What this covers

This is an edited version of Bridgewater's Q1 CIO call, in which Co-CIO Karen Karniol-Tambour lays out how the firm is reading an environment it calls radically different from the last 15 years of strong returns to traditional assets, the last 40 years of globalization and secular disinflation, and the last 80 years of US-led order. The organizing frame is Modern Mercantilism, defined as a state-driven paradigm pursuing national wealth, geopolitical strength, and self-sufficiency, in which a trade deficit is treated as a wealth transfer and a security weakness. She says the shift has been building for five to ten years, and that only asset prices appear to have moved abruptly.

The rest of the talk works through consequences. On the economy, she describes a productivity drag from producing where it is strategically safe rather than efficient, and a Fed that will struggle to ease proactively with tariff-driven inflation near 4% to 4.5%, while other central banks can ease more readily. On markets, she stresses that capital moves far faster than trade. US equities are now 70–75% of global market capitalization, a 50-to-70 point concentration she calls a vulnerability. She notes that the term premium on Treasuries rose 50 basis points in two weeks and may be only the beginning of a reassessment. She also argues that US corporates are more exposed than the domestic economy, with about 40% of earnings tariff-exposed through foreign inputs and another 40% earned abroad.

Several positions are openly contested. She argues that the dollar's 15–20 year secular rise should not be extrapolated, and that the largest remaining flow risk lies with traditional US allies, since China and Russia have already moved out of dollar bonds. She forecasts further gold appreciation, citing a small market, central-bank demand, and underallocated investors. She also treats AI as a separate once-in-a-generation force that could accelerate great power competition and partly offset the mercantilist drag, though expectations for Mag Seven capex and earnings leave little room for disappointment. For currency, she urges attention to structural risk over daily risk-on/risk-off swings.

Sharpest takeaway

Karen Carnell Tambbor argues that the global economy has permanently shifted from a US-led liberal order toward modern mercantilism, driven by structural discontents unrelated to Trump, making a return to the previous regime impossible and requiring urgent portfolio restructuring to account for policy-induced recession, Fed constraints, capital outflows from US assets, and rising geopolitical risk.

  • The transition to modern mercantilism reflects 5-10 years of building discontent with globalization and US dominance, not a Trump-created phenomenon; Trump is a symptom, not the cause
  • Trust destruction, uncertainty injection, and the desire for self-sufficiency are structural and irreversible even if Trump reverses specific policies
  • This environment cascades into policy-induced slowdown, constrained Fed easing, capital flight from US assets, and unprecedented dollar vulnerability despite recent dramatic market moves showing minimal repricing

The claims · ranked80 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

The shift to modern mercantalism is not reversible even if Trump were replaced by another administration because: (1) the underlying discontent with globalization and US-led order is structural, not temporary; (2) the chaotic implementation rapidly destroyed trust in the US as a reliable trading and security partner, making allies unwilling to rely on the US even if policies changed; (3) the uncertainty injected by unpredictable policy changes cannot simply be reversed.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“I'll say there's three reasons why there's really no going back to where we came from, right? One is the long-term reason which is there is a reason that there's been a buildup and a shift in this direction...Whether or not it's this set of policies or a slightly different set of policies, you're going to see an attempt to find an answer to what's seen as discontent to the last um paradigm. And so you're not going to stay in that old paradigm. Then the next two reasons they're not going back are more specific to how it's been implemented, which is look, it takes a lot of years to build up the trust to have the sort of USled international order that we've had. It doesn't take a long time to destroy the trust. And what's happened the last few months is that a lot of trust was very rapidly destroyed.”

0.78

Capital flows move far faster than trade flows and policy implementation; while the policy goal is to rebalance US trade deficits, trade adjustment takes years, but capital reallocation can happen in weeks or months, meaning the structural pressure from foreign investors reducing US exposure can materially accelerate before any actual trade rebalancing occurs.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“The capital can move a lot faster. And this is what is starting to happen. This is why US assets are under such risk because of how much faster capital can move than the trade.”

0.74

Mercantalist policies create a productivity drag on the economy because they prioritize national self-sufficiency and security over productive efficiency, meaning countries will not produce in the most efficient locations but rather in locations deemed strategically necessary, reducing overall global productivity.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“If productivity is sort of the underlying force that pushes the economy forward, these mercantalist policies are a productivity drag by definition. You're saying I'm not going to go produce based on where's most efficient. I want to be self-sufficient. I want to think about national security, etc. It might be offset by things like AI, but that's a productivity drag underlying everything.”

0.74

Strategically, investors should focus on structural currency risks rather than tactical day-to-day currency movements when building currency exposures, as the important question is what risk is being taken over months and years, not what happens during daily risk-on/risk-off trading.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“It is somewhat hard to take advantage of just the fact that it happens to be that on the same day one rises and one falls. And so when you step back and think about what are your currency exposures, the most important question is what are the structural risk that you're taking over months and years and probably not you know what's happening with your risk appetite really dayto-day.”

