144 | Solo: Are We Moving Beyond the Standard Model?
What this covers
Sean Carroll discusses two recent particle-physics measurements that, in April 2021, appeared to deviate from Standard Model predictions. One comes from the LHCb experiment at CERN, where B meson decays show an apparent violation of lepton universality—electrons and muons decay at different rates when theory predicts they should be equal. The other is a reaffirmed measurement of muon g-2 from Fermilab, where the muon's magnetic moment deviates slightly from the Standard Model calculation. Carroll argues these are potentially the most genuinely surprising particle-physics results since the 1970s, yet he frames the conversation not around what they might reveal but around how physicists should interpret them and what confidence we should actually place in anomalies.
The core tension Carroll explores is statistical and epistemic. Both results reach the "evidence for" threshold but fall short of the "discovery" standard, and he explains why sigma levels—often cited as though they quantify the probability of new physics—actually measure only the likelihood of a fluctuation if current error bars are exactly right. Theory mistakes and experimental miscalibrations pose larger risks than claimed. He maps the physics landscape: how muons act as sensitive probes for virtual particles, why the strong nuclear force makes precision calculations treacherous, and how new particles would necessarily sit in a narrow mass range to explain these deviations without contradicting existing collider data. Crucially, a competing lattice quantum chromodynamics calculation published the same week found the muon g-2 data consistent with the Standard Model within acceptable error, leaving the anomaly's reality theoretically unsettled. Independent follow-up experiments from Belle II and J-PARC will test both claims. Even if confirmed, Carroll emphasizes these would extend rather than overturn the Standard Model, while remaining honest about the deep unknowns—dark matter, gravity, the matter-antimatter asymmetry—that guarantee new physics exists somewhere beyond it.
Carroll argues that two reaffirmed muon anomalies (LHCb B-meson decays and Fermilab g-2) may be the first genuinely surprising particle-physics results since the 1970s, but that they would add to rather than overturn the Standard Model, and that proper skepticism about sigma confidence and unresolved theoretical (lattice QCD) disagreements means we should remain hopeful yet suspend judgment.
- Anomalies represent small deviations explained by new heavy virtual particles, leaving everyday-life physics untouched
- Sigma levels measure fluctuation probability assuming correct error bars, not probability of new physics, and theory/experiment mistakes are the bigger risk
- A competing lattice QCD calculation finds no discrepancy, so the g-2 anomaly's reality is theoretically unsettled
The muon g-2 and B-meson anomalies are genuine reaffirmations of prior hints that have survived independent scrutiny.
- The Standard Model predicts that neutral B mesons should decay into electron pairs and muon pairs at an equal rate (ratio of 1), but LHCb observes only about 85% as many muons as electrons, a 3.5 sigma deviation corresponding to 99.98% confidence—reaching the 'evidence for' threshold but not the 5 sigma 'discovery' standard.
“What in fact you see at the LHC B experiment seems to be that there's only about 85% as many muons being produced as electrons... this particular example of the B mesons decaying into electrons and melons has a 3.5 sigma statistical significance”
- The Standard Model predicts the muon's g-factor as 2.002331841 while Fermilab measures 2.002331836, meaning the muon's magnetic moment is slightly smaller than predicted—a 4.2 sigma combined result (with Brookhaven data) corresponding to 99.9987% confidence, still short of the 5 sigma discovery threshold.
“the standard model predicts that for a muon g should be 2.002331841... and what you measure is 2.002331836... This is a 4.2 sigma result, a little more than 4 standard deviations between the standard model prediction and the actual experimental measurement.”
- In April 2021 two independent particle-physics anomalies were reaffirmed—one from the LHCb experiment at CERN involving B-meson decays into electrons versus muons, and one from Fermilab's muon g-2 experiment—both involving muons but otherwise unconnected, representing apparent disagreements with Standard Model predictions.
“we had not one, but two different reports of completely independent anomalies in particle physics, that is to say apparent disagreements between the theoretical predictions based on the standard model of particle physics, which is very well-established, and new experimental results.”
- Both anomalies are checkable by independent follow-up experiments: the Belle II experiment in Japan will perform the same B-meson measurement in a few years, and the J-PARC experiment in Japan will measure muon g-2 by a completely different method, providing honest cross-checks of the LHCb and Fermilab results.
“there is another experiment called the Belle II experiment, Belle, in Japan, which should be doing the same kind of experiment in a few years from now”
- Anomalies in particle physics are 'a dime a dozen'—results disagreeing with the Standard Model appear often and then evaporate as more data is collected, so physicists have become jaded; what makes these two notable is that they are reaffirmations of existing anomalies that survived additional checking.
“anomalies in particle physics are a dime a dozen, there's many, many times when people will say, oh, here's an experimental result which does not quite agree with the predictions of the standard model, and then a few years go by, you collect more data and it evaporates”
The Standard Model omits gravity, dark matter, and dark energy, so new physics must exist despite fitting terrestrial data extremely well.
