114 | Angela Chen on Asexuality in a Sex-Preoccupied World
What this covers
Angela Chen, a science journalist and asexual person herself, speaks with Sean Carroll about what asexuality reveals when examined closely. The episode centers on a foundational definitional move: asexuality means lacking sexual attraction, not lacking sex itself or being repulsed by it. From that premise, Chen explores how society has bundled sexual desire, romantic attraction, libido, and adulthood into a single package—what she calls compulsory sexuality—and how studying asexuality exposes the cost of that conflation for everyone, not just asexual people.
The conversation ranges across how language creates recognition and community, examining both the power and limits of labeling. Chen traces how asexuality coalesced as an orientation only in the early 2000s when the internet allowed dispersed people to gather and collectively define the term, and how the mere existence of a word triggers self-understanding—much as discovering aphantasia organizes the scattered experience of not forming mental images. She unpacks the independent dimensions of sexual attraction, romantic orientation (so "straight ace" or heteroromantic make sense), libido, and aesthetic attraction, showing how people use the same language—"hot," "sexy"—while meaning radically different things. The discussion also touches on how sexual attraction gets wrongly pathologized in the DSM, the asymmetry whereby asexual identity is relentlessly questioned while allosexual experience goes unexamined, and how even non-asexual people stand to gain from interrogating what sexual attraction actually is and how compulsory sexuality constrains relationships across the board.
Chen argues that asexuality is best understood not as the absence of sex but as the absence of sexual attraction, and that examining it exposes how society wrongly bundles sexual desire, romance, attraction, and adulthood into a single 'compulsory sexuality' that everyone—ace or not—should learn to decouple.
- Asexuality means lacking sexual attraction, not lacking sex or being repulsed by it; it spans a wide spectrum.
- Sexual orientation, romantic orientation, libido, and aesthetic attraction are independent dimensions that culture conflates.
- Having a word/label for an experience creates recognition and community, but the long-term goal is a society fluid enough not to need the label.
Culture pathologizes low or absent sexual desire as illness, defect, or deception requiring cure.
- Culture valorizes high sexual desire as good and vital while simultaneously housing slut-shaming and purity culture; this pro-sex imbalance arises from evolutionary-psychology rationalizations ('we evolved to have sex, it's natural') and the commercial logic that sex sells, producing pervasive 'sex equals vitality' messaging that the ace movement seeks to counterbalance with a multiplicity of messages rather than de-sexualizing everything.
“there's so many ad campaigns around the idea of sex equals vitality. And so it compounds and it's all around us.”
- The TV show House gave one of the most mainstream depictions of asexuality, in which the brilliant House declares that the only people who don't want sex are 'sick, lying, or dead,' and the plot validates him: the woman is faking and her supposedly asexual husband actually has a curable brain tumor—presenting asexuality as always reducible to deception or medical pathology.
“House says something like, "She's definitely not asexual. Plenty of people don't have sex, but the only people who don't want sex are sick, lying, or dead."”
- Clinical research on asexuality is hampered because the term is so broad that pooling all asexual people—sex-repulsed, sexually active, with and without sex drives—into one sample muddies results, and historically the research was filtered through a bias treating absence of sexual attraction as disability, trauma, or pathology rather than normal human variation.
“if you pull in all these people from... That are all asexual, but have such different experiences, some are sex-repulsed, some have sex, some have a sex drive, some don't, then I think that will really muddy up your results”
- Asexuality is effectively pathologized in the DSM through Hypoactive Sexual Desire Disorder (now split into male and female forms), whose criteria—lack of sexual interest and fantasies—closely match asexuality; a late-2000s task group added an exception so that self-identified asexuals couldn't be diagnosed, but that exception is philosophically confused because it makes the disorder hinge on identity rather than experience.
“the diagnosis that most closely matches is Hypoactive Sexual Desire Disorder, though it's in the latest version since split up into male and female forms... you can make a very strong argument that asexuality is in the DSM.”
- Whether someone has low sexual desire and whether that state needs fixing should be separated: low desire and absence of sexual attraction are not deviations, yet it can be fine to choose to enhance desire for a relationship—what is objectionable is the stigmatized, profit-driven framing (libido-boosting drug marketing) that presents low desire as an objective defect that must be fixed.
“I think it's fine to have low sexual desire and not experience sexual attraction, that's not a deviation. And I think that in many cases, if you're that, even if it's fine, maybe it's okay to change it.”
Asexuality is a broad spectrum including people with sex drives, not a disorder or celibacy.
- Asexuality is commonly misunderstood as being without sex, but the official definition is not experiencing sexual attraction; it is a broad umbrella that includes people who have positive sexual experiences, are not repulsed by sex, and may even have a sex drive—it is distinct from celibacy, which is simply not having sex.
