What this covers

Sean Carroll speaks with Megan Rosenbloom, a medical librarian and co-founder of the Death Salon, about how American attitudes toward death have become historically anomalous and culturally constructed. The episode traces the machinery of modern death denial—how embalming, hospital deaths, and professionalized funeral practices came to feel inevitable and timeless—and explores the Death Positive movement as a response: not an advocacy for dying, but an opening of conversation to expand the choices available to the dying and bereaved. Rosenbloom argues that recognizing mortality as finite and chooseable, rather than something to deny or outsource to professionals, actually reduces anxiety and deepens appreciation of life. The conversation moves between history, ritual function, law, and the psychology of grief.

The substance ranges widely. Rosenbloom shows how the Civil War forced embalming into American practice for the first time—turning Abraham Lincoln's embalmed body into a mascot—and how the funeral industry then convinced families that body care required professionals and dangerous chemicals, displacing death from the home parlor to the funeral parlor (which itself became the "living room," a space for the living alone). She details how hospitals, once charity houses for the poor to die in, became the primary place of American death relatively recently. She engages Ernest Becker's thesis that all culture springs from Denial of Death anxiety, and discusses death with dignity as an act of agency restoration. The discussion also veers into anthropodermic bibliopegy—books bound in human skin—where Rosenbloom explains how peptide mass fingerprinting can authenticate such artifacts, and touches on how the clinical gaze of Michel Foucault helps explain why physicians saw skin as material to preserve. Throughout, Rosenbloom emphasizes that American death practices are neither mandatory nor traditional, and that Death Positive simply aims to inform people that alternatives—green burial, home funerals, witness cremation—exist and deserve their consideration.

Sharpest takeaway

Rosenbloom argues that modern American death practices (embalming, hospital deaths, professionalized funerals) are recent, culturally specific inventions born of death denial, and that the Death Positive movement reclaims autonomy and meaning by reopening conversation about death and expanding people's choices.

  • Current US funeral norms (embalming, concrete vaults, perpetual graves) are products of the Civil War era and industry marketing, not timeless tradition
  • Death denial leaves people unprepared, treating death as an emergency rather than a known inevitability
  • Facing mortality and exercising choice (home funerals, death with dignity) reduces anxiety and increases appreciation of life

The argument · threads14 threads · 29 claims
0.85

American death practices are historically recent and culturally specific, not timeless tradition.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Dying in hospitals is a relatively modern phenomenon: before clinical medicine emerged around the French Revolution, hospitals were charity institutions where the poor went to die, and it would have been scandalous for the wealthy to die in a hospital; for most of history people were born, sickened, died, and were laid out and buried at home with family caring for the body.

    “Clinical medicine sort of became a thing in right around the French Revolution time. Before that, the hospitals were like charity hospitals.”

  • The Civil War separated American death practices from European heritage: for the first time large numbers of people died far from home, and to transport bodies back by train, battlefield surgeons began embalming to stabilize corpses; Lincoln's embalmed body touring the country popularized the lifelike corpse, and over time embalming became the American norm, while it never caught on in other countries.

    “the Civil War really kind of took us... The Civil War and its aftermath was a thing that separated us from European heritage in terms of the way that we deal with death”

  • Funeral professionals took over body care from families by claiming embalming required professional handling of dangerous chemicals; as bodies moved from the home parlor to the funeral parlor, the home's parlor was repurposed into the 'living room'—a space for the living rather than the dead—illustrating how small shifts produced a wholly different culture of death.

    “instead of having a body in a parlor in your house, you take it to the funeral parlor, and then the parlor becomes a living room because it's for the living and not for your dead bodies.”

  • The standard American death practices—the expensive embalmed body, casket with viewing, and concrete vault in the ground—are not the only option and are actually very specific to our time and place, differing even from how things were done 100 years ago, yet people wrongly assume they are mandatory and traditional.

    “It turns out, not only are those things not the only option, they're actually very specific to our time and place, and they're not even the way we did things 100 years ago.”

0.85

The Death Positive movement opens conversation about death to reduce anxiety and restore personal agency.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The human condition around death is a push-and-pull, and the more you face your mortality through repeated exposure—learning, making plans, discussing it with loved ones—the less severe each exposure becomes, so that you end up a less anxious and more happy person overall.

    “the repeated exposure, then makes each exposure a little less severe... when you make plans, when you make choices and you talk about it with your loved ones... you actually end up being a less anxious and a more happy person in general.”

  • The Death Positive movement does not advocate a single correct way to die or be buried; rather than passing judgment on people who want the full embalmed funeral, it informs people that options like home funerals, green burials, and witness cremations exist and supports their ability to choose how involved they want to be.

