What this covers

Sean Carroll interviews Jane McGonigal, a game designer and futurist at the Institute for the Future, about how to imagine plausible futures and prepare for them. McGonigal argues that the standard approach—computer simulations that model parameters—systematically fails because it cannot capture human emotion, values, and disobedience. Instead, she advocates for social simulations in which thousands of real people roleplay through hypothetical scenarios, generating surprising and realistic emergent outcomes that no algorithm could predict. The key insight is that vivid, specific mental time travel—imagining yourself acting in a concrete future scenario with sensory detail—actually changes your present behavior and overcomes normalcy bias, the assumption that tomorrow will resemble today.

McGonigal draws on a portfolio of examples: pandemic preparedness games that correctly anticipated religious gatherings as super-spreader events but missed that governments would simply give up; evidence that imagining oneself taking climate action primes real-world adoption; and the observation that longer time horizons activate maximalist thinking while short-term planning contracts. The conversation ranges across psychology, game design, and political fragmentation. She advocates balancing positive and shadow imagination—hope alongside realistic threat assessment—and building hard empathy across political divides through simulation. The discussion includes practical claims about self-efficacy transfer from games to life, the value of diversity in large-scale simulations, and whether gaming culture should be as universal as reading. Carroll and McGonigal also examine how rapidly emergent cultural shifts, like the Ukrainian refugee welcome, can shape migration narratives in ways that preparatory imagination might help navigate.

Sharpest takeaway

McGonigal argues that imagining the future is a trainable skill best practiced through large-scale 'social simulations' where real people, not computer algorithms, generate emergent and surprising human responses, and that vivid, specific mental time travel changes how we feel and act today.

  • Computer simulations miss the complexity of human emotion, values, and disobedience that drive real crisis outcomes
  • Vividly imagining a future primes people to take action and overcome normalcy bias
  • Balancing positive and 'shadow' imagination plus hard empathy improves preparation for the future

The argument · threads8 threads · 34 claims
0.85

Gaming builds psychological self-efficacy and resilience skills that transfer to real-world problem-solving.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Gamers develop a unique transferable skill set—flexible mindset, creative thinking, collaboration, collective intelligence, and unbelievable resilience (staying with a problem when they can't solve it right away)—that could be applied to real-world problems like climate change and poverty.

    “it really taps into that unique skill set of a flexible mindset and creative thinking and collaboration and collective intelligence, and this kind of unbelievable resilience that gamers have, where if they can't figure something out right away, they stay with it”

  • Games are deliberately designed to be challenging and frustrating while always offering hope and help around the corner, which builds psychological self-efficacy—comfort with being bad at something, managing negative emotions like frustration and uncertainty, asking for help, and trying again—and laboratory studies show these behaviors transfer to real-world interactions.

    “games are designed to be challenging and hard and frustrate us... we develop this ease and comfort with not being good at something the first time we try it, of managing these negative emotions”

  • Explicitly having conversations about the gaming skill set—reflecting back to kids or adults that they don't give up, can find help, or always come up with new strategies—helps people internalize it as part of their identity, which makes the skills more likely to transfer to real-world situations.

    “when we talk to each other and reflect the skill set, then people, whether they're kids or they're grown ups... we're more likely to see ourselves as this is part of our identity. I'm someone who doesn't give up”

  • The benefits of gaming come from playing different, unfamiliar games with new interfaces and genres rather than the same game for decades; this develops the superpower of learning new systems quickly, and the most valuable benefits come from games many others play because of the collective, collaborative culture.

    “There's a certain super power, the ability to learn new systems quickly that comes from playing games that you've never played before, new interfaces, new genres, new challenges.”

  • Playing a game like Solitaire can count for something psychologically because it lets a player regulate thoughts and emotions—turning off depressive rumination or stopping a panic attack by controlling the imagination away from anxious thoughts.

    “it could count for your regulating your thoughts and emotions, you're using the game to turn off depressive rumination or to stop a panic attack”

0.85

Vivid, specific imagining of future scenarios primes people to act and reveals what they truly prioritize.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Vividly imagining oneself taking an action in a future scenario—such as adapting sustainably to an oil crisis—primes people to actually take those actions when the situation arises, because once you vividly imagine yourself as someone likely to act, it increases the likelihood you will, independent of whether the prediction was accurate.

    “just having imagined adapting to an oil crisis, and people imagine themselves doing all these cool sustainable creative things. I think that did prime them to actually do it”

  • Failures of imagination occur because imagination must reach into the hippocampus for facts and clues to recombine; if we do not deliberately plant vivid details of possible futures by collecting signals of change, our brain has nothing realistic to draw on and cannot conjure realistic possibilities, only fantasy.

    “the reason why we can't anticipate these surprising futures is that If we don't plant vivid details of what the future might be like into our minds, then there's nothing to draw on. Imagination, it needs to reach into that hippocampus for some facts”

  • When people imagine what they might do 10 years out, they think maximally—biggest, most exciting, most meaningful goals—and give more emphasis to their deepest values and purpose, whereas near-term imagining (today, next week, next year) is minimal and focused on what is realistic and feasible, because longer timelines give the brain a sense of creative freedom and hope.

