
The REAL Reason MEN VOTED for TRUMP… | Scott Galloway
What this covers
The clip is a short, election-eve argument about the 2024 race. It starts with how unusual the race is: neither candidate has strong approval, and no presidential candidate with sub-50% approval has been reelected, with an incumbent party in that position nearly unprecedented since Roosevelt or Truman. From there the speaker, identified by the title as Scott Galloway, turns to why Trump appeals to young men. He frames it as a story about Democratic messaging and a shift from economic policy toward social-justice enforcement, rather than about conservative ideology.
Much of the case rests on arithmetic and omission. The speaker counts the 16 constituencies on the Democratic Party's website as roughly 76% of the population and reads the remainder, mostly young men, as excluded by design. He notes that the Democratic National Convention (DNC)) paraded demographic groups without naming young men. He then cites male-skewed figures: three in four opioid addicts and homeless people are men, men are three times as likely to die by suicide, and twelve times as likely to be incarcerated. A contested example is the University of Michigan's $150 million DEI investment, followed by a thirtyfold rise in racism complaints. He also argues that non-white men feel blamed too.
The last stretch widens to gender divergence. Women under 30 out-earn men, more single women own homes, and women are gaining in parliaments and tertiary education. The High Heels Effect, as a metaphor, has women "getting taller" while men fall behind, shrinking the pool of men who meet women's preferences. He links this to young people not dating, to men without romantic prospects drifting into vaping, games and pornography, and to instability in societies with many men lacking opportunity. He presents most of these claims as causal, and many are contestable.
The speaker argues that young men are leaving the Democratic Party not because they are becoming more conservative, but because the party has adopted identity politics and DEI frameworks that explicitly exclude them from its advocacy priorities, creating political alienation and contributing to broader social dysfunction among young men.
- The Democratic Party's website lists 16 demographic groups constituting ~76% of the population as their constituency, effectively discriminating against the remaining 24% (young men) by design
- Young men face documented crises (opioid addiction, homelessness, suicide) that were not mentioned at the DNC, signaling they are unseen by the party
- The party has shifted from economic policy to social justice enforcement, which the public has rejected, leaving young men feeling alienated rather than attracted to Republican positions per se
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
When an organization explicitly advocates for and tries to advantage 76% of the population, it is not actually advantaging 76% of the population or advocating for them; instead, it is discriminating against the remaining 24%, and that 24% is predominantly young men.
“similar to kind of the Dei apparatus on campus now or on University campus when you're purposely advocating and trying to Advantage 76% of the population you're not advantaging 76% of the population or advocating for them you're discriminating against the 24% and that 24% are squarely group it's young men”
Young men and their families feel they are struggling and are not seen by the Democratic Party because the party has become self-appointed enforcers of social justice policy and has lectured the nation about correct social behaviors, which America has rejected.
“young men and their families feel that they are these young men are really struggling and they are not seen by the Democratic party because the Democratic party I would argue that our big failure over the last 20 years is we've become sort of these self-appointed cops of social justice Justice and have tried to tried to lecture the nation on what is the right social policy or behaviors and that America has pretty squarely rejected this”
Democrats have focused on social policy rather than economic policies that would actually impact people, and this is a major strategic failure.
“the Democrats have decided where about social policy as opposed to the economic policies that are actually going to impact you and a large part of America has sort of rejected it”
Young men do not feel seen by the Democratic Party, and this invisibility—not their actual political views becoming more conservative—is driving them away from the party.
“young men do not feel seen by the Democratic party”
Young men are moving away from the Democratic Party, not toward the Republican Party, and this is best understood as rejection of Democratic messaging rather than embrace of Republican ideology.
“I would argue it's not so much they're moving to the Republican party as they're moving away from the Democratic party”
Young men are moving more conservative while young women are moving more progressive, which has ramifications including serving as another reason why young people are not dating and forming relationships.
