120 | Jeremy England on Biology, Thermodynamics, and the Bible
What this covers
Jeremy England, a physicist and ordained rabbi, joins Sean Carroll to explore how the physical behaviors we associate with life—self-replication, energy harvesting, prediction, and homeostasis—emerge from thermodynamic principles rather than residing in some separate biological realm. The core argument proceeds through non-equilibrium statistical mechanics, where tools like the Crooks relation and Jarzynski equality allow us to calculate probabilities for microscopic trajectories in driven systems. England proposes dissipative adaptation as the mechanism: systems subjected to patterned external energy—a particular frequency of vibration, specific photon wavelengths, or chemical gradients—become biased toward configurations exceptionally matched to that pattern, as if trapped in the high passes of an energy landscape carved by the work being done on them. Simulations of springs and masses, or disordered materials under patterned forcing, exhibit this behavior: they self-organize to absorb energy efficiently, then settle into homeostasis, rearranging stably only when the driving pattern changes.
The conversation ranges across the distinct life-like behaviors themselves, treating life as a bundle of life-like behaviors rather than seeking a single boundary between animate and inanimate. Entropy as counting / probability reframing recasts the second law not as a mystical bias toward disorder but as a consequence of combinatorics—though organized work can drive systems into low-entropy states that remain probable under the right conditions. England argues that novelty through combination—the interplay of carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, and other elements—is essential to impressive non-equilibrium life-likeness, and that recognizing fine-tuning requires sufficiently complex, patterned environmental statistics. The discussion then pivots to different languages for describing the world: physics speaks quantitatively and draws no a priori line between life and non-life, while biology operates qualitatively and takes life as given. England then addresses the relationship between science and Scripture, arguing that science as a non-totalizing language—powerful for communication and replication but deliberately limited in scope—need not conflict with biblical contemplation of material phenomena. The Hebrew Bible's tangible imagery of mud, water, and branching sediment patterns offers intuitive parallels to how irreversible dissipation shapes emergent structures, without requiring the text to encode modern physics.
England argues that life's hallmark behaviors—self-replication, energy harvesting, prediction, and homeostasis—can be understood through non-equilibrium statistical mechanics as outcomes of 'dissipative adaptation,' where systems driven by patterned external energy get biased toward configurations exceptionally matched to their environment, and that this physical understanding need not conflict with religious contemplation of life.
- Life is best treated not via a single definition but as a bundle of distinct life-like behaviors studied individually in physical terms
- Non-equilibrium fluctuation theorems (Crooks, Jarzynski) let us assign probabilities to trajectories, making self-organization tractable
- Scientific naturalism is one powerful but non-totalizing language; biblical/qualitative experience offers a complementary, intuitive frame
Self-replication and life-like behavior require irreversible dissipation and constant energy work.
- Self-replication necessarily must be powered by irreversible dissipation: making a copy of yourself faster than that copy falls apart requires absorbing work from a source and dissipating it as heat, which is why this life-like behavior cannot occur at thermal equilibrium.
“that has to be powered by irreversible dissipation. You have to absorb work from some source and then dissipate it as heat in order to be able to do that.”
- What is striking about living things is not merely that they occupy rare, ordered arrangements but that they can rapidly rearrange into such special states, then stay there stably until sensing a change and rearranging again—a combination of dynamism and on-demand stability that is impossible at thermal equilibrium, where orderliness and inertness go hand in hand, and which therefore requires constant work being dumped into the system.
“there's this combination of dynamism on the one hand, with stability when it's desired and order when it's needed and you just can't buy that for love or money of thermal equilibrium.”
- Living things are not equally eager for any source of energy: most arbitrarily delivered energy acts like a bull in a china shop, activating random rearrangements that constitute damage, because life occupies a tiny, highly non-random corner of configuration space; only energy of the right pattern—chemical bonds in food for animals, specific photon spectra for plants—can flow through the system to power self-repair and maintenance rather than destruction.
“most arbitrarily chosen ways of putting energy into a system are gonna be like a bowl in a china shop... in a living thing, we call that damage.”
- In open systems where organized work is being done—such as a pump compressing air, an optical stimulus, or other patterned external forcing—local entropy can decrease in a physically permissible way, so outcomes can be likely either because they are high-entropy (more ways to happen) or because work powers a transition into a low-entropy state, just as crystallization lowers entropy when attractive forces overwhelm the entropic pull.
“you can take a pump and pump all the air into a much smaller space if you do work on the system, you're allowed to make a vacuum and so you're lowering the entropy of that air”
Dissipative adaptation explains self-organization through energy landscape dynamics and trajectory probabilities.
- Dissipative adaptation explains self-organization via an energy landscape analogy: a configuration of many particles is like a ball's location in a high-dimensional mountain range where height is energy. External work acts like ski lifts or escalators in this landscape; configurations good at absorbing the environment's patterned energy get lifted over peaks, and because there may be no lift on the far side, those transitions become statistically irreversible—so over time the system accumulates the most indelible marks of having been in shapes well-matched to the environment's pattern, ending up trapped in low-entropy 'high mountain pass' states sustained by the ongoing drive.
