Nick Kokonas - Know What You Are Selling - [Invest Like The Best, REPLAY]
What this covers
This replay pairs Patrick O'Shaughnessy with Nick Kokonas, co-founder of Alinea, Next, and The Aviary and CEO of the booking platform Tock. Kokonas studied philosophy and traded derivatives before moving into hospitality. That background shapes the conversation, including his Casino Edge Model of winning by being right slightly more than half the time across thousands of outcomes. The talk moves between restaurant operations, software company-building, and an outsider's critique of book publishing.
The restaurant material is concrete. Kokonas lays out a typical cost structure of roughly 30 to 35 percent labor, 30 to 35 percent food, and about 30 percent fixed costs, leaving about 10 percent margin. He argues that only about 4 percent of guests buy a tasting menu because it is offered mid-meal and any person at the table can veto it. He treats a seat as an option that decays toward expiration, and he says misstated party sizes cost Alinea over a million dollars a year. He also describes prepaying a meat supplier to cut dry-aged beef from $34 to $18 a pound. He predicts that dynamic pricing will reach any time-slotted service, from dentists to personal trainers.
The wider range is where the claims get contested. Kokonas explains why Tock turned away restaurant groups and started with high-end prix fixe venues, and how an enthusiastic response to his blog post misled him about demand. He recalls recognizing COVID as an existential threat by late February, and he argues delivery apps could not be profitable at 20 to 30 percent commissions. On publishing, he questions why printing costs are kept secret when authors earn around 10 percent. He also briefly takes up Picasso as a self-promoter and Alinea's edible helium balloon.
Kokonas argues that restaurants and publishing are good businesses when run with discipline: the operator must know exactly what experiences they sell, sell them explicitly through time-based and demand-based pricing, and own the customer relationship and economics rather than ceding them to intermediaries.
- Restaurants sell many distinct experiences (bar seats, tasting menus, private dining, merchandise) but most sell only 'food' and leave revenue unpriced and unexposed
- Time-slotted pricing and prepaid tickets reduce no-shows and unused capacity, and can lift margins from roughly 10% toward 20-30%
- Owning customer identity (email), vendor terms, and publishing rights turns intermediary costs into controllable economics
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
With thousands of outcomes, being right slightly more than half the time wins overall, so a business can be wrong 49% of the time and still come out ahead, like a casino with a small house edge and many players.
“If you have thousands and thousands of outcomes and you're right more than half, you're going to win even though 49% of the time you lose.”
Tock turned away restaurant groups that wanted to sign on because it lacked the features they needed, and it grew capital-efficiently by onboarding a limited number of restaurants and doing it perfectly.
“I just went, 'We're not quite ready for you yet.' ... we'll fail if we do this right now”
The generalizable lesson for any business is to know exactly what you are selling, categorize each product and experience, inform consumers that they exist, and then actually sell them, since customers cannot buy what is not offered.
“Know what you're selling and then actually sell it, which sounds incredibly obvious.”
Kokonas's 5,000-word blog post drew a flood of enthusiastic restaurant emails, but the people who write in are a small minority, so early enthusiasm misled him about market demand and the crossing-the-chasm problem.
“Now, if 200 restaurant owners email you, you fall into the trap like every startup going like, well everybody thinks this way.”
Book publishing hides its economics: a $50 retail book may cost about $2 to print, authors earn around 10 percent of cover price, and publishers reject transparency requests, which suggests publishers take little risk relative to the advances they pay.
“a $50 retail book cost about $2 to print, and you're going to get 10% of cover price”
Restaurants traditionally pay this week's bills with last month's revenue, but when deposits and prepaid tickets arrive early, they create a cash float that can be used to prepay vendors and lock in lower prices, which is more valuable than earning about 1% interest on cash.
“What are you earning in interest these days? 1% a year or something like that? It makes no sense to do that.”
Startups should grow capital-efficiently, since the value of scalable software comes on a long horizon, and restaurants that became profitable in their second month show that a business can invest upfront and still be profitable.
“The time horizon on investing money in a startup, tech startup especially, is a lot longer than people think.”
Third-party delivery apps lost money in COVID even as revenue tripled, because last-mile delivery to a single restaurant is not profitable at 20 to 30 percent commissions, which makes consolidation and pricing changes inevitable.
“every single one of the US based delivery applications actually lost more money during COVID even though their revenue tripled.”
Kokonas recognized COVID as an existential risk to restaurants and software serving them by late February, and the March 8 Seattle senior-care cases convinced him the whole industry was at serious risk.
“We started talking about that February 28th.”
