131 | Avi Loeb on Taking Aliens Seriously
What this covers
Astronomer Avi Loeb and physicist Sean Carroll discuss whether scientists should treat the possibility of advanced extraterrestrial civilizations as a serious, testable scientific question. The conversation centers on Oumuamua, an interstellar object whose unusual properties—non-gravitational acceleration, a pancake-like shape, and motion consistent with the local standard of rest—Loeb has proposed could indicate an artificial light sail. Rather than debating whether aliens exist, the speakers examine how science evaluates anomalous evidence and why the academic community has resisted taking such hypotheses seriously. Loeb argues that Earth-like planets are abundant enough (roughly one in two sun-like stars) that the Principle of Cosmic Modesty makes other technological civilizations statistically probable. He contends that dismissing the artificial-origin hypothesis reflects institutional herd mentality rather than reasoned engagement with evidence.
The discussion ranges across how scientists should handle provocative ideas, the gap between scientific standards and actual practice, and what signatures of alien technology might look like. Loeb points out that the light-sail hypothesis is genuinely falsifiable—unlike inflation theory or string theory, which he argues accommodate any observation—making it scientifically stronger by standard criteria. Carroll pushes back on the Principle of Cosmic Modesty itself, warning that claims to cosmic non-specialness can smuggle in their own presumptions. Both speakers acknowledge that distinguishing innovative ideas worth pursuing from unfounded speculation is genuinely difficult. Loeb criticizes how academic funding mechanisms reward mainstream work and reinforce echo chambers, while Carroll notes the countervailing bias against anything resembling popular-media sensationalism. The conversation also touches on technosignatures more reliable than oxygen biosignatures, the Fermi Paradox, and whether broadcasting humanity's presence to the cosmos poses existential risk.
Loeb argues that scientists should take the possibility of advanced extraterrestrial civilizations seriously as a testable scientific question, and that the dismissal of such hypotheses (like 'Oumuamua being an artificial light sail) reflects prejudice and herd mentality rather than reasoned engagement with evidence.
- Earth-like planets are common, making the prior probability of other life high (principle of cosmic modesty)
- 'Oumuamua's peculiar properties (non-gravitational acceleration without cometary tail, pancake shape, local-standard-of-rest frame) make an artificial origin a falsifiable hypothesis worth pursuing
- Academic science systematically underfunds and bullies innovative/anomalous hypotheses while tolerating unfalsifiable mainstream ideas like inflation and string theory
Oumuamua's unusual geometry, brightness variation, and acceleration indicate a non-natural origin requiring serious investigation.
- A decade before Oumuamua, Loeb and colleagues forecast the abundance of interstellar objects Pan-STARRS should detect based on known solar system ejection processes, predicting an abundance short by a factor of a hundred to a hundred million relative to what is needed to explain seeing an Oumuamua-like object; thus its mere detection is itself a surprise.
“We predicted an abundance of objects that is short by a factor of a hundred, to a hundred million, then the population needed to explain Oumuamua. So the mere detection of the subject is by itself a surprise.”
- Oumuamua's reflected brightness varied by a factor of 10 as it tumbled (period ~8 hours), implying an extreme geometry; modeling of the light curve shows at the 90% confidence level that the object is flattened (pancake-shaped) rather than elongated/cigar-shaped, an unprecedented feature among solar system objects.
“the light changed the brightness of the object... changed by a factor of 10 as it tumbled... at the 90% confidence, you can show that it should be flattened, not elongated, not cigar shape, but rather pancake shape.”
- The Spitzer Space Telescope detected no heat coming from Oumuamua, and given the amount of sunlight it reflected, it appears to have been more shiny than an average asteroid or comet—a simple question of what it is made of (a shiny rock or metal) that could be answered with existing technology by monitoring the sky for more such objects.
“the Spitzer space telescope did not detect any heat coming from it. Given the amount of sunlight that it reflected, it looks like it was more shiny than an average asteroid or comet.”
- Oumuamua exhibited a non-gravitational excess push away from the sun (reported May 2018), which on a comet would come from outgassing ice acting as a rocket, but the Spitzer Space Telescope detected no cometary tail, no carbon-based molecules, and no dust—making the source of the push the object's central peculiarity.
