Orlando Bravo - The Art of Software Buyouts - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 257]
What this covers
The host talks with Orlando Bravo, co-founder of Thoma Bravo, which has done more than 350 software acquisitions since entering the field about twenty years ago. The conversation starts with the firm's early deals. Little leverage was used between 2000 and 2005 because the syndicated loan market was tiny, so returns came from operations and multiple expansion. It then moves to how the firm works today. Each portfolio company gets an operating review at least monthly, lasting four hours, with the CEO and all direct reports present. The review goes through the P&L of every functional and geographic unit, which Bravo calls Segmented P&L Accountability.
The middle of the discussion covers a lot of ground. Bravo explains why the firm underwrites its own operating plan, often on break-even or loss-making targets, rather than current results. He argues that replacing management can cost a new leader up to two years of learning, and that short holding periods work because the plan is built with management before closing. He also explains why enterprise cybersecurity tends to consolidate around two or three vendors. Several forecasts are flagged as contested: that profitable software will earn index-like multiples with better growth, that a software-focused fund has effectively no size limit, and that blockchain may eventually beat traditional databases. He also says large pools of capital should stop treating software as a separate industry, a point he makes as Sector-Agnostic Capital Allocation.
The last stretch is about people and temperament. Bravo favors Culture Add over culture fit and criticizes the proliferation of C-level titles. He says centralized leaders mistake their own role in success, and he describes how surviving the dot-com bust left investors conservative enough to pass on some deals.
Bravo argues that software buyouts succeed by partnering with existing management, underwriting profitable growth rather than losses, and buying market leaders, and that public markets undervalue these businesses because they confuse growth with unprofitability.
- Sponsors who keep existing management and run disciplined monthly P&L reviews can improve margins and growth at the same time
- Public investors wrongly treat high growth and negative margins as inseparable, leaving profitable software undervalued
- Returns will come from operations and growth rather than leverage or multiple expansion, and capital is abundant relative to good software deals
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Public investors wrongly assume growth and negative margins go together; in reality high profitability often drives higher growth, because profitable companies have better operating management, better product-price fit, and more capital to reinvest in sales and R&D.
“Those two concepts are completely different. They many times have nothing to do with one another, and many times high profitability leads to higher growth”
Private equity software deals used very little leverage in the first five years (2000 to 2005) because the syndicated loan market was tiny, and returns came from operations and multiple expansion instead.
“if you look at our first five years in software, 2000 to 2005, there was very little leverage in the industry.”
Enterprise software companies are undervalued in volatile markets because they are not consumer household names, and public investors lack time to understand many complex products, and few investors specialize only in enterprise software.
“there's a lot of valuation and efficiency around these companies because when things get volatile”
High growth and high margin are not mutually exclusive, because growth should drop a higher margin to the bottom line, and in software the marginal cost of the product is near zero, aside from support and distribution costs.
“we believe in both high growth and high margin, and they're not mutually exclusive. One actually drives the other”
The gap between typical loss-making SaaS companies and profitable ones is driven by investors who incentivize management only on revenue growth, telling companies to grow as fast as possible regardless of profit.
“I think that comes from investors really incenting management teams, just on top line.”
The profitable software index grows earnings around 20 percent per year but trades at roughly 30 to 35 times earnings, while the S&P 500 trades near 20 to 23 times with 7 percent growth, so owning profitable software should yield about a 16 times multiple in four years, similar to the index, with better growth and cash flow.
“the profitable software index, ... is growing earnings at 20% and it's trading for a PE of 32, 35.”
Blockchain could offer better use cases than traditional database software in several areas, though enterprise use is still very early and most of the current activity focuses on financial systems and consumers.
“I do feel that blockchain could present better use cases than database software in a number of areas, and in the enterprise that is so early”
Large capital pools such as sovereign wealth funds, pension funds, and endowments should stop treating software as an industry to measure exposure against, because software now runs the entire business of companies in manufacturing, retail, hospitality, and real estate.
“to start looking first and foremost as software as not an industry anymore.”
Hiring should seek culture add rather than culture fit, because a culture of open-mindedness, collaboration, and different thinking requires diverse backgrounds, not a homogeneous group of people who went to the same schools.
“Don't think about culture fit. Think about culture add.”
There is effectively no limit to how large a private equity fund focused on software can be, because the capital available from limited partners far exceeds what the sector is currently being allocated, and fast-growing companies keep needing more capital.
“As we see it today, there is no limit to fund size. It's not even close to what the limited partner private equity community in general can provide.”
Thoma Bravo holds an operating review at each portfolio company at least every month, lasting four hours, with the CEO and all direct reports present, and reviews the P&L of every functional and geographic unit after a brief board meeting.