0.71

Modern mercantalism is defined as a state-driven paradigm where the state pursues three interconnected goals: accumulating national wealth, pursuing geopolitical strength, and achieving economic self-sufficiency, with trade deficits viewed as wealth transfers abroad and security vulnerabilities that require tariffs, industrial policy, and protection of strategic sectors.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“What we mean by that is something pretty specific. It's that the state has a role or is perceived to have a role which is to do three things that can be interconnected. One is really accumulate national wealth. The state should worry about how much national wealth is accumulated. Second is pursuing geopolitical strength and the third is economic self-sufficiency. You can see how trade deficits end up being kind of smack in the center of these things, right? Trade deficits are perceived as something to be avoided because they're perceived as a wealth transfer abroad as something that diminishes self-sufficiency...And so something like very intense tariffs on China is kind of smack in the middle of the set of policies.”

0.71

We are in a radically different economic and market environment than the last 15 years of extraordinary returns for traditional assets, the last 40 years of laissez-faire globalization and secular disinflation, and the last 80 years of a strong US-led international order, and there is no going back.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“we are in a radically different economic and market environment than what came before. It is very different than the last 15 years where there's been an extraordinary set of returns for traditional assets for equities. very different from the last 40 years where the backdrop was kind of a lazair high globalization secular disinflation background and for the last 80 years where there's been a very strong US-led international order. We're in a very different environment today and there's no going back.”

0.71

US corporates are more vulnerable to the policy shift than the broader US economy because they are highly international: approximately 40% of US corporate earnings are from products made with foreign inputs (tariff-exposed), another 40% are sold abroad (retaliation-exposed), and they face coordinated foreign retaliation strategies including currency depreciation, targeted market access restrictions, regulatory actions, and asset seizures.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“When you add that up you see that very little of what's going on in US corporates is making and selling things inside the United States. there is a large share about 40% that is sold in the United States but with lots of products and inputs from abroad. So very obviously sensitive to tariffs but also sensitive to other ways of kind of making it more difficult for these US companies to get all these inputs they need. And then another 40% are just sold abroad and so these are very vulnerable to retaliation”

0.71

We are in a radically different economic and market environment than the last 15 years, fundamentally different from the last 40 years of globalization and secular disinflation, and different from the last 80 years of US-led international order, and there is no going back.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“we are in a radically different economic and market environment than what came before. It is very different than the last 15 years where there's been an extraordinary set of returns for traditional assets for equities. very different from the last 40 years where the backdrop was kind of a lazair high globalization secular disinflation background and for the last 80 years where there's been a very strong US-led international order.”

0.69

US equities now represent 70–75% of global market capitalization (up from 50% in 2010), and most global capital is concentrated in equities and liquid assets after a 15-year run-up; this creates exceptional vulnerability to equity bear markets and US underperformance because there is no diversification benefit and concentrated capital becomes forced sellers in downturns.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“the assets that do well get more and more capital because they go up in value and people see that and want to be in them bigger and bigger part of market cap. So we're starting at a place where global capital is extremely concentrated in equities and in the liquids...The concentration in the US is greater than ever. And so performing well when the US is the underperformer is tough to do given the large size the US plays today.”

0.69

The yield curve (term premium on US treasuries) has risen 50 basis points in two weeks, reflecting a rise in risk premium being assessed on US assets and treasuries that was previously considered risk-free with almost zero return; while this adjustment is meaningful, it may be only the beginning of reassessment and represents a warning sign of balance-of-payments dynamics the Fed has not had to consider in decades.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“when you look at everything I spoke about in terms of the loss of trust in the United States, less reliable as a trading partner, as a security partner, it's very natural to see why people around the world are reassessing their exposure to the United States, and we expect that to continue. US assets are under tremendous risk. And so, if you're the Fed, what's happened so far, while it's been fast, is probably still tolerable. But there's clearly been a rise in the sort of risk premium being assessed on US assets and on treasuries in particular. And so if you think about not the level of rates but kind of the yield curve or how much is being charged by the markets to hold a longerterm treasury relative to being shorter term treasuries, you know, that yield curve probably rose 50 basis points in two weeks.”

0.69

The mercantalist environment is expanding the set of policy levers beyond traditional monetary policy (interest rates, quantitative easing, fiscal policy) to include tariffs, antitrust actions, industrial policy levers, and other non-monetary tools.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“Tariffs were not a common lever we were speaking about in the past. Now we're talking about tariffs, antitrust, lots of different industrial uh policy type of levers that can be used.”

0.69

China and Russia have been shifting out of their dollar and euro holdings, mostly bonds, in response to what they felt was a weaponization of dollar holdings after Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“China and Russia have been pretty much shifting out of the assets that they've held mostly bonds in response to what they felt was a weaponization of dollar holdings um after Russia invade Ukraine.”

0.69

Modern mercantilism policies directly impose a productivity drag on the economy because they prioritize self-sufficiency and national security over efficient production location, offsetting only partially any gains from technological disruption like AI.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“if productivity is sort of the underlying force that pushes the economy forward, these mercantalist policies are a productivity drag by definition. You're saying I'm not going to go produce based on where's most efficient. I want to be self-sufficient. I want to think about national security, etc. It might be offset by things like AI, but that's a productivity drag underlying everything.”

