YouTube8m· Jun 2024· cataloged

At some point we'll have to address the exploding entitlement spending, says PwC's Rohit Kumar


What this covers

This is a nine-minute "Squawk Box" segment built around a Congressional Budget Office (CBO)) estimate that this year's federal deficit will reach $1.9 trillion, up 27% from the original projection. The anchor frames the discussion, and two guests answer it from opposite sides: Kitty Richard, a former Treasury official, and R Kumar, a former policy director for Sen. Mitch McConnell. The question is what drives the long-run debt and whether the fix lies on the revenue side or the spending side.

Kumar relies on CBO averages. Over 50 years, revenue has run about 17.3% of GDP), with 18% projected, while spending has averaged about 21% and is headed toward 25%. He calls growing entitlement spending "termites in the wall" rather than "wolves at the door." He also notes that the permanent extension of the Bush tax cuts was a bipartisan deal between Biden and McConnell. He points to the two years after 2017, when household median income rose $6,000 more than over the prior ten years combined and unemployment among several groups hit record lows.

Richard answers on several fronts. She attributes the debt projections almost entirely to the Bush and Trump tax cuts, and she says that without them the debt-to-GDP ratio would be permanently declining. She argues the 2008 crisis grew out of private housing debt rather than government borrowing. She also says Kumar's two-year window leaves out a "lost decade" that followed an undersized stimulus. She treats deficit worry as a lead-in to cutting Social Security and Medicare, and she would shift attention to housing, education, infrastructure and the clean energy transition. The anchor pushes back with the claim that every financial crisis is sparked by debt and deficits. Richard concedes there is a point at which the country spends too much but calls the framing a straw man. The segment's main contested points are the causal story behind the debt and the choice of time windows.

Sharpest takeaway

Kitty Richard argues that focusing on deficit reduction through tax increases on the wealthy is a distraction from addressing real economic needs, while R. Kumar contends that spending growth (not revenue decline) is the primary driver of long-term debt and must be addressed through entitlement reform.

  • Bush and Trump tax cuts caused revenue declines, not spending growth
  • 2008 financial crisis was caused by private debt/housing, not government debt
  • Post-2017 wage and employment gains show tax cuts can benefit working people

The claims · ranked17 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

The permanent extension of the Bush tax cuts was negotiated by Vice President Biden and Senator Mitch McConnell as a bipartisan agreement, not a partisan exercise.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· R. Kumar

“permanent extension that was negotiated by then Vice President Biden and my former boss Senator McConnell this was a bipartisan agreement not some partisan exercise”

0.73

The 2008 financial crisis was sparked by the housing crisis and private debts of banks in the financial system, not by government debt; focusing on federal debt and deficit misses the actual problem.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Kitty Richard

“the 2008 financial crisis is a really great example that put millions and millions of Americans out of work and out of their homes it was not sparked by government debt growing what it was sparked by was uh the housing crisis and so was sparked by the debts frankly of the banks this is in the system focusing on the federal debt and deficit is a distraction if you thought in 2007 that the primary problem with our economy was growing government debt and the long-term debt projections you really would have missed the mark”

0.71

Narrowing the conversation to just the deficit and debt is a mistake; the real focus should be on the real needs that American families have around housing, education, and the country's investment needs for infrastructure and the clean energy transition.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kitty Richard

“I want to zoom out for a second because I think that narrowing the conversation to just the de the deficit and debt is a real mistake I'm honestly less concerned about the trajectory of the debt than I am about the real needs that American families have around housing around education um the investment needs that uh the country and the economy have for infrastructure for the clean energy transition and I think sometimes long-term projections about debt and deficit can really be a distraction from what the real needs of the economy are”

0.68

It is convenient to choose specific time windows; choosing to highlight income growth over 2 years after 2017 versus the previous 10 years omits that the previous 10 years were a lost decade of growth following the Great Recession that was largely attributable to too small stimulus and not enough investment.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Kitty Richard

“it's very convenient to choose your windows and say incomes grew more than they had over the previous 10 years when you're talking about a lost decade of growth following the Great Recession that was largely attributable to too small stimulus and not enough investment in the American people”

0.66

In the early 2000s, the United States had a balanced budget and people were concerned that the country was going to pay down its debt too aggressively before tax cuts benefiting the wealthy and corporations were implemented.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Kitty Richard

“if you look you know at the early 2000s we had a budget that was inbalance people were concerned in fact that the United States was going to pay down its debt too aggressively what we got was a series of tax cuts that benefited the wealthy and corporations at the expense of the American people”