A typical restaurant spends about 30 to 35 percent on labor, 30 to 35 percent on food, and about 30 percent on fixed costs, leaving roughly 10 percent margin, so revenue-side efficiency is the main lever to reach 20 to 30 percent per restaurant.
“It's usually 30 to 35% labor, 30 to 35% food costs, 30% on your fixed costs and insurance and overhead and all that. What are you left with? 10%.”
By offering to prepay a meat supplier for four months, Kokonas got a dry-aged beef price of $18 a pound instead of $34, because the supplier's net-120 terms caused waste from aging beef that was then sold as dog food.
“And he was like, $18 a pop. Half. Half price.”
Restaurant seats have option-like value that decays toward expiration, so the value of a seat changes as service time approaches, and a static pricing approach ignores that value erosion.
“If everything went to zero at the end of a day that's like an expiring option. And that option value changes the closer you get to expiration.”
Restaurants should collect every guest's email address as the unique customer identifier, since email enables re-marketing and lookalike audiences on platforms like Facebook and Instagram, and the phone number is inferior.
“Not their cellphone number, their email address. It's the unique identifier.”
Tock focused first on high-end prix fixe restaurants where it could prove a large return, then moved down market, similar to Tesla building the premium car first before cheaper models.
“It's kind of like the Tesla approach. Let's build the fancy car first and then work our way down market.”
Early software companies should deliberately decline restaurant groups that want the product before it is ready, because onboarding unready customers would cause failure, and Tock grew capital-efficiently by onboarding only 50 restaurants a month rather than 100.
“We're not quite ready for you yet.”
A business plan is not understood until it can be written on one page from the diner's perspective, and chefs who cannot describe the emotional experience they create for guests lack a clear vision of their business.
“Write up one page of what it's like as a diner to eat at your restaurant.”
Great artists like Picasso died rich while also being prolific and clever, so art and commercial success are not mutually exclusive, and Picasso's 1920s documentary of his painting was a deliberate self-promotion tool.
“four of the five of these guys died rich on their art and one of them cut off his ear... Picasso was prolific but he was also really clever and he was a genius. So they're not mutually exclusive.”
When an industry refuses to answer basic cost questions, such as printing costs in publishing, it signals that intermediaries are capturing outsized profits, and questioning them is a way to find opportunity.
“If you ask questions of an industry and they won't tell you the answer, that's always a good sign that someone's getting very wealthy.”
Alinea designed dishes by asking how to make adults feel childlike again, which produced an edible helium balloon dessert that is simple to make but wildly fun because it recreates a sense of novelty.
“We were like, how do you become more childlike? What is a way to make an adult feel like a kid again?”
Restaurant guests misstate party size and reservation needs to the restaurant, and this costs Alinea over a million dollars a year in forgone revenue, since a table booked for six but used by two wastes capacity worth about $1,000 per occurrence.
“So all of a sudden you have two people sitting at a six top and you've just forgone $1,000 in revenue.”
Any time-slotted service, including lawyers, dentists, salons, and personal trainers, should eventually be dynamically priced because peak times such as 10 a.m. Saturday are more valuable than off-peak times, and hard goods already do this while services lag.
“Any business that's time slotted should be dynamically and variably priced right down to your lawyer frankly.”
A restaurant like Gramercy Tavern actually sells at least eight distinct offerings (bar, casual, a la carte, two tasting menus, private dining, and merchandise) but the booking process reveals only that the guest is showing up.
“So eight things that they are selling. The bar, the casual, the a la carte, two prix fixe menus, private dining and merchandise.”
Only about 4 percent of guests buy a tasting menu not because of low demand but because the menu is offered by the server mid-meal, and any table member can veto it, so presenting it as a pre-sold option would sell far more.
“that's because you're relying on the server to surprise them with this as an option and then everyone at the table needs to agree to it at that moment.”
Holding cash for net-90 or net-120 vendor payments earns little interest, so prepaying suppliers in exchange for discounts and forward contracts is a better use of cash than the float.
“What are you earning in interest these days? 1% a year or something like that? It makes no sense to do that.”
OpenTable's business model intermediates the restaurant and diner relationship and charges a per-diner fee, so it claims to deliver diners and keeps the customer data, leaving restaurants unable to know their own guests.
“Open Table wants to own that relationship because that's how they monetize it.”
Tock built empathy for end users by putting its engineers to work as restaurant hosts instead of using focus groups, so they experienced the check-in process the software would replace.
“We did the opposite. We took our people and we put them into the restaurant.”