0.68

Other central banks (outside the US) face much easier easing decisions than the Fed because they: (1) face small tariff impacts on inflation; (2) face large cyclical growth weakness; (3) benefit from deflationary currency and commodity price effects, meaning they can ease without balance-of-payments constraints and should lead the easing cycle.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“the contrast I would make is really other central banks because other central banks will very likely lead this easing cycle because they are not facing this. And so if you put yourself in shoes of another central bank and this kind of average of non US developed countries but across the board it captures a lot of this which is the tariff impact on inflation is very small. The cyclical weakness is much bigger and they're actually seeing more deflationary effects from commodity prices from their currencies.”

0.68

Gold has appreciated substantially (breaking above $3,300/ounce, up ~2.5%) and is likely to continue appreciating because: (1) the gold market is much smaller than currency or equity markets, so smaller flows from repositioning have outsized price impact; (2) foreign central banks and reserve managers (China, Russia, allies) who previously held bonds now see those as weaponizable, so they buy gold as an alternative store of value; (3) most investors are underallocated to gold, creating room for further appreciation.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“When we walked into this room today to have this conversation and this call, gold had broken through $3,300 an ounce. It was up almost two and a half% in the morning. And this has just been a continuous kind of climb up.”

0.68

The dollar has risen secularly for 15–20 years despite persistent US trade deficits, signaling strong foreign demand for dollar assets, but this structural driver should not be extrapolated forward; instead, investors should not assume the dollar will continue to rise and should recalibrate neutral currency positioning given structural pressures for secular dollar decline from capital reallocation.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“I would say you do not want to extrapolate going forward the dollar continuing to rise as part of how you're building your strategic exposures. Dollar has just gone through, you know, 15 20 years of a big secular rise. You don't want to extrapolate that. And so thinking about your neutral position, not assuming that you're going to earn something from the dollar was already true before this.”

0.68

China and Russia have already largely exited dollar holdings (especially bonds) after perceiving the US as weaponizing dollar-based sanctions; it is traditional US allies (NATO members, Canada, Japan, Korea) with the largest remaining holdings who are now reconsidering their exposure, representing a much larger flow risk than China's adjustments.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“So the same trade deficit that there's an attempt to close. The other side of it is that every time we buy mortgages from abroad, people are buying our financial assets. And what you see is happening is that for many years the dollar was actually rising secularly despite the trade deficits showing that the foreign interest in US stocks and US bonds was greater than the United States desired around trade deficits. Now what's happening today is that these attempt to close the trade deficits, they're not moving very quickly to actually shift US trade...The capital can move a lot faster.”

0.68

The Federal Reserve faces unprecedented constraints on its ability to proactively ease policy in response to growth slowdowns because tariff-driven inflation will likely produce readings around 4% to 4.5%, making it difficult for the Fed to justify cutting rates aggressively even though cyclical weakness is occurring simultaneously.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“the Fed in particular, will have a harder time really being able to respond to this growth slowdown in a way that is nearly as proactive as they have been... you look at our leading inflation pressures the United States has a meaningful impact from tariffs that's likely to hit... very likely you're going to get something like a 4% 4 and a.5% type inflation set of prints that even if the Fed looks at them and says these are probably short-term, these are probably one-off effects, to have the confidence to ease proactively into that is a different bar.”

0.68

The mechanical relationship between dollar strength and risk-off market behavior—where global risk-off days cause dollar appreciation because of how buyers and sellers behave—has good mechanical reasons and should persist, but is offset by new risks to the US itself.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“in terms of that more day-to-day relationship, right, there are good mechanical reasons that really go back to who are the players and how do they behave, why when you have a global riskoff day, you tend to have the dollar going up. Meaning, when we really look at the buyers and sellers and how they're behaving, we understand what's driving that. It's not just a statistical correlation. And I don't see a lot of reason for that to go away.”

0.68

The Federal Reserve will have a harder time responding to the coming growth slowdown proactively compared to historical performance, particularly because of constraints from inflation pressures and balance-of-payments crisis-like dynamics.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“natural question is what can the central banks do? how much can they step in? And we're in an environment where the United States in particular, the Fed in particular, will have a harder time really being able to respond to this growth slowdown in a way that is nearly as proactive as they have been.”

0.66

AI and machine learning represent a once-in-a-generation technological disruption that will interact with the mercantalist environment; AI will likely accelerate great power competition (as evidenced by events like DeepSeek), contribute to labor market stress, but may also provide productivity offsets to mercantalist drag, with outcome uncertainty creating major room for disappointment given already sky-high expectations for AI capex and earnings among Mag Seven companies.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“we are living through this while simultaneously there is a once in a generation technological disruption that's going on and that has felt easier to ignore when you're getting you know intraday big shifts in policy you're not getting necessarily as fast of a move here but when you step back even over a month what's happening over a month and a few months in AI and machine learning is remarkable”

0.66

The transition from the old globalized, US-led order to modern mercantalism has been 5–10 years in the making across geopolitics, policy approach, globalization trends, Fed constraints, and secular disinflation, with only financial asset returns appearing to shift abruptly; the underlying environment shift has been visible for years to attentive observers like Bridgewater.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“When you look at what we've been used to, whether it's on geopolitics, the government's broad approach to economic policy, the kind of Washington consensus we were living in, what globalization was like, the constraints on the Fed, the secular disinflation, in all these areas, there was really a period of transition here that was, you know, 5 to 10 years, depending on which area, where you started seeing things pop up and say, 'Wait a minute, we're not so sure that the old environment works anymore.'”