- The Standard Model of particle physics extremely well accounts for ordinary matter—people, tables, the internet signals, even the sun, moon and stars—through its set of particles and forces.
“All of that is incredibly well accounted for in what we call the standard model of particle physics, even the sun, the moon and the stars”
- Physicists are highly confident the Standard Model is not the final theory because it omits gravity (no quantum theory of gravity for black holes or the Big Bang), dark matter, dark energy, and the matter-antimatter asymmetry—so new physics must exist beyond it, even though it fits all terrestrial particle data extremely well.
“nobody thinks that the standard model of particle physics is the final theory of everything... In a very trivial sense, there is gravity, right, gravity is not included in the standard model of particle physics... Plus there's dark matter.”
- The claim that the laws of physics underlying everyday life are completely understood remains unaffected by these anomalies, because the deviations (e.g., a difference between 2.002331841 and 2.002331836 in muon g-2) are tiny, involve particles like muons that decay away and are absent from our bodies, and require building particle accelerators to detect, so they have no impact on biology or consciousness.
“these new results, even if they're 100% true, leave that claim completely fine, completely unaltered... you don't have any muons inside you. Muons decay away very, very quickly.”
- If real, these anomalies would be the first truly new, surprising, completely unexpected result from a terrestrial particle-physics experiment since the 1970s; phenomena like neutrino masses were discovered in the interim but were somewhat expected, making this qualitatively different and warranting cautious hope amid epistemic uncertainty.
“maybe this is the time that we go beyond the standard model, the first truly new surprising result that was completely unexpected in a particle physics experiment since the 1970s, a particle physics experiment here on Earth. We had neutrino masses and things like that, but those were a little bit expected also”
- Rather than spend the full cost of building a new storage ring at Fermilab, physicists shipped Brookhaven's existing ring by boat around Florida, up the Mississippi, and by truck across Illinois at roughly 10% of the cost of building new—an impressive feat of logistics in experimental physics.
“It was about 10% of that price to literally pack up the storage ring at Brookhaven, put it on a boat, sail the boat around Florida through the Gulf of Mexico, up through the Mississippi River on a barge, unload the storage ring onto a big flatbed truck.”
- The cancellation of the Superconducting Super Collider in 1990s Texas was a costly mistake: the SSC would have been finished before the LHC and at noticeably higher energy, so it would already have found any particles hinted at by these anomalies; the US is now no longer in the running to build the next high-energy collider because such projects require multinational cooperation the US does not currently pursue.
“if the LHC will eventually be able to find it, the SSC would have found it by now, but we decided collectively through our decision-making process as a nation that it wasn't worth the money to us here in the United States.”
- Julian Schwinger calculated the first quantum correction to the anomalous magnetic moment (beyond the classical value of 2) and was so impressed with his result that it is engraved on his tombstone.
“Schwinger was the first to calculate the quantum corrections to the magnetic moment, and he was so impressed by his own calculation, the result that he got is engraved on his tombstone”
- Heavier particles tend to decay into lighter ones because doing so increases the entropy of the universe—a muon decaying into an electron plus a neutrino and anti-neutrino turns one particle into three, raising entropy, whereas the reverse process is extremely improbable.
“The reason, by the way, that heavier particles tend to decay into lighter ones is, roughly speaking, because entropy likes to increase... that little bit increases the entropy of the universe, going from just one particle into three particles.”
Standard Model predictions are theoretically robust for these measurements through cancellation and ratio techniques.
- The LHCb B-meson prediction is theoretically robust because it predicts a ratio of muon to electron decay rates rather than either rate alone, so any difficult-to-calculate contributions (such as from top quarks) should produce the same uncertainty in both the numerator and denominator and cancel out—making theory error a smaller concern than the experimental difficulty of distinguishing electron and muon detection efficiencies.
“we have good theoretical reason to think you should be making the same mistakes in both cases... it should be whatever it is the same uncertainty in your prediction for the muon decays and the electron decays.”
- In the perturbative regime of particle physics (electromagnetism, weak force, Higgs exchange), more complicated Feynman diagrams contribute progressively smaller amounts to the final answer, so calculating only the simplest diagrams yields a good approximation with predictable error bars—but the strong nuclear force is non-perturbative, so simple diagrams are not necessarily more important than complicated ones.
“as the diagrams get more complicated, their contributions get smaller, at least when nature is being nice to us. This is what is called the perturbative regime in particle physics. The strong nuclear force is not perturbative”
- A particle like a muon is not a bare point but is renormalized—surrounded by a cloud of virtual particles (photons, electrons, and heavier particles) constantly emitted and reabsorbed—and the magnetic field interacts with this whole cloud, so all Standard Model particles contribute to the measured g-2, which is why the anomalous magnetic moment is sensitive to undiscovered particles.
“what you should really think of as a little cloud around the muon of these virtual particles, so these virtual photons and electrons and heavier things, all of them contribute to the way in which the muon interacts with the magnetic field around it”
If real, these anomalies indicate new physical principles like supersymmetry or extra dimensions, not overturning the Standard Model.
