Will Ahmed - Optimizing Human Performance – [Founder’s Field Guide, EP. 39]
What this covers
In this Founder's Field Guide episode, Will Ahmed traces WHOOP from a 2011 business plan to a wearable common among professional athletes, a company that grew slowly before inflecting in recent years. He starts with how he narrowed the problem. Prospective customers describe problems well but specify solutions poorly, and he saw that the metrics mattering for training were measured during rest and sleep while the field fixated on exercise volume.
The physiology gets the most room. Ahmed defines HRV as the variation between heartbeats, a signal with a history stretching from 1980s Olympic powerlifters to the CIA's lie detection tests. It once required an electrocardiogram costing $20,000 to $30,000. He argues step count tracks strain poorly, and that seven hours in bed is not seven hours of sleep. He credits slow-wave sleep with most of the body's growth hormone production, a claim that is contested. Users cut back on alcohol after seeing what two drinks do to next-day recovery, and driven people like Navy SEALs use the device as permission to rest.
The business half covers deliberate exclusions: no screen, calls, or apps, a choice of Negative Scope Definition that he pairs with Full-Stack Control over hardware and algorithms. He explains why Fitbit won distribution but lost on retention, why big apparel brands stumbled, and why personal trainers were the quickest route to elite athletes. He also covers authentic partnerships and a forecast that continuous monitoring will replace the annual physical and shift spending toward prevention. He closes on separating a founder's self-worth from company results.
WHOOP's founder argues that continuous, recovery-focused physiological monitoring, delivered through a screenless wearable on a subscription model, can turn costly curative healthcare into cheaper preventive care.
- Optimal training depends on balancing strain against recovery, and recovery has been neglected relative to exercise metrics
- Continuous 24/7 wear and full control of the hardware-to-algorithm stack produce more accurate data than aggregating third-party devices
- Subscription economics and a deliberately narrow product scope let WHOOP iterate faster and resist competitors
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Seven hours in bed does not equal seven hours of sleep, because time in bed includes awake and light sleep, which contribute little to performance, while REM and slow-wave sleep are where most restorative work occurs.
“Seven hours in bed doesn't translate to seven hours of sleep.”
Prospective customers are very good at describing their problems but poor at specifying solutions, so the entrepreneur's job is to derive the solution from the stated problem rather than from the customer's requested features.
“I think that prospective customers are very good at describing their problems. I think that it's the entrepreneur's role to figure out the solutions to those problems.”
Users reduce alcohol consumption after seeing that even two drinks lead to a run-down recovery reading the next day, because alcohol is quite bad for autonomic nervous system function, and the device's apparent intelligence makes the lesson stick.
“you have two drinks, and then the next day WHOOP says you're run down”
Optimal training is fundamentally a balance between strain and recovery: a well-recovered body can absorb high strain, while a run-down body should take on less strain or none at all.
“my calculation was that the notion of optimal training was really just a balance between strain and recovery”
HRV has been used since the 1970s, including by 1980s Olympic powerlifters to set daily training loads, Tour de France cyclists to judge recovery, cardiologists to assess heart attack risk in former heart failure patients, and the CIA in lie detection testing.
“Olympic powerlifters were using heart rate variability in the '80s to determine how much weight they should lift on a given day”
Step count does not map to physiological strain, because a long walk on a run-down day inflates steps while a hard cycling or weightlifting session can yield few steps but high strain, and wrist motion may not reliably track steps at all.
“On a day where your body is run down, a perfectly reasonable thing to do might be to go for a long walk”
Heart rate variability is the variation in time between successive heartbeats, and higher variability indicates better balance between sympathetic (activating) and parasympathetic (calming) nervous system activity, which is why it works as a recovery signal.
“the more in balance your sympathetic and parasympathetic, the higher your heart rate variability”
Sports and exercise culture focused heavily on stress and strain while paying far less attention to recovery, even though overtraining and injury, the main threats to athlete availability, stem from inadequate recovery.