0.63

The gold market is much smaller than the dollar market, meaning that a much smaller number of players deciding to hold more gold can create large price movements.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“Well, we know that the gold market is small. It's nowhere near the size of the dollar market. And so if you look coming out of um Russia's invasion of Ukraine when um actors like China most importantly concluded that their dollar and euro holdings importantly could be weaponized against them. They moved meaningfully into gold. You barely saw any sign of that in the dollar or the euro but you saw huge price effect of that in gold. So it's a much smaller market where a much smaller number of players can decide I'd like some more gold in order to get a big price move.”

0.63

We are living through a once-in-a-generation technological disruption in AI and machine learning that has been easier to ignore amid recent policy turmoil, but will be one of the most important forces defining the next decade.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“We are simultaneously amid a once in a generation technological disruption. that's been easier to ignore the last few weeks, but when we look back a decade from now, this will be one of the most important forces that define what's going to happen in the next decade or so”

0.62

Jim Haskell's observation that the recent market action (dollar down, equities down, bonds not rallying, gold up) resembles a balance-of-payments crisis pattern is accurate; Karen characterizes this as being 'on the edges' of a balance-of-payments crisis, not yet a constraint on the Fed, but a warning sign that could become a major constraint.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“I think we're on the edges. I don't think there's a real constraint on the Fed yet. You're talking about a Fed that has not had to think like an emerging market central bank in decades, right? And so it's going to take more pressure for the Fed to really say this is a major constraint on me. But it's a start of a warning sign.”

0.62

Productivity growth expectations already incorporate significant AI benefits, and since Trump policies will restrict immigration, growth cannot come from labor force expansion; therefore, the economy needs very high productivity growth just to achieve reasonable non-inflationary growth, meaning much of the productivity upside from AI is already baked into forecasts with limited margin of safety.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“if you kind of say what's the productivity that's already expected to get a reasonable runway for growth that's non-inflationary especially at a time where you know that President Trump and his team are going to clamp down immigration so you're not going to get tons of growth from just labor force growing the number we would come to is you know pretty good certainly much higher than it was in the great financial crisis. So a lot's already baked in the cake.”

0.60

US assets have been bought by foreigners to a massive degree, which is the natural flip side of the trade deficit; for every dollar of foreign goods imported, foreigners have been buying US financial assets.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“US assets have been bought by foreigners to a massive degree and it's just the natural flip side of the trade deficit. So the same trade deficit that there's an attempt to close. The other side of it is that every time we buy mortgages from abroad, people are buying our financial assets.”

0.60

Long-term public debt is growing in many countries, and there is a strong temptation to deploy fiscal and industrial policy to manage the mercantalist transition, which raises questions about the limits of how far public sector balance sheets can go.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“from the perspective of long-term debts, we're going into this with kind of an ever growing size of public debts in a lot of countries. And the temptation to kind of move against this environment using fiscal policy, industrial policy, basically use public sector balance sheets is going to be there and really question the limits of how far that can go.”

0.59

The most important currency positioning question is structural risk over months and years, not day-to-day risk appetite dynamics, because it is hard to exploit the day-to-day correlation between currencies and risk sentiment.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“it's somewhat hard to take advantage of just the fact that it happens to be that on the same day one rises and one falls. And so when you step back and think about what are your currency exposures, the most important question is what are the structural risk that you're taking over months and years and probably not you know what's happening with your risk appetite really dayto-day.”

0.59

The transition to modern mercantilism has been building over 5-10 years across multiple domains (geopolitics, government economic policy, globalization, Fed constraints, and secular disinflation), with only asset returns showing an abrupt shift; this is not a Trump-created phenomenon but Trump is a symptom of deeper discontent.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“This did not happen in a day. This is not the story of one policy of one announcement where President Trump, you know, gets up and has liberation day tariffs. It is much bigger and broader than that...there was really a period of transition here that was, you know, 5 to 10 years, depending on which area, where you started seeing things pop up and say, 'Wait a minute, we're not so sure that the old environment works anymore.'”

0.57

US corporates have approximately 40% of sales in the United States but with many products and inputs from abroad, making them very sensitive to tariffs and other barriers to getting needed inputs.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“there is a large share about 40% that is sold in the United States but with lots of products and inputs from abroad. So very obviously sensitive to tariffs but also sensitive to other ways of kind of making it more difficult for these US companies to get all these inputs they need.”

0.57

Bridgewater's forward growth estimates for the US have fallen from approximately normal growth levels to very close to zero since the policy announcements, indicating a rising probability of US recession driven by both direct policy effects and uncertainty-induced business paralysis.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“since the election, United States coincident growth has already fallen a decent amount. Our forward estimate went from pretty much normal to very close to zero. That's a rising probability of a recession.”

0.57

Global growth is also slowing substantially (forward estimates around 0.4% for non-US developed countries on average), not just the US, and while some countries like Germany are deploying fiscal policy to offset effects, most are not, creating a synchronized global growth slowdown that will hit all asset prices and portfolios.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“When you look globally, this is not a US slowdown. This is going to be a global slowdown. Our US our forward growth estimate in other countries about 0.4%. You have the same meaningful uncertainty effect hitting everywhere. Tariff effects are bigger in some countries, smaller in others.”

