Sean Feeney - Reinventing the Restaurant Business - [Invest Like the Best, CLASSICS]
What this covers
The conversation pairs host Patrick with Sean Feeney, a former trader who left finance to open restaurants with chef Missy Robbins and now co-runs Grove House Hospitality, which owns Lilia and Misi. It follows his path step by step. It begins with the restlessness that made him leave and his view that stagnation is a signal to sit with, not escape by taking the same job elsewhere. It then turns to how an outsider's basic questions about purchasing and payroll exposed practices insiders had stopped examining.
The range is wide. On money, Feeney calls the lease the most consequential early decision and cites an industry rule of thumb that rent should stay near 8 percent of sales, a figure the extracted material marks as contested. On concept, he describes Misi's deliberately small menu of about 10 vegetables, 10 pastas and six gelatos filling a waitlist of roughly 2,500 a night. On service, he describes a survey of about 500 mostly close friends that set timing thresholds for the perfect turn, and he argues the guest relationship starts at booking, not at the door.
Further out, he covers a pasta business sold through weekly Instagram drops. He also covers a culinary high school partnership, where about 91 of 470 team members came from the school, and a forecast that restaurants will shrink in footprint, menu and staff. The softer thread concerns Brunello Cucinelli's Solomeo as a model of purpose, his wife's support, and teaching a host to say no warmly.
Feeney argues that restaurants can be run far more profitably and creatively by aligning incentives (percent-of-sales rent, intentionally narrow concepts, tight operating frameworks) and by treating the guest relationship as a long journey, and that people do their best work when they find and embrace their own 'genius.'
- Percent-of-sales rent aligns landlord and operator incentives better than fixed price-per-square-foot leases
- Narrow, intentional concepts create more demand than broad menus, and scarcity built through specificity drives waitlists
- Success is measured by daily fulfillment and by people being proud to be part of the business, not by bonuses or stars
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Feeney argues that a restaurant's lease, signed first and for 10 to 20 years, is the most important financial decision an operator makes, and that many New York restaurateurs are seduced by beautiful spaces and skip the financial diligence that would reveal the long-term damage a high rent can do.
“It's the most important decision you make, and it's the first one you make. And you sign 10-, 15-, 20-year leases”
Leaders should aim to replicate the feeling of success, not only the outcome, and should let talented people work from their own genius by framing a problem and asking what they would be excited to do.
“when you know you've got something that feels right, how do you replicate that feeling, not just the outcome?”
Feeney argues that when feeling stuck, the right response is to sit with the discomfort and understand it, rather than making a rash move like taking the same job at another firm, because that only moves the problem.
“instead of making a decision rash and going to another place to do the same thing, sit in it and find that feeling.”
Feeney says the company invested in a New York culinary high school since 2019 and that, of 470 team members, about 91 were aged 16 to 21 and came from that school, arguing that this builds local talent that will stay in New York.
“We now have 470 team members in all of our businesses, and probably, I think, at this moment, 91 of them are between the ages of 16 and 21, and they have come from this high school.”
Feeney notes that guests often book their next reservation before leaving Lilia, a behavior he finds remarkable because he himself never books the next meal after a great dinner, so he studies this as the key indicator of loyalty.
“Every single night in our restaurants, there's people who make reservations for the next time, and that is what I study a lot.”
Misi, one mile from Lilia, deliberately offered about 10 vegetables, 10 pastas, off-menu steak, and six gelatos, and despite concern it would compete with Lilia, it filled a waitlist of about 2,500 people nightly by being specific and intentional.
“We were going to have 10 vegetables and 10 pastas, off-menu steak, and that was it, and then we were going to create six gelatos.”
Feeney argues that the guest experience starts when a reservation is made, not when the guest walks in, so the restaurant has roughly 30 days of engagement to learn about the guest and prepare a personal experience.
“I don't think about it as it starts when you enter our doors. It starts when you do that reservation. What can we do in 30 days leading up until that point?”
Feeney argues that restaurant rent should be structured as a percentage of sales rather than a fixed price per square foot, because it turns the landlord into a true partner whose interests rise and fall with the operator's, and it protects the business during slow months and crises like the pandemic.
“I think it's a healthier relationship. It certainly helped us during the pandemic, where all of our restaurants were tied to a percentage of our sales, and we had zero.”
Feeney argues that an outsider who asks basic questions about how beverages, food, and payroll are purchased and managed can uncover inefficiencies, because insiders have stopped questioning practices that are simply accepted as the way things are done.
“this is just the way it is. And to me, I loved hearing that because, to me, it was people stopped looking for better ideas.”