“the unifying idea, which I've called dissipative adaptation... is that you think about the outcome structure... as being the result of a biased exploration of the space of possibilities where the history of moments in it's past when it absorbed energy from the environment in a way that involves some kind of matching between it's structure and the pattern of the environment, that the accumulated effect of those moments ends up being a signature you see in the structure”
- Fluctuation theorems—notably the Crooks relation and Jarzynski equality—transformed non-equilibrium statistical mechanics by shifting attention from macroscopic state variables to the relative probabilities of microscopic trajectories: the Crooks result states that of a forward 'movie' and its time-reversed version, the more likely one is the trajectory that dumps positive heat into the surroundings, revealing hidden, exploitable information in the seemingly random noise of driven systems.
“the crux result is saying. If I see a movie of a driven system and the time reverse movie, the rewind movie, how likely, relatively, are these two different movies in the dynamics that I'm observing.”
- In a Physical Review Letters experiment, a simulated system of masses and springs randomly hooking and unhooking in a thermal bath, when shaken at a chosen frequency, evolves not to a single arrangement but to a family of outcomes with a specialized, fine-tuned ability to absorb energy from that particular frequency—each individual outcome unique but all sharing exceptional energy absorption compared to random arrangements, a hallmark resembling a form-function relationship.
“you wiggle part of the system at that frequency and then what you end up seeing before too long is a particular evolutionary outcome, not a single microscopic arrangement but a family of possible outcomes that have a specialized ability to absorb more energy from that particular frequency”
- In simulations of disordered interacting systems driven by a patterned input (such as a particular frequency or pitch), the system initially absorbs a lot of energy and rearranges, but over the longer term it fine-tunes away from high absorption and settles into a low-dimensional, correlated excited state that stays matched to the source's pattern; changing the driving pattern causes a transient scrambling followed by re-settling into a new matched quiet state—mechanistically demonstrating self-organized homeostasis.
“in the short term, you absorb a lot of energy, the system jumps around, it rearranges, it changes it's shape and in the longer term, it learns how to absorb less energy from that environment and it fine tunes away from high energy absorption.”
Biology requires high-level descriptive languages fundamentally distinct from reductionist particle physics.
- Beyond the reductionism-versus-emergence debate, the choice of descriptive language has practical value: describing a stock market via molecular dynamics of all constituent particles, while feasible in principle, is hopelessly unwieldy, whereas economics provides a vocabulary naturally suited to the phenomenon—and the same applies to biology, where high-level concepts like cell division or DNA repair are expressed far more effectively in biological than particle-level terms.
“while it might be feasible in principle to describe what is going on in a stock market using a molecular dynamics simulation of all the particles... it's an extremely unwieldy way of trying to describe that”
- Living things differ from classic condensed-matter examples of emergence (like the liquid-vapor transition with its simple order parameters) because life is characteristically highly unsymmetrical, messy, and hierarchical across scales of length, energy, and time—so physicists' habitual search for symmetry that reveals hidden simplicity is misleading when applied to biology.
“living things are characteristically highly unsymmetrical and very messy and very hierarchical in the communication between different scales of links and energy and time”
- Physics and biology are not just different in subject but use fundamentally different languages: physics is inherently quantitative and draws no a priori line between life and non-life, while biology takes the category of 'alive' for granted at the outset and can proceed qualitatively, so the same phenomenon requires deliberate translation between conceptual frames.
“Biology by contrast, I would argue, is not inherently quantitative in the same way... if you go back to the beginning, the idea of what is alive is something taken for granted at the outset of biology.”
Energy absorption is system-specific and linked to homeostasis, not a universal organizing principle.
- There is no general rule that systems must maximize energy absorption; whether a driven system self-organizes toward being exceptionally good or exceptionally bad at absorbing energy from its environment is system-specific, depending on the particular interaction rules and the shape of the landscape—and the case of self-organized poor absorption is actually linked to homeostasis rather than feeding.
“there is no such rule because it is still a system-specific property”
- Recognizing fine-tuning requires a sufficiently complex, patterned external drive: if a system is driven by something simple (like merely heating one side and cooling the other, producing convection cells), it takes few numbers to describe the forcing, so there is little basis to call the resulting state exceptionally well-adapted—whereas the higher-dimensional and more 'bar-coded' the environmental statistics, the more clearly an exceptional structural relationship can be recognized.
“the higher dimensional the complexity is of that environment, the more we'll be able to recognize an exceptional relationship”
Life is better understood as multiple distinctive behaviors than as a single unified category.
- Striking life-likeness requires novelty through combination: the working material must offer enough combinatorial diversity that different arrangements respond qualitatively differently to the same environment—real life uses carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, sulfur, phosphorus and more—whereas a system limited to a single element like xenon might lack enough qualitatively distinct configurations to produce impressive outcomes under non-equilibrium driving.