“this object exhibited an excess push away from the sun, beyond the gravity of the sun... But then there was no cometary tail and the Spitzer Space Telescope... didn't detect any carbon based molecules, or dust”
- Loeb and Bialy proposed that the non-gravitational push on Oumuamua results from sunlight bouncing off its surface, which requires a large surface area relative to its weight; calculations showed a solar sail / light sail less than a millimeter thick would produce the observed acceleration, and this is a falsifiable hypothesis testable by finding similar objects in future.
“this push that the object exhibited is as a result of sunlight bouncing off the surface of this object... a Solar Sail, a LightSail would do it if it has a thickness of less than a millimeter.”
- Mainstream alternatives to the light-sail hypothesis face survival problems: a hydrogen iceberg (proposed to explain a tail-less push) would evaporate over the millions of years needed to reach us from a molecular cloud, and a 'dust bunny' a hundred times less dense than air the size of a football field is hard to imagine surviving such a journey while spinning every eight hours.
“a hydrogen iceberg would not survive the journey. It would evaporate over the millions of years that it takes it to reach us from a distant molecular cloud.”
- Oumuamua resided in a special frame of reference called the local standard of rest (the average motion of all nearby stars)—a 'galactic parking lot' where you cannot trace where an object came from; only one in 500 stars is so much at rest in that frame, and the solar system essentially collided with the stationary object like a ship hitting a buoy.
“Only one in 500 stars is so much addressed in that frame as Oumuamua was, it was not moving at all in our local frame. Then we bumped into it like a ship bumping into a buoy.”
- Even when an object is only a point of light, astronomers can constrain its geometry from how its reflected sunlight varies over time as it spins; assuming uniform surface reflectance and knowing the positions of the sun and object, the pattern of brightness change for a pancake-shaped object spinning differs from that of a cigar-shaped object, so the shape can be modeled—a calculation simple enough for a high schooler.
“if you imagine a pancake like object, the change in the amount of light that you get as the object is spinning, would be different than if you were to have a cigar shaped object spinning.”
- The 2020 SO object, later identified as the booster of a failed 1966 Surveyor 2 Moon Lander mission, demonstrated that we can recognize artificial objects from their orbit and the absence of a cometary tail, including detecting solar-radiation push that revealed it was hollow—a method analogous to how Oumuamua's anomalies were interpreted, except Oumuamua was not made by us.
“we are able to recognize the artificial objects like 2020 SO, based on their orbit and the fact that they don't show a cometary tail. To me, it reminded of Oumuamua except Oumuamua was not produced by us.”
- Comets are mostly rock with some water ice (icy dirt rather than dirty ice); in the vacuum of space, water ice on a small body cannot melt to liquid because that requires an atmosphere and external pressure, so when a comet nears the sun the ice sublimates directly into gas, which we observe as the cometary tail.
“comets are mostly a rock and they have some water ice on them... if you warm it up, when the rock gets close to the sun, the ice sublimates directly into gas and that's what we see as the cometary tail.”
Scientific integrity demands collecting evidence without prejudice rather than assuming answers beforehand.
- Science is about evidence, not prejudice; as Galileo demonstrated against philosophers who refused to look through his telescope, facts are those things that do not go away regardless of what we believe, so scientists should collect evidence without prejudice rather than assume they already know the answer.
“the bottom line is prejudice should not guide us but evidence should. Evidence or facts are those things that do not go away, irrespective what we think.”
- Breakthroughs and discoveries occur only when scientists pay attention to anomalies rather than shoving them under the rug of conservatism; as with gravitational lenses that appeared as unexplained giant arcs in old cluster images and were ignored until the field became popular, dismissing anomalies as noise becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy that prevents discovery.
“breakthroughs and discoveries occur only when you pay attention to anomalies. If you are not open to wonderful things, to new things, you will never discover them.”
- Scientists should behave more like children, who explore the world innocently and open-mindedly without bullying or ego-boosting, rather than bullying proposals that differ from commonly adopted ideas the way kids bully those who look different; criticism should be based on evidence and rational argument, which would improve the health and honesty of scientific inquiry.
“kids often are innocent when they explore the world. They don't do it for boosting their ego... I would very much like my colleagues to behave more like kids, like being open-minded”
- Loeb adopts the 'principle of cosmic modesty' as a working assumption (not a thesis): believing in humility and not assuming we are special or unique, because most of the time when you feel you are special you are proven wrong—a stance meant to let one examine evidence without prejudice rather than block the pursuit of evidence.
