194 | Frans de Waal on Culture and Gender in Primates
What this covers
Frans de Waal, a leading primatologist and ethologist at Emory University, discusses how gender, culture, empathy, and morality exist on a continuum across primate species rather than as uniquely human traits. Recorded as part of Sean Carroll's Mindscape podcast in 2022, the conversation draws on de Waal's long career studying cognition and behavior in chimpanzees, bonobos, and other species. Rather than reiterating fixed boundaries between animals and humans, de Waal argues that many capacities we regard as distinctly our own—fairness norms, altruism, even gender identity—have evolutionary roots visible in our closest relatives, and that examining primates as a mirror offers essential reality checks against the flattering but false stories psychology tells about human nature.
The episode covers several concrete domains where primate behavior challenges common assumptions. It traces how self-socialization produces gendered behavior independent of biology, how fairness mechanisms underpin cooperation in both primate groups and human societies, and how bonobos—with their non-territorial peacefulness and fluid sexuality—diverge dramatically from the competitive male-dominated model often treated as the primate norm. De Waal distinguishes sex from gender, documents targeted helping and genuine altruism across species, and argues that primates show no intolerance of homosexual or gender-nonconforming individuals because they lack the symbolic labeling systems humans use to police difference. He also challenges the notion that larger size or physical strength automatically translate to power, drawing on decades of field observation to show how coalition-building, reputation, and theory of mind reshape hierarchies in ways the dominance-hierarchy stereotype misses.
De Waal argues that gender, culture, empathy, and morality are not uniquely human but exist on a continuum across primates, and that the rigid nature/nurture and human/animal dichotomies obscure rather than illuminate our understanding of ourselves.
- Primates exhibit self-socialization along gender lines, showing gender (not just biological sex) operates in non-human species
- Empathy, fairness, cooperation, and altruism have evolutionary building blocks visible across mammals
- Primates display gender diversity without the human tendency to label, pigeonhole, and police nonconformity
Empathy and fairness evolved as cooperative mechanisms and remain foundational to primate and human social life.
- Mammalian empathy evolved to serve one's inner circle and family but, once it exists, can be applied outside that circle—as when dolphins help human swimmers against sharks—just as color vision evolved to pick ripe fruit but is now used to read maps or match clothes; capacities arise for a specific purpose but can be used for any purpose, which is true throughout biology.
“Mammalian empathy evolved to serve your own inner circle... but once it exists, it can be applied outside of that little circle... these empathy tendencies in the dolphin clearly did not evolve to help human swimmers, but once that situation arises, it can be used there.”
- In the cucumber-and-grape experiment, capuchin monkeys will perform a task 25 times for cucumber slices, but if a partner gets grapes (a better reward) for the same task, the cucumber-receiving monkey becomes upset and refuses to continue—an apparently irrational response that makes sense from the perspective of a cooperative primate needing to monitor relative rewards.
“if you give cucumber slices to both monkeys, they will do it 25 times in a row... But if the other one is getting grapes, then the one who gets cucumber gets very upset and doesn't wanna do it any more. Throws out the cucumber.”
- Strong fairness norms operate in small-scale societies like hunter-gatherers but are lost in our massive multi-million-person societies because anonymous relationships allow people to get away with unfair behavior that would be remembered and punished in face-to-face primate or small human groups.
“Unfortunately, it's lost in our massive, multi-million people societies nowadays, it's a bit lost. And it's because we have anonymous relationships where people can get away with these things.”
- Primates exhibit genuine altruism with no possibility of return, such as chimpanzees rescuing each other from drowning at great personal risk, or young females bringing water and helping a dying old female who could never repay them, refuting the cynical view that animals cannot be truly kind.
“each time she went to the water faucet to drink... younger females would run ahead of her to the water faucet and suck up a lot of water and then run back to her and spit it into her mouth... this old female clearly could not return any favors... there is altruistic behavior that is not between kin and that is not gonna be repaid.”
- A sense of fairness exists because cooperative societies require sharing at the end; without equity, cooperation falls apart, which is a lesson for human society—when billionaires take all the money, it undermines cooperativeness and creates revolution-level tensions.
“if you have a cooperative society, you need to share at the end. If you don't, that whole cooperation's gonna fall apart. And that's an important lesson, I would say, for human society as well. If you don't have equity in human society, if there are some guys who take everything, like we now have, some billionaires who take all the money, that's gonna undermine the cooperative-ness of the society”
- Empathy is found in almost all primates and likely all mammals, originating from parental (mostly maternal) care and regulated by oxytocin, which explains why empathy is generally more developed in females; it is more widespread in social species than in solitary ones because social living requires extending empathy beyond the mother-offspring bond.
“I think empathy is a general mammalian characteristic that I think probably came out of parental care, which in mammals is mostly maternal care, which also explains why empathy is more developed in the female than the male in general, is regulated by oxytocin, which is by origin the sort of maternal hormone.”
Female primates achieve and wield power through coalition-building and social bonds rather than physical dominance.
