What this covers

This is a nearly two-hour Bankless conversation in which host Ryan questions Chris Dixon of a16z, who frames Web3 through five overlapping mental models. It begins with how new technologies get received. Dixon says they are dismissed as toys, as too expensive, or as solving no real problem, and he argues that each objection tends to fail over time. He uses the telephone and Western Union to illustrate, along with the slow recognition that mobile was the primary computing platform. His test for a new technology is not "what problem does it solve" but "what design space does it unlock," and he applies that to Facebook as well.

The middle of the conversation moves through economics and ownership. Dixon returns to the take rate as the measure of a platform's exposure to disruption, contrasting Web2 platforms that extract 30–100% with Web3 protocols at a few percent. Axie Infinity and Spotify's artist payouts serve as examples of the creator economy. He also covers tokens as a general primitive that, like web pages, will outgrow their first forms, so that NFTs) start as JPEGs and may become tickets, game assets, and domain names. Other threads include skin in the game as an unpaid marketing engine, the Facebook and Twitter API shutdowns as evidence that "can't be evil" has to be built into architecture, and a New York versus Disneyland contrast, in the spirit of Jane Jacobs, between organic and command economies.

Several claims are openly contested. Dixon says competition checks platform power better than regulation, that founder-led companies will adopt crypto sooner, and that the weekend hobbies of the smartest technologists predict mainstream adoption a decade later. The final stretch turns practical, covering a16z's crypto fund and team, why he thinks investors should follow builders instead of prices, the regulatory outlook, and predictions for 2022.

Sharpest takeaway

Dixon argues that Web3 represents a fundamental shift to user-owned, token-orchestrated internet enabled by property rights in digital assets, fundamentally restructuring power dynamics from centralized platforms to creators and users through lower take rates and permissionless innovation.

  • Web3 adds property rights to the internet for the first time, enabling true digital ownership versus renting access from centralized platforms
  • Tokens as a primitive enable networks to transition from information-only to value-flowing economies with dramatically lower take rates (2.5% vs 30-100%)
  • Historical pattern shows disruptive technologies dismissed as toys eventually become dominant when infrastructure improves and developers build applications

The claims · ranked53 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

New technologies are predictably dismissed through three narrative traps—'it's just a toy', 'it's too expensive', and 'it doesn't solve any real problem'—but history shows toys improve (Moore's Law + developer iteration), expensive things become cheap (hardware cost curves), and new design spaces eventually spawn applications nobody anticipated

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Chris Dixon

“the um the and i think each is probably a different pattern and it depends on the technology so as an example it's too expensive tends to apply to hardware and so you know tesla would be an obvious example where you just it's just simply the nature of hardware i've been involved with a few hardware companies is when you're at subscale you just pay a lot more for supplies and assembly and everything else and so as you sell more units the price can can drop dramatically”

0.74

The telephone was dismissed by telegraph company Western Union as unsolvable for long distance, low quality voice transmission, and solving no real business problem because telegraph was optimized for railroad inventory management. Western Union passed on telephone patents because they asked existing customers what they wanted instead of recognizing paradigm shift

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Chris Dixon

“when a telephone came out was alexander graham bell invented the telephone that the time the telegraph business was income and business in the telegraph business basically they served the railroad so they were they would a railroad come railroads were the enterprise their enterprise customers of that era they paid a lot of money and they said we want to say hey this you know this we have this much lumber at this depot send that over telegraph over here and we'll pay you a lot of money to do it because it helps us manage our inventory telephone comes along it can only go like 500 feet sounds like crap and like why would you want voice when you want to send lumber prices and so western union because they were thinking like what are but this is a clever thing with clay christensen's framework is it he's not saying these managers are idiots”

0.72

Facebook is not a direct solution to a customer problem, but rather a new design canvas that created entirely new behaviors (social networking) that didn't exist before—this is how to evaluate new technologies: not 'what problem does this solve' but 'what design space does this unlock'

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Chris Dixon

“what problem did facebook solve at first the creating a giant social group they didn't solve a problem it created a new set of behaviors and opportunities computing computers the most obvious example like no computer by itself solves any problem the computer creates a design canvas upon which entrepreneurs and developers can create applications which then can sometimes solve problems although did the spreadsheet solve a problem kind of but at the time people didn't really have it was more that they just enabled them to do kind of more advanced business calculations right like the businesses were running perfectly fine before that um and they were doing accounting before that long before that”

