Suzanne Ciani - Exploring the Creative Process - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 239]
What this covers
Host Patrick talks with Suzanne Ciani, who moved from classical piano into modular synthesis and later into commercial sound design. The conversation starts with creative character. She defines originality as speaking from your own identity, not avoiding other work, and she treats student imitation, such as copying a Beethoven quartet or writing in the style of Xenakis, as compatible with finding your voice. She distinguishes the inner voice that guides work from the one that says "you're not good enough," and she describes money as a tool for being heard, not a goal. One anecdote has her playing piano in a pitch for clients who expected jingles, then delivering the different work she had actually made.
The middle of the episode is about the instrument. She explains the Buchla as modules for oscillators, filters, gates and envelopes, linked by voltage control. She argues that adding a keyboard misled players into treating it as a conventional instrument. She also covers the role of visual feedback in performance and the 40-page paper behind her comeback. Her design view is that instruments should start from the performer's body, the opposite of Materials-First Design. She also argues that immersive multi-speaker spaces need real cultural content.
The final stretch concerns women in music. Suzanne describes how few openings existed in classical composition, why electronic work offered independence, and why pioneers were isolated and need recovering as "herstory." She credits mentor Ilse Bing with affirming her professional identity. Her Homophily Explanation for exclusion is flagged as contested, as is Patrick's pushback on Constraint-Driven Creativity.
Suzanne Ciani argues that real creative work requires an internal source of validation, and that technology which removes gatekeepers, such as the analog modular synthesizer, opens new creative territory only when instrument design starts from the human performer rather than from available parts.
- Seeking outside approval signals a derivative, stuck creator; artists need the integrity to be their own test of quality
- The Buchla's keyboard attachment short-circuited its potential; voltage-controlled networks are a new language, not a keyboard
- Electronic music offered women composers freedom from the gatekeepers who controlled orchestral and Hollywood openings
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Women composers in the mid-twentieth century had almost no openings in the classical music world, and listening to classical radio showed little music by women, which made electronic music an attractive path to independence.
“Women composers really didn't have openings. So electronic music was this instinctive promise of freedom, where you could do it all yourself.”
Women were excluded from music not for deliberate reasons but because men were uncomfortable with them, and humans prefer similar people, so once women reach critical mass they will tend to gravitate toward each other.
“My theory is not that they excluded women for any particular reason other than they were uncomfortable. Humans like to be with similar people.”
Creative output benefits from constraints because a framework narrows the focus; Patrick argues that lack of freedom is another way of describing the constraints a creator works within, and that a pure blank canvas is not enough.
“I'm a big believer in the power of constraints for creative output.”
The Buchla is a modular system in which each module handles one aspect of sound generation, such as oscillators, filters, gates and envelopes, and the modules are linked by voltage-controlled signals that shape timbre, volume and pitch over time.
“So the envelope, this is all by the way, voltage controlled. What does that mean? That means that the shapes that are doing the controlling”
Designers should start from what the human body and creator need, such as hand size, rather than from available chips or parts, because when materials dominate the design, the result serves the parts rather than the user.
“A lot of people design based on what's available, what the parts are. It's like people build boxes for houses because that's what's available. In other words, the materials dominate.”
Creators who are stuck in a rut are not consulting their own voice; a clear sign is when they seek validation from outside themselves, which is meaningless for an artist.
“the idea is that the validation is outside of yourself. For an artist, that's not true. You do not need outside validation. It's meaningless.”
Placing a traditional keyboard on modular synthesizers caused players to treat them as keyboards, which completely short-circuited understanding of what the machine can do.
“they put a keyboard on it, a traditional black and white keyboard. Then people started to play it as a keyboard. That completely short circuited the understanding of what this machine could do.”
Women pioneers of electronic music did not know about each other because technological work can be very private and done in isolation, so the history of women in the field was lost and needs to be recovered as herstory.
“The odd thing is that we didn't really know about each other. Technological work can be very private.”
Professional work comes with outside requests that constrain output, and freedom in later life means generating the requests yourself, so the work is done because the creator wants it, not because the world needs it.
“So I've always thought of this dynamic as in my professional life, the requests came from outside. Now, I generate the requests.”
Creators, especially women, have inner voices that undermine them, such as 'You're not good enough', and the skill is to distinguish these from the useful inner voice that guides work, then ignore the unproductive one.
“there are other little voices for women that undermine them. That little voice that says, 'You're not good enough, you're not doing it right.'”
Ilse Bing's artistic stages were driven by emotional and historical events, such as the war and her Jewish identity, more than by technological change, though technology mattered too.
“But her emotional periods were really what counted. So when the war came, and she was Jewish, this was a big shift in her outlook”
Originality is the lifeblood of creativity; it does not mean isolation from existing work but speaking directly from one's own identity, which gives work energy and validity that derivative imitation lacks.
“Originality is the lifeblood of creativity. Originality doesn't mean that you don't interweave existing.”
Money is a tool serving a vision rather than a goal in itself; she pursued commercial work because she felt needed fame and wealth to be heard, a practical means to an end.
