What this covers

Charlie Jane Anders, a multiple-award-winning novelist and co-founder of io9, sits down to discuss the craft of storytelling as a learnable skill. The conversation moves systematically through what separates a publishable story from a mere clever idea. Anders argues that a premise—say, everyone starts walking on their hands—is only the spark; the real work begins when a writer finds a specific character with their own wants and obstacles through whose life the premise's larger implications unfold. She frames this progression from idea to premise to fully realized story as each step being roughly an order of magnitude harder than the last, and most of the friction happens not in dreaming up scenarios but in the disciplined work of transformation through character, plot, and revision.

The conversation ranges across what makes characters magnetic to readers: giving them orthogonal personal agendas that pull away from the central plot, building genuine interiority into supporting characters so they feel like whole people rather than NPCs, and understanding that conflict as struggle need not be antagonistic—it can be gentle disagreement between people who respect each other. Anders discusses the mechanics of dialogue, the dangers of trying to forecast realistic futures (given their fractal consequences), and how stories inevitably carry a point of view about the world, whether intentional or not. She also addresses wish fulfillment as a legitimate storytelling mode when complications are embedded within it, drawing on her own Young Adult novel Victories Greater Than Death, and argues that writing need not be solitary—that communal practice through workshops and writing groups sustains the work better than isolation.

Sharpest takeaway

Anders argues that storytelling is a learnable craft in which the hard, valuable work is not generating ideas but transforming a premise into a character-driven story with genuine (often gentle) conflict and a coherent moral point of view.

  • Ideas/premises are the easy part; converting them into working fiction through character, plot, and revision is the difficult craft.
  • Conflict is far broader than antagonism—it is struggle, including gentle and internal struggle—and is what makes characters interesting.
  • Every story carries a moral point of view and builds a model of the world for an imagined reader.

The argument · threads9 threads · 35 claims
0.76

Characters become compelling when they face struggle, make choices, and pursue their own distinct personal agendas.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • As a general rule, characters who never make choices, question themselves, or work for their goals are not interesting; storytelling centers on struggle—the human heart in conflict with itself—though the struggle can be gentle, cheerful, or against the universe rather than other people.

    “characters who don't have to kind of grapple with things in some way are not usually interesting characters.”

  • Characters become more compelling—and readers care more about the central goal—when they have their own selfish, personal agendas orthogonal to the main action, so a personal quest can be more engaging than a galaxy-saving one.

    “I always like characters to maybe have a, be a little bit selfish. I get bored if a character doesn't ever have their own agenda that's kind of separate from or orthogonal to the main action.”

  • A premise (e.g., everyone starts walking on their hands) is only a spark; it becomes a story once you find a specific character with their own wants, needs, and obstacles, through whose interesting vantage point the premise's larger second-order effects are felt.

    “you try to find a way in and you try to find a character who is affected by it in a way that seems interesting... And meanwhile, you have to kind of think about the larger implications and the second order effects”

  • Supporting characters feel like real people rather than NPCs when they have inner lives and their own desires—wanting to be off doing something else—rather than existing only to serve the protagonist; writing detailed origin stories for them helps give that interiority.

    “with All the Birds in the Sky, one thing I did was I sat down and wrote a detailed origin story for 20 different characters in the book, because... if I know where they come from and how they got here and what motivated them before the story started, then I can at least kinda have a sense of where they're going”

  • Because you can always find three people on Twitter saying anything and tweets are embeddable, social media has made trend journalism too easy—if tweets weren't embeddable, journalists would have to do more legwork to find people saying things.

    “Sometimes I wish tweets weren't embeddable, because I feel like if tweets were not embeddable, journalists would have to actually do a little bit more leg work to find people saying stuff.”

0.72

Plot must grow organically from character and premise, not precede them; ideas become stories only through the hard work of finding how they shape specific people's lives.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Stories can originate from very different starting points—a 'what if' premise, a character, or a setting—but in none of these cases does the plot come first; the writer's job is to turn that starting point into a story, which is distinct from a plot.

    “in neither case do you have a story. So in neither case did the plot come first, right?”

  • A 'HAITE' story (Here's An Idea; The End) merely explores an idea without a character on a journey; such stories can be published if the ideas are cool enough, but most of the time a real story requires the idea to shape a specific person's life.

    “HAITE is spelled H-A-I-T-E, and it stands for, 'Here's An Idea; The End.' And you can... There are actually professionally-published stories that are HAITE stories.”

  • Starting from only a setting—humans living on a tidally-locked planet with native lifeforms—it took Anders about two years to find the story, illustrating how much harder converting a bare premise into a story is than starting from character.

    “It took me two years, basically, to turn that setting into a story. And it was really kind of agonizing, it was really kind of excruciating.”