“The usual definition, the official definition is someone who is asexual, they don't experience sexual attraction.”
- Libido is not attached to sexual orientation; some aces have a sex drive and feel a desire for sexual release, but unlike allosexuals they never direct that desire toward another person—described as no different from scratching an itch on one's own arm rather than asking someone else to do it.
“for aces, even those who do have a libido, and not all aces have a libido, but for the ones who do, there's never a desire to get other people involved.”
- Many asexual people don't crave sexual intimacy for physical reasons but may still desire sex for emotional or social reasons—analogous to eating a food you don't physically crave but want because of routine and emotional association—so the reasons one might want sex (physical, emotional, boredom) are hard to disentangle.
“they don't crave sexual intimacy with other people for physical reasons, but there might be emotional reasons and social reasons and they're bored or they want to feel attractive”
- Sexual orientation does not have to be the same as romantic orientation; an asexual person may not be sexually attracted to anyone yet still feel romantic attraction—a crush or emotional desire—toward a particular gender, which aces call romantic orientation, so categories like 'straight ace' or 'heteroromantic' make sense.
“sexual orientation I think doesn't have to be the same as romantic orientation, that's one of the distinctions that people who are asexual make. You might not be sexually attracted to anyone, but you might still feel that romantic attraction, that crush, that emotional desire, and that is what we call romantic orientation.”
Precise language and community recognition enable asexual self-discovery and reduce isolation.
- The mere existence of a word like 'asexual' can trigger recognition and self-understanding, because much of the difficulty is linguistic—people use the same words ('he's hot') while meaning different things (aesthetic versus physical attraction), and without a label one cannot search for resources or community, just as discovering the term 'introvert' or 'material science' suddenly organizes scattered experience.
“it was only much later that I realized that we were using the same words, but we meant different things. When they said, "Oh, he's hot," they were feeling... I think they were experiencing something sexual... and I would just mean... I had aesthetic preferences, but it wouldn't feel physical.”
- Aphantasia—where some people cannot form mental images and only realize others can in adulthood—illustrates how shared language masks radically different inner experiences; the same applies to attraction, where people say 'hot' or 'sexy' without knowing whether they mean the same thing, making it nearly impossible to detect difference without glaring cues.
“he was 30 years old and had just discovered that other people can see images in their mind but he couldn't... he didn't realize that other people were actually seeing images in their head.”
- The widely cited figure that 1% of people are asexual comes from a survey more than a decade old and is likely a substantial undercount, because confusion about the term, its absence as an option on most forms, and lack of public awareness mean many asexual people never identify as such.
“The number that is thrown around all the time is 1% and it's based on a survey from more than a decade ago by now... I think the number honestly is much higher.”
- Asexuality only coalesced as a recognized orientation in the early 2000s because the internet let dispersed like-minded people gather, share experiences, and collectively define the term—the definition itself ('a person who doesn't experience sexual attraction') was a contingent agreement that could have been otherwise—though this origin also lets critics dismiss it as an illegitimate 'internet orientation for people on Tumblr.'
“it was really in the early 2000s that people started finding communities and discussing their lives and even describing what asexuality meant. Asexuality didn't have to mean "a person who doesn't experience sexual attraction." That's a definition that people made up and agreed on, and it could have been another way.”
Asexual and aromantic identities are distinct; society privileges romance while stigmatizing both orientations unequally.
- Deciding whether to want sexual desire—via libido-boosting drugs or otherwise—is fraught because it resembles Laurie Paul's 'transformative experience': you cannot fully evaluate the choice in advance since it may turn you into a person with different preferences, and it is complicated by whether the wish stems from genuine self-direction or from societal pressure.
“do you want it because you think that that would be good and it's like learning a new musical instrument, or do you want it just because society is telling you that you should want it?”
- Society should dismantle narrow standards (whether beauty standards driving breast implants or pressure to be sexual) while still allowing individuals to make personal choices within them—it would be wrong to ban breast implants even though the standards that motivate them should be abolished, an imperfect but instructive parallel for choices about sexual desire.
“women who get breast implants, oftentimes, that's because of these really narrow beauty societal standards that I think we should all get rid of... At the same time, I think it would feel weird to ban women from being able to get breast implants.”
- Being fully self-actualized as an asexual person is genuinely different from having one's sexuality repressed or shamed away; both states exist, including women who are sexually conservative due to shaming versus those who are simply that way, and respecting people requires acknowledging both and that each may need different things.