0.71

Cryptocurrencies grow without marketing spend by creating skin-in-the-game ownership psychology where users evangelize unpaid because they hold tokens, while Web2 requires 50%+ of revenue spent on sales/marketing to achieve similar adoption

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“bitcoin of course doesn't spend there is no bitcoin company they don't spend money on marketing but they've got an army of how many hundred million people who write millions of you know medium posts and tweets and you know all of these evangelists it's it's a religion okay and so i think the the so why why has crypto grown so quickly without any marketing because people feel skin in the game they feel ownership and that that causes them to go evangelize and it's a very very powerful force”

0.69

Mobile (2009-2011) was underestimated: iPhone came out in 2007 and app store in 2008, but the world didn't recognize mobile was the primary (not secondary) computing platform until Facebook's mobile pivot in 2012, showing that paradigm shifts take years to be recognized

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“so like a very important moment was facebook's mobile pivot in 2012. so 2012 was really in my mind 2012 was the year that the world real the tech world realized that mobile is not the secondary computing platform it's the primary computing platform so people knew it was a thing and it was important and it was growing but the to the extent to it specifically touch-based smartphones like you know there were many many cell phones but there was a lot of controversy as to whether they were look they were really expensive go look at that steve but it's the infamous steve ballmer video about the iphone and no one's going to buy it it's so expensive”

0.69

The Facebook/Twitter API massacre—where platforms summarily shut off third-party developer access—demonstrates that Web2 platforms lack immutability and immunity, meaning 'can't be evil' is architecturally enforceable in Web3 but 'don't be evil' is merely aspirational in Web2

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“there were all of these there was a huge wave of people that built startups on facebook and twitter and they were all just summarily kind of shut off um i had a lot of friends who had startups that were built on the twitter api twitter was a twitter was an ecos it was a developer platform for many years yes it had users using it directly but it actually didn't even have an app for a long time it was all third-party apps and those were all companies those were people who spent their lives on it and twitter did”

0.68

The take rate—the percentage a platform extracts from transaction value—directly correlates to vulnerability to disruption, with Web2 platforms extracting 30-100% of value while Web3 protocols operate at 2.5-4.7% rates, creating mathematical incentives for user and creator migration

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“i think a healthy take rate is something like two and a half percent right i think an unhealthy take rate is you know when you have 100 which is twitter instagram facebook and 50 youtube and 30 apple for doing very little in the case of apple like that to me is a sign of a basically a monopoly”

0.68

Axie Infinity demonstrates the Web3 creator economy model by taking only 4.7% of in-game transaction value compared to Fortnite's 100%, creating a peer-to-peer economy where 1.8 million players (predominantly in Philippines) earn living wages by playing, with SLP token becoming local medium of exchange

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“slp the you know the token has become i had uh dinner with gabby the other day kind of gabby from ygg is amazing... he said that his slp is so prevalent in the philippines now that it's like you'll see uh i think he tweeted one out today it's like craigslist ads priced in slp”

0.68

Healthy economies and cities (NYC vs Disneyland) develop bottom-up with mixed public/private ownership and organic emergence of diverse services, while centralized platforms produce monoculture—Web3 on Ethereum resembles NYC's organic diversity whereas Web2 platforms resemble Disneyland's command economies

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“the analogy i would use is to like new york city versus disneyland or something right so disneyland is a command centralized economy and new york city is much more kind of organically developed and so in new york you think about there's a great um some crypto people like jane jacobs she's a just amazing author who wrote about kind of the life of cities and has this amazing first chapter in this book where she's talking about just a city block and all the different things you have on a on a healthy block and a healthy block you have a sidewalk you have restaurants you have residences you have barber shops”

0.66

Most internet innovation follows circuitous, multi-step paths rather than direct problem-solution relationships, requiring developers and users to discover applications over time rather than problems being pre-specified

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Chris Dixon

“the thing that bugs me about the what problems to solve it assumes innovation is just like one direct simple thing right as opposed to a multi-step kind of community process which the biggest things follow these kind of much more kind of circuitous routes i would argue”

0.65

Mobile computing required broadband infrastructure buildout (by Verizon/Comcast) before applications could flourish, but Web3 does not face this constraint—internet hardware is already built out, enabling Web3 to innovate and scale much faster than mobile did

