Mitch Lasky - The Business of Gaming - [Invest Like the Best, EP.293]
What this covers
The host talks with Mitch Lasky, a Benchmark partner who has built, run, and invested in game companies for about thirty years. The conversation works as a history of how the business got its present shape. It starts with id Software's Doom, which Lasky calls the first modern game company because of its shareware distribution and its early grasp of internet multiplayer. It then moves to Half-Life, whose lasting importance he locates in Valve building Steam around it, which produced a platform-based publisher. From there he follows the move from $60 discs to free-to-play, through Nexon's KartRider and Riot's League of Legends, and explains why elastic pricing and a handful of heavy spenders now drive revenue.
The middle of the discussion covers a wide range. On design, Lasky proposes asking what a player does most often and whether that is pleasurable. He traces the hack-and-slash pattern back to DikuMUDs and credits EVE Online's concentric security zones. He also argues that durable play patterns like chess and poker outlast the industry's fast churn. On business, he gives rough market sizing, with mobile at over half of revenue. He covers the hit Apple's privacy changes put on paid acquisition, and the way YouTube and Twitch supplied marketing that money couldn't buy. He also notes that Unity and Unreal lower the barrier to making games without making great games any easier.
The most contested material is forward-looking. Lasky doubts VR will reach mass adoption soon. He says metaverse talk of portable items and currencies ignores the agreed protocols and trust those would need. He suggests Web3 developers should study EVE Online, and that a workable Web3 game would turn speculators into players rather than recruiters.
Lasky argues that video games are a durable, content-driven business whose economics rest on platform aggregation and elastic free-to-play monetization, and that current hype around VR, the metaverse, and Web3 underestimates the design and integration problems these models must solve.
- Games shifted from one-time disc sales to free-to-play models that monetize engaged users elastically, creating a whale-driven revenue curve
- Platform-based publishers win by aggregating demand, and content hits are the usual seed for that aggregation
- VR, Web3, and metaverse ideas face unsolved integration and design problems that hype overlooks
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The most important insight for understanding the modern games business is the change from an inelastic pricing model, where every buyer pays the same $60 for a disc, to an elastic model, where free-to-play lets heavy users spend far more while light users pay little or nothing.
“this change from an inelastic pricing model to an elastic pricing model”
Half-Life's most important contribution to the business is not its creativity but that Valve built Steam around it, creating the first and still most successful online game distributor, which became a platform-based publisher that enabled later products like CS:GO.
“what Valve built around the game ended up becoming Steam, which is one of the most important distribution vectors in the history of the video game business”
First-person shooters, adventure games, and MMORPGs have changed little in their core design patterns, and modern MMOs still use the design pattern from DikuMUDs invented in Copenhagen in the early 1990s.
“MMOs go back to the DikuMUDs that were invented in Copenhagen back in the early '90s.”
id Software, the developers of Doom, was the first modern video game company because it pioneered free-to-try shareware distribution, championed independent creative control, and recognized the power of multiplayer internet play, though its distribution was still limited by physical discs.
“I think that they are the first modern video game company in a lot of ways.”
YouTube, and later Twitch, became the most important non-game drivers of the gaming industry because uploading and watching gameplay created marketing that could not be bought at any price, as with Minecraft's billions of views.
“YouTube in the first instance, and then Twitch later, are the most important non-game drivers of the gaming industry in the world.”
EVE Online's concentric circles of security, with protected core zones and an unprotected null-sec frontier, let new players be shielded while experienced players migrate to more user-controlled play, creating built-in elder-game roles.
“they created these concentric circles of moderation”
The shift from physical discs to online platforms moved the publisher's core role from controlling distribution and rolling up supply to aggregating demand, so that major publishers like Activision and EA now publish on Steam to reach a pre-qualified audience.
“When that happens, it changes the nature of the supply side of the business.”
Making items and currency interoperate across games requires agreed protocols and trust, and it is far harder than metaverse proponents suggest, since translating a Call of Duty currency or gun into Fortnite raises monetary-system-level questions.
“In order to make these things work, we have to agree on protocols, which are going to allow us to interoperate. That is a massively non-trivial problem.”
When Riot pitched League of Legends, the idea of giving a hardcore game away and monetizing with cosmetics seemed radical, with the widespread assumption that the core audience would reject it; League of Legends went on to generate about $1 billion a year for a decade.
“League of Legends went on to generate $1 billion a year in revenue for a decade”
Twitch and League of Legends launched together and reinforced each other in a two-company network effect, where League streams drove Twitch viewership and Twitch viewership drove League downloads, with League making up half of streams early on.
