20 | Scott Derrickson on Cinema, Blockbusters, Horror, and Mystery
What this covers
Scott Derrickson, director of Marvel's Doctor Strange and the horror films Sinister and The Exorcism of Emily Rose, sits down with physicist Sean Carroll to discuss filmmaking, science, and worldview. The conversation uses Doctor Strange as a detailed case study—from pitch through post-production—to examine how a major blockbuster reaches the screen. But the larger argument concerns what makes cinema work and what it demands of those who make it. Derrickson contends that cinema succeeds by keeping the human emotional story at its center, no matter the scale of technical spectacle, and that both filmmaking and science require the same discipline: ruthless self-criticism, acknowledged constraints, and respect for what remains genuinely mysterious.
The discussion ranges across several distinct territories. On the craft side, Derrickson walks through practical decisions—why Benedict Cumberbatch's central role demanded a fall release over summer, how to assemble a first cut quickly to learn what works, and why compressed schedules actually raise creative standards. On theory, he develops the argument that movie genres map onto basic human emotions—Genres as Emotional Categories—and unpacks why horror is inherently philosophical terrain. The conversation turns to broader worldview questions when Carroll, a naturalist, and Derrickson, a Christian, debate whether both science and religion claim too much certainty. Derrickson argues for Epistemic Humility across both domains, and contends that Mystery as Excess Meaning—not meaninglessness—should drive inquiry. He also makes the contentious claim that an artist's core Worldview Determines Art: that his own immaterial beliefs shape which films he can authentically make.
Derrickson argues that cinema is the supreme art form because it emotionally amalgamates all other arts into a dreamlike immersive experience, and that great filmmaking—like science—demands ruthless self-criticism, disciplined constraint, and a respect for mystery as 'more meaning than we can yet comprehend' rather than meaninglessness.
- Blockbuster filmmaking succeeds or fails on keeping the human emotional story central amid technical spectacle
- Movie genres map directly onto basic human emotions (fear=horror, laughter=comedy, etc.)
- Both science and religion err by claiming to understand more than they do; mystery should drive a quest for deeper understanding
The director is the ultimate keeper of vision, responsible for holding the entire film together despite massive delegation.
- On a film this size the director is the captain of the ship: everything goes through them, all department heads come to them for direction, there is enormous delegation, but the director is ultimately the only person responsible for holding the entire vision together in their head.
“You're the captain of the ship. And so everything goes through you... you ultimately are responsible as being the only person who's holding it all together in your head.”
- Big Hollywood blockbusters often fail because, although they worked in the script phase, the human emotional story stops remaining central during the demanding production; Derrickson countered this by creating a document for every shooting day listing the central emotional narrative points so he would not lose sight of them amid practical concerns.
“that for some reason that human emotional story was not remaining central during the production because the production was so demanding”
- Marvel head Kevin Feige is not just a studio head but is very hands-on, working closely with the director without a lot of middlemen, which is why directors effectively make the movie with him.
“Kevin Feige, who runs Marvel, you really make the movie with him. He's not just a studio head. He is very hands on. He's really in there with you without a lot of middle men.”
- Once a clear basic vision is communicated, the director's best process is to encourage collaborators—department heads, visual effects artists—to bring ideas better than the director's own and to become co-creators, which good people reliably do, while the director still filters them against the core vision.
“My whole process for sure is encourage them to bring me better ideas than mine. And then they always do, when they're good.”
- Derrickson defined the target of Doctor Strange to all department heads as a mind-bending, psychotropic mind-trip action movie about a single personality—one man overcoming himself and getting past his own selfishness—and read this one-line definition at the top of his script each shooting day to stay anchored.
“This is a mind bending, mind trip, action movie about a sole personality about one guy overcoming himself, getting past his own selfishness.”
A film's emotional power rests on the lead character and performance; everything else is secondary to that core.
- A movie cannot be better than its lead character's story and performance—if the lead's character and performance are not emotionally satisfying the movie is not good, no matter how great everything else is; conversely, if the lead is satisfying, many other things can fail and the movie will still work.
“A movie cannot be better than your lead character's story and performance, can't, it's impossible, it doesn't matter how great everything else is.”
- Because Doctor Strange would venture into fantastical terrain, Derrickson deliberately wanted realistic rather than over-the-top, cartoony performances to distinguish it from other MCU films, which is why serious Oscar-caliber actors were cast in dramatic roles.
