
Fiscal Stimulus and the Risk of Runaway Inflation (w/ Kevin Muir)
What this covers
Kevin Muir, a market strategist and author of The Macro Tourist, is the only speaker in this Toronto conversation, filmed in October 2019. He begins with why monetary policy has stopped working. Corporate capital expenditure (CapEx)) is barely correlated with interest rates, and over the last decade the correlation has turned negative, since cheaper money signals weakness. He cites Deutsche Bank's CEO saying that companies won't borrow more at minus 75 basis points than at minus 50. Household behavior is different: falling rates have pushed Canadians into more debt to buy houses. From there he treats negative rates and QE as encouraging speculation rather than real activity, and sees a sovereign debt bubble in Europe, where a German buyer of negative-yielding bonds risks absolute capital loss.
The second strand is political. Muir expects governments to discover that spending at near-zero borrowing cost is nearly free, and to turn to Modern Monetary Theory (MMT)). He argues MMT is not a left-wing idea but a description of how a fiat system works. He is skeptical that its inflation-control tools would hold, because politicians rarely stop spending. He also describes European fiscal limits as self-imposed, so easily rewritten. Along the way he disputes the usual account of the 38-year disinflation, crediting fiscal discipline over monetary policy. He also argues that elected officials using fiscal transfers is preferable to unelected central bankers buying equities. Some of his claims are contested, including that Jerome Powell's tightening in real yields tipped the world toward slowdown, and that Donald Trump's deficit-financed tax cuts, rather than Fed policy, drove the US expansion.
The third strand is portfolio positioning. Muir warns that a 60/40 portfolio fails if stocks and bonds fall together under inflation. He points to Stanley Druckenmuller's argument that QE is bond-negative, and to Jim Bianca's work on the Fed being the tightest central bank. He proposes Treasury Inflation Protected Securities (TIPs)) breakevens as a hedge, while admitting equities may or may not outrun multiple compression. The talk also detours into Canada: oil pipeline constraints, the discount on Western Canadian Select, Trudeau's energy politics, and a case for carbon taxes over blocking pipelines.
Muir argues that we are in a sovereign debt bubble driven by misguided monetary policy, and the real risk ahead is unexpected inflation from eventual fiscal stimulus, not deflation—making inflation-hedging strategies essential portfolio positioning.
- Current negative interest rates and massive QE are ineffective and unsustainable; fiscal policy, not monetary policy, actually drives economic stimulus
- Governments will eventually recognize fiscal spending has near-zero cost and deploy it aggressively, triggering inflation the Fed cannot afford to combat
- Markets are unprepared for inflation because they've been conditioned to expect disinflation; crises occur in what people don't expect
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Lower interest rates have dramatic effects on individual consumer behavior and housing demand, even though they have minimal effects on corporate CapEx; Canadians have taken on increasing debt to buy houses as rates declined.
“Although we spoke about how interest rates do not affect the real economy, at least when it comes to corporations, or it has minimal effect to the corporations, I think it has very dramatic effects to individuals. The r-star for Canada was very sensitive to the fact that as they lowered rates, the consumer-- because the consumer had room, they could actually go out and buy houses, went out and bought houses by the bucketful, and it just ended up being something that fed upon itself.”
Corporate capital expenditure is nearly uncorrelated with changes in interest rates; in the last decade, the correlation has turned negative, meaning lower rates are associated with less business spending—this is because lower rates signal economic weakness and reduce confidence.
“You would think that it's hugely correlated. It's actually-- there's almost no correlation. I believe in the last decade, it's gone negatively correlated, meaning as they lower rates, there's less of a chance of them spending. I would attribute that to the fact that as they lower rates, it is indicative of an environment of less economic certainty. Therefore, corporations are less willing to spend.”
The 38-year decline in interest rates and disinflation was not understood by most economists and policymakers; it was actually driven by fiscal discipline and the fact that governments weren't spending, not by monetary policy alone.
“One of the things that I think that we haven't understood is why we've had this. It's a feeling of economics. It's a feeling of understanding what's truly driving the economy. We've focused on the monetary side of the equation so much that we've ignored the fiscal side.”
