
The Sovereign Debt Bubble with Luke Gromen
What this covers
Peter McCormack interviews Luke Gromen, founder of Forest for the Trees, about what governments can do as what Gromen calls the first bursting global sovereign debt bubble in a century unwinds. The conversation starts with Gromen's own Bitcoin allocation and moves through the mechanics of the debt problem: entitlements of roughly $3 trillion a year, about 65% of tax receipts, with the healthcare share owed in goods and services rather than dollars. From there it turns to Peak Cheap Energy, the argument that rising extraction costs give energy a built-in inflationary bias. Historical precedents are Weimar Germany and 1980s Israel, with Israel's social cohesion offered as a reason its inflation was milder than Argentina's or Venezuela's, and the US likely to fare worse politically.
The middle of the episode is about current policy. Gromen reads the March 2023 bank failures, the Bank Term Funding Program (BTFP)) and Treasury buybacks as soft yield curve control and quantitative easing (QE)) in disguise. He argues the Fed will stop hiking and resume liquidity injections because the fiscal position leaves no alternative. He also claims that rate hikes and fiscal stimulus are functionally similar, differing mainly in who receives the money. A more contested thread treats "Operation Chokepoint 2.0" as preparation for a high-inflation regime, meant to keep capital from fleeing into assets that would visibly signal policy failure.
The later sections are practical and geopolitical. Gromen covers who is protected by inflation: 30-year fixed-rate mortgage holders, and doctors, whose work is a real good rather than a dollar-denominated one. He explains why the UK is more exposed than the US. For investors, he recommends an unleveraged, diversified portfolio and warns that leverage gets margin-called in the violent month-to-month swings of hyperinflationary periods. The closing stretch covers de-dollarisation, with Russia and China's gold buying treated as rational defence, and his forecast that a gold-based reserve system would hit the dollar and sterling hardest.
Luke Gromen argues that the combination of a bursting global sovereign debt bubble and peak cheap energy creates an inevitable inflationary scenario where central banks must either default on debt or print aggressively; the US is increasingly likely to experience 100-300% compressed inflation within 2-3 years rather than sustained moderate inflation, requiring defensive positioning in non-correlated assets like Bitcoin, gold, and energy-tied holdings.
- Debt levels are structurally incompatible with deflation; any attempt to fight inflation reduces tax receipts and forces greater money printing
- Energy costs are secularly inflationary in high-debt economies; historical productivity miracles (like fossil fuel commercialization) are unlikely to repeat at scale needed
- Israel successfully compressed its debt burden via 2-3 years of 100-300% inflation; the US faces similar pressures and is already laying groundwork with BTFP and Treasury buyback programs
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Fixed-rate mortgages in the US (typically 30-year at 2-3%) act as an inflation hedge because wage earners can obtain 15% raises without their mortgage payment increasing, creating a de facto debt jubilee for home owners while savers holding cash are harmed.
“So, here most of our mortgages are fixed rate, right? So, it's an interesting dynamic of a debt jubilee, right? So, if we see if doctors go go up 15% here, uh cost, you know, get a 15% wage hike, their mortgage doesn't move, right? So, they're still paying 3% mortgages.”
Extreme volatility is expected across FX markets, interest rates, and commodity prices in coming years, and attempting to trade through this volatility is dangerous; the better strategy is to maintain a diversified, unleveraged portfolio and rebalance periodically rather than trying to optimize timing.
“there is a path and the path doesn't look like this. The path looks like this to this high rates of inflation. And number two, you want to be under levered because you don't want to be wrong for the right reason, right? You do you don't want to get carried out on your shield because you borrowed too much money. Well, we'll look into, you know, you know, pigs get fat, hogs get slaughtered or something my dad always tells me.”
Doctors have significant wage leverage in an inflationary environment because healthcare is a real good (not dollar-denominated), and if government and employers cannot keep up with inflation, doctors can simply exit the profession or demand higher compensation, creating a tightening spiral in healthcare costs.
“In this case the doctors have a lot of leverage. Doctors say, "Fine, you know screw it. I'll go work at Peter's bar." You know, I'll make You hear in the US after the last 30 years what's happened to health care. You know, we've got, you know, plumbers making $350,000 and I have a friend of mine who's, you know, oncologist and hematologist with 25 years of experience and he's probably not making that much money.”
The US experienced the dollar collapsing 10x against oil from 2000 to 2008, after which the US became the world's largest oil producer by 2015, demonstrating that currency depreciation against essential commodities can spur increased domestic production.