“I call it the principle of cosmic modesty. I just believe in modesty, being humble and not believing that one is special because most of the time when you feel that you're special, you're proven wrong.”
Advanced civilizations vastly older than ours would possess technology indistinguishable from magic and remain undetectable by current means.
- Because our technologies evolve exponentially on a few-year timescale, a galactic civilization that is even a thousand, million, or billion years more advanced than us would possess technologies indistinguishable from magic or miracles, making it hard for us to even know what to look for when searching for them.
“giving it them a thousand years, a million years or a billion years, basically it would look like magic to us. We would see things that look like miracles”
- It is extremely challenging to detect technological life at great distances: no telescope on Earth can detect even a giant spaceship at the edge of the solar system, and as an illustration, the city of Tokyo placed on Pluto would be at the limit of what the Hubble Space Telescope could see after integrating for a few weeks.
“the city of Tokyo, if you put it on Pluto, then that would be at the limit of the Hubble Space Telescope. If it integrates for a few weeks, it will be able to see it.”
- If there are gram-scale spacecraft (like Breakthrough Starshot's design) flying through the solar system, we would never notice them—reinforcing that advanced civilizations' probes could already be present and undetected.
“if there are one gram spacecrafts flying through the solar system, we would never notice them.”
- Self-replicating von Neumann probes or alien objects may already surround us undetected because current surveys like Pan-STARRS can only detect objects over ~100 meters at Earth-sun distances; smaller objects or objects moving extremely fast (e.g., near light speed) would be dismissed by astronomers as artifacts rather than recognized as genuine sources.
“If something would move at the speed of light across our sky, I can guarantee that no astronomer will pay serious attention to it.”
- Loeb's team believes they discovered the nearest black hole, about a thousand times the mass of the sun, at a distance of a few hundred light years from us—a completely unexpected finding for which they found evidence, with the paper currently being refereed.
“we think that we discovered the nearest black hole, and it's about a thousand times the mass of the sun and it's at a distance of a few hundred light years from us.”
Mainstream astronomy irrationally favors biosignature searches over technosignature searches despite superior scientific merit of the latter.
- There is an inconsistency in mainstream astronomy: oxygen is treated as a biosignature for proposed billion-dollar telescopes even though it can be produced abiotically (e.g., by breaking water), while phosphine on Venus was dismissed as possibly volcanic; CFCs would be a far more convincing technosignature because such complex industrial molecules cannot be produced by natural processes, so search programs should target CFCs as much as oxygen.
“if we search for signatures of molecules in the atmospheres of planets, why don't we search for CFCs as much as we search for oxygen?”
- The mainstream of astronomy is advocating hundreds of millions to billions of dollars for observatories to search for biosignatures like oxygen and methane (which at best indicate microbial life), while allocating zero dollars to the search for intelligent life—a choice driven by social pressure and herd mentality rather than reason, given that we have the technology to address the question.
“There is $0 allocated in those plans for the search for intelligent life.”
- The reluctance to study alien civilizations stems from social pressure, bullying, and herd mentality, plus the fact that scientists gain ego boosts from belonging to an elite club doing intellectual gymnastics (like anti-de Sitter space or extra dimensions with no evidence) to impress peers and win honors, rather than echoing the interests of the public—a self-inflicted wound that marks academia as part of the elite.
“right now it's social pressure, and bullying and herd mentality.”
- Fields like string theory have been popular for five decades with no evidence and are not even predictive enough to be falsified, becoming self-perpetuating cultures where evidence is no longer the oxygen that drives them but rather intellectual gymnastics—a dangerous mode of operation reminiscent of Aristotle and the ancient Greeks, which represents a retreat from the evidence-based progress science has made.
“You have string theory for five decades being very popular, no evidence and it's now not even predictive as to what we might look for in order to falsify it.”
Light-sail technology, developed by humanity, offers a plausible explanation for Oumuamua that is falsifiable and scientifically rigorous.
- Because the imagination of scientists is limited by the technologies they have mastered—we searched for radio signals after developing radio, looked for lasers after developing lasers—Loeb's involvement in developing light sails for Breakthrough Starshot is precisely what made it natural for him to hypothesize that another civilization, perhaps long ago, mastered the same technology, suggesting it could be common.