“every month we have an ops review at each of our companies for four hours, at least, with a CEO and all of her or his direct reports.”
In enterprise cybersecurity, CIOs and CISOs do not want to buy five to eight point products, so these strategic categories converge on the top two or three vendors over time, making the product selection decision central to investing.
“they will converge on the top two or three over time.”
Investors who lived through the dot-com bust developed a lasting conservatism, and even when partners say today's conditions are different, they still check each decision against that experience, which has sometimes limited them from pursuing more deals.
“We almost have, still, PTSD over that environment. Every time we make a decision, we still think, "Does that look anything like that?"”
Short holding periods are feasible because the firm works with existing management to develop the business plan before closing, and in people-based software companies that move quickly, changes can be made very fast.
“you can develop your business plan with them way before you close that deal.”
Replacing management is costly because a new leader takes time to learn the business and can take up to two years before acting, so models that assume fast turnaround from leadership changes often overlook this disruption.
“did you really model the disruption of changing leadership, the time that it takes to get new leadership, the time that it takes that new leadership to learn the business”
The proliferation of C-level titles, which began during the first dot-com wave, creates internal competition and unhealthy drama, and a key role for senior leaders is to tell people that mistakes are acceptable and to reframe complaints into positive problem solving.
“the C level title has proliferated. I remember it got started during the first dot-com movement”
Thoma Bravo's core approach, learned from its first deals, is to back existing management teams who know their markets and customers deeply, rather than replacing them, and combine their domain knowledge with an outside operating approach.
“that the best approach was to back existing management for all the reasons that I mentioned before”
Strong leaders delegate authority, know when to intervene and when not to, and rigorously think about how each decision affects the P&L, while being both strategic and detail-oriented, which is rare.
“There's not a lot of them in the world that really think that rigorously the P&L impact of every one of their decisions.”
When a strategic buyer approaches, a private equity owner should lean toward selling, because strategic interest may not persist: that buyer may buy something else, build the product organically, or shift its priorities the next year.
“you should lean on selling when a strategic buyer approaches, because if they're here today, it's likely that they won't be here tomorrow”
When Thoma Bravo buys control, it underwrites its own operating plan rather than the company's current results, often buying break-even or loss-making businesses, and that plan must be run in partnership with management so the model does not break.
“when you see us buy control of the business, we are underwriting our plan, not what is going on in that company.”
Investors who model a company's promised 30 percent operating margin in year four while excusing current losses as growth spending are making a mistake, because management's planning habits do not change automatically and margin improvement must start now.
“That company in year four is not all of a sudden going to change how they plan”
Leaders in centralized organizations trick themselves into believing success is due to them, when success actually happens despite centralization, because decisions take too long to flow to the top and leaders are too removed from operational realities.
“these leaders are tricking themselves into thinking that success was due to them. It's actually success in spite of that”
Breaking the company into detailed P&Ls by functional area, business unit, and geography gives each operator visibility into how their decisions affect profit, and their creative proposals then exceed the sponsor's own recommendations.
“When you let those operators know where exactly do they stand on direct revenue and direct cost in their activities, what they do creatively always exceeds our recommendations”
Companies that can afford losses try every sales channel and many R&D initiatives, whereas profitable companies only sustain the approaches that fit their product and customers, so profitability signals better investment decisions.
“if you lose money and you can lose money, sure, you'll try it all.”
Pools of capital that separate private equity, venture, and infrastructure allocations create artificial barriers that prevent capital from flowing to its most efficient ownership structure in software.
“not differentiate private equity from their venture allocation, from their infrastructure allocation, to others and create almost these barriers”
Even with a long track record, a sponsor must re-earn trust from management and boards on every deal because what matters to them is current behavior, so past success offers little protection and inexperience can sometimes be an advantage.
“I still think that the most difficult thing is that you have to earn it every single time.”
Thoma Bravo has never subscribed to buying high and selling higher, partly because its partners lived through the dot-com bust and still apply that caution, and the firm models potential multiple contraction rather than relying on expansion.
“We have never subscribed to the view based on what we all come from, of buying high and selling higher.”
Capital is no longer the constraint in private markets, so talent has become the scarce input, and diversifying recruitment beyond traditional elite institutions is necessary to access it.
“Today, what we need more of is talent.”
Many high-margin market leaders make investment decisions based on gut feel, which has served them well, but the firm's contribution is an analytical approach that uses data across functional, business unit, and geographic segments to guide where capital goes.
“so many of these companies... are making a lot of decisions based on gut feel”
The firm prices deals on revenue multiples and relies on building a profitability engine after acquisition, so the investment becomes fundamentally sound on earnings rather than revenue growth alone.