“what you've seen is young men are going more conservative young women are going slightly more Progressive and that has a lot of unfortunate ramifications because again it's another reason why young people are not getting together and mating”
The group that has ascended fastest globally is women, with twice as many women elected to parliament in the last 30 years and more women globally now seeking tertiary education than men.
“the group that has ascended the fastest globally is women um twice as many women in the last 30 years elected to some form of parliament more women globally now are seeking tertiary education than men”
The Democratic Party's website lists 16 demographic groups as their constituency, which the speaker calculates adds up to approximately 76% of the US population.
“if you go to the DNC the Democratic party's website there's a section that says who we serve click on it and it says these are the constituents in America that we serve that we advocate for and it list 16 demographic groups ranging from um Asians and Pacific Islanders the disabled seniors black Americans um veterans it goes through all of these groups and I tried to add it up and I think it adds up to 76% of the US population”
The United States does not have a general opioid or homelessness crisis; rather, it has a specifically male opioid crisis and a specifically male homelessness crisis, with three out of four opioid addicts and three out of four homeless people being men.
“we don't have an opioid or a homeless crisis in the United States we have a male opioid and a male homeless crisis three out of four opioid addicts three out of four homeless people are men”
Young men are not actually moving to the Republican Party or becoming more conservative; rather, they are leaving the Democratic Party, and the speaker argues many young men maintain support for gender rights almost equal to young women.
“I would argue that young men are not going to the Republican Party they're actually less conservative or people have this image of young men that their Knuckles are dragging along the ground they actually are almost as in favor of gender rights as young women what I would argue is that they're leaving the Democratic party”
Metaphorically, women are getting taller and taller each year (earning more money, more college attendance, more elected positions) while men are getting shorter (relatively declining), which reduces the pool of men who are economically and socially "taller" than women.
“metaphorically women are getting taller and taller each year making more money more College attendance they're just killing it more and more people elected to positions of power and influence men are getting shorter and shorter”
The 2024 election is unprecedented because neither major candidate has historically high approval ratings: an incumbent party with less than 50% approval would be nearly the first to get reelected since Roosevelt or Truman, and no presidential candidate with sub-50% approval has ever been reelected before.
“this is an unusual election in the sense that neither of these candidates based on their metrics has ever been elected before we've never had since I think since maybe uh Roosevelt was it Roosevelt or Truman actually have we had a president an incumbent party be reelected when they're have less than a 50% approval so we if Harris gets elected it's a almost a firsttime occurrence that an incumbent Administration this unpopular gets reelected Trump never cracked 50% approval no no presidential candidate who has never been above 50% has ever been reelected”
When men don't have the prospect of a romantic relationship, they come off the rails; women in the same situation typically reinvest that energy in friendships and work, while men reinvest it in vaping, video games, and pornography.
“when men don't have the prospect of a romantic relationship they come off the rails women oftentimes will reinvest that energy in friendships and work men reinvest that energy in vaping and video games and porn”
The most violent and unstable places in the world have a preponderance of men with very little economic or romantic opportunity.
“mean look at the most violent unstable places in the world they have a preponderance of things and that is a bunch of men with very little economic or romantic opportunities”
Fifty percent of women say they won't date someone shorter than them, though the speaker estimates the actual figure is closer to 80%, and this is an instinctual preference related to women's vulnerability during pregnancy and desire for physical protection.
“50% of women say they won't date someone who's shorter than them I bet it's more like 80% it's just an embarrassing thing to say and it's very instinctual because women at some point are more vulnerable because of pregnancy and raising kids and they want someone who instinctively they feel could physically protect them so they tend to be not attracted to a man shorter than them”
Women under the age of 30 are now making more money than men, and more single women own homes than single men.
“women under the age of 30 are now making more money than men more single women own homes than single men”
At the Democratic National Convention, there was a parade of demographic groups mentioned, but not one mentioned the group that has fallen furthest and fastest in the United States, which is young men.