“our imagination is limited by the technologies that we have, and we cannot imagine things that we have not mastered ourselves.”
- The light-sail hypothesis is genuinely falsifiable—we need only find another object with similar properties and photograph it or get more data—which makes it scientifically superior to ideas like cosmic inflation, which Alan Guth himself characterized as a framework that cannot be falsified because any cosmological data can be accommodated by some version of it.
“this is a falsifiable, unlike inflation, it's falsifiable hypothesis in the sense that, we just need to find another object that shows similar properties”
- To reach the nearest star Proxima Centauri (4.25 light years away) within a human lifetime of ~20 years, a spacecraft must move at a fifth of the speed of light; Breakthrough Starshot's solution is to push a gram-scale payload on a light sail (roughly person-sized, sub-micron thick) with a 100-gigawatt laser, accelerating it to that speed over a few minutes, since conventional probes like Voyager would take 50,000 years.
“if you have a laser of 100 gigawatts shining on a sail that is roughly the size of a person outside the atmosphere, you can launch the sail to a fifth of the speed of light over a few minutes”
- Just as naturally produced seashells on a beach all look different but a plastic bottle is obviously artificially made, Oumuamua—if it is a light sail—could be a 'message in a bottle' from another civilization, a hypothesis falsifiable by looking for additional similar objects in the future.
“perhaps, or Oumuamua is a message in a bottle from another civilization, if it is a light sail”
Life and civilizations are likely common because chemical conditions enabling life occur throughout the galaxy in vast numbers.
- Recent evidence shows that sun-like stars host an Earth-sized planet in their habitable zone in roughly half of cases, meaning the Earth-sun system is very common with billions of such systems in the Milky Way; rolling the dice of life that many times makes it very likely we are not special.
“sun-like stars have a planet of the size of the earth in their habitable zone in roughly half of the cases. And that means that the earth sun system is very common. There are billions of such systems within the Milky Way galaxy”
- Imagining extraterrestrial life as 'more of the same' is the wrong approach; life on disconnected planets need not share our genetic heritage, so for example grass on Proxima Centauri b might not be green because that star emits infrared rather than visible light, and animals there might have infrared eyes—we should expect to be shocked by both alien life and alien technology.
“The grass on Proxima Centauri b might not be green because that star is producing infrared light. It's not producing visible light.”
- Our form of life is probably common because Earth's chemical conditions are reproduced in many places, and like making many different cakes from the same ingredients, far more sophisticated and advanced civilizations than ours likely exist—so we are not necessarily the most intelligent or interesting life, and advanced civilizations would have little reason to be interested in us.
“When you look at recipe books, you can make many different cakes out of the same ingredients... I'm sure we are not the most tasty cake that one can imagine out of the same ingredients.”
Advanced civilizations might choose isolation or leave detectable traces despite vast separation from biological life like humanity.
- Very advanced civilizations might develop 'social distancing on a cosmic scale,' creating comfortable self-contained cocoons and closing themselves off from contact—possibly via uploading consciousness into computers, which would remove the evolutionary instincts driving exploration—yet they could still be detected because the second law of thermodynamics requires them to produce trash that reveals their existence.
“a very advanced civilizations might develop social distancing on a cosmic scale. They might create their own cocoons and then basically close themselves off”
- The Fermi Paradox ('where is everybody?') is not a serious concern because we may be too common to be of interest to advanced civilizations (like ants ignored by a pedestrian), and our instruments may simply not be sensitive enough to detect signals—analogous to a fishing net with holes too big to catch fish.
“when a pedestrian goes on the sidewalk, the pedestrian doesn't check every ant that is under his or her feet and we might be so common that we are of no interest to anyone”
- Even if technological civilizations are typically short-lived and mostly dead, we can detect them through 'space archaeology'—finding relics such as burnt-up planetary surfaces, industrial atmospheric pollution whose source industries are gone, photovoltaic cells with a characteristic spectral reflectance edge coating planets, or abandoned megastructures.
