
Why now is apples v. oranges compared to 2007 and 2001 (why no nominal recession is likely)
What this covers
This is a solo monologue by Luke Growman of FFTT, built around a comparison of today with two earlier downturns, 2001 and 2007. His case is that the setup now differs on the fiscal side and on the foreign balance sheet. In 2001 the U.S. ran a surplus, which drained money from the private sector, and Warren Mosler treated recession as close to arithmetic. Today's fiscal deficit works the other way. He also compares the net international investment position: roughly negative 3-5% of GDP in 2001 and negative 15% in 2007, against about negative 80% now. Foreign dollar-denominated debt was $4-5 trillion in 2007 and is about $13 trillion today.
The middle of the talk lays out the Non-Linear Recession Feedback Loop. Federal receipts fell 28% in the Great Financial Crisis and 19% in 2001. With interest plus entitlements already at or above 100% of federal receipts, a recession would push deficits and issuance up and the dollar higher. Foreigners short dollars would then sell Treasuries. He sees only three exits: massive Fed balance-sheet expansion, immediate 30-40% cuts to defense and entitlements, or default. He treats default as a zero-probability outcome and says it would mean hyperinflation.
The more contested material is political economy. Growman argues that the academic marginal return product of debt framing ignores that the military and Boomer voters will defeat the cuts needed to protect Treasuries' real value. His conclusion is that Treasuries must lose to every real asset. As evidence he cites the S&P 500, gold, Bitcoin and housing all accelerating against TLT. He ties this to a de facto Treasury Volatility Cap, tracing it from the September 2019 repo intervention through March 2020 QE (Quantitative Easing)) and the Q1 2023 bank-funding response. He also speculates that the government could contain Bitcoin by selling its holdings at key technical levels, as rules were changed for silver in 1980.
Growman argues that recession risk is extremely low due to the U.S. fiscal deficit (currently 8% of GDP), and that the policy response to any future debt stress will force real asset inflation rather than deflation, making long-term Treasury bonds structurally poor investments.
- With an 8% fiscal deficit, recession is mathematically unlikely unlike 2001 when the U.S. ran a surplus
- Policy makers have chosen to shrink government real value (allowing negative real rates) rather than cut nominal spending, forcing all real assets up relative to Treasuries
- A recession would trigger non-linear feedback loops (receipts down → deficits up → issuance up → dollar up → foreign selling of Treasuries) that force either MMT-style money printing or political cuts, both of which lead to inflation
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
History shows that when a government can print its own currency, it almost never cuts nominal spending to maintain the real value of debt; this time is not different from the pattern of a thousand years of human history
“that's how it's gone for a thousand years of human history with a few exceptions at most when you can print the money when you owe the debt in your own currency and you can print the currency you don't cut government spending to maintain the real value of the debt almost nobody has ever done that it's not different this time”
The academic discussion of marginal return product of debt assumes the real value of Treasuries must and will be maintained, but ignores political economy: when maintenance requires 30-40% cuts to defense/entitlements, the military and Boomer voters will win, and the real value of Treasuries will lose
“I understand that because Lacy runs a long-term treasury fund primarily however in in my opinion I think we are already past the point of marginal return product of debt fiscal spending Etc and in theory that points to a deflationary outcome I get it I get that's what the the the textbooks the academic textbooks are telling us however that ignores political economy and it ignores real politique”
Once debt exceeds a certain threshold (110-120% of GDP), the only politically feasible choice is to allow real asset inflation by keeping nominal government spending flat while nominal GDP grows, rather than cutting nominal spending to maintain Treasury real value
“once we get past that point of of of diminishing marginal return product of debt Etc the choices are very straightforward shrink the government on a nominal basis which means cut government spending...the other option is shrink on a real basis which is to say nominal GDP keeps growing up real G GDP Falls...the latter has been chosen”
Evidence that real asset inflation is being chosen: S&P 500 relative to long-term Treasury ETF (TLT) is accelerating up and to the right, gold relative to TLT is accelerating up and to the right, Bitcoin relative to TLT is accelerating up and to the right, and housing is accelerating up and to the right