Restaurant carryout pricing should let consumers choose pickup at a small fee or delivery at a flat fee of 5 to 7 dollars, which spreads the true delivery cost across the diner, reduces the restaurant share, and is equitable to drivers.
“give the consumer a choice between picking it up themselves at the restaurant or paying for the convenience of having it delivered”
Restaurants that demand net-90 or net-120 payment terms from vendors waste the supplier's inventory and deny the vendor certainty, while prepaying with an estimate of next month's sales and mitigating the risk with forward contracts lowers food costs substantially.
“It makes sense to get ahead of that curve, estimate your next month's sales, and prepay for the food. Now, there's risk involved in that, but you've mitigated that risk by much, much better food prices.”
Tasting menus sell poorly when offered by a server at the table because one dissenting guest can veto them; selling a fixed number of tasting-menu seats in advance, such as 100 of 250, guarantees sales and tells the kitchen what each guest will eat.
“If one person doesn't agree with it, it gets vetoed and everyone orders a la carte.”
Restaurants can sell prepaid tickets for time-slotted experiences like theater or sports events, as opposed to treating restaurants as non-entertainment, and selling ahead creates forward cash and reduces empty seats.
“Look, baseball games, concerts, theater, every other form of entertainment does some sort of ticketing.”
Variable pricing affects customer behavior even at small price differences, so a restaurant could charge $5 more for prime slots and still shift demand, and the approach is not limited to high-end restaurants.
“You could charge $5 and still affect people's behavior.”
Competing booking systems copied OpenTable's feature set and gave software away free to gain share, but free pricing attracts the price-sensitive customers who are least likely to thrive, so this strategy yields the worst customers.
“So in a weird way you get the worst customers. If people are that price sensitive they're probably not thriving.”
High-profile restaurants bring thousands of new diners to a booking platform because guests seek out those restaurants regardless of the booking system, so the platform gets distribution for free through its restaurant clients.
“we're getting thousands at the time, just a couple thousand, but thousands of new clients every time we add a high end restaurant because people are seeking out that restaurant.”
Making lots of decisions only helps if they reach a completed, measurable outcome; founders who spend time sketching logos or ideas without producing and testing anything have learned nothing.
“You need to get it to some sort of completion where there is an outcome that can be measured.”
Imitators copy trendy innovations but fail because they do not understand the core reason the idea works, and ideas without high-level execution fall flat, so one must identify the core why before copying.
“You have to figure out the core of why it's special and that's a tricky thing to do a lot of times.”
Restaurant operators fail to multiply small daily losses across seven days a week and 52 weeks a year, so even a $20 daily leak is significant and the industry ends up as a low-margin business.
“no one multiplies it out by seven days a week, 52 weeks a year. So if you have something that's costing you even $20 a day, add it up.”
Restaurants can pull demand-shifting levers such as pricing and deals to fill Tuesday nights, since nearly all restaurants are busier on Saturday, yet the high-end industry refuses to use pricing for fear of upsetting Saturday guests.
“What are you going to do about that? How are you going to get more people in on Tuesday? What levers are you going to pull to get them in?”
Exposing the process of creation, as Picasso did in a film made to promote himself, is a way to build awareness and value, and businesses should communicate directly with customers, since people buy the person as much as the product.
“At the end of the day you buy the person as much as the product.”
A risk that has a small chance of happening but would wipe out the business should be mitigated even if it probably will not occur, because being prepared costs little and preserves the company if the risk materializes.
“if something has a 10% chance of happening but if it happens it wipes you out, you need to mitigate that risk.”
Picasso's 1920s documentary of himself painting was a deliberate self-promotion tool, showing the creative process to build an audience, and Kokonas used it as a model for exposing the chef's process at Alinea.
“He made that in the '20s to promote himself. Think about that.”
Almost no restaurant, and many other businesses, cannot produce a customer list for the last six weeks, which Kokonas considers a basic failure to know who is buying.
“Okay. Show me your customer list for the last six weeks. And they can't.”
Because fixed costs such as rent are known, each additional sales dollar is the dollar the business keeps, so better selling efficiency and less waste compound margin improvement without changing the cost base.
“The denominator's the same and the numerator got bigger.”
Alinea was structured like a startup with three separate entities (investor LLC, restaurant, management company) whose interests were aligned for the long term, so investors still receive annual checks about 15 years later.
“Which means that 15 years later the investors in Alinea still get a really nice check every year.”
Alinea's team sells its own books directly through mailing lists, websites, social media, and roughly a couple thousand dollars a day in ads, generating $120,000 in one week with better margins than the restaurant, and the company owns the rights.