Feeney says the goal is to build a brand that people chase, so that demand far exceeds supply, rather than a brand that chases guests; he argues this comes from being authentic about who you are and how you treat people.
“how do we build that out in a thoughtful way, that's authentic in us so that people are chasing the brand versus the brand chasing the guests?”
Feeney surveyed about 500 mostly close friends on the dining experience and found that 85 percent were upset after 15 minutes of waiting to be seated, 90 percent wanted drinks ordered within minutes, and 93 percent wanted to leave within 20 minutes of the dessert menu, and he used these thresholds to design the service flow.
“85% of the people said, after 15 minutes, I'm upset.”
When rent is a percentage of sales, the landlord becomes a true partner who is motivated to keep the space and sidewalks attractive and to help when problems arise, unlike a fixed-rent landlord who is simply collecting a set amount.
“the landlord partner is more excited to make sure that the space looks amazing, that the sidewalks clean and every time something happens, they're willing to help out.”
Feeney reports that the advice he received from industry contacts was that restaurant rent should not exceed about 8 percent of sales, which is the benchmark he used when deciding how to structure his own leases.
“everybody that I was going to asking what should we pay in rent was telling me, you shouldn't pay more than 8% of sales in your rent.”
Feeney defines hospitality as creativity plus compassion, starting from understanding who is walking through the door each night and why they are there, then tailoring the experience accordingly.
“the definition of hospitality is creativity plus compassion. So hospitality, it's how you make someone feel”
Feeney believes every person has a genius, meaning a deep strength tied to what comes naturally and what makes them jump out of bed, and that success comes from identifying and embracing it, not from job title or external measures.
“I believe that every single human is a genius and there is one inside of them.”
Feeney argues that real success is doing something every day that you are happy to do for the rest of your life, and that finance metrics like bonuses and promotions are only by-products of that.
“what success was, it was doing something every single day for the rest of your life. Happy to do it. That, to me, was success.”
Feeney argues that people are inspired by brands that understand why they exist rather than what they sell, and that Brunello Cucinelli's Solomeo made that visible to him through workplace rhythms, craft, and shared meals.
“I get inspired by people love brands when they understand why those brands exist, not what they are.”
Feeney says that Missy Robbins' mentor Tony Mantuano's principle, that the most important ingredient is the one left out, shapes how he thinks about building a brand by cutting noise and keeping things simple.
“The most important ingredient is the one left out, and it is the way she cooks.”
A new host quit repeatedly because she had to turn away guests, and Feeney found the skill was learning to say no warmly, so that disappointed guests still feel welcomed.
“figuring out a way to let people warmly feel, it can't happen right now, but we want it to happen, is an art.”
Feeney says his wife's unconditional belief and willingness to move the family to a smaller apartment so he could be present at the restaurants gave him the courage to risk being his true self.
“She gave me the courage to risk being my true self”
Feeney defines the perfect turn as a restaurant's hello, experience, and goodbye, timed so that guests feel well treated while the restaurant still runs efficiently, rather than simply rushing people through to maximize covers.
“The perfect turn was not getting people in and out as quickly as possible so we could do as many covers. It was getting people the perfect experience that they wanted”
Feeney argues that an intensely specific concept, such as Misi's vegetables, pasta, and six gelatos, can be more compelling and profitable than a broad menu, and that narrowing the offering is what makes a restaurant an amazing business.
“to me, we realized that it is an amazing business when you are so specific and intentional with the concept.”
Feeney argues that restaurant brands can scale through media and experiences outside physical restaurants, such as home products, villa experiences, and screen content, provided they keep the same feeling they create inside.
“How do you continue to create those moments in different mediums but make people feel the same? I think it's possible”
Feeney describes launching a pasta company through weekly Instagram drops, announced Friday with pickup the next day, which converted unmet restaurant waitlist demand into a retail product and created the same line-up effect as the restaurants.
“we would put the flavor of the sauce and the shape of the pasta on Instagram, 2:00 the next day, pick it up, we would make 100 and 250 people would line up.”
Feeney forecasts that restaurants will become smaller in footprint, menu, and team size, and argues that such restaurants can have as much neighborhood impact as large ones, because large teams and operations create human capital challenges.
“I believe that the future of these restaurants are just smaller.”
Feeney argues that giving team members a clear operating framework, such as target times for seating and drink service, and then letting them figure out how to hit it, builds ownership and reveals who will lead.
“It was almost like giving the framework to our team and saying, if you believe in this framework, get us there.”
Feeney says he told his team at Lilia's opening that success would be measured by whether people are proud to be part of the restaurant and whether guests leave excited to return, not by profit, stars, or reviews.