“because we were gonna be venturing out into such fantastical terrain, I actually wanted the performances to be very realistic. So that was part of the casting process, which is why we got such serious actors”
- Moving Doctor Strange's release from summer to fall was a huge deal because the fall is simply not as lucrative, so they likely sacrificed opening-day money—but it was necessary because the movie was so centered around Benedict Cumberbatch.
“It's a huge deal because the fall is not as lucrative. It's just not. And so, we probably could have made even more money in terms of opening day”
Filmmaking requires constant self-criticism, rapid testing, and willingness to accept that first ideas rarely work.
- Filmmaking is like baking a recipe for the first time: you can make every hard choice and visualize a perfect film, but once the ingredients go in the oven you cannot fully predict what comes out—it will surprise you, often working in ways you didn't expect and failing where you assumed it would work.
“film making is a bit like baking, where if you're a chef... film making is like creating a recipe for the first time and you know so many things about how it's gonna work, but then it goes into the oven and what comes out is what's gonna come out.”
- Many big blockbuster movies are not great because the filmmakers have enough money to afford their first idea, and your first idea is rarely your best idea; reaching the best version requires conscious discipline to generate ideas and then be harshly self-critical of them.
“I think one of the main reasons why so many big blockbuster movies are not great is because you have enough money to afford your first idea.”
- Getting to the best version, the truth, or an ideal of something—whether in filmmaking or science—is impossible without admitting all your shortcomings, failures, and the things that don't actually work; constant criticism by everyone is uncomfortable but necessary.
“if you want to get to the best version of something or to the truth of something or to an ideal of some kind, you're not going to get there without admitting to all your shortcomings and all your failures and all the things that actually don't work”
- You must assemble the first cut (still full of green screen) and get it in front of small groups of people quickly, because you will learn very soon and painfully—like it or not—what works and what doesn't, which then drives the reshoot plan.
“what you really need to do is get it together, and get it in front of people quickly... And you will learn very soon and painfully... What doesn't work. And what does work.”
An artist's core worldview fundamentally determines what kinds of films they can authentically make.
- An artist's core worldview fully determines the work they can make: Derrickson's core belief system is born of a lifelong experience of the world as more than material, and he claims that if he converted to naturalism tomorrow he could no longer make any of the films he has made—he could only make movies about the shock of having that immaterial worldview's rug pulled out after five decades.
“it would be completely different, because they would be made from a completely different human experience... my core belief system is born of my experience.”
- Both science and religion have been and continue to be guilty of propagating the idea that we understand far more than we really do—in different ways—broadcasting to their constituents a false sensibility that 'we've got the world figured out,' when a disciplined humility requires not thinking we understand more than we actually do.
“I think both science and religion have been guilty, and have continued to be guilty, of propagating the idea that we understand a lot more than we really understand”
Compressed schedules and constraints raise creative quality by fighting the enemy of boundless resources.
- Compressed production schedules and limitations raise everyone's game; as Orson Welles said, 'the absence of boundaries is the enemy of art,' so a measure of pressure and limitation is necessary to facilitate the highest measure of creativity.
“It was Orson Welles who said, "The absence of boundaries is the enemy of art". And I really believe that's true, which you need, I think, a measure of pressure and limitation in order to facilitate the highest measure of creativity.”
- For a movie the size of Doctor Strange, the process from original pitch to opening night usually takes about two years, with a six-to-nine month script-writing period before hard pre-production even begins and continuous rewriting through prep and production.
“For a movie that size, from the original pitch to opening night is probably, usually about two years”
- To meet a compressed four-month post-production schedule (versus the typical six or seven months), Derrickson's visual effects team hired multiple big effects houses to all start work at the same time, contrary to the usual practice of relying heavily on a single house.
“they hired multiple houses, big houses, to all start work at the same time, which you usually don't really do. You usually rely heavily on a single house, a single visual effects house.”
- Derrickson spent $42,000 of his own money on the presentation for his eighth and final pitch meeting to win the Doctor Strange job, and Marvel bought the presentation outright when they hired him because they needed to own the material.
“I spent $42,000 of my own money on a presentation. Which was the eighth of eight meetings.”
- Despite safety concerns after the major earthquake had destroyed some chosen sets, the team decided to shoot in Kathmandu because Benedict Cumberbatch argued it was a moral good—Nepal depends heavily on tourism, which vanished after the earthquake—and that the place needed to be represented.
