Robert Smith - Investing in Enterprise Software - [Invest Like the Best, EP.291]
What this covers
Patrick O'Shaughnessy interviews Robert Smith, the engineer who founded Vista Equity Partners, about how a software-only investment firm is built and run. The conversation opens on the market itself. The shift from on-premise to cloud computing turned equipment spending into operating expense. Talent is the binding constraint, with roughly 29 million professional coders among 7.5 billion people. Smith also argues that many multibillion-dollar companies began by digitizing manual workflows. Looking ahead, he expects analytics applied to that digitized data, the second-order effect of software, to produce gains orders of magnitude beyond those so far.
The middle of the episode is operating detail. Smith describes Vista's three legs: about 150 investment professionals, a consulting group that codifies lessons from nearly 600 transactions, and direct training of management teams. He explains how more than 100 best practices get sequenced into 8 to 10 immediate actions, then 20 more, then 30. He notes that the leader who takes a company from $50 million to $100 million in ARR may not be the one to reach $400 million. He also gives deal-flow figures: 71% of recent deals were founder-influenced, and Vista won about 60% of contested deals even against higher bids, which he credits to the founder referral network.
The third stretch concerns valuation and timing. Vista prices on a growth-adjusted revenue multiple that ran from about 0.43 to a peak near 0.93 and back to about 0.41. Smith says Vista took six companies public in the 2020–21 froth, then bought private companies at roughly half the market multiple. Patrick presses on matching a firm's capital base to the capital cycle. Smith names winner-take-most uncertainty as Vista's largest intentional risk. He closes on philanthropy, including foster-care fellowships and broadband for historically black colleges.
Smith argues enterprise software is a systemically underpenetrated, high-ROI category, and that Vista's edge comes from an engineered operating system for improving acquired companies (especially managing technical debt and retention) rather than from buying at cyclical lows.
- Enterprise software delivers very high measured customer ROI (average 640%), so customers keep buying more of it.
- Failed software companies usually accumulate technical debt that investors overlook, and Vista screens for it.
- Vista's founder-friendly reputation and systematic post-acquisition improvement win contested deals even at lower prices.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Among foster care students, 65% want to attend college, 35% apply, and only 3% graduate, and Smith's Family Fellowship program has helped 49 of 50 participants graduate.
“65% of foster care students want to go to college. Only 35% apply and only 3% graduate.”
About 82% of historically black colleges and universities are in a broadband desert, so students cannot participate in the digital economy without connectivity, and upgrading all HBCUs at no cost to them serves over 300,000 students a year.
“82% of the historically black colleges and universities are actually in a broadband desert”
The move from on-premise software to public and private cloud converted customers' major cost from capital expenditure on equipment to operating expense on computing capacity bought from superscalers such as AWS, Azure, and Oracle, and this enabled faster innovation and cloud-native architectures.
“a big part of the cost was the operating cost characterized by capital cost of buying equipment. And today, it is truly operating cost”
Vista prices software companies with a growth-adjusted revenue multiple, dividing the price-to-revenue multiple by the growth rate (a revenue analogue to the PEG ratio); the overall market averaged about 0.43 in the first half of the decade, peaked near 0.93 in the recent frothy period, and fell back toward about 0.41.
“Rather than earnings, for a fast-growing software company, use revenue. So you do that, and you divide it basically by the growth rate of that business.”
The main constraint on enterprise software growth is talent: about 7.5 billion people exist, but only about 29 million of them write code for a living, even though software now runs nearly every business.
“7.5 billion people on the planet, there's only 29 million of us who write code for a living.”
Enterprise software is still early in its adoption; historically the rate-limiting step was access to computing power, which moved from governments and large corporations through minicomputers and cloud platforms, and many multibillion-dollar software companies started by merely digitizing manual workflows.
“we are in the early innings of this. You have to remember, in the early days, the access to computing power was the rate-limiting step.”