“Last week sold $120,000 of books in a week for our restaurant with margins much better than the restaurant.”
Within three days of Chicago's shutdown Alinea started selling $35 beef wellingtons for carryout, reaching 1,000 orders a night within a week and rehiring furloughed staff within about five weeks, because a cloud-based time-slot system could be adapted quickly.
“Three days after Chicago shut down we started serving $35 beef wellingtons out of Alinea”
Most businesses are not great businesses, and restaurants are often dismissed as terrible even though successful operators build multiple restaurants and some celebrity chefs own 35, which shows money can be made in them.
“If you build one and it's such a terrible business, why did you build four more?”
Restaurants have a low knowledge barrier to entry compared with businesses like software, since one can sign a lease, build a kitchen, and start cooking, and this low barrier is why the failure rate is high.
“The barrier to entry to a restaurant is you sign a lease and build a kitchen and start cooking.”
Art and commerce are not mutually exclusive: running a restaurant as a business first generates the profits that let it invest more in the art, creating a virtuous cycle, whereas artists who treat commerce as antithetical to their ethics limit their own outcomes.
“If we run it well as a business then we can invest more in the art and it becomes a virtuous cycle.”
Restaurants should avoid marketing language like avant garde and science because these words alienate potential diners, and molecular gastronomy was a misnomer that misled press and customers about what the cooking was.
“I was like, 'Well, you automatically eliminate 90% of people.' No one wants to eat science.”
Owning something is a more likely path to wealth creation than a corporate career, and it gives the owner responsibility so that their fate is not decided by someone else.
“it was own something. It wasn't go to college and become a lawyer or a doctor”
Alinea deliberately avoided words like avant garde and science in press and used fun and delicious, because avant garde and science alienated potential diners who did not want to eat science.
“Two words that we would avoid were Avant Garde and science.”
A small per-person deposit for a high-demand table reduces no-shows and, once paid, makes guests spend more and feel happier because the sunk cost is mentally settled before arrival.
“The sunk cost of that $10 per person is mentally done a week before they arrive.”
Self-publishing a book is feasible and profitable when the author already has a built-in audience through a business, social media, or mailing list, but academic books without built-in audiences are better placed with traditional publishers.
“if you have an audience already in whatever business you're doing, or a large social media following or any of that, doing a book and publishing it yourself is not hard.”
Calling startup losses burn is misleading, since money spent to build a scalable software business is an investment with a long payback horizon, and early SaaS companies must be capital-efficient, unlike the venture narrative of huge early raises.
“I'm not burning money, I'm investing it.”
When Next launched as a rotating-menu restaurant with ticketed reservations, it sold $562,000 in tickets on the first day, showing demand for a restaurant that sold its experience in advance.
“the first day we sold $562,000 in tickets to a restaurant for the first time ever.”
Customers accept premium pricing for peak events like courtside football tickets, so restaurants fear for nothing when they charge more for prime times and experiences.
“Do people sitting on the 50-yard line on the 10th row, are they pissed off that they spent $500 on the football game instead of $80”
Next sold out every seat for a year with a $85, 12-course opening menu, and generated over 30 percent margins in its first year, exceeding its goals while delivering value.
“we sold every single seat for a year. We made over 30% margins in the first year.”
The term molecular gastronomy was coined by Hervé This to describe the component aspects of cooking, not manipulating individual molecules, and press misusing it made chefs seem like scientists.
“it was actually coined by Hervé This and it was about the component aspect.”
Kokonas prefers hard businesses because if he can figure them out he gains an edge, and industry insiders who warn of high failure rates are often defending their position rather than telling the full truth.
“I like businesses that are hard because if I can figure them out”
Restaurants already compete with entertainment, so ticketing like sports, concerts, and theater is a rational approach, but restaurants were told it was a terrible idea because they are not entertainment, despite being social and entertaining.
“Eating out is a social endeavor. It's entertainment. It might be art. And it definitely is sustenance as well.”
For the first ten years of Alinea, Kokonas emailed two diners or bloggers every day, roughly 700 guests a year, which took about five minutes a day and produced a personal connection that customers found surprising.
“every single day when I woke up I emailed two people that were either diners or posted on their blog about their dinner.”
A three-Michelin-star restaurant targeting perfection should run 40 to 60 covers a night, since that volume is far easier to execute at the highest level than 120 covers a night.
“If you're shooting for perfection in a Michelin three star restaurant, you do 40 to 50 to 60 people a night.”