- Although male bonobos are individually bigger and stronger, females achieve collective dominance over males by forming strong ties through sex, grooming, and food sharing, which serves a protective purpose against male harassment and infanticide.
“the female dominance is a collective dominance, and it serves a purpose because males can be harassing females, and males sometimes kill infants in some species like in the chimpanzee. And so the female dominance of males has a protective purpose”
- Power should be distinguished from physical dominance: the alpha female chimpanzee Mama ranked below the males physically yet held more power and influence than most of them for 40 years, controlling the female coalition whose support determined which male became alpha—so the claim that the natural order is males dominating females is questionable.
“I always make this distinction between physical dominance and power... Mama the alpha female chimpanzee... she had more power than most of the males, even though she ranked below physically... when people say the natural order is males dominate females, I would say, well, that's questionable”
Sex and sexuality in primates function as social tools for bonding rather than merely reproductive acts.
- Bonobo sexual interactions are brief (15 seconds is long) and function as social tools like handshakes rather than primarily for reproduction, since they occur between same-sex members, in pregnant females, and in situations where reproduction is impossible.
“their sexual interactions are brief, like 15 seconds is a long time. So they're brief, you better look at them as sort of handshakes or patting someone on the shoulder, but then using the genitals.”
- A recent study measuring oxytocin from urine after sexual interactions found that female bonobos are emotionally more affected by sex with females than with males and probably derive more satisfaction from it, supporting the social-bonding function of their large clitoris.
“they also measured oxytocin after the fact from urine collection. And they found that females are actually emotionally more affected by sex with females than with males”
- All mammals have a clitoris—including mice and elephants—but the biggest relative to species is found in dolphins and bonobos, which is connected to the important social role sex plays in those species.
“all mammals have a clitoris people sometimes forget that. And the mouse has a clitoris, the elephant has a clitoris, but the biggest clitoris we find in the dolphin and the bonobo.”
- Unlike chimpanzees, who show only varying degrees of hostility between groups, bonobos are not territorial and engage in peaceful intergroup mingling—having sex, sharing food, sitting together, and even adopting orphans from other groups.
“bonobos, even though they're very close to chimps in many ways, they are not territorial... very soon they mingle, very soon they have sex with each other... there's now even observations of females of one group adopting orphans from another group... whereas chimpanzees only have different degrees of hostility.”
Gender is a flexible spectrum in primates, with sexual and gender diversity more prevalent than researchers have documented.
- Sex-typical behavior in primates arises substantially through self-socialization, where young individuals copy same-sex models—daughters imitate mothers' diet and behavior while sons watch and copy adult males—rather than through active parental teaching, meaning the gender concept applies to non-human primates and sex differences are not purely biological.
“young daughters, they copy the behavior of their moms more faithfully than young sons, and so there is this picking up of the model of your own sex, so to speak. And that enhances of course, sex typical behavior, and that means also that the gender concept is probably applicable to other primates”
- Unlike humans, primates show no intolerance of gender-nonconforming or homosexual individuals; because they are not a symbolic, label-applying species, they only ostracize troublemakers who disturb the peace, not those who simply differ in sexual or gender behavior, suggesting humans could learn tolerance from them.
“they don't have that tendency, the human tendency to label and to pigeonhole everyone. So we are a symbolic species, we like to paste a label on everybody... and if you don't fit, there are some people who just can't stand it and go against that, and that's not a problem that the primates have”
- There is likely much more sexual and gender diversity in primates than realized, because researchers have not looked for it and because many scientists are shy about sex—preferring to discuss violence over sex—which is also why the bonobo has been overlooked; once researchers look, more homosexual behavior and diversity will be found.
“A lot of scientists like to talk a lot more about violence than about sex and that's also why the bonobo is often overlooked because it makes many scientists uncomfortable to talk about their sexual activities. But once we start looking for it, I think we will find quite a bit of diversity”
- In primates as in humans, gender is divided into masculine, feminine, and everything in between as a flexible spectrum, whereas sex is about 99% binary; gender-nonconforming individuals like the chimpanzee Donna, who behaved like a male from a young age, demonstrate this diversity exists in other primates.
“gender, we usually divide not in male and female, but in masculine and feminine, and everything in between... gender is a much more flexible concept than sex... sex is 99% binary, and I would never call gender binary. Gender is more a spectrum.”
Behavior always results from nature-nurture interaction and cannot be meaningfully separated into genetic or environmental percentages.
- Animal neuroscience is moving from invasive methods (removing brain parts to see behavioral effects, which de Waal likens to removing an engine part to see how a car drives) toward training dogs and monkeys to sit still in scanners for non-invasive neuroimaging, which is preferable and will become more feasible as equipment shrinks.
“I always compare that as removing the part of the engine of my car and see how it still drives after that, which I think is not gonna tell me very much... I think we need to move to a non-invasive neuroscience like neuro-imaging on animals and that's gonna happen.”
- Cheating and free-riding are kept in check not by punishment but by partner choice: in an experiment where chimps could cooperate or compete, the group became nearly 100% cooperative because individuals refused to work with known cheaters, who learned that others disappeared when they approached the apparatus—so the system itself undermines cheating.