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“a big thing with web one is is the band it was broadband but you literally had to have companies like verizon and comcast like dig holes and everything else to get to the point where you could have youtube right we don't have that issue now we have the internet the hardware is all built out the wireless you know phones and we have web too”

0.64

The a16z crypto fund invested in major DeFi protocols (Uniswap, Compound, Maker) and has maintained diversified practice areas (infrastructure, DeFi, NFTs/gaming, emerging areas) with ~30 full-time and 10+ advisors, and other major VCs are now adopting crypto specialization, validating crypto as mainstream investment category

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“we raised a new fund we hired we've hired a bunch of people to become a meme on twitter we actually only have i think we have 30 or so full-time people on the crypto team so it is larger uh the meme's a little overblown maybe but uh but what's what's the meme i'm curious i haven't seen it it's like everyone's joking they joined a16z”

0.64

Spotify has 8 million artists but only 14,000-50,000 earn $50,000+ annually, demonstrating how Web2's payment structure is broken despite scale—Web3 models allow direct monetization enabling vastly higher income for more creators with lower take rates

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“spotify the statistic i just i like is that they i think they it's on their website they have eight million artists and of that only fourteen thousand and fifty thousand dollars a year or more so make sort of the average american living so fourteen thousand out of eight million they put that on their website they think it's a good thing like think about how engaged people are with music how much they love music”

0.64

Bankless newsletter grew to 100,000 subscribers using Substack by combining Web2 distribution (Twitter aggregation) with Web3-adjacent monetization (direct subscriptions), demonstrating the bridge model where creators use platform reach as funnel but retain direct audience relationship for monetization

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Ryan (Host)

“so um i think subtac is a perfect example because it's one of these bridge companies it's a bridge in the creator economy between like web 2 and web 3 right but it's like not fully tokenized but like bagless got its start on substance in uh 2020. we started with just like uh actually 2020 2019 for two years ago and and we started with like just a handful at on twitter as you said right we just hit a hundred thousand subscribers uh just like in the past week”

0.63

Web3 is an internet owned by users and builders orchestrated by tokens, fundamentally different from Web2's centralized platform control where users rent access rather than own digital assets

definitionhigh valuefringenovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“the way i define web3 is an internet owned by users and builders orchestrated by tokens”

0.62

Regulatory framework is secondary to convincing the public of crypto's societal benefit—crypto adoption will follow the Uber/Airbnb pattern where public sees the utility (e.g. musicians earning directly) and demands regulatory accommodation, but this requires demonstrating millions of actual beneficiaries in the next 1-2 years

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“i think ultimately there were regulatory questions around ride sharing there were regulatory questions around airbnb i think what ultimately convinced people that that there should be regulation of course but there should be regulation that allows those those companies to exist is they saw the value they saw they saw the value as a rider and you know you could click a button and ride an uber they saw the value they knew a driver who made a living that way and so that's the ultimate path to acceptance of technology is to prove to the world it has societal value”

0.62

Tokens are a general primitive like web pages—early web pages looked like magazines but evolved into diverse forms (SaaS, docs, spreadsheets, games); similarly NFTs start as JPEGs but will evolve into game assets, tickets, domain names, and forms we cannot yet anticipate as developers iterate

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“tokens are like web pages in the sense that they're they're they're very very general um general primitive so when the web the first websites came along they you know they had certain personality they had pictures on them they had they had uh text and people said oh i see it's like a magazine right but then over time... developers iterated and built new more and more new ideas and new kind of types of things types of websites and so today you have you know social networking you have very elaborate sas software you have spreadsheets google docs and today we can see we can appreciate kind of when we use the web how general concept the um the token is”

0.62

Web2 companies built on centralized control and shareholder value maximization are fundamentally misaligned with the health of networks they operate, forcing them to increase take rates and restrict access even as it harms creator productivity and user satisfaction

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“if you're an ultra founder jack dorsey or something you can resist this but for almost everybody else you ultimately report to shareholders and those shareholders want you to maximize profits and that i believe is fundamentally inconsistent with maximizing the health of the networks built on top i think the network i think that corporations and networks are fundamentally misaligned the corporation is going to want to grab more and more of the money and close off the network when the network what the network wants what the people on the network want is they want openness and low take rates and open permissionless access”

