Peter Fenton & Victor Lazarte - Purpose and Partnership - [Invest Like the Best, EP.354]
What this covers
The host, Patrick O'Shaughnessy, talks with two Benchmark general partners: Peter Fenton, the longest-serving, and Victor Lazarte, the newest, who spent a decade building Wildlife Studios and now has Peter on its board. The conversation alternates between how Benchmark is built and what it is like to move from operator to investor. Peter says the firm has no investment memos or formal sourcing process, and that it shrank back to four to six partners after seven or eight made dinners splinter, a stretch that coincided with Uber, Instagram and Twitter. He also calls venture a model that risks buying relationships with capital.
The middle of the episode covers a lot of ground. Peter lays out a Three Drives Framework for founders (aggression, pleasure, and a generative drive) and applies it to who endures through a distribution disruption. On AI he makes contested forecasts: application companies that sell work rather than seats and compete for OpEx budgets, a developer ecosystem that yields several half-trillion-dollar companies, and incumbents whose distribution edge is weaker than assumed. He also argues for overlooked public companies as 10x candidates, and for a future company that addresses social media's harms.
Victor supplies the gaming perspective. He discusses free-to-play as the practical default, games that evolve earlier mechanics (League of Legends from Dota, Monopoly GO from Coin Master), and why profitability gets hard once organic downloads give way to paid acquisition. He also describes a board member's core job as amplifying founder ambition.
Benchmark's edge comes from a small, equal partnership that keeps ego out of the firm and competes on founder trust rather than capital, and the same logic applies to founders, whose generative drive, not wealth or tailwinds, sustains great companies.
- Small fixed partner count and accepting the firm's finitude prevent ego-driven hierarchy and complacency
- Small fund size and trust-based relationships (not checks) are the source of founder access and returns
- Founders sustain greatness by protecting generative drive against pleasure and aggression, supported by a culture that rewards purpose
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Companies run as infinite games, where talent flows through the founder rather than being owned and beaten, do not produce a feeling of never having enough; the happiness is in the pursuit rather than the pursuit of happiness.
“when you're in the infinite game where there's -- the company is a manifestation of what you want to contribute to the world”
LLMs combined with enterprise technology will build application companies whose business models sell work rather than seats, so they compete for operating expenditure budgets instead of software tool budgets, a different framework from the history of software.
“a new continent of software application companies whose business models will not be selling seats. It will be selling work.”
Large tech incumbents are compounding network-effect businesses where winner-take-most dynamics concentrate users, capital, and resource allocation, making whole segments uninteresting to venture investors.
“they're compounding network effect businesses. And that network effect, the winner takes most concentration of wealth, concentration of users”
Openings in distribution create explosions of momentum where consumer demand is high, and the relevant question for AI is where the distribution dislocation is, which Peter argues is not as obvious as it was for mobile and social.
“we see openings in distribution end up creating explosion of momentum in areas that you have high consumer demand.”
Entrepreneurs are driven by three distinct forces: an innate aggressive drive to win, a pleasure drive that habituates and always wants more, and a generative drive to create, serve, and contribute; the mix explains a lot of what happens in a company.
“there's a primal aggressive drive that we all have”
Cash-generative consumer businesses depend on acquiring customers organically early in a market; once the market matures and companies must pay Google or Meta for users, customer acquisition cost makes sustained profitability very hard.
“if you have a business where you have to pay a lot to acquire customers, it gets very, very hard to make it very lucrative.”
A major future company will address the pathologies of social media, since people feel worse after 20 to 40 minutes on platforms like TikTok and Instagram, and the industry needs more attention to human flourishing and mental health in the companies it funds.
“anyone who's on TikTok or Instagram, 20, 30, 40 minutes later, they don't feel so good”
A million-plus developers building on transformer-based models will produce the next three to five companies worth $0.5 trillion or more, and Benchmark, which does not invest in foundation model companies, bets on that developer ecosystem and small teams backed early.
“there will emerge from that mass empowerment of creativity the next three to five $0.5 trillion market cap companies.”
