What this covers

Sean Carroll interviews astrobiologist Betül Kaçar about paleogenomics—the practice of reconstructing ancient proteins from modern genomic data, synthesizing them, and testing them in living cells. The central argument is that Earth's own deep past, radically different in chemistry and atmosphere from today, serves as a second (and third, and fourth) data point in the search for life's origins and habitability elsewhere. Rather than accepting the n equals 1 limitation imposed by having only one known biosphere, Kaçar explains how shared molecular machinery across all life—the universal translation system that converts DNA to RNA to proteins—lets researchers use phylogenomics to infer the sequences of the last universal common ancestor and push inference back more than three billion years. The method does not resurrect whole organisms; instead, it swaps single ancestral components into modern microbes while leaving everything else contemporary, creating a kind of molecular archaeology.

The conversation spans several scientific territories and open questions. Kaçar walks through how metals like molybdenum act as metabolic intermediaries and why a planet's elemental composition may hint at habitability. She describes experiments in which her lab resurrected ancient nitrogenase and oxygen-metabolizing proteins, finding signatures of the Great Oxidation Event written into protein structure itself—a result that challenged simple Just-So Story explanations of why life uses the elements it does. The discussion also touches on whether oxygen was necessary for complex life (it was not the initial enabler she suggests), why the abundance of the enzyme RuBisCO masks its inefficiency, and what remains unsolved about the chemistry-to-biology threshold. Kaçar proposes that understanding life's origins well enough might eventually enable seeding biotic capacity on lifeless worlds—a speculative prospect distinct from terraforming. Throughout, she emphasizes an Anti-Progressivist View of Evolution, cautioning against treating ancient biological solutions as inferior simply because they are old.

Sharpest takeaway

Kaçar argues that even though we have only one example of life (Earth), paleogenomics lets us reconstruct and physically resurrect billion-year-old proteins, effectively turning Earth's own deep past into many additional data points for understanding life's origins and the search for life elsewhere.

  • Shared molecular machinery across all life lets us infer ancestral DNA/protein sequences via phylogenetic trees
  • Resurrected ancient enzymes engineered into modern microbes can be compared against the geological rock record
  • Earth's ancient planet is itself an 'alien' sample, breaking the n=1 limitation

The argument · threads6 threads · 27 claims
0.75

Reconstructing ancient proteins reveals that life's molecular solutions were optimized for their era, not primitive precursors of today's forms.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Kaçar's lab reconstructed the molybdenum-dependent enzyme nitrogenase back to its ~2.5-billion-year-old origins and found it preferred molybdenum even though geologists say early oceans were not high in molybdenum, refuting the simple 'just-so' story that life used molybdenum merely because it was abundant in the environment.

    “we reconstructed the molybdenum-depending enzyme, nitrogenase, and we think we traced all the way back to its origins, which is about 2.5 billion year”

  • The signatures of the Great Oxidation Event are embedded in the proteins themselves: by resurrecting roughly 3-billion-year-old ancestors of a key oxygen-using metabolic protein and engineering them into modern microbes, Kaçar's lab found that parts of the protein responsible for breathing oxygen today were different about 2.5 billion years ago, as if oxygen 'tickled' the protein and left a readable signature.

    “we were able to see the signatures of this atmospheric change embedded on the proteins themselves”

  • It is a human-centric mistake to assume that ancient biological solutions were less optimal than today's; past conditions and the proteins suited to them were optimal and innovative at their given time, so reconstructed ancient systems should be treated as well-adapted to their era rather than as inferior precursors.

    “when we think about ancient life or things in the past, we tend to think that somehow today is better, and it's a very human-centric view”

  • Kaçar's method computationally infers ancient DNA sequences from modern data, has a company synthesize the DNA, expresses the protein, and swaps the single ancestral component into a modern microbe—everything else remains modern—so the approach resurrects one ~3-billion-year-old component at a time rather than reconstructing an entire ancestral organism, which is far beyond current capability.

    “reconstruct its ancient DNA sequence, use synthetic biology and actually synthesize them in the lab. That's when we say resurrection... and then engineer them inside organisms by swapping what is currently in the organism with this ancestral version”

0.75

Life's chemistry rests on elemental building blocks and metal catalysts, making planetary composition relevant to habitability.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • A single small molecule or protein can have a far greater impact on life than a whole organism: removing lizards would barely be felt, but removing an element like molybdenum would doom all life, illustrating why proteins and essential elements deserve study despite being small links in a long hierarchy of biological steps.

