Patrick O’Shaughnessy - Creating on Principle - [Invest Like the Best, EP.455]
What this covers
This is a role reversal: David Senra, host of Founders, interviews Patrick O'Shaughnessy, and the episode first ran on David's feed. Investing and interviewing barely come up. The conversation centers on Bret Victor's talk Inventing on Principle. Patrick explains how its idea of instant feedback shaped his software design, and how he turned the same logic into a personal mission about talent that goes unseen. A recurring anecdote supports it: in a large compiled survey of answers to "the kindest thing anyone has done for you," about two-thirds described someone betting on them early. Patrick offers that survey as evidence, and it is a contested claim.
From there the talk spreads across media strategy, biography, and family. Patrick argues that profiles are costly, slow, and poorly paid, and that this makes them uncopyable. He describes magazine covers as a way to direct scarce attention toward people he believes in, and says the best ideas often sound dumb, like starting a magazine in 2025. He also lays out a three-part test for a great story: originality, hardship, and transformation. David brings in Sol Price on teaching through repetition, Larry Ellison's deliberate feud with Bill Gates, and Walt Disney's refusal to accept mediocrity.
The personal turns are the most unusual. Sam Hinkie's description of Patrick as red on the color wheel gets unpacked, as does the lie Bruce Springsteen told himself about work and fame. David also argues that Patrick is the founder of his family, and he traces his own grandfather's exit from Cuba as a decision that shaped generations.
O'Shaughnessy argues that a person should live by an organizing principle, an obligation to find and foster undiscovered potential, rather than by goals or worldly success, and that this principle produces durable meaning and better outcomes than money, power, or fame.
- Goals create blinders, while opportunities that come from the periphery have produced most of his best outcomes
- Pursuing the feeling of being alive, or 'abiding joy', is a more reliable guide than money, power, and fame
- Being a good leader, and the legacy of relationships and family, is what earns the right to do more great work
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Repetition is persuasive, and great leaders are teachers who repeat their philosophy until their team can recite it; Sol Price's view that leaders should spend 90 percent of their time teaching is an example.
“if you're not spending 90% of your time teaching, you're not doing your job as the leader of the company.”
Charlie Munger's approach, which David and Patrick endorse, is to find an outlier and keep asking what is going on with them to reverse-engineer why they are successful.
“one of the best ways to learn is, like, you find somebody that's kind of an outlier and you just ask them, like, 'What the hell is going on with this person?'”
Larry Ellison deliberately picked a fight with Bill Gates because people are more interested in personalities than in companies or technologies, and the resulting billionaire rivalry raised Oracle's profile.
“people are interested in personalities more than they're interested in companies or technologies.”
Bret Victor's principle that digital creators should get instant feedback on what they make, like paint on a canvas, was applied as the primary design principle for Patrick's software, which made the portfolio choices visible and helped the business grow.
“his principle was digital creators should have instant feedback with their creation.”
Patrick reports that in a large compiled survey of answers to the question of the kindest thing anyone has done, about two-thirds described someone betting on them before they deserved it or seeing potential they did not see in themselves.
“something like two-thirds of the answer to this question were the same, which was the kindest thing was some person made a bet on me”
Patrick argues that profiles are declining because they are costly, slow, and poorly paid, but that this difficulty makes them singular and uncopyable, and the world is sick of cheap junk content like short-form video.
“things that are really hard to make are really interesting to me. And I think people stopped doing profiles because they're really hard to make.”
Patrick proposes an exercise asking who you would help if you could only help three people, citing Bill Campbell's mentoring of a few executives as proof that small-scale devotion can be as successful as famous business accomplishments.
“What if the only thing I was allowed to do in my life, nothing else was allowed, was help three people.”
Bret Victor's talk Inventing on Principle suggests finding a single principle (e.g., digital creators need instant feedback) and organizing one's life mission around collapsing a gap; Patrick adopts this to define his own mission as an obligation to correct undiscovered talent going unseen.
“find a principle. Don't necessarily have a goal, but find a principle”
Asking 'what is the lie you are telling yourself' surfaces the belief that determines one's trajectory; for Springsteen the lie was that work and fame were most important, and he changed course only after realizing his emotional well-being had been damaged.