AI is not only a technology disruption that favors incumbents; it is also a demand disruption as every large company asks how AI applies to its business, and a pricing disruption that changes distribution, so incumbents' distribution advantage is weaker than many assume.
“I think that's wrong in two ways. There's a demand disruption”
Free-to-play is the practical default because players can experiment before committing, subsidized hobbyists support the rest of the population, and the next gaming innovation will be in creation tools rather than business models.
“I think it's practical. The idea that you can experiment before you make a commitment”
There are more than a few potential 10x companies in the $1 billion to $5 billion public market cap range that were left behind after COVID, which offers better odds for 10x returns than bloated late-stage private companies valued in the same range.
“there's more than a few 10x-ers sitting right now in the $1 billion to $5 billion market cap in the public sector.”
Venture capital is a hack borrowed from oil-well risk models, in which investors promise to be partners but effectively buy relationships, and friends in pension funds will own more than a company's VP of sales.
“Venture's a hack. It came from other investment models... I'm going to be your partner in the fullest sense, but I'm also going to buy the relationship”
Benchmark deliberately raises a fund about half the size it could, around $500 million per fund, to force discipline that establishes the partnership on nonmonetary grounds; the venture model risks becoming a way to buy relationships with capital.
“I'm maybe the lone partner who thought, why don't we raise this fund that's half as big?”
The largest games are usually evolutions of earlier good mechanics that became more accessible: League of Legends evolved from Dota by going free, and Monopoly GO evolved from Coin Master by being more approachable.
“League of Legends, it's an evolution of Dota.”
Accepting that Benchmark is finite protects partners from investing ego and identity in the franchise itself, keeping the focus on the partnership with entrepreneurs rather than on building and managing the firm.
“Accepting the finitude of the project, I think, protects you from investing ego and identity in aspects of the firm that don't connect with the core work”
Founders often start with life's work intact but get clouded by extrinsic rewards, bureaucracy, and the trappings of wealth; a major part of partnership is deoxidizing and polishing the creative and generative capacities they had at the start.
“that life's work gets occluded. It clouds over, and it gets oxidized.”
A great board member's most important job is to amplify founder ambition, which is done by asking what it would take to be 10x bigger, since operational friction erodes the bar founders set for themselves; the other two jobs are recruiting and measuring the right things.
“I think this first one is, by far, the most important, which is, how do you amplify the founder ambition?”
Ego that wants to attach to something that outlives the individual is a form of refusing to accept finitude and ephemerality, and Benchmark's structure is designed to embody acceptance of that limit.
“My stroke in general with firms is that I think it's the ego that wants to attach to something that will outlive them”
It is not hard to make a compelling game, but it is really hard to make one that is compelling and holds players over a long duration, and the resulting explosion of content creates a discovery problem.
“it's not hard to make a game that's really compelling. It's really hard to make a game that's compelling and long duration.”
Once the firm grew to seven or eight partners, group dinners split into multiple conversations and the effort atomized, so the firm returned to a core number of about four to six partners, which coincided with its best period (Uber, Instagram, Twitter).
“there's eight people, you're going to have two conversations typically, sometimes three.”
The Benchmark model is like the flat, equal Western chimp tribe rather than the alpha-dominated Central tribe: a standard maintained over years prevents an egoic alpha partner, which would otherwise consume energy defending the position.
“a prevention against the egoic rise of an alpha, meaning the one partner that seems like”
Wildlife's approach was to find mechanics that worked in other games (paid titles or other platforms) and deliver them as compelling free products; the first game failed, but the second succeeded and funded a stronger team.
“We found a bunch of mechanics that worked well in other platforms or worked well as paid games.”
In 2011, paid-game mechanics were proven on the App Store, and making a compelling free game meant downloads flowed without heavy marketing; in-app purchases, not mobile itself, expanded the market and let early entrants earn organic downloads and cash.
“if you made like a compelling experience that was free, you just get a ton of downloads.”
In a distribution disruption, hypercompetitive founders can gain share quickly, but the enduring winners are those who protected their generative drive and curiosity while pursuing aggression and avoided letting success corrupt their focus.