    “if you remove, I don't know, lizards today, with all due respect to lizards, you would probably not feel it as much, but if you remove like molybdenum, we are all doomed”

  • RuBisCo is one of the most abundant proteins on Earth and central to carbon fixation and biomass production, yet it is a surprisingly slow catalyst and is 'confused' in that it cannot differentiate oxygen from carbon dioxide well, motivating efforts to engineer it back toward an ancient version that existed before atmospheric oxygen to improve its CO2 specificity.

    “RuBisCo is involved in carbon fixation. It's quite an important enzyme that functions in the production of the biomass; at the same time, it's a pretty slow catalyst considering the important job it does”

  • Metals are not inert chunks but the intermediaries that enable almost all metabolic functions, performing the catalysis that converts reactants to products; remove them and most biological functions collapse, which is why life is fundamentally a chemical system built on elemental building blocks and why a planet's elemental composition may give clues to its habitability.

    “they supply almost all the metabolic functions. They are the intermediaries that enable almost all life components to do their job”

  • Life on Earth relies on about 30 elements, including a shared 'CHNOPS' cocktail (carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen, sulfur, phosphorus) plus ancillary elements, but we do not yet know whether life distilled out this particular selection because it was chemically necessary—which would make it universal—or merely because those elements happened to be available, a distinction that matters for predicting life elsewhere.

    “we know life relies on about 30 different elements here, and it's common, it's shared, we know at least six of them, this Schnapps cocktail that astrobiologists like to call carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen, sulfur, phosphorus”

0.61

Life emerged rapidly after planet formation and evolved through microbial epochs, with oxygen as a catastrophic but enabling transition, not a prerequisite.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • There is reason to think life crossed the threshold from chemistry to biology around 4.1 billion years ago, only about 400 million years after planet formation, which is remarkably quick and suggests the planetary context rapidly enabled chemistry to cross into biology.

    “we have some reason to think that around 4.1 billion years into the past, something happened. So we're looking 400 million years following plant formation, and it's very quick, if you think about it”

  • For the first billion-plus years, life consisted of microbes with no atmospheric oxygen and they were fine; the rise of oxygen was a catastrophe for those microbes but set the stage for eukaryotes, which did not appear until a few hundred million years later, implying oxygen should not be treated as a necessary 'smoking gun' for life elsewhere.

    “the rise of oxygen is a horrible catastrophe for microbes, but it's great news if you are a eukaryote or a multicellular organism”

  • All life on Earth shares the same fundamental translation machinery that converts DNA to RNA to proteins—effectively the same computational processor across plants, humans, archaea, and bacteria—so whatever molecular components are universally shared today were likely the common shared components in the deep past, even if more complex organisms layer additional complexity on the same core system.

    “we all rely on translation machinery, for example, it is almost imagining that we all have the same computational processor inside of us. You do, I do, a plant does, we all rely on the same system”

  • Whether the Great Oxidation Event was driven primarily by geology or by biology (the emergence of cyanobacteria and oxygenic photosynthesis) remains genuinely unknown and debated, with recent papers favoring a geological trigger while biologists emphasize photosynthesis, and the environment and organisms likely co-influenced each other in ways we cannot fully reconstruct.

    “there were just recent papers that said it was primarily geological trigger, but for a biologist, of course, the invention of photosynthesis and the cyanobacterial... The emergence of cyanobacteria, rather, all triggered the rise of oxygen”

0.56

Reconstructing ancient biology mirrors linguistic reconstruction: using genomic and rock records to extract biological history from available evidence despite gaps.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Reconstructing ancient biology is analogous to a linguist resurrecting an ancient language: researchers use what living organisms 'left behind' (genomic and rock records) plus complementary contextual clues to extract the ancient 'language' of biology, accepting that there will be gaps and possible mistranslations but starting from available evidence.