0.57

According to the Congressional Budget Office, over the last 50 years revenues averaged about 17.3% of GDP with projections of 18% for the future, while spending averaged about 21% of GDP projected to be close to 25% of GDP; this clearly shows what is driving the long-term deficit and debt.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· R. Kumar

“if you just look at the data the Congressional budget office the ruthlessly nonpartisan uh Congressional budget office released new data on Tuesday and it says look over the last 50 years revenues as a percent of GDP about 17.3% projected in the future 18% revenues are doing their part spending over the last 50 years about 21% of GDP projected to be close to 25% of GDP so I mean it's clear what is driving the long-term deficit in the debt”

0.57

Revenues have been extremely low on average over the last 50 years specifically because for the last 15-20 years the country has been dealing with the Bush and Trump tax cuts.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Kitty Richard

“revenues have been extremely low on average over the last 50 years but that's because for the last 15 20 years we've been dealing with the bush and Trump tax Cuts”

0.56

In the two years after 2017, real household median income was up $6,000 more than the last 10 years combined, wages grew better than any three-year period in history, and unemployment among African-Americans, Hispanics, and those without high school diplomas all hit lowest recorded levels.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· R. Kumar

“if you just look at the data right in the two years after real household median income up $6,000 than um the last 10 years combined right wages up uh in the next in the following three years better than any threeyear period in history unemployment amongst African-Americans Hispanics those without high school diplomas all lowest in recorded history”

0.56

If Bush tax cuts had not been made and Trump tax cuts had not followed, the United States would have a permanently declining debt-to-GDP ratio even with the aging of the population and other pressures on the federal budget.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Kitty Richard

“if we had not had the Bush tax cuts and the Trump tax cuts in their wake we would have a permanently declining debt to GDP ratio even with the Aging of the population and the other things that are putting pressure on the federal budget”

0.51

Worries about government debt and deficit are designed to convince people that it is time to cut programs like Social Security and Medicare that the American people rely on.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Kitty Richard

“we've seen this movie before where we pivot from trying to recover from a huge shock very very quickly to worrying about debt and deficits and those worries are designed to convince people that it is time to cut programs like Social Security and Medicare that the American people rely on”

0.51

The growth in long-term debt projections has been almost entirely driven by the Bush tax cuts and their permanent extension, followed by Trump tax cuts piled on top, which were huge giveaways to the most profitable corporations and wealthiest individuals in the country.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Kitty Richard

“the growth in the long-term debt projections has been almost entirely driven by the first the Bush tax cuts their permanent extension and then the Trump tax cuts piled on top and those were huge giveaways to the most profitable corporations the wealthiest individuals in this country”

0.48

Every financial crisis is sparked by debt and deficits—the confidence doesn't get undermined in years or months but rather happens suddenly.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· News anchor

“while it may not be a problem today clearly and I think we've seen this in every financial crisis every financial crisis is sparked by debt and deficits that's that's what crisis is and the confidence doesn't get undermined in you know in years uh and in months it it happens like that”

0.48

There is a path for raising the social welfare of the population that is proven and it is not because we're not taxing enough; revenues are doing their part and the problem is exploding entitlement spending that must be addressed at some point.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· R. Kumar

“there is a path for raising the social welfare of the population uh it is a path that is proven and it is not because we're not taxing enough revenues are doing their part we just have you know exploding entitlement spending and at some point point we're going to have to address that”

0.47

Growing spending is like termites in the wall (a long-term structural problem) rather than wolves at the door (an immediate crisis), and this is what needs to be addressed.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· R. Kumar

“as an economist sort of famously said it's not the wolf at the door that's the problem it's the termites in the wall and this growing spending that's the termites in the wall and that's what we need to be drilling with”

0.45

The CBO is now projecting this year's federal budget deficit to jump to $1.9 trillion, up 27% from its original estimate.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 1/4· News anchor

“the CBO now projecting this year's federal budget deficit to jump to $1.9 trillion that's up 27% from its original estimate”

0.17

Kitty agrees that there is a moment where the country is spending too much, but characterizes the question as an absurd straw man.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Kitty Richard

“is there ever a moment where you'd say we're spending too much I'm sure that there is and I think that's an absurd straw man”

0.17

R. Kumar is concerned about the deficit and debt and believes they cannot just continue to be ignored, with the focus on what is driving them.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· R. Kumar

“I am concerned about the deficit the debt I I I don't think it's something that we can just continue to ignore but I'm more focused on what is driving it”