“an essential thing in understanding life likeness is that in order for it to be really striking, there needs to be novelty through combination coming from how building blocks can be put together in different ways so that they really are quite distinct in how they react to the same environment”
- Rather than defining life once and for all, the productive approach is to chop the multifarious bundle of 'life' into a set of distinctive life-like behaviors—self-replication, harvesting energy from difficult-to-access sources, and acting to embody accurate predictions of one's future—and then build separate physical theories of what permits, forbids, or causes the emergence of each, even though none alone marks the boundary between life and non-life.
“Let's take that multifarious bundle of what life is and try to chop it apart into a set of distinctive life-like behaviors”
Science and biblical religion address non-overlapping domains and need not conflict intellectually.
- Entropy should be reframed not as a mysterious tendency toward disorder but as simply counting the number of ways something can happen; this affects the likelihood of outcomes but is not the only factor, because organized work input can drive a system into low-entropy states that are nonetheless probable.
“whenever people talk about entropy, what they're really talking about is counting the number of ways something can happen”
- There may be something distinctively conducive in the monotheism of the Hebrew Bible to viewing the world as a single fabric governed by a coherent set of rules decided by one mind, whereas polytheistic traditions—explaining different phenomena via different interacting personalities—are less likely to represent the world as a unified, intelligible rule-governed whole.
“the desire to explain different aspects of the world as the result of different interacting personalities in more polytheistic descriptions probably makes it less likely that you end up thinking of the world as a whole fabric that has kind of a set of rules that one person decided”
- On the question of how life came into being, many people line up on either side of a perceived line of scrimmage between the natural sciences and biblical religion, seeking a winner-take-all outcome, and will take any physical explanation of life-like behavior as 'the last stake in the heart' of biblical belief.
“there are people who line up along either side of what they view as a line of scrimmage between the natural sciences and biblical religion and they're looking for a winner-take-all outcome”
- Science is a powerful compact among people striving toward objectivity—a discovery isn't scientific until it can be communicated, argued for, and replicated by others—but this is like a black-and-white camera photographing a rainbow: accurate within its forms of representation yet deliberately limited; one need not accept the further axiomatic claim that no truth exists that is not objective or eventually renderable objective.
“the whole enterprise of the natural science is kind of like a black and white camera that you could use if you want to photograph a rainbow”
- Powerful physical models rest on assumptions that are useful but not necessarily justified beyond their simplicity, beauty, or predictive success—for example, assuming a heat bath's noise spectrum has a simple form, or that a system's initial condition was not specially chosen; one could specially prepare fluid molecules to spontaneously collect in a corner, an exceptional state that would nonetheless look random for a long time, so physics has found rather than proven the order of the universe.
“there's a lot that goes into physical models that are very powerful and effective where we're nonetheless making assumptions that are useful but not necessarily justified other than for their simplicity or their beauty”
- One can address both the biblical text and physical science without compromising intellectual honesty or the methodological coherence of either enterprise; England sees no necessary contradiction or 'winner-take-all' conflict between the natural sciences and biblical religion, and aims to demonstrate by example that both can be discussed simultaneously without being at loggerheads.
“Here's the way you can talk about both of these things at the same time and not see them at logger heads.”
- Because the Hebrew Bible expresses contemplation of the life/non-life boundary in terms of tangible everyday phenomena—dust mixing with water to form different muds, river water that carries energy and creates branching sediment structures resembling leaf veins—it can serve as a pedagogical 'conceptual talisman,' giving accessible everyday equivalents that magnify a reader's understanding of how energy flow drives specialized configurations to emerge in a space of combinations.
“this is a very compact metaphorical discussion of what it is for a non-equilibrium system to explore a space of possible combinations because dust of the earth is, yes, is a particulate matter that can be stuck together”
- One should be cautious about claiming life would be impossible if the constants of the standard model were different, because emergent levels of organization (such as turbulent fluids developing hierarchies of energy scales) can produce effectively new 'chemistry' at higher scales from chemically simple constituents, and because reasoning about randomly chosen physical constants requires a model of how universes are made that carries deep philosophical challenges.
“I usually try not to rush to make declarations like that because I do think sometimes through kinds of physical emergence that we're aware of, you can sometimes get things at higher scales that don't seem built into the simple interaction.”
- The Hebrew Bible should not be related to as a secretly encoded science textbook to be decoded for anticipations of modern physics; that is an unsuccessful methodology that there are religious arguments against, and the apparent resonances arise instead because the Bible addresses the unfiltered, tangible everyday human experience of material phenomena—which overlaps with the qualitative intuitions relevant to non-equilibrium life-likeness.
“I don't want to advocate for relating to the text of the Hebrew Bible as saying, well because this is a revelation from the hand of the world's creator, it actually, secretly and ethotheoretically is a science text book if we just decode it in the right way.”
- Being portrayed in Dan Brown's novel Origin as someone uninterested in the broader implications of his work motivated England to go on record at length, combining the scientific and philosophical/religious discussions in one book.
“being portrayed as someone who wasn't interested in the broader discussion really made me feel like "No, I really am interested in the broader discussion so maybe I should just make sure to go on record at length to that effect."”