Scott Belsky - Focus on the First Mile – [Invest Like the Best, EP. 213]
What this covers
Patrick talks with Scott Belsky, who co-founded Behance, sold it to Adobe, now runs product there, and invests as an angel. The first half is product craft. Belsky describes the hook a product needs in its opening seconds, which he calls window dressing, and why founders go wrong by showing newcomers the value power users enjoy. He explains the object model as the answer to where a user is, how they got there, and what to do next. He also covers progressive disclosure, ego analytics, and enterprise tools that help users look good to their bosses. A separate thread concerns long projects. He argues people are not wired for multi-year efforts, cites Teresa Amabile's research on progress and motivation, and recalls Behance's playful bets, such as eating meat off a fork if the team hit 100,000 members.
The second half widens to the economy. Belsky forecasts that creativity tooling will spread through enterprises as productivity tools once did, favoring web-based, collaborative software over specialist programs. He sketches "edu-ployment," where companies train, certify, and then route tradespeople to paid work. He also describes a "reverse franchise" that supplies a business stack in return for about 7 percent of future income. He expects individuals to outgrow firms, with some already raising hundreds of millions on their own, while companies act more like people. The most contested claims include his doubts about the return on higher education and his view that the interface layer will turn the technology beneath it into a commodity. His example is giving away screens for every kitchen.
Belsky argues that product success depends on engineering the 'first mile' of the user experience, because users start out lazy, vain, and selfish, and that creativity tools and individual 'soloists' will reshape how work, talent, and investing function.
- Every user's first 30 seconds are dominated by laziness, vanity, and selfishness, so onboarding must deliver immediate utility before long-term value
- Long projects survive only when teams are given short-term progress rewards and visible milestones
- Interface layers and individual creators will commoditize underlying technology and firms as the primary units of value
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Humans are not wired for multi-year projects, since they evolved for short-term rewards and a lifespan of around 25 years a century ago, so pursuing something without a foreseeable end is biologically unintuitive and leaders must hack reward systems to sustain long efforts.
“as humans, we're not wired to embark on multi-year projects, we're wired towards short-term rewards”
Harvard Business School professor Teresa Amabile's study of daily motivation journals found that progress begets progress, meaning people must feel they are making progress in order to make more progress, so leaders must merchandise and narrate the journey.
“her basic takeaway was that progress begets progress. You have to feel like you're making progress to make more progress.”
An A-level designer uses progressive disclosure, showing users only what they need when they need it, while a B designer shows everything beautifully; less noise produces more signal and better-informed users.
“an A-level designer, will only show you the things when you need to see them”
As algorithms and software automate much work, the value of humans shifts from productivity to creativity, which Belsky argues is the most human thing only people can do, so creativity tool deployment across the enterprise will resemble the productivity tool deployment of past decades.
“the most human thing that only we can do is to be creative”
Design will commoditize everything underneath because customers love technology for its user experience, so the interface layer determines product fate as much as or more than the underlying technology, and users will become agnostic to the underlying services.
“my argument was that design is going to commoditize everything underneath”
Garrett Camp sketched a car-summoning idea that started from design, eliminating navigation and reducing steps to a single click, which compelled Belsky because it solved the pain of the paper-based car-request process he had experienced at Goldman Sachs.
“he whipped out a sketch pad of this idea of summoning a car”
Higher education is one of the weirdest return-on-investment purchases because people pay a fortune and take on debt with no guarantee of career return, and career services amount to a job fair and good luck, so guaranteed-employment alternatives will compete with it.
“higher education has been one of the most weird kind of ROI type of investments people ever make, because they pay a fortune and go in debt for no guarantee of any return”
When people call themselves technophobes, they are often saying that a product's design language and object model are not native to them, rather than that they fear technology.
“maybe what they're really saying is that this design language and this object model of this product is not native to me”
In the first 30 seconds of any product experience, every user is lazy, vain, and selfish: they want everything done for them, do not want to read, and feel their time should not go to anything new, so products must craft hooks that get users past these tendencies.
“in the first 30 seconds of every product experience, every user is lazy, vain and selfish. They want everything to be done for them.”
Founders make the mistake of falling in love with their power customers and assuming that showing new customers the value power users get will attract them, when the new customers instead see that value as unachievable.
“we also fall in love with our power customers and we see the value they get”
Users have an insecurity at each moment that products must address: in enterprise it is job security and falling behind, and in social it is self-esteem, so good design makes people feel secure in what they are doing.
“I think another aspect of use psychology is really understanding the insecurity of a customer at every moment in time.”
Many individuals will become soloists who have all the benefits of a business back office but operate independently, while large companies will behave more like people, with leaders building known relationships and employees becoming visible social accounts.