“Twitch benefited from the usage of League of Legends and League of Legends benefited from the usage of Twitch”
EVE Online has many attributes of a Web3 game, including a largely free economy with light developer steering, and its decade of dynamic emergent behavior is highly worthy of study by Web3 developers who are ignoring it.
“EVE Online, famous game, one of the forever games from CCP in Iceland”
Nexon's KartRider, launched in Korea around 2005, proved the industry could give an entire game away for free and monetize through cosmetics and status items, a model that its marketing advantage made highly successful.
“It was the whole enchilada. You got the entire game for free.”
Unity and Unreal have democratized game creation much as cheap cameras democratized filmmaking, but making a great game remains a unique and difficult skill, so more creators does not mean better games.
“More doesn't necessarily mean better in this case.”
The games business is fundamentally a customer acquisition and customer lifetime value business, similar to subscription businesses, although its monetization models are far more diverse, so retention matters but is not the whole story.
“The key things to understand about the business model are that it is ultimately a customer acquisition, customer lifetime value business, fundamentally”
The games business is roughly 180 to 190 billion dollars worldwide, with about 50 to 55 percent of revenue from mobile, leaving roughly 20 percent for PC and 25 percent for console of the remaining half, which surprises people who come from the historical games business.
“It's about 50% to 55% mobile in terms of revenue, which is very surprising to most people”
Apple's privacy changes reduced the ability to target whales and potential installers, causing install declines of 10 to 35 percent for aggregation-oriented companies that relied on paid advertising, while companies with a single product hit were hit even harder.
“installs are down between 10% on the good side and 35% on the bad side for some of these companies”
In free-to-play games, a small minority of extremely heavy users, the whales, generate outsized revenue, so the economics of the business depend on a tiny percentage of customers.
“the thousand hour person is going to pay you insane amounts of money and thus the rise of the modern whale”
Games that last indefinitely are built on play patterns that are highly durable across decades or centuries, such as chess, backgammon, whist, and poker, and the video game industry's rapid turnover has distorted people's sense of how long play patterns last.
“Fun game play patterns are incredibly durable. The nature of consumption in the video game business has perverted our understanding of that.”
VR is unlikely to become a mass market phenomenon soon because the headsets are still primitive in computation and graphics, users are shielded from the world, and despite about 10 billion dollars of investment, adoption and per-app economics are weak.
“It's really stillborn in a lot of ways.”
At one point Steam represented a double-digit percentage of industry revenues, making it a multi-billion-dollar business and the most successful online distributor of video games.
“At one point, represented double digit percentage of industry revenues in terms of what was flowing through Steam.”
A key test of a game's design is what the player does most frequently, and whether that high-frequency activity is pleasurable; most failed products have a mismatch between how constant the core activity is and how pleasurable it feels.
“most of the products I see that fail have a mismatch between the constancy of the activity and the pleasure of that activity”
The hack-and-slash role-playing pattern, descended from DikuMUD with character classes, experience investment, combat, and inventory, is probably the most important play pattern in video game history, more important than the console platformer.
“I think that is probably the most important play pattern in the history of the video game business.”
In League of Legends, selling potions that multiply experience gain monetized busy players who could not grind for long hours, and it was popular because it did not create pay-to-win, since players still had to grind.
“they could get 10 hours worth of credit”
Blake Robbins' three-body framing shows that Web3 games add a speculator to the developer-player relationship, and three-body systems are inherently unstable, so Web3 integration has not yet been solved at the level of design.
“when you introduce the Web3 stuff, you have now a speculator as the third body and three body problems are inherently unstable”
The successful Web3 product will create a gamification experience around speculators so their motivation is play rather than growth, avoiding a Ponzi dynamic where recruiting new buyers raises prices and over-rewards early speculators at the expense of later ones.
“A gamification experience around the speculator, such that their sole motivation isn't growth”
The next generation of games investors coming from deal-side backgrounds may be less capable than those with creative or publishing experience, because having made green-light product decisions gives an evaluation advantage.
“having those creative chops, having been a creative executive and having had to make green light decisions over product is incredibly valuable”
Games are eating the world in a certain way, because consumer internet, social networking, and Web3 are learning from games concepts such as virtual economies, making game thinking more broadly applicable to consumer investing than ever before.
“I think games are eating the world in a certain way too.”