“the way we are going to measure success of Lilia is not by profitability, it's not by stars or reviews and acclaim. It's if you are proud to be a part of this.”
Feeney proposes that a neighborhood pizzeria should direct a share of revenue, around 3 percent, back into the neighborhood, and pair that with low-cost rewards like free pizza for reading books or volunteering, to build a loyal community.
“what if we took 3% of our revenue and put it really back into the neighborhood?”
Feeney says Fini polled 1,200 people and 94 percent wanted Williamsburg to be cleaner, which led the restaurant to buy and place branded trash cans around the neighborhood.
“94% of 1,200 people said they really wanted Williamsburg to be more clean”
Feeney argues that community initiatives should not be designed for press; they should be done because the company believes in them, and then the community may join, which creates a call to action that spreads organically.
“It's not to say we want press about it, or, we're doing this. What can you do? It's just doing something you believe in and then hoping that others get involved in it.”
Feeney argues that the best team innovations come from letting people pursue what excites them, as when a partner proposed bagels for Marathon Sunday after Feeney asked what he would want to make rather than assigning a dish.
“I didn't tell Will to make a white pizza where you would squeeze lemon on it. That became the most popular pizza in New York City.”
Feeney contrasts Jay-Z, who turned his fame into ownership of businesses, with DMX, who stayed in the performing mode, arguing that a brand should expand into ownership rather than simply taking fees as a sponsor.
“instead of taking fees to be a sponsor, how do I own brands?”
Feeney describes how a host who repeatedly struggled with saying no to guests was coached, then became a maitre d', then a content and photography leader who wrote her own job description, and argues that letting people grow into new roles is one of the company's best decisions.
“our best decision is when someone comes and says, I want to do this.”
Ronnie Fieg's Kith succeeds by making every customer and employee feel part of something, and by sustaining long-term collaborations rather than one-time events.
“He never does something for one time. I think that's also very inspiring for me as I think about a hospitality brand that can be bigger than just inside four walls.”
The Fini neighborhood pizzeria concept rests on three pillars: consistent, delicious pizza and Italian ice; hospitality that greets regulars by name; and returning about 3% of revenue to the neighborhood.
“what if we took 3% of our revenue and put it really back into the neighborhood?”
Feeney argues that the best outcome for staff is when they write their own job description after discovering a talent, because it allows them to grow inside the company rather than leave to pursue their passion elsewhere.
“our best decision is when someone comes and says, I want to do this.”
Feeney argues that restaurant finances can be kept simple by estimating sales, assigning each variable and fixed expense a percentage of projected sales, and working backward to see whether a target net margin is achievable.
“I thought if we had a certain amount of sales attributing each expense a percentage of sales so that you could back into a 20% net income at the end of the year.”
Feeney argues that guests return across life events such as first dates, engagements, weddings, funerals, and bad news, so a restaurant should see itself as a long-term companion in people's lives rather than a two-hour transaction.
“you're going to come here on your first date. You're going to come here when you get engaged. You're going to come here when you get married”
Feeney argues that the balance between creative expression and financial discipline is maintained through trust between partners, where operators commit to providing the chef with a large creative canvas in exchange for a healthy business.
“They are the artists. I needed them to believe me that if we can be this business, this healthy business, you will have the biggest canvas”
Feeney says he set a goal of 20 percent net income for his restaurant, against an average of about 8 percent profitability for New York restaurants at that time, and built a strict expense formula backward from that target.
“I was obsessed with 20% EBITDA net income for a restaurant. And the average profitability of restaurants at that time in New York City was 8%.”
Feeney argues that a restaurant's story and passion, shown through behind-the-scenes content, drive people to want to try a place more than any advertising, which is why Chef's Table style storytelling works as marketing.
“there's nothing that can make you want to try that thing more than that”
When Fini's team had to serve Marathon Sunday crowds, partner Will made bagels after learning from YouTube, and the 300 pre-ordered bagels sold out within 72 hours, which turned the Fini backroom into a testing ground for new products.
“We had 300 bagels made. It was insane. We put a preorder for Bagels for Marathon Sunday, sold out, and that became a test kitchen.”
Feeney reasoned that, like negotiating between two buyers for a high-yield bond, he could structure a deal that made a skilled chef's creative talent and his financial and operating capability complementary, and he pitched a partnership on that basis.
“it was then that it hit me to do it with her.”
Because all of Feeney's restaurant rents were tied to sales, the company's rent obligations fell to near zero during the pandemic when revenue went to zero, avoiding the difficult renegotiations many New York restaurants faced.