“What is the lie that you're telling yourself?”
Sam Hinkie described Patrick as 'red on the color wheel', meaning he is intensely focused when interested and can make things happen, but his attention shifts quickly, leaving people whiplashed and his prior commitments forgotten.
“he described me as being red on the color wheel, which he explained meant that when I'm interested in something, I am intense.”
David argues Patrick is the founder of his family, having broken from an entrepreneurial family tradition to go a new direction, and that breaking generational patterns is his greatest accomplishment.
“I think of you as the founder of your family. And I think that's incredibly powerful, and I think it's your greatest accomplishment that things repeat through the generations.”
A magazine cover is the ultimate form of spotlight that people cannot say no to, so Patrick sees owning covers as a way to allocate valuable scarce attention to people he believes in.
“People can't say no to a cover.”
Colossus has started asking leading people for yearly lunches with no immediate output, collecting material for profiles that could be written a decade later, since the best profile material requires trust gained over time.
“Can I just have lunch with you once a year? And I'm not going to do anything with it”
Patrick argues that people should identify a guiding principle for their life rather than a specific goal, because goals channel attention into a known road while a principle keeps one open to opportunity and repeatable across domains.
“I love that way of thinking about finding one's life's mission, is find a principle. Don't necessarily have a goal, but find a principle.”
A real organizing or invention principle is one where, whenever you see it violated, you have an obligation to correct it, and that correction is an act of service to others rather than a benefit to yourself.
“The principle should be something that when you see it violated, it is your obligation to go correct it, and that that correction is an act of service for other people, not for yourself.”
Patrick's framework for what makes a great story has three principles: originality, hardship, and transformation, and he applies it both to people's life stories and to startup selection, arguing that unique paths, hard businesses, and customer transformation create durable success.
“the best principles for a great story that I could come up with were originality, hardship, and transformation.”
Walt Disney's insistence on making Disneyland better than the scammy amusement parks of his day shows that mediocrity stays invisible until passion exposes it, and a useful filter for creation is to improve every part and remove what does not make sense.
“mediocrity is always invisible until passion shows up and exposes it.”
David argues that one decision by an ancestor, his grandfather leaving Cuba under Castro with no money or English, shaped the course of generations, so present decisions may affect people long after one is gone.
“that one decision by somebody I don't remember, like, ripples through the entire generations.”
Patrick's cousin Tim O'Shaughnessy's unrewarded efforts to bring Patrick into his social circle at Notre Dame led directly to Patrick meeting his wife, best man, and groomsman, so whole lives can turn on small acts of kindness.
“whole lives are downstream of simple, quick acts of kindness.”
Money, power, and fame are the conventional proxies for success, but they become traps because once one is obtained it becomes the thing chased, whereas the feeling of aliveness and abiding joy never runs out and reliably guides a person.
“those are huge traps because once you start to get one, it's the thing you start chasing”
David argues that people already know most of what great biographies teach; the value is reminding them of truths they have forgotten or failed to apply, which is why he calls Founders church for entrepreneurs.
“what you're going to realize is just that there's a lot of stuff that you already know and you know is true”
Sam Hinkie's idea that people are power law and the best ones change everything implies that you should be ruthless about who gets access to you, because a few individuals produce disproportionate value.
“People are power law, and the best ones change everything”
People know what makes them feel most alive but do not pursue it for most of their lives, and Patrick attributes this mainly to fear of the unknown, since an original path means all responsibility falls on the individual and requires leaving a comfortable existence.
“Usually it's simple, which is fear.”
Patrick believes the most valuable ideas often sound dumb at first, such as starting a magazine in 2025, while obvious good ideas are typically crowded and competitive.
“I think the key is stuff that sounds dumb but isn't.”
Patrick observed that a magazine with famous people on its cover but little readership shows that people cannot say no to a cover, and he tested this theory and found it true.
“Oh, it's the cover. People can't say no to a cover. And so I tested that theory out and it was true”
Life's work is a lifelong quest to build something for others that expresses who you are; Patrick notes the term has become overused and that few people are actually doing it.
