Strauss Zelnick - Playing to Your Strengths - [Invest Like the Best, EP.347]
What this covers
Patrick interviews Strauss Zelnick, CEO of Take-Two, the owner of Rockstar Games and 2K. The conversation follows Zelnick's career: a 1983 hunch that pay television and home video were the future, a stint as president of the independent distributor Vestron, and a rough arrival at 20th Century Fox, where he says he was right about almost everything and still nearly failed because the organization seized up against him. It continues through Crystal Dynamics, where the 3DO platform had no installed base and Sony became the first third-party partner, and ends at Take-Two.
The Take-Two story is the most concrete stretch. An unamended Delaware charter let shareholders replace the whole board at the annual meeting, which made the company a takeover target. Zelnick describes a proxy fight won with 88 percent of the vote, run without owning shares so as to avoid group formation. He then lays out his turnaround sequence: vendor renegotiation first, one honest headcount cut last. He also explains why private equity has made easy turnarounds scarce, and states his litigation rule: settle when wrong, never when right.
The wider ground is the business of games. Zelnick takes up the Unexpected Hits Pattern, citing Red Dead Redemption, Backstreet Boys and Home Alone, and notes that half of Take-Two is mobile free-to-play. He explains why Hollywood talent has transferred poorly to computer-built games and sets out a rule for when to adopt AI. Patrick adds a quant finding on asset creep. Zelnick's leadership asides include Dale Carnegie's Sincere Interest In Others and a contested claim that fitness extends healthspan more than lifespan.
Zelnick argues that durable media success comes from recruiting genuine talent, protecting creatives inside a rational, low-ego organization, and balancing hits with new IP and platform bets, while sincere listening and self-criticism matter more than being right.
- Creators, not operators, make hits, so the operator's job is to create a safe environment and remove ego from the process
- Turnarounds succeed by cutting costs in a sequence (vendors first, headcount last) and by solving problems rather than imposing ideas
- Franchises decay, so new IP must be funded continuously, and platform bets should wait for market evidence but still be early enough to matter
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Under SEC rules Zelnick's group solicited up to 10 holders and won 88 percent of the shareholder vote at the Take-Two annual meeting, a result he says has never been repeated, and they did so without owning shares to avoid forming a legal group.
“we got 88% of the vote. That's never happened before since.”
Major hits are unexpected because they defy conventional wisdom: Red Dead Redemption succeeded when Westerns were thought not to work, Backstreet Boys and Britney Spears defied the belief that boy and girl bands would fail, and Home Alone overturned the belief that comedies needed big stars.
“conventional wisdom in the interactive entertainment business was Westerns don't work, period, full stop”
Patrick reports a quantitative-investing finding that companies with the largest percentage growth in assets were the worst performers and those with the largest asset reductions were the best, independent of other factors, which he links to asset creep.
“companies that had the largest percentage growth of their assets were the worst performing companies in the market”
Take-Two's plain vanilla Delaware unamended charter let shareholders take a floor vote at the annual meeting to replace the entire board, which made the company attractive for a takeover despite its poor management.
“it had a plain vanilla Delaware unamended charter, which enabled one to show up at the Annual Shareholders Meeting and take a floor vote.”
Under copyright and trademark law, a title cannot be protected, but using the underlying intellectual property in a derivative work is a violation, and a derivative product cannot easily be claimed as non-derivative.
“you can use any title you want. But if you use the underlying intellectual property, that's a violation.”
Half of Take-Two's business is mobile, which is free to play, and generally less than 20 percent of players will pay to upgrade, and usually well under that figure.
“half of our business is mobile, and mobile is free to play... less than 20%, may be willing to pay to upgrade the experience, and it's generally not 20%.”
Health and fitness practices are unlikely to meaningfully extend lifespan, perhaps by about 5 years at most, but there is strong evidence they extend healthspan, so the goal should be the quality of years rather than longevity claims.
“there's very little evidence that anything I'm doing really changes your lifespan much. Maybe you change your lifespan by about 5 years on the outside.”
Unlike recorded music and film, which are largely analog, modern video game production is created largely in computers over multi-year projects, requiring technical education, which is why Hollywood talent has not translated easily into interactive entertainment.