“all of our restaurants were tied to a percentage of our sales, and we had zero. So I didn't have to have these awkward conversations with landlords”
Feeney says his years in high-yield bond trading did not make him an extraordinary trader, but they gave him a clear, simplified way of thinking about restaurant economics that helped him build better businesses.
“my finance background, nothing in high-yield bond markets, helped me be a better restauranteur. It allowed me to think with a clear lens and try to keep it simple.”
Feeney says the mafaldine with pink peppercorn and Parmesan, created almost by accident during a test in his apartment, became the restaurant's signature dish, with about 200 bowls sold every night because its glistening pink look drove social sharing.
“we now sell 200 bowls of mafaldine, pink peppercorn and Parmesan cheese every single night.”
Feeney says that after receiving about 4,000 dollars in city fines for placing trash cans on curbs, he met with Sanitation Commissioner Jessica Tisch, who voided the tickets once he agreed to keep cans within three feet of buildings and to submit locations in advance.
“After an hour of conversation, she gave me the blessing and tore up the tickets.”
Feeney says he pitched a percent-of-sales lease projecting 3.5 million dollars in first-year sales, and the restaurant roughly doubled that figure, so the landlord ended up collecting more rent and the arrangement proved to be a true partnership.
“I thought we were going to do $3.5 million in sales in the first year, and I agreed to a percentage of sales, and we doubled that in the first year of sales.”
Feeney argues that opening another restaurant takes about two years start to finish, so the team chose to spend a year building a packaged pasta company to serve people who could not get reservations.
“instead of opening another restaurant that takes two years to do start to finish, maybe we could take a year to create our own company”
Feeney says that writing small, attainable goals on paper and crossing them off, then setting new ones, built the confidence and momentum that made him able to become a restaurant partner.
“it was putting little, small attainable goals on paper and watching myself cross them off. And as I would cross them off, I would set new ones.”
Pursuing stars, reviews, and awards as the measure of success in a craft can carry a high personal price, and a person's identity can become tied to outside validation.
“she attributed a lot of that success as a chef to stars and reviews, and acclaim. And that had a price.”
Feeney says the team used its reservation and floor management system to time guests' wait from check-in, so staff could step in before the 15-minute threshold when guests became upset.
“We had the control then to see on our technology of Resi, our floor management system.”
Fixed monthly rent is a structural burden for New York restaurants because January, February, and March are slow, so businesses must try to avoid bleeding in those months and recover in the remaining nine.
“It is a huge challenge for our industry in New York City to pay fixed rent all the time, especially when January and February and March, those are really slow months.”
Bonuses, promotions, and poaching offers were the wrong measures of success in finance because they never produced a sense of control or a feeling that the job was meaningful, and the fear of losing one's seat was constant.
“I always had a feeling in finance that if the music stopped, they would take my seat. I lived in that fear.”
Feeney describes Solomeo's schedule, with a midday shutoff of power and email, a shared lunch, and a firm end of day, and argues that such rhythms let people work hard and still have time for life, which he wants to emulate.
“Every day at 1:00, the lights get shut off. The power goes down, e-mails shut off.”
Feeney says the greatest reward has been realizing that neither he nor Missy Robbins could have built the restaurants alone, and that watching others gain confidence through a shared vision is a powerful force.
“one person or two people are not going to create your dream.”
Conventional wisdom in finance held that restaurants never return money to investors, but Feeney believed a systematic approach could make them profitable.
“Most of them said, don't do it. We've invested in restaurants. We never make any money back.”
Feeney says that when Lilia opened, the team's unpolished appearance did not matter; what built the brand was who they were and how they treated people, which aligned with the guests they wanted.
“But then when we did open, it was not about what we looked like. It was about who we were and how we treated others”
Feeney argues that restaurant operations are still extremely archaic and inefficient, and that the opportunities outside the restaurant walls remain a wide-open frontier for brands built inside restaurants.
“understanding the business side of restaurants, the operational side of restaurants, and how extremely archaic things still are.”
Feeney argues that the best creative outcomes come from freely tested accidents, such as using pink peppercorn instead of black, which led to a dish that became iconic.
“it was just serendipitous where it was this weird shape of pasta.”
Although other cities are investing in culinary arts and taking talent from New York, Feeney believes the local youth pipeline makes New York's hospitality talent pool better, not weaker, because those workers are committed to staying in the city.
“But I think it's even better than it was because we now have the youth of New York City who want to serve”
Missy Robbins left her executive chef role at 42 after twenty years of pursuing stars and acclaim, having depleted her finances and neglected her physical, mental, and family health, and she used a year off to rebuild.
