What this covers

This is a conversation between Times Opinion deputy editor Patrick Healey and columnist Tressie McMillan Cottom about how Donald Trump used gender in the 2024 campaign. Healey mostly supplies the campaign-trail evidence: Trump's appearances on podcasts hosted by Joe Rogan, Ben Shapiro and Tucker Carlson, aimed at male voters' grievances, and the ad line "Kamala Harris is for they/them and Donald Trump is for you." Cottom supplies the structural explanation and admits she underestimated how well masculine messaging would work among Latino men, Black men, and across class lines that usually sort voters.

Her explanation starts with economics. She cites Nobel laureate Claudia Goldin on how changes that made the economy fairer for racial minorities also made it harder along gender lines, as women gained in education and wages. Men then looked for other ways to be men. Cottom describes this as two trains heading toward each other: wage and status competition on one side, an online vacuum for masculinity on the other. She argues the same displacement is happening across the globalized West, which is why strongman politics is rising in other countries too.

The conversation also takes up the mechanics of the internet and the Overton window. Cottom says Trump and Elon Musk have removed the shame that once constrained extreme views, and that algorithms amplify binaries and give excluded men a sense of belonging. She contends that online authenticity is always performed, which Trump grasps intuitively. Healey points to the Pennsylvania "fight, fight, fight" moment, which many voters read as his real self, and to Trump's reversal on Caitlyn Jenner and bathrooms as evidence of transactional flexibility. Cottom counters that trans panic is manufactured, not a stable public view.

The most contested turns come near the end. Cottom argues that the left trying to out-man Trump could be its undoing, because his masculinity depends on demoralizing government. She also says strategy and the communication of strength cannot be separated, and that building a party able to produce candidates like Bill Clinton requires hard tradeoffs.

Sharpest takeaway

Trump's political success relies on weaponizing gender and masculinity as a more effective organizing tool than race, using performance and content creation to mainstream extreme views while simultaneously shifting cultural perception of what constitutes the political center.

  • Gender messaging cut across traditional political divides (race, class) more effectively than racial appeals in 2024
  • Trump rebranded negativity (boorishness, cruelty, strength without empathy) as positive masculine traits rather than hiding them
  • Internet algorithms and economic anxiety created a vacuum for masculinity that Trump and Elon Musk exploit by offering scapegoats and community

The claims · ranked69 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

Feminist economist Claudia Goldin's macroeconomic work shows that everything which made the economy more fair and accessible for racial minorities also made it harder for women, particularly women of color, creating economic pressure on men to find new ways to be men as women make gains in education and wages.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I've been reading a lot of like macroeconomic work especially done by like feminist Economist Claudia golden a Harvard Economist who won the Nobel has done this work for all of her career and one of the things that strikes me from Claudia's work that I think is really relevant In This Moment is that everything that made the economy a little bit more fair a little bit more accessible for like racial minorities also made it harder along gender lines it made it harder as women particularly women women of color make these roads into the economy as they start to make gains in education and in wages that puts a lot of pressure on men to find some other way to be men”

0.80

Feminist economist Claudia Goldin, a Harvard economist who won the Nobel Prize, has shown through her research that everything that made the economy more fair and accessible for racial minorities also made it harder along gender lines, as women—particularly women of color—make gains in education and wages, which puts pressure on men to find other ways to be men.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I've been reading a lot of like macroeconomic work especially done by like feminist Economist Claudia golden a Harvard Economist who won the Nobel has done this work for all of her career and one of the things that strikes me from Claudia's work that I think is really relevant In This Moment is that everything that made the economy a little bit more fair a little bit more accessible for like racial minorities also made it harder along gender lines it made it harder as women particularly women women of color make these roads into the economy as they start to make gains in education and in wages that puts a lot of pressure on men to find some other way to be men”

0.75

Trump has 'de fanged the shame' that used to constrain more extreme views on gender and masculinity, normalizing what were previously marginal views by bringing them into mainstream discourse and shifting the Overton window toward more extremism, and Elon Musk has done similar work on social media platforms.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“he has absolutely de fanged the shame that I think used to kind of constrain some of these more extreme views it is not that they have ever been eradicated but they came with a lot of social stigma and potential risk of like social status and reputation and Prestige if you espouse them so they flourished on the margins of the discourse that's where the internet really excels tapping into those margins expanding them sort of Shifting what you know political scientists would call sort of like the Overton window right keeps shifting it further and further towards more extremism”

