
Further Exploring Bitcoin as a Storehold of Wealth
What this covers
This is a conversation between Bridgewater's Rebecca Patterson, Director of Investment Research, and Jim Haskel, a Senior Portfolio Strategist. It works through the firm's research on Bitcoin as a storehold of wealth for institutions. It opens with the macro backdrop: developed-market central banks are running expansionary policy, nearly 30 percent of investment-grade debt carries negative yields, and negative real yields are pushing investors to look past cash. Patterson argues that Bitcoin drew institutional attention because of this environment, not because Bitcoin itself changed. She then measures it against gold's supply limits, long history, and ease of transport.
The middle of the discussion covers the practical weaknesses. Patterson cites Bitcoin's volatility, more than ten times that of major developed currencies, and its thin liquidity. Its market is about a tenth the size of tradable gold and roughly twice the size of iron ore. She also says a decade of history is too short to judge it as a diversifier. On cyber risk, she separates the protocol, which she calls relatively safe, from exchanges, where Mt. Gox is the largest hack. She also notes that lost wallet passwords destroy coins, and that the same slow, robust design that resists hacking makes Bitcoin a poor payment system. She also argues that thousands of rival coins don't erode Bitcoin's scarcity, since Ethereum and others serve different functions.
The last stretch looks forward. Patterson treats central bank digital currency (CBDC)) work as a different thing from Bitcoin, since it only digitizes existing fiat. She says over 80 percent of central banks are now engaged in it. On regulation she sketches two paths: a crackdown on the model of China's, or the slower tightening she thinks more likely in the US, which could prompt early anonymity-seeking holders to sell. Her model of a shift from gold into Bitcoin implies roughly 160 percent appreciation, which she calls conservative because it leaves out supply squeezes, reflexivity, and possible central bank buying.
Bitcoin has characteristics of a potential store of wealth (limited supply, portability, accessibility) but currently lacks the stability, diversification track record, and mature infrastructure needed for institutional adoption, making it more like an option on a future digital gold than a viable institutional asset today.
- Bitcoin shares gold-like supply constraints but lacks decade-long diversification history and has 10x higher volatility than major currencies
- Institutional liquidity is severely limited—bitcoin market capacity is only ~10% of gold and ~2x smaller than iron ore
- Regulatory uncertainty, immature infrastructure, and cyber risks at exchange level remain significant barriers to institutional adoption
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) are not innovations like Bitcoin but rather digital manifestations of existing fiat currencies—they provide the same attributes as traditional currencies (same inflation and devaluation risks) and therefore do not solve the storehold-of-wealth problem that motivates Bitcoin interest.
“central bank digital currencies uh they're often called cbdc's um they're not a new innovation like bitcoin instead they're really just a digital manifestation of existing currencies right call it cash for a modern age you could have a digital dollar a digital japanese yen a digital euro those digital currencies aside from being electronic instead of something you touch are going to have all the same attributes as the underlying currency and and that means when we're thinking about storeholds of wealth if you think the central bank is going to keep printing money if you think you're going to have negative real yields the risk to that storehold of wealth is the same whether it's a traditional piece of paper that you hold in your hand or if it's digital”
Bitcoin's digital nature creates potential cyber risks that gold does not have, and while the risk of Bitcoin protocol itself being hacked is relatively small because the community is incentivized to maintain code resilience, the risk of hacking at the exchange level has been significant.
“bitcoin has been around for just over a decade we have seen a lot of hacking attempts we have seen denial of service hacks some of them have been successful not on bitcoin this is a really important distinction but on exchanges so bitcoin itself we think the risk that it gets hacked is actually pretty small the community of investors in bitcoin are incentivized to make sure the code is resilient and is fixed if anything comes up and so it that makes it safe its strength because of its resilient actually is one of its problems to be used in other ways right it's one of the slower blockchains and it doesn't work terribly well so far as a payment system the flip side of that of course is that it seems pretty safe from hacking but again that's bitcoin itself but you still have to have a means to get in and out of bitcoin and that's usually the exchanges that's where we see the hacks”
Bitcoin has been around for approximately 10+ years and only emerged as a focus of serious institutional attention recently, not because bitcoin itself changed but because of the macroeconomic environment of negative real yields forcing investor search for alternatives.