“Benedict to his credit sort of led the charge in saying that we have to shoot here now... it's a third world country, and tourism is one of the primary sources of income, and tourism just vanished after that earthquake.”
- Kubrick reportedly held that only bad books make good movies, which Derrickson suggests is part of why Kubrick's relationships with the authors he adapted were touchy.
“he said, "Only bad movies make... Only bad books make good movies."”
- Most directors prefer editing and post-production to other phases because it is another phase of writing where all the work comes together and is highly creative, whereas production is grueling and the worst phase due to its extraordinary physical demands.
“All post production is so much fun... It's another phase of writing, you're still getting to write the movie, and it's as creative as writing... but production is the worst. Production is just grueling.”
- Because Thor had successfully grounded its god-figure with a science-flavored framing, Marvel recognized that with Doctor Strange it was okay to let magic be magic; trying to scientifically validate the mysticism of Doctor Strange would be uninteresting and a disrespect to the comics.
“as much as I love and respect science, I don't think that an approach of trying to scientifically validate the mysticism of Doctor Strange would be interesting to me, and it would feel like a disrespect to the comics”
- Marvel's short pitch document on what should and shouldn't be a Doctor Strange movie lined up perfectly with Derrickson's own view—valuing the comics' deep ideas and philosophical overtones, downplaying Lovecraftian monsters early, and seeking to open the cinematic universe into a literal multiverse of other dimensions—which convinced him he was the right director.
“They really liked the deep ideas and the philosophical overtones of the Doctor Strange comics... they were looking for a way to open up the MCU... to a multiverse, where you're actually dealing, literally, with other dimensions”
- Possession and exorcism are an anthropological fact existing in all cultures throughout history: people enter crazy mindsets with predictable patterns, and every culture develops a shock-therapy ritual that is often effective; the starting fascination is thus anthropological rather than theological, and the more extreme legitimate cases involve at least a mysterious trance-state of the human mind.
“possession and exorcism is a fact, it's an anthropological reality that exists in all cultures and always have. People get into these crazy mindsets and start doing these things with certain predictable patterns and then there's this kind of shock therapy ritual that every culture has developed that is often very effective.”
- After regretting an early-career decision to take a big studio movie just because it was offered, Derrickson adopted the belief that one should make every movie as though it is one's last, because one day it will be and you never know when.
“I've always operated under the belief that I should make every movie as though it's my last movie. Because one day it will be.”
- Mystery should be understood not as the presence of something meaningless but as the presence of more meaning than we can yet comprehend; the point of evolving as a species and individual is to get deeper into that mystery, so acknowledging 'it's a mystery, we'll never know' is a failure rather than a virtue.
“the concept of mystery is not the presence of something meaningless, but the presence of more meaning than we can yet comprehend”
- Navigating Hollywood and sustaining a directing career depends heavily on the ability to sell—you are always selling an idea, a script, a pitch, yourself to crew, studios, and in marketing—and Hollywood success generally requires at least two of three things: incredible luck, unparalleled raw genius, or an ability to sell.
“I think so much of Hollywood success demands either incredible luck, just unparalleled raw genius or an ability to sell.”
- Major scientific revelations are typically non-intuitive—relativity is profoundly counterintuitive and quantum mechanics far more so—and the difficulty of even conceptualizing them feeds the broader human experience that reality holds great mysteries still capable of surprising and frightening us.
“these sort of big revelations in science are typically non-intuitive... relativity, I mean, what could be more non-intuitive than relativity?”
- There is no such thing as a horror 'type': people's tolerance for horror is unpredictable—brave 9/11 first responders may refuse to watch any horror, while a sweet little old lady in a flower shop may love every Nightmare on Elm Street film.
“there is no such thing as a horror type. It's like you... I've met some of the bravest cops in New York City, who are terrified to watch a horror movie”
Cinema is the supreme art form because it fuses photography, literature, theater, and music into overwhelming emotional experience.
- Cinema can make us more human by letting us powerfully feel another person's experience of the world even when it conflicts with our own beliefs—Derrickson, though never holding Bergman's godless worldview, experiences Bergman's sense of being alone and unsafe in a silent universe through his films, relating to the truth-quality in it.