“a lifelong quest to build something for others that expresses who you are.”
Ravi Gupta's definition that a great leader is someone other people want to follow is the best; such leaders are hyper-communicative, consistent, lead from the front, and take risks and arrows for the team.
“a great leader is someone that other people want to follow.”
Overcommunicating your thinking with important people prevents unspoken assumptions from accumulating, since unstated differences in understanding stack on top of each other and can turn relationships weird.
“essentially just overcommunicate as much as possible with the people that are important to you, because then you're not going to have... there's no unspoken assumption”
David argues the most fundamentally important thing a person does is choose who is around them, since friends, employers, and recruits determine outcomes, so he invests heavily in deep relationships now.
“the most fundamentally important thing that you do in life is choose who's around you.”
Podcasters and interviewers have an unfair advantage because they get multi-hour conversations with accomplished people and can extract and reuse ideas from them, turning learning into a compounding asset.
“the unfair advantage that we have is essentially, we're professional learners.”
Sam Hinkie's idea of breadcrumbs means putting out one thing that people find amazing, since the internet is good at spreading great work, so a person can get ahead by pouring a year into a single exceptional output.
“Pour a year of your life into making one amazing thing that people are amazed by, and amazing things will happen, I promise you.”
David argues that criticism that a market has enough podcasts is misguided, because the market always has room for great work; the problem is mediocrity, not saturation.
“we need less bad shit, but that's always going to happen. Like, there's always room for great.”
To find talent for a creative role, consume the best work produced by many people and hire whoever made the best one; this is how Patrick found Jeremy Stern and mirrors an investor's view that a good invention signals a good inventor.
“if you want to hire someone for a thing, just go consume as much of the thing made by a million people as possible.”
A role-elimination game, where people discard roles until one remains, reveals what they most value; Patrick's father-in-law Dan kept grandfather, and Patrick says his final roles would be husband or father.
“It's a really interesting game. It's interesting for yourself, but also super interesting to see what your friends pick.”
David argues that Bruce Springsteen's autobiography shows a person channeling pain into work that brings fame but leads to depression, because the work was not what he actually wanted, and that understanding what you want matters more than achievement.
“the lie that Bruce was telling himself was that work was the most important, that becoming a rock star was the most important, fame was the most important.”
David reads autobiographies because the subjects, having finished their lives, are not incentivized to lie, so they reveal how human nature actually works more than how people say it works.
“I'm writing this book when I'm 80. I'm not incentivized to lie”
Patrick clarifies that his organizing principle is not helping as many people as possible but seeing enormous unrealized potential and feeling obligated to tell people about it and help foster it into existence.
“It is trying to see enormous, not yet realized potential.”
Talented people often do too much themselves, which Patrick calls heroics, and while founders must be flame keepers, becoming a great leader is necessary to earn the right to do more great work.
“I refer to this as, like, heroics. And that's always necessary.”
Patrick's career was a daisy chain: reading books in his 20s led to an email list, which gave him podcast listeners, which led to a software business, angel checks, a Series A investment, and the creation of a new investment firm. None of these were on any goal list.
“The whole thing is daisy-chained together because I loved reading fucking books in my 20s”
Dirty fuel such as fear, status, or competition can drive high performance, but it consumes the person, whereas generative fuel driven by love of the work and service builds a legacy of loyalty and reliance from others.
“Dirty fuel works really well, but it consumes the person in a way that I would far rather die”
The maxim 'the reward for great work is more work' means the reward is the privilege of doing more of what one loves, not money, power, or fame, and Patrick uses it as the one maxim his team operates by.
“The reward for great work is more work.”
Reece Duca's advice to simplify your life with rhythm and harmony means fewer, deeper relationships, fewer things done better, and aligning everything with what gives you energy.
“Simplify your life with rhythm and harmony.”
David argues that people underestimate volume: doing something more than anyone else builds the taste needed to judge good from bad ideas, creating a constant refinement loop.
“People vastly underestimate the importance of volume.”
Patrick advises people to find the activity they do with high repetition because they like it, since learning by doing compounds, and his reading habit prepared him for profile-producing and podcasting.
