What this covers

Sean Carroll interviews Elizabeth Strychalski, a biologist at the National Institute of Standards and Technology whose lab recently constructed a synthetic microbial organism capable of self-reproduction. The conversation spans the conceptual foundations of building minimal cells—stripped-down organisms containing only genes deemed essential—and what such construction reveals about how life actually works. Strychalski argues that synthetic cells serve two purposes: they expose the still-unknown rules governing even the simplest viable organisms, and they form the basis for genuine engineering biology—cellular systems that are predictable, controllable, and safe enough for therapeutic and manufacturing use.

The terrain covered is both technical and philosophical. On the factual side, Strychalski walks through the discovery that even the genomically minimal cell contains roughly 100 genes of unknown function, including four of the seven genes required for normal cell division. She explains how the team used systematic deletion to identify these division genes in JCVI-syn3A, and why JCVI-syn3.0, which looked normal at the colony level, produced chaotically misshapen cells under the microscope—revealing how much remains unknown about cellular behavior. The discussion introduces cell-free systems, genome transplantation, and the design-build-test-learn cycle that drives synthetic biology research. More conceptually, Strychalski addresses the N equals one problem—that we have only one example of life—and proposes that synthetic cells offer a way to escape evolutionary bias and imagine fundamentally different forms of life. She distinguishes between top-down and bottom-up approaches to cell construction, discusses why true control requires living feedback loops inside cells rather than external engineering, and argues that life and death are better understood as a spectrum. Carroll raises the ethics of increasingly powerful biology, while Strychalski sketches alternative approaches to climate engineering through carbon budgeting rather than releasing engineered organisms.

Sharpest takeaway

Strychalski argues that building minimal and synthetic cells is both a tool for discovering the still-unknown rules of biology (many genes have unknown function even in the simplest viable cell) and a path toward true 'engineering biology'—predictable, controllable, safe cellular systems for medicine, manufacturing, and sensing.

  • The genomically minimal cell still contains ~100 genes of unknown function, including 4 of the 7 genes needed for normal cell division.
  • Real engineering biology requires control loops (sensors + actuators) inside cells, not just assembling parts.
  • Synthetic biology can move from understanding life to designing 'agnostic life' not descended from prior cells.

The argument · threads9 threads · 36 claims
0.80

Minimal cells contain roughly 100 genes of unknown function, making them difficult to model and control despite being essential for survival.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • By narrowing the search to Segment 6 of the genome and systematically testing gene groups then single genes, the team identified seven genes that together reconstitute control of cell size and shape, producing the better-behaved JCVI-syn3A strain; strikingly, only two (FtsZ and SepF) are known division genes, one is a hydrolase with unknown substrate, and four have completely unknown function.

    “we drilled down on seven genes that seemed to together reconstitute control of cell size and shape in the minimal cell”

  • Even in the most basic aspects of cell physiology, the minimal cell contains roughly 100 genes of unknown function out of 493 protein-coding genes—essential because the cell fails without them yet untied to any known function—which is a major obstacle for whole-cell models and cellular engineering.

    “even in this most basic aspect of cell physiology, we run across these genes of unknown function. They are really an elephant in the room”

  • Defining where a gene begins and ends within a DNA strand is not a fully settled matter; experts parse genomes into databases, but groupings of base pairs into protein-coding genes can be revised or shifted, so even the operational definition of a gene remains somewhat in flux.

    “It's not all settled, also. People might say that, "Well, you gotta group these together... in order to form a gene that makes some protein," and then somebody might come on and say, "Actually, you've gotta shift it a little bit this way or that way."”

  • The genome transplantation process works but with low yield and is poorly understood: cells are grown in broth, then polyethylene glycol of a certain molecular weight is added at a particular time and temperature, causing cells to fuse into a syncytial cell containing multiple genomes that later divide apart, some carrying the new synthetic genome and some the old inactivated one.

    “the peg makes cells kind of slam together, so they slam together with this DNA that you want inside of them. We think there's something like a big syncytial cell that forms, and then at their next growth cycle, they kind of divide apart”

  • Identifying the seven genes was a tour de force reverse-genetics effort that took about seven years from the start of the project to publication—long even by the standards of biology.