0.73

There is no real authenticity online, only performances of authenticity, yet people crave glimpses of the 'real you,' and Trump understands this dynamic intuitively and at speed faster than most people recognize as natural.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“one of the things that you develop a sense for when you understand the sort of like incentives of authenticity online is that there is no real authenticity online there is only ever a performance of authenticity yet people crave it people crave a sense that they got a glimpse of the real you and the thing is Donald Trump is as embedded in that economy and that culture as I am and I think he understood intuitively at a speed that most regular people maybe see as natural but I just think it was a facility he had”

0.73

Trump spent significant time during the 2024 campaign courting the manosphere by appearing on podcasts with Joe Rogan, Ben Shapiro, and Tucker Carlson to speak directly to male American voters across different ages, targeting their frustrations and grievances.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“Donald Trump spent a lot of time during the 2024 campaign really courting What's called the manosphere going on these podcasts with Joe Rogan and Ben Shapiro and Tucker Carlson and trying to talk directly to male American voters of different ages and really zeroing in on what he saw as their frustrations their Grievances”

0.69

When Trump was asked about Caitlyn Jenner using a bathroom, he said 'Caitlyn Jenner can use whatever bathroom she wants', but three years later he reversed this position during his presidency, showing he is willing to flip-flop on trans issues to match voter preferences.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“I remember that moment where he was asked well how would you feel about Caitlyn Jenner you know a trans woman using a bathroom and and Donald Trump said you know Caitlyn Jenner can use whatever bathroom she wants and exactly I remember hearing from a lot of people after that when I was a reporter saying so where is Trump on this does Trump have hate in his heart for Trans people for lgbtq people or is it all about that transactional Trump Rel relationship with voters”

0.69

Donald Trump is very comfortable in his own skin being a certain kind of man, and for whatever reason, a bare majority of Americans like that about him.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“I think Donald Trump is very comfortable in his own skin being a a certain kind of man and for whatever reason a bare majority of Americans kind of like that yes they do”

0.69

Donald Trump spent significant time during the 2024 campaign courting the manosphere by appearing on podcasts with Joe Rogan, Ben Shapiro, and Tucker Carlson to talk directly to male American voters about their frustrations and grievances.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“Donald Trump spent a lot of time during the 2024 campaign really courting What's called the manosphere going on these podcasts with Joe Rogan and Ben Shapiro and Tucker Carlson and trying to talk directly to male American voters of different ages and really zeroing in on what he saw as their frustrations their Grievances”

0.69

Comedians like Bill Burr and Dave Chappelle built careers on crude, boarish humor targeting women while performing ignorance about underlying power dynamics (like female athletes earning less due to market mechanisms), creating a cultural template that Trump understood and exploited.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“a lot of these standup comedians whether it's you know Bill Burr and she starts bitching going like I don't understand how come female athletes don't make as much as male professional athletes right and all of these men had to sit there and act like they didn't know what the answer was”

0.69

Trump's assassination attempt moment in Pennsylvania when he stood up and raised his fist saying 'fight fight fight' was perceived by many voters not as masculine performance but as his true self appearing in a crisis moment.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“when that assassination attempt happened in Pennsylvania and the way that he stood up and he put his fist in the air and he said fight fight fight and a lot of Voters didn't feel that was a performance of masculinity they felt like that's a moment when your true self appears it was a huge moment that was very INSP iring to a lot of Americans”

0.69

Most Americans were not upset about trans people in bathrooms four years ago; a decade before Trump's presidency, most believed trans bathroom access was acceptable, demonstrating that current trans panic is manufactured rather than reflecting stable public opinion.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I just have find it really hard to believe that most people prior to like four years ago were that upset about trans people in bathrooms we had in fact had a decade prior to that where most people thought oh yeah that's good yeah that's fine let's put the signage”

0.69

Donald Trump previously said Caitlyn Jenner could use whatever bathroom she wanted, but when larger electoral rewards emerged from taking the opposite position, he flipped to accommodate transactional voter demands, demonstrating his priority is voter preference alignment over principle.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“even Donald Trump though I mean I remember that moment where he was asked well how would you feel about Caitlyn Jenner you know a trans woman using a bathroom and and Donald Trump said you know Caitlyn Jenner can use whatever bathroom she wants”

0.69

Joe Rogan became an economic elite by tapping into masculine grievance energy and alternative media positioning, demonstrating the economic viability of the masculine messaging that Trump and Musk later weaponized at scale.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I mean it arguably helped make Joe Rogan you know an economic Elite right just sort of like tapping into that energy”

0.69

The internet excels at tapping into marginal views, expanding them, and shifting the Overton window further toward extremism by amplifying previously stigmatized discourse.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“that's where the internet really excels tapping into those margins expanding them sort of Shifting what you know political scientists would call sort of like the Overton window right keeps shifting it further and further towards more extremism”