“she was broken physically, mentally. She put everything she had into this craft”
Feeney argues that people often lack belief in themselves until someone else truly believes in them, and that when this belief arrives, it gives the courage to pursue a path one never thought possible.
“I hope that you find belief in yourself a lot when others believe in you. I didn't have that belief in myself until someone truly believed in me”
Feeney says that in his twenties he planned to retire early from finance, but he later realized that early retirement would leave him without purpose, so he now aims to keep doing meaningful work indefinitely.
“what would I possibly be happy doing at 45 years old when I don't have a job?”
Fini turned its trash-can initiative into a $208 Clean Streets menu item, and guests bought 15 cans through the restaurant, showing that community action can attract paying participation when it is presented as an opportunity rather than publicity.
“We've had five guests buy 15. Of the five guests, 15 of the cans have been purchased by guests of ours, which is awesome because it proves you could do it.”
Feeney argues that staff must read whether a table wants conversation or privacy, such as a business dinner versus a loud birthday group, and adjust engagement accordingly, because both groups should leave wanting to return.
“So if you're a guest and you're there for a party of two and it's a business dinner, we might not even know that, but we have to feel it.”
Feeney says his early pitch to Missy Robbins was based on belief in her rather than rescue, and he argues that the support offered to a founder works best when it is about enabling them to do what they already want.
“it wasn't even like we were saving her, but I just believed so deeply in someone”
Feeney says that social media and direct messages, not just face-to-face interaction, can change a person's day, and that a meaningful connection made through a post led him to take Instagram seriously for the restaurants.
“it wasn't just a face-to-face interaction that could change somebody's day. It was, what else? What other modes of communication or connection can really change the course of someone's day for the positive?”
Feeney's Fini backroom, a former backyard built into a skylit room, became his office, a test kitchen, and the Friends of Fini room, which turned an unused space into a gathering place for loyal supporters who bring gifts after first learning the stories.
“I never tell someone to bring a gift on their first time. I want them to see it.”
Despite 15 years as a successful trader, Feeney felt his finance job did not make him extraordinary and lived with the fear that losing his seat would end his career, which led him to measure success by bonuses and promotions rather than daily fulfillment.
“I always had a feeling in finance that if the music stopped, they would take my seat. I lived in that fear.”
Patrick argues that people who leave long finance careers for hospitality often succeed because they apply finance discipline to a new industry, leading to outcomes that are unusually strong.
“approach the new business, restaurants and food and hospitality in your case with all the lessons and what they've learned in finance applied to the new place”
Feeney argues that a restaurant should treat the dessert menu and check arrival as the start of the goodbye, with the bill signed within about 20 minutes, because any visible check signal from staff reveals an imperfect turn.
“any time I would ever see in the restaurant, somebody doing the check signal, that's imperfect.”
When two parties both want a high-yield bond, the seller can extract a higher price, and Feeney applied that logic to negotiating partnership terms with Robbins.
“if I have a bond that somebody really wants, especially if two people really want it, maybe I could get them to pay the price.”
Feeney says Missy Robbins does not plan her menu in advance, so he learned not to ask about the menu until about three days before an opening, and he sees this creative process as part of her genius.
“Missy is a chef, a creative, that does not plan her menu in advance. So when we open restaurants, I've learned not to ask her about the menu until three days before we open.”
After Robbins rejected a nine-page business plan within seconds, Feeney pursued the partnership nightly for four months, which turned a dismissed idea into a co-founded business.
“for four months, every single night I came home from Anchorage with something to talk to Missy about on why we should be partners.”
Patrick argues that stories about the passion behind a restaurant can be more powerful marketing than ads, and that the conversation itself made the restaurants appealing to listeners.
“this is the best possible marketing for a restaurant, because when you're letting on a story behind a thing and you see a passion”
Feeney says the team looked at 38 spaces in Manhattan and found all of them unworkable, and roughly 50 operators had already turned down the landlords, so the Williamsburg location was only found after a long search where the team could afford the rent.
“we looked at 38 places in Manhattan, all were just awful. We struck out, left and right. They were too expensive, probably 50 operators that were known said no to before us.”
Lilia had about 5,000 people on its waitlist each night and Misi about 2,500, a level of demand Feeney attributes to brand alignment and how the team treated people rather than to the restaurants' appearance or marketing.
“every single night, at Lilia, eight years later, we have 5,000 people on our waitlist. And Misi, our second restaurant, five years old, is 2,500 people a night”
Feeney's early offer of support to Robbins was based on his belief that his personal network would fill her restaurant nightly, and that belief eventually grew into a formal business partnership proposal.
“I believed when I said that that night, it meant, when you open your own restaurant, we'll be there every night. We will fill it up.”