159 | Mari Ruti on Lack, Love, and Psychoanalysis
What this covers
Mari Ruti, a literary theorist and psychoanalysis scholar, discusses Jacques Lacan's account of human existence as a framework for understanding everyday life rather than as a scientific system. The conversation centers on how language acquisition creates a constitutive lack within us—a sense of having lost something precious—which generates desire and shapes our behavior across love, creativity, and mourning. Rather than treating this lack as a problem to solve, Ruti argues that the healthiest approach is to acknowledge it has no cure and instead channel it productively into meaningful pursuits. She contrasts this Lacanian view with Sigmund Freud's earlier theories and draws on thinkers like Todd McGowan, Alain Badiou, and Julia Kristeva to develop her argument.
The discussion ranges across several distinct domains. Ruti explains how ontological lack operates from infancy onward and how it connects to trauma as resilience-building, arguing that people who have endured severe trauma often develop better tools for coping with new hardship. On love, she contrasts narcissistic romance—where one seeks a partner to fill one's own void—with authentic connection, where two people's lacks are complementary and work together. She explores the distinction between mourning and melancholia, examines how the ego must be banished for creativity to flow, and addresses why Lacan's notoriously difficult writing style reflects his philosophical commitments. Throughout, she positions psychoanalysis as a humanistic philosophy of existence rather than a clinical science, one that preserves attention to psychological truth where other post-structuralist theories have abandoned it.
Ruti argues that Lacanian psychoanalysis, treated as a philosophy of everyday life rather than a science, offers genuine insight into human existence: a constitutive 'lack' produces desire, and the healthiest response is not to cure the lack but to harness it for creativity, meaning, and authentic love.
- Human ontology is grounded in a sense of lack created by language acquisition, which generates desire
- There is no cure for this lack; the goal is to learn to live with it and channel it productively
- Authentic love connects through complementary lacks rather than narcissistically filling one's own lack
Human beings are dynamic systems perpetually driven by desire and lack, so perfect happiness is neither achievable nor necessary.
- Human beings are out-of-equilibrium physical systems—like a surfer riding a wave rather than a rock on a beach—who must continually self-adjust to maintain homeostasis; therefore we should not seek a once-and-for-all cure, because we will constantly lack something and be driven to fulfill desire, never reaching a state of perfect happiness, and that is acceptable as part of the process.
“human beings are out-of-equilibrium systems, we have some more or less steady state, but it's like in my analogy, it's like you're a surfer riding a wave. It's not like you're a rock on the beach, you need to continually do little adjustments to make sure you don't fall off... that's why I like this emphasis on the fact that we shouldn't be seeking the once and for all cure”
Accessing subconscious thoughts through drugs or free association works by removing neural gatekeeping, which is neurologically sound.
- Contrary to intuition, drugs like LSD do not fire off neurons but depress certain brain activity—specifically the gatekeeper that normally zeroes out and silences ideas bubbling beneath the surface—letting subconscious thoughts flow free, which is analogous to the drug-free practice of letting subconscious thoughts flow more freely.
“you would think that if you take something like LSD and then you see all these colors and whatever, that it is firing off neurons in your brain... but in fact, it depresses certain activities in your brain, it's just that what it's depressing is the gatekeeper... taking the psychedelics lets them flow free, so maybe that's at least analogous to this drug-free version where we learn to let our subconscious thoughts flow a little bit more freely”
Psychoanalysis persists in academia as philosophy and literary theory rather than as clinical psychology practice.
- In contemporary psychology circles there are not a lot of psychology professors in the psychoanalytic tradition; psychoanalysis instead survives in literary and certain philosophical corners of academia as a way of thinking about human beings rather than primarily as a clinical practice.
“I think it's safe to say that in psychology circles, there aren't a lot of psychology professors who are in the psychoanalytic tradition these days. The psychoanalysis lives on in literary and certain philosophical corners of academia”
Freud's specific theories—the Oedipal complex, penis envy—were dramatically wrong and created a false caricature.
- Freud was not right about everything and was dramatically wrong about some things, producing a caricature of psychoanalysis—the Oedipal complex, penis envy—that has not held up over time.
“Freud was not right about everything, he was dramatically wrong about some things. So, there's this sort of caricature of psychoanalysis with things like the Oedipal Complex... penis envy that women have... things that haven't held up over time”