0.68

The internet and its algorithms love binaries (male/female, good/bad) and are designed to juice/amplify those binaries, allowing them to create communities and a sense of belonging for people who feel excluded from the regular economy.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“the internet comes along and says I can give you an answer for that I can build a community around that rudge around that victimhood algorithms love binaries and so a good binary like male female man woman good bad the algorithm is really set up to juice that and so it can create this sense that there is a place for you when the economy doesn't have a place for you”

0.68

The Trump campaign advertisement stating 'Kamala Harris is for they them and Donald Trump is for you' demonstrated powerful messaging that weaponized gender and gender identity politics in the campaign.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“that ad that we saw during the campaign about how kamla Harris is for they them and Donald Trump is for you that one really got me that had such power”

0.65

The campaign ad stating 'Kamala Harris is for they/them and Donald Trump is for you' had significant power as a political messaging tool conveying gender-based criticism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“that ad that we saw during the campaign about how kamla Harris is for they them and Donald Trump is for you that one really got me that had such power”

0.63

The intersection of the internet economy and economic competition created a vacuum for masculinity at the same time it created more competition for wages and status that men traditionally use to define their masculinity, which Cottom describes as a crisis of two trains barreling toward each other.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“oh in two words I'm going to say it's the economy and it's the internet the intersection of those two things as it turned out created a vacuum for masculinity at the same time it created more competition for the wages and the status that men use to define their masculinity this to me is a crisis of like two trains you know barreling towards each other”

0.63

The left trying to beat Trump on masculinity would possibly be the end of the left because Trump's version of masculinity depends on the demoralization of the role of government, whereas the left's politics rely on the belief that government has a role to play in making people's lives better.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I think the left trying to beat Donald Trump on this issue would possibly be the end of the left and I will tell you why I don't think not only can they not win they should not compete in this Arena Donald Trump's vision and version of masculinity depends on the demoralization of the role of government it is to say that there's no other way to oh I don't know provide child care for families except to send women back into the home when of course we can fund daycares right other ways Y and then men may not feel nearly as demasculate at it but if you can erase the role of the government in making people's lives better then sure your only solution is the strongman Trope the left's politics rely on the fact that there is a role for government to play in making people's lives better if you double down on the only people who can save you are the Cowboys of the internet and you try to out Cowboy Donald Trump Trump you are just reinforcing the belief system that the government has no role here and if you concede that then there's no more left”

0.62

Many Americans, especially in focus groups, don't want explanations or detailed justifications of policy; they want action and evidence of strength and confidence from their leaders.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“a lot of these voters and a lot of men in America they don't want to hear explainers they don't want to get explanations they want action most Americans aren't thinking about whether this is an authentic masculinity or a performative masculinity it's just masculinity in their mind”

0.62

Building party infrastructure to allow transformative candidates like Barack Obama or Bill Clinton to emerge requires difficult decisions and tradeoffs at the level of party strategy and leadership support.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“what kind of tradeoffs are you willing to make as a party to make that possible”

0.61

This dynamic of economic displacement for men is happening across the globalized West, which is why similar political waves favoring strong-man politics are occurring in other countries.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“that is happening and that's happening across like the globalized West which is why I think we see similar political waves happening in other countries as we have happening here”

0.60

Governance requires both detailed plans and strategy AND the communication of strength, collectivity, and identity, and these cannot be sacrificed for one another—the left's error has been treating strategy and communication as separable.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“there is something I think to the act of governance which absolutely requires detailed plans and strategy and the communication of strength of collectivity of identity and what we should be learning is that you cannot sacrifice one for the other I think we don't like that idea because as you point out that takes some really hard decisions at the level of party infrastructure who do you support who do you put forward how do you build an infrastructure that allows for a bar Obama to emerge a Bill Clinton to emerge and what kind of tradeoffs are you willing to make as a party to make that possible”

0.59

Tressie McMillan Cottom underestimated the efficacy of gender-based messaging in the 2024 election and was surprised how well masculinity and Trump's performance of it worked across typically strange political bedfellows including Latino male voters, Black male voters, and across class divides that normally sort voters by political party and ideology.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I underestimated the efficacy of messages about gender in this election and in how Trump continues to use them so successfully for governance I was surprised how well this messaging worked across what I would consider typically strange political bedfellows Latino male voters black male voters it worked up and down the class divides that normally sort voters by political party and ideology”