“you know this is an asset that's been around now for about a decade so why the sort of increased level of attention now jim i think the big reason we're talking about bitcoin now has nothing to do with bitcoin itself it has a lot to do with the environment we're in”
Gold has three distinguishing characteristics that make it an exceptional store of wealth: very limited supply that cannot be devalued by central banks, a deep recorded history as something of value dating back before the second millennium BC, and ease of transport and exchange especially through gold-backed ETFs.
“i think third but also importantly gold has such a deep history as something of value you know i was looking into this before our podcast just to make sure i had it right the recorded use of gold coins dates back to before the second millennium bc and it's like you have to just take a second to wrap your head around that i think we can agree it's a very unique track record and that also makes it um attractive to a lot of investors”
Bitcoin's strength in resisting hacking—resulting from slow block processing and cryptographic robustness—is one of its fundamental problems for functioning as a payment system, creating a trade-off between security and transaction speed.
“its strength because of its resilient actually is one of its problems to be used in other ways right it's one of the slower blockchains and it doesn't work terribly well so far as a payment system”
Bitcoin's risk of being hacked is actually quite small because the Bitcoin community is incentivized to ensure the code is resilient and vulnerabilities are fixed, making Bitcoin itself safe from hacking.
“bitcoin has been around for just over a decade we have seen a lot of hacking attempts we have seen denial of service hacks some of them have been successful not on bitcoin this is a really important distinction but on exchanges so bitcoin itself we think the risk that it gets hacked is actually pretty small the community of investors in bitcoin are incentivized to make sure the code is resilient and is fixed if anything comes up and so it that makes it safe”
Central banks and policymakers in developed markets are implementing expansionary monetary and fiscal policy to generate growth and inflation, making cash and cash-like assets increasingly unattractive to investors seeking stable storeholds of wealth.
“in developed markets policymakers are doing everything they can to generate growth and inflation and as part of that they're making cash and cash like assets increasingly unattractive”
Current regulatory focus on Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies centers primarily on preventing illicit use including money laundering and terrorist financing, as evidenced by recent comments from Treasury Secretary Yellen and ECB President Lagarde.
“the regulatory backdrop as it stands right now the main concerns policies are trying to address with regulation is the tie from bitcoin to potential use for illicit activities things like money laundering um or terrorist finance and we got comments just in the last few weeks from both treasury secretary yellen and ecb president lagarde mentioning these specific worries and the need for regulation”
Bitcoin's volatility against the US dollar has been more than 10 times that of major developed currencies since inception, making it unsuitable as a storehold of wealth for institutional investors who require stability.
“anyone who watches bitcoin knows how volatile it is since inception its volatility against the dollar has been more than 10 times that of major developed currencies”
One possible regulatory path is draconian regulation that clamps down on private digital currencies because policymakers fear these could undermine traditional fiat currencies and monetary policy effectiveness, as exemplified by China's 2017 ban on initial coin offerings and current push for sovereign digital currency adoption.
“the first path is more draconian it it would suggest a clamping down on bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies and i think that could stem from a fear among policy makers that these private digital currencies could undermine traditional fiat currencies and maybe also undermine monetary policy itself and i think china is a great example of this so back in 2017 china banned initial coin offerings”
A secondary Bitcoin hacking risk is coin loss—users literally forgetting their wallet passwords—which while smaller in individual cases can accumulate across the user base.
“the other risk which i think is smaller although it can add up is just coin loss and that's literally people forgetting their passwords to their wallets um but those would be the two risks i would be focused on”
The largest cryptocurrency exchange hack to date was Mt. Gox, where 450 million dollars of bitcoin was stolen, representing a significant problem for Bitcoin investors.
