
What this covers
This is a roughly twenty-minute commentary from the Rebel Capitalist channel in which a host and co-Josh work through clips of Jim Chanos on CNBC. They treat the debt ceiling as a candidate Black Swan. Chanos is quoted as believing the U.S. will pay its interest when forced to choose, but he still respects the tail risk and admits he is unsure of the outcome. The host adds that Black Swans happen because people talk themselves out of considering low-probability, high-impact scenarios. The host recommends putting the debt ceiling on any list of crises being handicapped.
Much of the middle section is plumbing. The Treasury General Account (TGA)) is explained as the government's checking account, currently holding roughly $400-500 billion, which gives the Treasury some runway. The discussion covers why that balance is not freely deployable, since reallocating spending takes time and political will. It also covers how the TGA was kept near $10-12 billion before Obama and peaked around $1.4 trillion under Trump. A side thread argues that TGA balances pull dollars out of circulation and return them as delayed inflationary pressure, though the host says this is one variable among many for CPI.
The more contested claims concern the global monetary system. The host argues that the Global Financial Crisis (GFC)) was less about subprime loans than about a system dependent on mortgage-backed securities) as collateral. By that logic, T-bills now play the same role, and losing their safety would be worse than the GFC by an order of magnitude. The Fed, the host says, could not move fast enough to stop the cascade. Deficit funding is called a "sideshow" by comparison. The host also offers a binary forecast: a default with a near-empty TGA would either go as smoothly as leaving the gold standard in 1971 or be catastrophic. The closing hope is that Jerome Powell will warn politicians off brinkmanship.
A U.S. debt ceiling default, while extremely low probability, represents a potential Black Swan event whose catastrophic consequences for the global monetary system are severely underestimated by policymakers and the public.
- T-bills are the foundational collateral of the global monetary system, making their loss of safety far more systemic than the mortgage-backed securities crisis
- The Treasury General Account (TGA) provides a buffer, but if depleted, default would be binary: either handled with minimal impact or catastrophic on a scale exceeding the GFC
- Politicians lack understanding of the systemic risk they would trigger, while the Fed's balance sheet and response mechanisms would be insufficient to prevent cascading collapse
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Black Swans occur precisely when nobody thinks they're possible—people check themselves out of considering low-probability, high-impact scenarios, which is the cognitive mechanism that enables them to occur.
“that's when we're checking ourselves and our own biases that's how a Black Swan occurs like when nobody thinks that it's possible to the point where they don't even give it any thought”
The Treasury General Account (TGA) acts as a checking account for the U.S. government; the balance in it represents available liquidity before the Treasury must issue new bonds to cover obligations.
“the TGA so the treasury general account uh let's see I don't know Josh do you have that let me I know I've got it up here if you do you just have to re-share your screen oh do I well can you pull it up real quick yeah one second I think it's 300 billion but give me a number as to what's in the TGA right now because that's going to give us an idea as to how much wiggle room the treasury has right now I mean it's just like you you know he got a bunch of bills due uh you would just look in your checking account or your savings account and say okay well do I have enough to cover the bills”
U.S. Treasury bills and Treasuries are not comparable to any other country's sovereign debt or foreign government bonds—the difference in systemic importance is categorical, not merely quantitative (like comparing an apple falling from a tree to a black hole).
“you cannot compare U.S treasuries to any other asset none zero no other Sovereign bonds I don't care none it's it's you're talking about the difference between um you know an apple falling from a tree and and a black hole”
The Treasury must maintain adequate TGA balances because it cannot instantly adjust spending priorities—reallocation takes time and political will, so even if TGA funds exist they are not flexibly available for emergency debt payments without disrupting other government operations.
“they actually might have enough to to cover them it's just they're probably earmarked for other things which would require Janet Yellen to issue more bonds or treasuries at auction which is why they're in this predicament in the first place but it doesn't mean that uh whatever they have the TGA funds allocated to or earmarked for now they can't change that you know again it's just like you having a thousand bucks in your checking account and you've got a thousand dollar payment to a mob boss that you have to make even though that thousand bucks is supposed to go to pay your car payment uh at the end of the day you can say you know what I'm gonna put that car payment off a little later to pay the mob Bots”
The 1971 U.S. abandonment of the gold standard was a major institutional change that was debated and uncertain in advance, but did not lead to systemic collapse or people living in caves within 3-4 years, providing a precedent for a non-catastrophic path through a major monetary shock.
“my argument for it being nothing would be like the United States going off the gold standard like can you imagine the debate that I'm assuming they debated this but can you imagine that in like 1970 or 1971 prior to Nixon going out there and doing that I mean it's not like they could see into the future and see that okay well this isn't good I mean it's going to lead to problems right you could argue that but it's not going to implode the entire global economy to the point where in three or four years we're all living in caves uh just rummaging through the forest trying to find nutrients”
If U.S. Treasury bills lost their status as safe collateral due to default, the resulting systemic disruption would be worse than the Global Financial Crisis by an order of magnitude (GFC times 10), because T-bills are more foundationally embedded in the global monetary system than mortgage-backed securities were.