“the same thing we can do in space. We can do space archeology and find, for example, burnt up surfaces of planets, industrial pollution of atmospheres of planets, where the industries that polluted the atmosphere are not around anymore”
- It is prudent to search for evidence of other civilizations quietly rather than broadcast our presence, because based on human history there were many predator cultures that conquered new lands to harvest resources and dominate; unfortunately we have already been careless, with anti-ballistic missile radars after WWII producing signals detectable across tens of light years.
“based on human history, there were lots of predators. Cultures that were more advanced and were trying to concur new lands... So there is no reason for us to be too loud. I think we should be quiet and first listen.”
Scientists' technological imagination is bounded by tools they have mastered, creating blind spots in what phenomena they recognize.
- Detection of faint signals follows a threshold-sensitivity pattern: just as LIGO detected nothing for years until it crossed a sensitivity threshold in 2015 and then found a flood of gravitational wave events, the search for alien signals may yield nothing until instruments reach the required sensitivity, after which detections could become abundant.
“for many years, LIGO did not detect anything. And then 2015, it reached a threshold sensitivity, and suddenly there was a flood of events.”
- Radio observatories built to image hydrogen in the infant universe (at 21cm wavelength) are hampered by radio/TV interference at similar frequencies, which suggested the same observatories could eavesdrop on leakage of radio and TV broadcasts from alien civilizations; calculations showed existing cosmology observatories could detect radio signals from civilizations like ours out to tens of light years.
“we should be able with existing observatories targeting cosmology, we should be able to detect the radio signals from civilizations like ours.”
- A possible solution to what happened before the Big Bang is that a sufficiently advanced civilization, having developed a theory of quantum gravity, could create a baby universe in a laboratory; if so, our own universe may have been created by a previous civilization, with each universe spawning civilizations intelligent enough to create the next.
“the universe like ours produces a civilization like ours, that they gets to be intelligent enough to figure out how to make a baby universe. And then a new universe comes out of us”
Academic funding and peer pressure reward mainstream consensus and ego-driven intellectual gymnastics over genuine innovation and discovery.
- The most undervalued quality in science is innovation; currently grant funding mostly goes to mainstream ideas that add nuance to existing themes because selection committees are mainstream people who create echo chambers and fund work that boosts their own egos, so a fixed fraction of funds should be allocated to innovative thinking—the commercial sector (Google, Bell Labs) recognizes the value of blue-sky research more than academia does.
“the most undervalued quality that I would like to highlight is innovation... A lot of the funding for grants is given to mainstream ideas that just add the nuance on an existing theme.”
Credible evidence of alien contact is impossible to conceal, whereas UFO reports remain unsubstantiated despite improved instrumentation.
- The discrediting of alien research partly traces to UFO reports that are not reproducible and do not stand up to scientific scrutiny; tellingly, these reports remained fuzzy 50 years ago and remain fuzzy now despite vastly better camera technology, which signals that something is wrong with them—genuine phenomena should become clearer as instrumentation improves.
“They were fuzzy 50 years ago with the cameras that existed back then, and now we have much better cameras and they're also fuzzy.”
- Claims that governments are concealing contact with an alien 'Galactic Federation' are complete nonsense, because our governments are not sufficiently competent to hide such an important revelation; conclusive evidence for anything that important would inevitably become known to everyone.
“I think our governments are not sufficiently competent to hide such an important revelation.”
Humanity should spread copies of itself beyond Earth to ensure survival while respecting the naturalist's concern for untouched worlds.
- All of humanity's eggs are currently in one basket (Earth), so it makes sense to spread copies elsewhere—like the Gutenberg printing press making each Bible copy less precious and survivable—so that if catastrophe strikes Earth, humanity survives; rather than a giant Noah's Ark, this could be done with a CubeSat carrying a computer, 3D printer, AI, and stored genetic information to reconstruct life at a destination with raw materials.
“right now all of our eggs are in one basket, the earth. It would make a lot of sense to spread the eggs in different baskets.”
- Whether to seed life elsewhere depends on how much one values our life relative to what may arise naturally elsewhere; a naturalist (like Thoreau) would argue we should avoid contaminating other places because nature is precious and if we perish, so be it, while those who value life's long-term future would make many copies—and based on how we treat our own planet, the naturalist approach would likely be less popular.
“if you are naturalists like Thoreau was, then you would argue we should avoid contaminating other places with our life as much as possible, because nature is precious”