Monetary policy has hit the zero lower bound and is no longer effective at stimulating the economy; it mainly encourages financial speculation rather than real economic activity.
“It was only once we hit the zero bound that we realized that the monetary policy wasn't is in control as we thought it was. All it was doing was actually affecting the behavior of individuals and encouraging financial speculation and other things of that nature, but wasn't really affecting the economy as much as we thought.”
When governments realize they can spend money at nearly zero cost (because borrowing rates are negative or near-zero) and invest in productive infrastructure, they will deploy massive fiscal spending that will create inflation—the unintended consequence of central bank policy.
“Once the government's realize that they can basically go spend with almost no cost, let's face it, Germany can go spend and actually make money by spending. As long as they don't lose the money, they invest in infrastructure that is productive for their economy, they're actually better off as a society because the interest rate is negative. Once people realize this, and once governments realize this, we're going to get a wave of fiscal spending that will actually create the inflation and it will be the old adage that be careful what you wish for, it might come and it might come too fast or too hard.”
Climate change should be addressed through demand-side solutions (e.g., carbon/gasoline taxes) rather than supply-side restrictions (e.g., blocking pipelines), which are economically inefficient and create unintended consequences.
“If you really wanted to solve the issue about climate change, then why don't we double the gasoline tax everywhere instead of trying to stop pipelines from Alberta going to the US and making it more efficient. The ironic thing is that when those climate activists delayed all those pipelines, it didn't in some cases stop the oil from flowing, what it did is it put it on rail cars. If you think about it, rail cars first of all are way more dangerous than pipelines.”
Unelected central bankers buying equities or real economy assets (Swiss/Japanese model) is worse policy than elected officials using fiscal transfers, because unelected officials lack democratic accountability and it distorts asset prices without helping Main Street.
“I think the idea of them going out and buying risky assets is a terrible idea...the problem with it is already that we're propping up financial assets as opposed to putting money into the real economy. Why we think that putting money into the financial economy is going to trickle down to the main guy is just beyond me. It's just ridiculous. It's ludicrous.”
We are currently in the third major bubble of the last two decades—a sovereign debt bubble—and the defining characteristic of a bubble is that people refuse to call it one, even as it's forming.
“here we are in the third bubble and staring us right in the face and nobody wants to call it a bubble. To me, that's the very definition of a bubble”
A traditional 60/40 portfolio (60% equities, 40% bonds) is vulnerable to an inflationary scenario where both stocks and bonds fall together, breaking the negative correlation that has protected investors for 20 years.
“if you think about a portfolio that's long, let's say 60/40 traditional portfolio, that's long 60% equities, 40% bonds or whatever it is that you view is appropriate. I think about the return of inflation, I could see a situation where that inflation causes both bonds and stocks to go down.”
The Fed is currently the tightest central bank globally (highest policy rate); Jim Bianca's research shows that periods when the Fed's rate exceeds all other major central banks coincide with major economic slowdowns and liquidity squeezes globally.
“Jim Bianca's got this great chart where he plots the Fed-- the number of countries that have policies that are higher than the Fed. What you'll see is that we're actually at zero right now. The Fed's the highest policy, and if you go look at periods that this has happened in the past, they coincide with major economic issues.”
A German investor buying bonds with negative nominal yields faces the risk of absolute capital loss if yields move higher (even if yields don't go as negative as minus 4%), making these securities an inadequate hedge in times of financial stress.
“I really worry about if you're a German investor and you're buying something at a negative nominal yield, how much that's going to save you in a time of stress? Who knows, maybe they go to minus four, but maybe it actually goes the other way and they actually end up being a negative return.”
Stanley Druckenmiller has argued that QE is bond negative, which seems counterintuitive to many investors (who think Fed buying bonds should push them up), but makes sense if you believe QE is inflationary—it should cause portfolio reallocation away from long-duration bonds due to expected future inflation.
“You see Stanley Druckenmiller talk about the fact that QE is actually bond negative. Everyone, that doesn't make sense for a lot of people. They say, 'But wait, the Fed's buying bonds, why would that cause the long bond to sell off?' The reality is that if you actually believe that QE is inflationary, and we could debate if it actually is or not, but if you believe that, at the very least, it should cause investors reallocate their portfolio and actually sell long dated bonds because they expect higher future inflation.”