“the project is largely created in a computer, not entirely, we have motion capture.”
Dale Carnegie's core principle, taking a sincere interest in other people, underpins both salesmanship and leadership, because meeting others' needs requires asking, listening, and not trying to convince people they have different needs.
“the principle really is take a sincere interest in other people, with emphasis on the word sincere.”
Private equity as an asset class has injected efficiency and best practices into enterprise so that sloppy, easy turnarounds of the 1960s type are now rare in the U.S. market, making turnarounds harder to find.
“private equity actually as an asset class has injected a lot of efficiency and a lot of best practices into enterprise.”
Zelnick believes in delegation combined with communication: he gives labels and executives independence but expects to know the problems first and immediately, because saying I do not care how you do it is how companies become noncompliant and go bankrupt.
“I believe in delegation with communication. Among the most dangerous words you can say at a corporation are I don't care how you do it, just do it.”
When a company is badly troubled, an investor can reasonably believe that whatever they do cannot make it worse, so the downside is limited and any improvement is upside.
“when a company is that troubled, it's not like you think you can make it worse. In other words, I was pretty sure that whatever I did, it couldn't be worse.”
Zelnick intuitively recognized in 1983 that new media, including pay television and video cassette home entertainment, was the future, and he became expert in those then-tiny ancillary businesses, which later gave him management roles as they grew.
“And I realized intuitively that the future was new media.”
Zelnick's litigation rule is that if he is wrong he settles and if he is right he never settles, which deters lawsuits because adversaries know Take-Two will litigate indefinitely when it is right.
“If I'm wrong, I settle. If I'm not wrong, I never settle.”
When Zelnick joined Crystal Dynamics, the company was making games only for the 3DO platform, which had no installed base; he then discovered that Sega and Nintendo would not license his company because their engineers had been recruited away, so Sony became the first third-party partner.
“the answer was, it's 0.”
Making a single, honest headcount reduction after exhausting other efficiencies earns staff trust, because remaining employees stop worrying about their jobs and often welcome the removal of underperformers.
“we tell them, look, we know enough to know we're like one and done.”
Being president of a large independent distributor like Vestron carried little weight with the major motion picture business, and Zelnick arrived at 20th Century Fox without relationships in Hollywood, which he failed to recognize.
“being president of a large independent in those days was utterly meaningless to the major motion picture business.”
On his first weekend at Take-Two, Zelnick resolved a threatened Hollywood infringement of a legacy IP by calling an old friend and credibly threatening an injunction after letting the studio invest $75 million, so the studio stood down without any lawsuit.
“I'm going to let you go ahead and invest $75 million in the movie that you want to make on this. And about two weeks before you release the movie, I'm going to go to court”
A leader can have correct strategy and still fail if the tone and approach alienate the organization; Zelnick at Fox was right about almost everything but nearly failed because the organization seized up against him.
“I was right about almost all of it, but it was irrelevant because my tone and approach was completely wrong.”
Boldness is valuable only with intelligence; conviction is justified when rooted in facts, but conviction without knowledge is magical thinking and dangerous, so leaders should gather information, synthesize, decide, and then act with conviction.
“In the absence of intelligence, there is no good role for boldness”
Developing new intellectual property is the riskiest part of the business and costly when wrong, and management is tempted to avoid it because the payoff may fall after their tenure, but Zelnick refuses to optimize for his own watch.
“The riskiest part of the business. It's costly when you get it wrong. And it's tempting for a management team not to do it”
To keep employees surfacing bad news early, leaders must not shoot the messenger; Zelnick says he has never raised his voice at bad news, and he wants problems even without proposed solutions.
“You don't have to show up with solution. I want to know the problem. I need to know. I can't be surprised.”
When taking over a company, Zelnick's team first lists the top 10 vendors and renegotiates their contracts, usually saving material sums, and only after exhausting efficiency searches makes a single, honest headcount reduction, rather than firing people first.
“You know what the first thing we do is we get a list of the top 10 vendors to the company”
Zelnick defines innovation as being the first company into a new market such as mobile, not the last, because early entry creates outsized value when the choice is right, and he admits Take-Two underestimated mobile and missed the boat.
“Innovation is being the first company to get into mobile, not the last.”