  • Novice writers overrate the idea and underrate the work of turning an idea into working fiction; the progression from story idea to premise to a premise expressed as conflicts, incidents, and emotional catharses is each roughly an order of magnitude harder than the previous step.

    “People who haven't gone through that process sometimes overrate the idea part of it, and underrate the turning the idea into a working piece of fiction part.”

0.58

Writers must revise systematically to plant setups, cut repetitions, and make solutions feel earned rather than arbitrary.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • A satisfying murder mystery requires working out the crime in advance from the murderer's rational point of view, because antagonists who behave in arbitrary ways just to connect the dots break the story's coherence.

    “they had to be thinking rationally from their perspective the entire time”

  • Anders generally avoids heavy pre-outlining to leave room for surprises, but plot-heavy work like the Victories Greater Than Death trilogy required much more outlining to track setups and payoffs that would otherwise bite the writer later.

    “With the young adult books... I definitely did a lot more outlining because those books are much more plot heavy... 'Okay, I'm setting up this thing here and it has to pay off here.'”

  • Outside of murder mysteries, a story's solution usually has to grow out of its problem so it feels plausible and earned, and revision lets you retroactively plant the necessary setups earlier so the audience never knows they weren't in the first draft.

    “the problem does contain the seeds of its own solution a little bit”

  • Borrowing journalism's rule that 'if something happens three times it's a trend,' a character doing something three times reads to the audience as constant; in revision you can cut ten repetitions down to two or three and readers will still perceive it as happening a lot.

    “in journalism, there's an unspoken rule that if something happens three times it's a trend.”

0.54

Violence in stories carries unavoidable meaning and must be depicted with realistic emotional consequences, especially for teen readers.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • While drafting Victories Greater Than Death, an unplanned scene in which the heroine must kill and then emotionally breaks down made Anders realize violence should be a struggle with consequences, turning a throwaway middle episode into a turning point that reshaped the ending and the whole trilogy.

    “once I had that part of the book, it didn't just feel like a one-off episode... It felt like a turning point and it felt like the rest of the book had to kind of be about that on some level”

  • Depicting violence realistically with its emotional consequences—rather than casual 'killing, killing, killing'—matters especially for teen readers living amid school shootings, and teen YA readers explicitly want to see violence and its consequences handled realistically.

    “I want to see a violence and the consequences of violence dealt with in a realistic way. I don't just want to see killing, killing, killing with no thought to the consequences.”

  • Stories inevitably carry a meaning that is political, personal, and social; showing a character doing something communicates a point of view about it, so a story depicting constant killing is, whether intended or not, saying something about violence.

    “stories have a meaning that is political and personal and social, and that if you show a character doing a thing, there are ways that you indicate kind of a point of view about that”

0.54

Writing is a learnable craft requiring deliberate work, not an innate gift; sustained practice and community support are essential.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Mental activities that involve concentration and thinking—including writing and math—can be learned by anyone willing to work hard at them, even if some people start with more aptitude; writing is therefore a craft, not an innate gift.

    “most things that are mental that involve concentration, that involve thinking, anybody can learn to do... anybody could, if they really worked at it, be good at math, anybody who really worked at it could be good at writing. I think that it just takes a lot of work.”

  • Writing distinct, naturalistic dialogue means escaping your own voice—by eavesdropping on real speech and giving characters distinct sentence rhythms and catchphrases—and reading work aloud is increasingly necessary to catch problems invisible to the writer used to their own style.

    “this character talks more kind of shorter, punchy sentences, this character talks in long run-on sentences... Sometimes I'll give a character a couple of catch phrases”

  • Writing should be fun and playful and need not be a solitary, lonesome activity; beginning writers should make it communal—through writing groups, sharing online, open mics, and workshops—because a shared experience is often a better way to sustain the work.

    “find ways to make it communal, find a writing group, find people to read your work to, share your work online... find community, because writing doesn't have to be this terrible solitary lonesome thing”

0.50

Conflict need not be antagonistic; it can be gentle disagreement among people who respect each other.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Conflict in fiction does not require enemies, shouting, or nastiness; it can be subtle and gentle disagreement between people who like and respect each other, and people who wish movies had less conflict usually want gentler, less antagonistic conflict rather than none.

    “it took me a long time to realize that conflict is not just people being nasty to each other... Conflict comes in many different forms, and a lot of times, conflict is subtle.”

  • When bad things happen or characters struggle, it creates the opportunity to show others supporting and helping that person; if nothing taxing ever happens, the story loses the chance to depict how people hold each other up.