“what's the thing you just can't help but do a crazy high rep count of? Probably that's a good clue to, like, where you could go build one of these compounding curves”
Patrick says the small set of 10 to 15 people for whom he would do anything is his most prized possession, following Dunbar's number, and that an acceptable outcome is being on someone's list of 50 rather than 15.
“that list of people for whom I would do anything is my prized possession.”
Setting a big goal makes the outcome predictable because the person knows the road ahead and gets blinders, whereas talented people who set goals reliably achieve them; Patrick says everything interesting he has done came from the periphery.
“the second you set some big goal, you kind of know what's going to happen because you go do it and you know the road in front of you, and you have blinders on.”
Patrick says that after he finally aligned his work and close relationships with what he was meant to do, his long-running health problems improved, despite having previously tried extensive diet, exercise, and tracking without success.
“when you're doing something you love and have great core relationships, all of a sudden, magically, your health gets way better.”
Patrick suggests using moments when you felt most present and alive as a signpost for your principle, since people know what makes them feel alive and then often fail to do more of it.
“using those as a signpost to what your principle might be or what you should be doing, I think, is a really great thing.”
Patrick's favorite activity is identifying undiscovered potential before others do, learning from the person early, and then helping the world see what he sees, which he considers the one thing he would do over and over.
“it means I get to learn about a person and whatever they're doing before other people do”
Autobiographies and biographies, especially of subjects writing late in life, are valuable because the subjects are no longer incentivized to lie and reveal what happened after they got what they wanted.
“I'm not incentivized to lie, and here's the stuff I went through”
Patrick admits that his excitability leads him to race ahead of his team, forgetting the people he needs to bring along, which was a long-term leadership weakness he learned to correct partly through Sam Hinkie's feedback.
“I'm billy-goating up ahead of the pack and forgetting that, oh wait, there are all these people that I want to do this with.”
Patrick built his software business by taking design principles from Daniel Ek on software building, Bret Victor on instant feedback, and Chetan Puttagunta at Benchmark on selling software, applying them without deep prior software knowledge, and the approach worked spectacularly.
“I basically just stole their ideas and applied it to my situation, and it worked to a spectacular degree.”
Patrick O'Shaughnessy finds championing other people, especially seeing their wins, more emotionally gratifying than his own accomplishments, which he says he does not care about or think about.
“by far my favorite thing in the world is championing other people”
Patrick judges that intensity is the thing that makes him effective but also whiplashes people, so he has worked to focus on fewer things and to stop chasing the flavor-of-the-month.
“I'm just so excitable... the flavor of the month club, which is something that can definitely snare me”
Access and opportunities, such as filming at The Aman in New York, come from personal relationships rather than cold requests, and the job of a learner is to absorb what they learn and package it for others.
“This is why I always say relationships run the world”
Patrick's great-grandfather Ignatius Aloysius O'Shaughnessy made a large fortune in oil and gave nearly all of it away, mostly anonymously, which shapes the family's values about money.
“he made this fortune, he did not give a shit about money. He didn't really spend it, he gave away basically all of it in his lifetime, mostly anonymously.”
Thomas Jefferson's tombstone omits his presidency and lists his authorship of the Declaration of Independence and founding of the University of Virginia, which Patrick uses to ask whether a person's main work will appear on their tombstone.
“his tombstone, has three things that describe his life, but one of them is not that he was the President of the United States.”
David Remnick's view that the best profiles occur when someone is obsessed with their subject and the writer is as obsessed with the person as the person is with their thing guided Patrick's Colossus profile strategy.
“The best profiles over the last 100 years are defined by somebody doing a thing they're obsessed with and a writer that is as obsessed with the person”
Patrick says it took him roughly a decade to state his organizing principle cleanly, and that a person knows they have found a principle when it begins informing nearly every daily decision about how they spend time.
“you know you've found your principle when it starts informing literally every decision you make every day with your time.”
Working backward from the end state you hope to be true, such as being loyal and relied upon at the end of life, is a simple heuristic for deciding what to do now.
“working backwards from what you hope is true is a simple heuristic for finding what to do well”
Understanding Patrick's core values shows that his media work and investing are the same thing, since both consist of finding people and telling the world about them.