“call up a chart of the S&P 500 over TLT the long-term US Treasury ETF up and to the right and it's accelerating up and to the right and gold over TLT accelerating up and to the right Bitcoin over TLT on high volatility accelerating up and to the right houses accelerating up and to the right”
In 2007, the U.S. deficit was much lower than today, net international investment position was only negative 15% of GDP (vs. 80% today), and foreign dollar-denominated debt was 4-5 trillion (vs. 13 trillion today), making 2007 fundamentally different from today
“in 2007 us at the GDP much lower deficit the GDP much lower us net International Investment position was only NE 15% or so it's 80% of GDP now foreign dollar denominated debt was much lower in 2007 I want to say it was four or five trillion it's 13 trillion now”
In Q3 2022, the Treasury ran down the Treasury General Account (TGA) aggressively to weaken the dollar at an annualized rate of almost 30% over 3-4 months, dropping from 114 to lower levels
“3 q22 treasury ran down TGA aggressively to weaken the dollar dollar went from 114 in September October 2022 uh down by about uh at an annualized rate of almost 30% over the next 3 to 4 months”
Higher interest expense is already priced in to long-term rate expectations due to lags in repricing, so even if the Fed cut rates to zero tomorrow, the U.S. would still face trillion-dollar annual interest expense and forced deficit choices
“a lot of it's a lot of it's priced in already like you would have to SL rates to zero tomorrow and you're still going to have like trillion dollar interest expense it takes a while for that to reprice”
In 2001, the U.S. net international investment position was negative 3-5% of GDP, versus 80% today; and U.S. foreign dollar-denominated debt was lower in 2007, meaning the current foreign short dollar position creates fundamentally different recession dynamics
“unlike 2017 when the net International Investment position was 15% of GDP and unlike 2001 when when the net International invest position was3 to 5% of GDP it's now 80% of GDP”
In 2001, the U.S. was running a fiscal surplus, meaning the government was withdrawing money from the private sector on net, and Warren Mosler warned recession was mathematically certain; by contrast today with an 8% fiscal deficit and rising, recession is extraordinarily unlikely
“in 2001 the US was running a surplus at the fiscal level uh means the United States government was actually withdrawing money basically from the private sector uh on net uh Warren Mosler was warning at the time that a recession was a mathematical certainty basically Mosler is now pointing out that a a recession is extraordinarily unlikely with an 8% of GDP fiscal deficit and Rising”
In a recession scenario, foreigners who are net short $3 trillion in dollar-denominated debt (unlike 2007 and 2001) would be forced to sell Treasury holdings to defend their currencies and pay their dollar debts, creating a non-linear cycle of rising yields that crowds out markets
“now foreigners unlike 07 unlike 01 are net short 3 trillion in dollar denominated debt they need to pay it back in dollars...foreigners own 22 trillion net 57 trillion gross in dollar denominated assets and they will sell every last one of those to pay their dollar debts okay they're going to start with treasuries they own eight TR trillion dollars in treasuries”
In Q1 2023, Treasury volatility spiked around regional banking issues, but these were actually Treasury market issues; the Fed responded by stepping in with the Bank Term Funding Program (BTFP) and began re-expanding its balance sheet
“1 q23 again treasury volatility spiked around the banking issues they weren't really banking issues they were treasury market issues fed stepped in with btfp bank term funding program I think or as some called it by the effing paper they started re-expanding their balance sheet”
The Fed stepped in with massive QE during March 2020 COVID crisis specifically to ensure the Treasury market continued to function, as stated in official Fed communications ('their words not mine')
“March 20 volatility cap on the treasury market again when off the un treasury market started crashing at the lows in the covid crisis fed stepped in with massive QE to make sure the treasury market functioned their words not mine”
If interest expense crowds out global dollar markets, causing the dollar to spike and rates to rise, a positive feedback loop forms: receipts down → deficit up → rates up → dollar up → stocks down → receipts down (nonlinear cycle)
“that would be caused by interest expense essentially crowding out Global dollar markets dollar up rates up stocks down receipts down uh uh deficit up rates up dollar up stocks down uh until receipts fall below interest alone”
Treasury bonds must function as 'certificates of confiscation on a real basis' (losing to all real assets) in order to keep the debt sustainable on a nominal basis, and this is a full stop, inevitable conclusion
“10year Treasury treasuries at the long end they must be made certificates of confiscation on a real basis to keep the debt sustainable on a nominal basis full stop”