“we're really thinking about revenue multiples and then creating an engine or the profitability then comes in and makes it a fundamentally sound investment”
Young people should do what they want now instead of taking a job to set up a later career move, because working directly in the field you care about builds the skills and reputation that differentiate you.
“Don't do something in order to do something else later.”
Thoma Bravo's flagship fund buys the number one player in each vertical or horizontal market, whether in apps, infrastructure software, or cybersecurity segments, and the key difference from other growth investors is that returns come from fundamentally improving how companies run, in partnership with existing management.
“We are buying the market leaders of today, the number one player in that vertical market in the case of apps, or even horizontal market”
When buying high-growth SaaS companies at high multiples, debt makes up a much smaller share of the capital structure, so returns depend on operations and growth rather than financial engineering.
“Then on those, the multiples are high, and therefore the leverage component is not nearly the majority of your capital structure.”
Thoma Bravo's core investment philosophy has not changed since it entered software 22 years ago, while its investing, deal, and operating tactics have evolved; the challenge has shifted from generating deal pipeline and winning deals to choosing which few opportunities to pursue.
“our philosophy has remained the same since we started doing software 22 years ago. The tactics are always evolving.”
In the ops review, each functional and geographic business unit's P&L is examined against best-in-class metrics, and the goal is to improve execution so that more profit can be reinvested in growth.
“We review the P&L and the activities, in case the company's organized differently, of every business unit, of every geographical area.”
Technology companies are reaching scale faster than private investors can raise capital to buy them, and this gap will only widen, so the constraint is deciding where to spend time, not finding money.
“These tech companies are going public and are achieving scale faster than you could raise capital to go out and invest in them, and that is only going to get worse.”
After the dot-com bust, Thoma Bravo's team concluded software maintenance streams were cheaper than almost any other recurring revenue, such as media, radio, or transaction processing, and their stickiness made them attractive buyout targets even though many companies were unprofitable.
“you can buy software maintenance streams less expensively than almost any other form of recurring revenue in different industries”
Software products that deliver growing value to customers can justify annual price increases above labor inflation, which funds profitability and allows reinvestment in growth.
“the yearly increase in the value of that product merits a price increase that is higher than your labor inflation, a key point today in this inflationary world.”
Over the last five years Thoma Bravo has been buying growth and earning returns from growth plus operational improvement, which is harder than operations alone because it also requires being correct about future growth.
“we have been buying growth, not earning returns through just operational improvements, it's earning returns through that, plus being correct on growth. That's harder to do as well.”
Software companies with roughly 90 percent gross margins can become high cash-flow generators under control ownership even when they are unprofitable, which makes them good candidates for control-style investing.
“theoretically, with 90% gross margins, these businesses can be high cashflow generative, and therefore good candidates for a fundamental control-type investing.”
Thoma Bravo's first software deal, Prophet 21, was bought at roughly two times maintenance revenue with little competition, and the company had never been meaningfully profitable and was near break-even.
“the price looked great at around two times maintenance revenue, one times two.”
The leverage boom that started around 2005 was short-lived because the 2007 financial crisis hit, and the firm only returned to deal-making around 2011 when the software-as-a-service transition was well underway.
“Leverage came into the market, really, in 2005, but that was short-lived, because the financial crisis came in, in 2007.”
Understanding what one is passionate about and what their mission is makes personal, business, and philanthropic decisions converge, because it clarifies how one spends time and why one is driven to help others.
“The more you can understand what you're passionate about and have an opinion on, the more those worlds converge and become the same.”
Young talent should listen carefully to a range of mentors who legitimately want to help, choosing whom to learn from, and maintain humble confidence rather than assume a field is mature or closed.
“keep your ears open, your heart open, your mind open, because there are mentors all around you”
Someone doing a deal for the first time can have an advantage over a seasoned dealmaker, because they may lack entrenched judgments and can be more open with the counterparty.
“Sometimes doing it for the first time is an advantage, because you may not come with certain judgements or experiences”
Wall Street uses the word volatile to describe falling markets, a euphemism that developed so brokers would not scare clients, and it obscures the fact that volatility is typically a sign of decline.
“we always say volatile means down. Nobody says the market's volatile when it's going up.”
Selling companies well to strategic buyers, who have bought three companies from the firm, builds relationships that lead to repeat acquisitions, and a company left in good hands with existing management continues to do well for the buyer.
“We have a strategic buyer that has bought three companies from us”
Decentralization, extended from organizational structure to Web3 networks, will be a defining force of the 2020s because interconnected, open idea exchange produces better, faster, and more equal outcomes than centralized systems.
“You have, ideally, an interconnected network of ideas where everyone that has a passion for something”
Many investors in the community are nervous about selling and become paralyzed by concerns about how the sale looks, while selling after a good return and handing the company to strong owners is a sound choice.