Zelnick's timing rule is that creative matters require being at the front of the line, business matters do not, and matters bridging both, such as AI, require being close to but not at the front of the line.
“generally speaking, with creative matters, you have to be at the front of the line. With business matters, you don't have to be at the front of the line.”
Losing both parents as a child and multiple childhood losses by age 10 can push people toward victimization or toward ambition; for Zelnick it produced perfectionism and ambition as well as empathy, though ambition dominated his first 35 years.
“great loss when you're little and I had multiple childhood losses, all by the age of 10 lead to 1 of 2 things”
Except for a few enduring franchises like Grand Theft Auto and James Bond, most hits have a decay curve, so a company that only bets on winners risks burning its furniture; Take-Two therefore always invests in new IP.
“pretty much everything else has a decay curve. And so, if you only bet on your winners in perpetuity, you run the risk of burning the furniture to keep warm.”
Zelnick claims that during his tenure his teams had the highest hit ratio in the business 100 percent of the time, and he attributes this to creating a safe, rational, well-financed environment in which creators work without ego interference, not to his own creative contributions.
“I did have something to do with creating an environment that made that possible.”
Although ZMC's fund documents require selling within 10 years, Zelnick builds companies for 20 to 30 years because stakeholders include colleagues and customers, and well-built companies with durable value earn a better multiple at sale.
“But we're building that company for 20 or 30 years.”
When Zelnick realized his mistake at Fox, he took responsibility directly with Barry Diller, saying he had approached the situation horribly, rather than listing what others could have done, and this enabled a reset that led to success.
“I took responsibility for the mistakes I made and got a chance to do a reset.”
Zelnick's approach to the early Take-Two crisis was to ask how he could help, solve the problem quietly without litigation, press, or spending money, and then repeat that across issues so the organization came to see him as competent rather than an outsider making sweeping changes.
“I didn't go in with, let me fix these 10,000 things. I went in and said, how can I help you?”
Leaders must synthesize information and decide even when things are unclear, since indecision can let the moment pass, and once a course is agreed upon, conviction and seeing it through to the end is essential.
“So what I learned is you do have to decide, you got to decide. That's what you're paid to do.”
Zelnick kept Greg Thomas, who was ready to leave Take-Two, by asking for only three months to show him the organization could be a place he would be happy working, and Thomas stayed for 17 years while Visual Concepts produced NBA 2K and other hit titles.
“I'd like you to give me 3 months. Just give me 3 months.”
Zelnick's main talent skill is identifying genuine talent, distinguishing the real deal from the rest, and persuading established people to work inside his enterprise, which he views as an unusual skill in entertainment.
“I seem to have an ability to identify genuine talent in other people, whether that's creative talent or executive talent.”
When taking over a troubled organization, a leader should break no glass initially, listen first, and treat people with respect rather than immediately announcing that their strategy or execution is lousy and that they have better ideas.
“I have learned and I learned the hard way to break no glass initially and to listen first and err on the side of treating people with great respect.”
Take-Two stays away from massive platform pronouncements absent market evidence, because owners of valuable IP can be late to a platform and still do fine, and it aims to be wherever consumers are through the broadest possible distribution.
“We stay away from huge pronouncements and massive shifts in the absence of market evidence because if you own intellectual property that matters, you can be late on a platform and still be just fine.”
Derivative intellectual property is generally not hugely successful, and while it can be moderately successful at times, the biggest hits are unexpected, as shown by multiple simultaneous Robin Hood films that did not become blockbusters.
“Bottom line is derivative IP is, generally speaking, not going to be hugely successful”
Zelnick presents the Greg Thomas story as evidence that being confident and asking for a bounded trial period retains talent, whereas leading with credentials and critique would have caused an exit.
“Had I handled it that way, which is some people's style, but not mine, he would have left.”
Talented creators like Jim Cameron did not want the executive's creative input. What they needed was support, empathy, kindness, enthusiasm, encouragement, and help navigating budget or timing concerns.
“So what he really needed was support and empathy and kindness and enthusiasm and encouragement.”
Take-Two's poor management caused the stock to fall at the hands of professional investors and hedge funds who wanted new leadership, which created the opening for an activist shareholder to win a floor vote.