“sometimes people who are sexually conservative, it's not because they're repressed, it's just because that's how they are. And so it's important to acknowledge that both exist”
- Even non-asexual people benefit from examining asexuality, because it forces hard questions about what sexual attraction even is (it is extremely difficult to define), how aesthetic, emotional, and sexual attraction differ, how consent and invisible inequalities operate in relationships, and how society privileges romantic relationships over platonic ones.
“a weakness of many people, broadly, is that people think that a community doesn't have lessons for them if they're not part of the community.”
- Writing honestly about oneself requires abandoning the management of others' perceptions—Chen, even while writing a book about why ace-related feelings of being a killjoy or prude are unfair, still felt those feelings, and concluded that to write truthfully one must 'throw yourself under the bus' rather than posing, because image management turns writing into self-PR that is not useful.
“if you're going to write about yourself, in some ways you have to throw yourself under the bus, you have to stop managing other people's perceptions, because that's going to make you pose too much and care too much about looking good, and then you're not honest and then it's PR.”
- Representation and role models powerfully reshape how people, especially the young, conceive of themselves and what is possible—illustrated by children who drew scientists as Einstein until they visited Fermilab and met a diverse crowd—and even for an adult, meeting aces who were unburdened by the worries that troubled her made a real difference to Chen's own self-acceptance.
“they asked some children to draw a scientist and they all looked like Einstein. Then they took them on a field trip to Fermilab... afterward they asked them to draw a scientist, and they were all this diverse crowd.”
- It is good to question why one might be a certain way—since the cause could be shame that, once worked through, frees a person—but the problem is asymmetry: people relentlessly question whether aces are 'really' asexual or just deluded, while almost no one questions whether allosexuals might be asexual, and identity should not become so rigid that it produces anxiety or prevents exploration.
“the problem to me isn't that people question, but the questioning only goes in one direction. The assumption is that you are deluded if you think you're asexual”
- Being among the first authors on a topic creates pressure that shapes the work itself: because there were no other books, Chen felt obligated to make hers broad and somewhat academic—covering race and disability—at the cost of cutting fascinating tangents, and to fact-check carefully and avoid a 'gotcha' tone because the field is not yet secure enough to absorb critical exposés.
“when you're one of the first ones... I knew I couldn't write a book about asexuality without talking about race, without talking about disability because there were none out there and it had to, in some ways, be a little bit more academic and more broad.”
- Friendship and devoted non-romantic partnerships (exemplified by the historical 'Boston marriage') can be as strong and committed as romantic relationships, but society privileges romantic relationships—often at the expense of platonic ones—leaving aromantic people fearing being 'left behind'; normalizing many types of permanent partnerships would address this.
“she really wanted to see the normalization of many different types of partnerships and friendships that were devoted and that were treated with just as much respect and a sense of permanence as we treat romantic relationships.”
- Aromanticism—not experiencing romantic attraction—is separate from and not coextensive with asexuality: not all aces are aromantic and not all aromantic people are asexual (one can enjoy sex while not wanting a romantic partnership), and aromantic people, especially men, face heavy stigma because culture assumes only sociopaths and serial killers lack interest in romance.
“not all aces are aromantic, obviously, many want and have romantic relationships. And actually, not all people who are aromantic are asexual either.”
Asexual representation in mainstream fiction is nearly absent and heavily stereotyped.
- Asexual representation in fiction is nearly nonexistent and stereotyped—male aces are coded as hyper-rational figures like Sherlock Holmes, female aces as quirky or childish—and what exists appears mostly in YA and science fiction rather than prestige mainstream culture, which reinforces the perception that asexuality is fringe, childish, or not part of normal everyday life.
“it can make the orientation itself seems like it's on the fringes and seem like it's something that's for children, or something that's not part of normal everyday life.”
- Compulsory sexuality is so embedded in storytelling that mainstream literary fiction almost always includes a romantic or sexual plot; the rare counterexamples (Holocaust, war, or rehabilitation novels) fall into labeled genres, suggesting genre fiction may partly be defined as stories that ground themselves in something besides romantic love and middle-class life.
“I did find examples of that, but all of those were of a different genre. So they might be literary, but they were Holocaust novels or they were war novels or they were about rehabilitation.”
- Because asexuality is not yet embedded in the culture, early representations carry special risks: explicitly labeling a disabled asexual character may lead audiences who don't learn the broader umbrella to assume all disabled people are asexual, and pioneering depictions (like the Todd Chavez episode) must double as pedagogical explainers, which makes them less dramatically compelling.
“if you have someone who, for example, is disabled and asexual and you explicitly label them as asexual, if people don't bother to learn more about the umbrella of asexuality, I think they'll just assume that all disabled people are asexual or vice versa.”
Sexual incompatibility is a shared relational problem, not a deficiency of the lower-desire partner.