Enterprise software companies that fail or face financial trouble typically carry too much technical debt, which compounds as code accumulates flaws and architectural idiosyncrasies that force costly rework on every upgrade, and most outside investors underweight this risk.
“technical debt is compounding. And as you write code over a year, 5 years or 10 years or 20 years, often, if you don't take the right product development approach to it, you create a tremendous amount of code that has some flaws.”
Many management teams do not understand how much technical debt their companies carry and keep spending more resources maintaining the existing code base while losing ground every day, treating the cost as ordinary cost of doing business.
“They just figure it's just the cost of doing business.”
In deals where other buyers were involved, Vista won about 60% of contested deals even when competing bids were higher, which Smith attributes to founders valuing how Vista will run the business after the transaction, not only price.
“of the deals that were contested, almost 60% of them came our way, even though there were people who had higher bids.”
The second-order effect of enterprise software is the data it digitizes, and the analytics applied to that data, not the systems of record themselves, is where the next real productivity expansion will come, especially when multiple systems are combined to show what customers actually do.
“If you think about it, I call it the second order effect of enterprise software, which is data. The analytics of that data is in its infancy.”
About 71% of Vista's recent deals were founder-influenced, and over half of its deals were non-processed, meaning Vista had access without a competitive auction because founders who had sold to Vista referred others.
“over half of the deals that we did were non-processed deals, meaning we had access when no one in the market did.”
Vista's core principle is to build systemic, engineered solutions that scale, with feedback and feedforward mechanisms that are constantly active, rather than episodic fixes that are applied only when a problem appears.
“The most important thing to think about in our firm is we focus on building systemic solutions that can scale. Engineer mindset isn't, what I call, an episodic fix but an engineered solution.”
Digitized operational data is now accessible across systems, and the analytics layer (predictive and algorithmic recommendations, combining multiple platforms to reveal customer buying patterns) is still in its infancy, and Smith believes it will generate productivity gains orders of magnitude larger than those seen to date.
“The analytics of that data is in its infancy. And that is where the actual true expansion of productivity will now come.”
Vista measures the average return on investment of the products it sells each year and finds it is about 640% for the average customer, with small to medium businesses higher and enterprise customers around 900%, so the next incremental dollar for almost any business is best spent on buying more software.
“The average ROI of the products that we sell to our average customer is 640% ROI.”
Vista's investing model rests on three legs: about 150 investment professionals seeking mission-critical enterprise software companies, a Vista Consulting Group that codifies best practices from nearly 600 transactions over 22 years, and close work with management teams to train and inform them.
“The second leg of this is a group called Vista Consulting Group, VCG, our value creation group”
Vista took six companies public during the frothy 2020 to 2021 valuation peak, the period when it had not previously taken companies public, and then bought mostly private companies in the subsequent downturn at prices about half the market's growth-adjusted multiple.
“We took 6 companies public during that run, selling into those robust markets.”
Vista maintains buying discipline at valuations it considers sensible regardless of where the capital cycle suggests the market is, because it seeks to create alpha by changing how acquired businesses approach the market and expand their opportunity set.
“we like to maintain discipline in buying at valuations that, from our perspective, make a tremendous amount of sense, irrespective of where the cycle might suggest that you are.”
A firm's capital base has to match its opportunity set, otherwise it cannot sell into froth and buy from despondency, which means the capital structure must be designed around the cycle.
“the capital base has to match the opportunity set. Otherwise, you're not going to be able to do those things you just said”
When customers churn, the first question is whether they chose a competing solution or went out of business, and if they went out of business, whether the industry has an underlying problem; Vista analyzes churn granularly by geography, segment, customer, and customer size to decide where to invest.
“Is it because the customers picked another solution or they went out of business?”
Vista develops investment and operating talent by bringing people from varied backgrounds and training them internally, rather than recruiting high-fliers from other firms, which Smith believes builds a culture of accountability, excellence, and long-term economic benefit.