    “I even made a t-shirt, it says, "Seven genes, seven years."”

0.75

Bottom-up synthetic life remains unachieved; top-down minimization from living cells is far more tractable because we excel at removing parts from existing organisms.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • There are two main approaches to building a synthetic or minimal cell: a bottom-up approach assembling non-living chemical parts until life emerges (not yet achieved), and a top-down approach starting with a living cell and removing parts until it dies; the top-down approach is more tractable because, as Strychalski puts it, 'we're good at killing things' while bottom-up efforts have no success yet to focus their efforts.

    “there are two main paths forward that people are walking down to arrive at something like a synthetic cell or a minimal cell. So you can take the bottom-up approach... The other path forward is more of a top-down approach where you start with something that is already a living cell, and you take parts out until it dies”

  • The minimal cell having nearly 500 genes, each with many base pairs, implies a large gap between a collection of macromolecules and a living, functioning cellular organism—a gap researchers are trying to close from both the bottom-up and top-down directions.

    “If the minimal cell has almost 500 genes... that sounds like there's quite a gap to be bridged from a bunch of macro molecules to a living functioning cellular organism”

  • Because so much about the rules of life is unknown, as we engineer biological systems it is almost as if we are not limited by the fundamental physics or laws of the universe but rather by our own imaginations.

    “as we go about engineering biological systems, it's almost as if we're not limited by the fundamental physics of it... At this point it's almost like we're limited by our imaginations”

  • Even if biology has no fundamental laws resembling those of physics, the search itself is worthwhile because stripping an organism to its essential elements reveals how much of what seems essential is actually the result of relationships between parts.

    “even if there are no fundamental laws that look like the fundamental laws we might be used to finding, even the search itself is worthwhile”

0.66

Minimal cells are defined by arbitrary human-chosen criteria; different criteria would yield different minimal sets, and cell behavior depends inseparably on its environment.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Minimal cells are minimized to arbitrary criteria—boundary conditions chosen by the scientists—so 'minimal' is never absolute; for JCVI-syn3.0 the criteria were normal-looking colony-level growth and growth fast enough to be laboratory-useful, criteria that ignored single-cell behavior.

    “when folks talk about minimal life or minimal cells, what's implicit in that is that you're minimizing to some criteria. You're putting some boundary conditions on this thing”

  • A minimal cell is minimized for a specific environment, so the two cannot be separated; a cell that fails may not be missing a needed gene but rather missing something in its environment—just as humans appear alive in an office but die without the surrounding air—so massively parallelizing and automating minimization across many environments is a path to new discoveries.

    “Because they're minimised in a specific environment, you can't separate those two”

  • There may be more than one way to be minimal: the identified gene set is a minimal set such that removing any member breaks it, but a different set containing different genes could also be minimal, which is why empowering people to make minimal versions of their own cells of interest—minimized to their own criteria—would be more valuable than the not-very-useful mycoplasma itself.

    “maybe there's another set that is containing different genes that is also has the feature that if you remove anything, it wouldn't work either... Maybe there's more than one way to be minimal?”

  • Whether a gene counts as essential is path-dependent, like removing engines from an airplane: a single engine seems non-essential because of redundancy, but removing both is fatal—so the order in which you delete genes matters, and one can accidentally delete genes that turn out to be essential, as happened with syn3.0's loss of cell-size and shape control.

    “imagine if you have an airplane and you wanna take parts off that airplane until it's not able to fly anymore... if I remove an engine, I'm gonna say that's not essential because I've got another engine... but what if I remove both engines”

  • Although JCVI-syn3.0 looked normal at the colony level, under the microscope its single cells behaved chaotically—starting as perfect spheres but producing filamentous cells, branching cells, and huge vesicle-like structures—and the biochemistry, biophysics, and division mechanism behind these morphologies remained unknown.