“there was a real focus in sports and in exercise, stress, and strain, but there was less of a focus on recovery”
Measuring HRV historically required an electrocardiogram costing roughly $20,000 to $30,000 in hospital equipment, which kept the metric out of mainstream use and motivated WHOOP's aim to make it cheap and widely available.
“For the most part, it required an electrocardiogram to measure, and that's 20, $30,000 hospital equipment”
Early WHOOP algorithm development involved building prototypes and tuning them against gold-standard ECG and chest-strap data, and the company has since collected over a million datasets of sensor data against these references.
“Today, WHOOP has collected over a million datasets of WHOOP sensor data against these various gold standards”
Slow-wave sleep is when the body produces about 95% of its human growth hormone and repairs muscle torn during training, so strength gains depend on sleep rather than on gym time alone.
“slow-wave sleep, that's when your body produces 95% of its human growth hormones”
The annual physical, which measures pulse oximetry and heart rate at a random moment and ignores the 25 preceding factors such as caffeine or rest, is an antiquated approach that continuous wearable measurement can improve on.
“The dumbest day of the year is when you go have that annual checkup with your doctor”
The gap between someone getting 30 minutes of REM and slow-wave sleep and someone getting over five hours is enormous, so improving the quality of time already spent in bed matters more than adding time there.
“All we're talking about is take the time that you're in bed and make it better”
Owning the full hardware-to-algorithm stack lets a company control sampling rates and accuracy, because third-party data arrives at different frequencies and accuracies, making it hard to build reliable scores or feedback loops on top of it.
“every hardware is collecting data at different frequencies and related with different accuracy”
The fastest route to high-profile athletes runs through people who have outsized influence over them but are little known to outsiders, such as personal trainers, who spend more time with athletes than almost anyone else.
“The secret to getting to anyone high profile is to figure who in their life has a big influence over them that other people don't know.”
WHOOP's success in wearables came from a narrow, strong view of why it builds hardware, which led it to exclude phone calls, a high-resolution screen, a microphone, speaker, apps, and similar features that would have diluted the health-monitoring purpose.
“I think that WHOOP has been successful in the wearable space because we had a very narrow and very strong perspective on why we were building hardware”
Physiological metrics that matter for training were being measured during rest and sleep rather than during exercise, yet the sports and exercise field focused almost entirely on exercise volume, so a gap existed for recovery-oriented measurement.
“the metrics that I found fascinating often were being taken outside of exercise, or while you're sleeping, or while you're even at rest.”
Continuous health monitoring could shift large amounts of curative healthcare spending to preventive care by detecting disease states before or at onset, replacing the once-a-year checkup that captures a random snapshot of the body.
“If you can shift a curative cost to being a preventative cost, then there are enormous savings associated with that.”
A screen would make WHOOP a watch and force it into a narrower, risk-based design lens competing with Rolex, Timex, and Apple Watch, so WHOOP's paradigm is to build wearables that are either cool or invisible rather than stuck in the middle.
“The second you have a screen, you're a watch.”
Large sports apparel brands failed to dominate wearables because they lost the performance-first origin that Nike had, and they were better at aspirational storytelling than at building technology.
“I think that the sports apparel brands lost that in the evolution of technology”
Hard-driving people, including Navy SEALs, executives, and entrepreneurs, can push their bodies past safe limits through mindset, and WHOOP's most valuable role is to give them permission to rest by providing an objective third-party signal.
“What WHOOP does a very good job of is it gives a hard-charging person permission to let themselves rest”
WHOOP's core test for partnerships is whether they feel authentic: the best partnerships grow from organic adoption, and the formal partnership then amplifies what is already happening, rather than manufacturing demand through paid placement.
“I would say the core thing that we think about with partnerships is does it feel authentic?”
Founders tie their personal worth to company performance, and productive leadership requires separating personal growth from business outcomes by focusing on improving as a leader daily rather than on daily business results.
“You tie yourself worth or you tie your own performance very directly to the performance of the company.”
WHOOP refused to pay athletes to wear its product, treating the question of whether an elite athlete would pay for it as a test of whether the product delivered real value.
“We refused to sponsor athletes. We did not want to pay athletes to wear WHOOP.”