When investing in League of Legends at about 20 employees with only a wireframe, Lasky overrode red flags about founder background and team inexperience because the founders were compelling, and a conversation with the executive producer confirmed their competence.
“In my experience as a publisher, having published hundreds of games, these would've all been huge red flags.”
Starting around 2000 to 2005, games like World of Warcraft, League of Legends and Fortnite became durable over years, whereas console, PC and mobile games previously lived a fruit fly's lifespan, creating a temporal mismatch that made it hard for investors to judge continuity of value.
“Historically with the console business and the PC business and even the mobile business, games would come and go in a fruit fly's lifespan.”
Phil Spencer's virtualization of the Xbox as a platform rather than a hardware appliance, through Game Pass, is one of the underappreciated business moves in video game history, bringing a Netflix-like subscription to games.
“his ability to virtualize the Xbox as a platform rather than as a hardware appliance is one of the underappreciated business moves”
Games are much harder to evaluate from early metrics than social networks, because early KPIs can be distorted by enthusiast adoption and by failure to transition to mass market or aggressive acquisition spending, so investors must make an aesthetic judgment about whether a game will find an audience.
“Much harder to do with the games business. Much easier for those metrics to be manipulated in the early days through enthusiasts coming on board early”
Almost every platform-based aggregator has been seeded by a must-have hit piece of content rather than by a platform launched on its own, and this is natural, as Disney's use of Star Wars and Marvel in its streaming service shows.
“almost all of the other ones that we've seen have come from using a piece of must have hit driven content to seed the aggregation”
The most successful monetization strategies are more art than science, because they integrate tightly with game design and the ethos of the game, so it is a design-first process informed by quantitative data rather than a quant-first process.
“it's a design first informed by the quant rather than a quant first, design second”
Some mobile casino companies on a 100 million dollar revenue run rate were spending 92 million dollars on customer acquisition, and such models are dangerous because when they fall over they collapse quickly and dramatically.
“They're spending $92 million on customer acquisition.”
Online poker before legal trouble showed that sharks, skill, and real money can disrupt the play experience but also deepen its emotional intensity, providing lessons for Web3 games.
“having sharks and minnows and skill and real money disrupts and perverts the play experience. But at the same time also enhances the play experience”
Web3 designs fail if they let NFT owners be motivated by something other than play, because the danger is creating a bifurcation between owners whose motivations have nothing to do with the play experience and the actual players.
“just owning an effing NFT really does it. And I think that's the danger”
Venture capital historically underinvested in games because it viewed them as a hit-driven entertainment business controlled by aggregators and publishers, and it lacked a model for translating game success into value until persistent forever games emerged around 2000 to 2005.
“It was always viewed through this prism of, it's an entertainment business. It's a hit driven business.”
Games differ from film because they deliver experience through continuous player interactivity and the player controls the experience of time, so designers should build around a fun core interaction first, as in Nintendo's approach of making a character fun before building the game.
“Make the character fun to play with against a black screen.”
Web3 monetization can only succeed if it becomes almost transparent and invisible within the play experience, which has not yet been achieved, so Lasky is long-term optimistic but short-term pessimistic about Web3 games.
“I would say I'm long term optimistic, short term pessimistic.”
Giving a game away for free is one of the greatest marketing advantages because it removes the purchase barrier and lets the company monetize later after users are already hooked on the experience.
“which is one of the great marketing advantages of all time, when you can basically say to your consumer, 'Hey, you don't have to pay me'”
Unhealthy communities pull up the ladder behind early adopters, creating a sharks-and-minnows bifurcation between veterans and newcomers.
“some of the worst communities are where you get these sort of independent grunge music type phenomenon where it's like, 'Oh no, no, no. I was here first.'”
Celebrities brought into games from outside, like Snoop Dogg, bring audiences that leave when they do, whereas gaming-native creators like MrBeast and PewDiePie built franchises with extraordinary recognizability and sticky audiences.
“that audience will leave when they leave. Those audiences aren't that useful and sticky in that way.”
Investing in games requires making an aesthetic call about whether an audience will exist for a game, a skill most venture capitalists lack, which causes many investors to avoid the market.
“it is not a skill that many venture capitalists possess. And I think it's something that scares a lot of investors when they look at the market.”
Doom's developer and Apogee pioneered giving away the first part of a game for free, but physical distribution on discs added friction, and the model would have been transformative about ten years later when the internet matured.