“that can serve you really well on a high disruption of distribution because you gain share.”
Benchmark makes about 10 Series A investments a year and says it makes commitments rather than bets; because a contract cannot secure founder time, the reputation for spending time with founders is what makes the model work, with relationships averaging about 10 years.
“We make 10 investments a year. They're typically Series A.”
The word platform has lost meaning in pitches; an investor's skeptical register activates when founders use it, and a rough test from an ex-Microsoft executive is that a company only earns the term once it has about a million developers.
“A platform is a company that has a million developers.”
Game development is entering a golden era because creative tools let smaller teams, and even single creators with a vision, build better games, as earlier technical hurdles like latency and graphics give way to imagination as the hard part.
“I think we're entering a golden era of game development.”
Founders who are disagreeable, truth-seeking and non-conformant exist in an almost fixed ratio of humanity, so venture investors must wait for the right substrate in which these founders can work.
“Those people exist in an almost fixed ratio of humanity, and our belief is they just need the right substrate”
Friends' hostility toward venture investors reflects a belief that great entrepreneurs are mission-driven while most investors are money-driven, and in the long run these two aims align but diverge in the short term.
“the primary motivation of the great entrepreneurs, it's achieving the mission. And for most investors, the primary motivation is make money”
Benchmark has no investment memos or formal sourcing process; its work is built on conversation, because finding the exceptional founder requires being present with them rather than being constrained by frameworks.
“We don't do memos, and we don't have like a sourcing process or anything like that.”
The venture industry has systematized transactional relationships with founders; the better model is deep concern for relational and mental well-being, which makes founders feel less alone and reduces the risk of derailment.
“We as an industry have systematized and scaled transactional relationships.”
Victor limited his spending to 1% of his dividends in the first year, and he argues Silicon Valley's culture, where spending money is not cool and great ideas are, is a structural advantage that keeps founders generative compared with places where conspicuous spending is the norm.
“I decided that for the first year, I would spend 1% of the money that hit my bank account.”
Gaming acquisition engines are sputtering because mobile is congested; large game companies that once grew 80 to 150 percent a year now grow 7 to 10 percent, creating a sense the industry needs disruption.
“we're growing 80%, 150% a year, and we're growing at 7% to 10%.”
Victor screens founders for three things: a big goal and boldness that matters more than the exact initial plan, intensity because building companies is extremely hard, and the ability to simplify; he then builds trust over a lot of time to amplify their ambition.
“You got to meet a person and you have to feel that this person has a big goal.”
Because Benchmark's track record lowers risk for later rounds, founders it backs typically experience less dilution across the three to five pre-IPO rounds, and the average founder sees a 6 to 7x increase in value over five years post-investment.
“the average founder who takes money from us is going to have a 6 to 7x increase in value over five years post-investment.”
A founder under 30 will imagine a generative experience around human connection that is missing today, and AI will fill that void, likely appearing in products before people can articulate it.
“I'm predicting that there's a sub-30, probably sub-25-year-old founder that is imagining in a generative sense an experience that is deeply missing today around human connection.”
A partner's relationship with a founder must make mental health the number one priority, since the CEO is the most lonely position and neglecting it puts founders at risk of leaving the leadership role recognizably intact.
“You put that to the side, and you start with how is mental health and making it the number one priority of the relationship.”
Of the three drives, the pleasure drive is the most dangerous for a successful operator because it feels good and habituates, so the operator always needs more; the aggressive drive works in sprints but cannot be sustained for years.
“The hardest thing is the pleasure drive. That is the most dangerous one because it just feels so good.”
The mental health of entrepreneurs is behind some of the greatest suffering in founders' internal lives and in the external lives of the companies being built, and this is under-discussed in the industry.
“the thing we haven't talked enough about in the industry is broadly in the category of mental health.”
Great entrepreneurs are primarily motivated by achieving a mission, and would give up half their wealth for a city on Mars, whereas most investors such as hedge fund managers are primarily motivated by money and would not give up returns for mission accomplishment.