“you would have and we've got a great example of that we've got the GFC it would be the GFC times 10. that's because if you think about one of the main catalysts of the GFC obviously we had a financial system a global monetary system that was fragile to begin with and it was heavily reliant on collateral and one of the main sources of collateral were mortgage-backed securities so when those mortgage-backed Securities all of a sudden are not quote unquote safe the whole system that is built upon those mortgage-backed Securities and the system that inherently is fragile boom implodes”
TGA spending adding to inflation supply is not a sufficient condition for Consumer Price Index inflation; it is one variable among many, and only if it were the only variable would it necessarily create positive inflation.
“which in and of itself might not create a positive inflation rate Consumer Price inflation but it would definitely add a Tailwind um and then if that was the only variable then obviously it would create Consumer Price inflation”
The current global monetary system in 2023 is similar to the pre-2008 system in being heavily dependent on a single collateral type (T-bills instead of MBS), making it equally fragile and vulnerable to cascading collapse if T-bills lose their safe-haven status.
“so now you fast forward to where we are today 2023 and I would argue and I don't want to put words in Snyder's mouth but I'm almost positive he would say the same thing that if you had a similar event but this time instead of mortgage-backed Securities it was t-bills it's it's game over I it is game over”
The Global Financial Crisis was not fundamentally caused by subprime mortgages or mortgage-backed securities, but rather by the fact that a fragile global monetary system was entirely dependent on MBS as collateral, so when their safety was questioned, the system as a whole collapsed.
“this is why Snyder always says that the the GFC wasn't really about mortgage-backed Securities because if the system would have been anti-fragile let's see and this is how I'm talking about the global monetary system and you would have had the housing bust that we had it would have definitely led to a recession but it wouldn't it wouldn't have been the GFC not not even close not even close so it to say that the GFC was a result of you know subprime mortgages it's not really accurate and you could say oh George well you're splitting hairs but I think in this case you need to have Nuance in order not to lose very important accuracy”
Even if the Federal Reserve intervened with emergency backstop programs and unlimited balance sheet expansion, they would not be able to respond fast enough to prevent cascading collapse if T-bills lost safety, because the systemic domino effect would unfold too rapidly.
“you say oh well George though the FED would come in and backstop it nah no no no no no no no this is Way Beyond the fed's balance sheet and although they have an infinite balance sheet they wouldn't be able to respond fast enough they could come out with Mill for you know whatever those four or five letter programs were that I was making fun of uh they can do all that nonsense they want but that would create such a massive domino effect that the whole thing would implode before the FED knew what hit it I mean talk about just a boom a quick left hook from Tyson I mean you're out before you even know he threw the punch”
The Trump administration allowed the TGA to run up significantly, and during 2020-2021 it peaked at approximately 1.4 trillion dollars, representing an extraordinary accumulation of liquidity.
“and more recently when Trump came on he allowed it to go up and then I'm assuming that was him doing that or whomever was the the treasury secretary at the time and then of right I think in 2020 2021 something like that if my memory serves me right it went up over a trillion like it was at like a 1.4 trillion at uh I think in 20 . but it got extremely high”
Political factions are currently willing to use the debt ceiling as a negotiating tactic, even if they expect resolution, which demonstrates that political risk to Treasury safety is higher than the complacency in markets suggests.
“it's clear that there's a faction of people that want to push the envelope on this”
The TGA balance has risen to 400-500 billion because the Treasury is collecting tax revenue but not spending it due to debt ceiling constraints, creating a misleading impression that the government is insolvent when the problem is actually about earmarked funds and the need for new bond issuance.
“how does that happen guys that would mean that the uh TGA isn't spending any uh they're probably not due to this debt ceiling thing oh it makes sense and because they're not spending anything they're still collecting tax revenue so when you pay your taxes that goes into the TGA so they're they're collecting taxes taxes they're not spending anything because they're worried about the debt ceiling and that's why you're seeing an uptick”
When the Treasury accumulates large balances in the TGA (like the 1.4 trillion peak), those dollars are temporarily removed from economic circulation, functioning like currency being dug into a hole and covered up—they represent delayed inflationary pressure that will return to the system when the Treasury spends them.
“so this was a lot of quote-unquote liquidity a lot of dollars that were kind of sitting on the sidelines that were waiting to come back into the economy which most likely would have added a Tailwind to inflation right because those are currency units that they're taking out of the economy through taxation and they're kind of parking them in the checking account of the treasury which is a liability of the Fed so those dollars are out of circulation you you've pretty much uh just dug a hole in your backyard and thrown those dollars in there and then covered it up and then what happens but you know that at some point in time the treasure is going to spend that money so that's going to be those dollars are going to be injected back into the system chasing goods and services”
If a U.S. debt ceiling default occurred and the TGA balance was at or near zero, the outcome would be binary: either it would be handled as smoothly as the U.S. going off the gold standard (causing significant disruption but not total system collapse), or it would be catastrophic beyond comprehension.