    “we don't pass judgement on people if they want the whole big embalmed everything. It's more, "Hey, there are other options and we support your ability to choose."”

  • Death positivity, modeled on terms like 'sex positive' and 'body positive,' does not advocate dying but aims to open up conversations about an uncomfortable topic, de-stigmatize it through cross-cultural and historical exploration, and thereby make it easier to deal with death personally.

    “the background of it is more like sex positive, or body positive, right? So it's, "Hey, here's thing that we feel really uncomfortable talking about. Let's open up conversations."”

  • Realizing that your life is finite makes you appreciate it more, analogous to learning that water is finite in drought-prone Los Angeles versus treating it as infinite on the water-rich East Coast; taking moments to acknowledge and ritualize important events is what makes them memorable and enriches one's appreciation of life.

    “when you realize that your life is actually finite, you appreciate your life more. And that was not an intention that I had getting into this.”

0.64

Confronting mortality directly through learning and ritual enriches life and reduces death anxiety.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • When faced with an uncontrollable tragedy like the death of a loved one, finding a way to do some good in the situation—helping with arrangements and supporting grieving family—gives a sense of control over something one had no control over, which is how Rosenbloom personally coped with her niece's death.

    “if I can find a way to do some good in the situation, then it makes me feel... It gives me a sense of control over things I had no control over.”

  • Following Ernest Becker's The Denial of Death, humans uniquely know they will die, and the terror of that knowledge is too much to handle, so we manage death anxiety by trying to leave something of ourselves behind—children, art, monuments, professional achievement—meaning that essentially all of culture, including the pyramids, springs from death anxiety.

    “that phrase is really was popularized by this philosopher named Ernest Becker, and he had this best selling book in 1975 or something called The Denial of Death.”

  • Rituals matter because they mark the passage from one stage of life to the next—weddings, birthdays, thesis defenses—and as society becomes more secular, the loss of such ritual is harmful; the abrupt modern transition from hospital to a box of ashes denies the bereaved the demarcation they need to process the change from a person being present to absent.

    “some of the things that get lost are things like the importance of ritual, of marking passages from one stage to the next... it matters to mark the change from being a single person to being a married person”

0.56

Language and terminology profoundly shape stigma around end-of-life choices and dying.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The words used to describe end-of-life choices carry heavy cultural baggage and change over time—'euthanasia' evokes Nazis, 'assisted suicide' was a 1990s term burdened by suicide's stigma, and even 'commit' implies a crime—so the movement deliberately adopts language like 'death with dignity' because terminology shapes whether the act is stigmatized.

    “we don't use commit anymore, because that's a crime. You commit a crime, right? So that kind of... The words you use are really important, and they change over time.”

  • Death with dignity allows a person with a terminal diagnosis of about six months to live to obtain, after many bureaucratic hurdles and cognitive-competence checks ensuring no duress, self-administered drugs to end their life; the doctor cannot administer them due to the Hippocratic oath, and for many patients simply having the option is relieving even if they never use it, because it restores agency at the end of life.

    “death with dignity is when you pass... When you get a terminal diagnosis and they say you have something like six months to live... Then you can choose to see your doctor, and you have to go through many different hurdles in order to get this.”

0.44

Religious traditions and anthropodermic books reveal alternative or overlooked death practices.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Human skin books, contrary to the popular Nazi association, are over 100 years old and almost always involved a doctor; they arose alongside clinical medicine, sometimes binding the trial records of executed murderers as extra punishment after dissection, or were made by physician book-collectors who—through what Foucault called the 'clinical gaze' of objectifying distance—saw the skin as material to be saved rather than discarded.

    “it's usually had a doctor involved. So we've got history of medicine and rare books and death all together.”

  • DNA testing cannot reliably identify human skin books because DNA is too sensitive—handling a book without gloves transfers human traces, and the intense process of making skin into leather plus age degrades DNA—whereas peptide mass fingerprinting reads collagen, which is very stable and lasts thousands of years but only resolves to the animal family level.

    “You can't do DNA testing on a human skin book because DNA is too sensitive... every time you do a weird process, which making skin into leather is a pretty intense process, and also age, the DNA just degrades”

  • Religion is not necessarily a barrier to the movement because traditions like Judaism and Islam already practice what amounts to green burial—ritually washing and wrapping the body in a sheet and burying it quickly without embalming—which is exactly what outsiders are now fighting to have included in traditional cemeteries.

    “a lot of traditions like Judaism and Islam, those... What they still do is green burial. They don't embalm; they wrap a body, wash a body, ritualistic washing of a body, wrapping it in a sheet and quick burial.”

  • Books bound in human skin (anthropodermic bibliopegy) are a real historical practice, but many alleged examples are fakes; using peptide mass fingerprinting of collagen, the Anthropodermic Book Project has tested about 30 of roughly 50 credible alleged books and found roughly 18 authentic and 12 fake, a roughly even split.

