

    “it very naturally results not only in a parity violating structure like the one in our world with plenty of room for all the leptons and quarks and all of that but the natural unified gauge groups were sort of the only thing that you could get.”

  • The theory of inflation, where the spectrum of CMB fluctuations and other evidence suggest emergent de Sitter symmetries in the very early universe, is an astronomical example of emergent symmetry for which there is even experimental evidence.

    “a well-known one is the theory of inflation, where the spectrum of the CMB fluctuations suggests... that the very early universe, there were emergent de Sitter symmetries and there's even experimental evidence for that.”

  • Strominger characterizes his first 15 years as top-down physics (starting from microphysical assumptions about the one known QM-GR-consistent theory and pushing down) but argues progress requires every approach—top-down has organized the bottom-up effort—and we will not even reach the next big step, let alone the final truth of nature, without using every method and turning over every stone.

    “I don't think we'll even get to the big next step without doing everything, using every approach, turning over every stone. That's our job.”

  • It often happens in physics that people who become totally immersed in a subject begin to see a beauty and inner harmony in a set of equations that outsiders cannot see; while it is easy to dismiss such people as lost in their equations, the field needs those who dive in, calculate, and get to the bones of something—as Green and Schwarz did for a decade.

    “people who get really totally a thousand percent immersed in a subject begin to see a kind of beauty and inner harmony in a set of equations that other people from the outside can't see”

  • Strominger half-jokingly claims theoretical physicists are largely 'stupid'—mostly rewriting last week's paper with different words—so even a slightly different perspective is enormously valuable, and observers are great precisely because their questions and the act of looking at an image force theorists to think about things differently.

    “if you can just think about things a little bit differently, that's huge. Just a little bit different perspective is enormous. And observers are great for asking you a question that makes you think about things differently.”

0.55

Real astrophysical black holes spin near light-speed limits and exhibit the same conformal symmetries as stringy black holes, enabling physical predictions.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • There is a speed limit on rotating black holes: the surface of the event horizon is not allowed to spin faster than the speed of light, which is essentially Einstein's speed limit, and black holes tend to spin up toward this limit when they interact with surrounding matter.

    “there's a speed limit on black holes and the speed limit is that the surface of the black hole, the so called event horizon, is not allowed to spin around faster than the speed of light. That's basically Einstein's speed limit.”

  • Real astrophysical black holes spin (Kerr black holes), and many spin very near the speed limit (the horizon cannot rotate faster than light)—Cygnus X-1 at 98-99% and GRS 1915 within about 2%—and when they approach this limit they develop exactly the same conformal symmetry used to construct the hologram for stringy black holes, enabling the Kerr/CFT correspondence to analyze them.

    “when they get very near the speed limit, as they like to do, they get exactly the same conformal symmetry that Vafa and I used to construct the hologram for the stringy black holes. And indeed, you know, Cygnus X-1, I think is 98, 99, within 1% of the speed limit.”

  • Like comparing the direct image in a mirror to the once-reflected image reveals the arrangement of the mirrors regardless of what clothes you wear, comparing successively wound photon-ring images factors out the unknown, messy details of the swirling matter and magnetic fields and yields clean information about the black hole spacetime itself—made possible by a conformal symmetry at the photon ring relating photons that wind once to those that wind twice, essentially the same symmetry as a black hole spinning at the speed limit.

    “if you look at the relationship between the direct image of the mirror and the once reflected, you can from that totally... it factors out all the uninteresting information about the clothes you're wearing... it turns out that this is all possible because of a conformal symmetry that appears at the photon ring.”

  • A black hole acts like a hall of mirrors: light can boomerang around it once, twice, or wrap around an infinite number of times, producing an infinite series of progressively finer images all converging on one place; a perfectly aimed photon orbits forever—that critical orbit is the photon ring, which the Event Horizon Telescope hopes to observe as finer images beyond the famous donut picture (which is just direct light from hot swirling matter).

    “a black hole, if you look at it, is like a hall of mirrors... a photon, if you aim it perfectly, will start to wrap around the black hole and will just keep wrapping around forever... That's the photon ring.”

0.51

String theory has no predictive power because extra dimensions curl up in countless ways, but similar failed theories later found unexpected homes.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Strominger estimates the chance that string theory is 100% right (the literal solution to reductionism needing only the right Calabi-Yau space) is essentially zero—one in a million or a billion—but the chance it is completely wrong and irrelevant is even smaller; like Yang-Mills theory, which was invented for the wrong purpose but reappeared everywhere, string theory will eventually find its place after accreting new ideas.

    “I think the chances of that... are, I don't know, one in a million, one in a billion, zero essentially. But I think that the chances of it being completely wrong and irrelevant... are even smaller.”

  • Because there are so many ways to curl up the extra dimensions, string theory has many phases and therefore no real predictive power; Strominger argued already in 1986 that string theory would not make an experimental prediction and is not the next step in the reductionist program.

    “there are so many phases of it that there's no real predictive power there... I wrote that already in 1986, a year after my paper on that, and it was not this kind of the next step in the reductionist program.”

  • Within a few months after the compactification paper, the number of people working on string theory went from dozens to roughly a thousand—a sudden surge Strominger has not seen matched anywhere else in his career.

    “within a few months after our paper, the number of people working on string theory went from dozens to a thousand or something like that. I haven't seen anything else like that in my career”

0.48

The photon ring, not the event horizon, is likely the actual holographic plate of real black holes, motivated by string theory but testable independently.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Strominger advances the hypothesis—motivated by string-theory thinking and currently lacking a mathematical proof—that the photon ring, not the event horizon, is actually the holographic plate of a real black hole; the strongest current evidence is simply looking at the image, where the circle around merging black holes in LIGO simulations appears to declare itself the holographic plate.

    “the hypothesis is on the table, that the photon ring is actually the holographic plate and the best evidence for that hypothesis is just looking at the image.”

  • The photon-ring and black-hole entropy results do not require string theory and make no different prediction than classical general relativity; rather, string theory provided the conceptual route through a seeming paradox—revealing that a path exists where previously the general relativity and particle physics viewpoints seemed irreconcilable—and the goal is to reproduce that route assuming only quantum mechanics and general relativity, taking the meat off the string-theory bones.

    “We're not even using string theory... the argument that they're irreconcilable had a series of loopholes which string theory brilliantly snaked its way through. So now we know that there's a route through that seeming paradox”

0.34

De Sitter space's lack of spatial boundary creates a deep conceptual puzzle for holography that negative-curvature holography does not face.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Of the three possible curvatures—negative (anti-de Sitter), zero (flat), and positive (de Sitter)—the one we understand best via holography (negative curvature) is the furthest from observable physical reality, since the real world is approximately flat and in the far future expected to be positively curved de Sitter space, making it surprisingly difficult to generalize holography to realistic contexts.

    “So of the three possibilities, negative curvature, zero curvature and positive curvature, the one that we've understood is the furthest from observable physical reality.”

  • Unlike anti-de Sitter space which has a convenient spatial boundary (like the can around soup), de Sitter space has no spatial boundary—if you move off in space you come back to where you started—and its only boundary is in time at the infinite future, which creates a deep conceptual puzzle: the holographic plate must contain all the time-information of the hologram, yet the boundary has no time.

    “de Sitter space, if you fix a moment of time and start moving off in space, eventually you'll come back right to where you are. It doesn't have a boundary in space. It has a boundary in time at the infinite future.”