“we do a lot of what I call building from the draft and not the trade”
Innovation across a broad portfolio requires built infrastructure rather than episodic effort, such as Vista's Best Practice Sharing Summits (26 planned this year) where 421 senior product and technology people from 78 portfolio companies met for three days across five tracks including hackathons.
“you have to build systemic infrastructure where innovation can occur.”
Vista's paranoia takes the form of a continuous bug-fixing culture in which every meeting asks what can be tuned, and issues are routed to committees that revisit them early and often, deciding whether the fix is small or an organizational change.
“I love our bug-fixing culture. As effective as we are on certain things, every time we are getting together and having a meeting, we're talking about”
Vista's largest intentional risk is building or buying into an emerging enterprise software space where winner-take-most dynamics mean the eventual winner is unclear, because the winner may be determined by capital, management, or regulation rather than things Vista controls.
“enterprise software still is kind of winner-take-most type of markets. Sometimes, they're very attractive, very interesting, and you're not quite sure who's going to be the winner just yet.”
When an enterprise software company loses large amounts of money on its small-to-medium business segment, that loss can prevent growth in the enterprise business, so a diagnosis of segment economics can justify restructuring.
“you're losing so much money on the small to medium business that, I mean, it actually takes away your ability to grow your enterprise business.”
Vista designs compensation so that team members share economic outcomes across funds and invest in developing peers, creating a collegial environment and behavior pattern that supports endurance in an investing franchise.
“shared, in many cases, economic outcomes by funds is one of the ways organization you'd like to design the way that we compensate our team”
Vista maintains over 100 operational best practices and, when underwriting a company, sequences them into roughly 8 to 10 things to do immediately, the next 20 within a couple of years, and another 30 if it holds the company long enough, under a continuous-improvement system rather than one-off fixes.
“We've got over 100 of these best practices. And when we're underwriting a business, we'll end up with, "Okay, here are the 8 to 10 that we really have to do right now.”
Vista's sector specialization in enterprise software, rather than oil and gas or insurance, makes it a more credible steward for founders who want all stakeholders considered when the business passes to the next owner.
“We do one thing. So we're actually pretty good at it. ... Some people just want to sell to the highest price, but others want to see that all the stakeholders in that business ultimately are thought about”
Vista avoids software categories, such as pharmaceuticals, where highly concentrated end customers gain market power over how the software and its code evolve, and instead prefers broadly distributed customer bases with low concentration risk and high ROI.
“where, often, the end user environment is so concentrated, they actually have the market power in how that software and that code advances”
Early Vista operational work changes business processes, organizational design, and sometimes management, because the leader who grows a company from $50 million to $100 million in ARR may not be the right person to scale it from $100 million to $400 million.
“someone who was great helping you grow your business from $50 million in ARR to $100 million may not be the right person to go from $100 million to $400 million”
Vista has built customized vehicles that keep limited partners invested in enterprise software when they realize they were under-allocated, reconciling the LPs' allocation cycles with private equity's episodic fundraising cycle.
“clients who realized over time that they were under-invested in enterprise software. So we've come up with some unique solutions”
Software ROI is measurable with simple arithmetic: a payroll system's value can be computed by counting payroll clerks no longer needed plus the cost, and robotic process automation for reconciliations produces very large ROI relative to manual 'swivel chair' work.
“It's math at the end of the day, and you've got to have some analytics around the math.”
Vista underwrites deals to the critical success factors that are under its control, meaning capabilities it has done before in enterprise software, and treats unforeseen external shocks as the residual risk.
“we think about really focusing on underwriting to critical factors for success being under our control”
Digital access is an on-ramp that gates educational opportunity, health equity, and wealth creation, so solving the digital divide is a systemic lever for broader equal opportunity and national productivity.
“And those things, to me, require on-ramps. And one of the most important on-ramps is this digital divide on-ramp.”