0.62

Founder-led companies (Twitter, Square, Facebook) are more likely to embrace Web3 than non-founder-led companies because founders have seen disruption patterns before and maintain decision-making flexibility, whereas committees and consensus-driven organizations move too slowly to adopt non-consensus bets

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“i think when they start to see the creators taper off and opt out of some of their programs because that's their soft underbelly they're very good they're very strong on the network effects on the user side right... i think my guess is it'll be different with founder-led companies that the founder-led companies they've seen this pattern before they've seen these things people have dismissed as a toy they come from below that seems silly that get called a scam and they realize it's not and so i you know it doesn't surprise me that twitter and square and facebook and you know instagram which of course is done by facebook are on the leading edge of this”

0.62

Financial institutions and banks will adopt crypto ownership not because they believe in ideology but because if the internet's value creation shifts to token-based models, traditional institutions must buy tokens to participate in that value capture, making crypto adoption an inevitable financial necessity rather than ideological choice

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“if we're right if i think the three of us probably agree on this if we all if we're right that future internet products are created in the web3 mold and they and the value accrual happens through tokens um then the rest of the world is going to want to they're going to want to follow that they're going to want to follow where that value on the internet is created and if it's i believe most of the value in the future of the internet will be created through tokens and and i think again a correlate to that would be most financial institutions interested in internet value creation will want to buy tokens and so i think it will spread not only from the venture side but i think that that's how also the you know the broader institutional side um the banks and the hedge funds and all sorts of other other folks like that um so yeah i mean look i think”

0.62

The way to maintain investment relevance is to stay close to entrepreneurial energy and product innovation rather than trying to predict price movements, which is both impossible and wrong as a strategy

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“what keeps me up at night is like look at my job is like i want to make sure we have the next open seat we have like what will it be and how do we stay close to the i what i try to do i don't look at the prices i stay close to the entrepreneurs i'm like where's the energy moving you know where is like the the world spirit moving what's the new area and how do we kind of make sure we're in there and if we do that and it i think this is generally true in innovative in kind of innovative markets if you follow that energy like and you have a long-term perspective i think it generally works out”

0.62

Competition is a more effective check on platform power than regulation—forcing companies to externalize networks or breaking them up may not reduce extractive behavior, but competition from lower-cost Web3 alternatives will force Web2 to improve by removing lock-in and lowering take rates

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“there's two ways to control kind of big companies that act in predatory ways one is to try to regulate them directly through monopoly law and things like that which i think we're about to see some of that happen i don't think that will work very well um if you've sliced up facebook into four different social networks or three different or however it is i don't think that's going to change the power dynamics um you might i think smarter in a regulation like forcing them to externalize the network to really let you leave the network and take your followers with you and and support open protocols maybe could work i don't know i don't see the head in that way the other way to control these companies is to is to provide competition and to provide a new model where the user is has power and has lower switching costs and don't let it happen again that users are locked in that they're locked in and that they're you know that they're dependent on these intermediaries and that's obviously what we're trying to work towards”

0.62

Companies founded during financial winters don't show correlation with market prices—iconic companies (Google, Facebook, etc.) were often founded in bear markets, suggesting that company founding and success depend on product opportunity and team talent rather than financial market conditions

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“i wrote a blog post about actually this would be a good tweet storm but i wrote a blog post once where i analyzed it kind of when companies were founded when iconic companies were founded in correlation to nasdaq and it's just uncorrelated wow it's just yeah so it's just like that'd be actually a good tweet storm i should do that”

0.62

The smartest people's weekend hobbies predict mainstream technology adoption 10 years later—this has held across computer science for 50+ years and applies to crypto, where smart technologists studying crypto now will drive broader adoption over the decade

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“i have this blog post what the smartest people do on the weekend everyone else will do in 10 years and i think it's i think that's been universally true for the last 50 years in software that the things that you know the steve jobs and the wozniak going to the homebrew computer club and like all the all the smartest computer science nerds in 1970s were right and the people at the big companies who bet against pcs were wrong um that's happened over and over um it happened with the internet it happened with open source software and i think it's going to happen here as well”

0.62

OpenSea's 2.5% take rate demonstrates that low-margin, high-volume marketplaces can outcompete high-margin platforms while still being extremely profitable, and their explosive growth validates this business model