Alinea's giant table-sized plate idea failed in practice due to weight, storage, and washing constraints, was shelved for months, and was revived when a collaborator suggested gray latex as a flexible substitute for the rigid plate.
“The idea went away for like four or five months after the big plates because it didn't work.”
Alinea hired Allen and Sarah Hemberger from Pixar and Industrial Light and Magic and gave them equity, and three years later the company has six books generating millions of dollars in revenue each year.
“We gave them equity in the thing so that they own part of it.”
Kokonas instituted a five-minute call time, mandatory temperature checks, hand washing and masks two and a half weeks before Chicago's shutdown, and enforced it by threatening firing, which got compliance even though staff thought he was unhinged.
“Anyone who doesn't do it is fired.”
Outdoor patios and plastic yurts are a six-week solution to a six-month problem because Chicago winters make them unusable, so restaurants need carryout as a lasting resilience layer.
“that is a six-week solution to a six-month problem.”
A booking network's resilience comes from coverage across many cities and restaurant types rather than concentration in coastal hubs such as New York, Los Angeles, and San Francisco, which is why the model resonated with investors only recently.
“You need everywhere and you need all sorts of different restaurants”
Tock charged restaurants a flat 3 percent for carryout orders, undercutting delivery apps that charge 20 to 30 percent, and Kokonas says he wishes he had charged 6 to 10 percent because the price was too low.
“We charged a flat 3% because we built the whole thing on the back of our events platform that charged 3%.”
In business, leaders must accept that many things will fail as an inevitable part of doing things correctly, so that they can remain productive and not become discouraged, even though they still prefer being right 80% of the time.
“Learning to be wrong and accept that as a process or indeed an inevitable outcome if you're doing things correctly means that you can be correct and wrong at the same time”
Alinea's investors paid full price with a 20 percent discount rather than receiving preferred-table perks, so that a frequent diner and an occasional one both contribute and the economics stay aligned with paying customers.
“We said every one of the investors will pay, including myself.”
Pre-selling restaurant seats gives the operator information advantage, analogous to a trader's five-second time advantage from connecting exchanges, because the operator knows demand before the seat is used.
“I had a five second time machine on the market.”
At the end of the day customers buy the person as much as the product, which is why executives like Steve Jobs and Elon Musk become associated with their companies because they communicate directly and sell their ideas.
“At the end of the day you buy the person as much as the product.”
Every restaurant experience should be fun and delicious, because the best restaurants make diners feel they are part of the performance rather than an audience, and anything not delicious is a farce.
“Everything we do has to be fun and it has to be delicious or we will not do it.”
The kindest acts are recognizing and thanking people for things they did long ago, and small thoughtful gestures such as a handmade knife with an embedded napkin carry more meaning than their monetary value.
“What's really cool is that he took the time to do it and sort of said, 'Hey, this is important to me.' Those kinds of little kindnesses are the big ones.”
Publishing is often assumed to be a bad business, but it can be very profitable when the operator owns the rights, sells directly, and avoids the publisher's margin.
“Which I think, again, like restaurants, many would knee jerk reaction say is a bad business.”
About 70% of everything booked on Tock is a free reservation, such as a bar seat, while ticketed experiences and carryout add revenue, so a mix of free and paid products makes the business model more resilient.
“70% of everything on Tock is a totally free reservation. It's not a ticket. It's not a deposit.”
Of five famous artists, four died rich from their art, so an artist who wants to die poor and cut off an ear can do so, but Kokonas does not want to invest in that model as a business.
“four of the five of these guys died rich on their art and one of them cut off his ear.”
Tock signed over 3,000 restaurants since March and expects to reach a billion-dollar gross merchandise value run rate by year end, with 70 percent of its reservations being free reservations rather than paid tickets or deposits.
“we've signed up over 3,000 restaurants. Our business will be at a billion-dollar GMV run rate by the end of the year.”
Some restaurants have operated for decades essentially as nonprofits, and that is a valid choice for them, though it is not what Kokonas wanted to build.
“there are restaurants out there by the way that have run for decades nonprofits essentially. And they don't mind.”
A meaningful act of kindness is thanking someone for help long after it was given, and sincere recognition or even tough love can count as kindness.
“Any time that someone says thank you for something that was done a long time ago is a nice thing.”
Allen Hemberger, who runs Alinea's publishing, once returned a stolen napkin by sending a hand-forged knife with resin embedded napkin, which Kokonas considered one of the coolest things anyone had done, because the time spent signaled it mattered.
“What's really cool is that he took the time to do it and sort of said, Hey, this is important to me.”