0.59

Trump is engaged in a novel and unique form of rebranding compared to how the Republican Party has historically rebranded unpopular ideas: rather than liberal-washing ideas by deemphasizing their divisiveness, Trump doubles down on negative qualities like boorishness and cruelty, rebranding them as good, and this approach could only have worked with gender rather than race.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“the GOP the Republican party has actually been quite good at rebranding things politically for quite some time so Trump in one way is like just doing that thing right...when the right used to do that before Trump they were sort of liberal washing these unpopular ideas right they were making them more palatable to the general voter by deemphasizing how divisive these ideas were what Trump has done particularly with masculinity is different he is doubling down on these negative qualies boorishness cruelty you know strength without empathy instead of rebranding that to make them more palatable for the general voter he is rebranding boorishness as good and is doing that so successfully that feels new and unique and something that could have only worked with gender in a way that I don't think would have worked with racism”

0.59

Tressie McMillan Cottom was surprised that gender messaging worked more effectively than racial messaging across typically divided political constituencies including Latino male voters, Black male voters, and across class divides in the 2024 election, with masculinity functioning as a more powerful political tool than race.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I underestimated the efficacy of messages about gender in this election and in how Trump continues to use them so successfully for governance I was surprised how well this messaging worked across what I would consider typically strange political bedfellows Latino male voters black male voters it worked up and down the class divides that normally sort voters by political party and ideology in many ways masculinity and Trump's performance of it and his branding of it as content as political messaging has worked as well if not better than race as a political tool”

0.59

The intersection of economic disruption and internet algorithms created a vacuum for masculinity: economic changes reduced the traditional sources of male status and identity (wages, job security) while algorithms amplified binary (male/female, good/bad) framing that creates community for displaced men.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“the intersection of those two things as it turned out created a vacuum for masculinity at the same time it created more competition for the wages and the status that men use to define their masculinity this to me is a crisis of like two trains you know barreling towards each other and I think Trump and Elon are particularly skilled at manipulating those because they were produced by them”

0.57

Prior to four years ago, most Americans were not upset about trans people in bathrooms, and in fact had spent a decade prior supporting trans bathroom access with appropriate signage.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Patrick Healey

“I just have find it really hard to believe that most people prior to like four years ago were that upset about trans people in bathrooms we had in fact had a decade prior to that where most people thought oh yeah that's good yeah that's fine let's put the signage”

0.57

The binary gender executive order declaring only two genders (male and female) and trans athlete bans reflect what the majority society wants, suggesting Trump is following rather than leading on these issues.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Patrick Healey

“I mean how much is society actually already there and I'm thinking really about the two genders male and female executive order that he put out and a lot of what he has been doing on trans athletes and women's sport I mean it it very much can be argued that the majority of society wants these things and that Trump is in fact kind of following as opposed to Leading them toward direction”

0.57

When Trump blamed a plane collision in Washington DC on DEI (diversity and inclusion hiring at the FAA), he was leveraging gender-based criticism more effectively than race-based criticism, because while DEI was broadly construed as addressing race and racism, it also included women and disproportionately benefited white women, and the pilot being dismissed in this case was a woman (Captain Rebecca Lobok).

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“when Donald Trump came out I speak to you this morning in an hour of Anguish for a nation and blamed that plane collision and crash in Washington DC on Dei the initiative is part of the faa's diversity and inclusion hiring plan...I don't think so I don't think so I think it's just the opposite at first I was like you know give me a break what is he doing this is so gross is so cynical and then I stepped back...and this is about shrewd tactics”

0.57

Over the past 15 years, Americans developed sophisticated language and critical capacity to discuss race and racism, but did not develop equivalent depth in discussing gender and gender discrimination, leaving gender politics more vulnerable to manipulation.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I actually think that de in that context while it sort of primed some like racial Energies was really doing its most effective work as a broad dismissal of women and I think one of the reasons that works is because we worked really hard especially the last like 15 years to develop and deepen the repertoire that Americans have to talk about race and racism I will be honest with you I'm not sure that we did as good a job of developing that capacity when it came to gender”

0.57

Trump's rebranding strategy differs from previous Republican rebranding efforts because instead of liberal-washing unpopular ideas by deemphasizing their divisiveness, Trump doubles down on negative qualities like boorishness, cruelty, and strength without empathy, rebranding them as positive masculine traits.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“the GOP the Republican party has actually been quite good at rebranding things politically for quite some time so Trump in one way is like just doing that thing right using to Rebrand is really good at that make America great is a I think an example but what is different is that when the right used to do that before Trump they were sort of liberal washing these unpopular ideas right they were making them more palatable to the general voter by deemphasizing how divisive these ideas were what Trump has done particularly with masculinity is different he is doubling down on these negative qualies boorishness cruelty you know strength without empathy instead of rebranding that to make them more palatable for the general voter he is rebranding boorishness as good”