“let's assume for a moment that that checking account balance of the treasury was literally zero like it was or close to you know prior to Obama and then they had this issue with a debt scene where they just refused to to do anything and you had a couple payments go by or maybe that they had to quite literally default you know what would happen I think it's a binary outcome it would either be and this is just my opinion here it would either be nothing or it would be catastrophic on a level that is hard to comprehend”
If T-bills lost safe-haven status, the collapse would extend far beyond banks and the financial system to encompass the entire monetary system and everything dependent on it.
“I mean it is it is forget the banks they're done I mean I mean not not just Banks the entire the entire monetary system would implode I mean everything”
Jim Chanos considers the debt ceiling a potential Black Swan event that could occur if political factions push the envelope, though he and most observers believe the U.S. will pay the interest on its debt when forced to choose.
“it's another black swan that would be a kind of another Black Swan that no one thinks will happen including me um I I mean just one push comes to shove I think we're going to pay the interest on our debt um but who knows it could be wrong”
U.S. government funding and deficit spending are not the most important consequence of a debt ceiling default—they are the 'sideshow' compared to the loss of T-bill safety in the global monetary system.
“we're not just listen this is not just about the United in fact the United States government and funding the government and whatnot that's that's Child's Play that that's not even a a that that's not even uh you know 10 of the story that that's uh that's a sideshow I think is the best way to say it that that would be irrelevant compared to it would be it's basically like uh you know going back to the GFC and trying to worry about you know what happens to the the car business or something well okay yeah that that would be a problem but listen we got way bigger fish to fry”
The speaker recommends adding the debt ceiling scenario to any list of potential Black Swan events when assessing odds and handicapping future crises.
“so the main point that I wanted to communicate by showing this clip from Jim chanos is if you've got a list of potential black swans that you're trying to assess the chances or the odds or you're trying to handicap I would definitely add this to the list for sure”
The current TGA balance is approximately 400-500 billion dollars, which provides the Treasury with some runway before they would be forced to default on obligations.
“while Josh is doing that it's around like 490 uh million no no it's a billion billion yeah you sure 409 that seems a little high Maybe they've ran it up the past few days or the last week or two”
Prior to the Obama administration, the Treasury General Account was kept deliberately low, around 10-12 billion, with revenues flowing in and being spent immediately rather than accumulated.
“if you look at the TGA and go back prior to like Trump Obama was the first person that really started to run up the TGA and allow it to get above like like 10 billion before Obama the TJ was was very very low it's it's basically they they come like Revenue would come in and they'd like immediately spend it they never let it really get above I forgot what the number was because call it 10 12 billion something like that but but it was low relatively speaking right”
Jim Chanos respects the potential severity of a debt ceiling default as a Black Swan event and acknowledges uncertainty about the outcome, despite believing the most likely scenario is resolution.
“but it's clear that there's a faction of people that want to push the envelope on this is that something that concerns you we just sort of slide through this like we typically do no I mean again it's another black that would be a kind of another Black Swan that no one thinks will happen including me”
The speaker hopes that Federal Reserve leadership like Jerome Powell would communicate to political leaders the catastrophic systemic consequences of a debt ceiling default, to prevent them from pushing the envelope as a negotiating tactic.
“I mean I I literally can't articulate how catastrophic that would be and again I I have to believe I I hope that the the I know the politicians don't understand that there's no way they do but I would hope that someone at the FED like you know like Jerome Powell or something who has their ear has the ability to call them up and say Hey you you can't you don't understand what you're doing here you know you want to default on that this this isn't about just getting back at the Democrats or the Democrats trying to get back to the Republicans you have no idea what you are doing”
Federal Reserve researchers and policymakers actively study and monitor Treasury market dynamics, repo markets, and collateral dynamics because they understand T-bills' systemic importance, even if this is not commonly discussed in mainstream financial discourse.
“the people the FED they have to know that I know that they try to pretend that they're the center of the monetary solar system and whatnot but they have to understand the significance of treasuries and t-bills in the global monetary system”
The Federal Reserve and U.S. political leaders understand the significance of Treasury bills and T-bills in the global monetary system, even if they may not fully grasp the catastrophic consequences of losing that safety status.
“one of the reasons I think that such a low probability although I I definitely think it's something that deserves our mental bandwidth is because the the people the FED they have to know that I know that they try to pretend that they're the center of the monetary solar system and whatnot but they have to understand the significance of treasuries and t-bills in the global monetary system”
The speaker would assign the debt ceiling default scenario a probability roughly equivalent to the probability they assigned to a global pandemic in 2019—extremely low, but non-zero.
“I would even put myself in that camp I don't think it's I I you know it's probably on par with the cervasive sickness like if you would have asked me in 2019 what is the probability of a global pandemic and you know I wouldn't have said it was Zero but I would have said it's just incredibly low and I probably would give the the debt ceiling issue the same probability”