    “when people imagine what they could do 10 years from now, they tend to imagine things that are different... we tend to think about maximal situations, so best possible things, biggest goals... When we imagine what we might do today, or tomorrow... we tend to think more minimally, we're more focused on what is realistic”

  • The more vivid, specific, countable details (colors, clothing, weather, songs, people, words spoken) one brings to imagining a future, the more the brain treats hypothetical possibilities as worth taking seriously and 'pre-feels' them with emotional intensity, which makes related topics more salient so the person picks up real-world clues faster and is motivated to act.

    “The more vivid, specific detail that you bring to imagination, the more that this imagination or memory of the future can change how you feel and act today.”

  • A participant in the 'First Five Minutes of the Future' game realized through repeatedly journaling future scenarios that her husband never appeared in any of the moments she imagined, which surfaced that they had been growing apart and led her to file for divorce—illustrating that imagining the future can reveal what we truly prioritize and challenge our present assumptions.

    “every journal entry, when I was writing what I was gonna do... my husband wasn't in a single one of these... It sort of drove home for her that they've been growing apart”

0.71

Social simulations using real people as algorithms outperform computational models by capturing human emotion and surprise.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Social simulations require large numbers of participants—thousands or tens of thousands rather than ten or twenty—to achieve a diversity of participants that yields a statistically significant correlation to what may play out in real society.

    “I wouldn't try this with 10 or 20 people, but when you have 1000 or 10,000 or 20,000, you start to, I think, have a diversity of participants where you'll get a more statistically significant correlation to what might play out in real society.”

  • Computer pandemic simulations fail because they only crunch parameter-based assumptions and miss the complexity of human emotion, needs, and disobedience, whereas social simulations use real people as 'the algorithms'—letting them surprise you and revealing patterns—because people can be experts on their own future.

    “If you just set a computer simulation to simulate pandemics, you're gonna miss this incredible complexity of human emotion and needs and what drives us and motivates us”

  • Because game design produces emergence—players doing something totally different from what designers anticipated—inviting people who can surprise you and each other is the best way to forecast the future, since a key obstacle to preparedness is normalcy bias, the assumption that the future will be more or less like the present.

    “game developers call that emergence, it's when you design a certain set of challenges, or rules, or behaviors and then player show up, and they're doing something totally different from what you anticipated, which is why when it comes to forecasting the future, I don't think you can do better than to invite a bunch of people who have that facility of surprising you”

  • In future-forecasting games, assigning a subset of participants as 'griefers'—whose only job is to break, block, or twist others' proposed positive solutions into social division—channels the antagonizing energy of part of the gaming community productively, making the simulation better prepared for real-world complications and opposition.

    “I always try to assign a certain subset of the community to be what I would call the griefers, which are people whose only job in the simulation is look at what other people are trying to do... and try to mess it up. What would you do to break it, to block it, to twist it into something that creates social division?”

  • Through experimentation, McGonigal has found it ideal for participants to spend at least 10 days in a scenario (about an hour a day) because it lets ideas percolate past obvious responses into more complex, nuanced, and surprising ones while remaining a feasible commitment, whereas six-to-ten-week formats are harder to sustain.

    “it's ideal if people can spend at least 10 days in a scenario because it allows it to percolate and really simmer in your mind and you can get past your obvious ideas into more complex and nuanced and surprising ones”

0.65

Collective imagination practices and shared gaming culture sustain engagement and deepen real-world discussion.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Playing games in common with people in your life builds a shared foundation that keeps conversations going and makes people more likely to interact and discuss real-world topics with those they play with, even if the gameplay itself is intermittent.

    “People interact more and have conversations about real world topics more with people that they play these games with... it just creates this rhythm of interaction and this common foundation.”

  • Imagination habits like collecting signals of change work better as a community practice—texting a friend a signal each week, coffee meetups, or brown-bag lunches—because, like games, people are more likely to keep up the practice if someone else is participating and waiting for them to show up.

    “it works better when you do it with other people, so you can make a commitment to text a friend once a week... because I think all of this works better as a community practice, just like games. You're more likely to play a game if somebody else is playing it”

  • Just as home video cameras let everyone become filmmakers and blogs let everyone become journalists, McGonigal hopes the step-by-step methods in her book will democratize the rare skill of designing social simulations so every organization, foundation, and social movement can run its own future scenarios.

    “in the same way that when video... Home video cameras became available and suddenly everybody could be a film maker... So I'm hoping we can all be simulation designers in this future, democratize the skill set”

  • Hard empathy—the empathy we must work to develop for people unlike ourselves, as opposed to easy empathy for people like us—is fostered by running social simulations where you hear real people respond to hypothetical futures, which moves discussion out of abstract, politically divisive opinions (as with Universal Basic Income) into understanding the real reasons people want or fear a particular future.

    “hard empathy, we can develop it by just actually seeing the future from other people's points of view. And to do that, we can play these games together”

0.46

Pandemic simulations successfully predicted mask challenges and religious gathering risks but failed to anticipate bad-faith governmental response.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Having simulation participants practice wearing real masks in 2008 revealed that adapting to masks was not simply a matter of willingness but had a physical endurance aspect and social-disconnection frustration, predicting it would be much harder in communities without an existing mask-wearing culture.