0.56

Strong man politics works by offering men a scapegoat—women, people of color, and minorities—while also claiming the government has been protecting these groups, creating a dual enemy narrative that justifies both removing those groups from power and delegitimizing the government itself.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“what are the things that this sort of strong man politics does by giving people a scapegoat giving men a scapegoat is that it says not only are women the enemy are people of color and minorities the enemy but the government is protecting them so not only do we need to sort of like push these people out but we need to delegitimize and gut the government that made them possible”

0.55

Trump's ability to pull audiences and shift perception of what the majority believes is more consequential than whether his views are authentic, because internet culture misleads people about majority opinion and algorithms shape what voters believe is the dominant belief system.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“his ability to pull an audience can convince constituents that oh everybody thinks this way everybody is upset about trans people right and what we kind of know from social psychology is that most of us will kind of go along with what we believe is a dominant belief system the problem is that internet culture and our current media environment can mislead us about what the majority of people believe it can shape our attitudes in a way that tells us that what we believe is normal by redefining what's normal”

0.55

Democrats talking about needing to go on Joe Rogan or into red areas and showing they're tough and confident are performing a certain kind of masculinity, which is a losing strategy because Trump isn't performing—he appears authentically masculine to his supporters.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“I hear the left and Democrats talking about how we need to go on Joe Rogan and we need to go into red areas and we need to show that we're tough and confident sometimes I wonder if that's Democrats performing a certain kind of masculinity and that Trump kind of isn't beat in this regard if young men and a lot of men just see him as that”

0.52

Most Americans don't distinguish between authentic and performative masculinity; they simply want someone who appears strong and capable, making voters' actual perception of Trump's character more important than whether it is genuinely masculine.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“most Americans aren't thinking about whether this is an authentic masculinity or a performative masculinity it's just masculinity in their mind and it's what they ultimately want”

0.52

No Democratic candidate is going to out-cowboy Donald Trump on the strongman narrative, making that a losing strategy, and Democrats trying to explain the positive aspects of policies like DEI or the federal government to voters who don't want explanations will fail because most Americans want action, not explainers.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“no Democrat is going to out Cowboy Donald Trump that's a losing issue at the same time when you're explaining you're losing you know Democrats who are trying to explain well this is the good part of Dei or this is the good part of the federal government a lot of these voters and a lot of men in America they don't want to hear explainers they don't want to get explanations they want action most Americans aren't thinking about whether this is an authentic masculinity or a performative masculinity it's just masculinity in their mind and it's what they ultimately want”

0.52

Trump wants America to look like Donald Trump—he wants to brand America the way he has branded hotels, a fake college, and a TV show, controlling his political legacy and how he is remembered by extracting resources from his administration for personal political and economic gain while controlling the memory of what type of politician and leader he was.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I think Trump wants for America what Trump has won it from any of his other business dealings which at the 10,000 foot view is he wants them to look like Donald Trump he wants to Brand America in the way that he branded hotels branded a fake college right the way he branded a TV show and I think what that looks like is controlling how he is remembered so like I'm paying a lot of attention to how much attention he's paying to cultural institutions archists and libraries and schools and I ities and the Arts because what I think he ultimately wants to do is to extract as much from his administration for political and economic gain as he can and then to control the memory of what type of politician and leader he was I think he is setting himself up to be remembered and perceived as this inevitable political figure you know cut from the cloth of Ronald Reagan but fundamentally bigger than Ronald Reagan and then he wants to make a lot of money while he does it”

0.52

Over the last 15 years, Americans have developed and deepened the repertoire to talk about race and racism, but have not done as good a job developing that capacity when it comes to gender, partly because there was a belief that feminism had already won that war and the work was already done.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“we worked really hard especially the last like 15 years to develop and deepen the repertoire that Americans have to talk about race and racism I will be honest with you I'm not sure that we did as good a job of developing that capacity when it came to gender and I don't don't want to critique feminism as like like it's just one big group but I think we thought we'd already won that war maybe we'd already done that work and so we didn't continue to do it in these really deep ways”

0.52

If gender-based resentment messaging pushes some women back out of the labor market and into the home, that benefits even men who disagree with Trump because it reduces competition for male workers and improves male economic prospects, creating economic alignments between men who may not agree culturally but have a shared interest.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“if it means it pushes some women back out of the labor market and back into into the home that benefits even men who disagree with Trump frankly right so it creates these alignments between people who may not agree on things culturally but who have a shared economic interest”