“There is nothing wrong with putting up a good return, leaving the company in great hands”
Investment firms' post-2014 commitments to diversity and mentoring women have opened recruiting to candidates outside Harvard-type schools, because talent is now found everywhere and the industry is more open to different backgrounds.
“talent is everywhere now, and our community, our industry, we're lucky to be a lot more open to different places”
Billion-dollar SaaS companies now compound at about 20 percent per year, which means they double roughly every four years.
“Even if you look at assets that are at scale, at a billion dollars plus, they're now compounding in the SaaS world at 20%, which means they'll double every four years.”
Continuation funds, long-dated funds, SPACs, and hybrid venture-hedge-private-equity structures are the financial industry's attempts to keep pace with software and tech innovation, because traditional fund structures cannot address the opportunity alone.
“All these are ways that the financial community has been looking to innovate in order to match or try to keep up with the innovations”
Thoma Bravo's portfolio of enterprise cybersecurity and software companies is among the largest software portfolios in the world, yet most of its companies are not household names because they sell heavy technical solutions to businesses rather than consumers.
“these are heavy enterprise technical solutions to corporate customers”
The speaker's personal mission is to provide opportunities to talented young adults who otherwise would not have a chance, and in acquisitions this means giving capable management a chance to do things differently while adapting to their culture.
“my mission is to provide opportunities to talented people, especially young adults, that otherwise wouldn't have that chance.”
The growth-first business model may have been taught to companies by early venture investors, who need companies to raise more money, creating more equity opportunities for investors.
“Is it that early-on VCs, teach these companies that way in order for them to, of course, grow in winning their markets?”
Dealmaking is not especially hard at the big-picture level, since people are more open than expected to a phone call, but the tactical details during the process are numerous and require repeated experience.
“On the one hand, it's really not that hard. If you really look at the big picture”
The Bravo Family Foundation's relief work after Hurricane Maria backed existing community leaders rather than imposing outside plans, and the Rising Entrepreneurs program in Puerto Rico gives young founders capital, VC access, and mentorship.
“We went directly to community leaders that run those communities, that know their people, that live in it”
Tokens and currencies that support decentralized networks act as collateral and as a way to measure the value of each community and system, and they are as real as any currency created under the traditional financial system.
“they're the collateral for the system. They're the ways of measuring the value of each of those communities and systems, and they're as real as any currency”
SoftBank's very large fund for minority technology investing was visionary because it recognized that software companies would stay private longer and need a large, fast-moving source of capital, though Orlando was initially skeptical.
“It was very forward-looking and visionary to say the world of technology and software, it's going to create these massive companies that are going to stay private longer”
The lack of public investors specializing in enterprise software is both a limitation on the market's ability to value great assets and an opportunity for specialized investors to exploit.
“Now, that's a limitation on what we believe are some great assets that are out there, but that's also an opportunity for others to focus on.”
One of Thoma Bravo's biggest mistakes has been not doing more deals, because there is not unlimited capital and the firm has stayed close to its historical pace.
“One of the biggest mistakes we've made is not doing more deals.”
Almost-100% recurring revenue software companies with stronger terminal growth rates are a better asset to own than the S&P 500, given their cash flow and performance breakout potential.
“These recurring revenue, almost a hundred percent recurring revenue companies with much better terminal growth rates”
Multiple expansion happened in software buyouts from 2000 to 2005, but investors were not underwriting it, so the firm's returns came from operations and multiple expansion was a bonus.
“In hindsight groups like us earned it on operations and then multiplied expansion obviously happened. I don't think people were underwriting that”
Orlando's favorite parts of the work are the competitive dynamics of deals and later hearing from management that the firm kept its promises, which he finds more meaningful than the deal itself.
“The second thing, and this takes longer, that I really love about our business is making those promises to existing management”
Growth equity investors invest their funds in roughly 9 to 12 months, while traditional control private equity investors usually take four to five years to fully invest a fund, so the whole community now moves faster, and Thoma Bravo has always invested fast and sold fast.
“investing those growth equity funds in a period of nine to 12 months. Then on top of that, you see what you would call the traditional private equity community, the control investors, that would take usually four to five years to fully invest the fund”
A mentor who helped Orlando move from New York to Silicon Valley in 1994 and a Brown friend's job referral were the kindest acts that shaped his career path into private equity.
“I had this great mentor from Puerto Rico who unfortunately passed away years ago, who worked so hard with me to leave New York to go to Silicon Valley in 1994”
Private equity is not a mature field despite its size, and anyone who believes it is fully mature and hard to enter is wrong, as the speaker found when he interviewed at Stanford in 1998 and the industry has grown since.
“Private equity, for example, if you think it's mature, it's just getting started.”