219 | Dani Bassett and Perry Zurn on the Neuroscience and Philosophy of Curiosity
What this covers
Dani Bassett, a neuroscientist, and Perry Zurn, a philosopher and Bassett's twin, discuss how to understand curiosity through network science and social critique. Sean Carroll moderates a conversation that moves between the mechanics of how knowledge structures form in the brain and the politics of which curiosities societies permit or suppress. The core argument reframes curiosity as fundamentally an act of connection-making—building, breaking, and reshaping networks of ideas—rather than accumulating isolated facts. This framing draws on Knowledge as Network, where information gains affordance and power through its links to other pieces of information.
The conversation distinguishes three styles of curiosity—Busybody, Hunter, Dancer—each defining itself by the pattern of connections it makes: the busybody connects loosely across many topics; the hunter digs into tight, local networks around a specific focus; the dancer makes creative leaps between distant ideas. Bassett connects this to neural flexibility and Cognitive Flexibility, showing how the brain's capacity to rewire which units communicate with each other correlates with learning. Zurn shifts the frame to power: societies actively police curiosity through policy and funding, deciding which questions are legitimate and which are dismissed, while certain academic traditions valorize the hunter style over others. The pair argue that Curiosity Needs Companions—an ethics of treating subjects as subjects rather than objects—to guard against destructive formations like spectacle-erasure, where something is celebrated while its context is erased. Examples range from Robin Wall Kimmerer having her botanical curiosity dismissed, to how book bans reflect rigid knowledge networks unable to accommodate new voices.
Zurn and Bassett argue that curiosity is fundamentally connectional rather than acquisitional—the act of building, breaking, and reshaping networks of knowledge—and that it comes in distinct styles (busybody, hunter, dancer) that are shaped by, and can reshape, social and political structures.
- Knowledge is a network of interconnections, so curiosity should be understood as making and breaking connections rather than collecting isolated facts.
- Curiosity manifests in at least three styles—busybody, hunter, dancer—each making different kinds of network connections.
- Social and political structures police and valorize certain curiosities, so curiosity must be paired with companion values like an ethics of subjectivity.
Curiosity is a network-linking act that becomes problematic only in particular formations that objectify or exclude.
- Curiosity itself is the act of linking and is not inherently good or bad, but particular formations or shapes of curiosity can be problematic—such as a colonial curiosity that objectifies and fetishizes the difference of others while alienating them.
“the kind of curiosity that drove a colonial approach to knowledge in which one can come in from the outside, one can assess how people live or how people move and just take that objectively and in some cases fetishize that difference. That's a problematic curiosity.”
- A troubling formation of curiosity is the spectacle-erasure approach, in which one celebrates or lifts up a person, object, or culture as an interesting curio while simultaneously erasing its meaning and context—treating a subject as an object of curiosity rather than as a subject.
“This approach to people or subjects where you spectacularize, you celebrate or lift up in some way... But even in that lifting up, you're essentially erasing the meaning and the context of that object or that person or that culture.”
- A pro-curiosity attitude alone is insufficient to distinguish worthwhile inquiry from discredited or harmful inquiry; curiosity needs companions—it must be accompanied by other values and investments that guide our inquiries, including an ethics that respects the subjectivity of those we are curious about rather than objectifying them.
“curiosity needs companions... It needs to be alongside of other values and investments that guide our inquiries together.”
- Rationality does not escape the problems attributed to empathy or subjectivity, because rationality only logically processes given assumptions and information; if that information is biased or the relationships between data were constructed in a biased way, one can reason flawlessly across the network and still reach a bad conclusion.
“Rationality is simply, if I have a number of assumptions and a set of information, I can make sense of that logically from the beginning to the end, but maybe the information that you have is biased... you can be as rational as you want on walking that network and can still be making a bad move”
Knowledge systems are actively policed and passively shaped to suppress curiosity about marginalized histories and exclude diverse ways of thinking.
- Book banning can be understood as a knowledge network getting stuck and unable to flexibly respond to how knowledge is changing—particularly in response to marginalized groups gaining a foothold and voice.
