Lex Fridman Podcast #498 - Anthony Kaldellis
What this covers
Lex Fridman talks with Anthony Kaldellis, who treats East Rome as the Roman state continued rather than a separate "Byzantium." The conversation starts in the third century. It covers the Constitutio Antoniniana of 212, which extended citizenship to nearly all free inhabitants, and then Diocletian's answer to an overextended empire: the Tetrarchy, a universal census, and a unified tax system that finally taxed Italy. From there it moves to Constantinople, founded as a copy of Rome in the East with a recruited senate of roughly 2,500 to 3,000 men, and to the Latin meaning of res publica as the common affairs of a community under any regime.
The range is wide. On religion, Kaldellis argues Christianity both polarized and unified the empire, and he contends that orthodoxy was often declared retroactively, a contested point. On law, he credits Justinian's committee with the Corpus Juris Civilis and notes that Roman inheritance law gave women unusual rights, with Jewish women taking disputes to Roman courts. Military and geographic threads include the Western loss of tax-yielding provinces, the Goths' lack of a fleet, and Leo III's defense of Constantinople with walls, ships, and Greek fire. Heraclius gets extended attention: his rebellion against Phocas weakened the Persian front, and he later won the war only to lose the East to Arab armies that struck exhausted empires. Smaller turns include emperors using eunuch commanders to counterbalance aristocratic generals, and the cycle of petitioned tax exemptions that emperors periodically cancelled. Kaldellis also makes a contested claim that emperors were generally sincere in their promises.
Kaldellis argues the East Roman state lasted about 1,000 years because its rulers and subjects were bound by a consensus of taxes for protection and a credible persona of responsive rule, not because of internal decay; its collapse came from a discrete series of external shocks.
- No right to the throne forced emperors to keep subjects content, since violent overthrow was common (about 46 percent of Constantinopolitan emperors).
- Taxation was the core bargain, and provincials showed no separatist movements apart from Bulgaria.
- The fall came in the 14th century from foreign invasions, Asia Minor losses, civil wars and the Black Death, not from internal rot.
Recent centuries may be seen as human flourishing, contrary to prevailing despair.
- The late twentieth and twenty-first centuries may be seen in retrospect as a period of human flourishing, judged by most measures of human welfare, which conflicts with prevailing despair.
“this period in history, the 20th, the, the late 20th century and the 21st century will be seen as the flourishing of humans.”
Historians must weigh sources because passionate groups over-represent their concerns and bias history.
- Historians must weigh sources because intensely passionate groups, such as religious writers, have their concerns over-represented in texts, which biases reporting of history.
“So you always have to be very careful to consider the sources when you're reading about anything involving religious events.”