“the primary motivation of the great entrepreneurs, it's achieving the mission. And for most investors, the primary motivation is make money.”
The biggest pathology in a board dynamic is absence of vulnerability: a defensive posture from the CEO and executives blocks real dialectic, which Peter says occurred in about a third of the boards he worked on; the CEO must model vulnerability.
“the biggest pathology that emerges in a board dynamic is absence of vulnerability.”
Benchmark invested about $40 million in Wildlife at a $1.4 billion valuation for roughly 3% ownership, with a 1% carry and a make-whole partnership giving one partner about 15 basis points, which illustrates that the partners' economic stake was small relative to the value they added.
“Benchmark invested at Wildlife at like a $1.4 billion valuation and they put around $40 million. So they own 3% of the company.”
Early dividends and a wealth level that would swallow an average pleasure-seeking person create teammate conflict over why they keep working so hard, so founders need discipline to keep wealth from changing them.
“a lifestyle that would, for the average pleasure-seeking human being, be more than enough to swallow you whole”
When a founder or stakeholders put their interests ahead of the customer's need, the company's purpose is the guide to return to, and this is the most reliable way to find truth in an ambiguous crisis.
“Beneath every business, there's a customer... you come back to that guiding principle”
At Benchmark partners do not delegate time with founders and simplify other work so they can spend substantial time with founders, because trust and context require a lot of time together.
“we don't delegate spending time with founders. We simplify a lot of other stuff”
Computers that can understand natural language will change communication, since current messaging is suboptimal compared with live conversation, and LLMs are only one piece of the new experiences that will be built around them.
“I think computers speaking natural language is a big deal.”
After moving to San Francisco, Victor concluded that being in the Bay Area is not enough; partnering with a great investor is a way to become plugged into the ecosystem, so Wildlife took outside capital for expertise and network access rather than cash.
“what we needed wasn't really the capital, but it was more the expertise.”
Benchmark's central value is wanting to be the best partner to founders, and being more dedicated to founders matters more than being smarter, since many people are smart but dedication to a founder is what differentiates.
“you're not going to be the best partner because you're smarter... if you're more dedicated”
When a founder must be replaced or a company is failing, there are no single sources of truth, so partners must reduce certainty and return to the company's purpose and customer, a guiding principle that does not always work.
“Beneath every business, there's a customer -- or above every business, there's a customer. ... it's a good way to come back to truth as you see it”
Benchmark often takes less than pro rata in follow-ons, which lowers its own cash-on-cash multiple; the firm accepts that trade-off because its objective is the partnership rather than maximizing absolute cash returns.
“Very often, we take much less than pro rata.”
For the first year of Wildlife's dividends, Victor chose to spend only 1 percent of the money that hit his bank account, as a discipline to avoid being changed by money.
“I decided that for the first year, I would spend 1% of the money that hit my bank account”
The rarest talent in a venture partner is the ability to build deep, trust-based relationships with great founders, which sits at the center of Benchmark's founder relationships; without it the firm is useless.
“that is an exceedingly rare talent, gift, whatever you want to call it, that is at the epicenter of Benchmark's relationships with founders. If we don't have that, we're useless.”
Many great entrepreneurs say financial rewards fuel their generative drive, but when founders begin consuming their gains, their capabilities as founders and leaders are undermined.
“when they start to go down the path of consuming those gains, personally, historically, it's really undermined their capabilities”
Dominant games have moved from hour-long sessions and 60-hour campaigns to mobile games played for three minutes a session but continued for years, as new technologies allow new patterns of gameplay.
“the dominant games now are games on mobile that you play for three minutes, but you continue to play the same game for many years.”
In any calendar year the probability of being the early partner to a company that will reach $10 billion in market value is very low, which creates endless healthy anxiety for investors who must stay patient and wait for the right pitch.
“The probability is you start in any calendar year really low that you're going to be the partner to that entrepreneur.”
Benchmark has no investment in a foundation model company because it does not fit the firm's model of backing small teams early, such as Instagram and Snap when they had fewer than 10 people and a plan for a billion users rather than 300 hires.
