YouTube1h 6m· Sep 2024· cataloged

MAGA Is Not as United as You Think


What this covers

This is a conversation between Ezra Klein and Emily Jashinsky, a D.C. correspondent for UnHerd who describes herself as having a foot in both the old and new right. It starts from the awkward position Donald Trump holds on Project 2025. He disavows the document but cannot disavow the people behind it. Jashinsky says the document exists because Trump has no policy infrastructure of his own, and that much of it records unresolved internal debates, such as competing child tax credit proposals, rather than consensus. It was organized under the Heritage Foundation with nearly every old conservative group behind it.

The middle of the conversation maps how the right has changed. Jashinsky traces the break from fusionism, the Reagan-era alliance of social conservatives, libertarians and neoconservatives, to an "America First" approach. As evidence she cites the closure of the Koch-backed FreedomWorks. They discuss national conservatism and Yoram Hazony's claim that America "privatized virtue." She explains the new right's idea of virtue through lowercase-r republicanism and the John Adams line about a constitution fit only for a moral and religious people. They also cover its new openness to regulation, including praise from JD Vance and American Compass for Lena Khan's antitrust work, against resistance from business-aligned figures like Ted Cruz.

The contentious stretch concerns how far government should go in enforcing virtue. Klein cites Kevin Roberts's call to imprison pornography producers. Jashinsky calls pornography a cultural emergency but says that going that far would be a moral and political mistake. Against that approach Klein sets the barstool, Joe Rogan-style conservatism that mainly wants to be left alone. The pair also look at why young people become receptive to critiques of modernity, and at the pandemic-era realignment around schools and women's sports. They also take up Trump's shifting immigration stance and the gaps between Trump and Vance on healthcare and abortion. They close with book recommendations.

Sharpest takeaway

The MAGA coalition has become ideologically diverse and increasingly post-liberal, creating tensions with Trump who lacks coherent conservative ideology, making governance difficult because Trump cannot easily disavow the movement he now owns without alienating the groups that sustain him.

  • The new right has developed post-liberal and classicist intellectual frameworks (virtue, national conservatism) that go far beyond Trump's intuitions
  • Trump faces an intra-movement conflict between those who want government to reshape virtue (JD Vance, Kevin Roberts) and those who want it to leave people alone (barstool conservatives)
  • Project 2025 exists because Trump lacks his own policy infrastructure, but he cannot disown it without losing the movement, creating a governance bind

The claims · ranked0 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

No claims extracted from this asset yet.