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“so you have centralized services in the mix and look it'll be reflected in take rates like openc like we're big investors in openc full disclosure um and i know there's some controversy in the decentralized world but look it's it i do think there's a role for centralized services and they charge two and a half percent right which is in stark con i mean the lowest web to take rate is apple at thirty percent youtube is fifty percent and instagram twitter and facebook give zero i.e they charge a hundred percent”

0.62

The golden period of technology adoption (2009-2011 for mobile, potentially now for crypto) features positive feedback loops where users/developers invest in infrastructure, which improves, unlocking new applications, which drives more users, compounding growth rate

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“in the really good golden period you get this you get this feedback loop so you've got the application developers coming in and doing cool new stuff which in turn drives more users and money into the infrastructure layer meaning like the phone or the blockchain and that gets better and as that gets better that unlocks so we're you know that unlocks new applications we're already seeing this i'm sure like for example in the l2 world right now that you've got real ethereum l2s you're now going to have a new class of applications now that you've got other l1 that are built for for like gaming use cases an example that's going to unlock a whole nother range of kind of games as an example or nft use cases anyways”

0.61

Machine learning investments in 2008 were correct in thesis (AI would transform computing) but wrong in timing (too early, requiring 12+ years for infrastructure/data to mature), illustrating how venture conviction must account for being too early as effectively failing

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“i started a machine learning company in 2008 and i was clearly too early on that it was called hunch it was acquired by ebay in 2011. um and i and i if you'd asked me and i you know in 2008 i said this is going to be the thing it's going to change the world ai is finally at a point where it's going to it's going to it's really going to happen ai had like a 50-year period of kind of false start you know going back to alan turing who predicted that i forget exactly but someone would pass would you know pass a turing test would trick would be able to simulate act like a human i think he said within 30 years or something way overly optimistic the field was seen as kind of a disappointment and i believed that people were underestimating and so i created this company and we had this recommendation technology ai stuff and i think i was right i just unfortunately was too early and you know that's as they say in venture too early is the same as being wrong so i guess i was wrong”

0.61

Skype exemplifies a toy technology that succeeded—janky voice calls over 500 feet seemed pointless to telegraph businessmen, but the 'useless toy' eventually captured the telephone market by being free and globally accessible

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“skype when skype first came out um it was this thing that you had to have a microphone people didn't have mics built into the pcs back then and it was janky and dropped calls and but it was free and you could call your family in india and talk for free right so it's sort of amazing but you go back and read that kind of stuff around it the telephone is the most canonical example”

0.57

Web2 has peaked in innovation—the last decade produced only incremental improvements (better cameras, batteries, chips) rather than paradigm shifts like iPhone/iPad, indicating that centralized platforms have exhausted their innovation frontier and Web3 represents the next growth frontier

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“would you go so far chris is to say web 2 has peaked like it's it's it's kind of done now it's now it's on the decline... i think it's nuanced so web 2 defined as the big companies their their market caps are high they're doing very well economically... i don't know i don't know anyone who works i do know people work these companies none of them seem very inspired they all seem you know they've gotten very corporate only one of the big companies is led by a founder anymore”

0.57

Music industry revenue has stagnated at ~20 billion while gaming has grown to 140 billion primarily because music licensing barriers prevent innovation, whereas games pioneered free-to-play with premium cosmetics monetization—a model that will transfer to music once NFTs allow direct artist-to-fan monetization

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“gaming has consistently grown every year every time the new tech gaming has grown gaming is 140 billion dollar industry music has shrunk it's been flat and now it's like 20 billion so it's a seventh the size of gaming which doesn't make any sense when you think about how popular it is and how much people love music the reason it's been it's been stuck there is if there's been no innovation and once the music industry is allowed to embrace new technology as i think they may be about to be they will grow along with gaming and they will embrace the same things”

0.57

Blau's 11 million dollar NFT drop proved that musicians can monetize directly without Spotify or labels by selling digital merchandise to fans, replicating the Substack effect where creators can earn sustainable livings by capturing 90%+ of revenue instead of labels/platforms taking 85-90%

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“when blau did his drop his nft drop and made 11 million dollars you don't need the labels or spotify or anything else it's just it's just it's just the musician and their fans it's a direct it's the sub stack thing we were talking about earlier”

0.57

Crypto has been dismissed as too expensive through high gas fees on Ethereum mainnet, but this ignores that block space is a valuable product in the 2020s with healthy pricing dynamics, and layer-2 solutions (Optimism, Arbitrum, Polygon) plus alternative L1s will moderate costs while maintaining premium L1 security tiers