    “we saw that there was a physical endurance aspect to learning to be comfortable wearing a mask that was not easy for people who had never done it before to pick up... it was gonna be much more difficult in communities that didn't have a practice or culture of it”

  • In 2008 pandemic simulations, participants said the number-one reason they would violate isolation orders was religious worship because it was fundamental to their values and sense of purpose—which accurately predicted that religious gatherings became the top super-spreading risk worldwide and a major source of early US social and First Amendment tension.

    “The number one thing people said back in 2008 when we first started simulating pandemics was for religious worship... and of course, that turned out to be the number one super spreading risk all over the world, Italy, Korea, the US”

  • While the simulations accurately anticipated the misinformation and infodemiology crisis, neither McGonigal nor her participants anticipated that governments and people in power would essentially give up or act in bad faith to downplay the severity—a global shrug that became the major surprise of the real pandemic.

    “What we did not anticipate was essentially, I guess, governments giving up or people in power acting in a kind of bad faith way to downplay the severity”

0.40

Balancing positive and shadow imagination lets societies prepare for risks while maintaining hope and identifying collaborative solutions.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Effective futurism requires actively balancing positive imagination (the futures we want to wake up in) with shadow imagination (willingness to acknowledge real risks and threats), using both lenses to assess any new technology or situation—letting shadow imagination inform exciting possibilities and letting positive imagination find hope within crises.

    “what I encourage people to do and what we practice at the Institute for the Future is to have an active balance of what we call positive imagination and shadow imagination”

  • If we rethink assumptions about human rights to move freely and seek opportunity or safety, freer planetary movement could allow people to contribute more to society and let us design higher-density cities than ever before—potentially fueling a new renaissance of ideas and culture that is incredibly green and where art flourishes.

    “if we're willing to rethink our assumptions about human rights to move freely... we could design a higher density cities than we've ever lived in before, and that could be amazing for a new renaissance”

0.38

Massive gaming adoption and lived experience of crisis response create cultural tipping points toward migration and human mobility.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Pokémon GO reached half a billion downloads within roughly 30-60 days, making it the fastest growing product or service in human history, and Niantic's choice to drop it without instructions triggered an explosion of player-led collaborative investigation via wikis, forums, and videos.

    “within 30, I think it was 30 days, 30-60 days, it was half a billion downloads, it was the fastest growing product or service in human history”

  • The amount of human time still spent playing Candy Crush Saga is equivalent to the labor of the three largest organizations on Earth (such as Walmart, McDonald's, and the Chinese Army), suggesting some of that effort could be redirected toward future-forecasting games.

    “the amount of human labor spent solving Candy Crush levels is equivalent to the three largest organizations on Earth in term of how much time is still spent every day”

  • Multiple independent signals of change—a US poll showing a majority now favors more immigration for the first time in decades, and US deaths exceeding births—are drivers pushing in the same direction toward a new way of thinking about migration, since aging populations cannot sustain life as we know it without young people.

    “I saw a headline that for the first time, we had more deaths than human... Than births in the United States, which is another reason to consider more migration, like aging populations. We're not gonna be able to sustain life as we know it, without young people”

  • The unprecedented welcoming response to Ukrainian refugees—people meeting them at borders, opening their homes—gives populations a lived experience of being heroic in welcoming people in crisis, which could become a tipping point shifting culture toward a more humane, positive narrative around migration, even though the response also contains racism since some countries accept these refugees because they are white and Christian.

    “people like my kids might grow up, having this narrative in their mind, this is what we do, we welcome people in crisis, we open our homes... is there anything I can do to help this be a tipping point for the culture of migration”

0.32

Gaming culture should become as universal as reading and exercise because it fuels creativity, resilience, and positive emotions.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Essentially every human being should participate in some gaming culture, in the same way everyone should read and exercise, because games are essential fuel for creativity, mental resilience, and a range of positive emotions.

    “I do think essentially, every human being should participate in some gaming culture... In the same way that I would say every human being should read and should exercise. It does seem like essential fuel for our creativity, and our mental resilience”

  • Two major studies found that despite all the misinformation and mask resistance, at the global scale public trust in science and scientists increased as a direct result of seeing the vaccines developed and the efficacy of interventions, and public understanding of the scientific method increased globally—even though social media fighting makes it feel otherwise.

    “There were two major studies that found that despite all of the misinformation, conspiracy theories, resistance to mask wearing, at the global scale, public trust in science and scientists has increased as a direct result of seeing the vaccines developed, their efficacy”

  • The big-picture lesson from the simulations is that people need to be more flexible and willing to change plans or practices—accepting that things can change on short notice or permanently, such as wildfire seasons forcing rethinks of school calendars and electrical grids causing less stable power—as the way to maintain well-being heading into the future.

    “what I'm telling everyone is we need to be more flexible, we need to be more willing to change plans or change practices... I think it's just gonna be how we maintain our well-being, is just to accept that things can change on short notice or permanently”