Fitbit excelled at distribution, growing units about fivefold year over year for a long stretch, but it won the wrong game because most buyers stopped wearing the device within three weeks to three months.
“They won distribution, they didn't win the product. And they had these crazy drop-off rates within three weeks and within three months.”
Offering a six-month membership at $30 per month with the hardware included, after tests showed that buyers at a $180 six-month rate kept using the product, created a major inflection by making the sign-up path feel cheap and the hardware feel free.
“we said, 'Well, what if you could sign up for only $30 but commit to six months?' And that in itself became a huge inflection”
Organizations can be evaluated on speed (how fast decisions, features, and marketing move) versus control (how much a leader is aware of and influences daily decisions), and WHOOP chose an intentionally uncomfortable pace that required the CEO to give up control.
“I realized years ago that I wanted WHOOP move at a really uncomfortable pace”
A founder of a 20-person company can still produce as an individual contributor, but between 50 and 100 people the role tilts toward management, and at 500 people most of the CEO's role must be management, with the tension arising when founders keep doing delegable work.
“In a stage of 20 people, you actually can still have an enormous output as an individual contributor”
Coaches and athletes said they wanted to measure more about exercise, yet when asked about their actual problems they described availability issues such as injury and being unprepared, which pointed to recovery rather than exercise measurement.
“they always came back to availability, some notion of an athlete being injured or not prepared for the game”
Hardware cannot be iterated in real time like software, so a company must hold a strong, uncompromising point of view on how the device will perform in the real world, because size, cost, and trade-offs constantly pull products away from the original vision.
“Hardware's really not a deal where you're iterating in real-time”
WHOOP rarely adjusts strategy in response to competitors, having chosen not to measure steps or include a screen, and its subscription and layered technology create defensibility that made Amazon's direct copy of its design feel non-threatening.
“We've benefited, I would say in large part, by not being that affected by what competitors in the space do”
Beyond the daily cycle, WHOOP runs weekly loops that check adherence to recovery and strain patterns and monthly loops that correlate 70 to 80 tracked behaviors, such as melatonin, alcohol, diet, meditation, relationships, and prescription drugs, with physiological outcomes.
“And then there's even a monthly feedback loop, which will look at a more detailed analysis of various behaviors and lifestyle decisions”
WHOOP aimed to grow like Nike rather than IBM by getting top athletes to wear the product authentically, reasoning that if the product delivered real value to elite athletes, they would pay for it and the brand would follow.
“we wanted WHOOP to grow up to look more like Nike than IBM”
Early on, Ahmed built a wall against negative feedback because it challenged his identity, but over time he learned to hear and wrestle with dissent, and now treats strong disagreement from his team as a prompt to examine why he holds a view so confidently.
“now it's almost like a source of excitement for me when someone on my team disagrees strongly with me”
WHOOP's subscription model requires releasing new features at a pace the company believes is much faster than competitors, and this cadence, combined with a narrow product focus, provides defensibility without reacting much to competitors.
“It forces us to be releasing new features at a pace that is, I would argue much faster than other people in the space”
Companies can move fast by telling new hires they were hired to make decisions, not form committees, and by accepting that some things will break, with manager-level checks added only for specific high-risk categories.
“We hired you to make decisions. And we say that on day one, 'You're here to make decisions. You're not here to form committees.'”
Controlling every layer, from sensors and sampling rates through raw metrics such as HRV and slow-wave sleep, to recovery and sleep performance scores and behavioral recommendations, creates many points of innovation that a software-only company cannot access.
“by controlling all the layers, you have so many different places where you can be innovating”
WHOOP the brand anchors in elite sport to make health monitoring cool rather than stigmatized, while WHOOP the product is designed for anyone regardless of age or background, since any user can gain health or performance value.
“WHOOP the brand... is trying to live in high-performance anchoring around sports”
WHOOP built a modular charger that lets the sensor be charged without removal, a costly pre-revenue decision made because the company believed continuous 24/7 data was key to health monitoring and to controlling accuracy.