“i think the biggest one to date has been called mount gox 450 million dollars of bitcoin was stolen i think that's going to be a big problem for a lot of investors”
A more significant risk to Bitcoin's long-term value is that a new cryptocurrency could emerge that displaces Bitcoin, similar to how the US dollar displaced sterling as a reserve currency, suggesting that historical precedent shows reserve currencies can rise and fall.
“the bigger question i'd ask on this front though is whether we could see a new cryptocurrency coming online that displaces bitcoin now if we think back over history of fiat currencies you have seen reserve currencies rise and fall we've written about that a lot so just thinking about how the dollar displaced sterling could we see something even better displacing bitcoin and so that's another kind of supply angle and evolutionary angle about this innovative space that i think one would have to consider if they were going to make an investment there”
Bitcoin's liquidity compared to other major markets is extremely limited: bitcoin's market capacity is approximately 10 percent of the tradable gold market and approximately 2x the size of the iron ore market, which itself is a relatively small market.
“the capacity today is close to about 10 of the size of the tradable gold market it's even bitcoin is even smaller in terms of just real market capacity what kind of trade you could do it's about half the size of the iron ore market and we know that's a pretty small market”
Over 80 percent of central banks today are engaged in some form of central bank digital currency work, up from approximately 65 percent two years ago, indicating rapid acceleration of CBDC development globally.
“there was a report jim last year by the bank for international settlements that showed more than 80 percent of central banks today are engaged in some sort of cbdc work and that's up from about 65 percent two years ago so this is this is moving quickly”
Bitcoin is currently used primarily for retail speculation rather than as a true storehold of wealth, though this could change if institutional adoption increases, which would improve liquidity and potentially reduce volatility.
“for now anyway bitcoin is largely used in a retail capacity and for speculation now this can absolutely change over time if it gets greater acceptance liquidity will increase and will likely help pull down volatility”
Although thousands of cryptocurrencies exist today and can compete for investor capital, Bitcoin's supply is still effectively limited because different cryptocurrencies serve different functions—Bitcoin is primarily used for transactions while Ethereum is used as a platform for smart contracts and applications—making them non-fungible and not in direct competition for the same capital pool.
“there's thousands of cryptocurrencies today and they can be very different as we said before that's part of the challenge for regulators you know bitcoin is mainly used for transactions for instance ether is used for a platform ethereum that facilitates smart contracts and and helps people launch apps uh smart applications so to the degree these currencies are not fungible i would say bitcoin supply is limited”
The risk in the gradual regulatory tightening path is that original Bitcoin holders motivated by anonymity and lack of regulation might exit positions when regulation increases, triggering selling pressure and volatility.
“the risk i see with this path is more in the process of going from today to the future state the tighter regulation in my view would probably make original holders of bitcoin who are there for the anonymity and the lack of regulation they might look for new pastures and that could trigger some selling and some volatility for some period of time”
Nearly 30 percent of the world's investment grade debt currently has negative yields, with many central banks continuing to print money and depreciate their currencies to fund fiscal packages, creating risk of further currency depreciation and negative real returns for cash holders.
“we're now looking at nearly 30 percent of the world's investment grade debt with negative yields but even there we're not done many central banks are continuing to print money and depreciate their currencies”
Bitcoin's short existence (only just over a decade old) means there is insufficient historical data to confidently determine whether it will function as a consistent diversifier or inflation hedge in the future, unlike gold's 4000+ year track record.
“we can't be sure going forward if it's going to be a good diversifier and or an inflation hedge we just don't know enough history about it to be confident and predict that that those patterns will continue going forward”
Rebecca's modeling likely represents a conservative estimate; actual Bitcoin price appreciation could be substantially higher than the 160% forecast because the real world would involve supply squeeze and reflexivity effects not captured in the simple reallocation model, and because the model excludes potential central bank Bitcoin adoption.