“the stock had fallen at the hands of professional investors and hedge funds who are desperate for new leadership.”
In 2007 Take-Two was in severe distress, with its chairman indicted, a criminal investigation of the company, about $700 million in core revenue, one profitable franchise, and roughly six months from bankruptcy, but Zelnick judged that it could only go up from there.
“it was probably 6 months away from bankruptcy. Apart from that, it was in great shape.”
Zelnick's team at Vestron tried to take Dunkin' Donuts private when its market cap was about $350 million and its EBITDA could roughly triple overnight, but they failed; another buyer later acquired it, and it was worth $3 billion within a couple of years.
“It was a screaming bargain. The market cap of the company was like $350 million”
Take-Two has grown from one franchise that had sold at least 5 million units in an individual release when Zelnick took over in 2007 to 16 franchises that have each done so.
“we have 16 franchises at Take-Two that have each sold at least 5 million units in an individual release. And then that's up from 1 when we took the company over in '07.”
Patrick notes Peter Chernin's content-to-commerce concept, underlying The Chernin Group, which holds that many of the best media businesses tie content to an adjacent business model rather than straight-line payment for content.
“I love his beautiful idea of content to commerce, this investing concept that he's based The Chernin Group on.”
Zelnick pushed Crystal Dynamics to become multi-platform immediately because depending on a single platform like 3DO would make the company fail if that platform failed, and having two sequential failures is strategically better than one.
“if 3DO fails, I don't want us to fail. So we can't have that as dependencies.”
Take-Two's strategy is to be the most creative, innovative, and efficient company in the entertainment business, though Zelnick admits it is not always the best and that innovation is the area needing the most work because innovation and efficiency do not necessarily go together.
“innovation and efficiency don't necessarily go together.”
Zelnick believed in 2007 that interactive entertainment was well positioned for growth, that Grand Theft Auto could be even bigger, and that new intellectual property could be created in a dynamic industry, while accepting the business's cyclicality and holiday seasonality.
“I had a pretty good sense that interactive entertainment was well positioned for growth.”
Zelnick's team cut $40 million out of Take-Two's annual expenses within six months of taking over, a sequence that began with vendor renegotiation and ended with a single headcount reduction.
“We cut $40 million out of the annual expenses of the company in six months.”
Because the biggest entertainment hits are unexpected, they cannot be organized around, so Zelnick is not worried that AI will eat the entertainment business's lunch.
“which means that you can't organize around them with AI. So I'm not worried about AI eating our collective lunches in the entertainment business.”
Content businesses work when consumers value the content enough to pay for it; when they do not pay, content that is valuable enough to be consumed is still monetized through advertising, which is why advertising-supported businesses exist.
“If the content is valuable enough to consumers, they will generally pay for it.”
Zelnick knew he could not add creative value to a talent like James Cameron, so he avoided creative input and focused on what the talent needed, a judgment that depends on honest self-assessment.
“And I knew enough about myself to know that I couldn't add any value.”
The ability to put one's own ego aside and refuse credit for hits is rare in entertainment, and Zelnick says he is willing to say he had nothing to do with a hit because it is true.
“Not too many people are willing to say, as I will, I didn't have anything to do with that hit.”
Zelnick's rational, sound-decision reputation was built because the prior management had made so many poor decisions that Take-Two's new decisions looked night and day, and employees concluded the new leaders were reasonably intelligent.
“the prior management had made so many poor decisions that the difference was really night and day.”
A lawyer-trained Fox executive equivocated and over-analyzed so much that decisions passed by; Zelnick concludes that the job is to decide, and the hardest part of leadership is making a call when everything is unclear.
“he would equivocate, and he would, at times, just analyze and equivocate so much that the moment would pass.”
The quantitative finding that companies with the largest percentage asset growth underperform and those shrinking assets outperform is less true today, because the modern market contains fewer badly managed companies with bloated balance sheets.
“I think it is less true. I think you don't tend to see really messed up companies anymore.”
Although the expression of media business models has changed dramatically, the underlying concept, that content is paid for directly or indirectly by advertisers, is the same as it was at the start of Zelnick's career.
“Everything is different in the expression, but the underlying concept is the same.”