“if you look at the Democratic National Convention it was a parade of demographic groups but not one mentioned the group that has fallen furthest fastest in the United States and that's young men”
Progressive activism has gone so far that it is no longer promoting the rights of non-whites; instead, it has become self-defeating where even non-white males feel blamed and excluded.
“the snake is eating its own tale that it's gone so far to the progressive that at the end of the day it's no longer promoting the rights of non-whites”
Women have made progress socioeconomically both horizontally and upward, while men have made progress horizontally and downward, shrinking the pool of men who are moving upward.
“we've talked about this women made socioeconomically horizontally and up men horizontally and down the pool of horizontal and up among men is smaller”
There is a cohort of young men and their families who are angry about their economic and social position, and while they may be unfairly expectant about what they should receive from the American economy, they are objectively not doing well.
“you have a cohort of not only young men but families that are upset and angry about this cohort may be unfairly expectant around what they should expect from the American economy but they're not doing well”
A non-white male who is not making as much money, more inclined to be an addict or gambler, and owns fewer homes is still told by media that he is the enemy and should feel collective guilt for privilege his father and grandfather received.
“as a non-white male that's not making as much money that's more inclined to be an addict or gambling that owns fewer homes somehow I'm still the enemy I'm still like I've been told by media that I'm kind of should have Collective guilt because of the privilege my dad and my granddad received”
The University of Michigan invested $150 million in DEI social policy, and as a result the number of complaints about racism increased 30-fold while overall sentiment and feeling about America declined.
“the example I use is the University of Michigan amazing university has invested $150 million in Dei social policy and the number of complaints about racism is up 30 fold the sentiment the feeling about America has all gone down”
Men are three times as likely to kill themselves compared to women, and men are 12 times as likely to be incarcerated.
“three times as likely to kill themselves 12 times as likely to be incarcerated”
Young men feel seen by the Republican Party and Trump, who are pushing back on the social policies that have made them feel excluded by the Democratic Party.
“and they feel seen by the repu the Republican party and Trump who are pushing back on many of these social policies”
Historically, there were 12 Black students at Princeton, Harvard, and Yale combined 60 years ago, which was a problem; now two-thirds of Harvard's freshman class identifies as non-white.
“60 years ago 12 black people at Princeton Harvard and Yale that's a problem uh two-thirds of Harvard's freshman class now identifies as non-white”
There is justifiable anger among young men (including non-white males) that the Democratic Party has moved away from advocating for them, despite their objective disadvantage.
“there's a I think justifiable anger and a feeling that the Democratic party has really moved away from young men”
There is an analogy called the 'high heels effect' which describes how women metaphorically are getting taller (gaining economic power, education, attractiveness, status) while men are getting shorter (losing relative status), making them less attractive as romantic partners.
“there's this analogy that uh uh Chris Williams the podcast kind of reminds me a little bit of you uses and he calls it the high heels effect and that is 50% of women say they won't date someone who's shorter than them”
The progress of women in economic and social measures represents a remarkable victory and should not be impeded in any way.
“by the way we should never do anything to get in the way of that that's a remarkable victory for us”
In a recent poll of six men, four said they wanted Trump to win the election, while the speaker's personal position is that no great option exists on the menu.
“I actually did a poll in my group chat the other day three or four days ago so six men in there and I polled them I said who do you want to win the election and four of them said Trump my position actually which I've not really ever shared publicly is that I I see no great option oh Perfect's not on the menu”
The speaker did not care about political affiliation when dating in his 20s and 30s, and politics was not a topic of discussion among couples of that generation, in contrast to current dating patterns.
“when I was your age I was thinking about this when I was dating for the life of me if I went through every person I've dated in my 20s and 30s I don't remember what their political affiliation was I didn't care we didn't talk about that it was like you know are you fun I'm fun are you attracting me I'm not you know like let's go out let's drink let's see what let's see where this goes we didn't talk about politics”