0.52

There is no real authenticity online—only performances of authenticity—but people crave a sense that they got a glimpse of the real person, and Donald Trump understood intuitively how to give that image because he is a masterful influencer.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“one of the things that you develop a sense for when you understand the sort of like incentives of authenticity online is that there is no real authenticity online there is only ever a performance of authenticity yet people crave it people crave a sense that they got a glimpse of the real you and the thing is Donald Trump is as embedded in that economy and that culture as I am and I think he understood intuitively at a speed that most regular people maybe see as natural but I just think it was a facility he had for understanding the moment he gave the image he knew to give because he is a masterful influencer”

0.52

When actors like Tom Cruise or Harrison Ford play hyper-masculine characters over long periods, the distance between the person and the character gets very short, and the instincts become shaped by both the danger of the moment and the responsibility of creating that image. Trump has played the character of Donald Trump for so long that his instincts have been shaped by both factors.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“let me tell you something you ask someone like like Tom Cruz who has played this sort of hyper masculine character for all of his career you know any actor who is like their main you know character they have played I think of something like uh Harrison Ford or John Wayne character who has played this sort of like iconic classtic masculine figure in popular culture and what they would tell you is that over time the distance between the person and the character gets very short yep and I think that if you play that character for as long as Donald Trump has played the character of Donald Trump that yes your instincts may be shaped by the danger of the moment but those instincts have also been shaped by how much you feel responsible for creating that image”

0.52

The Democratic Party needs to find candidates like Barack Obama or Bill Clinton who have a natural comfort in their own skin and a way in the world that voters enjoy and want to wake up to every morning, rather than getting too deep in strategy and tactics.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“when I hear Democrats and talk about it in some of the focus groups talk about well can we nominate a woman as the party's nominee in 2028 or when will be the next time or how do we win men back I I find myself thinking they're they're too deep in the Playbook of strategy you know they're they're too deep in tactics that ultimately you need to find candidates whether it's say yes a Barack Obama or a Bill Clinton who have a natural way in the world that enough voters enjoy and want to wake up to every morning and that can be a woman that can be a man you know in the white house but someone who has just more of a comfort in their own skin”

0.52

The government-is-the-enemy message is more politically effective because it resonates with people who feel personally vulnerable and abandoned, which is psychologically more powerful than abstract arguments about tax dollars.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“not only do we need to sort of like push these people out but we need to delegitimize and gut the government that made them possible so it doesn't happen again it is I think very important to point out a really effective political tool it says that the government is the enemy not just because it what was your tax dollars you know all that smoke what is really working and mobilizing people is that oh it's been the government that's been shielding the people that are making me lose right so it's super powerful for delegitimizing the government”

0.52

Trump wants America to look like Donald Trump, using the presidency to brand America the way he branded hotels, a fake university, and a TV show, controlling memory and perception of his legacy.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I think Trump wants for America what Trump has won it from any of his other business dealings which at the 10,000 foot view is he wants them to look like Donald Trump he wants to Brand America in the way that he branded hotels branded a fake college right the way he branded a TV show”

0.52

Democrats discussing whether they can nominate a woman as presidential candidate in 2028 are stuck in tactical playbook thinking rather than focusing on finding candidates with natural comfort in their own skin and identity like Barack Obama or Bill Clinton.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“when I hear Democrats and talk about it in some of the focus groups talk about well can we nominate a woman as the party's nominee in 2028 or when will be the next time or how do we win men back I I find myself thinking they're they're too deep in the Playbook of strategy you know they're too deep in tactics that ultimately you need to find candidates whether it's say yes a Barack Obama or a Bill Clinton who have a natural way in the world that enough voters enjoy and want to wake up to every morning and that can be a woman that can be a man”

0.52

Democratic governance requires detailed plans and strategy, but political success requires simultaneously communicating strength, collectivity, and identity, and sacrificing either governance detail or symbolic strength guarantees political defeat.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“there is something I think to the act of governance which absolutely requires detailed plans and strategy and the communication of strength of collectivity of identity and what we should be learning is that you cannot sacrifice one for the other”

0.52

Voters want candidates who have comfort in their own skin and a clear identity, regardless of gender, and Trump succeeds because he projects this comfort and voters like waking up to him as president.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“someone who has just more of a comfort in their own skin I think Donald Trump is very comfortable in his own skin being a a certain kind of man and for whatever reason a bare majority of Americans kind of like that”

0.52

Elon Musk is a product of the internet economy who understands how affect and outrage drive algorithms, which in turn drive profit based on attention and emotional engagement on platforms.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“Elon Musk is a production of the internet economy he understands how affect and outrage drives the algorithm which in turn drives profit based on attention and our emotions which we dump into these platforms”