Federal receipts fell 28% year-over-year during the Great Financial Crisis and 19% year-over-year during 2001, which combined with current 100%+ interest-plus-entitlements ratios would create a non-linear feedback loop requiring either Fed balance sheet expansion or spending cuts
“following that 07 period Federal receipts fell 28% year-over-year in 2001 they fell 19% year-over-year so let's take Federal receipts down 19 to 28% true interest expense entitlements plus interest is already at 100% year-to date of receipts in August it was 150% of receipts”
Foreigners own 22 trillion net and 57 trillion gross in dollar-denominated assets, and own 8 trillion in Treasury securities; in a recession they would sell all these to pay back their dollar debts, creating upward pressure on Treasury yields and downward pressure on asset prices
“foreigners own 22 trillion net 57 trillion gross in dollar denominated assets and they will sell every last one of those to pay their dollar debts okay they're going to start with treasuries they own eight TR trillion dollars in treasuries”
The non-linear recession feedback loop (receipts down → deficits up → issuance up → dollar up → foreign Treasury selling up) would only end when either interest alone drops below receipts and the Fed refuses to print (leading to default), or the Fed balance sheet expands massively (making COVID-era $600B/week QE look tame), or the U.S. cuts entitlements/defense 30-40% immediately
“wash rinse repeat until until either again interest alone is below receipts and then the FED says oh we're still not going to do anything about it we're just going to default on treasuries that ain't ever going to happen or the FED balance sheet at some point and it's not going to take long uh Grows by an amount that makes CO's 600 billion a week QE look tame or per the prior point the US Cuts entitlement spending and defense spending by 30 40% or or more immediately and permanently”
There is zero chance of the U.S. defaulting on Treasury holders because before reaching that point, policymakers will choose to print money to pay interest and entitlements rather than cut spending or default
“to be clear that isn't going to happen I think there is zero chance of that happening so if they allow that to happen then yes you'd get the mother of all recessions uh but only for a moment like I said uh because then one or another of things going happen they're either going to print the money to pay the interest”
Hyperinflation would result if the U.S. defaulted on Treasuries, because the currency is backed by the debt, and if the debt defaults, the currency goes to zero; on a nominal basis, there would be no recession (nominal GDP would be very high), but on a real basis people could buy only 3 eggs with a gazillion dollars
“when the currency's backed by the debt and the debt defaults the currency goes to zero you have hyperinflation so that's that's that's not going to happen and if that happens you're going to have GDP to the moon on a real basis by the way there'll be no no no uh recession in that case at all on a nominal basis now on a real basis yeah they would be the worst recession Of All Times uh but the stock market would be at a at a gazillion dollars and it would buy you like three eggs”
Policymakers explicitly allow this system to evolve by requiring all real asset charts to go up and to the right relative to Treasuries, and this is the only way to sustain debt over 110-120% of GDP
“the way they've allowed the system they policy makers broadly have allowed the system to evolve requires that those all go up and to the right...and that's the only way to sustain the debt once it's over H 110 120% debt the GDP”
Interest plus entitlement payments are already at or above 100% of federal receipts as of the recording date (interest plus entitlements were 150% of receipts in August and 120% in July), meaning the choice between printing money or defaulting must be made immediately
“as a practical matter I think the real number is not just interest it's interest plus entitlement pay goes and we're already at 100% of receipts on that number right now”
The release valve for the Treasury volatility cap has been the inflation of real assets: S&P up relative to TLT, gold up relative to TLT, homes up relative to TLT, Bitcoin up relative to TLT, and these must all continue accelerating up and to the right nonlinearly
“the release valve to this cap has been as we have seen S&P up especially relative to TLT gold up especially relative to TLT homes up especially relative to TLT Bitcoin up especially relative to TLT the way they've allowed the system they policy makers broadly have allowed the system to evolve requires that those all go up and to the right all those charts relative to treasuries go up and to the right over time increasingly nonlinearly”
The Fed and Treasury have instituted a de facto U.S. Treasury volatility cap, beginning with the September 2019 repo intervention when they stopped the repo rate spike at 8-10% instead of allowing market clearing