    “you would start with this perfect, spherical, round, totally normal looking cell, and then you come back a little while later, and there are filamentous cells, branching cells, huge things that I don't even know if it's a cell or a huge vesicle”

0.56

Engineering biology requires closing feedback loops through living measurement systems, not merely calling work engineering until rigorous control exists.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Calling cellular work 'engineering biology' is aspirational until there is a rigorous control engineering for biological systems; true control requires closing a feedback loop—a desired output, a controller, an actuator, and crucially a sensor that measures output and feeds error back—so Strychalski's lab builds living measurement systems out of biological parts inside cells, since biology already measures itself constantly.

    “unless and until we have a rigourous control engineering for biological systems, it's kind of an aspirational title to say that it's engineering”

  • Embedding sensors and even full control loops inside each cell in a bio-manufacturing vat would let producers detect when an individual cell's product yield drifts and have an actuator push that cell back to high production, going beyond external physical sensors that only detect aggregate problems like pH shifts—improving yields and profits to fund more research.

    “imagine having a sensor in each cell. In fact, imagine having that control loop in each cell, so that when the yield output from that cell does something you don't like, that actuator in that control loop then kicks that cell into becoming a high producer again”

  • Control is important for safety: a well-controlled cell lets you be confident that every cell sold as a therapeutic behaves exactly as programmed, so that you are actually curing someone's cancer instead of giving them cancer—the goal being for engineering biology to become as predictable, reliable, robust, and safe as boarding an airplane.

    “if you know you have a well-controlled cell, now you can be more confident... that you're actually curing someone's cancer instead of giving them cancer”

0.51

Creating synthetic cells is inherently reflective; scientists' choices and biases unavoidably embed themselves in the engineered product they build.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Strychalski hopes biology will yield laws resembling 'applied quantum mechanics'—a recipe book enabling practical action—so that the field looks less like synthetic biology and more like engineering biology, because the words we use to describe things matter.

    “I'm hoping that we find laws that look more quantum mechanics in the wild, or applied quantum mechanics, where we arrive at a recipe book that allows us to do practical things”

  • Creating synthetic, minimal, or proto cells is almost an art form or a mirror, because the scientist's own choices and biases unavoidably end up embedded in the product, using the new medium of engineered biology to reflect ourselves back to us.

    “how much of the scientist just unavoidably ends up in that process, in that product. It's almost like it's an art form in some ways, or a mirror”

0.47

Only one example of cellular life exists on Earth; escaping this bias requires finding life elsewhere or building it ourselves to imagine what else is possible.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The minimal cell work started from a mycoplasma, an obligate parasite that cannot live outside its host and which, because it inhabits a stable specialized environment, has not needed to retain much genetic information for responding to changing environments—making it effectively 'pre-minimized by nature' and a candidate 'hydrogen atom of biology'.

    “it's an organism that can't live outside of its host... it hasn't needed to retain a lot of the genetic information or proteins or other bits of itself that it needs to respond to a changing environment”

  • The idea of the minimal cell, dating to the 1930s with physicists in a leadership role, serves three purposes: it may reveal how cellular life came to be (the past), offer a platform for understanding present life including ourselves, and—newly—offer a platform for engineering what life could become in the future, including 'agnostic life' not descended from a prior cell.

    “It can tell us, maybe, how cellular life came to be... It might offer a platform for understanding life today... I think that it can offer a platform for the future, for what life could be”

  • A core challenge in understanding life is the 'N equals one' problem: we have only one example of cellular life—that which evolved on Earth—so to escape this bias we must either find life elsewhere (and recognize it) or build it ourselves, and we should be careful not to be so biased by our own cells that we fail to imagine what else is possible.

    “one of the challenges of creating synthetic life is that when we look around us, we really only have one example of cellular life, and that's what's evolved here on earth”

  • The minimal cell is extremely difficult to study because it is roughly the same size as the wavelength of light, making it very hard to see, prompting interest in whether engineering cell size and shape could be used to deliberately make the cell bigger and easier to measure.

    “This thing is really small, it's about the same size as the wave length of light. So it's really hard to see”

0.44

Biology and engineering are increasingly converging through robotics, machine learning, and cross-disciplinary integration of measurement and control frameworks.

6 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Biology labs are increasingly looking less like a person standing at a bench with a pipette and more like laboratories filled with robots, generating enormous data volumes that machine learning can analyze to ask new kinds of questions about biology.