The main challenge with MMT-style unlimited fiscal spending is that politicians will never voluntarily stop spending, making inflation eventually inevitable and political control impossible.
“one of the big push backs about MMT is the fact that no politician is ever going to stop spending. Once you start spending, it's going to continue and it'll be difficult to take back. I'm sympathetic to that argument.”
Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) has been incorrectly associated with left-wing politics, but it is actually non-denominational and applies to both left and right policies; the key insight is understanding how a fiat monetary system works, not endorsing unlimited spending.
“I'm frustrated that MMT has been associated with the left so much because it doesn't have to be. It is actually non-denominational, like it's not a left or right policy.”
There are legitimate pushbacks to MMT policy proposals—particularly that once governments start spending more, it becomes politically difficult to stop, and fiscal stimulus could be abused just as monetary stimulus has been abused—but these are reasons for institutional design, not for rejecting fiscal expansion.
“one of the big push backs about MMT is the fact that no politician is ever going to stop spending. Once you start spending, it's going to continue and it'll be difficult to take back. I'm sympathetic to that argument.”
The CEO of Deutsche Bank stated that negative rates are not driving corporate borrowing—companies won't borrow more at minus 75 basis points than at minus 50 basis points—which demonstrates the absurdity of expecting capital expenditure decisions to be influenced by 25-50 basis point rate changes and shows monetary policy's ineffectiveness.
“I've seen it where when you get the CEO of Deutsche Bank coming out and telling you, 'No, we do not need more negative rates.' He said, 'My customers, they're not going to borrow any more at minus 75 than they did a minus 50.' Like, let's just go and stop.”
The real question for equity investors in an inflationary scenario is whether earnings growth will outpace the multiple compression from rising discount rates; this is not entirely certain and depends on how quickly inflation arrives.
“stocks will obviously go-- like the earnings will go up because of the inflation. The question is, will they go up enough to compensate for the fact that PEs will go down? It's not entirely sure. It depends on how fast the inflation comes.”
Inflation breakevens—the difference between the yield on Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPs) and nominal Treasury bonds of the same maturity—represent the market's forward expectation of inflation and can be used as a hedge against simultaneous bond and stock declines.
“Inflation breakevens are-- they are the difference in the yield between a TIP of a certain maturity and that corresponding treasury of the same maturity...That inflation breakeven is in essence, the forward expected inflation that the market is pricing in, the difference between the two.”
MMT theorists claim they have tools to control inflation, but Muir thinks these tools will not work in practice and fiscal policy will eventually be abused like monetary policy has been (e.g., negative rates in Europe).
“I hear the MMT-ers give me all sorts of reasons why they're going to be able to control inflation. I think that they're not going to be able to control inflation, I think that it will eventually be abused. I think for a long time, it'll work really, really well. Then it eventually will, like all things will be abused, which will be abused. Listen, we've abused monetary policy, all you have to do is look at the like, minus 50 basis points in Europe and know that monetary policy is being abused tremendously. We will abuse fiscal policy in the same way.”
Canada's manufacturing base is struggling, its oil sector is constrained by pipeline limitations and poor energy policy, and Western Canadian Select crude trades at a significant discount to WTI/Brent due to lack of export capacity.
“Yet at the same time, we have our manufacturing base struggling. We have our main-- we're known as a petrol currency and oil stinking and in fact, we've shot ourselves in the foot with our energy policy, with our lack of pipeline. Much of our energy is trapped in Canada and we're trading-- we have something called Western Canadian Select, which is a benchmark in a trade that a discount to Western, the WTI which actually trades to a discount to Brent.”
Prime Minister Trudeau's position on energy policy has been contradictory: he's opposed by both climate activists (who want no pipelines) and Alberta (which wants pipelines), partly due to his father's legacy as architect of the National Energy Program.