“I experience his experience of the world through those movies so powerfully... I am made more human for having felt it and for having understood it, and having related to the truth quality in it, because even though I have a system of belief that is different than that, I know what it's like to feel alone in the world.”
- Cinema is the greatest art form precisely because it is the amalgam of photography, literature, theater, and music; when these combine into a pure experience the emotional power becomes overwhelming, producing a dreamlike, holistically emotional experience that speaks to the subconscious in a way no single other art form does, making the whole greater than the sum of its parts.
“I just think that it's the greatest art form, and it's only because it's the amalgam of all the other great art forms. It's the amalgam of photography, and literature, and theater, and music.”
- Kurosawa is an ideal entry point into international cinema because he merged the entertainment value of Hollywood movies with the artfulness of European cinema of his time—being as much a fan of John Ford as of Ingmar Bergman—producing films that are high art and high entertainment simultaneously, a combination few directors ever achieve.
“he took, I think, the sensibility of Hollywood movies, the entertainment value of Hollywood movies, and merged it with the artfulness of European movies of his time.”
Making audiences feel awe at the unrelatable requires grounding it in tactile, relatable physical materials.
- To make an audience feel awe at something unrelatable like magic, every physical material on screen should feel tactile and relatable to human experience; using unrelatable visuals to communicate something unrelatable fails, so magic effects in Doctor Strange were designed to look like familiar materials such as sparks and fire.
“the best way to get the audience to feel a sense of awe is if you're showing them something unrelatable but everything that's actually in the frame has a physical relatability to their experience”
- In the CGI-ready age it is too easy to just make amorphous effects do all the work, which connects to the principle that the first, easiest idea is rarely the best; resisting this required constantly rejecting effects that looked unreal even when nothing like them had been done before.
“in this CGI ready age it's maybe too easy to just make some amorphous lightning bolts do all the work”
- Digital photography is now the industry standard, but daylight exteriors—sunlight on faces or the sky itself—still look enormously better on actual film than on digital, to the point that digital daylight exteriors pull the viewer out of a movie; under cloud cover, however, the difference between film and digital is negligible.
“I've yet to see still daylight exteriors look great on digital, I just think daylight exteriors have a quality, even the best work that I've seen still has a quality that pales so to film.”
Genre categories exist because they reliably trigger specific human emotions audiences seek out.
- The major movie categories were created by audiences and correspond to the major categories of human emotion: horror for fear, comedy for laughter and joy, drama for sorrow and deeper feeling, action for visceral excitement, thriller for anxiety, and science fiction for wonderment usually combined with another genre.
“when I realized this is what they really are, is they're the major categories of human emotion. Fear for horror, comedy for laughter, joy, drama for sorrow for deeper feelings.”
- People seek out horror for the same reason they ride roller coasters: to experience the visceral power of fear—arguably the most powerful human emotion—in an environment where they know they are safe, getting the adrenaline rush without the actual danger.
“they like it for the same reason they like roller coasters, it's the powerful feeling of fear, which I think is arguably the most powerful human emotion. And to feel... To experience the visceral power of that emotion in environment where you know you're safe.”
Horror is inherently philosophical and inescapably engages with questions of good and evil.
- Horror is inherently philosophical and it is very difficult to make an amoral or non-moral horror film—even a movie that seems to have no moral center thereby makes a moral point—because dealing in horror lands you in inescapably philosophical terrain about good and evil in a way other genres do not.
“it's very difficult to make an amoral horror film or a non-moral horror film... even if it seems to have no moral center that becomes a moral point.”
- Horror in the 1970s and 80s was largely thought of as just slasher movies, with exceptions made by non-horror masters like Kubrick (The Shining) or Friedkin (The Exorcist), but the genre has since gained substantial respect for how it comments on the human experience.
“horror in the 80s, in the 70s and 80s, was just slasher movies... but I think that now it's a genre that has gained a lot of respect for how it comments on the human experience.”
Effective directing requires recognizing that each actor needs different communication based on their individual temperament.
- Effective directing, like sales, requires recognizing that you cannot communicate with every actor the same way—actors are powerfully emotional people who each need to be spoken to differently depending on who they are—so the director's job is to figure out who they are and how they need to be communicated with.
“in sales, you come to understand you can't talk to every customer the same way... actors or the same way, they're all powerfully emotional people, but they all need to be spoken to in different ways depending on who they are”