Zelnick's guideline is that if you do not have to make a choice, do not make it; he prefers the broadest possible business that meets consumers where they are, even if some channels earn a lower margin.
“If you don't have to make a choice, don't make that choice, keep all your options open.”
People's core needs for support are to be understood, acknowledged, and cared for rather than merely seen, and Zelnick meets these needs quietly by doing the work rather than publicizing it.
“people want to be understood and people want to be acknowledged and people want to be cared for.”
Interactive entertainment was highly cyclical and seasonal, primarily a holiday business driven by hardware replacement cycles that resembled the toy business, and it still carried economic order quantity risks, though these were smaller than in the cartridge era.
“At that time, the interactive entertainment business was still highly cyclical, driven by hardware replacement.”
Creators do their best work when the organization guarantees a safe place: no yelling, no leader ego, no credit stealing, no bankruptcy or scandal, and genuine personal support from the executive.
“No one is going their raise their voice. No one's going to let their ego interfere with what you do, myself included.”
Showing up physically fit, well-groomed, and natural-looking, rather than surgically altered, helps leaders lead because it signals self-respect and respect for others.
“it's a sign of respect for yourself and respect for others to show up as your best self.”
The kindest thing anyone ever did for Zelnick was when his aunt and uncle took him and his siblings into their home and raised them as their own children after he lost both parents as a child.
“my aunt and uncle took my siblings and me into their home and raised us as their children.”
Dick Parsons, former Time Warner CEO, synthesized huge amounts of information, was politically savvy without being political, and always made people feel important; Barry Diller is a tough, critical boss whom Zelnick argued with and who was right about 98 percent of the time.
“I don't know, 98% of the time he was right, which is incredible because I am reasonably intelligent and well versed in what I do.”
One size does not fit all in managing creatives; Katzenberg engages deeply in story while Zelnick lacks those skills and instead provides support, empathy, kindness, enthusiasm, and help navigating budget and timing concerns.
“So first, one size does not fit all.”
Zelnick is motivated by achievement, specifically doing hard things, rather than money or power; he sees money as a means to pay bills and educate children, and he has never lost money on a deal or failed to repay debt.
“But achievement very much. I like doing things. I really like doing hard things.”
Efficiency at Take-Two means running a tight ship without resorts, private jets, private dining rooms, or entourages, which Zelnick illustrates by arriving unescorted with his own iPad at a $28 billion enterprise.
“That means running a really tight ship.”
Zelnick's interest in fitness began with vanity as he aged, then became a game of performing at a high level with age, and then became a social community of athletes who skew younger, which made it powerful.
“I think my entree into this was just purely vanity.”
Zelnick does not consider his business successes masterpieces; the true masterpieces are creators' works, while his own meaningful achievement lies in helping people achieve their potential and live great lives.
“some of the products that we put out are master pieces, but they're not my master pieces. They are creative folks' masterpieces.”
Media operators do not have to be creators themselves; many important jobs in entertainment support the company's mission without creating the entertainment, though the people who create hits are the ones who ultimately matter most.
“There are numerous jobs in entertainment that are important for the mission of the entertainment company that have nothing to do with creating the entertainment itself.”
Zelnick believes his children would say that excellence mattered most to him as a parent, along with integrity and pursuing their passions.
“I think they would probably arrive at the conclusion that excellence really mattered.”
Zelnick does not want credit for things he did not do, though he would accept credit for what he did, and he sees being the star as the creators' role, with himself in the caboose.
“The creators will be the star. I'm not even in the backseat. I'm in the caboose.”
Zelnick believes Grand Theft Auto and James Bond will not go away as long as they are well treated, but nearly all other franchises have decay curves.
“I don't think Grand Theft Auto is ever going to go away. And I don't think James Bond is ever going away as long as they're treated well.”
Zelnick's physician Peter Attia wrote the foreword to Becoming Ageless and shares the view that health span matters more than lifespan, and Attia would not guarantee a specific lifespan for Zelnick.
“Peter Attia was my doctor for 4 years. He wrote the foreword to the book.”
Take-Two aims to be the number one pure-play company in the space, which would bring a higher valuation and better talent access; if Microsoft acquires Activision, Take-Two would become number two by default.
“We're now #3, if Activision gets bought by Microsoft, we will become #2 by default”