“We do not have an investment in a foundation model company at Benchmark”
Current thin wrappers around LLMs look like early App Store fart and beer-tilting apps, but the question is whether new AI platforms will be bot app stores, a possibility Victor finds intriguing even though the apps look trivial.
“are the new platforms bot app stores? I think it's one possibility that is intriguing.”
Compounding network effect businesses concentrate wealth, users, and capital so that winner-take-most dynamics make whole segments uninteresting to venture investors, and today there are three to five such Death Stars, versus one when Peter joined.
“that network effect, the winner takes most concentration of wealth, concentration of users”
Humans keep liking the same game mechanics for very long periods, as with chess and poker, so mechanics are durable while the packaging and access change.
“humans like the same game mechanics for a very long time. Like think about chess or poker”
Victor regards capitalism as humanity's number one invention and companies as the second, arguing that great companies improve places to live through positive externalities.
“I think capitalism is the number one invention that humanity had, and then number two was probably companies”
While human welfare has improved on many measures, mental health indicators such as suicide rates among young people are at their worst levels, and there is no Factfulness-style book making that case yet.
“if you take some other measures such as suicides under a certain age, it's the worst it's ever been.”
Most great businesses consume cash before they generate it, so the founder must be able to articulate the path to profit; many gaming companies spend heavily on user acquisition with no app producing real profit.
“I think most great business, they first consume cash before they generate something.”
When a company is falling apart, the board must return to the company's purpose and serving the customer, since no certainties exist beyond the faith that a better company can be built, and the decency in people is what allows recovery.
“you need something to come back to guide you. And I think that historically, for me, has always been the purpose of the company.”
Accel partner Bob Kagle left by simply stepping aside with no negotiation over residual economics, modeling a non-acrimonious exit that avoids the unkind narratives that usually follow partner departures.
“There was no negotiation about the residual economics.”
The founder motivation is not binary; the best founders combine mission with financial reward, and Kleiner Perkins' earlier framing of missionary founders versus mercenary founders captures that spectrum, while Jack's point that purpose outlasts mission is also valid.
“we want missionary founders, not mercenary founders. This is not a binary state.”
Large incumbents struggle with internal bureaucracy and their own capture, so a frustrated employee who has an idea might quit and build it, but in many cases incumbents either suffocate the idea or produce a grandiose flop.
“for reasons that relate to their own capture and the internal atmospheric of the bureaucracy, they'll suffocate it”
Peter's experience parenting five children taught him the most about partnering with founders: start with connection before correction, and see the role as relational partner rather than power structure.
“Nothing's made me better in the job in the last decade than being a parent to five kids”
Victor's grandmother, who raised ten children in poverty in Brazil after her husband was murdered, taught the family that hard work transforms lives, and Victor's daily question of what he could achieve with a little more effort changed his outcomes.
“what could I achieve if I worked a little harder? I think that asking myself that question radically changed my outcome.”
Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Solana collectively created more than $1 trillion of sustained market value, and crypto was a place where incumbents were structurally disadvantaged, though identifying the resulting companies has been harder.
“Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana collectively created over $1 trillion of today sustained market value.”
Wildlife Studios was bootstrapped by necessity: Victor and his brother were turned down by investors, and the best seed term sheet offered about $50,000 for half the company, so they built the business from their own cash flow.
“someone offered us roughly $50,000 for half the company.”
A flat, equal partnership's vulnerability is complacency; without an internalized sense of excellence, the firm can quickly become irrelevant and comfortable.
“Its vulnerability, of course, is that you could establish a norm of complacency”
During periods when Wildlife struggled, Peter spent more time with the company, holding weekly calls and engaging with executives, which Victor found to be the defining feature of how they worked together.
“the times the company was doing worse were the times that he spent more time with us”
The way buyers pay for AI will change the distribution model, because customers move from licensing or renting software to consuming a different experience, which is a second distribution disruption.