“oil prices in America went up 10x from 9 2000 to 2008 and voila, we're the biggest oil producer in the world a few years later. Like that, you know, that's the dollar collapsed against oil and then we produced a lot more oil.”
Two of the seven wealthiest counties in America are located around Washington DC, and they primarily export Treasuries (dollars) rather than physical goods, making them direct beneficiaries of the dollar's reserve currency status.
“two of the seven of the 10 wealthiest counties in America are around Washington, D.C. What does Washington, D.C. export to make all that money? Simple, treasuries. They export dollars. They don't make anything.”
The higher energy prices go and the more inflation erodes real wages, the greater the pressure on governments to support lower-income citizens through more spending or transfers, which requires more printing and higher inflation.
“I wonder how it nets out. My my suspicion is is that it will all eventually net out, but those who hold assets will benefit more and we will see an increase in the wealth divide and that will put a lot of pressure on families, but that will also put a lot of pressure on the government to support those at the lower end, which probably means more printing.”
US government entitlements (Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid) total approximately $3 trillion annually, representing about 65% of tax receipts; critically, the healthcare portion is not owed in dollars but in health care goods and services, creating a mechanism similar to foreign currency debt.
“Between social security, Medicare and medic all entitlements, social security, Medicare, Medicaid, some of the other stuff. This year will be $3 trillion or about 65% of tax receipts.”
The US military, when discussing sustainability internally for 10+ years, has concluded that current defense spending levels are unsustainable and the resources should be redirected toward infrastructure and education.
“most US military officers on down, they for 10 years they've been telling you this is unsustainable. We need to get out of this, you know, what we need to we need to reinvest into more productive enterprises such as infrastructure, education”
The UK is more vulnerable to high inflation and wage-price spirals than the US because of structural differences: (1) shorter mortgage terms (2-5 year fixed vs 30-year US fixed), meaning debt doesn't provide inflation protection, (2) smaller economic base with fewer natural resources, (3) less diversified economy, making inflation-driven production increases unlikely.
“I think there's a number of re you know, Israel's a a smaller economy. Uh it is it is uh it is more um uh what's the word I'm looking for? You know, it's it's more monocultural than the United States or than the UK or than Western Europe.”
A weaker dollar is economically good for the US and the world because it reduces global dollar debt burden, rebalances the economy away from Washington and Wall Street toward productive enterprise, and encourages US production at the expense of consumption.
“It's good for the world, right? When we talk about all the debt is owed in dollars, if you want to stimulate growth, the easiest way to do it is reduce the debt burden, right? Give the world a debt break. How do you give the world a debt break? You reduce the value of the dollar, right? So, the dollar falls, the debt burden of the world falls.”
The social impacts of high inflation in Israel were milder than in Argentina or Venezuela because Israel is smaller, more monocultural, and has stronger social cohesion (universal military service), whereas the US would likely experience more severe political fallout from sustained inflation.
“Israel's a a smaller economy. Uh it is it is uh what's the word I'm looking for? You know, it's more monocultural than the United States or than the UK or than Western Europe. Uh I think there is a greater sense of togetherness in in you know, everyone has to serve in the military in in Israel, right?...I'm not sure we could do it without some fallout politically. Uh uh Yep. Do uh from a domestic standpoint.”
Banking system de-risking from Treasuries is already underway (evidenced by the March 2023 SVB and Signature Bank failures), making it impossible for the US Treasury to rely on domestic banking system financing going forward, accelerating the timeline to explicit Fed support.
“We've now seen that, right? Like SVB and Signature Bank, they got carried out and like sorry, you got zeroed out...American banks aren't going to finance the government anymore. That was sort of 2013 to to about 2 months ago. Uh that suddenly they the the folly of that is suddenly um beginning to be realized that that was not a permanent solution.”
There is functionally no difference between the Fed raising rates (increasing government interest expenses by $500B, paid to wealthy bondholders) and fiscal stimulus ($500B paid to general population), except for distributional effects and wealth inequality.
“there's no functional difference between the US government printing a 500 billion in stimulus and handing it out to the people and the Fed raising the US government's interest expense by 500 billion and paying that out. The only difference is who it goes to. The 500 billion goes to everybody and the 500 billion...The 500 billion interest goes to the wealthy.”
During hyperinflationary periods (like Weimar Germany 1918-1923), the path of asset prices is not a smooth hyperbolic curve but rather violent month-to-month volatility where borrowed money positions get repeatedly margin-called despite the eventual long-term payoff.
“What really happens is face peeling volatility... It's by Dan Oliver at Meridian Capital... And that is an absolute bloodbath where literally it's like up 50, down 50, up 50 and you if you borrowed a bunch of money and bought gold and hoping the gold was getting rid of your debt, the reality was you lost all of your money probably four or five times. You got margin called out, gone.”