- There are so many candidate models (grand unification, supersymmetry, extra dimensions) that roughly 50 papers appeared on the arXiv the day after the muon g-2 result was announced, because everyone had their favorite model ready and plugged in the numbers—illustrating that guessing models is easy while determining the correct one is hard.
“there were literally 50 papers that appeared on the archive the day after the muon g-2 result came out, because everyone had their favorite model ready to go”
- Even if real, these anomalies do not overturn the Standard Model; they are like building an addition onto a house rather than demolishing it—all existing Standard Model particles and interactions remain exactly as they are, while new particles or fields gently influence the known ones.
“it's adding on a new addition to your house, not demolishing your house and building another one, okay. All of the existing pieces of the standard model are 100% in place.”
- The reason discovering new particles matters is not the particle itself but the new physical principles it implies—such as extra dimensions, supersymmetry, grand unification, or new forces possibly related to dark matter—and crucially, anomaly experiments like g-2 can reveal that new phenomena exist but cannot study them in detail, so understanding them requires building a giant high-energy accelerator.
“the new particle implies new ideas, it implies new physics... What we're hoping for is not just one more particle to add to the zoo, what we're hoping is that that particle gives us evidence for some new principles”
Statistical confidence thresholds like 3 or 5 sigma are arbitrary conventions and do not guarantee the anomalies are real new physics.
- A 3.5 sigma result does not mean there is only a 1-in-5000 chance the result is new physics; it means there is only a 1-in-5000 chance of seeing such a deviation as a statistical fluctuation IF the error bars on both theory and experiment are exactly correct—the bigger risk is that the theory or experiment contains a mistake.
“The fact that something is a 3.5 sigma deviation between prediction and observation does not mean there's only 1 in 5000 chance that it's new physics, what it means is there is only a 1 in 5000 chance that it would be a statistical fluctuation if you got both your theory and your experiment correct.”
- The particle-physics conventions that 3 sigma is 'evidence for' and 5 sigma is 'discovery' are completely made up; in reality 3 sigma results happen all the time and even 5 sigma results sometimes appear convincingly and then go away, because the theory or experiment was not understood exactly.
“particle physicists have made up these thresholds, like I said, 3 sigma is evidence for, 5 sigma is discovery. That's completely made up... 5 sigma results happen pretty convincingly and then go away pretty commonly”
Theoretical uncertainty in muon g-2 calculations between phenomenological and lattice QCD methods leaves the anomaly's reality unsettled.
- For the muon g-2, the hard part is computing the strong-force (QCD) contributions, which can be done either by measuring them phenomenologically (giving the 4 sigma anomaly) or by direct lattice QCD computer simulation; a lattice calculation published the same day as Fermilab's result claims the theory fits the data with less than 2 sigma discrepancy, meaning there may be no anomaly to explain—so the result's reality is theoretically unsettled.
“these lattice calculations claim that the theory fits the data fine, that there isn't really any discrepancy, or more like there's less than a 2 sigma discrepancy between the theoretical predictions and the experimental result.”
- The theoretical disagreement between the phenomenological and lattice QCD methods for the muon g-2 is answerable without building a bigger particle accelerator—it requires better theoretical calculation (possibly a bigger computer for more accurate lattice QCD)—but lattice QCD is notoriously difficult, so even though it agrees with experiment we should suspend judgment rather than assume it is correct.
“these lattice calculations claim that the theory fits the data fine, that there isn't really any discrepancy, or more like there's less than a 2 sigma discrepancy between the theoretical predictions and the experimental result.”
Any new particles explaining these anomalies face tight experimental constraints on their mass and coupling strength.
- Any new particle invented to explain the muon anomalies must be heavy enough that it wasn't already produced in Z boson decays at LEP or seen directly at the LHC, but not so heavy that its virtual contributions vanish (since heavier particles contribute less to Feynman diagrams), placing its mass at roughly Large Hadron Collider energies—hundreds to thousands of GeV.
“So on the one hand, we have a lower limit on how massive these particles can be; on the other hand, there's kind of an upper limit... they can't be too heavy, otherwise they wouldn't have any effect at all.”
- The fact that both anomalies involve muons does not indicate something special about muons; muons are simply a good tool for finding new physics because at ~200 times the electron mass they couple more strongly to the Higgs and have more 'oomph' to produce and be affected by virtual particles, yet live long enough to study in a storage ring—it is 'looking under the lamp post.'
“The point of the muons is just that they're a good place to look, it's looking under the lamp post... Muon are about 200 times heavier than electrons, which makes them more sensitive to new physics.”
- B mesons (containing a bottom quark) sit in a sweet spot for probing new physics: they are heavy enough to potentially couple to undiscovered high-energy physics, yet not so heavy that they decay before they can be studied, unlike mesons made from top quarks which decay too fast to form.
“B mesons, in some sense, are in a sweet spot, they're in a spot where you have some access to physics beyond what we've seen so far, but you have enough time to make these things, look at them and figure out what their properties should be”