0.52

Trump has de-fanged the social shame that previously constrained extreme views about women and gender, making previously marginalized positions mainstream by removing the social cost of expressing them.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“he has absolutely de fanged the shame that I think used to kind of constrain some of these more extreme views it is not that they have ever been eradicated but they came with a lot of social stigma and potential risk of like social status and reputation and Prestige if you espouse them so they flourished on the margins of the discourse that's where the internet really excels tapping into those margins expanding them sort of Shifting what you know political scientists would call sort of like the Overton window right keeps shifting it further and further towards more extremism”

0.52

Similar political waves of masculine identity politics are occurring across the globalized West in other countries, not just the United States, indicating structural rather than uniquely American causes.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“and that's happening across like the globalized West which is why I think we see similar political waves happening in other countries as we have happening here”

0.52

Donald Trump understands the panic that can be induced when the economy is captured by a small group of people, making workers vulnerable to political messaging that scapegoats others for economic insecurity.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“Donald Trump brings to this relationship that he understands the sort of like Panic that can be induced when the economy has been captured by a small group of people and it can make workers vulnerable to this sort of political messaging”

0.52

The 'strong man politics' gender framing provides scapegoats (women, people of color, minorities) and positions government as the enemy protecting them, making delegitimizing government itself a political tool to prevent future equality gains.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“the sort of the tax on government what are the things that this sort of strong man politics does by giving people a scapegoat giving men a scapegoat is that it says not only are women the enemy are people of color and minorities the enemy but the government is protecting them so not only do we need to sort of like push these people out but we need to delegitimize and gut the government that made them possible so it doesn't happen again”

0.52

Actors who play hyper-masculine characters for extended careers (Tom Cruise, Harrison Ford, John Wayne archetypes) experience shrinking distance between their persona and actual self over time, with instincts becoming shaped by both the moment's demands and responsibility for maintaining the image.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“you ask someone like like Tom Cruz who has played this sort of hyper masculine character for all of his career you know any actor who is like their main you know character they have played I think of something like uh Harrison Ford or John Wayne character who has played this sort of like iconic classtic masculine figure in popular culture and what they would tell you is that over time the distance between the person and the character gets very short yep and I think that if you play that character for as long as Donald Trump has played the character of Donald Trump that yes your instincts may be shaped by the danger of the moment but those instincts have also been shaped by how much you feel responsible for creating that image”

0.52

Government can provide solutions to the masculinity crisis through funding daycare and other services, but doing so requires explaining governance which voters don't want to hear; instead they want action and performance.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“when you're explaining you're losing you know Democrats who are trying to explain well this is the good part of Dei or this is the good part of the federal government a lot of these voters and a lot of men in America they don't want to hear explainers they don't want to get explanations they want action most Americans aren't thinking about whether this is an authentic masculinity or a performative masculinity it's just masculinity in their mind and it's what they ultimately want”

0.52

Even men who disagree with Trump's policies can benefit from his gender-based messaging if it pushes women out of the labor market and back into the home, creating economic alignment between ideologically diverse men around shared material interests.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“if it means it pushes some women back out of the labor market and back into into the home that benefits even men who disagree with Trump frankly right so it creates these alignments between people who may not agree on things culturally but who have a shared economic interest”

0.50

Comedians like Bill Burr and Dave Chappelle have made their stock and trade out of being boorish or crude, performing content that relies on making people act like they don't know the answer to straightforward questions, and Trump understands and taps into this form of entertainment value.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“a lot of these standup comedians whether it's you know Bill Burr and she starts bitching going like I don't understand how come female athletes don't make as much as male professional athletes right and all of these men had to sit there and act like they didn't know what the answer was or Dave Chappelle...a number of men who have made you know their stock and trade in kind of being borish or being crude it's that kind of like entertainment value that I think Trump kind of understands and Taps into it's this gender part that Trump is trying to sell”

0.49

Trump's two-gender executive order and policies targeting trans athletes are not leading public opinion but following a minority view that Trump has made appear dominant through media manipulation, shifting voters' perception of what the majority believes.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Patrick Healey

“a lot of what he has been doing on trans athletes and women's sport I mean it it very much can be argued that the majority of society wants these things and that Trump is in fact kind of following as opposed to Leading them toward direction that says there are only two genders male and female”

0.48

At the assassination attempt in Pennsylvania in July, Trump stood up and put his fist in the air and said 'fight fight fight', and many voters, particularly men, did not see this as a performance of masculinity but as a moment when his 'true self' appeared, which was inspiring and suggested to them that this is the kind of man they want in charge of America.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“you know this there's been a lot of hand ringing about how the left might be able to speak to young men to talk about masculinity to understand it better but what I've heard certainly during the campaign from some of our focus groups men women they point to Trump back in July when that assassination attempt happened in Pennsylvania and the way that he stood up and he put his fist in the air and he said fight fight fight and a lot of Voters didn't feel that was a performance of masculinity they felt like that's a moment when your true self appears it was a huge moment that was very INSP iring to a lot of Americans and I and I think there were a lot of men who looked at him who said that's the kind of man that I want to have in charge of America”