“we're going to have a lot of individuals that we work with that have all of the benefits of a back office of being in a business, but are in fact soloists”
Window dressing is the immediate, attention-grabbing hook that gets customers in the door, and it must address laziness, vanity, and selfishness, because founders wrongly assume new customers can see the long-term value their power users get.
“The problem is that the new customers see that as unachievable for the 30 second moment that they're in.”
The object model of a product answers three questions for the user: where they are, how they got there, and what to do there and next; very few products get this right, and it determines whether users get lost when attention is diverted.
“I drop you somewhere, and do you know where you are? Do you know A, how you got there, B, what you're supposed to do there, and C, what you're supposed to do next?”
A reverse franchise model gives a tradesperson a full modern business stack, including payments, SEO, and marketing, in exchange for roughly 7 percent of their future income, letting them grow with the latest technology without needing to understand those functions.
“in exchange for making about 7% of your income going forward, we'll get you on the full latest stack of everything”
A consumer electronics company should offer free screens in every kitchen because owning the indispensable household screen would let it control the interface through which families make purchases and requests, making the underlying services interchangeable.
“I would offer to install screens in every kitchen for free, because if you could own the indispensable real estate of a family, which is the screen”
Even cumbersome enterprise products succeed when they help users look good to their bosses, so enterprise products should offer editable, beautiful exports that users can rebrand and send to management as their own analysis.
“even the most cumbersome enterprise products I believe are successful when they make their users look good to their bosses”
Edu-ployment is a trend where companies recruit students to learn a trade, such as painting or appliance repair, certify them, and then route the newly certified workers to paid demand, creating a vertically integrated stack of education and employment.
“companies will basically solicit students for a trade to learn”
Users want to see and know they are succeeding, which Belsky calls ego analytics, so products should provide dashboards and instant feedback, and the same mechanisms can be addictive and need careful evolution.
“People want to know and see that they are being successful. And I always like to say that... I call it 'ego analytics.'”
Behance used playful bets, such as Belsky eating meat off a fork if the team reached 100,000 members, to create short-circuited rewards that pushed the team in the right direction while real progress was absent.
“It wasn't real, but it was actually pushing us in the right direction.”
Individuals can now build reputations and audiences directly on social platforms by sharing insights, removing the need for firm names as credibility shields and back-office support, so people emerge as thought leaders even anonymously.
“Now, you build your reputation based on the knowledge that you share.”
Talented individuals inside firms leave when the firm does not give them good economics, because they realize they win deals because of who they are rather than the firm's brand, and some individuals are raising hundreds of millions on their own.
“they realize that they're getting deals because of who they are, not because of who the firm is”
Enterprises should not train everyone on Photoshop and Illustrator but instead provide content-first, collaboration-first web tools, and templates synced to brand defaults would let non-creative staff produce consistent assets in real time.
“we can't rely on training everyone to use products like Photoshop and Illustrator. We have to have content first and collaboration first experiences via web”
Creativity tool deployment across the enterprise will follow the same trajectory as productivity tool deployment in past decades, shifting away from specialist creative software toward content-first and collaboration-first web experiences.
“there is a moment where the creativity tool deployment across the enterprise will be much like the productivity tool deployment”
Products should first deliver immediate, concrete utility to get people to try them, as Pinterest did by offering a way to collect things, and only then convince users of future utility they do not yet get.
“let's make sure that we come over the top with the utility for you before we try to you convinced that there's future utility that you won't get now”
Teams should not reinvent familiar interface patterns because familiar patterns breed utilization, and an unfamiliar pattern should be introduced only when truly innovating on something that never existed, otherwise following established patterns like Facebook's.
“don't reinvent familiar things. Familiar patterns are your friend. They breed utilization.”
A first-mile experience that works for one cohort of customers stops working as each new cohort differs, as Twitter illustrated when its follow-to-curate experience worked for early power users but broke down once a broader cohort wanted news, requiring the company to lean into topics.
“once you get a first mile, that's working in a product, it doesn't mean it will continue working because every cohort of new customers is different”
Behance avoided the words creativity and inspiration because creatives already have too many ideas and need focus on execution, so it positioned itself on portfolio discovery for job leads rather than inspiration.
“the last thing creatives need more of is creativity. They don't need more inspiration.”
Every product is the DNA of its team, so how a founder demonstrates a product reveals whether the team has product leadership that will care about the first mile, and a founder who starts in the middle of the product signals poor object model thinking.
“every product is sort of the DNA of its team”
Because all customers will ever experience is what they see first at the top of the funnel, the default landing state and first-time copy determine the whole customer experience, yet startups often make these as last-minute decisions.