“Had they come 10 years later when the internet was more of a thing, they could have been a radical transformer of the way that software was distributed”
The three major periods of virtual reality investment coincided with the publication of Neuromancer, Snow Crash, and Ready Player One, suggesting that the metaverse vision is partly a boy's fantasy inspired by fiction.
“three major periods of virtual reality investment and innovation coincided with the publishing of three key novels”
Pokemon Go showed that location-based, online-to-offline entertainment has unexplored potential, and Nintendo's release of its IP onto a mass-market phone platform was an underestimated driver of its success, so this category may be underinvested.
“those location based entertainment products are a potentially underinvested category”
Lasky favors games with organic distribution, such as community and word of mouth, because heavy reliance on paid acquisition makes companies vulnerable, and his portfolio company Jenova Chen's game spends a tiny fraction of revenue on paid acquisition.
“That's why I've always gravitated towards products that have a much more organic distribution opportunity.”
Lasky applies gaming-derived aesthetic judgment to non-gaming investments such as Snap and Discord, because better-designed products often win over the long term, although consumer products are also more amenable to quantitative cohort analysis.
“A lot of times, the better designed products win longer term.”
Mobile reinforced the move to free-to-play because thousands of new apps launch monthly, making upfront payment nearly impossible, and it also encouraged dark-pattern customer acquisition and incentivized installs, and extremely high acquisition spending.
“obviously when 2,000 games are being launched in the App Store every month, it's impossible to get somebody to pay for anything up front”
At a 20 to 30 dollar price point, the claim that 120 VR apps have made a million dollars implies only about 30,000 to 50,000 units sold per app, which Lasky considers failure.
“at a $20 to $30 price point, that's like 30,000 to 50,000 units. That's failure.”
Many Web3 developers are using land sales and NFTs as an alternative to venture capital, which is dangerous and may not end well for either developers or players, although it serves speculators well.
“developers essentially using land sales, NFTs, et cetera, as an alternative to venture capital, which is very dangerous”
Successful games investors need a strong internal sense of what makes a game fun, developed through playing extensively and talking with designers about their theory of fun, because a passive index-style approach to the games market can lose a lot of money.
“I think you can lose a lot of money that way.”
Games often stay relatively flat for the first six to twelve months after launch while teams identify which monetization hooks work, and it took his portfolio company Jenova Chen's game about a year to monetize properly.
“my expectations for some of these games is when they come out, they'll be relatively flat for the first 6, 9, 12 months”
Chess has changed little since the 14th century, backgammon is thousands of years old, and poker is about 150 years old, so their play patterns remain much the same over time.
“You could have sat down with Leonardo DaVinci and played a credible game of chess.”
Ben Thompson's aggregation theory explains the shift: control of distribution once let publishers roll up supply to create demand, while now platforms aggregate the demand and reshape the supply side of the business.
“To use Ben Thompson's aggregation theory as a way to think about this”
Riot's early success came from founders being present in online communities, such as Reddit, and designing to what users said they wanted, a lesson Lasky says all businesses can apply even though it is not especially novel.
“The founders were in there and they were having a dialogue with their audience.”
Delivering venture returns consistently over a decade or more is very hard, and despite fifteen years in the business, Lasky still feels like an amateur, with success often resembling a broken clock being occasionally right.
“It's not hard, I think, to be like a broken clock, occasionally right. But to deliver returns consistently across a decade or more is a really hard thing”
The disc-based model required pressing gold masters, packaging, industrial production, retail shipping, and advertising to drive store purchases, making cost of goods high and the model very different from today's constantly patched online games.
“The cost of goods was just ridiculous.”
Tencent became the largest video game publisher by revenue by layering a games business on top of existing user aggregation from QQ and WeChat, which together had about a billion users.
“Tencent is probably the world's most important example of this, where you have QQ and WeChat”
Quake 3: Arena, along with Unreal Tournament, was the first modern battle arena game and prefigured much of the modern games business.
“Quake 3: Arena was in many ways the first modern battle arena game”
World of Warcraft in 2004 was the first graphical 3D MMO to become a mass market phenomenon, and it made a subscription business around such games an incredibly important milestone.
“the first one to really spark the popular imagination and to become a real mass market phenomenon was World of Warcraft”
Nintendo executives developing a game with a director told him to make the character fun to control against a black screen before building anything else, illustrating that games should be built outward from a delightful, constant interaction loop.
“Make the character fun to play with against a black screen.”
Games differ from film and television because film controls the viewer's experience of time through mise-en-scene and editing, whereas in games the player controls the experience, so designers can only approximate control by putting players on rails.