    “it's starting to look more and more like laboratories filled with robots”

  • Synthetic and engineering biology takes deep bodies of knowledge from formerly siloed disciplines—biophysics, measurement techniques, automation, machine learning, control engineering—and mashes them together, for example overlaying control engineering from radios and cars onto cell biology.

    “we're taking these well-developed, deep bodies of knowledge from what used to be siloed disciplines, and we're basically mashing them all together to see what sticks”

  • Building computers or information processing out of cells need not look like existing silicon computers or Boolean logic; alternative approaches—such as DNA strand displacement circuits performing neural-network-like computation, potentially inside living cells with non-DNA threads—suggest we should learn how cells already process information rather than jamming conventional computers into them.

    “there are folks who use DNA strand displacement circuits to make neural network-like computations. Could we put that inside of living cells?”

  • Rather than releasing engineered cells to consume atmospheric CO2 (with run-away risk), a better climate approach is to make bio-manufacturing processes carbon-neutral or carbon-negative, shifting from an energy-budget framing to a carbon-budget framing, and engineering plants to sequester more CO2 in larger root structures.

    “why not change our bio-manufacturing processes so that they are carbon neutral or carbon negative?”

  • The intracellular environment is extremely noisy—thermal molecular motions dominate—but rather than a liability this can be treated as an asset; biological systems arrange themselves to harness the natural thermodynamics and gradients of their environment, only spending energy to modify those that yield a fitness advantage, much like a 'lazy' cell minimizing effort.

    “I prefer to think of it as a feature instead of a bug... you have to be willing to see it not as a liability, but as an asset”

  • Biology can be viewed as one of the most advanced manufacturing platforms imaginable—rather than industrial production, we might grow products the way we grow corn, or have a household device like a bread maker that grows desired products instead of a 3D printer melting plastic.

    “You can think of biology as one of the most advanced manufacturing platforms that we can imagine... imagine if we could grow our products the same way we grow corn”

0.43

Life and death exist on a spectrum rather than a binary; compartmentalization may not be fundamental, and engineered systems could occupy different points along this continuum.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Life and death are best understood as a spectrum rather than a binary, paralleling a spectrum from chemistry to biology, and depending on what capability you want to build you might situate your engineered system at different points along it—for example deliberately building bio-remediation organisms that cannot reproduce.

    “I like to think of life and death as kind of a spectrum”

  • Compartmentalization, traditionally listed alongside reproduction and metabolism as a requirement for life, may be the odd one out; life elsewhere might not occur in discrete cells but as more of a continuum, and engineering biology can reintroduce compartmentalization through liquid-liquid phase transitions or micro/nanofluidic confinement to bring reacting molecules into advantageous proximity.

    “could we imagine that if we go to other planets, life does not happen in cells, but is just more of a continuum that sort of smushes together”

  • Although the term gain-of-function is usually applied to infectious disease research, taken literally gain-of-function simply means engineering biology, and building a minimal cell or life from scratch is almost the ultimate gain-of-function research.

    “if you take it literally, gain-of-function is engineering biology, and if you talk about building a minimal cell or life from scratch, that's almost the ultimate gain-of-function research”

0.24

Cell-free systems and DNA synthesis enable rapid design-build-test cycles by decoupling biology's machinery from living constraints.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Being able to print any desired DNA and insert it into a cell whose genome has been inactivated would be transformative because it removes the need for living intermediates and incremental, adiabatic changes—you could simply print the genome rather than evolving toward it step by step.

    “if we could print any DNA we wanted, and insert it into any cell whose genome we've inactivated, think of what would be possible. Because you wouldn't have to go through any living intermediates”

  • Cell-free (transcription-translation) systems let you use the machinery of biology without the system being alive: you can run chemistries lethal to a cell, add reagents directly since the system is open, avoid transporting products across membranes, and use them as a fast intermediate test in the design-build-test-learn cycle since they need not grow.

    “they allow you to use the machinery of biology without that said system needing to be alive... You can start thinking about doing chemistries that would be lethal to a cell, and the cell-free system might not care”