“whatever a customer or potential customer sees first at the top of the funnel is the only thing that all customers will ever experience and then it's just downhill from there”
The default state a user lands in is what roughly 80 percent of customers will always see, so defaults like the LinkedIn welcome interstitial that nobody closes can persist for years unless they are designed deliberately.
“Wherever you land and whatever is there is what 80% of all customers will always see.”
Operating a state-of-the-art solo business now requires a full stack from five to ten vendors that can be obtained for roughly 30 to 50 dollars per month, removing the back-office barrier that previously required a firm.
“we can all get for maybe paying between $30 and $50 bucks a month from five to 10 different vendors”
Belsky holds a strong investment thesis that empowering the soloist will crack every vertical, so he seeks businesses letting individuals operate independently, such as CRM and lead generation tools, while big companies will behave more like people with known leaders.
“I have a very strong thesis around this empowerment of the soloist, and how that will crack every vertical.”
Voice interfaces like Alexa and Siri are disruptive because users will say they need a ride and accept whichever car shows up, which makes the competing underlying service interchangeable and potentially destructive to incumbents.
“Those interfaces are disruptive because they're audio, and if those interfaces then send that request down to a layer that competes”
For disciplines like law, accounting, and venture capital, clients care about the specific person rather than the firm, so founders would rather say their investor is a named individual than the legal entity behind them.
“In certain disciplines, it's all about the person.”
The unsung heroes of great companies are early customers who are willing and forgiving despite having no equity, and teams should prioritize acquiring these customers first because their feedback supplies the early satisfaction that keeps teams going.
“the unsung heroes of a lot of great companies out there are the early customers that for whatever reason, were so willing and forgiving to lean in”
Some designers make things look beautiful but without a clear object model, so the user cannot tell how they got there or what to do next; the best designers combine empathy and product sensibility to build states and progressive disclosure.
“they make things look beautiful, but the object model is not there”
Adobe's subscription model lets it get people in the door and then add value over time, but because competitors offer easier first miles, Adobe must continually reinvent its own first-mile experience rather than relying on the indispensability of legacy tools.
“We have to reinvent our first mile. That's why I love being a subscription business”
Nana trains certified appliance technicians because manufacturers like Whirlpool receive a large volume of inbound repair requests and are willing to offload that demand to certified third-party providers rather than operate service businesses themselves.
“these manufacturers get so much inbound from customers with problems, and then they're not in the business of service”
AI travel sites show a thinking icon and make users wait about six seconds not because they need processing time but to make users feel the computer is searching and to build confidence in the result.
“It's doing that not because it needs processing time. It's doing that because it's making you believe and feel secure in the result.”
Startups' competitive advantage is sticking together long enough to figure things out, because with the right people you will keep iterating until you find the right idea even if you start without it.
“Believing that the competitive advantage of startups is just sticking together long enough to figure it out if you have the right people.”
When a high share of users who show engagement signals fail to take the next step, such as 95 percent failing to proceed from a landing page, there is a concrete reason to diagnose and then test changes against empathy questions about utility, security, laziness, vanity, and selfishness.
“If 95% of people that come to a landing page and have certain behaviors that suggest that they're engaged enough to take the next step are not taking the next step, there is a concrete reason.”
At Adobe's Creative Cloud, the team mapped every screen of the signup experience and built personalized paths based on what they could detect and what users told them, with fallback help paths for users who stopped or struggled, and this required heavy funnel dissection to derive personas and journeys where customers get lost.
“how do we build a personalized experience for them based on their 'first mile' and what we can detect and what they tell us?”
The first mile of product experience is woefully neglected, underestimated, and under-invested in, even though it is the only experience every customer will ever have, and marketing copy, email frequency, and notifications should all be anchored to what the user feels.
“the first mile of product experience, which I think is woefully neglected and underestimated and under-invested in”
When meeting founders on Zoom, Belsky jumps straight into the product rather than the pitch, because how a founder unveils the product indicates whether the team understands the customer journey.
“when I get on a Zoom or meet with a founder, I just want to jump into his or her product quickly”
Stripe succeeded by letting developers get payments into their product with only two lines of code, appealing to laziness, and then by letting them achieve payments quickly, appealing to vanity.
“They were like developers with only two lines of code, you can get payments into your product.”
Mobile games have finely tuned feedback loops that make users feel they are learning rapidly, and Belsky's view is that the same user progress concept applies to every product including enterprise.
“it's amazing how finely tuned the feedback loops are in the best, say mobile games”
Great design is manifested as small things that make a big difference, such as clear mute indicators and active versus inactive states, because these nuances fuel or release user anxiety about decisions.