“You don't have that control at all in the games context.”
Healthy game communities show user ownership, emotional investment, user-generated content inside or outside the game such as Minecraft or Roblox creations and Twitch streaming, and openness to new members rather than gatekeeping by early adopters.
“Users ownership of the game, like sense of ownership”
Rich virtual worlds do not require full immersion or haptics, because people already conjure worlds through low-bandwidth media such as reading text and already live partly in a virtual world through video communication.
“I do not believe that we need to get to this end state of fully immersive virtual reality and haptics in order to make these virtual experiences happen.”
Subscription models like Game Pass fit mobile-style churn less well than PC gaming, because mobile players download many titles and quit within seconds, whereas PC games require higher investment and learning curves.
“They'll download 10 things, play them for 15 seconds and be like, 'Okay, this sucks,'”
The first generation of games investors, including Lasky, Bill Gurley, and Bing Gordon at Kleiner, pioneered the understanding that persistent games could generate durable value, and they have now aged out, leaving a new crop of investors who learned from them.
“it was generational. As we have aged out of the business to some extent”
A new Canadian games company is using a PC version as a customer acquisition vehicle, offering it to Twitch streamers and influencers to push demand toward the mobile version where monetization primarily happens.
“they're going to use the PC SKU as a very interesting customer acquisition vehicle”
Meta's metaverse strategy is to build within a walled garden, mirroring Apple's integration of hardware, software, and platform to create a very large company, which Lasky says is a much bigger problem than people think.
“I think Meta's strategy is we're going to make it happen within the context of a walled garden.”
It has never been a better time in venture history for games companies to raise private money, and Lasky expects significant change over the next five years as younger investors take over.
“It's never been a better time in the history of venture for games companies to raise private money.”
Lasky expects mobile, console, and PC to remain the dominant platform structure for the foreseeable future, with VR not a mass-market step beyond mobile and location-based experiences as a potentially underinvested category.
“I'm not long VR in the short term.”
Apple could replicate the same targeting dynamics inside its own walled garden if it steps into advertising, which Lasky considers potentially monopolistic and possibly not a good outcome for the market.
“to the extent that they then step into the place of Facebook later with an advertising platform and replicate a lot of this stuff”
Raph Koster's family tree of game genres is fascinating for players, but Lasky believes there is little that flows from a deep understanding of genre history into business success.
“As a gamer, I'm super interested in this. As a business person, less so.”
The independent creative-control model planted by Doom's developers in the mid-1990s has direct continuity with companies like Epic and Riot.
“a lot of what we see now with Epic and Riot and other companies is really a direct continuity with that flag”
The games that survive longest have the most vibrant and thriving communities, so community strength is a key feature to look for when identifying potential forever games.
“the games that have survived the longest have the most vibrant and thriving communities built around them.”
Brian Kelly, Activision's CFO, invested time in teaching Lasky the business philosophy during his first year, which Lasky considers the kindest thing anyone has done for him in business.
“his willingness to invest in me intellectually was probably the kindest thing anybody's ever done for me in business.”
Roblox is a strong example of how game-creation tools have lowered the barrier to making games.
“Roblox, tremendous example.”
Lasky made mobile games on feature phones before the App Store, including a bowling game on Motorola phones that sold millions of units, an early signal of where mobile was headed.
“we were making a bowling game on Motorola phones that did millions and millions of units.”
Discord pivoted into the platform it is today with the same community-listening approach Riot used, a company Lasky invested in before it was called Discord.
“a company that I was lucky enough to invest in when it wasn't even Discord”
Beat Saber is probably the most successful VR product because it sells almost one-to-one with its active user base, though overall VR success stories remain limited.
“Beat saber, I would argue is probably the mist of virtual reality”
Incentivized installs and pushing installs as dark patterns have harmed mobile game customer acquisition, similar to Zynga and Playfish-era social gaming.
“Some of the bullshit that we saw around social gaming back in the Zynga, Playfish days, mid-2000s, not my cup of tea.”
Lasky's publishing experience with id Software and the Quake 3 release at Activision gave him direct knowledge of Doom's independent development culture.
“I was their publisher for part of their history, published Quake 3:Arena”
Lasky has five attributes for identifying forever games but withholds them to protect his investment edge.
“I have five attributes that I look for in these things. I'm not going to share them with you”
Lasky dislikes the word gamification but uses it to describe designing speculator motivations around the play experience.
“I hate that word, but I'm going to use it anyway.”