Vladimir Putin has stated that the US Treasury real rate is negative 8%, calculated from the fact that Treasury issuance has risen 8% CAGR since 2008 while yields stayed below 3%, making it a Ponzi scheme where the US borrows more each year than it pays in coupon.
“Putin said this in in June of last year in a speech... He highlighted that the US has the real rate on on on treasury debt -8%. And where do you get that number? If you look back from 2008 to present, US treasury issuance has rose by 8% per year. It's risen 8% CAGR. The yield on the 10-year treasury has barely ever been above three.”
The US and other developed nations face a bursting global sovereign debt bubble (the first in 100 years) that can only be resolved through two mechanisms: defaulting/restructuring on debt or inflating it away by capping yields and letting real rates go deeply negative.
“we are in this unique period of time where we have our first bursting global sovereign debt bubble in 100 years. Um and at the same time we've got a peak cheap energy... it's that the stuff we use most of is getting more and more expensive to replace.”
Deflation and sovereign insolvency are fundamentally incompatible; if inflation falls too far, the government cannot pay interest, entitlements, and defense spending from tax receipts, forcing them to print regardless of inflation targets.
“deflation is the midwife of hyperinflation... deflation and sovereign insolvency are fundamentally incompatible. And so, they're wanting to get inflation down, but they're not going to be able to get it down enough um if they get it down too far, then they can't pay their interest, their entitlements, and their defense bill out of tax receipts. And then, given the choice between defaulting on Treasuries... or slashing defense spending... or slashing entitlements... then they have to print the difference.”
Peak cheap energy is a dynamic where the energy resources that make up the largest proportion of energy supply are becoming more expensive to extract and replace, creating a secular inflationary bias that is incompatible with high debt levels.
“it's basically it's not that we're running out of oil and gas and energy, it's that the stuff we use most of is getting more and more expensive to replace. And so there is sort of this secularly inflationary dynamic to just replace and keep our energy production flat of fossil fuels, broadly speaking, which is fine when you have a low debt debt-backed economy, but it's not fine when you have a high debt debt-backed economy debt-backed currency.”
The Federal Reserve's BTFP (Bank Term Funding Program) and Treasury buyback programs are soft forms of yield curve control and QE designed to maintain Treasury market functioning while avoiding explicit QE language; they inject liquidity regardless of whether economists call them QE.
“That is essentially, you know, bringing down, you know, bringing down the effective yield on those bonds. That's a yield curve control soft for the banks. Uh Treasury has quietly US Treasury has quietly been spending a lot of time looking at a Treasury buyback program.”
Operation Chokepoint 2.0 (regulatory targeting of cryptocurrency and alternative asset channels) should be understood as defensive preparation for a coming high-inflation regime, designed to prevent capital flight into assets that would visibly signal policy failure rather than into the stock market, which will appear to confirm economic success.
“if I was in charge of the US economic policy and they came and they said, "Look, we're going to have to inflate 100% a year for 2 years. We try, you know, we tried to inflate a little, inflation got be a political problem, then we went the other way, now we're having these Treasury market problems. We're going to have to inflate it. But, what what, you know, we can't allow We We can't put in capital controls, but we also want to control things in a way so that we don't look too bad, right? We We want We don't want things going up that make us look bad. You know, so if the stock market goes up a ton, there's not going to be any Americans going, "Ugh, you guys are terrible. The stock market's up 100% a year for 3 years."”
Russia has been buying gold as its primary reserve asset for 10-15 years, partly in response to 2013 sanctions and structural dynamics, because finite oil reserves cannot be stockpiled in depreciating Treasury assets where supply rises 8% and coupon is 3%.
“He has finite oil Like he has finite oil production... He would have to be an idiot and he's a lot of things, but an idiot isn't one of them. So, he he started buying gold as his primary reserve asset 10 years ago, 15 years ago. Uh some of that was in response post 13 in response to the original sanctions”
De-dollarization of commodity pricing by China, Russia, and others is a defensive, rational response to the exorbitant privilege of the dollar system; China needs to reduce its dependence on dollar reserves to avoid the 1997 Southeast Asia currency crisis scenario where it runs out of dollars.
“for the de-dollarization of commodities is largely defensive in nature. It is an existential threat to them to get away from the dollar monopoly in commodities... they're going to need to have more dollars every year just to keep their economy going or else all the debt they have, their economy will implode”
The transition from the dollar-based to a gold-based (or gold-backed) reserve system would cause the dollar and pound sterling (the world's largest deficit countries) to fall sharply against gold, while the yuan (surplus country) would strengthen, naturally rebalancing global trade imbalances.