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“what do you think about block space though do you think that's an example like some people are like gas fees are too high um yes for sure for sure we're going to see a lot of we can talk about that more but i think we're going to see a lot of um you know the optimism arbitram polygon phantom other l1 that said i think that i would predict that block space is going to be uh that that demand is going to outstrip supply for a very long time uh i think the prices the more supply coming on will be moderate it but i think block space is the best product to be selling in in the 2020s it's like it's a great product”

0.57

Top game developers (from Riot, Valve, Epic) are now in every a16z meeting asking about NFTs, signaling that serious game designers view token-based economies and player ownership as fundamental design improvements, and this influx of talent will accelerate NFT/gaming iteration beyond current naive implementations

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“we have a games group at our firm that's not you know they're not crypto they're just sort of traditional games like and they invest in really top game developers who come out of places like riot and valve and epic which are kind of the best game companies talent companies in the world and i think it was about four months ago as after asking blew up just every single meeting they have now involves nfts and in fact i was gonna say i'm betting they have some crazy fomo right now but also but they do but they also these are these people are really good designers i've seen the stuff and it's a it's another level like it's going to be awesome”

0.57

Product cycles and price cycles are independent—financial downturns will not slow Web3 product innovation because infrastructure, developers, and entrepreneurial energy are decoupled from price movements; the 2019 bear market had a 'product winter' problem (few launches) but 2021 has product launches every 3 days indicating the product cycle is accelerating

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“you know nfts are over and they're boring and then three days later a great new project launches right and you're gonna see that like every week now and i remember 2019 there was a financial winter in crypto you guys were there um but the thing that bugged me was not that it was the product winter i mean there weren't there were just so few product launches right there's like a product launch every three days now that that i don't think is stopping”

0.57

Talented entrepreneurs entering crypto report they 'fell down the rabbit hole' and changed their minds about crypto's legitimacy, creating a constant inflow of high-quality talent that sustains product cycle momentum independent of market sentiment or media coverage

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“i get an email i said this in the truth and it's true i get an email like a day from a very high quality entrepreneur saying i went down the rabbit hole and i you know i used to think you were crazy chris and now i'm like oh my god this is like the greatest thing ever this happens a lot and i think a lot of those people will stay you know regardless of prices”

0.56

The internet is experiencing constant waves of improvement and iteration, with NFTs launching new projects every 3 days currently (2021), fundamentally changing the internet back to being interesting and weird (like the early 'surfing the web' era) rather than optimized into corporate blandness

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“you know nfts are over and they're boring and then three days later a great new project launches right and you're gonna see that like every week now... finally the internet's like interesting and weird again it's like all these add-ons... i actually like enjoy going on the internet and seeing like weird interesting stuff again in a way i didn't in the same way that i do when i walk around new york and i'm you know i don't go to disneyland i don't want to go i want to be in new york the vibe is is cool once again”

0.55

Networks become economies when tokens enable value to flow peer-to-peer between participants, transforming information-only networks (Twitter, Facebook, Spotify) into value networks where creators can monetize directly without advertising intermediation

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“so they've got all these networks built out and we're nodes in these networks and maybe you've got your you know your your twitter account and you've got your followers and you've got tiktok and you've got youtube or whatever you have sub stack um but you know the only business model that we had layered on top of that for the most part we're advertising and and some with a few other exceptions um and now we have a way to take those networks which and and let value flow through them freely and that value is our tokens right”

0.52

Digital property rights are a novel concept that enables new behaviors and some early experimenting with speculation and 'degen' culture; while this may seem silly, it's not a bug but a feature of early property right systems and should be expected; the focus should be on the macro pattern, not dismissing based on early excesses.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“imagine we lived in the real world forget about the internet and we had no concept of property rights everything was rented from four you know big and large ioi pick your four dystopian companies and then one day somebody came along and you know threw the sledgehammer through the apple ad in 1984 and we had property rights you know at the beginning you suddenly could own something and at the beginning you would probably have some of the behavior we're seeing now like in the nft world like of speculation and sort of degens and all this other stuff right oh my god i can own something oh well i'm gonna own that you want to own that like i own the better thing or something you know this could be kind of a little bit we're in that phase now right”

0.52

D5 (decentralized finance) is narrower than Web3 because it only appeals to people interested in financial services, whereas NFTs and gaming appeal to all of culture, making NFTs/gaming the better onramp to Web3 for the masses