0.56

As a market practitioner, there is no certainty yet about where the AI winners and losers will be, but expectations are already sky-high, leaving room for disappointment.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“As a market practitioner, the main point I would leave you with is that there is no certainty yet about where the winners and losers will be, right? But expectations are already sky-high and so a lot of room for disappointment in the particular place expectations are there already very high expectations”

0.56

Since 2010-2015, the buyers of massive amounts of US stocks and bonds have not been US adversaries like China and Russia, but traditional US allies including NATO members, Canada, Japan, and Korea.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“it is really traditional US allies, NATO members, Canada, Japan, Korea, traditional US allies that have been on a buying spree, buying massive amounts of US stocks, US bonds”

0.55

Countries are employing creative retaliation measures including: limiting market access specifically for US companies, depreciating currencies, reducing purchases of US goods in a targeted way, increasing subsidies to domestic producers, restricting US imports of needed components, and taking regulatory actions that specifically target US companies or seize their local assets.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“attempts to say how do I limit the market access specifically for US companies? How do I depreciate my currency? How do I reduce my purchase of US goods in a targeted way? Increase subsidies to my domestic producers. Restrict US from importing the pieces that they need as well as have regulatory actions that very literally target US companies or seize their local assets.”

0.55

Falling growth is harmful to global capital because capital's profits are made when growth is rising and it loses money when growth is falling, and this is worse if liquidity is tightening and the Federal Reserve cannot flexibly ease into growth problems.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“Falling growth is not great for global capital. Makes all of its money in periods where growth is rising, loses money when growth is falling. It's worse if liquidity is also tightening and you don't have a Federal Reserve that can flexibly ease into a growth problem.”

0.55

Productivity growth from the great financial crisis through the prior decade was very slow at more than 10 years of slack, but productivity did accelerate coming out of the recession, as recessions are times when productivity can accelerate.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“We had very slow productivity growth coming out of the great financial crisis for more than 10 years. And that really held back, you know, what the economy could deliver. We did a great job on productivity um coming out of the uh recession because coming out of recessions is really a time where productivity can accelerate.”

0.53

Tariffs will likely generate inflation prints of around 4-4.5% in the US, and even if the Fed believes these are temporary one-off effects, the magnitude makes it difficult to justify proactively easing into such inflation.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“very likely you're going to get something like a 4% 4 and a.5% type inflation set of prints that even if the Fed looks at them and says these are probably short-term, these are probably one-off effects, to have the confidence to ease proactively into that is a different bar.”

0.52

Mercantilism creates a more volatile short-term debt cycle by injecting policy uncertainty while removing deflationary forces (globalization), making it harder for central banks to ease without inflation concerns.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“You're talking about a much more volatile short-term debt cycle. I just spoke about, you know, all the uncertainty that's been interjected. That's a lot more volatility in the business cycle and happening in a time where you don't have these deflationary forces anymore. So, tougher for central banks to balance the volatility um and be able to ease into it.”

0.52

Long-term public debt levels are already high across many countries, and the temptation to use fiscal policy and industrial policy (leveraging public sector balance sheets) to fight mercantilist pressures will increase, raising questions about the limits of sustainable debt and new policy tools (tariffs, antitrust, industrial subsidies) beyond traditional monetary levers.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“from the perspective of long-term debts, we're going into this with kind of an ever growing size of public debts in a lot of countries. And the temptation to kind of move against this environment using fiscal policy, industrial policy, basically use public sector balance sheets is going to be there and really question the limits of how far that can go. and the levers we're going to see used. If traditionally we had primarily, you know, interest rates, quantive easing, a little bit of fiscal, there's a whole range of levers that get employed in this type of environment. Tariffs were not a common lever we were speaking about in the past. Now we're talking about tariffs, antitrust, lots of different industrial uh policy type of levers that can be used.”

0.52

To maintain current asset valuations, the US needs approximately 70 cents of every cross-border dollar inflow to come into the US; but Bridgewater's structural estimates show these cross-border purchases declining due to uncertainty, loss of trust, and risks of worse US growth outcomes, creating downward pressure on US assets and the dollar.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“you need to get I don't know 70 cents of every crossber dollar to come into the United States um just to keep kind of where we are at the end of the day...we really try to get in there and estimate buyers and sellers of every asset in the world cross border within borders so you have here kind of our structural estimates of these purchases coming down based on the uncertainty the lack of trust in the United States this could be exacerbated by the United States having worse growth outcomes”

0.52

Modern mercantilism is a paradigm in which the state seeks to accumulate national wealth, pursue geopolitical strength, and achieve economic self-sufficiency, viewing trade deficits as wealth transfers abroad and sources of security vulnerabilities.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“modern mercantalism. What we mean by that is something pretty specific. It's that the state has a role or is perceived to have a role which is to do three things that can be interconnected. One is really accumulate national wealth. The state should worry about how much national wealth is accumulated. Second is pursuing geopolitical strength and the third is economic self-sufficiency.”