“if you are settling net settling in gold, then you're going to run deficits like the US and the US and UK run the biggest deficits, the US first, UK second. Uh your currencies are going to fall sharply against gold. And at the same time, China, who has been sort of manipulating this dollar system in a mercantile way, they're running this big surplus, their currency's going to uh uh strengthen meaningfully through the gold link”
The US Federal Reserve will stop raising rates and ultimately resume quantitative easing or liquidity injections, not because inflation is controlled but because the fiscal situation forces it, as the government cannot finance deficits without monetary expansion once banks and foreign buyers exhaust their demand.
“I do think they will stop raising rates. Maybe they do one more and then they stop, regardless where inflation is. And then I don't know that they go straight to QE, but I think we I do think we will get increasing liquidity injections in the manner we've seen, which is it's not it's not QE, it's BTFP. It's not QE. They are regular Treasury buybacks that are smooth the functioning of the Treasury market or something like that. Uh they're liquidity injections, right?”
Using the post-WWII analog, if the US debt-to-GDP needs to fall from 130% to 70-80% over 5 years, simple models suggest the US would need 12-18% annual inflation maintained for 4-5 years, or alternatively 100-300% inflation compressed into 2-3 years like Israel experienced in the early 1980s.
“we said okay we need to take debt to GDP down by 50 to 60 percentage points and let's say they do it over 5 years like they did after World War II. What would that entail holding everything else constant in this relatively simple model and what we found was that you needed 5 years 4 to 5 years of call it 12 to 18% annual inflation uh just to get it there.”
Bitcoin should be viewed as a neutral reserve asset with an energy tie due to its proof-of-work mechanism, making it valuable as a hedge against inflation and as a hedge against the combination of bursting global sovereign debt and peak cheap energy dynamics.
“I have become more bullish on the asset and its role as a neutral reserve asset for the people, and maybe at some point down the road, uh it can become a reserve asset at the sovereign level... there are elements where it does a lot of what gold does better than gold does, um but it's really about having a neutral reserve asset with an energy tied to it. To me, it's that that proof of work dynamic, that energy tied that is so critical”
UK energy price inflation has been 100-200% (doubling or tripling), and some people have experienced their energy bills double or triple, unlike the US which can produce more oil in response to price increases.
“In the UK, it's about up to about 10 11%. I think the US reached close to 10%... We've seen people have their energy prices double or triple. So, we we've seen masses We've seen high inflation here. We've seen it in the US. We know it is much higher. Um certain things have been I mean, energy in the UK has been... up up to 100 200% energy price inflation.”
The US Treasury issued a 38-page addendum to the Q1 2024 TBAC report (Treasury Borrowing Advisory Committee) after the fact on January 31st, discussing a 'clear and regular Treasury buyback program' framed as maintaining high-functioning markets, which Luke interprets as a dog whistle for soft yield curve control.
“Recently, there was an update someone pointed out to me. I didn't see it on on January 31st because it wasn't there. They amended it after the fact. There's a 38-page addendum that they amended after the fact to the one Q TBAC looking at What did they call it? It was a clear and regular Treasury buyback program benefits or something like that, right?”
Bitcoin will likely not be the reserve asset in the near term; gold will probably transition first as the primary reserve asset due to the need for a higher price of gold and transition through the status quo system, though Bitcoin could become a reserve asset further down the road.
“Could Bitcoin be that reserve asset at some point down the road? Yes, it could. Is it there yet? In my opinion, no, because you've got this status quo system and if there's going to be a transition in the system, it's probably going to go through gold first, which requires a much higher price of gold.”
Luke's base case is that policymakers will try to keep inflation in the double-digit range without letting it spiral, but there is an 'increasing risk' of triple-digit inflation over the next 2-3 years.
“I think my base case is that they are going to try to keep it in the double digit range without letting it get away from them. But, I think that is an increasing risk. I think it's going to be over the next 2 3 years really.”
Peter bought a bar and gave all staff a 20% pay rise to address underpayment, and was able to raise drink prices to cover the wage increase and new energy costs, demonstrating how inflation can be passed through in some businesses.
“I just bought a bar, right? And I've gone in and given all the staff a 20% pay rise. I think they're underpaid and I'm able I'm able to do that and I'm I'm also able then to raise the price of the drinks, which pays for it and also raise the price of the drinks to cover our new energy costs.”