“great design is ultimately manifested as small things that make a big difference”
Product building is a sequence of trade-offs in which teams must decide which problems to optimize later and which to solve now, since reality always imposes constraints.
“the reality is always trade-offs, which problems you want to optimize to have later and which ones you have to solve now”
Owning the interface gives a company the front door to user intent, the lowest-friction place to fulfill a need, which connects back to the first mile: the winner is whoever captures intent first.
“You do, and it goes back to the power designers.”
Liberal arts style learning may come from other sources as people can access MasterClass and other online knowledge sources, so people could augment their development personally rather than paying a fortune for traditional college.
“Maybe those learnings come from other sources. We're all online these days.”
Companies like Apple and Google may resist releasing APIs that let outside companies compete beneath the interface, but Belsky believes they will have to, because the interface war is a competition for the better and more accessible interface.
“Maybe not now, but I think they're going to have to, because the interface war is like a slap of hand game.”
Book covers and titles function like window dressing: an illustrator's clever cover determines whether a reader opens a book containing 300 pages of research, so the art of getting someone to read the first page is distinct from the purposeful long-term vision.
“whatever the illustrator that you're working with and the publisher thinks is clever, ends up being the representation of 300 pages worth of insights”
Big companies will not go away but will start behaving more like people, with leaders having known relationships with customers and more social media accounts for employees than corporate shingles.
“I don't think big companies are going away. I actually think, though, that they're going to start to behave more as people”
Creativity cannot remain an art class on Fridays; it must permeate the curriculum, so history reports should become multimedia presentations that teach video and audio tools for future-proof careers.
“It can't be art class on Fridays anymore. This has to permeate the curriculum.”
A large-fund venture capitalist must foresee what could go wrong because they manage large sums, whereas a seed investor or product person needs to see the potential of something to get excited, which is why Belsky sees himself as an eternal optimist rather than a classic VC.
“as a seed investor or a product person like me, you just have to see the potential of something to get excited”
Oreo's 'you can still dunk in the dark' post during the Super Bowl blackout shows that social marketers with templates and brand elements can produce real-time assets that professional creative teams could not, making real-time marketing a likely future.
“within 30 seconds, the Oreo social media accounts tweeted and posted, 'You can still dunk in the dark.'”
When hiring at Adobe, Belsky looks for people who can step back and understand where a customer is in their journey, because a product that carries a learning curve as a badge of honor will be displaced by competitors with easier entry.
“I also want people who can take a step back and kind of understand the context of where a customer is in their journey”
A prototype is worth a hundred meetings, and the greatest product failures happen when teams build from passion for a problem rather than empathy for the people suffering from it, so builders must get shoulder to shoulder with customers.
“I've always believed that a prototype is worth a hundred meetings. And the greatest failings I've seen in the product world, including my own, are when you build something out of passion for a problem rather than have empathy with those suffering from the problem.”
The kindest thing someone can do is make time for others when there is clearly nothing in it for them, as leaders did for Belsky as a high school or business school student, and he now tries to prioritize that pay-it-forward gesture.
“I think the kindest thing is really to make time when there's clearly nothing in it for them.”
Verified and Better Business Bureau badges on early e-commerce sites were mostly used without real certification, yet they existed to make customers feel safe enough to click through, and they faded because everyone used them.
“what they were there for is to make you feel safe, so you would click that button and proceed”
Behance was bootstrapped for five years before raising its first round from Union Square Ventures and angels including Jeff Bezos and Chris Dixon, and it operated hand to mouth through 2008, so Belsky's job was keeping the team together and cranking.
“we were bootstrapped for five years before raising our first round of capital from Union Square Ventures and folks like Jeff Bezos and Chris Dixon”
Augmented reality experiences similar to Pokemon GO, including scavenger hunts for hidden Bitcoins, were teed up by technology but went dormant during the pandemic and are poised to resurge.
“Just think Pokemon GO, but think doing scavenger hunts to find hidden Bitcoins”
Belsky predicts the decade after COVID will be explosive and adventurous, with pent-up demand for experiences and self-expression, citing Rent the Runway planning for 2022 and 2023 fashion as evidence.
“there's almost a culture-bending aspect of the resurgence that we're all going to have of the roaring '20s”
Behance treated getting Google to stop suggesting enhance for its name as a short-term goal, achieved by earning blog posts and link backs to portfolios that made Behance a legitimate search result within six to eight months.
“let's just get enough blog posts and enough link backs to portfolios that were a legitimate search result”
Behance lost its Google search ranking a year later when Beyonce became popular, then regained it.
“Beyonce became super popular a year later and we lost all over again”
Patrick summarizes the episode as ten great lessons on building products and respecting users.
“I think it's a great set of lessons”