Because LPs' allocations change with their organization, capital available, and past investments, managers must stay in close communication with them and build creative solutions, such as vehicles that keep clients invested in enterprise software despite the episodic fundraising cycle of private equity.
“there's episodic fundraising. That's a cycle that you live in, in the world of private equity, and it's a different cycle than what the LPs are in.”
Introducing computing into chemical process plants replaced periodic, human-timed observation and adjustment with measuring system output thousands of times per second and adjusting inputs at a similar rate, which eliminated a tremendous amount of waste in process industries.
“you're actually measuring the output of a system thousands of times a second, which gives you the ability to then make changes to the inputs at a similar rate”
About 70% of Vista's deals are founder-managed businesses, and about 90% of those founders remain involved with Vista's ecosystem, either at their companies or on other boards.
“About 70% of the deals we do at Vista, believe it or not, are founder-managed businesses. And 90% of those founders are still with us some place in our ecosystem”
Vista's overall portfolio, which Smith says would rank as roughly the fifth-largest enterprise software company if combined, has maintained a 104% net dollar retention rate over the last two years, which he cites as evidence the product creates value even in a recessionary environment.
“it's a 104% net retention rate. Think about that. That's pretty staggering”
Vista's senior team would most debate where to stand up the next center of excellence (options include Mexico, Canada, Australia, and the Middle East) given the war for talent, because portfolio companies need to hire hundreds of people in 18 months and the U.S. lacks enough participants and immigration policies that could fuel growth.
“Where do you invest in your centers of excellence capacity to expand the market opportunity for our businesses?”
Enterprise software companies whose products are mission-critical or business-critical tend to have high retention and visible recurring revenue, and quality assessment should weigh customer relationships, product superiority, and execution excellence.
“if you run them well, you'll have high retention rates with your customers. You'll be able to have businesses that have visible recurring revenue components”
When college dorms close during holidays, aged-out foster students lose the group home bed that would normally be paid for, pushing many into homeless shelters, which Smith's program addresses by providing a holiday facility.
“so these kids often go to homeless shelters”
Because private deals require both buyer and seller to agree, negotiation and sales skills matter far more in private equity than in public equities, where a buyer can simply purchase shares.
“One of the great features of what you do is that it's a double opt-in process. You can't just hit buy. Someone has to also hit sell.”
Vista has best practices for reducing and eventually eliminating technical debt, and Smith considers this one of the more liberating levers available to managers of software businesses.
“We have a whole set of best practices around reducing and then ultimately eliminating technical debt. To me, that is one of the more liberating elements that one can do in managing these businesses.”
Central governments' stimulus since the Great Financial Crisis, accelerated during COVID, flooded global equity, credit, and liquidity markets with capital, inflating software valuations, and investors must be thoughtful about this capital cycle.
“We had a massive amount of capital that flooded the global economic environment, frankly, since the great financial crisis, accelerated during COVID.”
Enterprise software has been identified as the most productive tool introduced into the business economy over the last 50 years and likely the next 50, because it digitizes, automates, and increasingly uses AI to aid decisions across business workflows.
“that is enterprise software, business software that ultimately has now been identified as the most productive tool introduced in our business economy over the last 50 years and likely for the next 50”
Smith says he does not dwell on mistakes and that Vista's regrets are about whether it should have acted more aggressively, since leaders must lean forward and decide based on the information available at the time.
“You've got to lean forward and take the best decisions based on the information that you have at the time.”
Vista's exclusive focus on enterprise software means its operating and private equity teams are expert in one domain, which makes founders prefer it to generalist buyers because they believe it will best develop the company.
“We're in enterprise software. I'm not investing in oil and gas 1 day and insurance accounting. We do one thing. So we're actually pretty good at it.”
The Student Freedom Initiative lets students at HBCUs and minority-serving institutions borrow from a fund and repay the fund rather than the government, so repayments are recycled to the next generation of students.