“He's managed to make everybody mad, which is not very good from a politician point of view. He was probably going to be a difficult sell for Alberta anyways, because his father was the architect of the National Energy Program and Albertans have a long memory. Then when he came in, and he did a couple of things with the pipelines that basically showed that it was incompetence and it was probably mishandled.”
Powell raised real yields on 2-year TIPs from 50 bps to 200 bps (a massive tightening in real terms), which pushed the global economy into recession and forced other central banks to loosen even more, creating distortions like Germany's negative 60 bps rates.
“You could see, and it was in a range from like 50 basis points to minus 150 basis points. Basically, from the period that Bernanke to Yellen and then Powell came in. When Powell came, we all of a sudden saw that real yield jumped from 50 basis points to 100 basis points to 150. Finally, it was at almost a 200 basis points when he did his-- we're long way from neutral. That caused a lot of pain and he basically got to the-- he raised rates to the point where the global economy cried uncle, he pushed the global economy into a recession.”
The restrictions on fiscal spending in Europe (e.g., Maastricht limits) are self-imposed political constraints, not genuine financial constraints, and in a crisis or even absent one, governments could easily change these rules to enable spending.
“those are all selfimposed restrictions that they put on themselves. It's not like it's an actual financial restriction. It's not like it's a country that's trying to defend their currency and they don't have the assets to defend it. This is a selfimposed restriction that they put in place together. I think in a time of crisis, or even maybe not in a time of crisis, maybe they just get together and changed it.”
Mosler and Kelton (MMT theorists) understood European economic problems far earlier and better than mainstream economists; they got it right about the nature of the eurozone crisis and QE impacts.
“I contend that the MMT guys got way more right than most traditional economists. Like if you go through Mosler and Kelton, they both were all over your understanding the problems associated with Europe, way before most of the rest of the world did.”
Trump's tax cuts and fiscal stimulus (4.5% of GDP deficit) in 2017-2018 were the primary drivers of a strong US economy and capital inflows, not just American capitalism or Fed policy; this created the 'cleanest shirt in the dirty laundry' dynamic where the US attracted global capital.
“They went and they did 4.50% of GDP as a deficit and they're spending. The Europeans are getting mad at Italy because they want to run at 2.50% the budget deficit and here we have the US running at 4.50%. What that did was that caused a booming economy and it caused capital flow into the US. It ended up being that famous saying about it being the cleanest shirt in the dirty laundry pile and it attracted capital and it end up being a self-fulfilling prophecy, more capital and chasing assets and it goes up and the dollar is going up.”
Inflation protection is best built into a portfolio through assets like TIPs-based inflation breakevens rather than relying solely on gold, because diversification across asset classes provides better coverage of the inflation scenario.
“One of the easiest ones most people will say is you should just buy gold. I'm not disputing that that's an easy way to do it. There's doubt that that might solve your problem but you don't want to be only invested in one asset class only, like as your protection against inflation returning.”
A tragic accident occurred in Quebec where a train full of oil rail cars went out of control and exploded, killing people, illustrating the unintended consequence of blocking pipelines.
“There was actually a horrible accident in Quebec where a train full of rail cars went down and lost control and exploded and killed many.”
If the Fed continues to be tight and delays rate cuts, they will tip the global economy into recession; the question is whether they have the will to get ahead of the curve and lower rates proactively, which so far they show little inclination to do.
“Well, if the Fed continues to be tight and drag their heels at lowering rates, then there's a good chance that they will actually tip the global economy into recession, that like-- the question is, does the Fed have the-- or do they even want it? Do they want to go out and get ahead of the curve and actually lower rates? So far, you're right that there's been very little signal that they've want to do that. It's baffling that they've been so reluctant”
Bernanke's Brookings blog proposal would create a fiscal account for the Federal Reserve to hand to elected politicians during downturns, allowing the Fed to inject stimulus while elected officials decide how to spend it, combining Fed timing power with democratic accountability.
“I'm actually more sympathetic to an argument that Bernanke came up with, and he wrote about this in his Brookings blog, he talked about the fact that instead of the Fed only being in charge of monetary policy, you could make a fiscal account that they go and they hand over to politicians in times of slowdown when they want to do stimulus and they basically say to the politicians, listen, it's up to you guys how you spend this. Just spend it.”