- Although every relationship has serious difficulties (money, kids, caring for parents) and sexual mismatch is extremely common since two people rarely share the same libido forever, sexual difficulties carry a unique stigma that makes them seem pathetic and shameful, and couples lack the cultural scripts they have for negotiating other incompatibilities.
“many people feel comfortable talking to friends about money troubles or how are we going to raise the kids, but there seems to be something pathetic and sad about having sexual difficulties or a sexual mismatch, even though that is so common.”
- Sexual incompatibility in a relationship comes from both partners, since if both had the same level of desire—high or low—there would be no problem; therefore the common dynamic of blaming and burdening the lower-desire partner to 'fix' themselves is unfair, and it should be treated as a shared problem with shared responsibility.
“If both people had the exact same level of desire, whether it was high or low, it wouldn't be a problem. So therefore, it should be a shared problem with shared responsibility instead of it all going on the lower desire partner.”
Sexuality is entangled with symbolism; decoupling desire from what it represents is challenging but possible.
- Sex and desire are heavily symbolic—in children's books sexuality signals leaving childhood and joining the adults, and it represents being chosen and loved by someone other than one's parents—so people cannot easily tell whether they want sex itself or merely the adulthood, recognition, and excitement it stands for; the central lesson is that sex is coupled with many things and can, with effort, be decoupled.
“sexuality is usually introduced as a way to signal that you are no longer a child... Sexuality is when you are chosen and loved by someone other than your parents for who you are.”
- Rather than treating sexual orientation as a deep, lifelong, immutable essence, it is more helpful to think of sexualities as fluid: people move in and out of orientations over their lives without their earlier experiences being fake, and people are more likely to go through phases of asexuality as they age—so research requirements that asexuality must be lifelong and uncaused are misguided.
“I personally think it's much better to think about sexualities in a much more fluid way. If someone is gay and then later they're with someone of the opposite gender, I don't think that means they were never gay or that that period of their lives was fake somehow.”
Intersecting identities and discovery timing shape vastly different asexual self-understanding and coming-out experiences.
- Intersecting identities compound the difficulty of asexual self-discovery: a Black asexual woman, finding the community overwhelmingly white, had to question whether her orientation was 'natural' or a reaction against racist stereotypes of Black women as hypersexual—and the scarcity of Black aces left her without peers to work this out with.
“do I just hate the fact that there are these racist stereotypes of black women as hypersexual? Is this my real "natural orientation" or is just some kind of reaction against racism?”
- Discovering an ace identity produces different responses: those who always felt different may feel immediate relief and recognition, but those who did not feel strange growing up often experience ambivalence and new baggage, because adopting the identity suddenly attaches stigmatizing perceptions—prude, repressed, lacking vitality—to a life that previously felt normal.
“if you didn't feel that strange or different growing up, which I didn't, then I think you can get saddled down with the baggage. One minute, you're just an allo person who maybe has some "strange" experiences with sex. The next minute you have to think, "Is this a whole identity?"”
- Coming out as asexual can feel uniquely awkward and even inappropriate—as if disclosing one's sex life directly—because talking about sexual attraction feels more intimate than other coming-outs, so aces sometimes feel coming out is unnecessary or uncomfortable in ways that differ from coming out as gay.
“when you talk about sexual attraction, I think it feels like you're talking about your sex life in this very direct way... it really does feel like I'm trying to talk to my co-workers about my sex life in a way that's not true for other orientations.”
- Despite the existence of ace dating websites, most aces in practice try to date allosexuals and make it work, primarily because aces are so few in number and geographically dispersed with no enclaves, so being surrounded by allos leaves little choice rather than reflecting a special attraction.
“most aces I know actually do try to date allos and see if there's a way to make that work.”
Asexuality coalesced through internet community; its eventual elimination would signal cultural acceptance.
- In its early years the ace community engaged in harmful gatekeeping—excluding disabled people and survivors of sexual assault to avoid the impression that asexuality was caused by illness or trauma—which cut off people and was unhealthy, and gatekeeping persists today over who is 'ace enough' and whether straight aces count as queer.
“in earlier years, it's a lot of discussion that if you're disabled, you can't be asexual because the idea was people already thought that asexuality was related to some kind of medical illness.”
- Asexuality as an identity arose as a response to compulsory sexuality; the ideal endpoint is a society where neither the DSM entry nor the asexual label is needed—because people could simply state their experience without being doubted or needing a community to validate them—so the existence of the identity is itself a symptom of current societal pressure.
“asexuality developed as a response to all of these societal pressures to be sexual, what I call compulsory sexuality. If these pressures didn't exist, then I think there would be much less need for people to find community”