“part of the book banning process is a network getting stuck and unable to flexibly respond to how knowledge is changing and is changing often in response to marginalized groups of folks who are gaining some foothold and voice”
- Society both passively shapes the knowledge networks we imbibe by being raised in a particular family, location, and culture, and actively polices curiosity through policy-level fights (such as suspending critical race theory teaching, resisting LGBT history in schools) and funding structures that support or fail to support certain questions, so that being curious about marginalized or peripheral topics is discouraged rather than celebrated.
“the work to suspend critical race theory or learning racial histories of the US. The very, very long fights to try to get LGBT history into K through 12 schools. These are policy level arguments about what people should and shouldn't know or should and shouldn't be curious about.”
- Rather than treating all curiosity equally, one should commit to supporting curiosities that create space for more diverse ways of thinking, especially in response to histories that have excluded particular knowledges and lives—such as the enslavement of African people, the genocide of indigenous people, and the criminalization of LGBT life in the US.
“we're committed to thinking about supporting curiosities that create more support for more diverse ways of thinking about the world, especially in response to histories that have excluded those knowledges.”
Curiosity manifests in three distinct styles—busybody, hunter, and dancer—each equally valid and all deployed together in successful social movements.
- Curiosity manifests in at least three distinct styles defined by how they connect knowledge: the busybody connects loosely across many topics, the hunter makes tighter, more local connections focused on something specific, and the dancer makes creative and imaginative connections—and these styles are both accessible to anyone and tend to characterize individuals' personalities.
“The busy body connects things quite loosely, is interested in all sorts of things. The hunter focuses more on something specific and makes tighter connections, more local connections. And then the dancer is someone who is more creative and imaginative in the connections they make”
- Contrary to the view that resistors arrive already knowing the answers, social justice movements engage all three curiosity styles: busybody-style broad data-gathering about a problem (e.g., civil rights data on segregation in housing, education, employment), hunter-style narrowing to specific policies and people, and dancer-style imaginative envisioning of the world they want to create (e.g., MLK's 'I Have a Dream').
“much of the early work of the civil rights movement involved gathering data about segregation... that's busy budding in a sense is broad investigation. But then it moves to saying... here are the specific policies that need to be changed... And that's the dancer move.”
- In the Western intellectual tradition curiosity was long dismissed as selfish and proud (a self-directed interest that ignored what God might want one to know) in favor of wonder, which was prized for its reverence; but with the rise of early modern science the two reversed, with wonder becoming associated with simple thoughts and curiosity becoming the prized, erudite approach to knowledge.
“there's a really interesting moment where early modern science starts, where the two of them flip and wonder becomes the thing that's less supported because it's associated with simple thoughts... which would require curiosity.”
- The current academic preference for hunter-style curiosity reflects a particular academic and largely Western culture's values rather than any built-in necessity; other academic cultures function differently and value, for example, storytelling-based approaches that would lift up the busybody style.
“the current academic preference for hunting is reflective of a particular academic culture, but also a larger sort of, especially Western culture. And I do think there are other academic enclaves in other parts of the world that do function differently”
Polarization breeds defensive resistance to reassessing knowledge, whereas flexibility and aporia enable growth and coherent political society.
- In an increasingly polarized world there is a tendency to resist reassessing what we know out of defensiveness and an insistence that one already knows and is on the right side, which limits both our ability to build a coherent political society and our capacity to grow as knowers.
“there's such a defensiveness and an insistence that I already know. And I'm on the right side of things. And I think that limits not only, obviously, our ability to get along with one another”
- Socrates was famous not for answers but for questions that undid connections and created bigger gaps, aiming to bring people into aporia—a state of not knowing where one stands—which functioned to reignite flexibility by loosening knowledge network structures.
“He was famous for his questions, which precisely undid the connections and made bigger and bigger and bigger gaps. He said his goal was to bring all of us into aporia”
- Political resistance movements work by breaking specific learned connections—for example the civil rights movement targeted associations of whiteness with power, privilege, greater education, intelligence, and capacity to lead—demonstrating intentional breaking of network connections in practice.
“Those associations of whiteness with power, with privilege, with greater education, greater intelligence, greater capacity to lead, et cetera... So I think any political resistance movement is doing that specific breaking of connections.”