    “thus far, we've found about 50 credible, actually existent, alleged books. And we've tested somewhere like 30 of them. And about, I wanna say, 18 or so were real and 12 were fake.”

0.43

American funeral culture is ecologically wasteful and reflects professionalization that excluded families.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Embalming is a very dangerous profession occupationally because of the chemicals involved, posing cancer risk to embalmers, which is one reason Rosenbloom would not want her child to enter the field.

    “I personally would, if my kid wanted to be an embalmer, I would be upset because I don't want her to get cancer. It is a very... It's a very dangerous profession in that way. Occupationally dangerous”

  • Modern American graves are ecologically wasteful because bodies are placed in caskets inside concrete vaults in the ground—partly so the grass can be mowed without settling—and graves are held in perpetuity on land that would be valuable elsewhere, unlike Europe and South America where land is at a premium and graves are reused.

    “it's not just a casket in the ground, it's a casket inside a concrete vault in the ground. So ecologically, it's pretty wasteful that they do that partially so that it's easy to mow the grass”

0.43

The Death Salon and Death Positive movement face resistance because they empower people and threaten professional gatekeeping.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The Death Salon began as a casual idea among the Order of the Good Death collective to simply get together for a party, evolved into an invite-only salon of about 30 people, and after a public event drew 300 attendees and an Atlantic feature, rapidly snowballed into an annual international event with dozens of lectures, performances, and workshops.

    “we got there and there was 300 people there... And then the Atlantic did a big feature on us, and then it just kind of blew open.”

  • The Death Positive movement faces a difficult political climate because it is empowering for ordinary people, often results in inexpensive options that bypass professionals, and is explicitly intersectional and inclusive; Rosenbloom characterizes it as ultimately a social justice movement that some people will reject for those reasons.

    “death positivity is empowering for regular people. It often results in very inexpensive options that you don't need a professional for.”

0.21

American law unusually respects the stated wishes of the deceased compared to other countries.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • American law is unusually permissive about honoring the wishes of the deceased—what you say you want done with your body and end of life carries significant legal weight—whereas other countries, even in Europe, largely disregard a dead person's stated wishes.

    “the American laws especially are unusually permissive about the wishes of the deceased. That's something that in other... Even in European countries, they're like, "What? Who cares about... They're dead."”

0.21

Grief has no time limit and requires acceptance rather than attempted remedies.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • Grief does not have a time limit, and pressuring the bereaved to 'get over it' or offering fix-it cliches—however well-intentioned—is harmful; the right approach is to let people remain in their grief and support them rather than trying to fix it.

    “grief... It's not... It doesn't have a time limit; it's not like, "Oh, that was six months ago. You're still upset about that?"”

0.21

The United States is distinctly in denial about death compared to other cultures.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • The United States in the early 21st century is unusually in denial about death compared to other cultures, treating death with somber seriousness, sanitizing it with euphemisms, and trying to ignore mortality, whereas other cultures incorporate images and rituals of death into daily life.

    “We just pretend it's never gonna happen to us, and then when it does, when it comes into our lives because of a family member or something with us, then it's an emergency, we don't know how to deal with it.”

0.07

Death doulas assist the dying by easing their transition, analogous to birth doulas.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • Death doulas are the death-side equivalent of birth doulas, with varying levels of training and certification, who help ease a dying person's transition from life to death by providing comfort—much as a birth doula assists in the birthing process.

    “if there's someone on the birth... If there's a job on the birth side, there is a comparable job on the death side.”

0.07

Cremation rates reveal how far behind the United States lags other developed nations.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • Cremation rates differ enormously by country: most European countries are around 96%, Japan is roughly 99.9%, while the US only recently passed the 50% mark, having been around 12% in the 1980s—reflecting how far behind the US was in adopting cremation.

    “Most European countries, you're looking at 96% of people get cremated and stuff.”

0.07

A Masters in Library Science is a rare professional requirement unlike most advanced degrees.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • To be an actual librarian rather than just work at a library, one needs a Masters in Library Science—a rare position that requires a Masters specifically rather than a PhD.

    “in order to be an actual librarian and not just work at a library, you need a Masters in Library Science... it is one of those rare positions that you actually need a Masters, not a PhD”

0.07

Bare washed hands damage rare books less than gloved handling.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • Contrary to popular belief, wearing gloves when handling rare books is a myth that does more harm than good; you are more likely to damage a book or rip a page with gloves than with bare, washed hands.

    “you don't wear gloves. It's actually less... You're more likely to damage a book or rip a page or something if you're wearing gloves than if you have your... Bare, washed hands.”