Jacob Fugger, a historically wealthy man (by % of economy), used a 25-25-25-25 allocation across cash, gold, stocks, and real estate, rebalancing during tumultuous times, which Luke recommends as a model allocation.
“there's a um one of the wealthiest men in history by percent of the economy at the time was a man named Jacob Fugger, F U G G E R... he had a allocation where it was 25% cash, 25% gold, 25% stocks, 25% real estate. And then just reallocate and it, you know, through tumultuous times, you know, you sort of recover.”
The Treasury-Fed Accord of 1951 formally restored central bank independence from fiscal authority after the post-WWII coordination period, establishing the modern framework of separate institutions; this historical precedent suggests that the current coordination (BTFP, Treasury buybacks) may eventually be formalized or explicitly reversed.
“And then they did this thing called the Fed uh Treasury Fed Accord where basically at that point they said okay now we're going to go back to being separate entities the Fed's independent again they're going to set policy based on what's best for the currency not what's best for the government and away we go.”
There has been systematic capital misallocation for decades across government spending, trades, and labor markets, with oversupply in some areas (e.g., plumbers relative to doctors) and undersupply in others; inflation will force a painful reallocation but leaves policymakers no easy answers.
“there's been a misallocation of capital for so long into different trades labor markets, et cetera across the government spending. Now you're sort of stuck. You need to reallocate stuff and there's there's no easy answers.”
Stan Fischer, a former Fed Vice Chair (2017-2018), wrote authoritative papers on managing high inflation crises and wrote a BlackRock white paper in 2019 on how to 'inflate your way out' of crises.
“Stan Fischer who was a former Fed vice chair. He wrote one of the authoritative papers on how to manage the process. And he was he was a Fed vice chair as recently as 2017-2018. He wrote a BlackRock white paper in 2019 about how to inflate your way out of the next crisis.”
Luke's Bitcoin allocation grew from 2% in September 2020 to approximately 40% of liquid net worth by mid-2021, then he sold most of it in June 2021 to pay off his house, retained 5%, began adding back in late 2021, and ratcheted up again meaningfully in 2022-2023 after the sub-$20,000 crypto winter when major exchanges collapsed.
“So, I think the last time we spoke probably would have been what, like like 2020? Maybe say September... shortly after we spoke, uh I ratcheted up my allocation pretty meaningfully, actually. Um when it broke over 20,000, November of 2020, if you remember, it was Thanksgiving weekend here... I bet it peak, I was probably in 2021, uh I don't know. I was probably 40% at one point of my liquid net worth... and then when it ran to uh that summer, June of '21, I actually sold most of it. Um uh to be blunt, I paid off my house.”
Jason Lowry has written influential work on Bitcoin as a reserve asset, including his book 'Softwar' and an MIT PhD thesis on the topic, which influenced Luke's thinking.
“I think there's been some interesting work done on that uh in that vein, uh most notably by Jason Lowry. Uh his new book Softwar and it um his his PhD thesis at MIT.”
The US has experienced a period of 20-30+ years (with particular intensity in the last 20 years) where the primary winners have been China, Wall Street, and Washington D.C. interests, while most American workers and businesses have lost on a net basis in real terms.
“It's just not good for the part of the US that has won the last 20 years, the last 30 years. Who's won the last 20-30 years in the US? It hasn't been the US. It's been China. Mhm. It's been Wall Street. And it's been Washington, D.C., certain interests in Washington, D.C. Those have been the winners in the US. Everyone else has lost on a net basis. Like we're all just, you know, it's Washington's world”
Peter Schiff (implied, not named) would argue for gold holdings as inflation protection, representing the alternative view to holding Bitcoin; Grommen acknowledges this disagreement exists but does not own gold himself, preferring Bitcoin.
“Do you have a gold allocation? Peter Schiff is listening. Uh you do. Yeah, I haven't yet, and I've considered it a couple of times, but every time I just buy more Bitcoin.”
The combination of sovereign debt crisis + peak cheap energy + geopolitical tensions creates multiple potential outcomes with fat tails in both positive and negative directions, so the period ahead can end "really, really happily" or "really, really painfully" with many intermediate possibilities.
“it's it's a monumental time and there's a lot of different ways this can play out. This can end really, really happily. This can end really, really painfully. Um and there's it can end sort of a whole range of outcomes in between those two extremes, which unfortunately both have fat tails based on debt, geopolitics, etc.”
Peter (the podcast host) is balls deep in Bitcoin with fingers crossed, indicating an aggressive allocation that differs from Luke's more diversified approach.
“I'm like I'm like I'm balls deep in Bitcoin, fingers crossed”