0.52

The mercantalist environment creates a much more volatile short-term debt cycle because of the uncertainty injected, and this volatility occurs in a context where deflationary forces no longer exist, making it harder for central banks to balance volatility and ease.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“You're talking about a much more volatile short-term debt cycle. I just spoke about, you know, all the uncertainty that's been interjected. That's a lot more volatility in the business cycle and happening in a time where you don't have these deflationary forces anymore. So, tougher for central banks to balance the volatility um and be able to ease into it.”

0.52

The loss of trust in the United States as a reliable trading and security partner is driving reassessment of US asset exposure globally, and this is likely to continue as countries pursue economic self-sufficiency and avoid coercion.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“when you look at everything I spoke about in terms of the loss of trust in the United States, less reliable as a trading partner, as a security partner, it's very natural to see why people around the world are reassessing their exposure to the United States, and we expect that to continue.”

0.52

Rebuilding trust in the US as a reliable partner would take years of shifting not just policies but the direction of policy, because destroying trust is fast but rebuilding it is slow.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“it'll be very difficult for a new government to meaningfully rebuild the trust quickly. And so if you have four years where trust is destroyed, it gets very difficult to build that up in a day. And so some of the pressures that will be in the system, for example, reduce reliance on the United States. It takes a lot for somebody to say, you know what, now I trust the United States. I no longer want to be self-sufficient away from the United States. Um so you probably would need years of shifting away not just of specific policies but of a direction to rebuild some of that trust.”

0.51

Non-US central banks will very likely lead the easing cycle because they face smaller tariff impacts, much bigger cyclical weakness, and more deflationary effects from commodity prices and currency moves, with no balance-of-payments constraints.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“other central banks will very likely lead this easing cycle because they are not facing this. And so if you put yourself in shoes of another central bank and this kind of average of non US developed countries...the tariff impact on inflation is very small. The cyclical weakness is much bigger and they're actually seeing more deflationary effects from commodity prices from their currencies.”

0.51

There are good reasons to expect a slow secular decline in the dollar as countries reassess their US exposure, though this decline could occur at a slow pace, as evidenced by how slowly China has moved out of its dollar holdings.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“there's good reasons why you could get a slow secular decline in the dollar as that revisiting it can happen at a slow pace. Look at how slowly China has moved out of its dollar holdings. But that's a persistent pressure that'll be much bigger than China because these are much bigger holdings.”

0.50

Global capital is extremely concentrated in equities and liquid assets after a massive 15-year run in financial assets, particularly US equities, which makes capital vulnerable to growth slowdowns, liquidity tightening, and equity bear markets.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“we're coming out of a period of just a massive run in financial assets. most importantly a massive run in US equities and in liquid assets. And as naturally happens, the assets that do well get more and more capital because they go up in value and people see that and want to be in them bigger and bigger part of market cap. So we're starting at a place where global capital is extremely concentrated in equities and in the liquids.”

0.50

The concentration in US equities makes it very difficult to perform well when the US is the underperformer given the large size the US plays in global markets today.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“And so performing well when the US is the underperformer is tough to do given the large size the US plays today.”

0.50

Foreign investors holding huge piles of US assets should be asking themselves whether they want that US exposure to rise, and whether it is likely that exposure would be weaponized in the future.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“huge piles of US assets at a time where it's very reasonable to say how much do I want that exposure to rise. How likely is it that that exposure would be weaponized in the future?”

0.49

Since the election, US coincident growth has already fallen a meaningful amount, forward growth estimates have fallen from normal levels to very close to zero, indicating a rising probability of recession.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“United States coincident growth has already fallen a decent amount. Our forward estimate went from pretty much normal to very close to zero. That's a rising probability of a recession.”

0.48

A different government could continue the broad mercantalist direction even if reducing chaos and being more selective about specific policies, because the underlying concerns and discontents will remain in place.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“a different government could easily come in and say we're going to reduce the chaos we're going to create more predictability they may not like specific policies if you look at the map of policy laid out they could choose that a bunch of them are not good policies to pursue they could be more selective in how to do them but I think the broad direction of where we're going the concerns that are kind of leading to these policies is likely to stay in place”

0.48

The only place the transition has been extremely sharp has been in financial asset returns, which enjoyed an exceptional unabated run from 2010 until recently, making the shift feel abrupt in prices despite the underlying structural transition taking 5-10 years.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“Really, the only place the transition has been extremely sharp has really been asset returns. We had an exceptional run in financial assets, especially US equities. They really went from 2010 and pretty much continued unabated until pretty recently. So there the shift in what financial markets feels like feels abrupt.”

0.47

The winners and losers in the AI revolution are highly uncertain; we are early in the cycle (analogous to 1998 in the internet boom, not 2024); many future winners don't yet exist, so attempting to pick winners today has low probability of success.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“as a market practitioner, the main point I would leave you with is that there is no certainty yet about where the winners and losers will be, right? But expectations are already sky-high...if you look back at the internet boom, and you think where do you think we are in that story? I think it's hard to argue we're well past, I don't know, call it 1998, which is a lot of promise, but the internet is not yet kind of where it is today with us all having phones. A lot of the winners today in markets that would have made you all this money from this revolution. I mean, Meta didn't even exist yet. Google didn't even exist yet at the time. So very hard to believe that we know who the winners are and that you'll be able to pick them today. Some of them may not even exist yet today.”