“providing through the Student Freedom Initiative a fund where students from HBCUs and MSIs can borrow money from this fund, and they don't pay it back to the government.”
An organization that drives change in its portfolio companies must also be internally accustomed to change, so Vista applies the same innovation methods to its own capital structure and value-creation methodology.
“If you're an organization that focuses on creating change for other organizations, i.e., portfolio of companies, you darn well better have the DNA internally that you are accustomed to change as well.”
Vista measures greenhouse gases across its entire portfolio, sets reduction targets, and offsets emissions, with 100% of its majority-owned companies not being exited having signed the Vista Climate Pledge, which enables portfolio-wide offsets.
“we are one of the few firms that actually now has the ability to measure and do measure all of our greenhouse gases across all of our portfolio of companies”
Smith argues that opportunity gaps in education, health equity, and wealth creation can be closed by building on-ramps such as digital access, and that corporate resources should be brought to solve them, through initiatives such as the Southern Communities Initiative and the Student Freedom Initiative.
“Let's bring corporate resources to solve those problems.”
The kindest thing done for Smith was that friends, family, and colleagues forgave a humbling mistake in a deal over 20 years ago, which had been resolved with the government, and encouraged him to keep going.
“that power of forgiveness is so powerful and that power of love is so powerful in the world we live in”
Vista's main regret is that it should have expanded its non-U.S. platform more aggressively given the rapid global distribution of computing power through the superscalers, since it opened only a couple of non-U.S. offices early on, and cybersecurity can never be fully won.
“we have a couple of non-U.S. offices open, but I would look at that and say, "Should we have been more aggressive in that dynamic?"”
Restructuring a sales force by centralizing field salespeople in one location, rather than distributing them, is harder but builds deeper customer relationships, and such simple operational changes often matter most.
“Some people will have all their field salespeople in one location as opposed to distributing them. It's harder to do it that way. But if you do it that way, you get deeper relationships with the customers.”
Patrick compares Vista's preference for founders' businesses to the Berkshire Hathaway model of offering sellers a good home, implying the price is less decisive than the post-acquisition environment.
“It's like the old Berkshire thing, like it's a good home.”
By Smith's count, Vista owns the largest number of cloud-native software companies, a category that barely existed 8 to 15 years ago and that offers more flexibility to innovate and grow faster.
“I think we own now the largest number of these cloud-native software companies based on our count”
Over the last couple of years Vista invested about $18.8 billion and returned about $18.2 billion, showing it remains active in both buying and selling even while disciplined about entry prices.
“over the last 2 years, we invested $18 billion and returned $18 billion, invested, I think, it was $18.8 billion, almost $19 billion and returned $18.2 billion”
If forced to name one investor to whom he would entrust all his capital outside Vista, Smith would name William Heard, a thoughtful public-market investor with a systemic approach, though he would probably not put everything in public markets.
“There's one young man who I really, really like.”
After extreme froth in enterprise software valuations over the prior two years, public multiples have come back down to roughly their long-term norm, which Patrick notes and Smith uses to argue for current buying.
“the prior 2 years has been the most frothy from a valuation perspective that we've seen in the history of enterprise software”
Higher inflation and Fed tightening are slowing consumer businesses disproportionately, which releases talent in the U.S. labor market for enterprise software companies, though not enough to meet their growth needs.
“some of the consumer businesses, I think you know, those are getting hit disproportionately harder in this current environment of higher inflation and the Fed really looking to dampen those inflation dynamics.”
Patrick notes that Sequoia's partnership culture is perpetually paranoid about not seeing the next thing, and asks whether Vista has a similar insecurity.
“the partnership there has been perpetually paranoid at not seeing the next thing, resting on their laurels and so on.”
Vista's portfolio includes more than 80 software companies, about 300 million users, roughly 2.2 million customers, and over 800,000 enterprise and 1.4 million SMB customers.
“we have 80-plus software companies, 300 million users of our software”