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“i think we had the kind of early history bitcoin ethereum and then we had a lot of infrastructure stuff a lot of our investments in like 2017-18 were infrastructure and then and then d5 of course right we're investors in uni swap and compound and maker and all that and that was great too but you know d5 it's finance is just a narrower set of there's a smaller set of people that are interested in finance versus nfts which is in gaming which is kind of all of culture by the way i think they're all going to reinforce each other like i think of the way that we get d5 to the next level is by bringing 100 million people in through gaming and nfts and those people are going to naturally want to save their money in d5 and so i think they're all like kind of closely connected and reinforcing”

0.51

Metamask and Web3 UX are intentionally janky despite 10 million active users willing to tolerate poor experience, indicating massive product-market fit signal that metrics-focused product managers at Google/Facebook would miss by overweighting UX quality

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“i mean actually i would argue that's an amazing the positive signal for us the fact that it is so janky and yet there's 10 million people you know active usual metamask people are sort of clamoring you know and willing to go through all the pain to get it but”

0.49

Web3 applications will emerge from creators and cultural innovators first rather than mass adoption, creating a 'cream skimming' model where creators aggregate audiences on Web2 platforms (Twitter, YouTube) and monetize directly through Web3 (Substack, NFTs, tokens), bypassing platform intermediaries and demonstrating value before network effects compound.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“the soft underbelly of web 2 is not i don't i think the adoption pattern like if for web 2 the adoption pattern was get a whole bunch of users this is sort of ben thompson's kind of theory aggregation theory get 100 million users and then layer on monetization i i think web 3 is going to be the opposite which is the way that it's going to start with the creators um and the soft underbelly of web 2 is that the the off the take rates are anywhere from zero to you know like 50”

0.48

Mobile adoption faced skepticism because people dismissed the idea that anyone would pay $1,000 for a phone; what critics missed was that a smartphone is actually a supercomputer with internet connectivity worth $1,000, not just a phone, demonstrating how new technologies require reframing value propositions rather than comparing to old categories.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“the idea of people paying a thousand dollars for a phone just seemed kind of crazy of course what they weren't thinking through was i think what they underestimated is first it's not a phone it's a super computer internet connects a super computer right which is worth a thousand dollars and secondly this is this is the hardest this is the most important thing with computing new computing waves is is there there was this exponential improvement curve that it went on okay”

0.48

The problem is not the internet itself but Web2's specific implementation with ads, algorithmic feeds, and corporate extraction; Substack proved this by enabling writers to make $1M/year on the internet—something previously thought impossible—by removing intermediaries and enabling direct subscriptions.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“it's not the problem is not the internet the problem is web too the problem is we we put in between the writers and their audience algorithmic feeds and you know and and ads and that was not a good and and companies that decided to take almost all the money right so spotify the statistic i just i like is that they i think they it's on their website”

0.48

Regulatory environment shifted negatively with the new administration (toward end of 2021), but a16z is addressing this with 10+ policy specialists. Regulatory acceptance will ultimately depend on proving societal benefit through real-world examples (musicians, creators, developers whose lives improved via Web3)

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“the way i kind of think about this there's many many kind of layers to this um there's specific kind of you know legal and regulatory kind of tactical level stuff and we have now at our at a c crypto 10 people who work on that like we very heavily invest in that area”

0.46

The majority of Web2 companies will eventually integrate tokens and Web3 primitives as the default, making the distinction between 'crypto funds' and 'traditional tech funds' irrelevant, just as the distinction between 'internet funds' and 'non-internet funds' became irrelevant by 2010

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Chris Dixon

“i think that look i think if we're right if i think the three of us probably agree on this if we all if we're right that future internet products are created in the web3 mold and they and the value accrual happens through tokens um then the rest of the world is going to want to they're going to want to follow that they're going to want to follow where that value on the internet is created and if it's i believe most of the value in the future of the internet will be created through tokens and and i think again a correlate to that would be most financial institutions interested in internet value creation will want to buy tokens and so i think it will spread not only from the venture side but i think that's how also the you know the broader institutional side um the banks and the hedge funds and all sorts of other other folks like that um so yeah i mean look i think i think there's probably i think it'll be a much slower to affect enterprise software”