The German Bund yielding negative 60 basis points is absurdly expensive and reflects a bubble in sovereign debt, yet this is widely accepted and even lauded by investors as a 'safe' asset.
“interest rates at minus 60 basis points in Germany and I see people telling me how 100-Year Austrian bonds are the greatest thing since the spread.”
Trump was right in his criticism that the Fed was too tight; he had a legitimate complaint that the Fed should be easing, not because the Fed shouldn't be the central bank of the world, but because the reality is that the Fed IS the world's central bank and was throwing the global economy into slowdown.
“Basically, Trump was right in the sense that the Fed was too tight...I 100% think that Trump's right. Like he has legitimate complaint when he says that the Fed is too tight. People will say, well, the Fed shouldn't be the banker to the world, they should tune for the US economy for the world. Well, that could be but you can't-- when you trade the market, you have not the market you want and the reality is that they can scream and yell that they shouldn't be the central bankers of the world. The truth of the matter is that they are the central bankers of the world. They have thrown the global economy into at least a slowdown and possibly a recession.”
If the US had balanced the budget instead of implementing Trump's tax cuts and fiscal stimulus, the economy would be much weaker and recession would be certain.
“If he had gone and tried to balance the budget, instead of spending, I suspect that you would have gotten an economy that was much weaker, and we would have for sure been in a recession now.”
Canadian consumer debt levels are so high that they are reaching saturation, where further debt accumulation will be incrementally difficult, potentially triggering a housing market rollover.
“We're in a situation where I thought it was going to roll over because of the sheer force of just there's so much debt in Canada that eventually, the consumer will reach a point where they cannot put any more debt on, or at least it'll be incrementally difficult to put on more debt.”
Canada's real estate market has been frothy/bubbly since the Great Financial Crisis, unlike the US market which has been more moderate, and is a major concern for policy.
“We have this situation where our real estate has done much better than, for example, our friends in the south, the US. Our real estate market has been going up ever since the Great Financial Crisis and is actually a point of concern.”
Powell had multiple 'r-stars' or neutral rate targets—one for financial conditions (much higher, around 2.5%) and one for Main Street (much lower, near zero)—and he prioritized raising the financial conditions r-star even though Main Street didn't need tightening.
“He talks about there's been multiple r-stars, levels that that the Fed feels is above the period or the point where they should be raising rates and one of the r-stars is for financial conditions which is dramatically different than the r-star for let's just say Main Street.”
Trump was the most MMT-like president because he cut taxes during an economic expansion (when traditional Keynesians would balance budgets and Austrians would raise rates), and justified it by saying there was no inflation—an MMT-style argument.
“In fact, I've argued that Trump is the most MMT president that we've ever had. We were eight years into an economic cycle and Trump, what did he do? He didn't go and try to balance the budget like the Keynesians would say you should do. He didn't go and say I got to crank rates because that's what the Austrians like malinvestment of capital would say you do. No, what he did was he said, we're going to cut taxes. He says, why are we cutting taxes? Because there's no inflation.”
Crises always occur in things people are not expecting; by definition, if a risk were obvious, everyone would have already hedged it, so inflation (not the widely-feared deflation) is the real tail risk to prepare for.
“The one thing that I've learned is that crises always occur in the stuff that people aren't expecting, and that's by its very definition of crisis. If it was obvious, everyone would have already hedged for it. That's one of the reasons that I think that inflation is something you should be worried about as opposed to deflation because deflation feels to me like we've been down this road before.”
Norway is a model for combining oil production with climate-friendly policies; Norway produces 5x more oil per capita than Canada yet maintains green energy focus, showing that oil production and climate action need not be mutually exclusive.
“I look at Norway and I see them as more of a model for us. Norway pumps as a per capita, five times more oil than us. Yet they still managed to live their lives with a focus on more and more green energy and more climate friendly solutions. I don't think that they need to be mutually exclusive.”
Prominent investors like Bill Gross, Jeremy Grantham, and Jeffrey Gundlach predicted a bond bear market in the mid-2010s, but were wrong because they misattributed the cause—they thought yields would rise due to Fed tightening, but actually the Fed was itself the problem, and subsequent easing drove rates lower.