“the reality would be a lot more complicated than this exercise and probably suggests our number is conservative that the bitcoin price could go higher for example there would probably in this case be some sort of supply squeeze and reflexivity that could push bitcoin prices much higher and again we didn't include central banks here if we thought that there could be a movement from central banks to diversify from just gold to gold and bitcoin obviously that could move the price quite a lot more”
A more likely regulatory path especially in the US is slowly evolving regulation that will ultimately engender more trust in Bitcoin as an asset, which would be positive for Bitcoin's long-term prospects.
“the path instead that we think is more likely to evolve especially in the us is a slowly evolving regulatory environment that i think at the end of the day ultimately is going to engender more trust in the asset and this would be great news for bitcoin long term”
Bitcoin is highly accessible and portable, with more than 80 countries currently having at least one Bitcoin ATM, allowing investors to physically get in and out of Bitcoin globally through digital networks.
“you can buy bitcoin and cash out of bitcoin nearly anywhere in the world today you have more than 80 countries that have at least one bitcoin atm and many have decent sized atm network so you physically can get in and out of it pretty easily and pretty globally”
Regulatory uncertainty remains a significant barrier to institutional Bitcoin adoption because cryptocurrency regulations are still evolving rapidly and vary significantly country by country, and no unified regulatory framework exists.
“regulation which is still evolving very very quickly and is very different country by country”
Bitcoin has not reliably served as a portfolio diversifier during equity market drawdowns; while gold has successfully provided diversification benefits in most instances, Bitcoin has fallen alongside equities and bonds in at least two or three documented instances.
“if my 60 40 portfolio has a drawdown is bitcoin going to be the thing that helps offset those losses when we think about drawdowns obviously it's going to depend to a degree on what's causing the drawdown but more often than not gold has successfully worked to provide that diversification and help your portfolio through those periods bitcoin again shorter history it's worked some of the time but there have been at least two or three instances where bitcoin prices fell along with your stock bond portfolio”
A storehold of wealth should maintain purchasing power over time while providing stability (relatively low volatility) and serving as a good portfolio diversifier.
“a storehold of wealth is something that's going to maintain its purchasing power over time and and just to make that more plain english i think most of us associate storeholds of wealth with stability so relatively low volatility and a good diversifier”
Bitcoin has a hard-coded maximum supply of 21 million coins with issuance rates that halve every few years, ensuring supply growth becomes progressively smaller over time.
“bitcoin has hard-coded 21 million coins that's all they can ever make and the issuance rate so the supply growth if you will halves every few years so supply growth is going to get smaller and smaller over time”
The Bahamas has already rolled out a central bank digital currency called the 'Sand Dollar', providing an example of operational CBDC implementation.
“i mentioned earlier some countries already have digital sovereign currencies my favorite by the way is in the bahamas it's their cbdc is called the sand dollar i think that's awesome”
The draconian regulatory path represented by China's approach is highly unlikely in the United States, though Rebecca expresses uncertainty by saying she would never say 'never'.
“that's one path and it's happening in china i think it's highly unlikely in the united states although i would never say never”
The 160% potential price increase for Bitcoin is notable but not extraordinary when compared to last year's market movements.
“which sounds like a lot except we know last year that's what happened”
Ray Dalio and Rebecca Patterson published research observations on Bitcoin two weeks before this conversation, authored by Dalio (as co-CIO) and Patterson (as director of investment research), recognizing Bitcoin as a deserving asset for institutional commentary due to its increased marketplace attention.
“two weeks ago we published two observations on bitcoin authored by co-cio ray dalio and director of investment research rebecca patterson we did so with the recognition that bitcoin was an asset that deserved commentary and of course was getting a lot of attention in the marketplace”
Ray Dalio characterized Bitcoin as 'one hell of an invention', suggesting recognition of its technical achievement despite reservations about its current institutional suitability.
“indeed ray called it quote one hell of an invention given the attention our research received”