“I think that's another aspect of this whole thing is that you're motivated by a vision or a cause. Money is a tool.”
Feedback from the instrument, such as hundreds of LEDs showing rhythm, pace, volume and voltage level and spatial location, is essential to being in the moment during performance, and early opaque instruments were hard to play for this reason.
“How do you get feedback so that you know what's happening in the instrument? That's a major part of the interface.”
Performance techniques she developed on the Buchla in the 1970s remain valid, and she based her comeback on a 40-page paper written for a National Endowment for the Arts composer grant describing how to play the instrument.
“I wrote a 40-page paper about how to play the Buchla. When I came back to the Buchla six years ago”
A keyboard yields one action per result, whereas voltage-controlled sweeps can move sound through space, shift filters and amplitude, and create a network of possibilities that functions as a new language rather than an instrument for notes.
“I can create a network of possibilities, that is a new language, really. It's not really about the sound. It's about the way the sound moves”
To win commercial clients who expected traditional jingles, Suzanne presented sound-design work by playing a piano during the pitch even though the final piece contained no piano, then delivered the different work she had actually made.
“There wasn't even anything connected to a piano in that piece. It was all sound design. Well, you couldn't tell somebody that then.”
Educational years are necessarily imitative, since writing out a Beethoven quartet or writing in the style of Xenakis is how artists learn, and this imitation does not conflict with later developing one's own voice.
“my educational years were more imitative because that was the process of learning. Write out a Beethoven quartet, get close to it”
Electronic sound removes the range limitations and technique constraints of acoustic instruments, allowing a composer to move sound from below to above the audible spectrum in a sweep rather than maximizing the aptitudes of particular instruments.
“You don't have range limitations, for one. I can go from below the sonic spectrum to above in a sweep”
Technology opens new avenues for creators to make work without permission, because new fields have less structure and norms, leaving space that is simply there for the taking.
“There's this amazing idea that I play with a lot about how technology opens up new avenues for creators to create things without permission.”
Ilse Bing's mentorship mattered because she asked Suzanne about her work first, affirming her professional identity when young women were otherwise treated as objects rather than professionals.
“She always let me know that my work was a thing. It was a valid source of interest.”
Creators should be pleased with their own work and listen to their inner voice rather than asking whether it is good, since seeking reassurance is already leaking the creator's confidence.
“Please yourself. If you have to ask, 'Is it good? What do you think of this?' That is already just bleeding there, you're leaking.”
Performance is about being in the moment, and nervousness is a detriment because it communicates to the audience, so a performer should dispel fear logically and focus on channeling the work rather than themselves.
“Do I want to make my audience feel nervous? Do I want to be nervous? Because then that'll communicate to the audience.”
Immersive multi-speaker and visual spaces are becoming standard, but they are empty without content, so immersive experiences need substantive cultural material such as a Van Gogh body of work rather than spectacle alone.
“It's not enough to have an immersive Van Gogh space without Van Gogh. There's something to put in there.”
Creating expressive electronic instruments is an art and engineering task that requires designers to work closely with the musicians who will use them, because engineers each bring their own company's frame, so finding a collaborative engineer is difficult.
“If I worked with an engineer from Moog, he thinks like a Moog. It's really hard to find a collaborative system, you have to find your engineer.”
The creative process begins with putting yourself in a place of receptivity and attentiveness, free of distraction and interruption, so that a muse or idea can be received, and she does this by going to remote places where nobody can reach her.
“The process is putting yourself in a place where you're ready to receive, where you're attentive and listening.”
Playing a modular synthesizer is like jazz in that the performer works from an underlying architecture, the patch, and improvises within it, though that structure is built from raw materials rather than an existing song.
“as in jazz, you're working off of a structure. Usually there's some foundational architecture to it, might be a standard song. Then you riff on that”
For commercial scoring, Suzanne required being alone during the first viewing of a commercial because complete immersion in that initial encounter is when she opens herself and grabs a small idea to nurture into a full piece.
“The first time I saw, say, a commercial that I was going to score, I wanted nobody else in the room.”
Artists typically pass through periods, and their language tends to move into greater freedom in later years, which Suzanne says she is experiencing now.
“Artist's language can evolve. It usually goes into a state of more freedom in the later years. I'm in that stage now.”
Her weekday commercial work gave her access to top studios and budgets, which synergistically fed her weekend art music, though she did not use the commercial musicians on her personal albums.
“They had a synergistic relationship because in my work music, my commercial music, I got to work in the best studios with the biggest budgets”
Her quadraphonic Buchla performances could not be toured because theaters would not install the four speakers required, and she could only perform in art galleries, which stalled her career.
“I was playing in quadraphonic. So that was the nature of the instrument, spatial control of sound. I couldn't do it. The theaters wouldn't put up the four speakers.”
Like the arpeggio on piano or pizzicato in strings, every instrument develops a language of techniques, and new instruments like the modular synthesizer solidify only gradually, as the trumpet did over many versions.
“All instruments develop oddly and gradually. You look at the trumpet, how many versions there were before it solidified.”