0.48

The tools to change Trump's transactional political incentives exist but are currently undemocratically controlled by a small group of people who share Trump's political beliefs, making it difficult to shift his positions through incentive changes.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“if we were to look for a little bit of hope I would point to the fact that with transactions you can then change people's incentives and that means that that can happen it is just that right now the tools to change them are undemocratically controlled and that control is Con con with a very small group of people who right now share Donald Trump's political beliefs”

0.48

Building Democratic infrastructure that produces candidates like Barack Obama or Bill Clinton requires making hard tradeoffs and difficult decisions at the party level about resource allocation and candidate support.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“it takes some really hard decisions at the level of party infrastructure who do you support who do you put forward how do you build an infrastructure that allows for a bar Obama to emerge a Bill Clinton to emerge and what kind of tradeoffs are you willing to make as a party to make that possible”

0.48

If the Democratic Party focuses only on being better explainers of governance without addressing the symbolic and identity dimensions of politics, the party faces a long dark political night.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“if the Democratic party doubles down on just yet being the better explainers of governance to Americans then we are going into a long dark political night”

0.48

While Trump's transactionalism could theoretically allow policy reversal through changed incentives, control of the tools and levers to change those incentives is currently concentrated in a small group sharing Trump's political beliefs, making incentive-based reversal difficult.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“if we were to look for a little bit of hope I would point to the fact that with transactions you can then change people's incentives and that means that that can happen it is just that right now the tools to change them are undemocratically controlled and that control is Con con with a very small group of people who right now share Donald Trump's political beliefs”

0.47

Trump and Elon Musk are particularly skilled at manipulating the intersection of economic anxiety and internet culture because they were produced by these forces themselves—Trump understands the panic that can be induced when the economy is captured by a small group of people, making workers vulnerable to his political messaging, while Musk understands how affect and outrage drive algorithms which drive profit.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“I think Trump and Elon are particularly skilled at manipulating those because they were produced by them right Elon Musk is a production of the internet economy he understands how affect and outrage drives the algorithm which in turn drives profit based on attention and our emotions which we dump into these platforms I think Donald Trump brings to this relationship that he understands the sort of like Panic that can be induced when the economy has been captured by a small group of people and it can make workers vulnerable to this sort of political messaging”

0.47

When Trump blamed a plane collision in Washington DC on DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) initiatives within the FAA, this was initially perceived as cynical but reflected shrewd tactical understanding of how DEI messaging resonates with voters by dismissing both racial minorities and women, particularly targeting women pilots.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Patrick Healey

“when Donald Trump came out I speak to you this morning in an hour of Anguish for a nation and blamed that plane collision and crash in Washington DC on Dei the initiative is part of the faa's diversity and inclusion hiring plan which says diversity is integral to achieving faa's mission of ensuring safe and efficient travel I don't think so I don't think so I think it's just the opposite at first I was like you know give me a break what is he doing this is so gross is so cynical and then I stepped back and I thought I actually am a little surprised that they are that clever in in a way”

0.45

If the Democratic party continues to focus on being 'better explainers' of governance to Americans without addressing the need for authentic political figures, the party is heading into 'a long dark political night'.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“if the Democratic party doubles down on just yet being the better explainers of governance to Americans then we are going into a long dark political night”

0.42

Trump and Elon Musk go to the UFC to perform masculinity, a venue where they can present themselves to audiences as embodying strength and dominance.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Patrick Healey

“and that's why I think Donald Trump will continue to double down on it try how much is Donald Trump leading on gender and masculinity and how much is he actually following I mean how much is society actually already there and I'm thinking really about the two genders male and female executive order that he put out”

0.38

Gender identity and LGBTQ inclusion have become central to Democratic party identity in a way that makes the party vulnerable to backlash messaging that weaponizes these issues.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Patrick Healey

“when I'm a reporter saying so where is Trump on this does Trump have hate in his heart for Trans people for lgbtq people or is it all about that transactional Trump Rel relationship with voters”

0.26

Joe Rogan became an economic elite largely through tapping into and amplifying the energy of masculinity narratives and gender-based grievances.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Tressie McMillan Cottom

“it arguably helped make Joe Rogan you know an economic Elite right just sort of like tapping into that energy”