“the chimps became almost 100% cooperative and only a few percent competitive. And that is because individuals didn't wanna work with these competitive individuals... So yes, you have cheating, but it's not encouraged by the system... It's undermined by the system of partner choice.”
- Female chimpanzees and bonobos lack menopause and keep reproducing into very old age, often still carrying youngsters; humans uniquely have menopause, theorized to exist because grandmothers serve an important function supporting their daughters' children—de Waal considers menopause a great advance for human society.
“for females, they don't have menopause... There are theories about it that we have menopause because of grandmothers with having an important function supporting their daughters with their kids... I think menopause was a great advance for our society.”
- While empathy is a central building block of morality and present in animals, de Waal does not call chimpanzees or bonobos moral beings because human morality additionally requires reasoning about moral rules, consensus building, enforcement, guilt feelings, and justification—though the building blocks were not designed from scratch by humans.
“there's more to human morality than just empathy... because there's also reasoning about moral rules, there is consensus building about moral rules, that is the enforcement or the guilt feelings, the justification of moral rules... but still, some of the building blocks of human morality can be found in other species, it's not like we designed it from scratch.”
- We should resist both setting ourselves apart from animals and the simplification that human behavior is cultural while animal behavior is instinctive; psychology in particular is obsessed with self-flattering stories (such as that women have no hierarchies) that are nonsense, so studying primates as a mirror gives us a reality check and a better understanding of ourselves.
“psychology is very much obsessed with the stories that they tell themselves... they tell themselves that humans are not very hierarchical... We tell stories about ourselves, which I think are nonsense... the primates provide a mirror, then we look at that mirror and we get a little bit better understanding of ourselves.”
- Skinnerian behaviorists have spent 25 years trying to explain animal cognition through associative learning and conditioning, but have become less successful as cognitive experiments are designed to rule out conditioning; their field now mostly counters new ideas rather than generating them, and the younger generation no longer takes that program seriously.
“their whole field now consists mostly of countering ideas instead of generating new ideas... They're in the business of shooting down explanations that the cognitive scientists come up with... it's largely unsuccessful. They're not taken so seriously anymore.”
- An interactionist view holds that behavior is always both nature and nurture interacting and is virtually impossible to disentangle, so claims like 'this trait is 90% genetic' are misguided because there is no meaningful percentage—it is always an interaction with something else.
“I'm an interactionist, I think, it's always both. It's always a little bit nature and a little bit nurture, and it's very hard to disentangle them.”
Primate cognition includes genuine altruism, perspective-taking, forward planning, and advanced forms of fairness requiring theory of mind.
- Targeted helping—where an animal helps another based on an understanding of the other's specific situation, such as selecting the exact tool another chimpanzee needs—is a high-level form of cooperation requiring perspective-taking and theory of mind, observed in chimps, elephants, and dolphins.
“that's targeted helping, what is based on understanding the situation of the other. And it requires taking the perspective of somebody else, and so in animals like chimps and elephants and dolphins, I think we see that kind of level of corporation.”
- Unlike capuchin monkeys and young children who only protest disadvantageous inequity, chimpanzees may refuse a superior reward (grapes) until their partner also receives it, equalizing outcomes even when the imbalance is in their own favor—a more advanced, less egocentric sense of fairness.
“in chimpanzees, the one who gets the grapes may refuse the grape until the other one also gets a grape. So in chimpanzees, they will equalize the outcome even if the outcome was in their own favor.”
- Apes demonstrate forward planning, or mental time travel, as shown by a female bonobo who carried a 15-pound rock for a kilometer over 15 minutes, collecting nuts along the way, to a hard surface where she cracked them—meaning she selected her tool long before she had the nuts or reached the cracking site.
“she picked up her tool 15 minutes before she knew she would be having the nuts there at that particular location, and before she was even at the place where she could use the rock... that kind of planning... is present in the apes, which means they can think forward, they can plan ahead.”
Alpha males maintain status through peacemaking and empathy rather than aggression and terror.
- As male chimpanzees age and testosterone declines (as in humans), they shift from aggressive status competition (ages 20-30) to easygoing intimate friendships and playing with kids; high-ranking males who retire often become popular grooming partners and play more with children, revealing a distinct lifespan arc.
“The older males who are over 40, they take it easy... they have friendships that are more intimate with each other because they're less focused on political alliances... once they retire... became very popular grooming partners for everyone. But what they also do is they play a lot more with kids.”
- Contrary to the stereotype of alpha males as bullies, those who terrorize the group often end badly—sometimes killed in the wild or removed in captivity—while alpha males who keep the peace and act empathically become so popular that the whole group defends them against challengers, making it almost a democratic system based on reputation.
“if you have an alpha male who keeps the peace and is friendly with everyone... Those males become so popular that if there's a young challenger who tries to take their position, the whole group is gonna defend him... if you have a male who's a bully... Those males may end up badly, in the wild we know that they're sometimes killed by the group.”