Suzanne was credited as the first woman to score a major Hollywood feature film, The Incredible Shrinking Woman, and no other woman scored a Hollywood feature for another 14 years.
“I was given the endorsement, whenever, that I was the first woman to score major Hollywood feature, the Incredible Shrinking Woman. No other woman scored in Hollywood feature for another 14 years.”
The concept of controlling sound this way goes back a long time, but the instrument had to wait for the technology to be able to express it.
“The concept goes way back, the idea of having this type of control of sound goes way back. But it was because it's now based in technology, they had to wait for the technology”
Being fully in the moment is what defines strong performance, and it protects performers from fear, because performance is an energy system that includes the audience.
“Being in the moment, performance is about being in the moment. It is an energy system that usually includes an audience”
Meeting Don Buchla was not a gradual evolution but a complete earthquake that led her to drop everything and not touch a piano for many years.
“So when I met Buchla, it wasn't a gradual evolutionary thing. It was a complete earthquake. I dropped everything, I did not touch a piano for many years.”
For a first listen to her work, Seven Waves is a good entry point, a studio album built on Buchla-designed waves, while Buchla Concerts 1975 is a historic, happenstance quadraphonic recording made with probably one microphone.
“Buchla Concerts 1975. This was done by a label in Manchester, England called Finders Keepers.”
No two people play a modular system the same way, and in modular synthesis no two people have the same instrument on many levels, because each user configures the patch differently.
“no two people are going to play it the same way. In fact, in modular, no two people are going to have the same instrument on many levels.”
Creative clients should give the artist freedom and avoid backseat driving the initial output, and if they do not like the work they can go elsewhere, because she will not second guess herself.
“I really do believe in a creative job, you have to give the person freedom. You don't try to backseat drive or control the initial output of somebody.”
The National Academy of Recording Arts and Sciences categorizes electronic music as dance or turntable music, which fails to recognize analog modular synthesis as a distinct new instrument.
“It's odd that National Academy of Recording Arts and Sciences thinks of electronic music as dance music, turntable music.”
One missing component for electronic music is performance spaces designed for spatial sound, such as quadraphonic setups, since visuals and multiple speaker arrays are now integrated.
“I think still one of the missing components is the spaces, the performance spaces.”
Early electronic instruments had very little memory and were mostly analog, and the digital components that existed were volatile, so prepared material could be lost on a power interruption.
“There was very little memory in the electronics. It was analog mostly. There was some digital, but the digital was volatile.”
Kindness is a two-way street, and receiving kindness requires vulnerability and awareness, which Suzanne only later recognized in the birthday party her friends and family gave her.
“You have to be vulnerable to receive kindness, even to be aware of it.”
Eurorack systems are too tiny for a human hand to operate comfortably, a design failure that she attributes to designers not starting from the human body.
“I thought, Oh, my god, they're so tiny. I can't get my hands in there. I'm a woman, and I can't get my hands in there.”
Don Buchla was a designer who focused on how a human touches, responds to, and interacts with the machine, and Suzanne describes him as the Leonardo da Vinci of electronic instrument design.
“Don Buchla, who passed away several years ago, was this brilliant, I call him the Leonardo da Vinci of electronic music instrument design.”
An artist does not retire or quit; the work is a permanent identity, so when Ilse Bing stopped photographing at 60, it frightened Suzanne as a young person because she thought it meant Bing had stopped being an artist.
“An artist is forever. I mean, honestly, it's not a job. You don't quit. You can't retire. It's just there.”
Creative strength comes from the integrity of not being a victim of what other people think, although appreciation is pleasant, the artist must remain the ultimate arbiter of quality.
“But the strength comes from this integrity of not being a victim of what other people think.”
During her 1980s appearance on Late Night with David Letterman, a production crew member unplugged the computer running her prepared piece, so her play button did nothing on live TV, and the show cut to commercial as she began playing.
“the production person had unplugged the computer that I was using for my piece. So I come out on live TV, and I push the button that says play. Nothing happens.”
Her first album, Seven Waves, was built from sounds designed on the Buchla, and her concerts begin with waves because she lives on the ocean and the emotion of a wave can set a song's mood.
“My concerts always start with waves. Because I live on the ocean, I'm listening to the waves all the time. My first album was called Seven Waves.”
Playing with analog modular synthesis is fabulous, fun, and good for the brain, and such tools are useful as spiritual creative tools, though not everyone needs to become a great artist.
“Everybody should be out playing with their analog modular sense. It's fabulous, fun, it's good for your brain.”
Buchla Concerts 1975, released by Finders Keepers in Manchester, was an unintended recording of a quadraphonic performance captured with probably a single microphone, but it is a historic document of early Buchla performance.
“It wasn't intentional recording. It was a quadraphonic performance that was recorded probably with one mic in the room.”
A listener can tell derivative music from original music because derivative work tries to fit an existing mold, while original work has an energy and validity of its own.
“I can always tell if it's something derivative or trying to be in the cookie mold of some existing thing or whether it just has an energy and a validity that is original.”