0.45

Loot is a fascinating NFT experiment by Dom Hoffmann that emphasizes composability and enables community participation like 'stone soup'—providing base inventory items and letting the community build games, stories, and utilities on top, with variations like SyntheticLoot and MoreLoot testing different tradeoffs between financialization and accessibility.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“i'm sure you followed the loot loot stuff that dom hoffman did i think is fascinating and that you know a couple of interesting things he does you know one is the you know sort of the composability it's the the first loot drop is just the inventories of these imagined characters and he's it's almost like my analogy i use is if you know ernest hemingway just released the first page of his book and then had the audience write the rest or something right it's very it's very um provocative to to like leave the rest undone”

0.45

Turntable.fm was killed because music labels refused to grant licensing and innovation partners, treating Web2 as a threat rather than opportunity; Web3 allows musicians to bypass labels entirely and go direct to fans through NFTs, making label permission irrelevant and creating a new distribution paradigm.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“i had a friend uh who started if you remember turntable turntable fm if you guys remember i remember it was really it was a really cool app that was um kind of music avatar experience anyone can get up on stage and dj and you'd listen to in the background just be kind of a little community um and he i saw him years later and it uh you know he'd given up because the music labels just wouldn't they just wouldn't give him the licensing he tried to pay them he tried to cut deals they just don't want to”

0.26

Blockchains are not just computers but computers-plus-communities-plus-economies, combining computer science, game theory, human economics, culture, and media in ways that make them endlessly interesting unlike any other domain

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Chris Dixon

“a blockchain is not just a computer it is a computer in the sense that it runs code and stores information but it's also a community and a network right so you have this human aspect to it you have economics you have game theory”

0.22

Non-fungible tokens represent the majority (~95%) of the real-world economic value because most real assets (computers, Pepsi bottles, clothing, art) are unique, not fungible like money; fungible assets (cash) exist but are a minority; therefore non-fungible should dominate the tokenized economy reflecting real-world asset composition.

causalspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“our friend adapter labs likes to say most of the world is non-fungible so he you know you can debate this but he believes sort of non-fungible will be in the end be sort of 95 of the tokens in the world just simply because it'll look like the real world where you have you know i'm sitting here i have a computer that's an object i have a pepsi that's an object and we have money too i have fungible stuff too but it's not the kind of majority of the world”

0.19

VR (Oculus) was invested in by Dixon in 2013 with the belief it would be 3 years away, but it took much longer; it's now finally reaching the inflection point and will be 'really big' in the next 2-3 years despite the decade-long delay

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Chris Dixon

“i think vr is a good example where i think you know we invested i led our investment in oculus in 2013 and i thought it was three years away i think it's actually right around the corner right now i think it's about to really kind of get really big and it's finally there and people are underestimating it but it took longer so usually my this is my mistake like before i went and started a crypto fund i did a kind of full personal audit”

0.17

Enterprise software adoption of blockchain/crypto will be slower than consumer adoption because 85% of enterprises still use on-premise software rather than SaaS, creating structural inertia; however, consumer internet value creation will increasingly flow through tokens, making this the mainstream business model.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“i think there's probably i think it'll be a much slower to affect enterprise software and i mean enterprise software i think it's like 15 of enterprises use sas software today and the rest is still on premise so it's just a slower moving area”

0.17

Ethereum (not just as a price, but as a network community) feels healthy and is building interesting things across many layers (infrastructure, applications, DAOs), making it the healthiest blockchain network by community composition and architectural design

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Chris Dixon

“ethereum on the other hand is a great example where to me it feels like a city it's a very kind of beautiful community the people are building interesting things on top many different layers um a lot of the blockchain world is like that ethereum's probably the most the the healthiest network”

0.13

A16z operates with a 'bat signal' philosophy of attracting talented technologists away from big tech companies (Google, Amazon) who are tired of ad targeting and want to work on something meaningful; the firm employs 30+ crypto team members and hundreds of portfolio companies with thousands of open roles, creating a recruitment pipeline for Web3-interested engineers.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 1/4· Chris Dixon

“i want to put up the bat signal i want to put up the bat signal and say if you're at google or at amazon and you believe the internet can be a better better better place than it is today and you don't want to spend your life you know on ad targeting there's an alternative and you can come you can come start a company uh and you know we're always wanting to meet entrepreneurs and potentially fund them or you can come join a company we have hundreds probably thousands of openings in our portfolio”