“we felt so strongly that continuous data, Patrick, was the key to health monitoring... that we invented a modular charger”
After the consumer launch at $500 one-time fee in late 2016 and early 2017, buyers kept wearing the device for the next 12 months, which showed that the same metrics serving elite athletes also work for everyday executives and recreational users.
“The fact that people were still really using the product and not taking it off was a big breakthrough”
When WHOOP sold for $500 upfront, hardware cost $250 to $300 to make, and falling costs plus evidence of sustained usage led the company to move the whole business to a subscription in May 2018.
“When we were selling WHOOP for $500, it cost is between $250 and $300 to make the hardware”
Fitbit traded at roughly 1 to 2 times revenue as a public company, while Peloton traded in private markets as high as 20 times ARR, so the company wanted to look like Peloton rather than Fitbit, which rewarded recurring subscription revenue.
“Peloton, which wasn't a public company yet but was in the private markets was trading as high as 20 times to ARR”
Tracking reveals personal sleep disruptors such as looking at a phone until bedtime, eating within two to three hours of sleep, and warm rooms, which people often discover on their own once data makes the link visible.
“if you eat with it two to three hours before bed, that pretty dramatically messes up your sleep”
REM sleep is when the mind repairs cognitively, and people who cannot recall dreams may be getting too little REM sleep.
“REM is when your mind is repairing cognitively. That's when you're dreaming”
The WHOOP recovery score is a composite of heart rate variability, resting heart rate, respiratory rate and sleep quality, and the score is what makes recovery the product's most unique and complicated feature.
“that encompasses a combination of heart rate variability, resting heart rate, respiratory rate, and your sleep quality”
WHOOP chose photoplethysmography, which shines LEDs under the skin to read blood flow, as the best way to capture HRV noninvasively from the wrist, after exploring unusual options such as audio sensing from the body.
“we ultimately felt that photoplethysmography, which is effectively shining LED underneath your skin, was going to be the best way to do it”
WHOOP's daily cycle is designed to live a step ahead of the user: morning recovery sets how much strain is advisable, accumulated strain is tracked through the day, and end-of-day strain determines the sleep needed to recover for tomorrow.
“WHOOP sets up your whole life to try to stay a step ahead of you on this daily cycle”
WHOOP deliberately positioned itself as a tool for coaches and trainers rather than a disruptive replacement, avoiding any design that would make a trainer compete with the technology.
“we very intentionally did not want to disrupt that equation, which is to have a trainer competing with our technology”
The company's guiding principle is that you can only manage what you measure, and seeing one's own data quickly reveals habit effects, which is why measurement drives behavior change.
“we describe this phenomenon as you can only really manage what you measure”
Once a company has a reliable funnel that drives website visitors to explain the product and convert a predictable share into buyers, marketing becomes an execution-oriented exercise rather than a creative gamble.
“once you get to a place where you've got a really good funnel... then marketing becomes really fun and it becomes very execution-oriented”
Daily transcendental meditation gave Ahmed the ability to observe himself in the third person, letting him anticipate reactions such as anger or rash decisions before they happened.
“the thing about meditating is that it allows you to look at yourself in the third person”
Within CrossFit, when three people in a gym (box) began wearing WHOOP, the whole box typically followed within three months, which made CrossFit a grassroots growth story that led to an official partnership.
“if three people within a CrossFit box started wearing WHOOP, within three months the whole box would be wearing it”
Health monitoring has the potential to dramatically increase human lifespan by identifying the three to five daily, weekly, or monthly changes each person can make to become healthier.
“I truly believe that health monitoring has the potential to dramatically increase the human life span”
Ahmed expects that the 10 to 20 measurements taken in a doctor's office or during a health event will eventually be made noninvasively through wearables, though WHOOP is keeping its specific next measurements private.
“the 10 to 20 things that are being measured when you go into a doctor's office or when something bad happens”
By early 2020, roughly 60% of the PGA Tour was organically wearing WHOOP, and after a golfer detected COVID-19 through the device, the PGA Tour bought over a thousand straps for players, caddies, media, and staff to create a safer bubble.