0.46

Developments in AI and machine learning will interact with the mercantalist environment, reinforcing some of its drivers while potentially giving breathing room to others.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“developments in AI and machine learning are going to interact with this environment, reinforcing some of its drivers, potentially giving some breeding room to others.”

0.46

Very high expectations are already priced in for capex from AI leaders to support the economy, though there is potential for more capex when non-AI leaders realize they face existential threat and must invest in AI themselves (the "Barnes & Noble moment").

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“very high expectations for capex from AI that will support the economy. I think they could go more than this because companies that are not the AI leaders, not the mag seven, can wake up one day and realize kind of in what um you know my colleague Cos Greg Jensen called a Barnes & Noble moment. They can realize, wait a minute, we're under existential threat.”

0.46

This is a global slowdown, not merely a US slowdown, with forward growth estimates of about 0.4% in non-US developed countries, driven by the same meaningful uncertainty effect, though tariff effects vary by country.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“when you look globally, this is not a US slowdown. This is going to be a global slowdown. Our US our forward growth estimate in other countries about 0.4%. You have the same meaningful uncertainty effect hitting everywhere.”

0.46

We expect a policy-induced slowdown with a rising probability of recession, and the chaotic implementation of mercantalist policies is a major driver of this slowdown.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“we're in a point today where we really expect a policy induced slowdown and there's a rising probability of a recession. As I mentioned, the chaotic implementation of this shift in environment is a major driver of this.”

0.45

It is an excellent time to revisit currency posture because currencies were not moving much recently, so currency positioning seemed less relevant, and because foreign investors benefited from holding dollars as they rose secularly over 15-20 years.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“I think it's a really excellent time to revisit currency posture partly because currencies were just not moving that much and so it seemed less relevant to be asking the question of what is my currency posture? In addition to that, just like you said, if you were outside the United States, you just benefited from holding dollars, they went up secularly.”

0.45

Foreign investors should not extrapolate the dollar continuing to rise secularly going forward as part of how they build strategic exposures; a long 15-20 year secular rise in the dollar should not be assumed to persist.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“Dollar has just gone through, you know, 15 20 years of a big secular rise. You don't want to extrapolate that. And so thinking about your neutral position, not assuming that you're going to earn something from the dollar was already true before this.”

0.45

US assets are under tremendous risk, and a rise in risk premium is being assessed on US assets and treasuries in particular.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“US assets are under tremendous risk. And so, if you're the Fed, what's happened so far, while it's been fast, is probably still tolerable. But there's clearly been a rise in the sort of risk premium being assessed on US assets and on treasuries in particular.”

0.45

The yield curve slope rose approximately 50 basis points in two weeks, which is meaningful but started from a level where treasuries were considered virtually risk-free with minimal risk premium.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“that yield curve probably rose 50 basis points in two weeks. It's meaningful, but it's starting from a level where for many years there was virtually no risk premium in treasuries. It was considered a risk-free asset.”

0.45

The US moved from 50% to almost 75% of world stock market capitalization since 2010, and recent underperformance barely undoes a couple months of US outperformance.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“the US moved from 50 to almost 75% of world stock markets. What's happened recently is barely noticeable. The US has been outperforming every single country in the world massively. The last few weeks have felt like dramatic underperformance, but it barely undoes, you know, a couple months of this.”

0.45

The dollar is not equally unattractive against every currency; it appears most unattractive against the yen and euro, and more matched against other currencies.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“the dollar is not equally unattractive against every currency. It looks most unattractive against the yen, also against the euro, against other currencies. It is more matched and so you have to sort of match all the different pressures that are going in in the dollar”

0.45

Gold has broken through $3,300 per ounce and is up nearly 2.5% in a morning session, continuing a continuous climb upward during this period of policy uncertainty and capital reassessment.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Jim Haskell

“when we walked into this room today to have this conversation and this call, gold had broken through $3,300 an ounce. It was up almost two and a half% in the morning. And this has just been a continuous kind of climb up.”

0.45

Recent stock market moves (down 10% in 48 hours, then rebound) and currency moves (yen from 155 to 145) feel dramatic in real time but are actually very small relative to the magnitude of underlying structural change in the global economy, suggesting that most of the repricing of assets has not yet occurred.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“the two days after liberation day with stock market being down more than 10% I mean that's probably some of the worst 48 hours since World War II or something and then you had a very big rebound on the other side of that being paused the currency markets a shift from the yen at 155 to 145. certainly feels dramatic. We talked about a 50 basis points move in that yield curve slope in the United States. That's a lot to live through in a very short period of time... But when you then just go and step back and look at these market moves in the context since 2010 or so, since this run we had in the last 15 years in assets, they are very small.”