“the media and investing are not two separate things. If you actually know Patrick and what is important to him, like, they are the exact same thing.”
Patrick says he cannot visualize anything with his eyes closed, which he discovered only recently and which surprised him.
“For me, it's just black. I can't visualize anything.”
Patrick's key software design ideas came mainly from offline, unrecorded conversations with experts such as Chetan Puttagunta, who gave feedback on demos without investing, not from the podcast interviews.
“mostly just offline asking questions”
Introspection was a tool that Patrick used to find his life purpose, and once that purpose was clear he no longer needed it, consistent with David's view that the tool can be set down after the job is done.
“once I had clicked into, I think, understanding what I want to do, I don't think about it at all.”
Great stories are about the reader rather than the subject; the audience sees its own experiences in a story about someone else, which is why understanding of human nature comes through biographies.
“It's not really about them, it's about you”
Patrick applies weightlifting's progressive overload principle to life: continually doing a little more, so that the path extends unpredictably and growth compounds without a fixed endpoint.
“progressive overload, of always, like, a little bit harder, a little bit more.”
A passage in the Upanishads, 'Those who feed the hungry protect me; those who don't are consumed by me,' changed Patrick's worldview and convinced him the whole point of existence is to help other people.
“Those who feed the hungry protect me. Those who don't are consumed by me.”
Patrick's childhood fear of death, which made him need his parents to hold his hand to sleep, started a decades-long search through philosophy and religion for the meaning and purpose of life.
“I had this just crippling fear of death.”
Patrick believes founder-led companies are generally more interesting than professionally managed companies, and that becoming a great leader is the most important way to secure the right to do more great work.
“founder-led companies are, of course, so much more interesting... than professionally managed companies”
John Pfeffer repeatedly moved from one field to a very different one, from KKR to cryptocurrency to a UK grocery chain, each time having to build an entirely new network from scratch, which he enjoys.
“I literally had to start from scratch, and I love it.”
Patrick met his wife Lauren at age 19 and has been with her for over 20 years, so most of his adult development happened within that relationship.
“I was 19 when I met her, she was 20”
Patrick's maxim of learn, build, share, repeat describes a loop that he believes is a governing principle, and it began with reading books and sharing favorite books through an email list that became his podcast audience.
“Learn, build, share, repeat”
Charlie Munger and Warren Buffett, as relayed by Brent Beshore, find a great CEO and ask them to come do the job, rather than hiring for potential.
“We just find somebody that is a great CEO and say, 'Come do that for us.'”
Patrick's recognition that he cannot visualize things with his eyes closed mirrors the way intensity cuts both ways, and his focus is valuable but makes him wish he were less of an 'Eye of Sauron.'
“I wish I wasn't the Eye of Sauron. That sounds so bad.”
Patrick prefers Colossus to become bigger than his podcast because his time is the bottleneck, and a world where he is not required for every output lets more talented people create more work.
“so a world where it's no longer rate limited by my time and energy is much more exciting than a world where it's me.”
David wants to avoid a spike and flame-out, preferring slow build decade after decade, and he reads fiction and biography to learn what happens after people get what they wanted.
“I'd rather just do the slow build decade after decade, get better, and keep doing it.”
David considers people who stop creating and cease to pour themselves into work to be the saddest, because they are in an infinite game that they have left.
“I think they're the saddest people.”
Understanding a person deeply takes at least 100 hours of conversation on the low end, and David knows only a handful of people that well.
“It takes at least 100 hours of conversation on the low end.”
Patrick says he would prefer to end each episode by flashing people's memories so they forget who he was, since he is not interested in fame.
“I wish at the end of each of my episodes, to flash people in the face, and they forgot who I was”
After being rejected by every college he applied to, Patrick transferred after getting good grades at a list of compatible schools, which was the path that eventually led him to Notre Dame.
“I got rejected from every college I applied to the first time”
Patrick committed to an investment in Sam Hinkie's fund, then quickly launched his own fund in the summer of 2020 after one company opportunity, which shows how sudden interest can shift his commitments.
“There was this investment opportunity in one company that led to a fund very quickly in the summer of 2020.”