“fed and the fed and treas treasury instituted a US Treasury volatility cap in September 2019 uh when they stepped in to stop the repo rate Spike if we all wanted free markets we should have just let repo stay at 8 to 10% in September 2019”
The government can theoretically contain Bitcoin by bleeding out government-owned Bitcoin over time at key technical levels to prevent short squeezes, similar to how they changed silver rules in 1980
“all they can really do in my opinion in the in the intermediate to long term is bleed out government-owned Bitcoin over time at Key technical levels to try to contain do I think that's happening I I I don't know I I I I don't know uh we know the government has sold a little bit but I don't know whether that's happening or not I'm simply saying that that is something that Theory they could do”
S&P at record highs combined with VIX at relatively low levels (21) is explained by the Treasury volatility cap: the Fed and Treasury cap Treasury market volatility, which forces all real assets up relative to Treasuries, creating a risk-on environment
“S&P F 500 at the highs vix volatility 21 which is still relatively low explain please fed and the fed and treas treasury instituted a US Treasury volatility cap”
If the U.S. cuts entitlements and defense by 30-40% immediately, brings military forces home from overseas, and cedes Eurasia to China and Russia, the result would be a genuine depression with nominal GDP contraction and likely political populism worse than recent precedent
“we pack up all our boys and girls overseas we bring them home we seed Eurasia to China and Russia we tell the Boomers spend your own money we're done in front of an election and then we get an actual honest to goodness depression with a capital D in terms of what happens to nominal GDP and we probably in short order get some sort of political I don't want to say the word because on YouTube will stop monitor won't even publish this or well but uh you'll get a political you'll get a political populism uh episode that makes what's his name from a couple years ago uh look tame by comparison”
MicroStrategy's Bitcoin strategy is analogous to the Hunt Brothers' silver accumulation, except Bitcoin is harder (higher stock-to-flow ratio) than silver and lacks unallocated derivatives markets like COMEX, making it harder to contain
“I think ultimately and a useful analog it's not a perfect one but I think it's useful it's the Hunt Brothers on Silver except Bitcoin is harder lower stock to flow excuse me higher stock to flow uh than silver uh and there's no unallocated Bitcoin derivatives uh on the horizon centered in London and comx probably can't change the rules to sell only on bitcoin like they did for silver”
In Q3 2023, the Fed and Treasury managed the Treasury volatility cap by shifting issuance to the front end of the yield curve while the Fed held shorter-term Treasuries, which weakened the dollar and lowered Treasury volatility
“3 q23 fed and treasury fed job owned treasury shifted issuance to the front end voila dollar down treasury volatility down treasury volatility cap”
There is some outflow risk if China repatriates capital out of the U.S., which would drive stocks down and yields up, but this would only cause recession if it forces the U.S. government to shrink its size or allows the Treasury market to dysfunction
“I do agree there is some outflow risk uh if China repatriates Capital out of the US that drives stocks down it drives yields up and then in theory you could see recession but again only if that forces the United States government to shrink its size uh or and or allows the treasury market to dis function”
The 10-year Treasury moving up in 2007 while the Fed was cutting rates, ultimately declining significantly, parallels current dynamics, and rising yields today are a 'Tremor' of the bond market beginning to recognize the Fed is cutting rates to support fiscal situation
“it did the exact same thing in 2007 moved up while the Fed was cutting ultimately yields on the 10-year Treasury went much lower I think it was a Tremor of some in the bond market beginning to recognize that the FED is cutting rates to help the US fiscal situation”
Today's environment is completely different from 2001 and 2007 (apples and oranges) because of higher debt, higher foreign dollar exposure, higher interest expenses relative to receipts, and the political impossibility of cutting spending
“it is apples and oranges to 2001 someone kind of highlights a 2001 case to you crinkle it up throw it in the trash completely different now uh from B”
The Ten Most Interesting Things product at FFTT synthesizes ten topics weekly and for each provides a brief synopsis of what captured attention, how it's changing or confirming prior thinking, and what it means
“check out fftc about what we're up to and our tree rings product 10 most interesting things brief synopsis on what grabbed our attention about each of them how it's changing or confirming a way we'd previously been thinking about the world”