0.43

Capital outflows from the US from foreigners reducing their exposure are likely to be faster than any offsetting inflows from foreign companies building factories in the US, because capital decisions (sell) can be made in seconds while FDI (build factories) takes years.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“if you just take those two types of flows and you say well how quickly could you decide wait a minute maybe I don't want lots more US exposure I'm okay with my 70 50% I'm okay with my 70% I'm just going to hold off here you can decide that in a second you don't need to worry about a lot versus a decision to go build a factory in the United States there could be real pressure to do that and in some cases it may even make sense economically to do that but that's going to be a much slower decision”

0.43

Recent market moves in US stocks, currencies, and bond yields, while dramatic in appearance, are very small relative to the magnitude of underlying tectonic shifts in the environment, indicating pricing has not moved much despite the chaotic appearance.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“when you then just go and step back and look at these market moves in the context since 2010 or so, since this run we had in the last 15 years in assets, they are very small. The magnitude of what's actually occurred in pricing is very small relative to what I really believe is the magnitude of underlying tectonic shifts that are underway here.”

0.42

Some countries that have chosen to employ fiscal policy to offset mercantalist policy effects will be better off, with Germany as an example of a country front-footed in creating economic self-sufficiency, defense capabilities, and infrastructure.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“in some places they have chosen to employ fiscal policy to offset these effects. and more countries might follow. So Germany is probably the best example of who's been front-footed saying, 'We see all this. We don't need to live with this. We can go and change rules that were considered unchangeable in Germany, but go and create our own economic self-sufficiency, our own defense capabilities, our own infrastructure, and that's why you end up a little bit better.'”

0.42

Many shoes are still to drop from the policy environment into real economic activity, capital flows, and the major forces driving the economy, indicating that pricing has not moved much and creates a time for great opportunities.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“how many shoes are left to drop that what's happening in the policy environment is just starting to show up is still ahead of us to really come into real economic activity to really hit all the capital flows that are going to be reassessed and asking these questions. You see that the pricing has not moved much yet which really creates a time for great opportunities.”

0.41

Tariff policy remains genuinely uncertain and evolving day-by-day, making it impossible for planners to know what the final tariff regime will be or when it will be implemented, which materially increases business and investment decision uncertainty.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“we were planning this call, we were planning it just a couple business days ago. We had no idea what trade policy would be by the time we did the call. That's a few business days.”

0.41

The Fed could get political pressure to ease despite inflation concerns, remaining more proactive than current market pricing suggests, which would be an offsetting factor to structural dollar depreciation.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“You could get a Fed that gets political pressure to ease that eases anyway that is still more proactive. And so when you weigh all the elements of pressure on the dollar, the dollar is not equally unattractive against every currency.”

0.39

However, easier easing by non-US central banks does not help investors as much because investors are very materially exposed to US corporates, which are extremely international entities vulnerable to the breakdown in international cooperation.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“investors are very materially exposed to US corporates. So in other places, an easier way of easing and less of a um uh constraint around easing doesn't help investors as much. And particularly, let me talk about the exposure to US companies because, you know, it's intuitive that growth slowing is not good for stocks. And in addition to that, the Fed not being able to ease is not good for US stocks. But US corporates are even greater risk than that. These are extremely international bodies that are very exposed to international cooperation kind of not going well.”

0.39

A reasonable productivity growth level needed to deliver non-inflationary growth is already quite good, much higher than post-GFC levels, especially given that Trump administration policies will restrict immigration and prevent labor force growth.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“what's the productivity that's already expected to get a reasonable runway for growth that's non-inflationary especially at a time where you know that President Trump and his team are going to clamp down immigration so you're not going to get tons of growth from just labor force growing the number we would come to is you know pretty good certainly much higher than it was in the great financial crisis.”

0.39

Gold is emerging as an alternative store of wealth because of the vulnerabilities in US dollar holdings and the structural outflows expected from the US, indicating rational capital flow toward gold.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“Well, look, we definitely could not get through this call, especially with you moderating it, not touching on gold, right? And I do think when you look at everything I said, it's hard to not walk away from that and say maybe I should hold some gold, right? I mean, you look at all these vulnerabilities and it's just a natural thing to go and want more of when very few people have it. Very few people have a big exposure to gold.”

0.39

The degree of uncertainty injected into policy makes it hard for businesses to make investment decisions about building factories, creating paralysis that stalls potential FDI inflows.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“the biggest thing that's occurred is that the degree of uncertainty that's been interjected is going to make it very hard to have particularly short-term large flows to build factories...in my view has been radically stalled by the degree of uncertainty”

0.36

A lot of AI productivity improvement is already baked into the cake of current expectations, reducing the probability of significant positive surprises from AI.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 1/4· Karen Carnell Tambbor

“So a lot's already baked in the cake.”

0.32

Germany has been proactive in deploying fiscal policy to offset the economic drag from mercantalist policies and is considering changing rules that were previously thought unchangeable, which has positioned Germany better than countries that are not offsetting with fiscal policy.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Karen Carneal Tambor

“Germany is probably the best example of who's been front-footed saying, 'We see all this. We don't need to live with this. We can go and change rules that were considered unchangeable in Germany, but go and create our own economic self-sufficiency, our own defense capabilities, our own infrastructure, and that's why you end up a little bit better.'”

0.13

Bridgewater has spent the last 5-10 years studying the green shoots of policy environment shift, their cause-and-effect linkages, and preparing for the ultimate structural shift, giving them time to position ahead of recent acute repricing.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Karen Carneel Tambbor

“And for us at Bridgewwater, that's given us the time over the last five and ten years to be seeing these green shoots of a shift in environment, studying them, studying their cause and effect linkages and preparing for the ultimate shift that's occurred.”