“Bill Gross. I'm thinking about Jeremy Grantham, Jeffrey Gundlach. That's the third one. They were all saying that the end-- the bond bear market is upon us...bond rates went lower.”
Interest rates falling from 15% in 1981 to 1.5% in 2019 reflects a 38-year trend of disinflation, but most investors assume this trend will continue indefinitely, drawing extrapolations to negative rates, when in fact the trend may be reversing toward inflation.
“We look at it and we look at this trend in 1981, interest rates for the 10-Year were 15% and they're now 1.50%. We think to ourselves, well, this trend is going down, and it's just going to continue downward. Many people are drawing trend lines and saying, 'No, no, this is going to go negative, the US has headed minus or to zero or maybe minus four, whatever the number.'”
Inflation is scarier than deflation for portfolios because when inflation emerges, the Fed won't be able to afford to stop it due to high debt levels, making it uncontrollable; in contrast, deflationary spirals can be arrested through fiscal stimulus.
“The real endgame occurs when we get inflation, and the Fed won't be able to stop that and they won't be able to afford to stop that. That is actually much scarier of a situation for a portfolio than deflation.”
Both major Canadian political parties are running on housing-friendly policies (easier credit for homebuyers) to improve affordability, which artificially extends the housing cycle and delays the correction that Muir expected.
“both major parties are actually running on a policy of real estate friendly policies...At one point, the liberals were trying to tamp it down because they, again, just like Powell, they were worried not about the financial excesses, they were worried about the real estate excesses. They've realized that they need to get elected and they're running on this policy of more friendly credit to new homebuyers to make it more affordable.”
If Muir were a benevolent dictator in Europe, he would immediately raise rates to 100 bps (removing negative rates), cut taxes, and spend aggressively on infrastructure until the economy balanced—a policy combining positive real rates with fiscal expansion.
“I laugh and say if I was a benevolent dictator in Europe, what I would do tomorrow is I would actually raise rates to 100 basis points. I would immediately put them positive. Then what I would do is I would go and I would cut taxes, and I would infrastructure spend until the economy balanced.”
Powell, when he took office, believed that the pain from the 2008 financial crisis was so severe that it was better to preemptively stop bubbles before they formed (by raising rates) rather than clean them up afterward (Greenspan's approach).
“Powell, who was new to his job looked at this and I think that when he came in, he truly believed that he thought that the pain from the 2008 credit crisis was so large that it made more sense to stop a bubble before it was created than mop it up, which was in contrast to Greenspan who had previously said something to the effect...he'd said, 'No, you're better off just cleaning it up afterwards.'”
Attempting to solve economic problems with ever-more monetary stimulus is 'absolute madness,' and building a portfolio based on this continuing is very dangerous because the shift away from this approach will happen suddenly.
“I still believe that trying to solve your problems with more and more it stimulus is absolute madness and to make a portfolio based upon that continuing is very dangerous. Because when it turns, it'll turn quickly and we'll be surprised at how fast that mantra disappears.”
India's recent corporate tax cut from 35% to 22% is mimicking Trump's successful tax-cutting strategy and should lead to similar growth effects.
“India came out and cut taxes from 35% down to 22%. To me, it looks like they're just going and doing exactly what Trump did. We look at the effect of what happened in the US, let's face it, the US was the strongest performing economy over the last few years”
Canada's housing market will likely experience a correction, but this may be offset by improvements in the energy sector if pipeline infrastructure improves, creating an offset between housing weakness and energy strength.
“I could see a situation where a year from now, the Canadian real estate's doing poorly, but yet the Canadian energy's doing better and we get to once again, it's almost Canadian and that it's a little bit of both, and it's not going to be going one way or the other.”
There is a possibility that the Fed is intentionally waiting to force other countries to solve their own problems via fiscal stimulus, making the Fed no longer the only game in town and allowing other economies to lift the global picture.
“There is a chance that maybe the Fed is trying to wait everybody out and force other countries to solve their problems and make it so that they're no longer the only game in town and that may be some other countries can lift the global economy up as well.”