    “when bad things do happen or when people are struggling with things, it's an opportunity to show everybody else supporting that person... if nothing scary or taxing or troublesome ever happens, then you don't have that opportunity to show how we support each other”

0.45

Stories help people understand reality, gain emotional resilience, and imagine possibilities; escapism enables real-world change rather than opposing it.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Humans tell stories as a way of dealing with stress and epistemic crises and of modeling reality—working out how the world functions by showing that if you do X, then Y will happen.

    “storytelling is kind of an engine of... It's a way of modeling reality. It's a way of modeling reality and it's a way of kind of showing like if you do this, this will happen, basically.”

  • Escapism is a healthy impulse rather than the opposite of effecting change; being able to escape into stories gives people the emotional resilience and inspiration to go out and make the real world better—the two go hand in hand.

    “Being able to have escapism and be able to escape into stories when you need to will give you the emotional resilience to go out and make the world a better place in reality.”

  • You have to imagine something before you can do it; speculative fiction about space travel preceded actual space travel, and dramatizations need not be realistic to plant the 'what if' that motivates real achievement.

    “people had not yet been into space when we started to write stories about, 'Here's what it would be like to go into space.' And you know, I think, I say this all the time, but you have to imagine something before you can do it.”

  • Stories let you experience situations vicariously—living imaginatively through events you couldn't or shouldn't experience in real life—so books save you from the tiresome process of learning purely from experience.

    “Books are wonderful because they save you from the tiresome process of learning from experience.”

0.44

Accurate future prediction is nearly impossible due to fractal consequences; writers should either forecast carefully forward or build vivid far-futures without explaining their origins.

7 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Most pandemic fiction—especially movies and TV—cuts corners and dramatizes unrealistically, so it will look eye-roll-worthy after living through an actual pandemic; sci-fi is not a purely didactic, predictive genre.

    “I feel like we're going to look back at most of our sort of pandemic fiction, and especially movies and TV, and kinda roll our eyes after having actually lived through a pandemic.”

  • Writers always have an implied ideal reader in mind, and because defaults tend to assume the reader shares the writer's identity and privilege, it takes imaginative labor—and tools like sensitivity readers and reading diverse fiction—to project to a reader unlike oneself, which is where many writers fall down.

    “there's a certain amount of imaginative labor that you have to do to kind of project yourself to a reader who is not you, who is not someone who shares your viewpoint.”

  • Anders no longer bases characters on real people because it is limiting and keeps the writer from truly knowing them as fictional characters; she prefers to start from an interesting 'what if' spark and let the character develop independently.

    “basing characters on real people just gets you into trouble sometimes... it's kind of a limiting thing and it kind of keeps you from really knowing them as a fictional character”

  • Wish fulfillment is an underrated storytelling mode, but it must contain complications and problems or it becomes boring—Anders built Victories Greater Than Death from a teenage wish (aliens whisking her away) but made it juicy by asking what goes wrong.

    “The thing about wish fulfilment is there have to be complications and problems or else it's just boring.”

  • Holistic prediction even five years out is unreliable; someone in March 2016 trying to predict March 2021 would not have seen much of what actually happened coming.

    “if someone in March 2016 was trying to predict March 2021, there's some stuff that they would not have seen coming, let's just say.”

  • Writing a trilogy is much harder than a single book; middle volumes are especially difficult because they must move things forward without resolving everything, and choices made in the first book can force re-outlining of the rest.

    “middle parts of trilogies are especially hard because you can't resolve everything, you have to kinda just move things forward, but not resolve everything.”

  • Imagining a realistic future is nearly impossible because every change has fractal, second-order consequences; writers can either forecast forward from the present (very hard) or, more safely, pick a far-future point and make it vividly weird without explaining how we got there.

    “it's really hard because it's kind of fractal or whatever... there's like every single change has a million unintended consequences and second order effects”

0.40

Mechanical and stylistic choices like POV, tone, and genre have different revision costs and shape what kinds of events fit the story.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Mechanical choices like first vs. third person can be changed relatively easily even after a draft, but the harder-to-change decision is tone and genre, because tone determines which kinds of events are allowed in the story.

    “the main thing that you need to think about that is harder to change once you have a first draft is kind of just the sense of tone and vague sense of genre”

  • Giving a large supporting cast genuine inner lives is a different problem from making characters sound distinct in dialogue; the former requires each character to have their own agendas, the latter requires distinct verbal patterns.

    “That's actually two separate things... One is, how do you create a larger cast... who feel like people... And then the other question is a question of dialogue and how to make people sound different”

  • If a writer is surprised by what happens during drafting, the story is alive and 'cooking'; if not, the writer is on auto-pilot, regurgitating familiar stories—so self-surprise is a useful diagnostic of creative engagement.

    “if I'm surprising myself, that means that the story is kinda cooking. If there's no... If I'm not being surprised by what's happening, usually, that means I'm on auto-pilot, and that I'm just kinda regurgitating stories I've read before”