“The other distribution model disruption, I think, is pricing”
After 25 years in venture, a veteran's easily satiated motivations (not failing, being decent among peers) burn off, leaving generative purpose and full relational potential as the central drive, which Peter scores at roughly five out of ten.
“you burn off motivational systems that are easily satiated.”
Peter scores himself about 5 of 10 on achieving full potential in founder relationships, reaching 8 or 9 occasionally, and believes relational life always allows higher flourishing.
“I would score myself, if I were being brutal, on a scale 1 to 10, is having gotten above a five in full potential”
Many founders went through isolating post-COVID periods marked by major headcount reductions, feeling exposed, defeated, and beleaguered, and such feelings can become fatal for a company when leaders have nothing left.
“a lot of people have gone through that post-COVID because there have been major head count reductions.”
An underdeveloped venture capital scene in Brazil leads to bad investor behavior, such as trying to buy companies very cheaply, and this is one reason there are few interesting technology companies there.
“this venture capital scene that is not well developed and leads to like a lot of bad behavior, like trying to get a company for that cheap.”
After 13 years as an operator, Victor found that operating builds deep industry knowledge and long team bonds, while investing gives breadth across many industries and people but costs the daily connection to a team on a shared mission.
“what you get is this breadth. You get to learn about so many different industries”
Jeff Bezos said the board member he most wanted was one more ambitious than he was, who would ask what it would take to reach 100 million Prime subscribers after he presented a plan for one million.
“a plan to reach a million subscribers on Prime”
Victor measures his success by how many founders he identifies early and remains a meaningful part of their journey 10 years later, a standard he saw modeled by Eric in his relationships with CEOs that stretch over five years or more.
“how many times I identify this great person and I'm a meaningful part of their journey 10 years in.”
Chetan tells founders pitching him everything he knows about their space, even when he says no, so pitching founders leave happy and get free expert work from a knowledgeable investor.
“even if people say no, they're getting free work from someone that is knowledgeable”
Jack argued the firm should speak of purpose rather than mission because missions can be accomplished, and Peter agrees there is truth in that because purpose is continuous.
“it should be about purpose, not mission because missions can be accomplished”
Founders often say they want to win, but in business the scorecard is often money, which is the game being played, though Peter challenges this framing and says purpose matters more.
“Win what? Often it's money. Complicitly, the reward in business is money.”
When Peter joined, the average partner age was 43 to 44 and the partners were relatively tall white men; the average age has since fallen to about 38 to 39, and the median partner has zero vacation homes, signaling Bay Area commitment.
“our average age when I joined was 43, 44, all relatively tall white men. Today, the average age, I think, is 39 -- 38, 39.”
Pavel Durov of Telegram, with close to a billion monthly active users and about 30 employees, personally funded most of the company with no revenue model, and Peter admires him as an example of founder purpose over indulgence.
“close to a billion monthly active users and 30 employees.”
Mark Zuckerberg has kept the same dynamic, generative energy since the Accel days in 2005, illustrating the founder who matures without losing the drive behind the company's start, in contrast to founders who become rigid.
“What always struck me about Mark Zuckerberg is that he kept it fresh.”
A Brex co-founder told Victor that he is the closest thing to a cofounder outside the team, which Victor said was not about equity but about the value of his partnership.
“you're the closest thing that I have to a cofounder outside of the team”
Victor feels confident he can help founders build companies because he built games generating a couple billion dollars in revenue without investor capital, but sourcing and selecting companies are still big question marks for him as a new investor.
“I feel very confident because I build a company, I build games that generated a couple of billion dollars”
After 13 years as a founder and three months as an investor, Victor still identifies as a founder, expecting that his identity will shift to investor over a decade or more.
“I don't see myself as an investor because I've been a founder for 13 years”
The kindest thing anyone did for Peter was his nine-year-old daughter Natalie telling him after a hard parenting day that they loved him completely.
“she said, I know it was really hard for you today, but we love you completely”
Because companies are now experimenting with AI in new ways, there will be strange outcomes and epic failures, and some have already occurred.
“So weird things are going to happen. There's going to be some epic failures. There already have been some.”