“By early 2020, let's say, I would estimate about 60% of the PGA tour was organically wearing WHOOP”
Although WHOOP took many zigzags in business model and execution, the core vision of what the device measures and why was fixed from day one, with the original 2011 paper on intensity, recovery, and sleep anticipating today's strain, recovery, and sleep pillars.
“the paper that I wrote in 2011 was titled The Feedback Tool, measuring intensity, recovery, and sleep”
WHOOP Live displays players' heart rate and other physiological data during broadcasts, starting with golf, and Ahmed believes professional sports must innovate in how they are watched, similar to telemetry in Formula 1.
“bringing heart rate data and other physiological data live to the broadcast”
Two of WHOOP's first hundred users were LeBron James and Michael Phelps, and this high-profile adoption bought the company a couple of extra years to develop its business model while investors credited it as cutting-edge technology.
“two of our first hundred users were people like Lebron James and Michael Phelps.”
WHOOP's uncomfortable pace is core to its DNA and is a criterion for both hiring and firing, and employees report seeing orders of magnitude more change in six to twelve months than at larger organizations.
“that's a reason that we hire people, it's the reason that we fire people.”
A mentor advised Ahmed that he should try to hear people's feedback even if he does not have to act on it, and that habit became a core part of his leadership.
“someone told me it was a great piece of advice, 'You should really try to hear people's feedback. You don't necessarily have to listen to it.'”
The first technical milestone, starting in summer 2012, was proving that heart rate variability could be measured accurately and noninvasively from the wrist, a capability that had not been done before.
“the first thing we needed to prove, starting summer of 2012, was that we could measure heart rate variability accurately from the wrist, noninvasively”
Companies that keep the same attitude through hard years, when technology, sales, business model, and capital are all difficult, eventually feel momentum as a tailwind once things begin to go their way, making the company feel as if it is moving very fast.
“it just feels like the wind is turned and it's at your back”
WHOOP is building toward wearable technology that effectively disappears on the body, and once people see that technology can be invisible, the lack of a screen will make more sense.
“how do you make this technology effectively disappear on your body?”
WHOOP is arguably the first fitness product to tell users not to exercise, because it can recommend zero strain on days when recovery is poor.
“In a lot of ways, WHOOP is the first fitness product to tell you not to exercise.”
When Amazon launched a direct copy of WHOOP's design two years after meeting for investment, WHOOP management was not alarmed, because the clarity of the copying and the company's layered defensibility gave confidence.
“When Amazon very directly knocked off our design”
Ahmed's experience of overtraining as a Harvard squash player, getting fitter then collapsing, motivated his undergraduate research into physiological metrics, which he found were typically measured with antiquated equipment and were not focused on exercise alone.
“I was someone who used to overtrain, where you get fitter and fitter, and then you sort of fall off a cliff”
It is unclear whether wrist movement truly correlates with the number of steps a person takes, since moving the wrist several times can register as steps.
“If I move my wrist half a dozen times, I probably get six steps.”
Current wearables are underwhelming, but most people drastically underestimate how much wearable technology will change health and healthcare, and the change will come sooner than ten years.
“I think it'll be even sooner than the next 10 years.”
WHOOP's recovery score, shown each morning on a 0-100% red, yellow, or green scale, combines heart rate variability, resting heart rate, respiratory rate, and sleep quality to indicate readiness for strain.
“you wake up every morning with a recovery score from 0 to 100%, which is red, yellow, green”
WHOOP's team combines signal-processing engineers who previously worked on detecting gunshots and missile systems with apparel designers, and that mix of disciplines is a source of both energy and product innovation.
“we're doing signal processing algorithms with engineers who previously worked on how to detect bullets being shot”
Ahmed credits his parents, an immigrant father and an intellectual mother, with teaching him street smarts and book smarts at a young age, which he says prepared him to be an entrepreneur.
“my parents blend this sort of street smarts and book smarts”
The share of users who wear WHOOP for more than a minute in a day and for more than 18 hours differs by only about 2 to 3 percentage points, meaning daily wearers are close to wearing it continuously.
“those percentage points are about 2 or 3% apart. So if someone's wearing WHOOP in a day, they're very close to wearing it all the time”