    “my approach is similar to perhaps a linguist that is trying to resurrect an ancient language”

  • We know life extends back about 3.5 billion years because remnants of ancient organisms left a biological carbon isotope record—they preferentially 'chewed' certain carbon isotopes in the same way modern microbes do—and the challenge is discerning whether such isotopic records are biological or abiotic.

    “We know that because these remnants of these bugs that once lived in these environments tell us that, hey, I did something that is similar to what an organism that around you today does, and that is that I chewed the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, the isotopes in the atmosphere”

  • Rocks and fossils older than roughly a billion years are far too old to extract DNA from; only relatively recent specimens preserved in conditions like permafrost or ice (thousands to about 10,000 years old) can yield extractable DNA, so deep-time inference must rely on morphology and chemistry of rocks plus phylogenetic reconstruction rather than ancient DNA itself.

    “these are way too old to extract DNA from”

0.44

Earth's unique chemistry deserves protection; understanding life's origins teaches humility and offers thought experiments like protospermia for seeding life elsewhere.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Physics imposes itself on biology: life is 'lazy' and consistently picks lighter isotopes over heavier ones because of biophysics, illustrating how physical and biophysical constraints shape the chemical solutions that biology adopts.

    “We see this when organisms chew up different isotopes in the atmosphere. They always pick the lighter one because you just don't want to deal with the heavy one, so physics imposes itself a lot in the way biology operates itself”

  • Commercial DNA synthesis has become dramatically cheaper, dropping from about a dollar per base when Kaçar started to roughly 10 cents per nucleic acid today, with typical reconstructed sequences around 1500 base pairs.

    “When I first started, they used to charge us a dollar per base and now which is at... Now, it's 10 cents”

  • Kaçar proposes 'protospermia' as a thought experiment: once we understand life's origins well enough to know what a lifeless planet is 'missing' to cross the chemistry-to-biology threshold, we might give such a planet a chemical nudge that, over millions of years, lets it develop its own unique forms of life genetically unrelated to us—seeding biotic capacity rather than spreading Earth life, distinct from terraforming and panspermia.

    “It is not panspermia, I called it protospermia, that again, so it's sort of empowering the capacity of these planets to express their own unique forms of life that are not genetically related to or look nothing like us”

  • The supposed n=1 problem is misleading because Earth's own ancient past is effectively an alien planet—completely different in landscape, atmosphere, and chemical composition from today—so studying that deep past gives us an extra, profoundly different sample of how life and a planet co-evolve, an opportunity we waste if we ignore it.

    “we think, okay, there's n equals one problem, there's one life, there's one sample is the problem, but that's actually not quite true. Our past is itself an alien planet”

  • Earth hosts a very special chemistry that, as far as we know, has not happened anywhere else, and studying life's origins instills the humility to appreciate and want to protect this unique chemistry—'backing up life's chemistry'—rather than recklessly meddling with or colonizing other worlds as humans have done to cultures they failed to understand.

    “What we have is very special and this is beyond our presence here, that there is a very interesting chemistry, that's going on on this planet that's so far we know did not happen anywhere. And it may be important to think that we may want to protect this chemistry and save it”

  • Mars provides a useful nearby 'control system' for understanding Earth's ancient past—though Earth has richer chemistry—and over the next decade improving technology will let us characterize the atmospheric and chemical composition of exoplanets, even if no single biosignature will yet give a clean probability of habitability.

    “we have a nice control system in our neighborhood, but when it comes to exoplanets, we will be able to understand the chemical composition of these planets, especially the atmospheric composition, over the next decade”

0.38

Origin of life remains unsolved because evolvability—not mere chemistry—is what transforms chemical systems into living ones.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • If starting life were very easy, scientists would likely have created it in the lab by now; the fact that we haven't suggests either that nature is a better chemist than us or that the process is hard, though Kaçar believes the origin-of-life problem will likely be solved within our lifetimes even if we can never know whether what we create matches what actually happened.

    “if it was very easy, we would probably have done it by now ourselves in the lab, right? So either nature is a better chemist than us”

  • In the lab we can build chemical systems that process some limited information, but we cannot yet make such systems evolvable—and evolvability is the component needed to count something as life—so the deeper unsolved problem is what enables a chemical system to explore solutions, evolve, and maintain a memory of those solutions over billions of years.

    “we can't make the system evolvable yet, which we need it... We need that component for... To pin it there as life”